A close reading of the opera Mandela trilogy, with a special focus on the performance of Mandela's masculinities LR Sello orcid.org 0000-0002-1395-9179 Dissertation submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree Master of Music in Musicology at the North-West University Supervisor: Dr C van Rhyn Assistant supervisor: Prof Jaco Kruger Examination: November 2018 Student number: 22565140 i Declaration This is to declare that I, Annette L Combrink, accredited language editor and translator of the South African Translators’ Institute, have language-edited the dissertation by LR Sello with the title A close reading of the opera Mandela trilogy, with a special focus on the performance of Mandela's masculinities Prof Annette L Combrink Accredited translator and language editor South African Translators’ Institute Membership No. 1000356 Date: 11 November 2018 ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Dedications I would like to dedicate this study to my late father, Philimon Moeketsi Sello. He believed that education was the most important tool and skill one must have in order to enrich their lives. I wish you were here to see how your son has lived to aspire to success as a result of your inspiration. Acknowledgements This journey has been the hardest in my whole life. There were moments where I felt like quitting and just find something else to do with my life. However, I had extensive support from family, colleagues and friends, and I would like to thank them from the bottom of my heart. Firstly, my gratitude goes to my amazing supervisor, Dr Chris van Rhyn, for his endless support and his enthusiasm to motivate and teach me something new every day. My assistant supervisor, Prof Jaco Kruger, was always willing to ask the difficult questions with the purpose of ensuring that I write the best dissertation possible. I would like to thank Cape Town Opera, with special mention of my friend Masixole Makwetu, as well as Madré Loubser and Lesley Liddle who were always a call or email away, and ready to welcome me at their offices and send me any relevant documents I required for my study. I would like to thank my wonderful mother, Queen Matsoku Lydia Sello, who from the start has been my rock and support when I decided to study music. My sister Mpeo Kgoadi, brothers Patrick Masilo, Sello Sello and Khitsane Sello for being the best siblings anyone can ever ask for; when I had difficulties in completing my studies you were always a phone call or visit away. The warmth and support of my extended family in Potchefstroom cannot go without mention. Johan and Beulah Le Grange, thank you for being parents to me; not once would I visit and not leave motivated and loved. Duane and Tammy Aslett, I would not have attempted to study BMus, let alone MMus, if you were not pushing and encouraging me all these years. More than friends, you are family that I hold very close to my heart. Shirley Apthorp was my rock and a mother who would debate my research outputs and still put iii a smile on my face. Thank you to Ewie Erusmus and Mignon van Vreden who were also my go-to people when academia or work got too hard – thank you for being you. I am going to mention all my friends who have been with me throughout this journey, be it physically or a phone call away. Itumeleng, Kgomotso and their daughter Otlotleng Lesabe, thank you. You opened your home for the final year of my dissertation, not charging me a cent and just allowing me to feel at home, especially in this year that was emotionally and mentally difficult. Your efforts are greatly appreciated, and I will forever be grateful. Thank you to: Johan Le Grange, Aubrey Lodewyk, Nombulelo Notuku, Mpho Kgotlagomang, Thabang Magagula, Melanie Medell, Kamohelo Tsotetsi, Mokhethi Makhanya, Lesego Maphetle, Mzondeki Makatla, Siyabonga Maqungo, Itumeleng Pooe, Heinrich Heiriss, Ugo Louw, Hederick Prinsloo, William Quinton, Hanru de Vos, Boitumelo Moalosi, Segomotso Shupinyaneng, Nkululeko Semenekane, Nkosinathi Tom, Tumi Sehurutse, Puseletso Ramotheba, Bianca Moalosi, Mmolawa Mokhutle, Eric Plaatjie, Palesa Malieloa, Oamogetswe Seoto, Maleshoane Ntsebe, Mathabo Piitso, Ofentse Magala, Bonolo Moalosi, Puseletso Radebe, Thapelo Libazi, Ofentse Makgala and Sidwell Mile. This dissertation could not have been a success if you did not offer your support, and for that I am thankful and grateful. iv ABSTRACT This study explores the mediation of socio-political and life realities, and the performance of Nelson Mandela’s masculinities in the opera Mandela trilogy, and what that says about the function and nature of contemporary opera in the current socio-political contexts in South Africa. Mandela trilogy is a three-act opera in which events that unfolded in Nelson Mandela’s life are portrayed, from the time he went to the traditional initiation school to his speech after his release from prison in 1990. Acts 1 and 3 were composed by Péter Louis van Dijk and Act 2 by Mike Campbell, and the libretto was written by Michael Williams. The style of the original music in Act 1 is derived from AmaXhosa traditional songs, but it also includes arrangements of existing traditional IsiXhosa songs. The music of Act 2 is predominantly in a jazz style, and Act 3 is in a contemporary classical operatic style. In this close reading, significant technical aspects of the music, musical styles, orchestration, textual content and structure (libretto), staging, costumes, choreography, acting, the locations depicted, and singing are described in detail. In addition to this, a number of important issues, presented as ‘digressions’ from these descriptions, are highlighted. In Act 1, ‘post-blackface’ is presented as a concept that relates to the progressive reconstruction of social relations in South Africa. Stylistic influences are suggested to be symbolic of Mandela as the ‘elder statesman’ and the ‘prosecuted outsider’. In Act 2, jazz is referred to as a symbol of exile and as a space for an emerging, politicized African urbanism. Historical correctness in the depiction of previously- oppressed persons and cultures are related to the use of existing music in this act. In Act 3, more ‘conventional’ operatic devices portray the prosecution and imprisonment of the Rivonia trialists. The separation of men and women takes on musical significance as women become a tool for strength and endurance for the prisoners. In this act, Mandela is first seen as vulnerable, and later as a token of hope. In Act 1, masculinities that come to light include ‘militarism’, the display of which is reflected in the music through the instrumentation. The influence of the Thembu regent on Mandela’s masculine development is presented as being significant, as well as seminal in shaping Mandela’s gender performance amongst Thembu people. The self- assertion of Mandela’s masculinity comes to light in a number of ways, including his participation in activities that served to strengthen male camaraderie. In Act 2, leadership v qualities Mandela acquired are displayed through dance and music. The idea of ‘smart- cool/bravado’ is linked to womanizing and gender-division as a display of masculinity. In Act 3, militarism, rather than being a symbol of power (like before), is connected to loneliness, weariness, helplessness and endurance; this is especially evident in the military-like routine the prisoners were subjected to, as displayed in this act. In conclusion, I suggest that the combination of musical platforms from which Mandela’s story was told in Mandela trilogy was necessary in sketching the almost complete picture of him we encounter in the opera. Keywords: Mandela trilogy, Nelson Mandela, masculinity, Péter Louis van Dijk, Mike Campbell, Michael Williams, contemporary South African opera, Xhosa music, South African jazz vi OPSOMMING In hierdie studie word die bemiddeling van sosio-politiese en lewenswerklikhede, en die uitvoering van Nelson Mandela se manlikhede in die opera Mandela trilogy ondersoek, asook wat dit suggereer omtrent die funksie en aard van hedendaagse opera in die huidige sosio-politiese kontekste in Suid-Afrika. Mandela trilogy is ’n drie-bedryf opera waarin gebeurlikhede wat in Nelson Mandela se lewe ontvou het voorgestel word vanaf die tyd wat hy die tradisionele inisiasieskool bygewoon het tot sy toespraak na sy vrylating in 1990. Bedrywe 1 en 3 is deur Péter Louis van Dijk gekomponeer en Bedryf 2 deur Mike Campbell, en die libretto is deur Michael Williams geskryf. Die styl van die oorspronklike musiek in Bedryf 1 is afgelei vanaf tradisionele Xhosa-liedere, maar dit sluit ook verwerkings van bestaande tradisionele Xhosa-liedere in. Die musiek in Bedryf 2 is hoofsaaklik in ’n jazzstyl, en Bedryf 3 is in ’n hedendaags-klassieke operastyl. In hierdie stiplesing word noemenswaardige tegniese aspekte van die musiek, orkestrasie, tekstuele inhoud en struktuur (libretto), verhoogontwerp, kostuums, koreografie, toneelspel, die voorgestelde plekke en sang in detail beskryf. Verder word ’n aantal belangrike kwessies beklemtoon, aangebied as ‘afwykings’ (‘digressions’) vanaf hierdie beskrywings. Met verwysing na Bedryf 1 word ‘post-blackface’ as ’n konsep wat verband hou met die progressiewe rekonstruksie van sosiale verhoudinge in Suid-Afrika aangebied. Stylinvloede word voorgehou as simbolies van Mandela as die ‘ouer staatsman’ en ‘vervolgde buitestaander’. Met verwysing na Bedryf 2 word na jazz verwys as ’n simbool van ballingskap en ’n ruimte vir ’n opkomende, verpolitiseerde Afrika- stedelingskap. ’n Verband word getrek tussen historiese korrektheid in die uitbeelding van voorheen-benadeelde persone en kulture en die gebruik van bestaande musiek in hierdie bedryf. In Bedryf 3 word meer ‘konvensionele’ operagebruike aangewend in die uitbeelding van die vervolging en gevangeneming van die Rivonia-verhoordes. Die skeiding van mans en vroue neem musikale betekenis aan soos wat vroue ’n bron van krag en uithouvermoeë vir die gevangenes word.