Landscapes of Settlement in South-East Cyprus
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
LANDSCAPES OF SETTLEMENT IN SOUTH-EAST CYPRUS THE LATE BRONZE AGE ORIGINS OF A PHOENICIAN POLITY INCORPORATING THE RESULTS OF FIELDWORK BY THE AUTHOR AT PYLA-KOKKINOKREMOS 2007-2009 MICHAEL GARETH BROWN THESIS SUBMITTED FOR THE DEGREE OF PH.D. SCHOOL OF HISTORY, CLASSICS AND ARCHAEOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH 2011 ii I hereby declare that this thesis has been composed entirely by myself and, except where explicitly acknowledged, represents my own work. Its contents have not previously been published, nor submitted for any other degree or professional qualification. ………………...……………………………………………………………… “Journeys, like artists, are born and not made. A thousand differing circumstances contribute to them, few of them willed or determined by the will—whatever we may think.” Lawrence Durrell, Bitter Lemons (1957, 15) iii ABSTRACT The origins of Early Iron Age polity in south-east Cyprus have traditionally been attributed to the formal imposition of Phoenician dominion over Kition in 707 BC. It is proposed that this paradigm fails adequately to acknowledge local agency in the preceding development of relations with Canaan and the Nile Delta from c.1650 BC onwards. Longue durée trends in settlement and societal development suggest that Late Bronze Age communities became pre-adapted to incorporation into wider Levantine spheres of interaction through participation in 'orientalizing' exchange. An emphasis is placed upon the significance of bulk commodity industry as a catalyst for social innovation, including the adoption of urbanism, concurrent with secondary state formation. Three case studies examine the development of regional settlement landscapes within the environs of Ayios Sozomenos, Pyla, and Hala Sultan Tekke. Discussion chiefly incorporates the results of new fieldwork conducted by the author [2007-2009] at the site of Pyla-Kokkinokremos. This involved pedestrian, geophysical and remote sensing survey combined with trial excavation. Several previously unknown archaeological features were identified, providing significant new information concerning the character and intramural composition of this important maritime centre. These findings complement those of previous missions, and reflect an established community rooted in its surroundings. A dominant trend of continuity in settlement and societal development, most clearly apparent through successive episodes of synoecism, is proposed for south-east Cyprus as a whole across the Bronze-to-Iron Age transition. Changes in occupation throughout the eastern Mediterranean at this time have conventionally been attributed to successive waves of migration and colonisation. This thesis constitutes an attempt at a pre-colonial narrative for Phoenician Cyprus, and by extension a conceptual framework to structure investigation of Levantine diaspora communities elsewhere in the Mediterranean. iv CONTENTS Declaration iii Abstract iv Illustrations vi Acknowledgements x PREFACE 1 1 INTRODUCTION 5 1.1 Bronze-to-Iron 5 1.2 Phoenician Identity 9 1.3 Landscape Perspectives 14 2 ALAŠIYA AND THE FOREST 19 2.1 Introduction 19 2.2 Woodland Industry 22 2.3 Riverine Settlement 28 2.4 Alašiya 41 2.5 Summary 46 3 KOKKINOKREMOS AND THE MARITIME LANDSCAPE OF PYLA 49 3.1 Introduction 49 3.2 Techniques of Archaeological Survey 53 3.2.1 Pedestrian Survey 53 3.2.2 Remote Sensing 54 3.2.3 Geophysical Prospecting 55 3.2.4 Trial Soundings 56 3.3 Architecture and Landscape Features 57 3.3.1 The 'Fortification' Wall 57 3.3.2 Intramural Diversity 68 3.3.3 Extramural Occupation 74 3.4 Surface Collection and Material Culture 80 3.5 Discussion 84 4 KITION AND THE LEVANT 93 4.1 Introduction 93 4.2 Ecological Niche 96 4.3 Hala Sultan Tekke and Kition 99 4.4 'Orientalizing' Artefacts and Merchant Firms 113 4.5 Summary 127 5 CONCLUSIONS 131 5.1 General Summary and Conclusions 131 5.2 Priorities for Future Research 138 5.3 Phoenician Cyprus 143 Bibliography 151 v ILLUSTRATIONS (Prepared by the author unless otherwise stated) FIGURES 1.1 Map of Late Bronze Age settlement on Cyprus with principle sites in the south-east 3 of the island. 1.2 Chronology and relative occupation of principle Late Bronze-to-Early Iron Age 4 settlement sites in south-east Cyprus mentioned in the text. 2.1 Map of Late Bronze Age settlement in the region of Ayios Sozomenos 21 (Background image OpenStreetMap.org). 2.2 Modern pine forest in the Troodos foothills. 22 2.3 Wall relief from the palace of Sargon II at Khorsabad depicting the transport of 29 timber along a river (Vigneau 1936, Plate 4). 2.4 Progression siltation of the Gialias-Pedieos Delta. a) c.5000 yrs B.P.; b) c.3500 yrs 31 B.P. (Devillers 2008, 155). 2.5 Model boat fragment from Sinda tomb I (Furumark and Adelman 2003, Plate 39:14) 33 [scale 2:3]. 2.6 a) "Assyrian soldiers towing a boat during a campaign against Merodachbaladan" 33 (Loud et al 1936, fig. 72); b) Boatman towing a sailboat upstream along the Ganges River in modern Bangladesh (photograph BBC Worldwide). 2.7 Early Bronze Age Red Polished Ware pack animal figurine from Pyla district (Morris 34 1985, 204) [scale 1:2]. 2.8 Ayios Sozomenos-Ambellia. Late Bronze Age graves and well visible in section facing 35 north-east from the Alykos River bed (Devillers 2008, 110). 2.9 Ayios Sozomenos-Glyka Vrysis plan and reconstruction of MCIII first 'fortress' 36 (Åström 1972a, 31 after Gjerstad 1926, 39). 2.10 Dhali-Kafkallia tomb G bronze belt and axe [scale 1:3] (Overbeck and Swiny 1972, ill. 38 5). 2.11 Wall relief from the palace of Sargon II at Khorsabad depicting longshoremen loading 40 timber onto riverboats (Botta and Flandin 1849, Plate 35; for description of relevant scenes see Linder 1986, 273-274). 3.1 Map of Late Bronze Age settlement in the region of Pyla (Background image 52 OpenStreetMap.org). vi 3.2 Northern sections of settlement boundary (or 'fortification') wall on Kokkinokremos 58 photographed in 1976 but no longer visible in 2007. a) Wall segment facing north- west [Plan I, feat. 6]; b) Wall segment facing south-west [Plan I, feat. 7]; c) Wall segment facing west [Plan I, feat. 8]. Photographs courtesy of Michel Fortin [all scales 50cm]. 3.3 View from south-east promontory of Kokkinokremos looking south-west towards 59 Larnaca Port. 3.4 a) In situ Cypriot pithos abutting exterior of 'fortification' wall segment on south-east 60 promontory of Kokkinokremos. Scale 1m (Plan I, feat. 4); b) Stone channelling recovered during Kokkinokremos surface survey. Scale 10cm [no. 1305gb]. 3.5 Kokkinokremos sounding EU10 facing north-east. 62 3.6 Plaster floor applied to bedrock at western end of EU10 showing recycled door socle 63 on interior face of western boundary wall [scale 20cm]. 3.7 Kokkinokremos sounding EU11 facing north-east. 64 3.8 N-S baulk across centre of EU11 during excavation showing spatial relationship 65 between segment of LCIIC boundary wall and overlying accumulation of modern field clearance along plateau edge. a) Facing north-east; b) Facing south-west. Scale 1m. 3.9 Kokkinokremos from the air in June 2007 with line of shallow bedrock terrace visible as 67 right-angled soil mark across centre of plateau. 3.10 a) 3D projection of Kokkinokremos geophysical mapping transect GT3 [length 68 40m/width 20m]; b) W-E tomographic section across Kokkinokremos shallow bedrock terrace feature [length 16m]. 3.11 Kokkinokremos sounding EU3 facing west. 69 3.12 Distribution and density of Kokkinokremos survey units relative to shallow bedrock 71 terrace (artefact plot courtesy of W. Caraher pers. comm 2009). 3.13 a) Rock-cut architecture on south-west flank of Kokkinokremos facing east [scale 1m] 74 (Plan I, feat. 1); b) Exposed segment of wall on south-west flank of Kokkinokremos slope facing west [scale 20cm] (Plan I, feat. 2). vii 3.14 Geological section at northwest base of Kokkinokremos facing north-east. Marl 75 sediments (strata A-C) forming colluvial cover of stable terrace soil deposits (strata D- F). A = Pinkish Grey exposed top-soil. Abundant small angular limestone fragments and occasional diabase pebbles (7.5YR 6/2); B = Light brown marl with occasional medium angular limestone fragments (7.5YR 6/3); C = Brown marl-calcarenite composite with few stones (5YR 6/4); D = Pale pinkish grey silty clay marl. Dense fabric with few cracks and occasional calcium carbonate concretions (7.5YR 7/2); E = Pink compacted coarse clay marl (5YR 7/3); F = Pink very firm marl-calcarenite matrix with abundant calcium carbonate fissures and occasional Pleistocene microfossil inclusions (5YR 8/3). 3.15 Mavrospilios-Kokkinokremos gully facing north-west. Geo-section [fig. 3.14] top right. 76 3.16 Pyla-Steno architecture under excavation in 1956 facing south-east, "structures west of 78 L.C. cemetery" (Photograph courtesy of Dept. of Antiquities, Cyprus) [scale approximate]. 3.17 Chronology of Steno and Koukoufouthkia tomb assemblages (Åström and Åström 1972, 79 828). 3.18 Proportional composition of Kokkinokremos site surface assemblage by gross ware 81 category (utility/bulk/fine). 3.19 Pyla-Steno incised potmarks. a) Detail of incised “ladder pattern” pot-mark on neck-to- 82 shoulder handle of Black Slip IV ware globular jug [tomb 2, 61] (Åström 1972a, 78- 79) [scale approximately 1:2]; b) Plain White Hand-made ware jug, almost biconical with handle from just below rim to shoulder, short narrow concave neck and ring base. Detail of incised pot-mark on handle from SCE IV:1C fig. 45.7 [tomb 4, 9] (Åström 1972a, 229, 231, 251); c) Plain White Hand-made ware piriform jug with handle from just below rim to shoulder, narrow concave neck and flat base. Detail of incised two sign inscription on handle [tomb 4, 19] (Åström 1972a, 229, 231). Photographs courtesy of Dept. of Antiquities, Cyprus.