(Public Pack)Agenda Document for Planning Committee, 21/01/2021
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Contact details Committee Officer on 01730 814810 Email [email protected] SOUTH DOWNS NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY PLANNING COMMITTEE A meeting of the Planning Committee will be held at 10.00 am on Thursday, 21st January, 2021 at the Online via Zoom Cloud Meetings Trevor Beattie, Chief Executive (National Park Officer) AGENDA PART I 1. Apologies for absence 2. Declaration of interests To enable Members to declare to the meeting any disclosable interest they may have in any matter on the agenda for the meeting. 3. Minutes of previous meeting held on 10 December 2020 (Pages 3 - 8) To approve as a correct record the minutes of the Planning Committee meeting held on 10 December 2020. 4. Matters arising from the previous meeting minutes To enable any matters arising from the 10 December 2020 Planning Committee minutes that are not covered elsewhere on this agenda to be raised. 5. Updates on previous Committee decisions To receive any updates on previous Committee decisions. 6. Urgent matters To consider any matters on the agenda which the Chair agrees should be considered as a matter of urgency due to special circumstances. DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT 7. Application No.: SDNP/20/03965/FUL Newton Valence Farm, Newton Valence (Pages 9 - 24) Local Authority: East Hampshire District Council Proposal: Grain store and drier after demolition of existing agricultural buildings. Address: Newton Valence Farm Selborne Road Newton Valence Alton GU34 3RN. To consider a report by the Director of Planning (Report PC20/21-27). 8. Application No.: SDNP/19/03709/FUL - Oaklands Farm (Pages 25 - 48) Local Authority: East Hampshire District Council Proposal: Change of use of Oakland Farm and associated land holdings from Agriculture and B8 (Open Storage) to mixed use Agriculture, B8 (Open Storage) and Seasonal Event Space associated with the holding of a Religious Festival associated with the Ahmadiyya Muslim Association; alongside the provision of external storage space, new landscape and revised ventilation and extraction equipment in association with the onsite kitchen. Address: Oaklands Farm Green Street East Worldham Bordon GU34 3AU. To consider a report by the Director of Planning (Report PC20/21-28). Members of the Planning Committee Alun Alesbury, Heather Baker, Janet Duncton, Thérèse Evans, Barbara Holyome, Diana van der Klugt, Gary Marsh, Robert Mocatta, Vanessa Rowlands, Andrew Shaxson and Richard Waring Ex officio Members (may participate on Policy items but not vote): Ian Phillips 1 Members’ Interests SDNPA Members have a primary responsibility for ensuring that the Authority furthers the National Park Purposes and Duty. Members regard themselves first and foremost as Members of the Authority, and will act in the best interests of the National Park as a whole, rather than as representatives of their appointing body or any interest groups. Members are required to declare any disclosable pecuniary interest that is not already entered in the Authority's register of interests, and any personal interest and/or public service interest (as defined in Paragraph 18 of the Authority's Code of Conduct) they may consider relevant to an item of business being considered at the meeting (such disclosure to be made at the commencement of the meeting, or when the interest becomes apparent). Access to Information If you would like a copy of this agenda in large print or an alternative format/language please contact the Committee Officer at [email protected] or 01730 814810 Recording of Meetings The Openness of Local Government Bodies Regulations give a right to members of the public to record (film, photograph and audio-record) and report on proceedings at committee meetings. The Authority has a protocol on ‘Filming, Recording and Reporting of South Downs National Park Authority Meetings’ which is available on our website. As part of the Authority’s drive to increase accessibility to its public meetings, this meeting will be filmed for live and/ or subsequent broadcast via the internet; at the start of the meeting the Chair will confirm if all or part of the meeting is to be filmed. The images and sound recording may be used for training or any other purposes by the Authority. By entering the meeting room and using the public seating area you are consenting to being filmed, recorded or photographed and to the possible use of those images and sound recordings for webcasting and/or training purposes. If you have any queries regarding this, please contact the Governance Officer [email protected] Public Participation Anyone wishing to speak at the meeting should register their request no later than 12 noon, 3 working days before the meeting by e-mailing [email protected]. The public participation protocol is available on our website www.southdowns.gov.uk/ Feedback If you wish to give us feedback on your experience of the meeting please e-mail [email protected] 2 Unconfirmed Planning Committee Meeting Minutes to be approved at the next meeting SOUTH DOWNS NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY PLANNING COMMITTEE 10 December 2020 Held: online via Zoom videoconferencing, at 10am. Present: Alun Alesbury (Chair), Heather Baker, Janet Duncton, Thérèse Evans, Barbara Holyome, Diana van der Klugt, Gary Marsh, William Meyer, Robert Mocatta, Vanessa Rowlands, Andrew Shaxson and Ian Philips (ex. officio). Officers: Tim Slaney (Director of Planning), Rob Ainslie (Development Manager), Lucy Howard (Planning Policy Manager), Becky Moutrey (Solicitor), Richard Sandiford (Senior Governance Officer) and Sara Osman (Governance Officer). Also attended by: Heather Lealan (Development Management and Enforcement Lead) and Amy Tyler-Jones (Senior Planning Policy Officer). OPENING REMARKS 194. The Chair welcomed Members to the meeting and informed those present that: Due to the current Coronavirus pandemic full meetings were not able to be held at the Memorial Hall until further notice, hence the meeting of the South Downs National Park Authority was held using the Zoom Cloud Meetings software. The meeting was being webcast by the Authority and would be available for subsequent on-line viewing. Anyone entering the meeting was considered to have given consent to be filmed or recorded, and for the possible use of images and sound recordings for webcasting and/or training purposes. 195. The Senior Governance Officer confirmed the Members of the Planning Committee who were present, that the meeting was quorate and reminded Members of the protocol that would be followed during the online meeting. 196. The Chair reminded those present that: SDNPA Members had a primary responsibility for ensuring that the Authority furthers the National Park Purposes and Duty. Members regarded themselves first and foremost as Members of the Authority, and would act in the best interests of the National Park as a whole, rather than as representatives of their appointing body or any interest groups. ITEM 1: APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE 197. There were none. ITEM 2: DECLARATION OF INTERESTS 198. The Chair declared a non-prejudicial, public service interest on behalf of all Members as David Coldwell, who was a speaker on item 8, was previously a Member of the SDNPA, and had been a member of the Planning Committee, and was therefore known to the majority of Members of the Committee. Diana van der Klugt was also a Councillor on Horsham District Council where David Coldwell had previously been a Member. 199. Barbara Holyome declared a personal and a non-prejudicial interest in item 9 as the applicants, and some of the speakers, were known to her. She was also a member of the Bramdean Parish Council but had not sat on any meetings which had discussed this item. ITEM 3: MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING HELD ON 12 NOVEMBER 2020 200. The minutes of the previous meeting held on 12 November 2020 were agreed as a correct record and signed by the Chair. ITEM 4: MATTERS ARISING FROM PREVIOUS MINUTES 201. There were none. ITEM 5: UPDATES ON PREVIOUS COMMITTEE DECISIONS 202. The decision has been issued for SDNP/18/06292/OUT - Land North of Buckmore Farm, Petersfield. ITEM 6: URGENT ITEMS 203. There were none. 3 Unconfirmed Planning Committee Meeting Minutes to be approved at the next meeting ITEM 7: SDNP/20/02616/FUL - Dangstein 204. The Case Officer presented the application and referred to the update sheet. 205. The following public speakers addressed the Committee: David Campion spoke against the application representing clients who objected to the proposal; Cllr Steve Williamson spoke against the application representing Rogate Parish Council; Nick Jacobs spoke against the application representing himself; Paddy Cox spoke in support of the application as the agent and the applicant; Dylan Walker spoke in support of the application representing himself; Archie Yellop spoke in support of the application representing himself. 206. The Committee considered the report by the Director of Planning (Report PC20/21-24), the update sheet and the public speaker comments, and requested clarification as follows: Could the Committee approve a temporary permission until 18 November 2022, in order that the renewal of planning permission would be considered at the same time as the other application for this site (SDNP/17/03623/FUL)? How would enforcement of the conditions be monitored? Could condition 3 be amended to require a vehicle log to be kept, in order that Officers could monitor that conditions were being met, rather than relying on local residents to notify the Enforcement team if a breach had occurred? Clarification on the number of vehicle movements permitted in and out of the site. When would forestry work be considered light industrial as opposed to ancillary work, and therefore outside of the constraints of this application? How was woodland management being achieved to ensure any trees that were removed were being replaced? 207. In response to questions, Officers clarified: Members could decide to limit the length of a permission to coincide with the appeal decision.