Lower Canada/Canada East/ Quebec: Factors Leading To
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Lower Canada/Canada East/ Quebec: financial woes. In 1860, the government had to confrontation with the United States. In the mid- Factors Leading to Confederation borrow more money to buy out the Grand Trunk 1860s, Great Britain encouraged negotiations to Railway Company's debts. In 1860, Canadian debt transfer these territories to the new country that Political Factors reached $50 million. The Reciprocity Treaty with would become Canada. When Confederation the United States was about to expire and Canada came into effect in 1867, the Hudson's Bay By the early 1860s, Great Britain was gradually had no choice but to turn to the markets of the Company began the transfer of the North- losing interest in its North American colonies, British Atlantic colonies. When the Reciprocity Western Territory and Rupert's Land to the new which were seen to be an economic, military and Treaty came to an end in 1866, fewer markets Dominion of Canada. political burden. With this detachment came a were available to Canada. A union of the British desire to reorganize the colonies' political colonies in North America would open up new Finally, Great Britain also feared that Fenians structure by giving them greater autonomy. The markets. might attack its North American colonies. political system of United Canada had been extremely unstable since the mid-1850s. Security Factors Factors Related to the Railway Government crises occurred every year from 1854 In the mid-19th century, Great Britain wanted, for to 1857, and twice a year in 1858, as well as from Great Britain was no longer interested in financing strategic reasons, to connect its North American 1862 to 1864. Once in power, the Great Coalition the defence of its North American colonies and colonies by means of a railway. Given the project's of John A. Macdonald, George-Étienne Cartier and asked that United Canada assume the scope, no single colony could provide the George Brown planned a legislative union of the responsibility for its own defence. In 1862, as a necessary financial resources. A political union British North American colonies. The debate show of goodwill, the Macdonald-Cartier would allow the colonies to pool their resources surrounding the issue of representation by government proposed a bill allocating $1 million and make the railway project more feasible. population (rep by pop) also called for a political to maintain a militia of 50,000 men. The bill was defeated in the House, disappointing the British reorganization. The Process authorities. From then on, they would be Economic Factors receptive to any project to unite the North In 1858, after George-Étienne Cartier and American colonies, which would solve the Alexander Tilloch Galt reached an agreement, the The success of railway companies, particularly that problem of North American defence. former announced a government project in these of the Grand Trunk Railway Company, was crucial terms: to the economic health of United Canada. In 1855, When the American Civil War ended, Great Britain skyrocketing construction costs forced the worried about the victors' reaction to British "Le gouvernement étudiera l'opportunité d'une government to begin massive investment in the support of the Southern cause. Britain's union fédérale des provinces britanniques de Grand Trunk Railway Company in order to save withdrawal from North America might normalize l'Amérique du Nord, et se mettra en the project. This commitment spelled financial relations between Canada and the United States. communication à ce sujet avec le gouvernement ruin for the government, which would soon be impérial et avec les provinces Maritimes. Le The perceived "threat" posed by expanding unable to pay interest on its debt. It became clear résultat de ces communications sera soumis au American interests increased when the United that railway profits would never materialize. The Parlement à sa prochaine session."1 government of United Canada was forced to States purchased Alaska. Great Britain believed increase import tariffs, its main source of revenue. that the uncertain status of the North-Western [translation] But these hikes could not solve the colony's Territory and Rupert's Land might lead to "The government shall study the timeliness of a federal union of British North American provinces, resolve the political crisis once and for all, and North American colonies. The union could include and will contact the imperial government and agreed to co-operate with any government that only Canada East and Canada West, or the Maritime provinces in this regard. The result of accepted constitutional reform.2 Maritime colonies as well. Having heard of the these communications will be presented to John A. Macdonald, who did not like George discussions of underway among the three Parliament next session." Brown at first, made an overture to him. Brown Maritime colonies, the Parliament of United replied that he would join a Conservative majority Canada contacted the various colonial This project was essentially that of Alexander government if it agreed to include federation as governments. All agreed to meet in Charlottetown Tilloch Galt. It arose from an ideological debate part of its platform.3 This government, called the in September 1864 to discuss a possible union. begun by some members of the Canadian political Great Coalition, included several politicians who elite, Francophone and Anglophone, when the favoured a union of British colonies, including The Parliament of United Canada obtained Canadas were united in 1840. In 1858, many of Alexander Tilloch Galt, George-Étienne Cartier, permission to send seven of its members. For the main players in the Confederation conferences Hector-Louis Langevin, Étienne-Paschal Taché, Canada West, the representatives were of 1864 to 1867 were already on the scene, Thomas D'Arcy McGee and Jean-Charles Chapais. John A. Macdonald, George Brown and William including George Brown, George-Étienne Cartier, It was this overture to George Brown that set the McDougall; for Canada East, they were George- John A. Macdonald, Alexander Tilloch Galt, wheels of the Confederation project in motion. Étienne Cartier, Alexander-Tilloch Galt, Hector- Joseph-Charles Taché, Antoine-Aimé Dorion, The overture was also remarkable in that political Louis Langevin and Thomas D'Arcy McGee. Étienne-Paschal Taché, Hector-Louis Langevin and foes joined forces to support a common goal. This The United Canada delegates explained their plan Thomas D'Arcy McGee. Others, like Joseph- goal was hard to define, however, since not for a union of British North American colonies. Édouard Cauchon, exerted a more subtle everyone had the same definition of They did so with such conviction that the influence. Though only a member of Parliament, Confederation. Alexander Tilloch Galt, for delegates for the Maritime colonies set aside their Cauchon managed to influence public opinion in example, believed the Confederation project initial Maritime union project to concentrate on favour of a political union through his newspaper, should include the Maritime provinces, while the new Canadian federation project. In Le Journal de Québec. George Brown initially viewed it simply as an Charlottetown, they agreed to resume discussions amendment to the union of Canada East and In 1858, George-Étienne Cartier, Alexander Tilloch at a second conference in October 1864, this time Canada West. In the end, all managed to agree. Galt and John Ross travelled to London to present in Québec. Queen Victoria with a federation project for the The Charlottetown Conference British North American colonies. There were Before returning to Canada, the United Canada received with polite indifference. After this For close to ten years, the British Atlantic colonies delegates toured the Maritime colonies, giving refusal, the political class put its project aside for a had considered a union to improve their lot in speeches and drumming up support for their number of years. The frequent changes in colonial North America. By simplifying their project. government also disrupted the process. The administration, reducing expenses, and pooling The Québec Conference federation project resumed in 1864, and this time, their energies and resources, Prince Edward it was brought to a conclusion on July 1, 1867. Island, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia might face The United Canada delegates who attended the the future with serenity. Québec Conference were, for Canada East: In 1864, when the Conservative Taché-Macdonald Étienne-Paschal Taché, George-Étienne Cartier, government was defeated in the House, George As we have seen, the Province of Canada was also Alexander Tilloch Galt, Jean-Charles Chapais, Brown, who held the balance of power, wanted to considering a political reorganization of the British Hector-Louis Langevin, Thomas D'Arcy McGee and, for Canada West: John A. Macdonald, George believed that inclusion of the Maritime colonies John A. Macdonald, William McDougall and Brown, Alexander Campbell, Oliver Mowat, would increase the financial burden on United W. P. Howland; for Canada East: George-Étienne William McDougall and James Cockburn. Canada. Moreover, the Senate, as it was proposed Cartier, Alexander Tilloch Galt and Hector-Louis at the Québec Conference, could impede the will Langevin. The talks were chaired by The Québec Conference was held in the utmost of the people and block adoption of progressive John A. Macdonald, who tried to change the secrecy from October 10 to 26, 1864. When the legislation. Finally, he firmly believed that the wording of the Québec Resolutions several times. general population made it clear that it wanted to Confederation project should be subject to the George-Étienne Cartier and other delegates had to know more about the negotiations that would people's approval by a vote. Antoine-Aimé Dorion temper his zeal. decide their future, the Québec Resolutions were gave a speech to the constituents of the published. These resolutions served as the basis Hochelaga riding and, in 1865, he made a long Once the London Resolutions were drafted, the for the talks leading to Confederation.