Reconstructing the Concept with Aldo Capitini Submitted by Roberto

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Reconstructing the Concept with Aldo Capitini Submitted by Roberto NONVIOLENCE AS IMPURE PRAXIS – Reconstructing the Concept with Aldo Capitini Submitted by Roberto Baldoli, to the University of Exeter as a thesis for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Politics, September 2015. This Thesis is available for Library use on the understanding that it is copyright material and that no quotation from the thesis may be published without proper acknowledgment. I certify that all material in this thesis which is not my own work has been identified and that no material has previously been submitted and approved for the award of a degree by this or any other University. Signature 1 | P a g e ABSTRACT: This thesis aims to ‘reconstruct’ the concept of nonviolence, offering a new unifying and pluralistic definition, which rejects recent worrying uses of the term, and is able to deal with the crisis of democracy and the construction of a post-secular society. Currently nonviolence is split in two between principled and pragmatic nonviolence. This division has been successful, but it is now a problem: it divides means and ends, politics and morality, religion and politics. In order to find a way out we will turn to the Italian philosopher Aldo Capitini. He interpreted nonviolence as a tension, a praxis of liberation from the chains of reality and openness to the existent. This approach includes a pragmatic dimension, which is a logic reinterpreting current practices and inventing new ones to build up via facti a new society (omnicracy); and a principled dimension, which is a craft of integrating reality with values, reaching its peak in the connection with everybody in an action of value (compresence). This approach offers actions of protest-to- project to overcome the division between means and ends; a political approach between ‘realism and serenity’ to overcome the division between politics and morality; an open religion which can work at the centre of society and politics. Finally, we will extend Capitini’s reflection claiming that nonviolence as praxis is a non-systematic revolutionary approach aiming at freedom and plurality. We will add that this praxis is impure, because made of less than perfect actions performed in a very imperfect environment by imperfect human beings. Reconceiving nonviolence as impure praxis will allow us to reunite principled and pragmatic nonviolence, reinterpreting the former as actualisation of a public principle and the latter as a phronesis. This interpretation will offer an interesting form of transformative realism, which enriches via facti any democratic order with life, and show the way to overcome the secular divisions towards a post-secular society centred on the Assisi presumption. 2 | P a g e Declaration I, Roberto Baldoli, hereby declare that this PhD thesis titled: “Nonviolence as Impure Praxis - Reconstructing the Concept with Aldo Capitini” is written by me and that all material in this thesis which is not my own has been identified and properly cited. Student’s name: Roberto Baldoli Signature: Date: 1st September 2015 3 | P a g e Table of Contents Preface…………………………………………………………………………………6 Introduction……………………………………………………………………………8 1. The Success of a Division: Nonviolence as Principled and Pragmatic..39 1.1. Nonviolence: Between Anti-terrorism and Religious Preaching………..….40 1.2. The Distinction between Principles and Methods of Action……………..….47 1.3. Nonviolence is Two: Pragmatic and Principled……………………………...60 2. The Cost of the Division…………………………………………..……………71 2.1. Nonviolence as Action: More than Behaviour, Less than an Ideal………..73 2.2. Reconciling Politics and Morality: Sharing Construction with Everybody…80 2.3. Bringing Religion Back In……………….…………………..………………….85 3. Aldo Capitini’s Concept of Nonviolence………………………..…….……..91 3.1. Nonviolence as Praxis of Liberation and Openness…………………...……92 3.2. Beyond Pragmatic Nonviolence: a Different Method for the Power of All……………………………………………………………………………………..104 3.3. Beyond Principled Nonviolence: the Great Refusal and the Craft of Shaping Reality………………………………………………………………………………..108 4. The ‘Reality of All’: Protests-to-Project, Transformative Realism, and Open Religion………………………………………………...……………………118 4 | P a g e 4.1. Keeping Together Obstruction and Construction: Action as Protest-to- Project………………………………………………………………………………..119 4.2. Nonviolence between Realism and Serenity towards Omnicracy…..……135 4.3. Religion and Nonviolence……………………………………..……………..146 5. Reconstructing nonviolence…………..……………….…………………….156 5.1. Nonviolence as Impure Praxis……………..….……………………………..158 5.2. Transformative Realism for Order with Life……………………..………….180 5.3. Religion and Nonviolence: towards the Assisi Presumption………..…….192 Conclusion………………………...……………………………………………….198 5 | P a g e Preface This dissertation started by chance, but it revealed to be the necessary end of a coherent journey started in Milan some years ago. The choice to work on nonviolence, and in particular on Aldo Capitini, came from the precious encounter with Claudio Radaelli. He introduced me to the world of nonviolence, and he provided me with trust, guidance, understanding, encouragement and friendship. Without him, this work would not have been possible. Before focusing on nonviolence, my interests revolved around concepts such as peace and just war. These are very well-established topics. Instead, since I started to work on nonviolence, I had to deal with a completely different situation. Nonviolence is a recent and quite mistreated concept, which achieved already a lot in practical terms, but still suffers a chronic lack of theoretical analyses (and debates). Besides, I found that the literature on nonviolence was almost completely ignored by mainstream political theory. This was definitely the sign that a much more comprehensive work was needed. In this journey, I found in Aldo Capitini the perfect guide and help. His formation, influence and style are at the same time very Italian and very international. He represents an interesting mix of various Italian schools of thought, from the Actualism of Gentile, to existentialism of Baglietto, to the school of Milan of Martinetti, Preti and Dal Pra. At the same time, these very deep roots do not limit his thought. Capitini is part of an international dialogue on how to work for a better and more pacific world. At the centre of this international drive, we find the concept of nonviolence, which he marvellously described as something neither only for saints, nor for cowards. This was the best starting point for a student who received his training in philosophy in Milan, with a strong phenomenological blueprint, but found himself in a political science department of the UK, with different concerns and sensibilities. The result is in my view a very interdisciplinary work, which tries to speak to everybody without closing down into one tradition. This interdisciplinary work is also a mix of help from very different scholars coming from very diverse backgrounds, who I want to thank. I would like to thank 6 | P a g e dr. Andrew Shaap for his precious help. He showed me what is expected from a political theorist through the many suggestions and criticisms to the (many) versions of this work. I would also like to thank prof. Mario López Martínez for the many discussions we had while I was Visiting Researcher at the University of Granada, and prof. Antonino Drago of the University of Pisa for the email exchange we had, in which he offered important suggestions on early drafts of the thesis. At the same time, I would like to thank prof. Massimo Parodi of the University of Milan. This dissertation is inevitably the result of the many discussions I had with him during my years in Milan. All this work, training and network would have been impossible without the help of my family. No word of this dissertation would have been written without Alessandro, Rosanna and Giampietro, who I should thank for their endless faith in me and providing all the help and support I needed to realise my ambitions. Also, I thank Tania Risoleo for all the care, encouragement, patience and love. They represent the bedrock upon which all my life and work are built. The result of this journey lies in the following pages, which I hope will represent the basis for future research and work. The usual disclaimer applies. 7 | P a g e INTRODUCTION The opposite of foot is what? A mountain top’s one answer, but If you are thinking of a bed, The opposite of foot is head. To ancient generals, of course, The opposite of foot is horse. Richard Wilbur, Opposites The poems of Wilbur are perhaps the best way to describe the varying connotations that can be derived from the meaning of a simple term. His poems on the opposites are meant to be for children, but they reveal an important lesson for everybody. Each word he uses, even the most common and apparently unambiguous term, like ‘foot’, finds itself always in use, in new and unexpected plays with other words. And in the play of life, words arise, change in meaning, and play with different opposites, are frequently used, or die. This word interplay underlies a war, a real struggle for the term’s existence. This struggle leads us back to the words of Heraclitus. With the famous sentence, “we must know that war [polemos] is common to all and strife is justice, and that all things come into being through strife necessarily,” the Greek philosopher reminds us of the worldly features in which this struggle takes place. This world is far from immutable and stable; it is a flux, in a cosmos interpreted as fire, as energy in endless transformation. The harmony of the world does not lie in the conciliation of opposites, which would lead to dead quiet, but in a continuous struggle between them. The being is the result of this struggle, in perfect adherence to the logos, the universal law that governs our existence. In this play, or struggle, it happens that the many different circumstances of everyday life constantly create and destroy words and meanings.
Recommended publications
  • Change in the Italian Party System
    Change in the Italian Party System Luciano BARDI Senio r Lecture r in Po litica! Science, Università di Bologna 1. Introduction 1 The Italian party system appears to have undergone a rather dramatic trans­ formation in recent years. lts extent is revealed by the fact that none of the 13 major competitors in the 1994 Chamber of Deputies' proportional election (ac­ counting for almost 95% of the votes and all but a handful of seats) were present with the same names and symbols as in the 1987 election. Moreover, all but four of them, the Democratie Party of the Left (PDS) and Communist Refoundation (RC) as well as the Catholic inspired La Rete and the Radical Party's (PR) new elec­ toral incarnation, Lista Pannella, experienced important formal or even substan­ tial changes since the 1992 election. Although only one of the 13 lists, Silvio Berlusconi's Forza Italia, appears to be completely new, the sheer number of the­ se changes, albeit formal and superficial in some cases, reveals not only the mag­ nitude of the party system's transformation, but also the radical shift in public attitudes toward the old, party-based, regime. Because party is now a word used only with contempt by politicians and commentators, it is a label which electoral competitors carefully try to avoid. In the 1994 election only three of the most important competitors (PDS, PSI , PPI) still called themselves "parties" 2 . By 1994 even ltaly's surviving historica! parties had adopted new organizatio­ nal models. The PDS remained closest to its earlier tradition, and the prelimi­ nary party rules accepted in 1991 provided a formal structure which resembled the mass party model, albeit in a context of emerging factionalism and stratarchy.
    [Show full text]
  • Executive Intelligence Review, Volume 6, Number 23, June 12, 1979
    EXECUTIVE INTELLIGENCE REVIEW June 12-18, 1979 New Solidarity International Press Service [THIS PAGE IS INTENTIONALLY BLANK] Editor-In-chief: Fernando Quijano Editor: Paul Arnest Associate Editor: Kathy Stevens Senior Editor: Vin Berg Production Manager: Patricia Van Zwaren Circulation Manager: Bohnie Silver Contributing Editors: Lyndon H. LaRouche, Jr., Criton Zoakos, Christopher White, Costas Kalimtgis, Nancy Spannaus NEW YORK BUREAU: Nora Hamerman, bureau chief Africa: Douglas DeGroot Asia: Daniel Sneider Counterintelligence: Jeffrey Steinberg Military Strategy: Paul Goldstein Economics: David Goldman Energy: William Engdahl Europe: Vivian Zoakos Labor: L. Wolfe and M. Moriarty Latin America: Dennis Small Law: Felice Gelman Middle East: Robert Dreyfuss Science and Technology: Morris Levitt Soviet Sector: Rachel Douglas United States: Konstantin George and Stephen Pepper United Nations: Leif Johnson INTERNATIONAL BUREAUS: Bogota: Carlos Cota Meza Bonn: George Gregory Brussels: Christine Juarez Europe attacks Chicago: Mitchell Hirsch Copenhagen: Vincent Robson Mexico City: Robyn Quijano the oil speculators Milan: Muriel Mirak Paris: Catherine Kantor Having created an oil "shortage" in the Vnited States, \ and Sophie Tanapura Energy Secretary James Schlesinger has turned around Rome: Claudio Celani and moved to create one in Europe-by granting V.S. Stockholm: Clifford Gaddy Washington D.C.: Laura Chasen oil companies a $5 "entitlement" subsidy to speCUlate and Ron Kokinda on the Rotterdam spot oil markets. The move has Wiesbaden: (European Economics): infuriated Euro eans, who thought they had Schlesin­ Mark Tritsch p ger's promise that the V.S. would absorb two-thirds of an overall lEA energy consumption cutback. In our Executive Intelligence Review is INTERNATIONAL REPORT this week, we look at published by New Solidarity Europe's angry response to the Schlesinger moves­ International Press Service highlighted by French Foreign Minister Fran�ois­ 304 W.
    [Show full text]
  • Resoconto Stenografico
    Atti Parlamentari — 13153 — Camera dei Deputati XI LEGISLATURA - DISCUSSIONI - SEDUTA DEL 6 MAGGIO 1993 RESOCONTO STENOGRAFICO 175. SEDUTA DI GIOVEDÌ 6 MAGGIO 1993 PRESIDENZA DEL PRESIDENTE GIORGIO NAPOLITANO INDI DEI VICEPRESIDENTI SILVANO LABRIOLA E ALFREDO BIONDI INDICE PAG. PAG. Comunicazioni del Governo (Discussio• NANIA DOMENICO (gruppo MSI-destra na• ne): zionale) 13215 PRESIDENTE... 13157, 13168, 13179,13183, NAPOLI VITO (gruppo DC) 13220 13186,13193, 13198, 13201, 13205, 13211, PANNELLA MARCO (gruppo federalista eu• 13215, 13218, 13220, 13222, 13225, 13226, ropeo) 13168 13228, 13229, 13231, 13233 PARLATO ANTONIO (gruppo MSI-destra BASSANINI FRANCO (gruppo PDS) 13201 nazionale) 13222 PIOLI CLAUDIO (gruppo misto) 13225 CAVERI LUCIANO (gruppo misto-V\) ... 13179 RAPAGNÀ PIO (gruppo federalista euro• CIAMPI CARLO AZEGLIO, Presidente del peo) 13229 Consiglio dei ministri 13157 ROJCH ANGELINO (gruppo DC) 13231 CICCIOMESSERE ROBERTO (gruppo federa• RUTELLI FRANCESCO (gruppo dei verdi) . 13186 lista europeo) 13218 THALER AUSSERHOFER HELGA (gruppo mi- FERRARI MARTE (gruppo PSI) 13226 sto-SVP) 13228 FERRI ENRICO (gruppo PSDI) 13183 ZANONE VALERIO (gruppo liberale) .... 13211 GARAVINI ANDREA SERGIO (gruppo rifon• dazione comunista) 13205 Conferimento di incarichi a ministri LABRIOLA SILVANO (gruppo PSI) 13193 senza portafoglio: MASTELLA MARIO CLEMENTE (gruppo DC) 13198 PRESIDENTE 13155 175. N.B. I documenti esaminati nel corso della seduta e le comunicazioni all'Assemblea non lette in aula sono pubblicati nell'Allegato A. Gli atti di controllo
    [Show full text]
  • Welcome to Holy Family Parish 17 Fordham Avenue, Hicksville, NY 11801 516-938-3846 [email protected]
    Welcome to Holy Family Parish 17 Fordham Avenue, Hicksville, NY 11801 516-938-3846 www.HolyFamilyParishNY.org [email protected] February 24th, 2019 The Seventh Sunday in Ordinary Time Mass Schedule Parish Office Hours Monday - Thursday Monday - Friday: Saturday: 9:00 am 9am - 4pm & 7pm - 9pm 7:00 am and 9:00 am 5:00 pm Friday: 9am - 4pm Anticipated Sunday Mass Saturday: 10am - 6pm Sunday: 7:30 am, 9:00 am, 10:30 am, 12:00 pm, & 5:00 pm Sunday: 10am - 1pm Mission Statement Holy Family Roman Catholic Church is a parish community where all are welcome. Empowered by the Holy Spirit, we are called together to worship the Lord, celebrate the sacraments, and are sent forth to live and teach the Gospel of Jesus Christ through education and service to our families, community, and world. The Seventh Sunday in Ordinary Time February 24, 2019 Mass Schedule Sunday, February 24, 2019 The Seventh Sunday in Ordinary Time Sacrificial Offerings 7:30 am The Parishioners of Holy Family 9:00 am George Bopp Altar Candles for the Week of February 24, 2019 In Loving Memory of Peter Johnson 10:30 am The Brennan Family By The Johnson Family 12:00 pm Sister Joanne Deas, OP 5:00 pm Barbara Desmoni Altar Bread & Wine for the Week of February 25, 2019 In Loving Memory of Peter Johnson Monday, February 25, 2019 By The Johnson Family 7:00 am Al Puppo 9:00 am Evelyn Bennett Mass Intentions are a significant practice of our faith; offering the sacrifice of the Mass for the deceased and spiritual graces for the living.
    [Show full text]
  • Some Aspects of Life and Politics in the United States of America in 19321)
    M. S. VENKATARAMANI SOME ASPECTS OF LIFE AND POLITICS IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA IN 19321) To the present generation of young Americans the so-called two party system appears to be an almost unshakeable and permanent feature of the nation's polity. Several well-known American liberals (as, for instance, Senator Paul Douglas of Illinois and Walter Reuther, head of the powerful United Automobile Workers), who, in earlier years had reposed little faith in the Republican and Democratic parties, have gradually veered round to the view that the quest for reform must be pursued within the framework of the two major political parties. "Third parties" on the American scene have become virtually skele- tonized for various reasons and their plans and platforms receive scant notice at the hands of the media of mass communication. With the advent of good times during the war and post-war years, organizations advocating a radical reconstruction of the social and economic order have found a progressively shrinking audience. Radicalism among the intelligentsia has become a factor of minor significance. Will there be any important changes in such a state of affairs if the current business "recession" continues much longer or intensifies? Do "bad times" favor the growth of militant parties of protest and dissent? Few students of the American scene expect that in the foreseeable future there will be any widespread move away from the two traditional parties. It is interesting in this connection to examine the developments in the United States a quarter of a century ago when the nation was plunged into one of the most serious economic crises in its annals.
    [Show full text]
  • Gandhi Wields the Weapon of Moral Power (Three Case Stories)
    Gandhi wields the weapon of moral power (Three Case Stories) By Gene Sharp Foreword by: Dr. Albert Einstein First Published: September 1960 Printed & Published by: Navajivan Publishing House Ahmedabad 380 014 (INDIA) Phone: 079 – 27540635 E-mail: [email protected] Website: www.navajivantrust.org Gandhi wields the weapon of moral power FOREWORD By Dr. Albert Einstein This book reports facts and nothing but facts — facts which have all been published before. And yet it is a truly- important work destined to have a great educational effect. It is a history of India's peaceful- struggle for liberation under Gandhi's guidance. All that happened there came about in our time — under our very eyes. What makes the book into a most effective work of art is simply the choice and arrangement of the facts reported. It is the skill pf the born historian, in whose hands the various threads are held together and woven into a pattern from which a complete picture emerges. How is it that a young man is able to create such a mature work? The author gives us the explanation in an introduction: He considers it his bounden duty to serve a cause with all his ower and without flinching from any sacrifice, a cause v aich was clearly embodied in Gandhi's unique personality: to overcome, by means of the awakening of moral forces, the danger of self-destruction by which humanity is threatened through breath-taking technical developments. The threatening downfall is characterized by such terms as "depersonalization" regimentation “total war"; salvation by the words “personal responsibility together with non-violence and service to mankind in the spirit of Gandhi I believe the author to be perfectly right in his claim that each individual must come to a clear decision for himself in this important matter: There is no “middle ground ".
    [Show full text]
  • The Ethics of Cosmopolitan Government in Europe
    University of Warwick institutional repository: http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of Warwick http://go.warwick.ac.uk/wrap/3921 This thesis is made available online and is protected by original copyright. Please scroll down to view the document itself. Please refer to the repository record for this item for information to help you to cite it. Our policy information is available from the repository home page. THE ETHICS OF COSMOPOLITAN GOVERNMENT IN EUROPE SUBJECTS OF INTEREST / SUBJECTS OF RIGHT Owen Parker Thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor in Philosophy in Politics and International Studies. University of Warwick Department of Politics and International Studies August 2010 i Summary of Contents INTRODUCTION: THE ETHICS OF COSMOPOLITAN GOVERNMENT IN EUROPE .......................................... 1 PART I: A GENEALOGY OF LIBERAL GOVERMENT IN EUROPE: TOWARDS A MARKET COSMOPOLITAN ORDER? .................................................................................................................................................... 57 CHAPTER 1: A GENEALOGY OF LIBERAL GOVERNMENT IN EUROPE I: CONCEIVING A EUROPEAN ECONOMIC UNIT .............. 60 CHAPTER 2: A GENEALOGY OF LIBERAL GOVERNMENT IN EUROPE II: REALISING A EUROPEAN ECONOMIC UNIT ............. 110 PART II: LEGAL COSMOPOLITAN GOVERNMENT I: THE ETHICS OF A EUROPEAN COSMOPOLITANISM ... 159 CHAPTER 3: CONCEIVING LEGAL COSMOPOLITAN GOVERNMENT I: EUROPE AS ‘SOCIAL EUROPE’ ............................... 162 CHAPTER 4: SECURING LEGAL COSMOPOLITAN GOVERNMENT I: ‘SOCIAL EUROPE’ AND ITS OTHERS .......................... 205 PART III: LEGAL COSMOPOLITAN GOVERNMENT II: THE ETHICS OF A COSMOPOLITAN EUROPE........... 254 CHAPTER 5: CONCEIVING LEGAL COSMOPOLITAN GOVERNMENT II: PLURAL EUROPE AND DELIBERATIVE GOVERNANCE ... 257 CHAPTER 6: SECURING LEGAL COSMOPOLITAN GOVERNMENT II: ‘SUBJECT OF RIGHT’ MEETS ‘SUBJECT OF INTEREST’......
    [Show full text]
  • "The Crisis in the Communist Party," by James Casey
    THE CRISIS in the..; COMMUNIST PARTY By James Casey Price IDc THREE ARROWS PRESS 21 East 17th Street New York City CHAPTER I THE PEOPlES FRONT AND MEl'tIBERSHIP The Communist Party has always prided itself on its «line." It has always boasted of being a "revolutionary work-class party with a Marxist­ Leninist line." Its members have been taught to believe that the party cannot be wrong at any time on any question. Nonetheless, today this Communist Party line has thrown the member­ ship of the Communist Party into a Niagara of Confusion. There are old members who insist that the line or program has not been changed. There are new members who assert just as emphatically that the line certainly has been changed and it is precisely because of this change that they have joined the party. Hence there is a clash of opinion which is steadily mov­ ing to the boiling point. Assuredly the newer members are correct in the first part of their contention that the basic program of the Communist Party has been changed. They are wrong when they hold that this change has been for the better. Today the Communist Party presents and seeks to carry out the "line" of a People's Front organization. And with its slogan of a People's Front, it has wiped out with one fell swoop, both in theory and in practice, the fundamental teachings of Karl Marx and Freidrick Engels. It, too, disowns in no lesser degree in deeds, if not yet in words, all the preachings and hopes of Nicolai Lenin, great interpretor of Marx and founder of the U.
    [Show full text]
  • Aldo Capitini on Opposition and Liberation
    Aldo Capitini on Opposition and Liberation Aldo Capitini on Opposition and Liberation: A Life in Nonviolence Edited by Piergiorgio Giacchè Translated by Jodi L. Sandford Aldo Capitini on Opposition and Liberation: A Life in Nonviolence Edited by Piergiorgio Giacchè Translated by Jodi L. Sandford This book first published 2020 Cambridge Scholars Publishing Lady Stephenson Library, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE6 2PA, UK British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Copyright © 2020 by Piergiorgio Giacchè and Jodi L. Sandford All rights for this book reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner. ISBN (10): 1-5275-4846-5 ISBN (13): 978-1-5275-4846-6 This book is dedicated to all people who have furthered the concept of inclusion, peace, and nonviolence; opposing fascism, prevarication, and prejudice of any sort. TABLE OF CONTENTS Premise ...................................................................................................... ix Giuseppe Moscati Introductory Note to the Translation ......................................................... xi Jodi L. Sandford Translation Once Again with Capitini ........................................................................... 2 Goffredo Fofi Introduction ...............................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Framing, Transnational Diffusion, and African- American Intellectuals in the Land of Gandhi
    IRSH 49 (2004), Supplement, pp. 19–40 DOI: 10.1017/S0020859004001622 # 2004 Internationaal Instituut voor Sociale Geschiedenis Framing, Transnational Diffusion, and African- American Intellectuals in the Land of Gandhi Sean Chabot Summary: Most of the contentious-politics scholars who pioneered the study of framing in social movements now also recognize the importance of transnational diffusion between protest groups. Interestingly, though, they have not yet specified how these two processes intersect. This article, in contrast, explores the framing- transnational diffusion nexus by highlighting three historical moments of inter- action between African-American intellectuals and Gandhian activists before Martin Luther King, Jr traveled to India in 1959. After briefly reviewing the relevant literature, it illustrates how three different types of ‘‘itinerant’’ African- American intellectuals – mentors like Howard Thurman, advisors like Bayard Rustin, and peers like James Lawson – framed the Gandhian repertoire of nonviolent direct action in ways that made it applicable during the American civil rights movement. The final section considers possible implications for social movement theory and fertile areas for further research. In February 1959, a few years after the Montgomery bus boycott had anointed him as a prophet of nonviolence, Martin Luther King, Jr arrived in India to talk with fellow disciples of Gandhi and witness the effects of the Indian independence movement. He and his wife, Coretta, toured the country, had dinner with Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, visited Gandhi’s ashrama (self-sufficient communes), participated in conferences, and attended numerous receptions in their honor. During their four-week stay in India, the Kings discussed Gandhian nonviolent action with native experts like Dr Radhakrishnan, India’s Vice-President; Jayaprakash Narain, a contemporary protest leader; and G.
    [Show full text]
  • Genealogy of Nonviolence
    GENEALOGY OF NONVIOLENCE “Nonviolence is the greatest force humanity has been endowed with” Gandhi “History will have to record that the greatest tragedy of this period of social transition was not the strident clamour of the bad people, but the appalling silence of the good people” Martin Luther King “Peace won’t come from a violent approach to violence. Nonviolence is the only way out” Silo (Mario Rodriguez Cobos) WHAT IS ACTIVE NONVIOLENCE ? Violence in the present world is increasing and expanding in all fields, generating a climate of fear, uncertainty, asphyxia and dark times. We are not only speaking of the physical violence of war and criminality, but also of economic, racial, religious and psychological violence, domestic and family violence and inner violence. Sometimes we hear the word nonviolence but, also due to the superficial nature of information, we don’t always have a precise idea of what it is. Nonviolence is not pacifism, neither is it a simple methodology for demonstrating. Nonviolence is not the resigned attitude of those who through fear avoid confrontation. Nonviolence is a great life philosophy and methodology of action, that has always inspired profound moral and religious convictions and today is the only coherent response to the spiral of violence that surrounds us. Frequently nonviolence is identified with pacifism, but in reality the latter is not a method of action or a life style, but a constant denunciation against the arms race. Therefore, it is inferred that nonviolence and active nonviolence consist of a personal commitment, a style of life and a methodology for social change.
    [Show full text]
  • Nonviolent Weapons
    1 Nonviolent Weapons The Transnationalism of Nonviolent Resistance Liam Comer-Weaver Dept. of International Affairs, University of Colorado April 1, 2015 Thesis Advisor: Dr. Lucy Chester Defense Committee: Dr. Victoria Hunter Dr. Benjamin Teitelbaum 2 Abstract This thesis takes a deep historical look at the adaptation of Mohandas Gandhi’s nonviolent ideology and strategy in the civil rights movement in the AmeriCan South in order to understand the Composition, ConstruCtion, and behavior of the modern nonviolent movement known as 15M in Spain. The Complete translation of Gandhi’s repertoire resulted in the formation of subversive groups, or Contentious Communities, whiCh shared the Common goal of desegregation and Cultural integration of the southern black population. These Contentious Communities regrouped in nonviolent efforts, and interaCted as a groupusCule with the same ideology. This adaptation of nonviolent ideology and strategy also recently occurred in what is known as the 15M movement in Spain. The 15M movement is similarly Composed of many diverse Contentious Communities whose ColleCtive purpose is eConomiC equality and inCreased representation in government. 3 Table of Contents Glossary of Key Terms and Organizations .................................................................................. 4 Preface ...................................................................................................................................... 6 Part I: Nonviolent Resistance Campaigns ..................................................................................
    [Show full text]