DOCSLIB.ORG

The Coral Reef Environmental "Crisis": Negotiating Knowledge in Scientific Uncertainty and Geographic Difference Ba#Rbel G

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Coral Reef Environmental Florida State University Libraries Electronic Theses, Treatises and Dissertations The Graduate School 2010 The Coral Reef Environmental "Crisis": Negotiating Knowledge in Scientific Uncertainty and Geographic Difference Ba#rbel G. Bischof Follow this and additional works at the FSU Digital Library. For more information, please contact [email protected] THE FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF SOCIAL SCIENCES & PUBLIC POLICY THE CORAL REEF ENVIRONMENTAL “CRISIS”: NEGOTIATING KNOWLEDGE IN SCIENTIFIC UNCERTAINTY AND GEOGRAPHIC DIFFERENCE By BÄRBEL G. BISCHOF A Dissertation submitted to the Department of Geography in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Degree Awarded: Summer Semester, 2010 i The members of the committee approve the dissertation of Bärbel G. Bischof, defended on May 7, 2010. !!!!!!_____________________________________________ !!!!!!Philip E. Steinberg !!!!!! Professor Directing Dissertation !!!!!!_____________________________________________ !!!!!!Ronald E. Doel !!!!!! University Representative !!! !!!!!!_____________________________________________ !!!!!!James B. Elsner !!!!!! Committee Member !!!!!!_____________________________________________ !!!!!!Xiaojun Yang !!!!!! Committee Member !!!!!! Approved: ______________________________________________________________ Victor Mesev, Chair, Department of Geography ______________________________________________________________ David W. Rasmussen, Dean, College of Social Sciences & Public Policy The Graduate School has verified and approved the above-named committee members. ii I dedicate this to all of those who commit themselves towards conserving our natural environments, especially those of our oceans. Ultimately, this is for my three noodles, Sienne, Keah, and Zalynn, for whom I want a better world, one that when they are grown, still harbors the ocean’s beauty and wonder that I have been fortunate enough to behold. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ! I would first like to thank the U.S. National Science Foundation, which awarded me the Doctoral Dissertation Research Improvement Grant in 2008 (BCS-0825623) and therewith allowed me to have the freedom to complete my work from my field site in South Florida’s coral reef environments. Also, many thanks to the FSU Department of Geography faculty and staff for their assistance and support in helping me reach my goal, particularly to Victor Mesev, Christina Dippre and Shawn Lewers. Many thanks also to respondents of my survey without whom I obviously would have been quite stuck. I am fully aware of the mental energy I requested of them to complete the Q-sorts, and sincerely appreciate those who had the depth and vision to understand my goals and the respect my efforts. Thanks to those who took the time to provide valuable feedback, particularly those who I know did not have much time to spare, given the demands made of them as leading reef scientists and management professionals. ! I would like to extend extra-special thanks to my dissertation advisor Phil Steinberg, for accepting me as his student, and his attention to my interests, his mentorship, his openness to my crazy ideas, and for his always-impressive articulation of philosophical issues that gave me brain-freeze when attempting to understand them on my own. Without a doubt, truly the best dissertation advisor anyone could hope for. And also extra-special thanks to Jim Elsner for his practical contributions and skill with “R” and writing and correcting the R-code that put my ideas into action; but also, and maybe more importantly, his willingness to listen to my concerns and his constant encouragement and confidence in me when my own sometimes faltered. I’d also like to thank Ron Doel and Xiaojun Yang for their willingness to serve on my committee and their valuable comments and feedback. Ben Clark in the College of Social Science Dean’s office deserves credit for his time and skill in setting up the online Q-sort surveys, and fixing the .html code to adapt it to my needs and make it work as it should. Also, to Jack Tyndall in the Graduate School, for his patience and help in navigating through the administrative hurdles. I would also like to thank Bruce Stiftel, now at Georgia Tech, for his early participation as committee member, and always sound advice and sobering analyses of my assessments regarding marine management planning and policy analysis. ! To one of my greatest inspirations and heros, Robert N. Ginsburg, once my MSc. committee member and mentor at UM/RSMAS, and now good friend and reef-exploring companion. He is among the very few who understood my steadfast motivations and goals. It was his doing that I became so deeply involved with coral reef issues and tropical marine environments, and where I began to see the marine system beyond a purely “material” and “natural” space. His constant questioning (his infamous “so what?”) and his awareness and openness to the socio-political aspect of reef conservation, despite his own focus on natural sciences, allowed me to understand this environment from a wide range of perspectives and be able to engage in the necessary critical thinking that first clued me into the sociological and philosophical aspects of science. He was among the few who emphasized the iv importance of connection, not only of the environment, but of knowledge, its power, and its effects. His support, teachings, and honest friendship have furthered me beyond anything I could have achieved without him. Great thanks to the trusty Rock Star, the 32-foot, 1968 Bertram that safely took us on those many trips to “our” reefs for so many years, and brought us back safely from those adventures we did not anticipate. I would also like to thank my mother, for her support and financial backing when I was counting pennies and scrounging for change under my furniture and car seats, or looking around for something to sell on eBay to make ends meet; to my sister for being a fantastic sounding-board and just simply an awesome sister, as well as Bryan Rodwell for being a loving husband and father to her family, and a good friend to me. To both of my parents for forcing me to retain my bi-lingual abilities as a child, which has come in handy more than once, and for supporting my wild adventures even though they may not have always understood what I was doing, or why. My father deserves thanks for the opportunities he has provided me throughout my life to travel and see the corners of the world we explored together. And, to “my girls,” my precious, beautiful nieces, who when moments got hard and frustrating, made me smile in my heart and gave me the necessary strength to carry on by reminding me why I was doing this. ! To my “academic friends” just for putting up with me as I rode the roller-coaster of emotions and mood-swings an endeavor such as this imposes, especially to Heather Gamper and Andres Platta-Strappa for their friendship, and for always welcoming me in their home when I needed a warm (and cool) place to stay in Tallahassee, and to Celeste and Dookie who let me share their space. To Mrs. Julie Cliff, Wando High School marine science teacher who lit the spark that started me down the marine science road; to Dr. Arthur Mariano, RSMAS scientist and friend whose sword-fishing trips not only allowed me to see some of the most awesome nature out there, but also clued me into aspects of the political ecology of fisheries and engaged my critical thinking in aspects of recreational and commercial fisheries; to Nick Onuf whose constructivist teachings, encouragement and conversations about science helped me understand how to converge my diverse background, and how to organize my critical thinking and attach it to theory, society, and the intersection of environment, politics and international law. I feel lucky to have been able to be among his students. To my kiter-buddies for helping me retain some sanity and become a kitesurfing fool, especially to Jaaz Bousquet, Juan Herrera, Muriel Vandenbempt, and the S. Florida and Chucktown crews. The times we had together on and off the water still rank among the best in my life. And to my enduring friends, the people that have stuck by me: David Brown, Marion Krause, Mita Saksena, Astrid Ellie Hurley, Terri-Ky Ross Rand among so many others. The gratitude and love I feel for the people in my life who have chosen me as I have chosen them is beyond words. ! In my mind, all people who enter our lives are important in some way, even if they only remain there for short measures –– they all leave a trace. Seven years in New York City, four of which in Harlem quite a few years before Billy, Starbucks and McDonald’s moved in, taught me that sometimes even the briefest encounters can affect one in ways that only later become evident. To those fleeting associations and encounters, even the ones that were quite awful or that scared the living hell out of me, I also owe some appreciation, as they have had some influence on my convictions and motivations, and taught me about myself and helped me organize the world we live in. v TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES.......................................................................................................................................... ix LIST OF FIGURES......................................................................................................................................... x ABSTRACT..................................................................................................................................................... xi
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Our Precarious Earth and Its Biosphere
    I. The Environment 1 The Earth’s Biosphere: Our Life Support System Our common shared biosphere is our planet’s life support system, capturing light via photosynthesis, conserving energy and matter, and obeying the basic laws of physics and thermodynamics. These laws are fundamental, governing all occurrences in the universe. All biological systems must abide by them. We must function within their confines. In spite of the universality of these laws, problems arise because of humans and their activities. There are simply too many of us for our planet. We are consuming too many irreplaceable resources and causing long-lasting planetary damage. This last problem is tremendously enhanced by human greed and a disregard by many for the biosphere. When our numbers were much smaller, our impact could be absorbed. This is not so today. Because we operate within the confines of the universal laws, we cannot continue to squander resources as we have in the past. Consider the following question: How much damage is caused to the natural environment in order to make a profit from the sale of a consumable item? Consider that many of the consumables produced are dispensable and often of minimal value. Realize that valuable resources must be used for their production. Moreover, these products ultimately become waste that must be disposed of, often in a manner that harms the environment. Why allow the continuation of activities that damage our common life support system? We already know that much of this damage cannot be repaired without a human population decrease. Why allow an increase in our population, recognizing that the consequence will be immense human suffering? Why allow resource consumption, pollution and global warming when we know that their continuance will prevent us from solving global problems and meeting the immense challenges that lie before us? We behave as though we have no regard for future generations.
    [Show full text]
  • The Reflection of an Ape an Aquatic Approach to Human Evolution
    The Reflection of an Ape An Aquatic Approach to Human Evolution A thesis submitted to the Miami University Honors Program in partial fulfillment of the requirements for University Honors with Distinction by Erica Kempf December 2006 Oxord, Ohio Acknowledgements There are a number of people I would like to thank for their help in the production of this story. Linda Marchant was my advisor and provided invaluable data, advice, support, and motivation during this venture. Lynn and Greg Kempf offered helpful feedback throughout, but especially during the early stages of writing. Mary Cayton and Scott Suarez kindly agreed to read the last draft of my project, and gave me final grammatical suggestions to further polish my final copy. I am also grateful to the people whose enthusiasm and moral support throughout the long process of writing this story kept me going: Amanda Zorn, Kait Jones, Ali Wolkin, Ashley Piening, Lindsay Good, Rachel Mount and Jamie Eckert. Special thanks also go to Randy Fiedler for the initial idea to begin this work and for his help in getting started. Table of Contents Introduction viii Map x Kinship Chart xi 1 Meer 1 2 Natte 13 3 Bain 18 4 Welle 22 5 Etang 28 6 Praia 34 7 Lago 39 8 Samman 43 9 Rio 47 10 Alga 51 11 Gens 56 Works Consulted 59 Introduction The study of how humans have come to be what we are has fascinated us for as long as we have written such things down, and for countless generations before that through oral histories. Every human culture has some type of creation myth, a tale of how people came to be on Earth, ranging from molded mud to thrown rocks to drops of deity’s blood and nearly everything in between.
    [Show full text]
  • Paleoasia Project Series 26 A02 2019年度研究報告書
    表4 表1 「パレオアジア文化史学」 Cultural History of PaleoAsia パレオアジア 文部科学省科学研究費補助金 文 化史学 文部科学省科学研究費補助金 新学術領域研究 （研究領域提案型）2016‒2020年度 新学術領域研究 （研究領域提案型） 2016 計画研究 A02 班 2019 年度 研究報告 Cultural History of PaleoAsia ‒ パレオアジア 2020年度 文 化史学 計画研究 計画研究 A02 班 2019 年度 研究報告 A02班 PaleoAsia Project Series 26 ‒ 2019年度 ‒ 研究報告 ‒ ホモ ・ サピエンスのアジア定着期における行動様式の解明 ホモ・サピエンスのアジア定着期における行動様式の解明 4 4 門脇誠二 編 門脇誠二編 表 2-3 は白 第4回_14.indd 1 2020/03/03 12:21 Cultural History of PaleoAsia パレオアジア 文化史学 文部科学省科学研究費補助金 新学術領域研究 （研究領域提案型）2016‒2020年度 計画研究 A02 班 2019 年度 研究報告 PaleoAsia Project Series 26 ホモ・サピエンスのアジア定着期における行動様式の解明 4 門脇誠二編 第4回_本文 3.indd 1 2020/03/06 10:10 【例言】 ・本書は、文部科学省科学研究費補助金新 学術領域研究（研究領域提案型）2016– 2020年度「アジア新人文化形成プロセス の総合的研究」（領域番号1802「パレオアジア 文化史学」）研究項目A02「ホモ・サピエンス のアジア定着期における行動様式の解明」 （課題番号 16H06409）の2019年度研究報告 である。 ・「パレオアジア文化史学」プロジェクトの概要 や研究体制、活動予定、発表業績などの最新 版についてはパレオアジア文化史学ホーム ページhttp://paleoasia.jp/を参照されたい。 i 第4回_本文 3.indd 2 2020/03/06 10:10 研究報告 はじめに はじめに 本書は、文部科学省科学研究費補助金新学術領域研究「パレオアジア文化史学」2016–2020年度の 計画研究A02「ホモ・サピエンスのアジア定着期における行動様式の解明」の2019年度研究報告書で ある。これまでに引き続き、アジアに新人が拡散・定着した頃の行動様式に関する考古記録の収集 と解析を行った。 遺跡調査： 2019年度もヨルダン（門脇誠二）、モンゴル（出穂雅実）、インドネシア（小野林太郎）、 北海道（中沢祐一）における遺跡調査を予定通りに行い、ホモ・サピエンスがアジアに拡散・定着し た頃の行動様式を復元するためのオリジナルの研究標本を収集した。それぞれの調査の速報が本書 に掲載されている。調査の主な対象は、ホモ・サピエンスが拡散・定着した時期であるが、その時 期の行動様式の特徴を的確に把握するためには、その前後の時期も含めて調査を行い、行動の通時 変化を明らかにする必要がある。また、これまでに得られた資料の研究成果を確認するためにサン プルをさらに増やす必要もある。このように信頼性の高い成果をあげるために、着実な記録収集を 継続している。 また、今年度も調査現場での異分野連携を推進した。ヨルダン調査では、A03班の田村亨が光ル ミネッセンス年代測定のための放射線測量を行い、B01班の池谷和信が水場利用と鳥罠猟の民族調査 を行った。またモンゴル調査に関連して、古気候変動と人類行動の変化の関係を明らかにするため の共同研究を、A03班の長谷川精と共同で進めている。
    [Show full text]
  • Verhaegen M. the Aquatic Ape Evolves
    HUMAN EVOLUTION Vol. 28 n.3-4 (237-266) - 2013 Verhaegen M. The Aquatic Ape Evolves: Common Miscon- Study Center for Anthropology, ceptions and Unproven Assumptions About Mechelbaan 338, 2580 Putte, the So-Called Aquatic Ape Hypothesis Belgium E-mail: [email protected] While some paleo-anthropologists remain skeptical, data from diverse biological and anthropological disciplines leave little doubt that human ancestors were at some point in our past semi- aquatic: wading, swimming and/or diving in shallow waters in search of waterside or aquatic foods. However, the exact sce- nario — how, where and when these semi-aquatic adaptations happened, how profound they were, and how they fit into the KEY WORDS: human evolution, hominid fossil record — is still disputed, even among anthro- Littoral theory, Aquarboreal pologists who assume some semi-aquatic adaptations. theory, aquatic ape, AAT, Here, I argue that the most intense phase(s) of semi-aquatic Archaic Homo, Homo erectus, adaptation in human ancestry occurred when populations be- Neanderthal, bipedalism, speech longing to the genus Homo adapted to slow and shallow littoral origins, Alister Hardy, Elaine diving for sessile foods such as shellfish during part(s) of the Morgan, comparative biology, Pleistocene epoch (Ice Ages), possibly along African or South- pachyosteosclerosis. Asian coasts. Introduction The term aquatic ape gives an incorrect impression of our semi-aquatic ancestors. Better terms are in my opinion the coastal dispersal model (Munro, 2010) or the littoral theory of human evolution, but although littoral seems to be a more appropriate biologi- cal term here than aquatic, throughout this paper I will use the well-known and common- ly used term AAH as shorthand for all sorts of waterside and semi-aquatic hypotheses.
    [Show full text]
  • World Prehistory from the Margins: the Role of Coastlines in Human Evolution
    Journal of Interdisciplinary Studies in History and Archaeology Vol. 1, No.1 (Summer 2004), pp. 39–50 World Prehistory from the Margins: The Role of Coastlines in Human Evolution Geoff Bailey Professor of Archaeology, University of New Castle, U.K. ABSTRACT Conventional accounts of world prehistory are dominated by land-based narratives progressing from scavenging and hunting of land mammals and gathering of plants to animal domestication and crop agriculture, and ultimately to urban civilisations supported by agricultural surpluses and trade. The use of coastlines and marine resources has been viewed as marginal, late in the sequence, or anomalous. This bias is primarily the result of three factors: the removal of most relevant evidence by sea- level change; the bad press given to coastal hunters and gatherers by 19th century ethnographers; and a belief in technological ‘primitivism’. In this paper I will examine the case for treating coastal habitats as amongst the most attractive for human settlement, and coastlines and seaways not as barriers but as gateways to human movement and contact, from early hominid dispersals to the rise of the great coastal and riverine civilisations. Introduction The recent claims of a submerged Harappan city 40m beneath the surface of sea in the Gulf of Khambhat in Northwest India have re-emphasised the impact of sea-level change on the archaeological record, and the potential importance of the now-submerged landscapes and coastlines of the continental shelf. Just what the Khambat finds consist of, and just how much of the material dredged up from the sea bed represents genuine artefacts, let alone evidence of a submerged Harappan city at least 2,000 years older than its counterparts on dry land, will have to await detailed and expert scrutiny.
    [Show full text]
  • Australopiths Wading? Homo Diving?
    Symposium: Water and Human Evolution, April 30th 1999, University Gent, Flanders, Belgium Proceedings Australopiths wading? Homo diving? http://allserv.rug.ac.be/~mvaneech/Symposium.html http://www.flash.net/~hydra9/marcaat.html Marc Verhaegen & Stephen Munro – 23 July 1999 Abstract Asian pongids (orangutans) and African hominids (gorillas, chimpanzees and humans) split 14-10 million years ago, possibly in the Middle East, or elsewhere in Eurasia, where the great ape fossils of 12-8 million years ago display pongid and/or hominid features. In any case, it is likely that the ancestors of the African apes, australopithecines and humans, lived on the Arabian-African continent 8-6 million years ago, when they split into gorillas and humans-chimpanzees. They could have frequently waded bipedally, like mangrove proboscis monkeys, in the mangrove forests between Eurasia and Africa, and partly fed on hard-shelled fruits and oysters like mangrove capuchin monkeys: thick enamel plus stone tool use is typically seen in capuchins, hominids and sea otters. The australopithecines might have entered the African inland along rivers and lakes. Their dentition suggests they ate mostly fruits, hard grass-like plants, and aquatic herbaceous vegetation (AHV). The fossil data indicates that the early australopithecines of 4-3 million years ago lived in waterside forests or woodlands; and their larger, robust relatives of 2-1 million years ago in generally more open milieus near marshes and reedbeds, where they could have waded bipedally. Some anthropologists believe the present-day African apes evolved from australopithecine-like ancestors, which would imply that knuckle-walking gorillas and chimpanzees evolved in parallel from wading- climbing ‘aquarborealists’.
    [Show full text]
  • Science Supporting Marine Protected Areas
    Letter coordinators: Professor Hugh Possingham, University of Queensland, phone 0434 079 061. Dr Jon Nevill, PO Box 106 Hampton Victoria 3188; phone 0422 926 515. Monday 16th August 2010 The Hon Julia Gillard Prime Minister Parliament House Canberra ACT 2600 The Hon Tony Abbott Leader of the Opposition Parliament House Canberra ACT 2600 OPEN LETTER TO THE PRIME MINISTER AND LEADER OF THE OPPOSITION SCIENCE SUPPORTING MARINE PROTECTED AREAS Dear Ms Gillard and Mr Abbott Recently articles have appeared in State and national press suggesting that there is little or no scientific evidence to support the creation of systems of marine protected areas. This is false. In this letter we briefly discuss the scientific evidence that shows marine protected areas have very positive impacts on biodiversity, and in many cases fisheries as well. Some reserve systems also produce substantial economic benefits through tourism1, as well as providing important educational, inspirational and research opportunities. Here we use the definition of marine protected areas of the Australian Marine Science Association (AMSA): areas of the ocean or coastal seas, securely reserved and effectively protected from at least some threats2. In the discussion below, we look briefly at threats to the marine environment, the history of marine protected areas, the development of networks of MPAs in Australia (against a background of bioregional planning), and their importance to Australia in an uncertain future. The marine environment faces five general threats: climate change and ocean acidification 3 resulting from rising CO2 levels , overfishing, habitat damage, pollution, and the effects of alien organisms4. On the global scene, modern fishing activities constitute the most important threat to marine biodiversity at the present time, although this will change in the 5 near future as rising CO2 levels affect ocean chemistry, temperatures and sea levels .
    [Show full text]
  • The Honolulu Declaration on Ocean Acidification and Reef Management
    The Honolulu Declaration on Ocean Acidification and Reef Management Prepared and adopted by participants of the Ocean Acidification Workshop, convened by The Nature Conservancy, 12-14 August 2008, Hawaii 1 IUCN Global Marine Programme Founded in 1948, The World Conservation Union brings together States, government agencies and a diverse range of non-governmental organizations in a unique world partnership: over 1000 members in all, spread across some 140 countries. As a Union, IUCN seeks to influence, encourage and assist societies throughout the world to conserve the integrity and diversity of nature and to ensure that any use of natural resources is equitable and ecologically sustainable. The IUCN Global Marine Programme provides vital linkages for the Union and its members to all the IUCN activities that deal with marine issues, including projects and initiatives of the Regional offices and the 6 IUCN Commissions. The IUCN Global Marine Programme works on issues such as integrated coastal and marine management, fisheries, marine protected areas, large marine ecosystems, coral reefs, marine invasives and protection of high and deep seas. The Nature Conservancy The mission of The Nature Conservancy is to preserve the plants, animals and natural communities that represent the diversity of life on Earth by protecting the lands and waters they need to survive. The Conservancy launched the Global Marine Initiative in 2002 to protect and restore the most resilient examples of ocean and coastal ecosystems in ways that benefit marine life, local communities and economies. The Conservancy operates over 100 marine conservation projects in more than 21 countries and 22 U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Submission from Dr Gideon Polya to the Senate Inquiry Into Australia's Faunal Extinction Crisis (12 August 2019). Credentials
    Submission from Dr Gideon Polya to the Senate Inquiry into Australia’s Faunal Extinction Crisis (12 August 2019). Credentials. BSc (Zoology and Chemistry majors, University of Tasmania, 1965), BSc Honours (First Class, University of Tasmania, 1966), PhD (Biochemistry, Flinders University of South Australia, 1969), Postdoctoral research fellow, Cornell University, New York (1969-1971), Queen Elizabeth II research fellow (Research School of Biological Sciences, Australian National University, 1971-1972), variously as a fulltime Lecturer to Reader (Associate Professor) (La Trobe University, 1972-2003), part-time lecturer (School of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2004-2006, and at La Trobe University, 2007-2013). I have published about 100 scientific research papers, 19 chapters of books [1] and 3 substantial books, namely “Biochemical Targets of Plant Bioactive Compounds. A pharmacological reference guide to sites of action and biological effects” (2003) [1], “Jane Austen and the Black Hole of British History. Colonial rapacity, holocaust denial and the crisis in biological sustainability” (1998, 2008) [2], and “Body Count. Global avoidable mortality since 1950” (2007) [3]. I write and publish extensively overseas about the horrendous impact on Humanity and the Biosphere of violently-backed resource exploitation [1]. Growing up in Tasmania I was aware of the extraordinary beauty of the Tasmanian environment and after reading “Silent Spring” by Dr Rachel Carson [5] at the beginning of my zoological and chemical studies was horrified by the impact of chemical industry on animal life and became convinced that Man has no right to destroy any species, let alone complex ecosystems containing numerous plant, animal and microbial species. This view was reinforced by the likely extinction of the Tasmania tiger (Thylacinus cynocephalus) [6, 7], the biocidal pollution of the environs of Queenstown, and the drowning of numerous ecosystems by the Tasmanian Hydroelectric Commission (HEC).
    [Show full text]
  • Oppenheimer S. Human's Association with Water Bodies: The
    HUMAN EVOLUTION Vol. 28 n.3-4 (137-170) - 2013 Oppenheimer S. Human’s Association with Water Bodies: Institute of Cognitive and Evolutionary The ‘Exaggerated Diving Reflex’ and Anthropology, School of Anthropology and Museum Ethnography, its Relationship with the Evolutionary University of Oxford, UK. Allometry of Human Pelvic and Brain Sizes E-mail: [email protected] As Darwin suggested, humans first evolved in Africa, then quickly spread out. Occupation sites from the Palaeolithic to the present show a niche preference for proximity to water bod- ies, rivers, lakes and sea coasts. From 165 Kya there is clear evidence for shellfish use, with characteristic shell middens in littoral zones. Genetic phylo-geography for Anatomically Modern Humans (AMH) indicates there was a single definitive exit from near the Horn Africa about 70 Kya, moving, with ex- traordinary rapidity, along coastlines around the Indian Ocean to Bali, later to China and the Americas. They crossed the sea to New Guinea and Australia by 50 KYA. Although AMH were not the first humans to cross Wallace’s Line, they were the first to make open-sea voyages of over 100 miles. Why are anatomi- cally modern humans associated with water bodies? Is it to do with their daily need for fresh drinking water? Is there any spe- cial significance to their exploitation of the food they find there, or is it just making the best of their niche? What aspect of their past evolution explains their ‘exaggerated mammalian diving reflex’? How is it connected with water? The pan-vertebrate reflex cardio-vascular response to extreme hypoxia has long been acknowledged as essential protection in terrestrial vertebrates against the risk of perinatal asphyxia as their milieu changes from aqueous to air.
    [Show full text]
  • Reef Encounter
    Volume 33, No. 1 September 2018 Number 46 REEF ENCOUNTER LIFE ACCOUNTS – Bob Ginsburg, Charlie Veron, Rod Salm, Wes Tunnell Society Honors, Prizes and Awards New Topic Chapter – The Coral Restoration Consortium CONFERENCES – Mexico, Florida Keys, Bremen, Oxford Graduate Fellowship Reports – corals, algae and fish The News Journal of the International Society for Reef Studies ISSN 0225-27987 REEF ENCOUNTER The News Journal of the International Society for Reef Studies ISRS Information REEF ENCOUNTER Reef Encounter is the Newsletter and Magazine Style Journal of the International Society for Reef Studies. It was first published in 1983. Following a short break in production it was re-launched in electronic (pdf) form. Contributions are welcome, especially from members. Please submit items directly to the relevant editor (see the back cover for author’s instructions). Coordinating Editor Rupert Ormond (email: [email protected]) Deputy Editor Caroline Rogers (email: [email protected]) Editors Reef Edge (Scientific Letters) Dennis Hubbard (email: [email protected]) Alastair Harborne (email: [email protected]) Edwin Hernandez-Delgado (email: [email protected]) Nicolas Pascal (email: [email protected]) Beatriz Casareto (Japan) (email: [email protected]) Editor Conservation and Obituaries Sue Wells (email: [email protected]) INTERNATIONAL SOCIETY FOR REEF STUDIES The International Society for Reef Studies was founded in 1980 at a meeting in Cambridge, UK. Its aim under the constitution is to promote,
    [Show full text]
  • The Original Econiche of the Genus Homo : Open Plain Or Waterside ?
    In: Ecology Research Progress ISBN 978-1-60021-807-1 Editor: Sebastian I. Munoz, pp.1- © 2007 Nova Science Publishers, Inc. Chapter 6 THE ORIGINAL ECONICHE OF THE GENUS HOMO : OPEN PLAIN OR WATERSIDE ? Marc Verhaegen *, Study Center for Anthropology, Mechelbaan 338, 2580 Putte, Belgium Stephen Munro, School of Archaeology and Anthropology, Australian National University, Canberra, ACT, 0200, Australia Mario Vaneechoutte, Laboratory for Bacteriology and Virology, Faculty of Medicine, University of Ghent, De Pintelaan 185, 9000 Gent, Belgium Nicole Bender-Oser, Institute for Social and Preventive Medicine, University of Bern, Finkenhubelweg 11, 3012 Bern, Switzerland Renato Bender Clinic Selhofen, Selhofenstrasse 31, 3122 Kehrsatz, Switzerland * [email protected] http://groups.yahoo.com/group/AAT 2 Marc Verhaegen, Stephen Munro, Mario Vaneechoutte et al. ABSTRACT That humans evolved as a result of a move from forests to more open plains is still the prevailing paradigm in anthropology, and researchers often assume that this transition influenced the origins of human bipedalism, omnivory, tool use, large brains, and even speech. Here, we argue that there are no scientific grounds on which to base such a hypothesis. While we agree that Homo may have evolved in more open (tree-poor) habitats than other apes (which could account for our relatively poor climbing skills), the suggestion that humans shifted to drier habitats away from water is, according to our research, unproven. We propose instead a more parsimonious model compatible
    [Show full text]