P27-32.Qxp Layout 1
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
Established 1961 29 Lifestyle Features Wednesday, October 11, 2017 Shock Iraq torture photos raise ethical dilemmas They are like the infamous images from Abu report for the US television network, ABC. thing to covering extreme stuff. They just feed the Ghraib prison, only worse. Iraqi civilians in Mosul “What began for Ali as a positive story about machine” of photo agencies that want to show facing rape, torture and murder from members of Shia and Sunni Iraqi soldiers fighting on the same “they are still in the business even if they don’t their own army who had retaken the city from the side against a mutual enemy, turned into a horrific cover most things anymore. Islamic State. “They are the most sinister, upset- journey that included torture, rape, killing and “And then when something goes wrong, the ting pictures I have seen in my entire life,” the thieving of innocent Iraqi civilians by the ERD,” guy becomes a scapegoat and everyone becomes veteran BBC war correspondent Jeremy Bowen said the US-based photo agency, VII, who helped very self-righteous.” VII co-founder Gary Knight said of the images taken by Kurdish photographer get him out of Iraq. “I’d seen two heroes (the said that the agency did not know what Arkady Ali Arkady. This weekend the brutal series of pic- unit’s commanders) do something bad,” Arkady had uncovered while he was working on the story. tures called “Kissing Death” Arkady took last said. “They started torturing people, raping “We did not pressure Ali to publish the images, year while embedded with members of an Iraqi women. Everything the opposite is special forces unit, won France’s top prize for war changed in my mind. true,” said Knight. correspondents. I was confused. I “We suggested that The photographs were not just “really strong” decided to investi- he think long and said Bowen, who chaired the Bayeux-Calvados gate more.” hard... because we jury, “they were evil”. But it wasn’t only their Bowen, who has Most sinister, knew that he would content that disturbed the jury. Arkady, 34, admit- spent decades have to leave the ted to being pressured into hitting two suspects reporting from the upsetting pictures country for his own A photo by the Bayeux-Calvados Awards for war correspondents, and taken by during a torture session to save his own skin, Middle East, said security — possibly Iraqi photographer Ali Arkady, from the VII Photo agency, as part of his cover of actions of which he said he was “not proud”. But the fact that Arkady I have seen forever-if he did,” the Mosul battle entitled ‘Kissing Death.’ other war photographers asked whether a line had exposed abuses he added. had been crossed? While Bowen insisted that that would other- in my entire life Knight said he “the service he did by taking those pictures is wise have gone and the agency’s more powerful that the fact he made some mis- unreported was the other acclaimed war takes”, others were not so sure. overriding factor. “I think it is very important he photographers Christopher Morris and Ron Haviv Another member of the jury, who asked not be admitted the mistakes he made. In moral terms, he had mentored “Ali for years to offer him support named, told AFP that he was disturbed by the is not a torturer,” he said. Award-winning British and advice”. Smith said although Arkady should ethical issues the “shocking” pictures raised. “The war photographer Sean Smith of The Guardian, not have taken part in torture, photographers story is not clear. A lot of people think he has who was not on the jury, said he “would not con- were sometimes put in desperate positions. “If been very brave in telling this story... but I think demn” Arkady either. For him, however, “the sys- you go with people like that you can’t say, ‘I don’t we are not sending the right message in reward- tem which put him in that position-where often agree with what you are doing.’ You blend in and ing this type of work,” he added. inexperienced locally hired freelance ‘stringers’ disappear, you may even end up getting drunk provide the coverage” from dangerous war zones, with them.” For there is always “a very real dan- He admitted his mistakes is the real problem. ger you can end up dumped by the side of a road Arkady was forced to flee Iraq with his family with a bullet in your head”, he said.—AFP earlier this year, bringing with him images and Whole system compromised films which he said proved war crimes were com- “The whole thing has got so compromised mitted by the Emergency Response Division because major news organizations are sending (ERD) which he had followed for two months. fewer and fewer experienced people,” he said. Iraqi photographer Ali Arkady receives the Photo Prize award during the closing Arkady said he kept working with the unit after “There is no one there. Virtually all the coverage ceremony of the 2017 Bayeux-Calvados Awards for war correspondents in the torture began partly from guilt because he is coming from stringers and social media,” he Bayeux, northwestern France. — AFP photos had painted the soldiers as heroes in an earlier said. Stringers often go “from not covering any- New Fifty Shades Great pumpkins! novel from Christian’s Grower wins trifecta point of view of giant food titles Once again, E L James is letting Christian a statement that the new book would give Grey speak for himself. Vintage Books readers a “darker and more haunted” take announced yesterday that the next “Fifty on Christian. James’ original “Fifty Shades” Shades” novel, “Darker: Fifty Shades Darker trilogy, the sexually graphic saga of In this file photo, author E L James arrives at the amfAR as Told by Christian” will come out Nov 28. Christian Grey and Anastasia Steele, has Inspiration Gala in Los Angeles. — AP “Grey,” published in 2015, also was told sold millions of copies. — AP from Christian’s point of view. James said in Original Bananarama line-up announces first US tour It took a kitchen sing-song to get ‘80s British pop just thought it was such a shame she had never soundtrack for “Karate Kid.” The group said it group Bananarama back together and out on the experienced it with us and it just seemed like such realized how big the song had become when road after 30 years. The girl group’s original a crying shame really.” Mike Tyson once sang the lyrics to them as they members - Sarah Dallin, Keren Woodward and Fahey, who now lives in Los Angeles, said she walked past him in his limo. Further hits includ- Siobhan Fahey - say they are touring the US for was excited to perform the band’s songs live. “I ed “Venus,” “I Heard A Rumor” and “Robert the first time in February. Fahey left the band in am re-familiarizing myself with our body of work DeNiro’s Waiting,” which led to a London meet- 1988 to form Shakespears Sister, and Dallin and over the summer,” she said. “I was so proud, it is ing with the Oscar-winning actor. Woodward have been performing as a duo in really something to celebrate.” Rehearsals began The group was once named by the Guinness recent years. They were joined briefly by Jacquie this week and tickets go on sale Friday. Some World Records as the most successful girl O’Sullivan, who took part in a 1989 world tour but British tour dates have already sold out. “It has group of all time. The group’s North American left in 1991. been a constant love wave actually this time tour begins in Los Angeles on 20 February, tak- “We were having a dance around Siobhan’s around. Times have changed and people seem to ing in San Francisco, New York and Toronto, kitchen a few years ago,” Woodward told The appreciate us a lot more this time,” says Fahey. Canada.—AP Associated Press in an interview. “And I said to Bananarama’s stateside success began with her, ‘you just don’t understand the love and how it “Cruel Summer” of 1983, which became a hit feels when you are getting your songs sung’ and I after the track was picked to appear on the In this photo provided by Susan Jutras, Joe Jutras stands with his world record breaking, 2,118-pound squash, following a weigh-in at Frerichs Farm in Warren, Rhode Island. — AP A Rhode Island grower is first in the hobby. Jutras noted that others had won world to achieve a trifecta in the hobby multiple world records for fruits and of growing gargantuan foods: world vegetables before, but in categories such records for heaviest pumpkin, longest as carrots that are not as competitive. long gourd and now, heaviest squash. He credits a new soil cultivation tech- After previously breaking two records, nique and a seed from last year’s world Joe Jutras got his third during the week- record breaker for this year’s win. Ron end when he smashed the giant squash Wallace, a multi-time pumpkin record record with one that weighed more than breaker, called Jutras’ feat “unbeliev- a ton. His green squash tipped the scales able.” He said Jutras’ accomplishment at 2,118 pounds during a weigh-in at showed the best of the hobby. “It’s about Frerichs Farm in Warren on Saturday. people competing and pushing the His other titles came in 2006, when boundaries,” he said.