DOCSLIB.ORG

Medical Aid in Dying Is NOT Suicide, Assisted Suicide Or Euthanasia

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Medical Aid in Dying Is NOT Suicide, Assisted Suicide Or Euthanasia Medical Aid in Dying Is NOT Suicide, Assisted Suicide or Euthanasia Medical aid in dying is fundamentally stricken with life-ending illnesses. They feel different from euthanasia. While both deeply offended when the medical practice is practices are designed to bring about a referred to as suicide or assisted suicide. peaceful death, the distinction between the two comes down to who administers the means to Leading medical organizations reject that peaceful death. Euthanasia is an intentional the term “physician-assisted suicide.” act by which another person (not the dying The American Academy of Hospice and person) administers the medication. By contrast, Palliative Medicine, American Medical Women’s medical aid in dying requires the patient to be Association, American Medical Student Associa- able to take the medication themselves and tion, American Academy of Family Physicians and therefore always remain in control. Euthanasia is American Public Health Association have all illegal throughout the United States. adopted policies opposing the use of the terms “suicide” and “assisted suicide” to describe the State legislatures and courts in states medical practice of aid in dying. The American where the practice is authorized Association of Suicidology, a nationally recognized recognize medical aid in dying as organization that promotes prevention of suicide differing from suicide, assisted suicide or through research, public awareness programs, euthanasia. Euthanasia and assisted suicide are education and training comprised of respected both illegal in jurisdictions where medical aid in researchers and mental health professionals, dying is authorized. Medical aid-in-dying laws documents 15 ways medical aid in dying is funda- on the books in California, Colorado, the District mentally distinct from suicide and “a matter of Columbia, Hawai‘i, Maine, New Jersey, Oregon, outside the central focus of the AAS.” Vermont and Washington expressly state: “Actions taken in accordance with [the Act] shall not, for The most prominent professional any purpose, constitute suicide, assisted suicide, society in the United States address- mercy killing or homicide.” And in Montana, where ing issues that arise at the interface of assisted suicide is specifically illegal, the Montana law and medicine rejects the term “physician- Supreme Court ruled in Baxter v. Montana that assisted suicide.” The American College of Legal medical aid in dying provided to terminally ill, Medicine filed an amicus brief before the United mentally competent adult patients in no way violates States Supreme Court in 1996 rejecting the term established state law [including Montana’s assisted and adopted a resolution in 2008 in which they suicide statute] or the principles of public policy.” “publicly advocat[ed the] elimination of the word ‘suicide’ from the lexicon created by a mentally The American Association of Suicidology competent, though terminally ill, person who (AAS) recognizes that the practice of wishes to be aided in dying.” medical aid in dying is distinct from the behavior that has been traditionally and ordinarily described as “suicide.” People who seek medical aid in dying want to live but are For more information, visit CompassionAndChoices.org Updated: 1.6.21.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Right to End-Of-Life Palliative Care and a Dignified Death 1
    THE RIGHT TO END-OF-LIFE PALLIATIVE CARE AND A DIGNIFIED DEATH 1 CONTRIBUTION FROM UN-ECLAC FOR THE EXPERT GROUP MEETING ON “CARE AND OLDER PERSONS: LINKS TO DECENT WORK, MIGRATION AND GENDER” 5-7 December 2017 United Nations Headquarters, New York – Secretariat Building, Conference Room S -2725 1. The right to life and dignity in old age The approach of death involves a number of activities, as different practicalities pertaining to the end of life have to be organized. It is essential for these activities —which are carried out by family members, caregivers and medical personnel, among others— to meet standards that ensure appropriate living conditions until such time as clinical and biological death supervenes. Older persons are among the most vulnerable to death. Their position in the age structure of society becomes almost by default a predictor of their demise. This social construction of old age prompts a particular way of treating the elderly: “The social structures in which [older persons] are involved are oriented to the fact of their forthcoming death; their families have become increasingly independent of them; the scope of references to the ‘future’ has progressively narrowed; ‘dying’ is of considerably less consequence for others, e.g., it is not felt to be a matter which requires drastic revision of others’ life plans, as does the ‘fact’ that a young adult is dying” (Sudnow, 1967).2 Older persons are sometimes treated like cadavers even when they are, clinically and biologically, still alive. This occurs especially in cases where they are dying or suffering from terminal illnesses, although they do not necessarily have to be in this predicament to receive degrading treatment.
    [Show full text]
  • Some Facts About Suicide and Depression
    Some Facts About Suicide and Depression WHAT IS DEPRESSION? Depression is the most prevalent mental health disorder. The lifetime risk for depression is 6 to 25%. According to the National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), 9.5% or 18.8 million American adults suffer from a depressive illness in any given year. There are two types of depression. In major depression, the symptoms listed below interfere with one’s ability to function in all areas of life (work, family, sleep, etc). In dysthymia, the symptoms are not as severe but still impede one’s ability to function at normal levels. Common symptoms of depression, reoccurring almost every day: o Depressed mood (e.g. feeling sad or empty) o Lack of interest in previously enjoyable activities o Significant weight loss or gain, or decrease or increase in appetite o Insomnia or hypersomnia o Agitation, restlessness, irritability o Fatigue or loss of energy o Feelings of worthlessness, hopelessness, guilt o Inability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness o Recurrent thoughts of death, recurrent suicidal ideation, suicide attempt or plan for completing suicide A family history of depression (i.e., a parent) increases the chances (by 11 times) than a child will also have depression. The treatment of depression is effective 60 to 80% of the time. However, according the World Health Organization, less than 25% of individuals with depression receive adequate treatment. If left untreated, depression can lead to co-morbid (occurring at the same time) mental disorders such as alcohol and substance abuse, higher rates of recurrent episodes and higher rates of suicide.
    [Show full text]
  • Physician-Assisted Suicide and Voluntary Euthanasia: Some Relevant Differences John Deigh
    Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Volume 88 Article 14 Issue 3 Spring Spring 1998 Physician-Assisted Suicide and Voluntary Euthanasia: Some Relevant Differences John Deigh Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/jclc Part of the Criminal Law Commons, Criminology Commons, and the Criminology and Criminal Justice Commons Recommended Citation John Deigh, Physician-Assisted Suicide and Voluntary Euthanasia: Some Relevant Differences, 88 J. Crim. L. & Criminology 1155 (Spring 1998) This Criminal Law is brought to you for free and open access by Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology by an authorized editor of Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. 0091-4169/98/8803-1155 THE JOURNAL OF CRIMINAL LAW& CRIMINOLOGY Vol. 88, No. 3 Copyright 0 1998 by Northwestern University, School of Law Prinfd in U.SA. PHYSICIAN-ASSISTED SUICIDE AND VOLUNTARY EUTHANASIA: SOME RELEVANT DIFFERENCES JOHN DEIGH" Yale Kamisar, in a series of influential articles on physician- assisted suicide and voluntary active euthanasia, has written elo- quently in opposition to legalizing these practices.1 Today he revisits the first of these articles, his seminal 1958 article, Some Non-Religious Views Against Proposed "Mercy-Killing"Legislation. 2 In that paper Professor Kamisar used the distinction between the law on the books and the law in action to quiet concerns about the harsh consequences of a blanket prohibition on mercy kill- ing. A blanket prohibition, after all, if strictly applied, would impose criminal punishment on physicians and relatives whose complicity in bringing about the death of a patient, or loved one was justified by the dying person's desperate condition and lucid wish to die.
    [Show full text]
  • The Constitutional Status of Morals Legislation
    Kentucky Law Journal Volume 98 | Issue 1 Article 2 2009 The onsC titutional Status of Morals Legislation John Lawrence Hill Indiana University-Indianapolis Follow this and additional works at: https://uknowledge.uky.edu/klj Part of the Constitutional Law Commons, and the Law and Society Commons Right click to open a feedback form in a new tab to let us know how this document benefits you. Recommended Citation Hill, John Lawrence (2009) "The onC stitutional Status of Morals Legislation," Kentucky Law Journal: Vol. 98 : Iss. 1 , Article 2. Available at: https://uknowledge.uky.edu/klj/vol98/iss1/2 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Journals at UKnowledge. It has been accepted for inclusion in Kentucky Law Journal by an authorized editor of UKnowledge. For more information, please contact [email protected]. TKenf]iky Law Jornal VOLUME 98 2009-2010 NUMBER I ARTICLES The Constitutional Status of Morals Legislation John Lawrence Hiff TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION I. MORALS LEGISLATION AND THE HARM PRINCIPLE A. Some Difficulties with the Concept of "MoralsLegislation" B. The Near Irrelevance of the PhilosophicDebate C. The Concept of "Harm" II. DEFINING THE SCOPE OF THE PRIVACY RIGHT IN THE CONTEXT OF MORALS LEGISLATION III. MORALS LEGISLATION AND THE PROBLEMS OF RATIONAL BASIS REVIEW A. The 'RationalRelation' Test in Context B. The Concept of a Legitimate State Interest IV. MORALITY AS A LEGITIMATE STATE INTEREST: FIVE TYPES OF MORAL PURPOSE A. The Secondary or IndirectPublic Effects of PrivateActivity B. Offensive Conduct C. Preventingthe Corruptionof Moral Character D. ProtectingEssential Values andSocial Institutions E.
    [Show full text]
  • EUTHANASIA and RELIGION the Advance of Technologies to Prolong Life and Control Dying Can Raise Agonizing Moral Dilemmas
    Article 32 EUTHANASIA AND RELIGION The advance of technologies to prolong life and control dying can raise agonizing moral dilemmas. What guidance is offered by the great world religions? Courtney S. Campbell In “The Parable of the Mustard Seed”, the Buddha choices, religious traditions and values can offer guid- teaches a lesson that is valid for all cultures: human be- ance and insight, if not solutions. ings receive no exemption from mortality. Deep in the Historically, religious communities have sought to ap- throes of grief after the death of her son, a woman seeks propriate death within the life cycle through rituals of re- wisdom from the Buddha, who says that he does indeed membrance, and religious teachings have emphasized have an answer to her queries. Before giving it, however, that death brings meaning to mortality. The process of he insists that she must first collect a grain of mustard dying is often portrayed as an invitation to spiritual in- seed from every house that has not been touched by sight and a key moment in the cultivation of spiritual death. She canvasses her entire community, but fails to identity. collect a single seed. Returning to the Buddha, she un- derstands that, like all other living beings, we are des- tined to die. Judaism, Christianity and Islam Death is a defining characteristic of human experience. Yet, while the event of death remains elusively beyond basically address ethical issues human control, the process of dying has increasingly concerning the end of life from a been brought into the domain of medicine and life- extending technologies.
    [Show full text]
  • Attitude of Doctors Toward Euthanasia in Delhi, India
    Published online: 2019-04-05 Original Article AAttitudettitude ooff ddoctorsoctors ttowardoward eeuthanasiauthanasia iinn DDelhi,elhi, IIndiandia ABSTRACT Introduction: Deliberation over euthanasia has been enduring for an extended period of time. On one end, there are populaces talking for the sacrosanctity of life and on the other end, there are those, who promote individual independence. All over the world professionals from different areas have already spent mammoth period over the subject. A large number of cases around the world have explored the boundaries of current legal distinctions, drawn between legitimate and nonlegitimate instances of ending the life. The term euthanasia was derived from the Greek words “eu” and “thanatos” which means “good death” or “easy death.” It is also known as mercy killing. Euthanasia literally means putting a person to painless death especially in case of incurable suffering or when life becomes purposeless as a result of mental or physical handicap. Objective: To study the attitude of doctors toward euthanasia in Delhi. Methodology: It was a questionnaire based descriptive cross-sectional study carried out between July 2014 and December 2014. The study population included Doctors from 28 hospitals in Delhi both public and private. Equal numbers of doctors from four specialties were included in this study (50 oncologists, 50 hematologists, 50 psychiatrists, and 50 intensivists). Demographic questionnaire, as well as the Euthanasia Attitude Scale (EAS), a 30 items Likert-scale questionnaire developed by (Holloway, Hayslip and Murdock, 1995) was used to measure attitude toward Euthanasia. The scale uses both positively (16 items) and negatively (14 items) worded statements to control the effect of acquiescence.
    [Show full text]
  • Thesis Final
    In Pursuit of a Good Death: Responding to Changing Sensibilities in the Context of the Right to Die Debate A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Juridical Studies at the University of Sydney VICTORIA HILEY The Faculty of Law University of Sydney January 2008 ABSTRACT This thesis challenges a number of claims that are made in the context of the euthanasia debate: that there is only one version of the good death; that rights discourse is the most appropriate vehicle by which to secure legal recognition of a right to die; that the Netherlands is either a model for reform or the epitome of a slippery slope in its regulation of euthanasia; and that a key argument in the euthanasia debate, the sanctity of life doctrine, is a fixed, immutable concept. In this thesis I use process sociology, developed by Norbert Elias, in order to capture changing sensibilities toward death and dying in the common law jurisdictions (Australia, England, the United States of America, Canada and New Zealand) and in the Netherlands. At the same time I analyse changing attitudes among key groups whose work impacts upon the euthanasia debate namely, parliamentarians, law reform bodies, the judiciary and medical associations. My aim in adopting this approach is threefold. First of all, to examine evolving attitudes to death and dying in order to determine whether the institutions of law and medicine are responding in an adequate manner to changing sensibilities in the common law countries and in the Netherlands. Secondly, to highlight shifting balances of power within the euthanasia debate.
    [Show full text]
  • On the Relationship Between Suicide-Prevention and Suicide-Advocacy Groups
    Letter to the Editor On the Relationship Between Suicide-Prevention and Suicide-Advocacy Groups Margaret Pabst Battin Uniuersity of Utah Largely in response to contemporary medicine's advancing technological capacities to extend the process of dying to extraordinary lengths. recent years have seen the emergence of numerous advocacy groups concerned with what is often called "death with dignity." For instance. the New York-based group. Concern for Dying, distributes the Living Will as a means for individuals to secure their right to refuse unwanted, life-prolonging medical treatment. Another New York group, the Society for the Right to Die, lobbies for passage of "natural death" legislation, and has seen passage of Natural Death Acts in California and ten other U.S. states, and legislative consideration of similar bills in another twenty-seven. The Los Angeles-area group, Hemlock, led by a British writer who helped his cancer-striken wife drink a lethal potion, argues for societal recognition of assisted suicide as an option in terminal illness. Britain's Voluntary Euthanasia Society, once renamed EXIT: The Society for the Right to Die with Dignity, has published and distributed to its members a booklet of suicide methods for use by terminally ill persons; a similar book has become commercially available in France. Nor are such groups a local phenomenon; they are emerging world-wide. Although their views range from quite conservative insistence on passive refusal of treatment to radical suicide-advocacy, there are new voluntary euthanasia societies in Australia, Norway, Sweden, Japan, Denmark, New Zealand, South Africa, Holland, Germany, France, Colombia, Zimbabwe, Canada, India, and Switzerland.
    [Show full text]
  • SUBJECT: Euthanasia
    Public Shelter Protocol Ver 1.0 Effective Date: 6/27/2012 SUBJECT: Euthanasia POLICY: Euthanasia is reserved only for situations involving animals that cannot be safely handled – either because of aggression or contagious disease, or in situations where the animal is suffering and a reasonable level of treatment would not be effective at providing a good quality of life. Prior to a euthanasia decision being made, all other options are explored including: return to owner (if an owner can be identified), adoption, transfer to a rescue group or shelter capable of providing better care and/or rehabilitation, and treatment. Identification of Animals to be Euthanized All animals that become the property of the Public Shelter (after legally required hold times) will be considered adoptable until they have been determined otherwise through a medical and/or behavioral evaluation as per the policies and procedures in effect. Medical Conditions The medical staff (Veterinarian, Veterinary Technician, and/or trained staff) will evaluate each animal for any medical problems and determine if an animal is medically adoptable. The medical exam will be done based on a physical exam checklist which will be included in the animal’s record. This exam will include body score and pain assessment. The medical evaluation will be done as soon as the medical staff is available. In the event that a supervisor is unavailable and an emergency occurs where an animal is suffering greatly, the Euthanasia Request Form can be completed by three available staff and photo documentation may be attached to the form. Any medical problems noted by the medical staff will then be assessed to note if this is a resolvable medical problem based on severity and resources available.
    [Show full text]
  • The Court Upholds a State Law Prohibiting Physician-Assisted Suicide
    Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Volume 88 Article 3 Issue 3 Spring Spring 1998 The ourC t Upholds A State Law Prohibiting Physician-Assisted Suicide Brett einbF erg Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarlycommons.law.northwestern.edu/jclc Part of the Criminal Law Commons, Criminology Commons, and the Criminology and Criminal Justice Commons Recommended Citation Brett einbeF rg, The ourC t Upholds A State Law Prohibiting Physician-Assisted Suicide, 88 J. Crim. L. & Criminology 847 (Spring 1998) This Supreme Court Review is brought to you for free and open access by Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology by an authorized editor of Northwestern University School of Law Scholarly Commons. 0091-4169/98/8803-0847 THE JOURNAL OF CRIMINALLAW & CRIMINOLOGY Vol. 88, No. 3 Copyrght © 1998 by Northwestern University, School of Law Printed in U.S.A. THE COURT UPHOLDS A STATE LAW PROHIBITING PHYSICIAN-ASSISTED SUICIDE Vacco v. Quill, 117 S. Ct. 2293 (1997) I. INTRODUCTION In Vacco v. Quill,' the United States Supreme Court ad- dressed whether a terminally ill person has a constitutionally protected right to commit suicide with the assistance of a physi- cian.2 The Court held that state laws prohibiting physician- assisted suicide are constitutionally permissible since they do not violate the Equal Protection Clause.3 In making its decision, the Court determined that the right to die with assistance is not a fundamental right.4 The Court
    [Show full text]
  • Surviving Suicide Loss
    Surviving Suicide Loss ISSUE NO 1 | SPRING 2021 | VOLUME 1 IN THIS ISSUE Letter from the Chair ………….……….……….……………….……….………. 1 AAS Survivor of the Year ……….……….…………………..……….……..…. 1 Editor’s Note ....……………………….……….……………….……….…………... 2 Surviving Suicide Loss in the Age of Covid ……….……….…………...…. 2 What the Latest Research Tells Us ……………….…….……….……………. 3 Waiting for the Fog to Clear ……………….…………………..……….…..…… 4 AAS Survivor-Related Events ……………….…..……….…………………..…. 4 In the Early Morning Hours …………………………………………………..…... 6 IN SEARCH OF NEW BEGINNINGS Letter from the Chair I clearly remember attending my first AAS conference in 2005. Six months after losing my sister, I was scared, confused, thirsty for knowledge and ever so emotional. There I met so many people who are near and dear to me today. They welcomed me, remi- nisced with me and, most of all, inspired me. On my flight back, I had many thoughts and feelings. As I am Building Community sure many of you have experienced, writing was both helpful Seeing my article made me feel a part of this community in and healing. So I wrote down my musings from the conference and when back at home, I edited the piece and sent it to Ginny the best ways, surrounded by supportive and like-minded Sparrow. minded folks. As you may remember, Ginny was the extraordinary editor of the Thus, I am happy to have a part in reviving “Surviving Suicide” print newsletter Surviving Suicide, a publication sent to AAS Loss in digital form. I hope it will be a place where all of us can Division members from approximately 1998 through 2007. share our thoughts, our news, our hopes and fears, while hon- oring our loved ones and further building our community.
    [Show full text]
  • Abc's of Suicidology
    ABC’S OF SUICIDOLOGY: THE ROLE OF AFFECT IN SUICIDAL BEHAVIORS AND COGNITIONS A Dissertation Presented to The Graduate Faculty of The University of Akron In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy Cynthia Ann Yamokoski August 2006 ABC’S OF SUICIDOLOGY: THE ROLE OF AFFECT IN SUICIDAL BEHAVIORS AND COGNITIONS Cynthia Ann Yamokoski Dissertation Approved: Accepted: _____________________________ ______________________________ Advisor Department Chair Karen R. Scheel Sajit Zachariah _____________________________ ______________________________ Committee Member Dean of the College Sharon Kruse Patricia A. Nelson _____________________________ ______________________________ Committee Member Dean of the Graduate School James Rogers George R. Newkome _____________________________ _______________________________ Committee Member Date Robert Schwartz _____________________________ Committee Member Linda Subich ii ABSTRACT The study of affect and cognition has been important in understanding suicide; however, the research and literature historically have placed more emphasis upon cognitive factors. Clearly, cognitive processes play a significant role in suicidal thoughts and behaviors, but it is also important to increase the focus on affect. There is support for the role of affect and the fact that cognition and affect combine with one another to impact suicidal behaviors. These findings may be advanced through the application of a theoretical model of affect in order to gain insight into the manner in which cognition and affect specifically relate to one another to impact suicidal thoughts and behaviors. Other goals of the current study were to examine the relationship between affect and cognition in suicidal individuals, to determine if different patterns of affect exist for different subtypes of suicidal individuals (i.e., no suicidality, suicidal ideation only, suicidal behaviors), and to assess the unique role of affect in relation to cognition.
    [Show full text]