THE MESSENGER
or THE CHURCHES:
MAGAZINE OF SCRIPTURE EXPOSITION, AND MEDIUM OF INTERCOMMUNICATION ON ALL SOCIAL AND PRACTICAL TOPICS OF IMPORTANCE ITO THE BROTHERHOOD.
WITH THE
CONGREGATIONAL INTELLIGENCE OF THE YEAR 1866.
VOL. II.
New Series,
EDINBURGH: PRINTED BY A. & W. R. WILSON, 56 HIGH STREET.
MDCCCUtVl.
Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ CONTENTS.
PAGE. The Condemned Hierarchy ((e , 1 Messiah’s Mercy to the Poor 8 The Little Horn: The Antichrist ' . 11,26 Miracles . . . 57 Duration 67 Satan 88 The Ten Kings and the One King 135 The Man of Sin 166, 180 Spiritualising ..... 17 An English Reply to the Rochester Epistle 20 The Gospel Preached to Jew and Gentile . 22 Jesus Christ and Him Crucified . 33, 71 Friendly Greetings across the Sea 37 What is Literalism . 40 Translations of the Seventy Weeks or Heptades Prophecy 46 A Word of Criticism . 47 The Inquirer . . . . • • 447,7, OU,80, 144 The Importance of the Historical Books of the Old Testament in relation to Prophecyr 49 53 The Unwritten Rubric . • • • ' The Gospel of the Kingdom of. God . . . . 55, 77 . 57, 87 The Proximity of the Kingdom . • . • • 61 Letter from Birmingham . 65 Calvary and Zion . . 73, 82 . The Witch of Endor...... 76 Persistance of Old Bible Names . 79 The Power of God in His Word . 81 Let Brotherly Love Continue Is the Proximity of the Kingdom, the “ Gospel ” preached by Jesus . 92 " 93 Sacred Criticism . . • • ' 97 The Lord’s Prophecy . 99 The Personality of Satan . • ■ • 104 What is the True Age of the World • . 107 Familiar Spirits . . • • * Ill Mello . . . 113 The Annual Meeting, 1866 • • 129 Wherewithal shall we be Clothed . • • ’. . 131 Shahvooag; the Hebrew word translated “ Week ” in Dan. ix. ■ 132 Jesus Washing the Disciples’ Feet 142 The Working Man . • . 145 Remarks on the Genuineness of Revelation xx. 5..
Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ CONTENTS.
page- The Doctrine of Life ’ 147 Reconnoitring an Eneniy’s Fortress 148 The Inspiration of the Scriptures .... 152 Spirits of Antichrist .... 153, 177 That Blessed Hope . . • • 157 A Church’s Testimony to the Word of the Truth of the Gospel ■ 161 Things most surely Believed .... 172 Intelligence— Aberdeen ..... 143 Barrow in Furness .... 31, 95 Birmingham ..... 188 Brooklyn, U.S. . . . 95 Buchan . ... • • • 128 Crossgates ..... 47, 63, 79 Dundee . . 95,187 Edinburgh .....47, 63, 79, 95. 174,188 Glasgow ..... 80,95,112,143 Halifax, N.S...... 95, 160 Huddersfield . ■ . 128, 159 Innerleithen . ... 15 Jarrow-on-Tyne ...... 48 Kirkcaldy . . 48 Lanarkshire ..... 176, 188 Liverpool ..... 95 Mumbles ..... 15,31, 48, 64,174 Newcastle on-Tyne .... 176 Nottingham . 160 Sheffield ...... 143 Swansea . 31 Tranent ..... 64 Turriff . . . . . 16, 32, 64, 96 United States ..... Hi Hymn for the .Evening ...... 31 A Proverb ...... 53 AU is Vanity ..... 62 The Holy Land ..... 141 Invocatory Hymn . . 159 All things for Good, 187
Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES.
>
" I SPEAK AS TO WISE MEN, JUDGE YE WHAT I SAY.”
No. 1. January 1, 1866. New Series. Vol. II.
THE CONDEMNED HIERARCHY. Elucidation Class Notes on Luke xvi. enlarged.
This chapter (verses 19-31), is to them in parables, and without a the grand resort of all persons who parable spake he not to the people,” attempt a defence of the unscriptural Matt. xiii. 34. idea of the immortality of the soul. The other reasoners, whilst having Our object then must be to see what truth in admitting its parabolic is the true teaching of this portion of structure, are quite as wide of the Scripture, and thus obtain the best word by deducing an untrue and answer to the suppositious meaning unintended lesson from the parable fastened upon it. —i.e., the existence of a separate We have however to meet two soul. To such we would commend classes of reasoners: those who affirm, Dr Trench’s remarks, who writing of and those who deny, its parobolic these fictitious narratives lays down structure. this law thereupon: “ They may not The latter is the more illogical, rely be made first sources of doctrine. ing almost solely upon the absence When a doctrine is settled by plain of the preface of comparison “the texts, they may illustrate it. But kingdom is like to.” This is but a controversialists, to sustain some feeble reason, because seeing that it weak position, often forget this rule; is not the kingdom which is in con and looking round for arguments, sideration it is unnecessary. But it :invent for themselves supports in is alleged that the words “ there 1these. ” Till the believers in the was,” stamp it as a fact, or real iimmortality of separate souls have history. This7” ' cannot ‘be granted, found the plain texts they must not - for the same mode of expression' use the parable. And knowing that occurs in ver. 1, in chaps, xv. 11, such plain texts cannot be found we xiv. 16, all of which are accepted as may proceed to investigate the na parables. Then, the style of the ture and teaching of this supposed words is evidently parabolic, and case, upon its own merits. especially the appended moral.- But— Before doing so we must, however, the evangelist’s words settle the ques take note of the direct scripture tion : “ All these things spake Jesus testimony, which utterly negativing
Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 2 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. January 1,1806. the popular ideas of the nature of whilst the subject is in “the cold man and his state in death, leave no damp grave.” foothold for the ordinary understand If, then, the uniform teaching of ing of this parable. We shall do scripture is against the popular ideas, this from the parable as a basis. we may be sure this parable will . 1. It is said that the subjects, not prove them. And so, having both the poor and the rich man died. demonstrated the negative, we may Now death is to cease to exist (Gen. proceed to consider the affirmative iii. 19, vi. 17, vii. 21-23; ~Ecc. iii. teaching: of the fiction. 19, 20). Life and its antithesis The first inquiry should be,— death are spoken of in terms the Whose is the parable? Scholars very opposite of immortal soulism have' doubted our Lord’s authorship, (Job xiv. 12, viii. 9, x. 19, 20, xiii. and; indeed not without reason, see 28, iv. 19, vii. 6; 1 Pet. i. 24). ing it is not at all of his character With life perish its results ; e.q., ac istic utterances. M‘Culloch says,— tion, thought, speech, &c., so that of “ Neither is it directly said that our them it is said,—“ they know not Saviour did use the parable, but it is anything, ... their love, their hatred, abruptly introduced. I am unable their envy, is now perished,” Ecc. ix. to learn whether a similar parable 4-6. “ His breath goeth forth, he has been recognised in the rabbinical returnethIcillLUClll toIV hisA11O earth&O/L Vll ;, in that very writings, but the complexion .of it day his thoughts perish," Ps. cxlvi. 4. certainly accords with their mode of 2. The rich man was in hades, i.e., illustration much better than it does in the grave ; concerning which it is with that of our Saviour.” Dodd said, “ there is no work, nor device, ridge goes further, and affirms that nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the “ Dr Lightfoot and others have grave,” Ecc. ix. 10. “ In death is shown that the Jews in their Genera no remembrance of Thee; in the have a parable much to the same grave, who shall give Thee thanks'?” purpose.” And in Josephus we have Ps. vi. 5 ; Is. xxxviii. 18, 19. what we think ample confirmatory 3. Lazarus was in Abraham’s bo testimony. It will not be mis spent som. Now, as Abraham was dead labour to give an abstract of his and buried (Gen. xxv. 8, 10, xv, 15 ; Dissertation on Hades, both because Zeeh. i. 5; Luke xx. 37, 38), it fol it shows us the original of the pop lows, that for Lazarus to lie in his ular teaching, and because of its bosom, he must find it in the bearing on this parable. grave. “ Hades, wherein the souls of the 4. Hell, as the place of punish righteous and unrighteous are de ment, is not yet in existence. This tained, a subterraneous region, in (in the New Testament, Gehenna, perpetual darkness, a place of custody , not hades') is always represented as for. souls,___ , in which__ angelsa are guard- future. The punishment of Gehenna ians, who distribute to them tern- is everlasting destruction, 2 Thes. i. porary punishments. In this region 9 ; for there the wicked will be burnt is a lake oj unquenchable fire, where- up, consumed into smoke, Ps. xxxvii. into we suppose no one hath hitherto 20, so as to “ be no more," Ps. civ. been cast; but is prepared for a day 35 ; become ashes under the feet of afore-determined by God, when the the righteous, &c., Mai. iv. 1-3. So• unjust shall be adjudged to this that it is impossible for the parable■ everlasting punishment, while the just . to teach ordinary notions of hell-fire■ shall obtain an incorruptible and i Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ January 1,1865. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 3 never-fading kingdom. There is one sequence, as an exposition of the descent into this region, at whose original vain philosophy, out of which gate we believe there stands an arch- sprang purgatory, the wild, God angel with a host; which gate when dishonouring fancies of eternal tor those pass through who are conducted ments, shown in the writings of such by the angels, they do not go the men as Jonathan Edwards; and also same way; but the just are guided of the more modern notion of Hades, to the right-hand, to a region of light, as the ante-judgment prison (or in in which the just have dwelt since termediate state) of the naked souls. the beginning of the world ; not con To suppose that He of whom it is strained by necessity, but ever en testified, “ he taught them not as the joying the prospect of the good things scribes” and Pharisees, should en they see, and esteeming those things dorse the foolishness of their heathen beyond what wg have here; with notions, is a libel upon him who whom there is no place of toil, no “ spoke as never man spake.” burning heat, no piercing cold, nor We think there can be no doubt arejany briers there ; but the coun that it was such teachings as this tenance of the fathers and of the just, which Jesus condemned, and warned while they wait for that rest and his disciples against, Matt. xvi. 6, eternal new life in heaven which is 12. Doubtless some will object that to succeed this region,—this place as Josephus was not a Pharisee, we we call Abraham’s bosom. The un are wrong in concluding this to be an just are dragged by force to the left exposition of their ideas on the sub hand by the angels allotted for pun ject. True, Josephus was politically ishment, no longer going with good not a Pharisee; but as to doctrines, will, but as prisoners driven by he differed little. His objection to violence. Now those angels drag them was much such a difference as them into the neighbourhood of hell that betwixt Presbyterianism and itself, and they do not stand clear of Episcopalianism, or Puseyism and the hot vapour itself; but when they Popery. That they held the views have a nearer view of this spectacle, as shewn in his dissertation is, we as of a terrible and great prospect of think, amply shewn by other‘ men fire, they are struck with a fearful tions of them in his works. “ They expectation of a future judgment, believe that souls have an immortal and in effect punished thereby; and vigour in them, and that under the where they see the place of the fa earth there will be rewards or pun- thers and of the just, even Ihereby ishments, according as they have are they punished also; for a chaos lived virtuously or viciously in this deep and large is fixed between life; and the latter are to be de them, insomuch that a just man who tained in an everlasting prison, but hath compassion on them cannot be that the former shall have power to admitted, nor can one who is unjust, revive and live again; on account of if he were bold enough to attempt which doctrines, they are able greatly it, pass over it.” to persuade the body of the people,” This abstract, but more especially Antiq.Anh'n III.ttt xviii.v-tnii 3. 11 They say that the complete dissertation, presents all"n souls are incorruptible ; but that such a tissue of confusions, childish the souls of good men are only re nesses, bathos, and perverted scrip moved into other bodies,—but that ture, as to stamp it at once with the the souls of bad men are subject to impress of foolishness. And by con-1 eternal punishment,” (Wars. IL, ch. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 4' the messenger of the churches. January 1,1st a.' viii. 14.) Such remarks as these tional works, and as such are con evidently are of the nature of a demned by Jesus, Matt. xv. 3, 6, 9. Presbyterian’s upon the Calvinistic 3. That they are in direct opposi teachings of the English Prayer tion to our Lord’s own teaching con book, i.e. sympathetic. When cerning immortality. Josephus condemns the Pharisees, it But do you then deny the authen is where their political rivalry comes ticity of the parable, or that our into play, like that of the Scotch Lord used it 1, it will be asked. No, versus English established churches. far from it. But we are driven to A few quotations will show how this point, that it is a Pharisaic directly antagonistic to our Lord’s doctrine which he makes use of with own teachings these Pharisaic notions which to point his rebuke to them. were. The kingdom of heaven, a It is an acknowledged truth, that to yet future state, is the only hope he crush an opponent \^ith his own ar held out, Matt. v. 3-10, 19, 20. guments is the greatest victory. It “ Except your righteousness exceed is to slay Goliah with his own sword. that of the scribes and pharisees, you And this parable appears to be a shall in no case enter the kingdom carrying out of the invincible logic, of heaven, (Comp, with Luke xvi. “ out of thine own mouth will I con 15; Matt. vi. 33, 10, vii. 21, 22.) demn thee, thou wicked servant.” Life was also a thing to be sought Whether Jesus took some already for (not possessed, as it would be made and standard parable (as is had men immortal souls), Matt. vii. quite probable), to which he affixed 14; John iv. 14, 36, vi. 53, 57, viii. the moral of verses 30 and 31; or 51, 12. It was to be a future re constructed it upon the basis of their ward and bestowment, secured by teachings, just as we might upon the present faith and good works, Matt, popular notions of the state of the xix. 29, xxv. 46; John iii. 15, 36, dead, or as we might condemn v. 24, 39, 40, x. 10, vi. 27. It was a papist by a supposed case of only to be enjoyed through resurrec purgatory, — cannot be decided. tion, John v. 25-29, vi. 39, 40, xi. But neither way affects the value of 25, 26, xiv. 19 ; Matt. xix. 28. If its use in argument. And neither the doctrine of the immortality of commits hims to a recognition ■ • of,"or the soul be true, then the apostles sympathy with, the quoted notions. are “ found false witnesses of God,” In his mouth, and as he used it, it for they proclaimed Christ as haringo became somewhat like the voices “ brought life and incorruptibility to from the grave of Ez. xxxii. 21; Is. light through the gospelwhich xiv. 9-11; Rev. vi. 9-11. It was as could not be if it was known before fraught with a great moral and pro by philosophy (as the soul-doctrine phetic lesson as though it were of was), and especially if Jesus said the purest doctrine. Let us then nothing of the immortality of the proceed to an analysis of the parable. soul in his gospelling. Its antecedent context begins at From the preceding we conclude : verse 14 (where the - paragraph sign ; 1. That the ideas ordinarily, de 5| should stand, instead of at verse 13, ; duced from the parable, in so far as which is a pendant to the preceding they imply a future state, are Phar lesson.) isaic. “ The pharisees, who were covet- ’ 2. That similar parables are to be ous,< ridiculed him,” and so brought r_____• t______■ ______i j.___ I found in JewishChurch ofrabbinical God General tradi- Conference: down.. u McDonough,on themselves GA; his rebuke. Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ January 1, 1868. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 5 “Ye are they who justify yourselves direction,” (Antiq. Book III, chap, before men ; but God knoweth your I xviii. 3). “Alexandra . . . put all hearts; for that which is highly things into their power.>wer.” “Hyrcan- esteemed among men is abomination us,r” the highK:~1" priest,— permitted the in the sight of God.” It is this Pharisees to do everything; to whom truth which the parable illustrates. Alexandra ordered the multitude to , They are shown from their own be obedient. . , She had indeed the teachings how valueless their osten name of regent, but the Pharisees tatious piety (Matt. vi. 1-7; Luke had the authority; for it was they xviii. 9-14, &c.) was in the eye of who restored such as had been ban God. The fiction used also shewed ished, and set at liberty such as were a future retribution, when the dis prisoners, and, to say all at once, turbed balance of equity would be they differed in nothing from lords," righted, and those who had enjoyed (Antiq.'f " XIII., xvi.’ ',1, '2; ; see also God’s good gifts (ver. 25) without Wars I.,F v. 2).“ TK“ Thereava w , was a cer making a right use of them would tain sect of men who were Jews, not inhabit everlasting mansions, who valued themselves highly upon (ver. 9-12, 21. They were relying the exact skill they had in the law upon the fact of their fleshly sonship of their fathers, and made men be to Abraham: the parable shews lieve they were highly favoured of them what John had before de God, by whom this set of women nounced to them (Matt. iii. 9,) that were inveigled . . . These are those inheritance of the promises made to who are called the sect of the Phari Abraham involved the manifestation sees, who were in a capacity of great of a character like Abraham’s ; and ly opposing kings. A cunning sect that wanting this, Abraham would they were, and soon elevated to a reject them as reprobates (ver. 25.) pitch of open fighting and mischief,” “ The law and the prophets (weres (XVII., ii. 4). yours) till John, since that time, thei If we substitute for “ Phari kingdom of God is preached, and sees,” the words “papal priests,” every man presseth into it.” This “ ecclesiastics,” or “ monks,” we get is the historic fact, the bearing of' a picture of a more modern phase of wliich upon the parable viewed pro- the) same ecclesiastical usurpation. phetically, is important. They had And this will help us better to un the ecclesiastical, and much of the derstand the eo-temporary politics of civil power in their own hands. We our Lord’s time. If for “John the need only refer to such mentions of immerser,” we substitute “ Luther," them as iu John xi. 46, 47, 57, for then we have an almost perfect par- proof of this. Our Lord’s affirma rallel afforded us, and are enabled to tion, Matt, xxiii. 2, 3, “ The scribes read the two reformations in mutual_ and Pharisees sit in Moses’ seat ” light. For what the Romish priest speaks the same thing. Josephus hood was in Luther’s time, the sect here again affords us valuable corro of the Pharisees was in John’s days. borative testimony. But a change took place : not in “ The Pharisees, on account of the characters of either, but in their their doctrines are able greatly to political status. By the reformers’ persuade the__ body__ j of__ the___ ±people, ±-> preaching, a great unshackling of and whatsoever they do about divine the popular mind was effected. By worship, prayers, and sacrifices, they John’s and Jesus’ gospelling, “every perform them according toj-- their man pressed into the kingdom,” no
Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 6 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. January 1, longer blindly and ignorantly doing also the terms in which they speak the behest of the Pharisees. That of themselves (Matt. xix. 27, 29), this grand popular movement (Luke and are addressed by their master i. 76-79; Mark i. 5), gave rise to (Matt. x. 9, 10, 38). Mary’s pro strife (Matt. xi. 12), that it was phecy (Luke i. 51-53), and Hannah’s transient, no more affects the fact or (1 Sam. ii. 7, 8), still further con the testimony of its being a reforma tribute to identify the subjects. tion, than did the restoration of the Jesus and his followers may then papal religion in Saxony, the reality aptly be understood as corresponding of Lutherl_.l______’s efforts. to the beggar, whose sores were We have quoted and argued thus licked by the dogs. The whole class lengthily as a necessary premise to of which they were representatives, identifying the subjects of the par were full of the sores of civil griev able, which we purpose to view in ances, sores irritated by the licking its prophetic aspect. For that it of Gentile dogs, such as Herod, was a prophecy we think there is no Pilate, &c.* But Jesus and his doubt: and that our Lord, out of disciples were pre-eminently thus such unpromising materials as Phari- conditioned, being subjects of the saic notions, should construct a Gentile persecutions instigated by moral and prophetic parable, stamps the Pharisee class. him as one of the most notable dis It is noticeable that the death of putants the world has ever seen. both is well nigh coetaneous. But Micaiah’s prophecy, 1 Kings xxii., their fate is different. To see the is perhaps one of the nearest exam point of this we must remember the ples, but infinitely far beneath our circumstances attending the political Lord’s. death of the Jewish nation. The We have thus far identified the believers were almost exempt from rich man, “ clothed in purple and the sufferings at the captivity of fine linen, and faring sumptuously Jerusalem, they having had warning every day,” as the ecclesiatico—civil and fled from the city in time. Pharisees, they being the sacerdotal Though they politically died, in lords. Who then was Lazarus 1 ceasing to be connected with a body Obviously, that party in direct op politic, yet their dispersion was com position and circumstances; those of paratively a comforting, for their the contextual all men, who having hunger, thirst, and sickness, were in pressed into (or towards) the king Jewry. Out in the world among dom persevered still in their reforma their fellow believers of the Gentiles, tory course. This party would be they would as it were be reclining found in Jesus and his disciples, most of whom were of the crowd, * It is sufficient to quote Matt. xv. 26,27, in sup port of tho well known estimation in which the the common sort (Mark xii. 37). Jews held the Gentiles, and to identify the ohss These the Pharisees, from their pin named “ the dogs.” Bnt it will be objected that there is an error in accounting the licking as irrita nacle of gnosis or exact knowledge, tion, it being usually accounted as pity. We be. utterly despised, and accounted as lieve that it is true that the licking of a sore by a house dog will benefit the wound. But it is very worthless scum (John vii. 45-49), doubtfill if such would be the case with the prowl ing scavenging dogs of tho East, whose saliva but it was out of their midst that would be more likely to poison the wound as a Jesus choose his consorts. The fact swine’s would. Yet even supposing this incorrect, it does not alter the chief fact that the dogs were that he and his companions practi Gentiles, for Pilate, who crucified Chiist, had more cally subsisted on alms, identifies pity than the Pharisees, and woludhavelethimgo. (Matt, xxvii, 19,20,24; Luke xxiii, 4,14 23. See them with Churchthe Lazarus of God Generalclass, as Conference: do also Acts McDonough,xvill. 12-17, &c.) GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ January 1,1868. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. in the bosom of Abraham. For the All these,* more or less, sprung up gladness of the gospel, the hope of like the Pharisees out of the seed of life,r, was that1 the blessing\ /of A” braham ’ Babylonian- ’ ’ • false notions and prac- should come on the Gentiles through tices. With these they defiled their faith; that the Gentiles should be father Abraham’s house. fellow-heirs, and of the household of Abraham acknowledges the son- faith. ship whilst casting him off. This The Pharisees died and were and his second answer still more buried, ceasing, like the others, proves that the application must be their living relationship to the found in, and confined to Jewry, nation. Their sacerdotalism, vir- because “ they have Moses and the tually, if not really, ceased before prophets.” This' was not true of the captivity—the ecclesiastical body the' Gentiles,~ nor yet of the common being in a state of decomposition people of the Jews, who could no during the internecine feuds which more be said to have had those writ raged. So that there was a truth ings than the laity could be said to and reality in the metaphor of their have had the Bible during Papal buried body suffering the fiery tor domination. tures of the siege. At this time The untruth of the notion, that there could be no communications “ if one went from the dead they betwixt the two classes. The poor would reform,” was shown by their in faith were then afar off; and even unbelief of the writings. If the if their pity had moved them to lessons of Abraham’s life, if such help, they could not have passed to laws as were given with all the ac the sufferers in their hades of Jeru companiments of the divine presence, salem. The Roman armies inter proclaiming “thou shalt love the posed, an impassable barrier, to com Lord with all thy heart, and thy plement the yawning, unbridgeable neighbour as thyself”—if the con gulf of the unpardonable sin those tinual warnings of the prophets did had committed in murdering the not artmse them to their duty, vain Prince of life, and not repenting. would be the voice of one sent to The answer put into the mouth of them from the dead. Even when the Abraham v equivalent to Paul’s Lord spoke, there had been a proof statement when speaking of much of this. He had raised a Lazarus the same class, 2 Th. i. 5-10. from the dead, and by this act sup- The request for Lazarus to be pHedr______theo greatest______r plea___ for refonna- sent to this rich man’s house still I tion and1 faith” in him.. What re further identifies the sacerdotal hier- sponse did they give 1 They sought archy of which we have spoken. to kill both him and Lazarus. And He had five brethren. Now there when they had murdered the heir, were just five sects or classes who and he had risen from the dead, they shared with the Pharisees in the tried to enact a He, by suborning the ecclesiastical and magisterial honour’s watch to say, “ His disciples came and emoluments. These were— and stole him away while we slept.” And when he sent his messengers 1. Scribes. with the voice of the risen Saviour, 2. Lawyers or elders. “ they would not be persuaded.” 3. Herodians. ■ Corresponding to the Papal sects or orders of 4. Sadducees. Jesuits, B-. nedictines, Franciscans, Dominicans, 5. Essenes. &c., &c. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ » THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. January 1,188J, Hence they were left to suffer tor- their brother sacerdotals in general), ment in the flame of “ the siege and foundedJ-J uponXT their;' ’ teachings.~ J But straitness: ” a torment which their whilst it is a prophecy, it is also a dupes and allies may be said to moral rebuke and condemnation, suffer in measure even yet, (Matt. being in this respect made like to xxvii. 25.) our Lord’s own illustrative cases. We learn then that this parable For most of his parables have a is a prophecy of the fate of the doctrinal lesson conveyed through a pharisaic sect in particular (and of prophetic medium.. J. W.
MESSIAH’S MERCY TO THE POOR. “ And the poor have the gospel preached unto them,’’ Matth. xi. 2-6
Jesus is that Christ the Son of the broken-hearted. And so Jesus God who should come into the did preach the gospel to the poor world. In vain do the Jews look meek ones of the earth, and so proved for another. And their doing so that he was Messiah. The common is worse than vain. It prepares people heard him gladly. The poor them for receiving the wrong man, among men rejoiced in the Holy One this rejection of the right one. I of Israel. They found his words to am come unto you in my Father’s be words of life most admirably name and you receive me not; when adapted to their case; and so be another cometh unto you in his own lieved on him. As, for instance, the name him you will receive. In our poor fishermen of Galilee. And common version it is, “ if another,” Jesus said to the twelve, Will ye &c. But the same Greek word is also go away 1 And Peter said, translated in 1 John iii. 3, “ When Lord to whom can we go? Thou he shall appear,” &c. hast the words of eternal life. And It was written in the ancient pro we believe, and are sure, that thou phets that Christ when he came art that Christ, the Son of God. should heal the bodily maladies of In the ancient writings it is also men. In his days the lame man testified that the Messiah should be was to leap as an hart, and the to many a stone of stumbling, and tongue of the dumb to sing. Well, rock of offence. And so many were Jesus healed all their diseases, thus offended in Jesus. But blessed is showing he was the Messiah, “Sure every one who trusteth in him, as ly he hath carried our griefs, and anointed and born of God, to be his borne our sorrows,” as saith Esaias king on his holy hill of Zion. the prophet. Many of the Jews were offended Also, according to the ancient in him, because he did not at that scriptures, M essiah was to preach time fulfil all that is written of the the gospel to the poor, or meek, who Messiah. Some might say, surely are generally the poor. Thus, Is. this Jesus is the Christ. When the Ixi. 1, says, The Spirit of the Lord Christ cometh shall he do more is upon me, because he bath anointed works (greater or better), than this me to preach glad tidings to the man doeth ? But others might say meek; he hath sent me to bind up (for they had great reasonings among Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ January 1,1869. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 9 themselves), “ Yes, the Messiah will look for at the hands of the Messiah. do more works than this man doeth. But the end is not yet. It will come The Messiah is the Son of man who however. Though it tarry, wait for will come in the clouds of heaven, it. And then you will see this Son and save Israel out of all the lands of God- completely, and forever de and hands of our enemies ; he will stroy all the works of the devil. plant us in the land that God gave Then there will be a world without to our fathers to dwell in; he will sin, and without disease, and with make us the head of the heathen; out poverty, and without ignorance, and he will reign over us on Mount and without a grave. But, in the Zion, from thenceforth even forever. meantime, we, you his forerunner, Let this Jesus of Nazareth show us the the Messiah himself, and all we his sign from heaven, and we will believe disciples must enter into that glori on him. Remember that the false ous state of things through much Messiah comes before the true one. tribulation. That the coming of the false one is Blind, lame, leprous, deaf, dead, with all power and signs, and lying poor, ignorant, doubting, damned. wonders, and with all deceivableness 0, what a sad, sad, catalogue of of unrighteousness. Does not this human woes. Sair, alas ! and sad, Jesus cast out devils by Beelzebub and many are the ills poor mortals the prince of.. the ______devils ?” So~ might‘ share. But, blessed be God, our they reason among themselves. Saviour is more than equal to our And so might John reason in him sorrows. Our help is laid upon one self, “ I hear that Jesus whom I who is mighty. He will save us, baptized, does many miracles such save us from all our sins, and from as the Messiah should do. I hear all our sorrows. He is infinitely he preaches the gospel to the poor, able, and infinitely willing. Come healing the broken hearted. But unto me, all ye who labour, and are this is not all that the Messiah should heavy laden, and I will give you do. He should open the prison doors rest. • No matter what your burden to them that are bound. In the very is. Come to me, and I will give same scripture, where it is written you rest. Him that cometh unto that he should preach the gospel to me I will in no wise cast out. Other the poor, it is written he should set physicians may refuse cases for want free the prisoners Why does Jesus of fees, oi’ because beyond their skill ; not set me free if he be the Christ. but I refuse no case on any ground. If thou be the Christ save thyself Come to me. I will heal you. and us.” Sight was Messiah’s mercy to the Ah ! John, patience, patience. blind, strength to the lame, cleans Jerusalem is not all saved in one ing to the leper, hearing to the deaf, day. How poor is he who has not life to the dead, and what to the patience. Let patience have its per poor? Wealth? No. Riches are fect work, that you may be perfect not always a blessing ; they are more and entire, wanting nothing. The frequently a curse. Riches harden time is coming when Jesus will ful the heart, blind the mind, and drown fil all that is written of the Messiah. men’s souls in perdition. They are The day is at hand when he will strong to do this through the weak- come in1— the__ — clouds~___ — of - heaven with ness of the fiesh. So that it is easier power__ and j greate__ _ glory.o’ . Then he for a camel to pass through the eye will do all that yen and the Jews of a needle than for a rich man to
Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 10 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. January 1>uw enter into the kingdom of God. How the more you see how rich it is as hardly shall they that have riches be Jmercy 7 toi the poor. How well cal saved 1 For— culated its precious promises are to Alas ! how oft in haughty mood enable them to bear up under tie God’s creatures they express ; ills of this world to which they are Or else, neglecting a’ that’s gude, exposed, as poor men in hopes of They riot in excess ; Baith careless and fearless the world to come. 0, what a sad O’ either heaven or hell, fate would be that of the poor, if Esteeming and deeming they had not the hope of a better It a’ an idle tale. world. And so wealth was not Messiah’s The poor afflicted, honest man mercy to the poor. He knew well Had never sure been bora that, in the most of cases, the cure Had there not been some recompense would be worse than the disease, To comfort those that mourn, Jesus was more inclined to make in another state and world to come. rich men poor, than poor men rich That there is such a recompense is in this world. made certain in the gospel, as He preached the gospel to them. preached by Jesus Christ. That was Messiah’s mercy to the Sometimes the poor are afflicted poor. The poor need mercy. Poverty with hunger and nakedness. They is a real evil. As much so is blind have no bread to eat, and then- ness. Yes, extreme poverty often looped and windowed raggedness quenches the fear of death. The exposes them to the cold blasts of poor man was therefore led to look wrinter, and the scorching summer for mercy from the Messiah, as well suns. With what joy may these as the blind. And this is the mercy read what is written. They shall he gives them, the hopes and com hunger no more, neither thirst any forts of the gospel. more—neither shall the sun light on In the synagogue of Nazareth, them, nor any heat. Foi’ the Lamb Jesus read, The Spirit of the Lord is who is in the midst of the throne upon me, for he hath anointed me shall feed them, and shall lead them to preach the gospel to the poor. unto living fountains of waters, and He refers to what was written of God shall wipe away all tears from him in Isa. Ixi. 1. But in Isaiah their eyes. it is not poor but meek. However, The rich have many friends, but it comes, generally speaking, to the the poor are despised by their neigh same thing. In general, the poor bours. The poor are often galled are the meek. Now then this is by the contempt of both rich and how Messiah preached the gospel to poor. the poor. “ Blessed are the meek, I want less, I tent less, for they shall inherit the earth.” Their roomy fire-side, The rich and the proud have it now. But hanker, and canker. The poor meek ones shall have it To see their scornfu’ pride. hereafter. The rich have it, but for But here again the gospel comes a time, for a time how short. The in with its glorious consolations to meek shall have it forever. Is not the poor. Thou hast made us unto that consolation for the poor ? Is it our God kings and priests, and we not mercy to make known this to shall reign on the earth. Or, as them 1 Greek scholars read it, over the The more you look into the gospel, earth. Yes, wait a little. The rich Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ r
January 1. IMS. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 11 shall be poor, and the poor rich that now is. Seek ye first the king- 1 TTTWait ‘J. on J.1.^the TLord, and keep his ' rlrxw-idom zx-Pof God nand vx rl !■»■»£»his ■»*»righteousness,on aoo wa;,•ay, and he shall exalt thee to in-1 and all these things shall be added herit■ - the earth,•...... when the wicked’ ' • to you. ""What ■ mercy■ to the poort ! are cut off, thou shalt see it. “ And He that trusteth in the Lord shall the daughter of Tyre shall be there not want any good. with a gift. Yes, the rich among Let the poor then embrace their the people (of Israel ?) shall entreat mercy. Let us not sin against our thy favour,” to speak for them to mercy. Let us believe and obey, the Great King, thy husband. What and so enjoy the rich mercy of the a change. God doeth great things gospel. truly, And will soon, do them The gospel is preached to the rich too. as well as to the poor. Yes, and ' And that is another gospel, con the rich have as jnuch need of it as solation to the poor, as the gospel the poor. If the poor need it to was preached by Jesus and his save them under the ills of poverty, apostles. The kingdom of God is the rich need it to save them from at hand. He that turneth the world the great evils of riches. And the upside down, and maketh all things gospel is free to all alike, whether new, is at hand. Yet a little while, rich or poor. Let the rich in wealth and he who shall come will come, of gold and silver only be poor in and will not tarry. Bear up awhile, spirit, and their’s is the kingdom of ye virtuous and believing poor. heaven also. It is a great mercy to the poor Is the gospel Messiah’s mercy to that the salvation of the gospel is the poor ? Then let no one despise free, gratis. He was a poor man, or oppress them. Their Redeemer is indeed, who had not a turtle-dove or mighty. Hearken, my beloved two young pigeons; but under the brethren, hath not God chosen the gospel, remission of sins and eternal poor of this world, rich in faith, and life do not cost one sparrow. Of heirs of the kingdom, which he hath course, I speak of the gospel as promised to them that love him. preached by the Lord and his apostles How can you visit and associate and John. Ho, every one that with such a poor woman? said a thirsteth, THE LITTLE HORN. THE ANTICHRIST. In one of the discourses delivered i tion spoken of by Daniel Direction by the Lord to his disciples on the [ being given to the disciples in Judea Mount of Olives, to be found in the to flee to the mountains, when they twenty-fourth and twenty-fifth chap- see the abomination standing in the ters of Matthew, reference is made, holy place. This is a conclusive by him to the abomination of desola- proof that the prophecy, to which Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 12 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. January 1,18M. reference is made, was not fulfilled none could be placed in it. Neither previous to our Lord’s first coming. was it possible for any of the disciples In the making of this reference, the to have seen any abomination under reader is specially directed to under these circumstances. Prior to the stand, or to think, concerning this final investment of Jerusalem by statement. It is therefore to the Titus, they had fled to Pella, a city passage in Daniel, with its context, beyond the Jordan, and not to the that we must turn our attention. mountains. This Pella was one oi ,It may be observed that this the ten cities of Decapolis. Euse- allusion is made by the Lord to bins and Epiphanius both state that Jewish disciples, in answer to several the disciples were warned beforehand questions which they had propounded[ of' God~ to depart from the doomed to him. mlThe passage. in' T'Daniel ■ ’ also’ city, and go to Pella, which warning was written for Jews, concerning was obeyed. Jews, and the prophecy it contains, Without entering further into a delivered to a Jew. Consequently consideration of the items of the it is in the light of Jewish history context in Matthew, let us notice in that we have to ask : Has it been whose 'time,L‘ it_'x is’ said by Daniel, X1the fulfilled since the delivery of this abomination that maketh desolate is discourse of the Lord ? If so, when ? to be placed. The further considera If not, what are the statements of tion as to what constitutes the abom Daniel which demand our considera ination, &c., is reserved for a future tion 1 article. It is in “ the latter days that the The passage in Daniel has refer prophecy is to be fulfilled,” for (Dan. ence to the doings of a king, termed x. 14) it says, “ I am come to make “ a vile person,” (Dan. xi. 21), and thee know what shall befall thy also “ the king,” who “ shall do people in the latter days.” It may be according to his will ” (v. 36.) It gathered from other parts of scrip is to the features characteristic of ture that the phrase, the latter days, this king that we desire to direct has always reference to the period the attention of the scripture reader elapsing between the first and second and searcher. Many expositors of coming of Christ. It is therefore in scripture teach that the abomination this period the prophecy will be ful was set up by a vile person before filled. the coming of Christ. But it is to The abomination of the desolation be noticed in such expositions that is to stand in the holy place, and the portion of the prophecy contained when seen there, they who are in in the twenty-first verse is applied Judea are to flee to the mountains. to two kings, whereas it is clear There can be no two opinions as to that “ the vile person. to whom they where the holy place was situated— shall not give the honour of the in the temple itself. The Septua- kingdom,” is also the same of whom gint reads, “ In the temple shall be it is said, “ but he shall come in the abomination of desolation.” Has peaceably , and obtain the kingdom any abomination of desolation stood byEw flatteries.”” qStill+;ii more unanswer in the holy place since the ascension able is the ______statement of__ ....the ...... Lord of the Lord! No, for no abomina- himself that “ when ye” (the dis- tion was placed in the temple prior ciples) “ shall see the abomination to its destruction by1 „ the’ ”Romans, of desolation,” they are to flee to the The temple was burnt down,J------so that I mountains.This, too, being said Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ January 1,18S8. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 13 I some two hundred years after the Hebrewscholars translateit “seventy I time when these expositors say it heptades.” The context shews the was fulfilled. ’ sense in -which the phrase is to be May be it will be as well to notice understood. Daniel had just seen in .proceeding the intimate relation that seventy years of desolation, as which the visions and prophecies of testified by Jeremiah, were fulfilled Daniel have to each other. The on Jerusalem; and has given, after vision of the image (ch. ii.) gives his prayer, a prophecy relating to as a conclusion the setting up of a seventy heptades of years',' upon kingdom by the God of heaven “ in thy people, and upon thy holy the days of these kings.” The vision city. of the four beasts (ch. vii.) concludes These seventy heptades are divided with the uprising of ten kings, three into three parts, seven, sixty-two, of whom are afterwards uprooted by and one. The conclusion of the one king, but all meeting with de seventy heptades is to be remarkable struction, by means of a kingdom for the events then to transpire. set up in their days, by one like the To finish the transgression—to make Son of man, and the people of the an end of sins—to make reconcilia saints of the Most High. The vision tion: for iniquity—to bring in ever of the ram and he-goat (ch. viii.) lasting righteousness—to seal up the concludes with the uprising of a vision and the prophecy—and to king, who is destroyed by the Prince anoint the most holy. of princes. In the prophecy of thei • We now ask, at what period does seveimty heptades (ch. ix.) that deter- the history of the Jews testify that mined is to be poured upon the de- these prophetical statements were solator. In the prophecy concerning fulfilled? Has their transgression the king, “ who shall clo according ceased? Are their sins ended? to his will ” (ch. xi.) “ he shall When were they reconciled to God ? come to his end, and none shall When vros, everlasting righteousness help him.” The coincidences are brought into existence in connection not only remarkable, but, as we with them ? Has all prophecy been believe, intentional, in these vari fulfilled ? or sealed up ? When was ous passages, as we may hereafter the Most Holy acknowledged by the see. Jews as their anointed? History In the ninth chapter of Daniel, does not answer any of these ques after the prayer of Daniel for Israel tions. The present dispersion and and Jerusalem, it says (21st ver.) antagonistic position of the Jews is “while I was speaking in prayer, proof beyond dispute, that this por even the man Gabriel, whom I had tion of the prophecy has not yet been seen in the vision at the beginning " fulfilled. , informed me, and (23d ver.) said, It is generally admitted that the “ I am to shew thee, for thou art first seven heptades were literally greatly beloved, therefore under fulfilled ■ and that the Messiah, the stand the matter, and consider the prince, did not appear till after the vision.” expiration of the sixty-nine heptades. Then follows the prophecy known But, strange to say, the remaining as .the prophecy of “ the seventy heptade is said to have been weeks.” The Septuagint translates fulfilled during the life of the Mes the Hebrew of this phrase, as siah at his first coming. The scrip “ seventy weeks of years.” Other ture statement is, that after the Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 14 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. January 1, IMj. sixty-nine heptades, Messiah would the sanctuary. If the Messiah is be cut off, but not for himself. This the prince, or the he spoken of, then all admit to have been fulfilled. But he should have been cut off after the between the cutting off and the se destruction of the city and sanctuary. ventieth heptade, several things are If the Messiah was the confirmer of to occur,—“ the people of the prince,” the covenant, how could he confirm or, as others translate it, “ the mili it with “ thy people ” after this tary commander,” “ that shall come, destruction ? It will be apparent shall destroy the city and the sanc that if we are to accept the state tuary.” This was fulfilled in the ment of scripture, then the prevalent destroying of the temple and Jeru expositions of it are unsound, dis salem by the Romans under Titus, crepant, and opposed to the scrip and the after desolation of the Jews. ture. Here, however, as in the vision Dan The King of Daniel vii. and viii. iel saw at the beginning, a wide in is to spring out of the ancient Roman terval is made between this portion ~Empire, which,' as before stated, of the prophecy and the last heptade. covered the greater portion of the His end, that is the end of the prince Greek Empire. The prince who of the Romans, will be “ with a destroyed the city and sanctuary, flood.” “ And he will confirm the was a Roman one (Titus, after covenant with many for one heptade, wards emperor). Is it not ap &c. ” This he, being a Roman prince, parent, that he who will confirm and not the Messiah. Z/the Messiah the covenant for the one heptade, was the he here spoken of, then the will also be of Roman power and passage, as generally expounded, authority. contradicts its (said to be) fulfilment. This prophecy has relation to the For instance, if the Messiah was the vision previously seen by Daniel confirmer of the covenant for this It is by comparing these, that we heptade, then in the midst of the get a clearer insight into the mean week, or, as others translate it, “ in ing of this prophecy. In the tenth one-half of the week,” “ the sacrifice chapter of Daniel, we meet with a and the oblation ” ceased. But they statement, that Daniel considered did not. For it was five heptades the thing and comprehended the after the cutting off of the Messiah vision before him. After fasting for before they ceased. It is testified twenty-one days, another prophecy (Acts xxi.) that the apostle Paul is given to him, concerning what had to shew that he walked orderly, shall happen to “ thy people in the as a Jew, and kept the law—that latter days, for yet the vision is for he had to purify himself—until an days.”“ Then, in the eleventh chap- offering should have been made for ter, we have particulars given. Two himself, and those accompanying visions had been previously seen by him. These offerings included Daniel, and now, he has a second sacrifices in the temple, so that, prophetical statement, in further from the testimony of scripture, it is elucidation. We cannot go into all evident that the sacrifice and obla the points of gradual increase; so tion had not ceased after the death we will proceed at once, to compare and ascension of the Messiah. Again, the particulars given, concerning the confirmation of the covenant is the one king, or a king, or a little after the destruction of the city and horn. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ January 1,188^. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 15 THE VISION. THE VISION. THE PROPHECY, THE PROPHECY. Dan. vil. Dan viii. Dan. ix. Dan. xi. 1 After the ten kings A king of fierce coun- The king will do ac shall arise another. tenance cording to his will. 2. He will subdue three His power will be He will exalt himself. kings. mighty. 3. He will speak words He shall magnify in his Shall speak marvellous even against the Most heart. against the God of gods. High. They that understand 4. He will tax the saints He will destroy the shall fall by the sword,ie. of the Most High. holy and mighty people Shall he corrupt by 5. Shall devour the By peace he will de flatteries. whole earth. stroy multitudes. 6. He will conclude to He will cause craft to He will confirm the Such as do wickedly changes, times, and laws, prosper. covenant with many for against the covenant, one heptade. 7. Until a time, and In the midst of the times, and dividing of week. time. 8. Destroy him to the He will stand against a'a" Till that determined He will come to his end end. The kingdom to be prince of princes, and shall be poured out upon and none shall help him. given to the people of the without hand he shall be the desolator. saints of the Most High, broken. All dominions shall serve and obey him. As stated elsewhere, this king latter part, which will be for three will spring out of that portion of the' and a half years, or a time, times, Roman Empire, originally possessed and a dividing of time, the saints by the four kingdoms, springing out will be thoroughly in his power, and of the Grecian Empire. By careful remain in that condition, until in his perusal of the scripture statements, boasting against God, he will bring it is evident, that the duration of his himself, or be brought, into collision, •power will be seven years. A covenant with a Prince of princes. The re having been confirmed by him with sult being—his destruction—the de the Jews for that time, but during livery of the saints—and, the setting the latter part of which, he will up of the kingdom. cause the sacrifice to cease, and set Christianos. up the abomination. During this (To he continued). Intelligence, Notes, &c- Inneuleithen.—The small church in tb’s quair, and his son, Mr William Inglis of place, _formerlyv______numberingo ___only rfour____ persons,F Musselburgh, and the three left the toll to- haslas now been reduced to three, in.c Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 16 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. January 1,18ft.. been baptized into the Christ. Their names the NEW TESTAMENT, according to the are,—Jane Rees. Thomas Bennet, Walter Recension of Dr J. Griusbach, with an Whiustone, and David Lewis. The Sunday Interlineary Word for Word English Trausla- evening lectures continue to be well attended, tion : a New Emphatic Version, based on the- and We hope that the ingatherings of the past Interlineary Translation, on the Renderings of year are only the first-fruits of an abundant Eminent Critics, and on the Various Readings harvest to the glory of God. We are sorry of the Vatican Manuscript; together with to add that death has entered the house of Illustrative and Explanatory Foot Notes and our brother and. sister Jones, and bereaved a Copious Selection of References; to the them of their youngest daughter, after an whole of which is added a Valuable Alpha- ■ illness of only seven days. May our Father betical Appendix. sustain them, and enable them to say with The above highly important and valuable the good man of old, “ The Lord gave and Work, which has been in course of prepara- the Lord hath taken away. Blessed be the tion for the last seven years, is now completed, name of the Lord.” containing 884 pages, 18mo, and will be sup Turriff, &c.—On the 10th December was plied at the following prices:— baptized at Cuminestown, John Taylor, shoe Plain leather binding, . 16s. maker. After a year’s investigation, he was Extra do., gilt or red edges, 18s. able to give a good confession of the faith. Coloured calf or morocco, do., 20s. On the 14th were united in marriage brother Postage, 4d All orders, accompanied with Charles Reid (Cuminestown) and sister Mar cash, and addressed to J. Wilson, 53 North garet Fraser. Brother Robertson has been gate, Halifax, will receive prompt attention. displaying Lis usual diligence in setting forth the word, having been to Insch and White THE DISCIPLES’ CHORAL SERVICE hills respectively, speaking to the people, aiid OF BIBLE THEMES, comforting the brethren; and yet he abates not in his efforts, though smarting under a A collection of Christian Songs,—the bereavement in his own family. subjects selected from the Holy Scrip tures, and set to suitable music (in both *.**- The great length v.of thevuc articles far-- notations), arranged for four voices. This nisLed].. .. in this.. number... has put. it-out. . of„ our bo“k, got up expressly for the use of the- power to insert the■ Response~ to the■ -Rochester ■ brethren in their social services, and suitable Epistle, and other papers. -Will the brethren either for the church or the fireside, is now who write be kind enough to condense and reduced in price, and may be had of G. cut down their articles as much as possible ? Dowie, 88 Nicolson Street, Edinburgh,—in We need a greater variety, and our space is a neat printed cover, price Is.; or in cloth small; besides, short papers are more gene boards, Is. 6d., post free to any part of the rally appreciated by the readers. United Kingdom. May be had of G. Dowie, The Treasurer acknowledges receipts for the Messenger from Birmingham, Devonport, The Messenger of the Churches, Glasgow, Leeds, and Newburgh. First Series, for 1861, 1862, 1863, 1864; in single volumes, sewed, Is.; or the four to gether, in cloth, lettered, 4s. 6d. The two Publicatiors. first Nos. of the vol. for 1860 are out of print, Important Work for Bible Students, but a few copies of the others are still on hand, and may be had at Id. each. Postage THE EMPHATIC DIAGLOTT in all cases extra—for single vols., 2d.; for Containing the Original Greek Text of the cloth vols., 6d. The Messenger is Registered for Transmission Abroad. Articles should be sent in by the 15th of the month, and items of intelligence not later than the 24th ; all papers, meant for insertion, or notes of intelligence, may be forwarded to George Dowie, 88 Nicolson Street; and all business communications to James Cameron, 12 Calton Hill, Edinburgh, to whom money orders should be made payable. ChurchAND of W.God R GeneralWILSON, PRINTERS,Conference: HIGH McDonough, STREET, EDINBURGH. GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ THE MESSENGER OF. THE CHURCHES. ♦ “ I SPEAK AS TO WISE MEN, JUDGE YE WHAT I SAY.” No. 2. February 1, 1866. New Series. Vol. II. SPIRITUALIZING. Language is the means by which a understand it in its literal sense, it may in person expresses what he feels, volve an absurdity, or conflict with some thing he has stated elsewhere; in such cases thinks, or purposes; and, in order we not only may, but are bound to, reject that the means may accomplish the the literal meaning, and seek for a figura end contemplated, it is indispensible tive interpretation that will remove the that there be a common understand difficulty, and render consistent all the author has said.” s ing between speaker and hearer, regarding the import of the terms It is plain that the foregoing employed. In conversation any de applies to “ the holy scriptures,” in fect in this matter can be remedied common with all other writings; yet by explanation; but written language, it is only by disregarding these rules, to convey the correct idea of the in reading the scriptures, that so writer, must be used, and under many, and so conflicting explana stood, according to certain rules, else tions have been given pf the writings uncertainty, error, and confusion are of the holy prophets and apostles. the necessary results. The three If the Bible is a revelation of the following mles, laid down by Judge will and purposes of God to man, we Lewis, seem to us fair, necessary, are bound to understand its terms, and complete:— according to the same rules we apply “ 1st. We are hound to understand what to any other writings. “ To adopt a speaker or writer says to us, in that sense any other method ” (says Greswell, a and meaning which he intends to convey; learned author) “of arriving at the and bis meaning and intention are always to true sense of the Scripture, is to be collected from the true and legitimate meaning of the language he employs, as that substitute an indefinite and capri is settled by universal usage and consent.” cious standard of interpretation, “ 2nd. The literal sense is the true and taken from, I know not what, legitimate sense of language to which we are imaginary notions and preconceived bound to adhere in our interpretation of what any writer or speaker says to us, except in opinions of the interpreter himself, those cases where it is apparent from the and consequently of as many kinds subject considered, in connection with the as there are expositors, all equally language employed, that its author intended arbitrary, precarious, and unsatis it to be used in a figurative sense.’’ tn m “ 3rd. If no such intention be apparent in | factory,' J’ to any but those who set what any writer or speaker says, still if w-e | them up, and1 apply them.” Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 18 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. February 1, It will be observed that, in the God under the New Testament.” rules quoted, there are only two “ The wolf and the lamb shall feed senses in which ordinary language is together, and the lion shall eat straw understood, namely, the literal and like the bullock i.e., “ The wolf, the figurative ; but interpreters of the which is an exceeding fierce, rapaci Bible assert that the language of the ous creature, and greedy of devouring scriptures is sometimes employed in its prey, exhibits a striking emblem a sense different from these. This of the barbarous enemies of the flock additional sense they term the of Jesus Christ. The lamb, well spiritual,—a sense never sought for known for its innocence, blameless in the language of any other book. ness, and usefulness, significantly Well, what is meant by the spiritual represents the disciples of Jesus sense of a passage? Not the figur Christ, who are distinguished for ative, for that sense is as apparent, humility. The lion, exhibits a proper where it is used, as the literal; for a emblem of the powerful blood-thirsty sentence cannot be used in a figur adversaries of the people of God. ative sense, unless a figure be ex_- The bullcck, may be considered as pressed or implied, and every term symbolical of the laborious useful in such a sentence must have a literal servants of God. Concerning people signification; because a figure of of these contrary tempers, our pro speech is not in the terms of a phet foretells that those of the sentence, but in their application to former sort, being divested of their subjects to which they do not properly ferocity and enmity by the influence belong. For instance, in the sen- (of the ~Holy Ghost,■ and rendered tence, a Fear not, Abram, I am thy ■mild and peaceable, they shall famili shield,” all the terms must be under ;arly feed together, ... on the stood in their literal sense before the doctrines of the gospel,” which doc import of the figure, evidently im trines, the author says, are repre plied in the language, can be proper sented by strawI After the same ly apprehended. Neither does the fashion, the declaration of the angel spiritual sense mean the symbolic, of the Lord to Mary, that her child which differs somewhat from the should sit on the throne of his father figurative, and is sometimes used in David, and reign over the house of the sacred writings; but by the Jacob for ever (Luke i. 32), means, spiritual sense, is meant the mystic, sitting at the right hand of Jehovah which is in no way expressed, but in the heavens, and reigning in the rather concealed by the terms used. hearts of God’s people on earth. The character of this spiritual sense Jerusalem, Zion, the mountain of will, however, be better understood the house of the Lord—the temple by examples of the mode in which itself, all mean the Gentile Church. interpreters employ it. Thus, on Israel returning to their own land, Isa. Ixv. 17-25, M‘Cui loch affirms means the conversion of the heathen that — “Behold I create a new to Christianity, &c., &c. heavens and a new earth,” means, Such is the method of spiritualiz “ I am about to give my church a ing the scriptures. Obscuring would new and beautiful form by intro be a far fitter term. ducing a new dispensation of grace.” Tn Rev. xi. 8. we read of a city When Jehovah says, “ Behold I “ which spiritually is called Sodom create Jerusalem a rejoicing.” “" By~_ and Egypt, where also our Lord was Jerusalem Churchis meant of God the General church Conference: of crucified McDonough, ;; ” but thisGA; use of the term Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ February 1,1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 19 spiritual is very different from that or whatever in scripture conflicted to which we are adverting. This is with his philosophy. This is the simply designating “ the city where man who in our day is, by the pro our Lord was crucified,” by the fessed adherents of Christianity, styled names of places which it resembled “ The father of biblical criticism in wickedness and impiety, just as and exegesis in Christendom; ” and, Jehovah had reproved its wicked from their point of view, justly so, rulers and inhabitants by his pro for those principles of interpretation phet Isaiah, many centuries before. with which his name is identified, “Hear the word of the Lord, ye and by which the words of God are rulers of Sodom; give ear unto the made void, are contended for, and law of our God, ye people of Gomor applied with filial faithfulness, in rah—to what purpose is your sacri the present day, by almost every fice,” &c. Nowhere in the scriptures contributor to religious literature. do we find the term pneumatikos The instances we have cited of this used in the sense contended for by spiritualizing process, regarding the these perverters of the word of God. ’language of Isa. Ixv. 17, and Luke Spiritual, in scripture, means accord i. 32, are but a sample of the mode by ing to the Spirit, just as carnal which almost, if not every, article means according to the flesh. The of real scriptural faith and hope has prophets “ spoke as they were moved been explained away. The promises by the Holy Spirit,” (2. Peter i. 21.) God made to Abraham of an inherit and the apostles spoke in words, ance of the land he shewed to him.— which the Holy Spirit taught them The promises made to David, that his (1 Cor. ii. 13), consequently those seed should sit for ever on his throne. who interpret these Spirit-given —The restoration of Israel to their words by their own conceptions, or own land, having the law of God according to laws of correspondence written in their hearts.—The re of their own framing, carnalize the storation of the kingdom to Israel.— words of the Spirit of God to their The coming again from the heavens own, and their neighbour’s hurt. of the Lord Jesus to sit on the This system of so-called spiritualiz throne of David on mount Zion.— ing was introduced to the adherents The resurrection of the saints at his of the doctrine of Christ, in the third appearing, and their reigning with century, by Origen, who has been him over the nations.—The resur styled “ the father of biblical criti rection of the rest of the dead when cism.” Deeply embued with the Neo the thousand years are finished.— platonic philosophy, and the puerile The making of a new heavens and allegorizing of the Jewish Rabbins, new earth. — The descent of the whatever he found in scripture New Jerusalem. All this is at the contradicting his notions of truth present hour denied by some sect or and propriety, he explained accord- other, substituting, in place of these ing to what he termed the spiritual glorious realities,some----- 42 ------figmentx of sense. He affirmed that “as man their own vain fancy. Were the consists, according to Plato, of Lord to make his descent to earth body, soul, and spirit, so Scripture just now, how truly should we find has a threefold sense; ”—that is, his words verified, “ When the Son the literal, intellectual, and alle of man cometh shall he find faith on gorical, or mystic. By this means the earth.” Faith in the hopes of he got rid of Eden, Adam, and Eve, the gospel is rare indeed; and even Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 20 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. February 1,186#, where it exists, it is sadly diluted been done by others) to get quit of by fancy. Let the faithful in Christ it, and of every other object of our Jesus beware of the vain philosophy hope in the age to come. Beloved, taught by Origen ; for, even among let us beware of the false principles the believers of the gospel of the of the apostacy. Is it not the case, kingdom of God, and the name of that on every point where we differ Jesus Christ, the principle and prac from the sects, we differ simply be tice of spiritualizing is growing in cause we adhere to the plain, obvious, favour.f?______TiIt 1has indeed_1 . _ JI existed • _.J_ _ JI among and ordinary meaning of the words us, to a small extent, for a long of God, from which they have, un- time; for has not "the coming of the happily, departed’ 1 I know we are Lord, spoken of by himself in Matt. desirous' ""to ~~maintain our faith in xxiv.,, been interpreted alla spiri- purity, therefore have I called atten tualizing, to signify the destruction tion to a false principle of under of J erusalem by the Romans ; and standing the scriptures, which, I the events describeebin 2 Pet. iii. 10, have reason to fear, is stealing in 12, by the same process, metamor- sidiously into the household of faith. ■ phosed into the dissolution of the Let each of us be able to say, in the Jewish state? Such applications of face of all men, “ There is no doc this deliterious principle of interpre- trine of my creed,—no article of my tationj I • 1has, we say, existedJ-X JI forP a- long1 faith, which I cannot express correctly time amongst us, and now it seems in the unaltered words of scripture; on the increase, some even affirming and I am determined, God helping that “ the sea,” which, when the me, to hold fast the form of sound thousand years are finished, is said words, in faith and love, which I have to “ give up the dead which are in learned in the holy scriptures.” it ” (Rev. xx. 13), and of which there W. L. is ultimately to be “ no more,” (Rev. xxi. 1), does not mean “sea,” but Note.— For the quotations in the early part of this article, I am indebted to an nations. It is plain that we only article quoted from an American print in the require to apply the same method to “ Quarterly Journal of Prophecy,” October the “ first resurrection (as has already 1865. AN ENGLISH REPLY TO THE ROCHESTER EPISTLE. The disciples of Christ meeting in Edward, sired, but such unity cannot be obtained Street,L------, —Birmingham, ------q------, England,! send- this letter- unless attention' be given to the utterance of greeting,rr.ootinr, to+a the assembly-woAn.hlv meetingmnptinir in Rnpll-JKoch- | thettiA apostle,nnostlp.—---- PrnVA“ Prove all alliliino*fi. things, hald hold fast fast ester, New York; and to all of like faith and that which^iUaI, is good. ’ Let1 any »A<>Ai>in Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 22 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. February 1,1866. standing reproof of the Lord is, “Let him the unity of the Spirit by the uniting bond that is without sin among you cast the first of peace; there being one Body and one stone.” The use of personalities, in ths Spirit, as also you were called in one hope of truest acceptation of the word, is the right your calling; one Lord, one faith, one im only of him who was without sin or fault at mersion ; one God and Father of all; he all. Who is there amongst the disciples who who is over all, and through all, and in all.” can say this of himself? “If we say we Amidst the turmoils, quarrels, personal have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the ities, and divisions of the sects, the disciple truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, he ever relies upon his master, Christ. Through is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and his strength he is able to bear and forbear; to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. If to pray for and love his enemies, as well as any man sin, we have an advocate with the friends. Ignored, cast out as none of theirs, Father, Jesus Christ the righteous.'1' down trodden, yet uprising, he may be ; yet To you, then, we would hold out the right his hope and anchor resting in the heavens i hand of fellowship. Bearing witness as your is firm and sure. Knowing that “what letter does hy its internal evidence to your things werewritten aforetime for our instruc desire to co operate with those whose hope is tion were written t hat we through thepatience “ the hope of. Israel.’' To us, the disciples, and consolation of the scriptures might pos there is no distinction of race or clime,—no sess the hope.” ties of clanship or feudal servitude,—all are '• And may the God of that patience and one in Christ Jesus. Whether the govern that consolation give you the same disposi ment under which we live be imperial or tion toward each other, according to Christ republican matters not to us. All powers Jesus ; so that with one mind and with one that be are ordained of God; to them we mouth you may glorify the God and Father yield obedience, looking for deliverance when of our Lord Jesus Christ.’’ he comes whose right it is to reign—then, “Now, unto the King aionian, immortal, the triumph of the believer;—now the cross, invisible, the only wise God, be honour and then the crown. glory for the ages of ages. Amen.” What better exhortation to union can we May his love, the favour of the Lord Jesus use than that of the apostle Paul,—“ I ex Christ, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit, hort you, therefore, I, the prisoner of the be ever with the Israel of God. Amen. Lord, to walk worthy of the calling with Geo. Hatfield. which you were called; with all humility Henry Brittain. and gentleness, with patienee sustaining each M. A. Hatfield. other in love; using diligence to preserve Birmingham, Dec. 1865. THE GOSPEL THAT WAS PREAQHED BY THE LORD JESUS AND HIS APOSTLES TO JEW AND GENTILE* In all writings, human or divine, for the Jews believed in the king terms are employed both in a primary dom of God even when they rejected and secondary sense. In a secondary the gospel, It was of believers in sense, the term “ gospel ” is applied the kingdom of God that Paul said, to the cross of Christ, in 1 Cor. i, “ As touching the gospel they are 17, 18; and in the same secondary enemies for your sakes.”’’ And that sense, to the kingdom of God, in this term “ gospel ” is conly used in Gal. iii. 8. We say that the term a secondary sense, when applied to gospel is only applied to the king- the death of Christ,, as a sacrifice for dom of God in a secondary sense ■ sin,’ ’is evident, from this that the apostles preached the gospel long * From “ The Reflector of Divine Truth,” before they either understood or be reprinted by request, and with the full per lieved in the death of Christ. mission of the author. What then is the primary, strict, Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ February 1,1806. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 23 original meaning of the term gospel Matthew shows that Luke means, in the New Testament? What was “ the gospel of the kingdom of God.” that gospel which Jesus aud his Three times at least Jesus pre apostles preached to Jew and Gen dicted that “ this gospel of the king tile 1 To the candid reader we sub dom should be preached in all the mit, on the following scriptural world for a witness unto all nations,” evidence, that it was, strictly speak Matth. xxiv. 14; Mark xiii. 10; ing, neither more nor less than this Mark xiv. 9. And in accordance —“ The kingdom of God is at hand.” with these predictions, after his re Was not this the gospel which the surrection, he commissioned the prophets predicted that Jesus and apostles to “go into all the world, his apostles should preach? As it and preach the gospel to every is written—“ How beautiful upon creature,” Mark xvi. 15. the mountains are the feet of him Neither in his gospel, nor in “ The that bringeth good tidings, that pub- Acts,” does Luke represent the lisheth peacei ; that bringeth good preachers of the gospel as ever using tidings of good,—.i thatn.i publisheth_ it.i .1 sal__i these words, “ the kingdom of God vation ; that saith unto Zion, “ Thy is at hand.” But in both these Godreigneth!”—Isa. Iii. 7; Nahum precious portions of the sacred writ i. 15; Rom. x. 15. An attentive ings he represents these preachers as examination of the passages will delivering in other words the same show that the words—“ thy God gospel. In his gospel he represents reigneth,” are intended to comfort the seventy as assuring the Jews that Israel under the fierce rage of anti the kingdom of God was come nigh christ ; consequently that it is just unto them, Luke x 9-12; and in a prophetical way of saying “ thy “ The Acts,” he represents Peter God is about to reign,” or “the connecting together, as nearly simul- reign or kingdom of God is at hand.” taneous+»n«ni8 events,avati+. And all agree with and confirm the gospel “God hath appointed a day of judgment.” that the kingdom of God is at hand. And so as L says, “ As the prophets said so Hence, in a secondary sense, and because it came to pass.” thus connected with it, we may call these The opening statements of paragraphs 7 things the gospel. Thus;—Paul says, ‘ Re and 8, are singularly wanting in proof, in the member that Jesus the Christ . . . was very point needing it. Thus:— raised from the dead, according to my gospel.’ “ In the New Testament the kingdom —2 Tim. ii 8. How according to Paul’s being at hand, made from Matthew to Reve gospel! ‘ Repent, for God has appointed a lation, the main ground of repentance.” day in the which he will judge the world in “ In nearly all the epistles, the day, the righteousness, by that man whom he hath coming, and the Kingdom of Christ, are re ordained ; whereof he hath given assurance to presented as being at hand. Rom. xiii. 11, all men, in that he hath raised him from the 12; 1 Cor. vii. 29; Heb. x. 37 ; James v. dead’—Acts xvii. 31. Thus, Jesus as the 8 ; 1 Pet. iv. 7 ; Rev. xii. 12, are examples.” Messiah, the Lord’s ordained, or anointed, But supposing this point to be disposed of, was raised from the dead, because the king and that we are confined in our inquiry to the dom of God was at hand, or, in other words, four evangelists—is it quite certain that the because God had appointed a (day’ of judg-' proximity of the kingdom constituted the gos- ment; as predicted in Psalms. xcvi.---- • and. i pej op f jle kingdom ? The proof text in xcviii.”] Mark i. 147 15, seems to read more naturally another way. It reads, “ Jesus came into As the subject of the foregoing paper has Galilee preaching the gospel of the Kingdom of late been made to assume more importance of God, and saying, the time is fulfilled, and than formerly, it will not be deemed out of the Kingdom of God is at hand! repent ye, place to accompany it with a few remarks, and believe the gospel.” The question here not intended as a complete exposition of the is, Is the intimation and~comrnand in verse subject, but simply as indicative of a scrip 15 explanatory of, or in addition to, the tural settlement of it. preaching of verse 14. If explanatory, the The definition at the close of L’s explana word “and” must be omitted,thus, “preach tory note, is one which has often been given ing the gospel of the Kingdom, saying, the as the sense in which “ the Kingdom of God time is fulfilled, and the Kingdom of God is is at hand ’’ was preached to the Gentiles. at band,’’ &c. This is a point, therefore, It is a definition in which every disciple which must be proved from some other source heartly concurs. It is as follows:—“ Because than this standard proof text. the Kingdom of God was at hand, or, in But it js said here " the Jews believed in the OTHER WORDS, BECAUSE GOD HATH APPOINTED Kingdom of God, even when they rejected A day of judgment.’’ Now if‘‘the King the gospel.’’ The inference intended to be dom of God is at hand,” in the mouth of drawn from this is that the gospel must have John the Baptist, Jesus and the twelve been something else, than the mere future before Pentecost, is the same thing in the establishment of the Kingdom. But this is mouth of Paul, as “God hath appointed a not so self-evident as is assumed. If one day of judgment,” which latter declaration were to say, those Jews who rejected the every disciple rejoices to believe, why should gospel did not believe in the Kingdom, it not this be satisfactory to every reasonable would be more easily proved. Who rejected mind? If proximity can be so easily re the gospel ? The ruling and influential solved into future certainty, why should classes, the chief priests, Scribes, Pharisees, not future certainty be accepted for proximity. and rulers of the people, constituting “ all Again L. asks, “was not this the gospel Jerusalem,” and a considerable portion of the which the prophets predicted that Jesus and provinces Thii whole party had for many his apostles should preach ? ” As it is written years been dependent for place and power on —“ flow beautiful upon the mountains are the patronage of Rome. Patriotism was thus the feet of him that bringeth good tidings . . eaten out of their nature, and loyal allegiance . . that saith unto Zion, ‘‘Thy God reigneth.” to the theocracy of their fathers had no place It is just a prophetical way of saying, “thy in their hearts. “ How can ye believe who God is about to reign,’’ or, “ the reign or receive honour one of another?” was the Kingdom of God is at hand.” It is well cutting inquiry of tfcsus presented to this very known that the prophetical sense of such an class. “ Had ye believed Moses, ye would expression as “thy God reigneth,” is simply have believed me ; for he wrote of me.’’ “ Thy God shall reign.” This, if understood Now it was to the nation as a nation, and as a prediction of the preaching of Jesus— as represented by this very party, that the “the Kingdom of God is at hand,’’affirms testimony of Jesus was mainly borne. He no more than future certainty, and is sin never claimed the Messiahship except when gularly confirmatory of Paul’s definition — challenged by them. This came to a point Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 26 Ul'HE.THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. Eebruary I, ism. after his apprehension, when placed before [ years before this, Herod and all Jerusaleji the high priestiriest and Roman Governor. HisJ , with him were troubled at the__ inquiry of the words before Pilate were—“Thou sayestvpsI I wiseWISA men —“WhereWhoro isie heTin f-Tiatthat isis'bornio komborn ^jnaKingKii 1 that I am a King. To this end was I born, I of the Jews ?” Why should all Jerusalem and for this cause came I into the world that have been troubled at the birth of the King IT shouldJinnlA bearI.O5.r witnesswiinocc unto thetka wl.truth. ” || ooff the Jews ? The only answer is, they had The representative character of the ruling (! lost faith in the Kingdom, because they were party is seen in the lament of Jesus over , satisfied with the position they had secured, Jerusalem, apostrophising it as the respon and feared to risk losing it. sible representative of the nation—“ If thou “ The common people heard Jesus gladly’’ hadst known,' even thou, at least in this thy —although few would acknowledge his day, the things which belong unto thy peace ! Messiahship, probably through fear of the but now they are hid from thine eyes. For ruling party, see John ix. 22. This acknow the days shall come upon thee, that thine ledgment was the turning point, although enemies shall cast a trench about thee, and not preached either as gospel or otherwise. compass thee round, and keep thee in on L says “the Kingdom of God is at hand” every side. And shall lay thee even with the is the primary strict original meaning of ground, and thy children within thee; and the term gospel in the New Testament.” Gal. they shall not leave in thee one stone upon iii. 8, contains the most original, strict, and another; because thou knewest not the time primary sense of the term gospel—“In thee, of thy visitation.” Thus the nation through Abraham, shall all nations be blessed j” and its rulers is proved to have lost faith in their here proximity is awanting, except in the kingdom, and was consequently unprepared sense of future certainty. to acknowledge their king. Even thirty J. 0. THE LITTLE HORN. THE ANTICHRIST. There is one particular feature of call his name Immanuel,” (vii. 14) this King given in Daniel xi. to which “ Unto us a child is bom, unto us a we would refer more particularly. son is given, and the government He is said, not to regard the God of shall be upon his shoulder,” (ix. 6). his fathers, “nor the desire of women.” Micah had said “out of thee shall We are fully aware that this is he come forth unto me to be ruler in generally applied to “ the forbidding Israel,”(v. 2). Jeremiah, “Iwillraise to marry,” of the Apostle Paul. This up unto David a righteous branch, and being however one of the features of a King shall reign and prosper, and the apostacy, or falling away, and not shall execute justice and judgment of the Man of Sin. Other character in the earth. In his days Judah istics are given of the apostacy, as shall be saved, and Israel dwell well as this by the apostle. The safely,” (xxiii. 5). Haggai, “ The best of these, is applicable to every desireof all nations shall come, ” (ii. 7). church, sect, or ism, now existing to Matthew, “ Now all this was done, a greater or less extent, and not to that it might be fulfilled. Behold any one in particular. But this a virgin shall be with child,” (i. 23). peculiarity described by Daniel, Luke gives the salutation of Eliza belongs to this King. We think it beth, “ Elizabeth wa>s filled icilh the applies in a manner nob generally Holy Spirit, and she spoke out with understood. Previous to this, Isaiah a" 1loud~'1 —voice,’ — and—1 said,•’ ™BlessedJ art had uttered his “Behold a virgin thou among women, and blessed is shall conceive, and bear a son, and the fruit of thy womb, and whence Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ February 1,1366. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES 27 is this to me, that the mother of my HYMN FOR THE EVENING. {Fourth Century). In the time of the evening, The evening despises him. Let praise be given to Thee, And treats him with contempt, ■ From the united tongues, And his oppressive covetousness Of the children of men. Is not satisfied. Thou hast given the day time, Blessed be thy majesty, For business and labour, Who from the beginning. And that we may provide Hast carefully regarded, All useful things. Our human nature. Behold, all who are oppressed Who hast appointed a returning With heavy toil, To the children of men, Return Thee their thanks, And all living creatures Because Thou dost give them repose. In the time of the evening. Who is the being, He hath put a seal upon his church, That will not worship Thee, And defendeth her children Because thou carest so much, From the adversary Satan, For our humanity ? And all his hosts. To the hungry and thirsty, Let thy peace, Lord, he diffused, - To those who labour and are fatigued, Through the four regions of the earth, The evening comes, And let the wicked one flee away And sets them at liberty. From the midst of us. The season of evening From every tongue Hath now arrived, Of all animated creatures, And maketh joyful And from all places, The world and its labourers. Let praise ascend. But he who is pitiless, And we, together with them, Towards his fellows, Will ascribe glory And he who is avaricious. To thee, 0 Lord, and to the Father, Not being satisfied with his work, For ever more. Fjohraem Syrus, Intelligence, Notes, Ac- Barrow in Furness, Lancashire.—By nth. It had been intended to have these an overlook last month, we neglected to lectures divided between Swansea and Mum notice the presence of a brother as a tempor. bles, but as the place of meeting in Swansea ary resident in this place,—George West could not be obtained during the week, the garth (with Mr John Barrow, Church village of Mumbles came in for a double sup • Street.) Our brother is a stone-cutter, and ply. The lectures were well attended, has come from Geneva, Illinois, U.S. where considering the amount of opposition in the his family presently resides. His stay in place. On Sunday January 10th, brother this country is not likely to be very long ; Roberts gave three lectures in the brethren’s but should any brother happen to be within meeting-room, in the Music Hall, Swansea^ reach, it might be well to give him a call, or Twenty-six brethren and sisters from Mum if any have time to correspond with him to bles (5 miles distant) met with those in do so; for encouragement in the faith, and Swansea for the breaking of bread at ten a.m. for fellowship iu the glorious hope. The attendance during the day was very good. Mumbles and Swansea. The brethren On the evening of next day the brethren hero have been favoured with a course of held a tea meeting in Mumbles ; after tea the lectures by R. Roberts of Birmingham, ex doors wore thrown open, aud an opportunity tending from December 29th, to January given to those present to put any questions Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 32 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. February 1, w suggested by the previous lectures. Advan tage was taken of this privilege by a Wes- Publications. leyain local preacher, a very intelligent man, THE DISCIPLES’ CHORAL SERVICE who put several inquires of a metaphysical OF BIBLE THEMES, nature,towhich appropriate answersweregiven. A collection of Christian Songs,—the What good may have been done to those subjects selected from the Holy Scrip outside is not yetknown, but we hope to hear tures, and set to suitable music (in both ere long of fruit to the glory of God. One notations), arranged for four voices. This effect these lectures seem to have had is to book, got up expressly for the use of the have stirred up the clergy to more active brethren in their social services, and suitable opposition to the truth, which, naturally either for the church or the fireside, may have more effect in calling the atten Is now reduced in price. tion of the public to it, than any effort on One Shilling in a neat "printed cover; One our part. and Sixpence cloth boards, post free. May be had of G. Dowie, 88 Nicolson Street, Edinburgh. Turriff,— “ Dear brother, I spent my old Yule days with the brethren in Buchan. On Also may be had of G. Dowie, the 7th January I baptized at Mintlaw, The Messenger of the Churches, George Anderson, (tailor), New Deer, and First Series, for 1861, 1862, 1863, 1864; in met with the brethren at Fetter-Angus. single volumes, sewed, Is.; or the four to And here on the 21st I baptized James gether, in cloth, lettered, 4s. 6d. The two Strachan, (farm servant), New Deer. Two first Nos. of the vol. for 180 are out of print, or three in Buchan are inquiring. You will but a few copies of the others are still on see by this programme what I am doing at hand, and may be had at Id. each. Postage 1home. ”-J. R.—Lectures on the Gospel of in aT)l cases extra—for single vols., 2d.; for the“ great salvation to ’be obtained1 - 1 —in -v,the t- ...... Tr • i n ft t . •> v • n . 1 the cloth vols., 6d. Kingdom of God at the second coming of the . ___As it„ „is inconvenient_ 1__ to„ 1keep r up_r stock so Lord,I rxT-rl jA CourseAl, i.nA atof lecturesi zxzt+vt Tinwill 11 t(D.V I 1 \ )1 1be 1long, _ *it I is desired___ - .. _ .7 of_ f 11.those . -wishing - AlA to-procure—, delivered inIT. thefllZV Town”F~r Hall,Cl11 ^1^11 Turriff, ri'I CP onf 11 /thea ' — ______any back numberslx AH or______volumes/,4- ’ of4 lx Athe Messen- following subjects by Mr James Robertson:— ger, 1st series, to apply before April 1st, ass Sunday,„, January 21, “ Paul’s reason for at that time the whole remainder will be dit-du- not-Al. being _r_ ashamed______.J .Iof’xi the GospelJanuary’ •* posed of some other way. 28,9ft 11“ H'KThea vnnnnf.mount ofnf trnnaficnimtinntransfiguration; •” i i i r nr The following may be had from W. Norriei February 4, “ Peter’s confession February 9 Ingliston Street, Edinburgh. 11, “ The restitution of all things, and the The Destiny of the British Empire renovation of the world;” February 18, - Revealed in the Scriptures. Piice 6d. “Christ consoling his apostles;” February The Contrast between Protestantism 25, “ The two thrones,”—Lectures to com and the Gospel ; 36 pp. 8vo, 6d. mence at half-past 5 o’clock, all are invited What is the Gospel ? 4 pp. 12mo, Is fid per to attend. “ Be ye also patient, stablish your hundred. hearts for the coming of the Lord draweth The Kingdom of God. 1 page, 8vo, Is. per nigh.’’ hundred. The Gospel Witness. 16 pp. 8vo, complete The Treasurer acknowledges receipts for in 12 Nos. at 2d. each. Single Nos. the Messenger from Barnstaple, Dundee, (except No. 5) may be had to complete sets. Jarrow, Lanark, Malvern, Mumbles, New Saving Faith 20 pp. 8vo, Id. burgh, and Swansea. The Bible. 8 pp. 12mo, 2s 6d per hundred. The Messenger is Registered for Transmission Abroad. Articles should be sent in by the 15th of the month, and items of intelligence not later than the 24th ; all papers meant for insertion, or notes of intelligence, may be forwarded to George Downs, 88. Nicolson Street; and all business communications to Jambs Cameron, 12 Gallon Hill, Edinburgh, to whom money orders should be made payable. AND W. R WILSON, PRINTERS, HIGH STREET, EDINBURGH. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. ♦ " I SPEAK AS TO WISE MEN, JUDGE YE WHAT I SAY.” No. 3. March 1, 1866. New Series. Vol. IL JESUS CHRIST AND HIM CRUCIFIED. When Paul says to the called in eitheri prophet, priest, or king. Con Corinth, I determined to know isequently he is other than the Christ nothing among you save Jesus I will give you two examples of what Christ, and? him crucified; he evi I mean. dently intimates that the knowledge Jesus is the Word of God. John (and of course the faith) of these gives: us the knowledge of Jesus as two things is essential to salvation. the Word of God in the following Let us, then, in the first place, ask terms—“ In the beginning was the what is the scriptural knowledge of Word, and the Word was with God, Jesus Christ, and, in the second place, and the Word was God. The same what is the knowledge of him cruci was in the beginning with God. fied, according to the scriptures. All things were made by him; and Jesus is the Christ. Christ is a without him was not anything made name or title of office. It is a Greek that was made.” Now, Jesus being word, which, being translated into the Word is one thing, and his being English, is anointed. Thus, Jesus the Christ is another. For he was is. called the Lord’s Anointed in not anointed to be the Word of God, the second Psalm; that Psalm is or the Creator of the world. quoted in Acts iv., he is called in Jesus is the Lamb of God who the quotation the Lord’s Christ. beareth away the sin of the world. The Lord’s Christ is the one that As under the law, lambs without the Lord has anointed. natural blemish or spot were offered Of old, men were anointed to be up in sacrifice to God for the sins of prophets, priests, and kings. No the people, so Jesus, the holy spotless man, no creature, and no thing, was Lamb of God, in a moral point of view, ever anointed as anything else. loved us and gave himself a sacrifice, From this it follows that Jesus is and an offering to God, for a sweet not, and cannot be, the Christ as smelling savour. But Jesus being anything else than as prophet, priest, the Lamb of God is one thing, and or king. Thus you see that you his being the Christ is another. have not the full knowledge of Jesus This will appear evident to you in when you know him only as the ■I a moment, if you only bear in mind Christ. Jesus is other things than‘ ; that’ 1 no 1lamb ’> or any other creature Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 34 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. March 1,1856. ever was anointed as a sacrifice, pel, that “ Christ died for our Sacrifices are not anointed to be sins.” sacrifices. Come, then, let us learn from the Do not Paul’s words in 1 Cor. ii. holy Scriptures what Jesus is as the 2, very clearly convey the idea that Christ. Since men were of old it is one thing to know Jesus Christ, anointed of God to be prophets, and another thing to know him as priests, and kings, one would natu crucified. He does not say (as the rally think that Jesus is the Christ passage is sometimes misquoted), I as the Lord’s anointed Prophet, determined to know nothing among Priest, and King, But when we you save Jesus Christ crucified, but look into the Bible, carefully as we he says, J esus Christ and him cruci- iought to do, we find that no man fied. Some translate the word kai was ever called Christ, or the Christ, into even Jesus Christ, even him •or the Lord’s Christ, or his Christ, that was crucified. This only makes or my Christ, as a prophet or as a my case all the stronger. It is as if priest, but only as a king. Some Paul had said, I determined to know people indeed suppose that Ps. cv. nothing among you save Jesus Christ, 14, 15, is an exception to this rule. even that Jesus, who was crucified When Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, by Pontius Pilate. There were were wanderers from nation to many christs that were not crucified nation, “ he suffered no man to do by any one. But the Christ I deter them wrong, saying, Touch not mine mined and still determine to know anointed, and do my prophets no among you for your salvation, is that harm.” But this may mean, Touch Christ Jesus who was crucified. not my kings, and do my prophets no Now this is a point of great im harm. For as kings then went, portance, It shows that you may Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, were have much Bible, and even saving, mighty kings in the land. You may knowledge of Jesus, and all the remember how Abraham armed his while not know him as the Christ. people and defeated the kings who You may know him as the Word of took Lot captive. Besides Jesus God who created the world, and as was called the Christ before he was the Lamb of God who beareth away anointed. So might Abraham, Isaac, the sin of the world, and yet not’' and Jacob, be called by God mine know what he is as the Christ. anointed, with reference to that Now, it is saving knowledge to time when all nations shall be blessed know him as the Word, and as the in them. Thus he reproved kings Lamb of God. The Bible makes that, for their sakes, saying, Touch not my certain beyond all rational dispute., kings. What are the kings of the But then the Bible makes it equally earth compared to the kings of the certain, that saving knowledge is kingdom of heaven. also the knowledge of Jesus as the Now, when this Ps. cv. 14, 15, is Christ. “Ye are all the children of so easily and naturally susceptible of God by faith in Christ Jesus.” being -explained in that way, it fol “ Whosoever believeth that Jesus is lows that it can be to no rational the Christ, is born of God.” “If man a satisfactory proof, that of men you believe not that I am he, you being called of God mine anointed s shall die in your sins.” Jesus died as prophets. for our sins. Hence Paul declares, In the whole Bible then, there is as one ofChurch the first of Godthings General of the Conference: gos-! not McDonough,a single place GA; where you can Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ March 1, 1886. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 35 say with certainty, Here men are relieve men out of all their miseries. called Christ, or the Lord’s Christ, That is why he is anointed. Now, or my Christ, as a prophet, or as a death is one evil, and poverty is priest. another, the latter sometimes more But many are the scriptures in than the former. Well, Christ was which men are so called as kings. christed to raise the dead, and to Thus, Saul was anointed by Samuel comfort the poor with the gospel; to be king of God’s people Israel; with those words of the eternal life and as such, he is called the Lord’s to which Peter refers as a poor man, Christ, or the Lord’s anointed, in 1 in John vi. 6-8. Lord to whom Sam. xii. 1-5. Samuel was both a shall we go ? Thou hast the words prophet and a priest, yet he speaks of eternal life. (In thy words we of Saul as the only Lord’s anointed poor men only find comfort). And then present. David also is called we believe (therefore), and are sure, the Lord’s Christ. And so is Cyrus, that thou art that Christ the Son of king of Persia, as a king raised up the living God. of God for the salvation of Israel. Here it is you see. As a good And now let us come to Jesus shepherd carries his lamb of his flock himself How is he called the Christ, in his bosom, and gently leads those or the Lord’s Christ, in the holy who are with young, so “ Christ, Scriptures? Is he ever called the the king of Israel,” cared for the Christ, or the' Lord’s Christ, or poor of his flock, preaching the gospel Anointed, as a prophet, or as a to them fcr their comfort, being priest ? No, never once in the made “ Christ, the King of Israel,” whole Bible. for this very end. No man has ever dared to say This is what the Bible calls Jesus that there is a single place in the as the Christ—a king; and as no Bible where Jesus is called the thing else. There is not a place in Christ as a priest. all the Bible where Jesus is called But some point us to Is. Ixi. 1, as the Christ as anything else than a quoted too in LLuke— iv. 18, and —king.o- —In many places he is called again referred to in Acts x. 38, as a1 the Christ“ i; as a king. In not one proof thatylla LJesus isxo called thevuv. Christ j placeL------—as anythingan else. This is the as a prophet. “ The spirit of the truth, whatever you may make of Lord is upon me ; for he hath Is. IxL, Luke iv. 18, and Acts x. 38. anointed me to preach the gospel to i Jesus is not called the Christ in the poor.” Well, and also to open these places. And no one denies the prison doors, to give sight to the ! that he was both a prophet and a blind, feet to the lame, hearing to I priest. The question is not whether the deaf, and life to the dead. All I Jesus be an anointed prophet and this he does as the Christ. But this' priest, but whether he is ever called you will observe is being more than ■ the Christ as such. I say no ; if a prophet. The spirit of the Lord 1 you say yes, down with your proof, was upon Jesus, he was anointed to | 1 Sam. ii. 10, is the first scripture preach the gospel to the poor. He i where Jesus is called the Christ of was also, by the same anointing, i the Lord, or his Anointed. Here qualified to raise the dead. Here, I Jesus is called his Anointed, which is therefore, Jesus is said to be the1 the same as his Christ, neither as Anointed of the Lord, as more than a ' prophet, nor priest, but as king, prophet. In fact, he was anointed to ' “ The enemies of the Lord shall be Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ t 36 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. March 1,1866. broken in pieces, out of heaven shall the son of Abraham ? King of all he thunder upon them ; the Lord nations. Abraham and his seed are shall judge the ends of the earth; heirs of the world. In Abraham, and he shall give strength to his and in his seed, all nations of the king, and shall exalt the horn of his' earth shall be blessed ; and Israel anointed.” How excellent is this| itself in the seed of David. This is scripture when you look at it in the the view we got of Jesus as the light of other scriptures, comparing 1Christ in the ancient scriptures. spiritual things with spiritual things, 1This is the view we got of him in that is the things of one scripture 'these more modern scriptures. In with the things in another. The iall the Bible you will find no other enemies of the Lord shall be broken 'view of Jesus as the Christ than this, in pieces; so in the second Psalm, ;and this everywhere. Thou shalt break them in pieces as Look now at Matt. ii. 1-6.—The a potter’s vessel. Out of heaven ‘wise men led of heaven came to shall he thunder upon them. He FRIENDLY GREETINGS ACROSS THE SEA. It has been suggested that it might do good to the Rochester epistle; No. 2, some portions to afford a wider publicity to the following of a rejoinder from the church in Rochester, letters, than was intended when they were We trust that such brotherly communication written, and we therefore insert them here, will not be rare among those who are of like No. 1 is tho reply of the Edinburgh brethren precious faith. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 38 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. March 1,186 « No. 1. we might be strengthened ami guided in the way of life. O, brethren, what a boon is this Edinburgh, 1st November 1865. which1 our Heaverfly Father has given us, To the church in Rochester, N. Y., their event the knowledge of his own will and pur brethren in the faith residing in Edinburgh pose] revealed in his word. This study adds, and neighbourhood, and meeting in Union fromi time to time another stone to the Hall, 98 South Bridge, send greeting— building of our character; but the develope- Beloved,—It has given us much pleasure meet; of love alone can make these grow into to receive your circular letter. Not only be- each< other like living stones : so that being cause it indicated the interest which you feel knit together by love, we are of that fine and in us, as a church of the living God, but admirable texture which is after the pattern because of the excellent spirit which pervades of Jesus Christ. it all. As it may be interesting to you to know We very cordially reciprocate those holy our fashions, if not our features; and to he and godlike sentiments which you have aware of our aggregate character and work grouped together from the word of truth, and ing, although strangers to us individually, feel confident that the spirit of these is in your we have much pleasure in noting these few hearts, else there would have been no prompt items :— ing to the trouble of writing so long a letter to We have now lived together in brother those whose faces you have not seen in the hood for twelve years, and some of those who flesh. formed the church at its first start, take an But, brethren, though we are strangers to active part and lively interest in it still. We one another, as men reckon acquaintanceship, meet twice every first day of the week for yet we are very familiar with you in the sight worship, mutual edification, and commemora of, and in relation to, God. Are you not tion. During the winter months we always our brothers and sisters in Christ Jesus. have a course of lectures, in the way of set T ea, and your likeness is before us when we ting forth the faith. These tend not only to look on one another, as surely as if we pos inform the people of our peculiarities, but sessed your several picture portraits. also to stimulate ourselves to holding on to Had we ourselves sat down to write you, the word of life. Our ordinary meetings are this is the style in which our feelings and conducted without any chairman, the acts of utterances would have flowed, even as you worship and service being, for the most part, have expressed yourselves, so that our sym quite spontaneous. Our number at present pathies are qnite with yon, brethren. Love, is fifty-six, and an occasional addition from unitv, peace, and purity appear to us a very the ranks of the enemy gives us heartening; excellent summary of virtues to stir up and but our great strength is firm faith in the cultivate in each other. These we have made plain words of God. Speculative interpreta- it our study to abound in, and have often hadI tion is at a discount with us, and we rather cause to thank God for the spontaneousi seek to excel in the iteration of those reason growth of those fruits of the Spirit, which, ings and demonstrations of the Lord and his under the stimulation of the truth, and thei apostles contained in the scriptures—to re- fostering care of faithful brethren in the Lord,, pose with perfect assurance on the very sure has sprung up among us. word of prophecy, and to render into living Yet, alas, we are not perfect, for there have form those gracious words of doctrine and been strife and division, and their concomitant duty with which the Bible abounds. evils amongst us, and we have hardly yet Our hope is in the fulfilment of those pro outlived the bane of a very sad disruption mises-----. ------made to Eve, to Abraham, and to which took place upwards of three years ago. David, which all concentrate in Jesus of In calmly reviewing which, and its results, Nazareth, the Christ, the Son of God, whois we have become more satisfied than ever that -----now at1 1his 17,1Father ’s right'1 Lhand,*’ 5 ,biding :j: his while knowledge—boasted and much exalted time to establish the kingdom under the knowledge—puffs up, puffs up indeed for one whole heaven, and give reward to all his against another, as you have so aptly quoted; saints and faithful brethren, making them love—that self-denying, generous, godlike kings and priests unto God. For the coming spirit, which made the early disciples so good of the Lord to fashion us into his own image, and of such good report, most naturally and we are constantly looking, waiting, and efficiently builds up. watching : hoping to be found of him in Speaking so, we do not disparage the know peace, without spot, and blameless. These ledge and wisdom which are of God, for things of the kingdom of God, and name of without them we are nothing, and our constant Jesus the Christ, have all along constituted - occupation, as it is our constant study, is to essential elements of our faith, having which increase our acquaintance with the lively we were baptized into the name of this seed oracles of God,Church that by of the God knowledge General of Conference:them of Abraham McDonough, and son GA;of David, in order to Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ March 1, 1369. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 39 the remission of sins, and inheritance of you.; Although unknown in the flesh, and eternal life in the kingdom of God. ifar distant from you all, yet we feel as if To help us in our acquaintances with each present with you in spirit, joying and behold other, to consider one another, to provoke ingi your order, actuating us as a stimulant unto love and good works, we give attention to provoke to love and to good works. .... to the amenities of social life, and thus know Our object iu writing to brethren every each other -well. Our mid-week evening where, was because we mourned in heart to meeting i< regularly held in the house of one see and know the sad mangling of the body or other of the brethren, and generally well of Christ, by the distractions, divisions, attended—the mutual interest we feel con and strifes abounding among brethren, which straining us to assemble, as much as the inter we, as a body, stand aloof entirely from, ex change of thought and feeling for which it cept to mourn over it. There is a gangren affords scope. ous sore somewhere, and we see both parties Thus we live like a family—a family, how at fault, and grievously too, and we had no ever, away from home, whose sympathies are intention to urge that this sore should be more within its own bosom, ami its desires smoothed over and externally healed, and for the appearing of the Head and Chief of■ still fester within; but rather find counsel all, the Lord Jesus Christ, our elder Brother,, from the lively oracles how to settle such Priest, and Lord—praying with all fervour, difficulties, and crucify the old man of the Come, Lord Jesus, come quickly. flesh. It really seems to us there are more It will give us much pleasure to hear from than one Diotrephes in these last-days, who you again and we shall give good heed to seeks to have the pre-eminence. The apos your excellent counsels, for they are the divine tle John had to rebuke one in his day—0, admonitions: and shall count it a pleasure and that an apostle were here now to exercise an honour to be brethren of the faithful in authority, and put certain men in their pro Christ Jesus, which are at Rochester. Fare per places, discussions would then cease. . . well.—Yours in the hope of the kingdom of We are much gratified in learning your God, aggregate character, your ordinary meetings, For the church, G. Dowie, Sec. your acts of worship, your breaking of bread, your mid-week meetings, your lecturing for No. 2. the good of others, and, lastly, your aggregate n umbera. To the Church of God in Edinburgh, Scot And would now iterate again in return— land. Their brethren in the faith once de are you not our brothers and sisters in the livered to the saints, residing in . the city Lord? echo answers with bowels of mercy, of Rochester, New York, America, send Yes. It may somewhat interest you to know greeting— our manners, habits, and aggregate character; Dearly Beloved,—With much pleasure! our numbers are comparatively small (in a city your reciprocal letter of love, bearing date of of sixty thousand souls, and generally a November 1st, in due time has reached us church-going people), yet, from all that across the great deep, and was received by aggregation, only fifteen have dared to come the church with joyful acceptance, not only out on the Lord’s side, who like the Samari- because you have condescended in th:the spirit tans .(Acts viii. 12), have believed the things of love to reciprocate your tender regards•Acrnrdfi in j concerningroncovnincr the Kingdom of God,God. and the Christian charity towards us (a church of ; name of Jesus the Christ, and have been iru- the living God), but, also, because of your' merged, both men and women. We ore, and very cordial reception and warm sympathy | live as one family, realising we are children in unison with those holy principles so en-[ of our Father in heaven, who careth for us. dearingly portrayed in the lively oracles, and , Our feelings and sympathies one, knowing which we ourselves hitherto have, as ‘an each other well. We meet for worship, and organized little body of Messiah's brethren, ; edifying each other, twice every first-day of acknowledging no head or superior but Jesus; the week, in a school-room, central in our ever remembering his words—call no man city, for hire only on first-day. At 10-30 aA.M..m. master, for one is your master, even Christ, we meet' to study' and1 'investigate the scrip-~ and all ye are brethren j and he that is chief- tures______‘ (very------beneficial), one of’ us■’ in the' r Tchair,, estcr.t among you, let him be servant of all. to —whom1— —we 1look-~1’ up to for order, &c. ‘Wevv“ Weh v uivare willing tolv readluau all, and hear all, but have a small library, consisting of a Greek- yield not ourselves to any/ man, WHAT IS LITERALISM? A few weeks ago a zealous re another minister advocate the abso vivalist, after trying to teach us his lute necessity of children studying the spiritism, prayed that we might “ be Shorter Catechism to enable them led to see that the written word was to understand the Bible. This is only symbols, needing the Holy Spirit but another way of expressing the to give it meaning and life.” We general idea “ that the Bible is a audibly dissented, for our previous dark book,” or in that man’s words, argument was upon the principle “ an advanced treatise needing human enunciated by our greatest authority manuals to explain it.” The logical —“ The words which I speak to you consequence is—the need of a clergy — they are spirit and they are1 or teaching class. “ The minister is life.” . the human guardian and expositor The same day we had a discussion of Scripture . . . , In studying with a minister, whose basis of the Bible, the way of duty is the way reasoning in defence of the im of danger; there is no such forlorn mortality of the soul was, that the and miserable journey as that of a Bible did not mean what it said, and young man’s travels on this track who boldly confessed that he did not without a guide .... The need the Bible to teach him what minister, be he whom he may, was man was. sent for this, among other purposes, Not longChurch afterwards of God General we heard Conference:to give McDonough, directions GA; in all things Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ I March 1,1868. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 41 pertaining to the Bible.”* Hence blind,” as “ deceivers,” &c., yet retain the Reformed Presbyterian Church the premise of which they are the affirms—“ The charge and office of necessary consequence. For if the interpreting the Holy Scripture is a words of the Bible need interpreting, part of the Ministerial calling which then there must be a class of inter- none, however otherwise qualified, preters.. And as these can only should take upon him . . . but interpreti ' according to their mental he that is duly called thereunto by _proclivities, sects and schisms; are God and his Kirk.” inavi*«Woinevitable. The only way to fight The foregoing reminiscences are priestcraft of every type and guise,— given on account of sundry letters, Papal, Protestant, Brethrenistic—is &c., received anent the article in to deny that the Bible needs interpre Messenger for December last—“The ting at all: to oppose “ I say,” or first and last curse.” One esteemed “ he says ” with “ thus saith the brother writes, “You seem to be Lord.” No other course is open, for drifting to the extreme of literalism. if we quote or endorse one man’s —Literal progeny of the serpent! exposition, our antagonist has a perfect dear me, what next?” A second right to bring another commentator; accounts the same “ as directly and all human opinion and words are antagonistic to the Gospel,” &c. of equal authority—-Origen, Pius, Another, (not, however, writing on Luther, Calvin, Swedenborg, Wesley, the article), advises us “ not to look or whomsoever1 isn amed. Gal. ii. 6. at'all objects through the oblique lens The only freedom then is to be of literalism if we -wish to view them found in the truth, and the truth in their true light and just propor- only in the word.I “ If ye continue tion.” One who believes that what in my word, ye are my disciples the prophets have foretold will come indeed ; and ye shall know the truth, to pass, as however improbable things and the truth will make you free.” seem now—such as the restoration of “Every word of God is pure.“” “The Israel, the triumph of the king of words of the Lord are pure words ; the north, the establishment of the as silver tried in a furnace of earth, Kingdom of Christ on the earth, &c. purified seven times.” “Thy word is —yet objects to other and contextual very pure: therefore thy servant testimonies of the restoration of the loveth it.” “ I have hoped in thy physical creation, the New Heavens word.” Can these expressions have and Earth, and the like, as 1being any meaning or power to us, if they “ far away from all region of likeli are not assurances of the reality of hood (seemingly unaware that the the words in which God utters His true region of likelihood is secularism, promises ? If we receive an assurance Acts xxvi. 8); and all because it is from a friend, do we honour him “ absurd literalism.” when we believe he does not mean From these we are led to conclude the thing he says? Does not our that there is some serious error yet doubt and construction make him a blinding the eyes of the brotherhood, liar ? Only in words can truth be as well as the world, when the given. It follows, then, that we only scriptures are viewed. For these, believe God when we believe the whilst energetically denouncing sec words He uses. Or to express it in tarianteachers as “blind leaders of the another phrase, we only believe His spoken word, the Bible, when we take * Lon,Ion Quarterly Review October 1862, its statements in their ordinary, Article, “ Bible Classes.” natural, or obvious sense, just as we Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 42 THE MESSENGER OF THE'CHURCHES. March 1, L8GC. should if they occured in any other to dust again in death, If He did book. This is literalism.* not mean this by the words His Literalism, then, is neither more scribes used, then "we are of all men nor less than just the foundation of the most miserable,” for we have our faith—that God means what he found it impossible to believe the ex says. On it,we have built up the position —that this is true only of the hopes we have. Thus— husk, the body, and that God means God promised to give to Abraham that the soul—the real man—lives for andd his seed the land of Canaan for ever. We have fallen into an error, an everlasting possession, and to bless of expecting eternal life only through all nations through him and his seed. resurrection, if it be so that the Bible We have believed that God meant does not mean what it says. this, and “have hoped imHis word ” We have literally read that Israel for a share with Abraham in this weredispersed throughout allnations. estate. If the principle is unsound, But then we don’t know that it was and God meant something else, then so, if the words don’t mean what they our eternal prospects are wrecked, for say. Symbolism is as powerful with we have denied the interpretation,— history as prophecy, and we must that he meant an inheritance of a needs fall back on the expositions we Canaan beyond the skies. remember glancing at nigh twenty We have literally read that God years ago, that Adam, Eve,* Noah, made man of dust, and that he returns Abraham, and Israel, were a series of symbols and allegories, not real per sonages. + * One writer condemns the essence of onr faith as “a pernicious literalism.” Onr only We have as literally read that God answer to this charge is to quote from his own will gather Israel again into their writings the following cogent passages.- “ If own land, to make them the greatest the Scriptures are to he understood on some nation on the face of the earth. But novel principle of interpretation, the informa tion to this effect must exist somewhere. It if there is a possibility of their God is not in the Bible itself-, if it were there meaning something else than what would be an end to the question. Where He says, then we have hoped in vain, then ? How are we to deal with this “ spirit have prayed for them in vain, have ual” mode of interpretation, then ? Simply to set it aside, and ascertain from the Scrip loved Jerusalem for nought. tures themselves bow it is intended that we We have understood from Moses, shall understand them. Take a prophecy, the Prophets, Jesus, and the Apostles, Lev xxvi. 31—33. Pent, xxviii. 37. How has this been fulfilled ? All admit that in that God would establish His King fulfilment of this prediction the real Israel dom upon the earth, that His Son were driven from their real, literal land, which Jesus would be the King thereof, became rwZb/and literal'y desolate, and that that he would reign in Jerusalem, Israel has been really and literally scattered among the literal nations of the earth . . and with His Saints over the earth, . . All ftilfilleH prophecies came to pass exactly as the terms of the prediction, * We have a dim idea of memory that the plainly and literally understood, would have ordinary interpretation of the curse on the led us to expect . . . Now are we not serpent in Gen. iii. 15, was the foundation of here supplied with a rule for the understand the whole structure. ing of unfulfilled prophecy. 3 he spiritualizing rule is gratuitous . . . It is not in the f For those who are curious in such matters Scriptures . . . Therefore we are sbnt up we would mention that Howitt's Journal, vol. to the conclusion thatit is a human invention L Page 1G2, contains a scheme of interpreta —one of the lineaments in the countenance of tion ol the Seals, A ials, &c., quite as reason that hideous apostacy which still frightens the able, and far more comprehensive, than the world out of its judgment.Church of God General Conference:| usual run ofMcDonough, such, for it GA;begins with Adam Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ March 1, 1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 43 that the temple would be rebuilt, &c. and like all other murderers, had But it is probable that we have all denied their identity, and fixed it on the while been believing a lie, if some other race and place inhabiting expositors are to be allowed the the Mediterranean region. Jeru- slightest credit_____ i:x tox_ theirxi. showing„i______/• of_____ salem,i____ where__ i_____ our____ tLord _ i was_____ crucified,_ some111V other meaning.XXXVCVLlXLAg. f he located on some Lanarkshire We have believed that this Son of muirland. Like all other interpreters, God and future King of the whole geography, history, and other sciences world was once before on the earth, were of no value against his ideas, that he died for our sins, and rose he taking refuge in that much abused from the dead. But if “the Revelation warning, 1 Tim. vi. 20, 21. Yet of Jesus Christ ... to his absurd as is this en masse translation servant John, who bore record of the -of the Biblical theatre and subjects, word of God,” does not mean what is it worse than current transfer it says, then there is every probability ences of Babylonian and Judean that the Gospel of the same author is prophecies to Italy, France, Con- likewise mystical, and the other three stantinople, Austria, Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 44 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. March 1,1366. simply be a delusion, a trap, sa | If any figure or symbol is not accord- Pandora’s box. We are necessitated1 ing to the letter or rule of the com to come at the conclusion, that the bined sciences of grammar and rhet only way to accept the Scriptures is oric, it is false. in their plain, obvious, or literal Literalism is the God-honouring meaning. acceptance of His words. The sup- Literalism,______; ___ then,7 ais______just takingo theposition that a “ style of language word of God to mean what it says, by peculiarly deep, mysterious,spiritual," accepting its words in their simple, was necessary for revelation, so that natural significance. Applied to His men would not be able to understand promises, it is to believe He will do it, cannot be honouring God. The or give what He says, not something idea that he must thus conceal his else. Applied to prophecy, it is to meaning, lest men, being warned, believe that events will happen just should not do what he had foretold, as He has foretold, not some other is just to, accuse him of setting a trap way according to so and so’s “private to catch men into sinning. But it interpretation.” It is to believe that is not so with Him. He has always future events will be just as literally warned in the plainest and fullest fulfilled as past events have been. language, Lev. xxvi.; Deut. xxviii. Before we proceed further we xxx. If the results be such as must make a definition. We have shown in Jer. vi. 8-17, or John ix. used the term literalism thus far in 39-41, xv. 22-24, the guilt is wholly its conventional significance, as the men’s own. For if they have not antithesis of mystical or symbolical. sinned openly and defiantly against In thissense, itis the equivalent of the the word like J ehoiakim (J er. xxvi.), obvious, natural, or ordinary mean they have sinned in preferring the ing of the scripture words. Etymo darkness of Rabbinical interpreta logically, it is according to the letter, tions to the light of plain shining and hence some have supposed that words. it leaves no room for simile, meta One of the most telling passages phor, figure, or symbol. This is a in the gospels is Luke xviii. 31-34, mistake, for a word conventionally which shows that the plainest spoken used has conventional amplitude. predictions are aye the least under But the word, whether used etymo stood. From this cause it is that logically or conventionally, recog Daniel and the Apocalypse are to nises all these. For as we have so this day stumbling blocks to exposi far found the Bible uses no unex tors, and that most men will blindly plained symbol; and an explained misunderstand them, till it be too one comes into the class of plain, late, to derive warning from them. obvious Words. By this means the A famous diplomatist, Talleyrand, authorised explanation, in supplying■ said, “ words were given to men to the literal idea to the form, reduces, conceal their thoughts,” But it is the symbol, or hieroglyph, to the> recorded of a certain British ambas- nature of a colouring, or garniture; sador that he successfully thwarted to the real. And the metaphors,, the designs of a court who made comparisons, &c., being always self- that saying their basis of action, by evident, occupy in Scripture, as in simply speaking the plain truth. In all other works, the office of polish this he did but imitate his Maker. and ornament, by means of which Literalism is the only satisfactory, the real is heightened, not concealed. Church of God General Conference:mind-filling, McDonough, heart-warming GA; mode of Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 1 March 1, 1868. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 45 * receiving the words of God. In words,” are able to make wise to John xiv. 1-3, we have great con- salvation,s' and free by the truth. solation given : but if we begin to ~Even l 1were interpretation always doubt that the Lord means what he used by honest hands, it is essentially says, then our comfort vanishes, and weak and bad. For were the mean we are tossed from wave to wave. ing of scripture dependent on any The sublimity of literalism’s power thing but the natural sense of the is shown in the record of the fathers, words,wuiua, we suuumshould never reach a “ Having seen the promises afar off meaning at all:— they were persuaded of them, and em braced them, and confessed that they “ For each man’s mind is a different prism, With angles of thought, with stains of sin, were strangers and pilgrims in the Which breaks up the sound rays as they land.” But how would it have been if pass in, they had doubted but that God didnot Into this, and that, into curse or chrism, mean something else than He pro Joy or regret.’’ mised? But they believed the record that God gave, and hence it would be, —The------fact that------each man— ’s phreno- to them as to us, a cause of “rejoicing logical organs, in their multiple with joy unspeakable, and full of-relationships*1‘x —withx1 each1 -other,x1 allow glory,” lively hope,” blessed several______t ...millions mi_____ of-i? _____variations,• _ . .. . _.renders ___i___ hope.” Whence would the Thes- ]it hopeless\ ' to' expect. identity' of salohians have got comfort if they thought apart from plain words, had taken Paul’s words, 1 Eph." " iv.‘ Hence we find the same individual so 13-18, as having any meaninging, but often denying to-day what he wrote just what he said. Had they be yesterday, and censuring others for lieved with some interpreters of holding his late interpretation, in their day, that the resurrection was stead of his later or latest. past already; or, that the dead were Literalism, then, is to accept Bible alive; or, that the Lord would descend ideas in Bible words. And is ex- _____silently ___into some desert place,, that emplified in believing that man is they would hear some whisper to set constitutionally dust and ashes ; off“ on travel‘ to find ...... him ; that- - -by that the.1 1hope ofn talife is• contained. • inL “clouds,” Paul meant the crowd certain tangible promises made to whom they would find at the place of fl16 fathers; that it will be given meeting, that this meeting-place;— through a resurrection from the “ the air ”—was the political aerial; dead; that it will be enjoyed in a had they conceived these and other kingdom of Christ upon the earth, alterations, would not the strife of over all Israel and rebuilt Jerusalem; mental debate have destroyed their afterward to be eternalised in new power to “comfort one another with heavens and a hew earth, and with these words.” the heaven-built city of new Jeru Literalism is the only safe guard salem as the abode of God, thereby alike against priestly pretention and realising the highest form and nature infidel deadliness. It proves that of blessing, “ God all in all.” “ the words of the Lord being pure J. W. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 46 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. March 1,186c TRANSLATIONS OF THE SEVENTY WEEKS, OR HEPTADES prophecy. From the Hebrew. Daniel ix. 24-27. By John Bellamy. London, 1863. Byi Isaac Leeser. London, 5625, Translation of the Book of Daniel. ,, Philadelphia, 5616. Translation of the Twenty-four Books of the Holy Scriptures. Seventy weeks are determined upon Seventy weeks are determined upon thy people and thy holy city, to finish thy people and upon thy holy city, the transgression, to make an end of to close up the transgressions, and to sins, also to make reconciliation for make an end of sins, and to atone iniquity, and to bring everlasting for iniquity, and to bring in ever righteousness, and to seal up the lasting righteousness, and to seal up vision and the prophecy,- and to the vision and prophecy, and to anoint the most holy. anoint the most holy thing. Know, therefore, for thou shalt Know, therefore, and comprehend, understand, from the going forth of that from the going forth of the word the commandment to restore and to to restore and to build Jerusalem rebuild Jerusalem, to Messiah the unto the anointed the prince will be Prince, will be seven weeks and seven weeks : and during sixty and sixty and two weeks : then the street two weeks will it be again built with shall be built again, and the wall, streets and ditches (around it), even even in troublous times. in the pressure of the times. And after sixty and two weeks, And after the sixty and two weeks Messiah will be cut off, but not for will an anointed one be cut off with himself: and the people of the prince out a successor to follow him: and that will come, will destroy the city the city and the sanctuary will the and the sanctuary, but his end will people of the prince that is coming be with a flood even to the end of destroy; but his end will come in a the war, desolations are determined. violent overthrow ; but until the end of the war, devastations are decreed (against it). And he will confirm the covenant And he will make a strong cove with many for one week : and in nant with the many for one week; the midst of the week he will cause and in the half of the week will he the sacrifice and oblation to cease, cause the sacrifice and the oblation and by the overspreading of abomi to cease, and this because of the pre nations, it will be a desolation even valence of the abominations which till the consummation, and that be bringeth devastation, and until de determined upon the desolate. struction and what is decreed shall be poured out upon the waster. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ March 1,1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 47 A WORD OF CRITICISM. TO THE EDITORS. Dear Brethren—In last month’s “ Mes- the1 brethren at Birmingham, I think that senger” I notice a reply to the Rochester were we to admit that considerations like address. It is, generally speaking, a very this, in themselves, forbid fellowship, where good and brotherly reciprocation of affectionate might we stop ? It seems to me altogether solicitude. Some of it I do not quite under inmaterial whether x>r not a man prefers to stand, but there is one passage which I wish call himself a “ christadelphian,” “ antipas,” to express my dissent from, because I think it c. c. c. (constituent of the church of Christ), is not in keeping with the spirit of the a member of “ the royal association of Rochester letter, nor our duty, as sensible believers,” &c., &c. The vital question I Christians, whd ought to be above any petty submit is, Does he believe and obey the jealousies upon matters which do not rise to gospel of the Kingdom of God and the name the level of the one faith. The objectionable of Jesus the Christ? If he does so truly, passage occurs in page 21, and reads—“ with any pedantic or fanciful designation he may parties who assume names not to be found sanc- adopt will not surety blot out his name from . tioned by use of the apostles, or their hearers, God’s book of life. And neither should it , the disciple of Christ can have no fellow • move us, who are God’s children, to cast him | J‘: ship.”. from us.—I am, &c. Now, with deference to the judgment of M. THE INQUIRER. I wish to ask the solution of an apparently &c. 1 do not myself assert that such very difficult subject, of any of the brethren things so viewed, will subvert, or over who may think themselves competent to the turn the things concerning the Kingdom task. We sometimes hear it asserted, that of God, and name of Jesus Christ. Will any this and the other thing; “ subverts the faith.” one who does so (since the matter is of For instance, to call in question what is considerable importance to him), take the commonly known as “ the year day theory,’’ trouble to demonstrate scripturally and logi as a rule in the understanding of prophecy ; cally, that the faith is overturned by the to suppose that a personal adversary or holding of such opinions, or of any one of them. devil, is sometimes alluded to in scripture; or The assertion has frequently been made, but to think that the “ fervent heat,” mentioned never attempted to be proven, so far as I am in 2 Pet. iii., is not to be taken figuratively, aware. Sergius Paulus. Intelligence, Notes, &c- Edinburgh.—Mrs Henderson, a very old of Alexander Black, bookbinder (son of our woman, who has been resident in London for brother and sister Black of Aberdeen), who, ten years, and known to some of the brethren upon February 27th, made the good confes there, has returned to Edinburgh. The first sion, and was baptized into Christ. thing she has done, after resting from the Crossgates.—On Monday, 12th February, fatigues of the journey, is to make the good John Cunningham, miner, Cowdenbeath, confession and be baptized into the name of having made a clear and intelligent confession the Lord: thus correcting years of wrong of his faith, was immersed into the name of standing in relation to God, and securing her the Lord. This took place at Edinburgh, title to the Kingdom of God. She is now and he forthwith returned to his own place, numbered with the faithful in Edinburgh, and rejoicing in hope of the glory of God. The purposes to spend the remainder of her days very small church here finds itself much there, in the patient waiting for Christ. The strengthened by such an acquisition. He brethren also receive accession in the person has been for some time a leading member of Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 48 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. March 1,188f. “ The Reformation,” and now transfers his tality of man, and his absolute dependence energies and abilities to a more apostolic for eternal li'e on faith in the Christ Jesus. cause. A good deal of excitement has been caused, Jarrow on-Tyne.— The small company which we hope shall lead many to search the of believers in this place has been enriched scriptures, jrnd believe the truth. by the fellowship of brother and sister George Davidson, from Aberdeen, who have come to On and after May 25th, the address of G. reside in this quarter. Peace be with them 1 Dowie will be as formerly, 12 Beaumont Kirkcaldy.—The series of lectures already Place. noticed as having been delivered here, in November and December, has been supple mented by another one in January, and by two The Treasurer acknowledges receipts for public conferences with those who have been the Messenger from Birmingham, Dundee, interested in the weighty matters brought Dunkeld, and London. under their notice for the first time. The second conference with them, being by their THE DISCIPLES’ CHORAL SERVICE own request, indicates an anxiety to thorough ly comprehend the doctrine of The Kingdom OF BIBLE THEMES, which has been set forth. There are but few A collection of Christian Songs,—the brethren in that locality, two in Burntisland, subjects selected from the Holy Scrip and one in Kirkcaldy—we hope their number tures, and set to suitable music (in both will be augmented ere long, by some of those notations), arranged for four voices. This who have had ears to hear, and who, we book, got up expressly for the use of the trust, have also hearts to obey. brethren in their social services, and suitable Mumbles.—On Sunday, the 18th Feb- either for the churchUIVu or the...... fireside, rnary, Mrs Rachel Delve and Helen Hay- c“uv‘ J^nowreduced in price.’ ward (a sister of Mrs Clement), were im- Qne shilling in a neat printed cover; One mersed into the name of the Lord, and re-|and Sixpence cloth boards, post free. May • ceived into fellowship. At the same time*be had of g. Dowie, 88 Nicolson Street, and place, Mr Evans, Swansea, put on theEdinburgh.----- Lord Jesus. Ha is added to the church at Swansea. The opposition of the clergy, to Also may be had of G. Dowie, which we referred in last month’s report from The Messenger of the Churches, this place, took the form of a public defence of “The immortality and immateriality of First Series, for 1861, 1862, 1863, 1864; in the soul, and consequent conscious existence single volumes,.----- > sewed,- ,Is. ■; or ,the four to- of the dead,’’ in a course of seven lectures by1 gether, in cloth, lettered, 4s. 6d. The two Mr D. Evans, student from the Baptist Col first Nos. of the vol. for 18 *0 are out of print, lege, Pontypcol. The chair was, with one but a few copies of the others are still on or two exceptions, filled by a clergyman be hand, and may be had at Id. each. Postage longing to some of the neighbouring churches. in all cases extra—for single vols., 2d.; for Our brethren were denied the privilege of the cloth vols., 6d. putting questions at the close of each lecture ; As it is inconvenient to keep up stock so but this defect hasbeen to some extent supplied long, it is desired of those wishing to procure by a course of three lectures by our brother, any back numbers or volumes of the Messen D. Clement, in which he reviewed the posi ger, 1st series, to apply before April 1st, as tions of Mr Evans, and stated and defended at that time the whole remainder will be dis the doctrine of Scripture regarding the mor- posed of some other way. The Messenger is Registered for Transmission Abroad. Articles should be sent in by the 15th of the month, and items of intelligence not later than the 24th ; all papers meant for insertion, or notes of intelligence, may be forwarded to George Dowie, 88 .Nicolson Street; and all business communications to James Cameron, 12 Calton Hill, Edinburgh, to whom money orders should be made payable. A. AND W. R. WILSON, PRINTERS, HIGH STREET, EDINBURGH. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. “ I SPEAK AS TO WISE MEN, JUDGE YE WHAT I SAY.” No. 4. April 1, 1866. New Series. Vol. II. THE IMPORTANCE OF THE’ HISTORICAL BOOKS OF THE OLD TESTAMENT IN RELATION TO PROPHECY. The historical books of the Old were learned from written documents. Testament not only form a great The Scriptures teach us that there and imposing panorama of the events was another means by which the of the past, and the special dealings future purposes of God were dis of God with his people Israel, and played before the eyes of Israel. with the nations of the earth; but in Them’ actions------and-1 events in this people’Ss many particulars they serve another history, as well as other facts recorded high and important purpose, namely, in the Bible, were constituted the to display in definite terms the course types or prophetic signs, of greater which God -will adopt in the future and more important transactions in the accomplishment of his great which will be enacted on a grander designs. There is reason to believe and more imposing scale in a future ’ that a written language was not age. We will consequently take the extensively employed during the admonition of the prophet and turn patriarchal, and even in later times our attention to, and “ remember the of the J ewish history. The materials former things of old.” which were then in use upon which In the fourteenth chapter of the to write, needed considerable prepara- book of Exodus, we read an account tion. The skins of animals must go of the passage of the Israelites through a process, in order to render through the depths of the Red Sea, them fit for receiving any record. and we should certainly be inclined The papyrus which was sometimes to regard thisAas purely historic, used was a somewhat frail and perish- relating a miraculous circumstance able material, and the process of en which has long since passed away: graving upon stone, would not only that it is simply a narrative of a be a very slow one, but would more remarkable deliverance effected by over be exceedingly inconvenient if the God of Israel, in proof of his transmission or circulation among the favour and love towards that people, people were necessary. It is not without supposing it to have the therefore very probable that the re slightest reference whatever to the velations of God to men in those times future. But on searching into the Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 50 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. April i, iss« treasures of divine wisdom we dis our readers’ attention to a prophecy cover that there is an importancei in Isaiah the 10th chapter where we and significance about this fact, are told that at a future day, when which we would not gather from the “the remnant of Israel shall turn Exodus narrative. In the 68th unto the mighty God”—the Assyrian Psalm we are informed that it is the of the future will “ lift up his staff purpose of God “ to bring his people against Israel after the manner of again from the depths of the sea.” Egypt. But the Lord God shall stir There is distinctly a reference to the up a scourge for him, and as His rod passage of the Red Sea, out of which was upon the sea, so shall He lift it God brought his people once, but no up after the manner of Egypt.” This history records the circumstance that testimony proves most distinctly he ever brought them up again, a that an event similar to that which second time, from the sea’s depths, took place at the Exodus of Israel and especially could this not have from Egypt, will be repeated. We been since the production of that know from the Mosaic narrative the Psalm. Let us suppose we had no effect of the lifting up of the rod over historic books in the Old Testament the sea. The result of this act was —no Exodus to detail the facts con the dividing of the waters for the nected with that remarkable passage people of Israel to pass over. The over the bed of the sea, we should be future lifting up of the rod is to have completely ignorant of the meaning a like conclusion, for as the rod was of the Psalmist’s word. “I will employed with a definite effect in the bring my people again from the one case, so it is to be in the future depths of the sea” would bemysterious one. It is to be lifted up after the language which we could not com manner of Egypt, and the result will prehend, and we should no doubt be be the same—for Israel will be re inventing some spiritual interpreta leased from their last oppressor— tion to explain it. But with the “ his yoke shall perish from off their historic narrative before us, with its shoulder.” vivid picture of the passing of that In the same verse in Isaiah from mighty host between the congealed which we have already quoted, we waters of the Red Sea, we are com are told that a slaughter, is to accom pelled to the conclusion, that the pany the other judgment upon the prophetic announcement in the Psalm Assyrian of the last day. This points to another event of a similar slaughter is described as being of the nature which is to occur in connec same character as one which is related tion with the same people at some in the historic record. It is stated period of their eventful history. that it will be “ according to the By this means we are also led to slaughter of Midian.” What do we know that this Red Sea passage has know respecting this slaughter of some relation typically with a future Midian ? It is obvious we can gather deliverance of Israel. no information regarding the special On this point we are not left to nature of this historic battle, from doubt. The Ilater prophets predict the scanty allusion in the prophecy. that another wonder the exact----- .------coun- we were unable f0 obtain any terpart of the passage through the knowledge concerning it from another Redt>„j Sea,o— yet_.x remains----- t ------to be accom. SoUrce, we 1 would’’ 'be 'incapable 11 of* plished. Tom quote all the testimony apprehending the full meaning of the would be needless, but we will direct prophet. We would have been in Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ April 1,1888. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 51 1 such a position if there had not been in consequence of the darkness, that in the sacred volume the book of the mutual slaughter will be induced, Judges. In this book however there and thus the enemies of Israel will is a full description of the slaughter be again defeated. There is abundant of the army of Midian in the past, evidence that this is to be exactly the and from this account we are able to fact. We learn this from the comprehend the nature of that des prophecies of the Old Testament. truction which is to overtake the Even Isaiah tells us concerning these Assyrian in the last days. The last times that “ through the wrath future event referred to by Isaiah, is of the Lord of hosts is the land declared to be “ according to the darkened and the people shall be as slaughter of Midian, then the cir fuel of fire, no man shall spare his cumstances which attended and in brother," Isa, ix. 10. In Ezekiel duced the historic defeat, must of thereJ-T. —. — — is— ... similar- * 1 testimony,l i* where1 necessity be repeated, or it could not are told that “ every man’s sword be said that the future is to be like shall be against his brother.” These the past. On turning to the seventh references are connected with that chapter of the book of Judges, we period denominated “ the day of the have the account of that remarkable Lord,” which day it is also declared engagement and slaughter. It is is a day of darkness and of gloominess, evident from the record that the a day of clouds and of thick darkness conflict took place in the night, and —and they shall lay hold every one consequently in the dark. The Jews on the hand of his neighbour, and his dividedtheir night into three watches, hand shall rise up against the hand and we are informed that Gideon of"e Khis’’" neighbour ” Joel. ii. 2. See proceeded to make the attack at the also Amosv. 18, 19, 20. From these middle watch, which continued from quotations the reference of Isaiah to 10 o’clock until 2, and this would in Midian is confirmed, and we are clude the hour of midnight. It thus led to know that, in the future, appears from a careful perusal of the there...... is to be the antitype of Gideon’s circumstances attending this conflict, conquest, so that the historic state which we have recorded in the Bible, ment in the book of Judges forms the that1 under the hand of God, it was details of a prophecy which yet remains the darkness which preventing the unfulfilled. Midianites from recognizing each In Isaiah xxviii. 21, we are also other, and each supposing that the taught in as brief a manner as in the person with whom he came in contact former examples, that “ The Lord was his enemy, caused “ every man will be wroth as in the valley of to set his sword against his fellow,” Gibeon.” In this instance again, if and by this means the whole army we were without the book of Joshua, was scattered, with little effort on we should be completely ignorant as the part of Israel. Such then is the to what was indicated by this re nature of events that are to occur mark. And here we have to rest again in the future, according to the exclusively upon the historic record testimony to which we have referred to discover what the events are, in Isaiah: there is to be in connection which will take place at the time with the last wars of Israel, an event about which the prophet is speaking. in which the characteristics of the The narrative of the battle of Midianitish defeat are to exist. On Gibeon is recorded in Joshua x. 10, that future occasion it will again be 11, as follows “ And the Lord dis- Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 52 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. April 1,1886. comfitted them before Israel, and slew In the whole of the instances which them with a great slaughter at Gibeon. we have quoted, it will be observed And it came to pass as they fled from that there are no details whatever before Israel, that the Lord cast down given concerning the prediction in great stones from heaven upon them the prophecy. These we can only unto Azekah.” Such then, as is de learn by reference to the history, we ( tailed in this quotation, is one method are then directed by the book itself by which God will effect the defeat to look to the historical events in in the future, and these circumstances, order to form a just estimate of what combined with others which we need they will be when repeated in the not now enter upon, will bring the future. We wish to impress this judgments which God has threathen- point particularly upon our readers’ ed against his enemies. If the Lord attention—that the history explains is again to rise up as in’ the valley the prophecy in all the examples to of Gibeon—and this is the only in which we have made reference. stance in which the enemies of Israel But what do we learn further from have been destroyed in that place— these remarks ? What is the chief it amounts to the most conclusive object in the prophecies of the future evidence that in the future incident being so intimately associated with which the prophet foretels, great the facts of the past? Are not all these stones shall fall from the heavens as proofs of a very decided nature, that they did at Gibeon. Here then we the occurrences of the future will be have another example of the manner as actual and real as those that are in which the future enemies of Israel historic? We must perceive in these shall be defeated and destroyed. The lessons the manner in which prophecy repetition of this historic event is, will be fulfilled. It will be “ like as moreover, corroborated by the pro it was ” in the former days and in phets, without making reference to the times of old. Are we then to the history. We are told in various refuse the teaching of God in these portions of the sacred volume that things or to believe it ? If he declares God will “ rain from heaven great that the events in the future are to hailstones, fire and brimstone.” Ez. be like those in the past, are we to xxxviii. 22 ; Ps. ii. 5 ; Rev. xiv. 21. deny it ? There are some persons who Numerous additional incidents will tell us that no doubt the history might be cited to the same effect. of the Old Testament was literal The days of Noah are given as the enough, but that the facts were description of the condition of things merely types to set forth a future at the second coming of the Lord. condition of events of a mystical, or The wilderness journey of Israel, and spiritual character ; and thus, that the pleading like as he pleaded with any prophetic allusions they may have the fathers, the miracles which at will have a mystical fulfilment. But tended their journey, and the entry is this correct 1 By no means. If into the land of promise—the giving the fulfilment is to be of a different of the law on Mount Sinai, &c., form nature from the historic accounts to a reason of which we might obtain which we have referred, then is it accurate pictures of the future ; and evident they are not to be “ like unto ” the fact that the prophets direct our or “ according to ” those that are attention to them, is doubtless one past; and we therefore cease forever object for their insertion in the to aim at understanding a prediction history of Israel. from the words in which it is re- Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ .1 April 1,1806. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 53 corded. No: God does not say one There is howeveranotherside to this thing and mean another. When he question. If the events in the future declares that the events shall be alike, are of a spiritual or mystical nature, it becomes our duty to believe his what becomes of those that are past word, and not to invent some plausi —they certainly must be mystical ble theory by which to build up also, for the events are declared to some spiritual or mystical antitype. be alike. So that if we fail to ad The antitypes will be as real and sub- mit the future reality, and literality stantialasthe types; just as Jesus was of these prophetic productions, we as real a man as Moses, and will be at transform the history into a fiction, his appearance on the earth again. and make the past and the future And as the antitypical sacrifices in the equally uncertain. future temple at Jerusalem shall be as actual as those under the Mosaic code. H. N. A PROVERB. Abraham had two sons, And every man’s hand against him. Ishmael and Isaac. Now we, brethren, As Isaac was, Isaac was a peaceable man, Are the children of promise. And would rather suffer wrong But as then, Than be contentious. He that was born after the flesh, Ishmael, his brother, Persecuted him that was born after Was of another disposition, the spirit, He was a wild man; ! Even so it is now. His hand was against every man, THE UNWRITTEN RUBRIC. In the acts of Christian worship and with the hand; and, indeed, it is service we conduct ourselves as if we reckoned most devout, even when only had a scriptural direction. The listening to a prayer to which we shall fashions of different places vary in give our Amen, that we keep our eyes some things, but in more are they down-cast or closed. Whence has similar. Now, when we have no this fashion originated 1 It is not a direction in the Scriptures, and no scriptural one; thus we read,—“Jesus precedent from the usage of the Bible lifted up his eyes to heaven and said; personages, and yet follow a uniform —and although we admit that the style, this style must be the result of expression of Isaiah is a figure of tradition. How venerable that tradi- speech—“Mine eyes fail with look tion may be it is difficult to determine, ing up,” yet it is a figure which but still it is not apostolic. derives its meaning from the pi-actice Thus in the act of prayer we uni- of looking up while praying. Tliis formly close our eyes, or cover them is manifest from such phrases as— Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 54 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. April 1,1868 “ Mine eyes are ever toward the our prayer be enhanced by open Lord,” Ps. xxv. 15; cxv. 1. 8. There instead of shut eyes 1 Does not God is presumptive evidence of this being delight in the beauty and goodness the uniform practice of Israel in the of those He has created, and will not act of prayer. Now, was it because He rejoice in His own handiwork ? of the strong feeling of reality in the Should not the brilliant eye of joy be object of their petitions ; or in a cer turned toward Him; should not the tain sensuousness in connection with longing eye, expectant of his answer, the place to which the prayer should lookupwards; should not the weeping be addressed ? Whichever it may be, eyes------gaze ...... through x------their tearsTT to“ Him we have as good reasons, Is our who dries the mourner’s tears, and faith not strong enough to give vivid gives promise of a time when He ness to the object we address, should shall wipe the tears from off all faces? - we not lift up our eyes to heaven as Even so: let the eyes be lifted, and the saints of old did? Or how much holy hands with them. These are is our spirituality aided by the intro- good reasons for the practice of. Christ vision we assume upon closing our and his apostles; for the holy eyes. Had it been the fashion in prophets and men of old, who feared ordinary religious society to pray God and called upon His name. with the eyes open, we would have For the other, the traditional practice fallen into that fashion, and never which we follow, they can render have missed the abstraction which we reasons who are its apologists. pretend to obtain by having them Again, in our observance of the shut. True, the practice of those Lord’s supper, we have some very who use a written liturgy is neccesarily uniform fashions, for which we have to pray with the eyes open. In not seen the reason, and cannot direct extemporaneous prayer, however, we to the tradition. The appointment do not remember to have seen any of that institution was that we should who did not shut their eyes. Now, “eat of that bread, and drink of that wLtt'ier are we right or wrong in cup.” It has been supposed that following this traditionary usage ? there is a rebuke of the Corinthians The eye of man is an organ which (in chap. xi. of 1. Ep.), “ because God has invested with great power, it they had made a common meal of it.” is the focus of many nervous and This is not the case—the evil was mental forces: and in our biological that it had not been a common meal, influence upon one another, or on the in the sense of all partaking of the lower animals, or even in the fascina same loaf, and drinking out of the tion of the lower animals themselves, same cup : in eating every one ate this is the medium by which the his------own supper— (ver.x __.21.)z But we vital influence is conveyed. The eye could hardly imagine how1------that11- .x abuse-quse of man in short is his noble point, could have crept in had the original In health it is bright, in disease it practice been such as we now have; is dull, in mental activity it is we_ only taste __ a --fragment o ____ of- ax piece of almost sparkling, while1XXO in111 idiocy1U1VVJ itXU isio jj bread,Uixail, and0,1X11 littleXXUUXV moreXllUXU thanIIJIXIX wetUVU ourVUl lustreless, and in death it hardly -, lips with wine. Is this eating of the shows the—- oghost~— of its former appear-1 bread (or loaf, more properly); is ance. The animated speaker enforces ij this drinking of the cup?cup ? Were it his eloquence by the eye, and kindles ’ not that we have a veneration for enthusiasm by the vividness of his our ovrn traditionary usage we would glance. WouldChurch not of Godthe Generalintensity Conference: of laugh at McDonough, it. But inGA; so saying we do Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ April 1,1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 55 not mean to go to the other extreme, there is laid on the table one biscuit; and fill ourselves with bread and and when the fragments of the feast wine. This could hardly have been are removed, two-thirds of it are left; possible even in primitive times ; for while the cup of wine has received when a large assembly sat down to scarcely a perceptible diminution. eat of one loaf, it could not fill all, And, again, why should there be any and when they drank of one cup, thing left at all, even though the loaf they would not be drunken with it. were a little larger, or the cup could We have, however, amongst ourselves, contain more? Now, I would like in our domestic and social usages, a to know the good end which is served practice which will suffice to direct by such infinitesimal partaking of us to the proper medium; we offer these, the materials of our feast in our visitors refreshment, and they, memory of the Lord. Or can any even when they are not hungry, one direct me to the apostolic rubric partake of a small portion—a biscuit, which has suggested the practice of or a piece of cake, and if they call at which we complain ? tea time, they need little pressing to In the meantime we leave these take one cup. Why is the case so things with the brethren, as samples different when we formally assemble of practices for which we neither find to eat the Lord’s supper? For a command nor precedent. company of twelve or more persons G. Dowie. THE GOSPEL OF THE KINGDOM OF GOD. I have long thought it is explained “ and saying ” is used not as introduc- in Mark i. 14, 15, to be the good ing something additional, but; as news that the Kingdom of God is at explanatory of what precedes it, just hand, “ Jesus came into Galilee as I have supposed it is used in Mark preaching the gospel of the Kingdom i. 14, 15. Here are some examples. of God, and saying, the time is ful “ Tempting him, and saying unto filled, and the Kingdom of God is at him, is it lawful for a man to put hand ; repent ye and believe the away his wife ? ” Matt. xix. 3, gospel.” “ Tempting him, and saying, Master But now a brother says, “ The which is the great commandment in question here is, is the intimation the law ?” Matt. xxii. 35, 36, “ Prais- and command in ver. 15 explanatory ing God, and saying, Glory to God of, or in addition to the preaching of in the highest.."” ILuke ”ii. 113, s “Cry ver. 14. If explanatory, the word ing out, and saying, Thou art Christ “and”must be omitted,thus, “preach the Son of God.” Luke iv. 41, “ I ing the gospel of the Kingdom of God heard a voice speaking unto me in saying, the time is fulfilled, and the the Hebrew tongue, and saying, Saul, Kingdom of God is at hand,” &c. Saul, why persecutest thou me.” In This is a point, therefore, which these cases the phrase “ and saying ” must be proved from some other is used as explaining what precedes source than this standard proof it, just as 1 have assumed it is used text. in Mark i. 14, 15. To this I answer, in the first place, In the second place, is there any that in other scriptures the phrase scripture where this phrase, standing Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 56 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. April 1, I860. as it does in the above scriptures, is “As touching the gospel they are used, as introducing something ad enemies.” But as a nation they did ditional, and not as explanatory of believe in the Kingdom of God. As what precedes it ? a nation they believed that all nations In the third place, Griesbach says shall be blessed in Abraham. As a that the word “ and ” in ver. 15 of nation they believed that the Christ Mark i. ought to be omitted. He should be raised up of the seed of also objects to the words “ the king- David~ ‘ to be God’s King_ on the holy dom” inverse 14. If Griesbach be hill’ ” of~ Zion, there to reign over all right, the passage should read thus, nations to the end of the earth, Jesus came into Galilee preaching These things they believed as anation, the gospel of God, saying, the time while as a nation they did not believe is fulfilled, and the Kingdom of God the gospel. is at hand, Ac. Now Griesbach is a One may ask, what then do you good authority. make of Gal. iii. 8 1 Does not Paul So, then, I still look upon Mark here define the gospel to be the bless- i. 14, 15, as a sure and clear proof ing• ofr* .all ii ..nations . j •____ in Abraham?4 1___ i. _ . n tPaul» j that the gospel preached by Jesus at says that this good message was first is the good news that the King- preached before to Abraham. That dom of God is at hand. This point is before he was circumcised, as in the is proved by this standard proof- parallel passage of Rom. iv. But the text. question is not, what is the good I am afraid that our brother takes message preached so long ago to up another position on this subject Abraham? but, what is the gospel ' contary to the scriptures. He holds oi' sood message which God hath in that “those Jews who rejected the these last days spoken unto us by his gospel did not believe in the King Son ? Is it not this, that the Kingdom dom.” I hold on the contrary that, of God is at hand ? while the Jews rejected the gospel of Where the gospel of the kingdom the kingdom, they were firm, cordial is preached to people who are ignor believers in the kingdom itself. ant of the kingdom it is of course That is, they believed, on the testi necessary to tell them what the king mony of Moses and the prophets, that dom is, as Paul at Athens showed the kingdom promised by God would them how that God had appointed a come, while they rejected the testi day iu which he would judge the mony of John, Jesus, and the apostles, world in righteousness by that man that it was at hand. whom he has ordained. When we Did the Jews not believe in the hear that the Kingdom of God is at kingdom of God 1 Why the little hand, it is natural to ask where then children believed in the coming of is the King ? and what is that right the Son of David to be king of Israel. eousness by which we may inherit What is the Kingdom of God ? Is it it? The answer is, Jesus is the Christ, not the promise that the Messiah and he died for our sins. It is thus should be raised to reign on God’s holy that the first truth of the gospel hill of Zion over Israel and all preached by Jesus that the King- nations ? And does not Paul say ! dom/Iawi ofrx-P God inis <->at 4- 1 handrl -f/xllcifalls illin QTinand “ unto which promise our twelve . becomes incorporated with thetrest. tribes instantly serving God day and i night hope to come.” The Jews as L a nation didChurch not believeof God General the gospel. Conference: 1 McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ April 1, 1808. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 57 THE PROXIMITY OF THE KINGDOM. J. Cl has, in page1 25 of the February’ Syria. Acts xviii. 14, And when Paul was number, maintained;d that, in Paul’s defence, now about to open his mouth.” Heb. viii. 5,1 Acte xvii, 31, there is no “ Pkoximity,”’ “ Moses was admonished of God when he wail but simply future “ Cebtainty’’. about to make the tabernacle.’’ Rev. x. 4,1 I have taken the liberty to request him to “And when the seven thunders uttered their take a second glance at the subject; and tell voices, I was about to write.” us whether or not the translation of King Will J. C. have the kindness to examine James is to be depended on in this case. the subjects more carefully with these facts The Diaglott runs thus, as nearly as I can before him, and give replies to the following recollect “ Because he has appointed a day questions,—First, Does the word in Acts xvii. in which he is about___ to vjudge the world. ’’ 31, translated “will” always denote “future The difference arises from the rendering of certainty.”? Second. Does it not always de- the word “ mello ’’ which the Diaglott trans- note nearness, or proximity ? Third, Will he lates“is about ” and which the authorized11 ’ name a word in all the Bible that denotes version renders “ will.’’ 1 call his attention closer proximity than this word Mello ? to the fact, that the translators of our English A. F. Bible did sometimes translate this “ mello ” in the same way as the Diaglott has it. John iv. 47, * “ For he was at the point of death.*' * I mark in italics the words which represent Acts xx. 3, “As he was about to sail into Mello. THE LITTLE HORN. Miracles. With as little diffusiveness as may be Turning to Revelation xiii. 13, we consistent with the topic about which find- ' the’ apostle■ - John- - saying,‘ _ oft the we write, we would direct attention dragonJ------speaking," 1” lamb - like v.beast, to miracles as a mark of the little named also in the xvi. 13, and xix, horn, or the man of sin, or the anti 20, “the false prophet,” that “he christ. doeth greatwonders (semeia megala),” The Apostle Paul, 2 Thess. ii. 9, or great signs, and “ deceiveth them says, his coming is, “ with all power that dwell on the earth by those (duname), and signs (semeiois), and miracles (semeia) which he had power lying wonders (terasi pseudous).” to do in the sight of the beast,” or Precisely the same words are used to antichrist. The testimony of the describe the miracles, done by the Christ concerning this period of time Christ. Acts ii. 22 (compare Heb. is, Matthew xxiv. 24 (compare Mark 11. 4), “ Jesus of Nazareth, a man xiii. 22), “ for there shall arise false approved of God among you, by christs and false prophets, and shall miracles (dunamesi), and wonders shew1 great signs (semeia: megala), andJ (terasi), and signs (semeiois), which wonders (terata).” God did by him in the midst of you.” It is certain, from the testimony And also of the apostles, 2. Cor. xii. of thes scriptures, that miracles, 12, “Truly the signs of an apostle "and 1 signs, and wonders, will be were wrought among you in all characteristic of the reign of anti patience, signs (semeiois), and christ. But'they will be pseudo, wonders (terasi), and mighty deeds false, or lying miracles. Real as to (dunamesi). appearance, but false as to origin. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 60 THE MESSEMGERMESSENGER OKOF THE CHURCHES. April 1,186j It is not recorded that they attempt- iliar spirits, had only made himself ed to perform, or rather, imitate, again an abomination to the Lord. any of the succeeding miracles. See And, it is impossible and improbable, also the statement concerning Simon that God should make laws against Magus, Acts viii. 9-24, and also of that which has not a positive exis Elymas the sorcerer, Acts xiii. 8-12. tence. The false prophet has “ power to It is true, that we, in these last give breath (pneuma) unto the image days, have not yet seen miracles of the beast, that the image of the done; and, it is equally true, that beast should both speak and cause for many years, in fact, since the age that as many as would not worship close to the apostles, miracles (do homage, pros kunesosi), should be have ceased. But cessation of mir Tailed.'’ It is an image of the beast, acles is the exception, and not the or the antichrist, which is caused to rule, during this lapse of time. No breathe and speak, and not the student of the scriptures will contra antichrist himself, for the simple dict our statement, when we say, reason, that the antichrist will be a that prophets, apostles, and the Lord living, breathing person before the himself, attested their right to their image is made. For the false pro position, by signs, and wonders, and phet, working miracles, sayeth, “ to mighty deeds. them that dwell on the earth, that It is still said, the devil is the' they should make an image to the antagonistic principle in man. The beast, which had the wound by a apostle Paul says, “ Forasmuch sword, and did live.” Which, it is then as the children are partakers obvious, is done. of flesh and blood, he (Jesus) also Is it said, impossible. Let us himself likewise took part of the turn to 1 Samuel xxviii., and, after same; that through death he might noting principal features, ask, which destroy him that had the power of we consider would be the greater death, that is, the devil (ton diabolou, impossibility, the statement in the the accuser).” The apostle John, preceding paragraph, or, that in the Rev. xii. 9, says, the dragon is the chapter we now refer to. Samuel accuser, and, 10 ver., “Now, is come is dead. Saul enquires of the Lord, salvation,—for the accuser of our but the Lord will not answer him, brethren is cast down, which accused “neither by dreams, nor by Urim, them before our God day and night." nor by prophets.” He then seeks a The accuser having previously been woman with a familiar spirit, whom cast out of the heaven into the he desires to bring up Samuel. earth. If the heaven mean the And, Samuel is brought up. It is higher powers on the earth; and not an apparition, but the man him the earth the inferior people or self. For, 15 ver., “Ami Samuel power, and the devil, the fleshy im said to Saul ” 16 ver., and “ Then pulses only, how can fleshly impulses said Samuel.” Do vapors, shadows, be cast out of the higher, to the or essences speak? By permission lower people ? Do not all men, ir of the Lord this coming of Samuel respective of degree, possess already, was allowed, and 19 ver., through carnal or fleshly impulses, desires, Samuel, his death and defeat on the and thoughts I The abandonment following day are announced. For, of these makes men more like unto see Lev. xx. 27, and Deut. xviii. Christ, it will be admitted. Will 9-14 ; Saul, by consulting with fam- then these higher dignitaries sud- Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ April 1,1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 61 denly become holy, and transfer first dwelling on the earth. But, their impurities to the common despite of the miracles, signs, and people 1 How can this possibly be, wonders, worked by his instrument for the apostle continues, 12 ver., ality, he, with his co-adjutors will “Woe to the inhabiters of the earth, meet with destruction at the hands and of the sea! for the devil (b dia- of him who is called “ Faithful and bolos) is come down to you, having True." great wrath, because he knoweth You will say, why do that he hath but a short time.” If itants of the earth have if' already present no where else but in reason of the wrath and' the fleshly thinkings of men, how of the evil one. “A could he come down at all from any received not the love ob other place ? that they might be saved^w There is no other conclusion to be this cause God shall send them*. drawn from the statements of scrip- delusion, that they should belli ture, than that there is an accuser Ee! that they all might be ca at present in the heaven as well as demned who believed not the truth, in the earth, who, through his mes but had pleasure in unrighteous^ sengers, constantly accuses and tries ness.” the disciples of Christ. He will be Let us therefore by earnest prayer cast out of the heaven, to have his unto our God, even the Father of sphere of operations limited to the our Lord Jesus Christ, endeavour to earth for a short time. During this become rooted and built up in Him, short time, forty-two months, he will the author of eternal Efe and salva energize the antichrist, work mir tion ; and be clothed with the whole acles by means of the false prophet, armour of God, that we may be and cause signs and wonders to be able to withstand in the evil day, and displayed before the dwellers on this having overcome all, to stand. Even earth; antichrist receiving at his in the Christ, whose house are we, hands power “ over all kindreds, if we hold fast the confidence and and tongues, and nations.” That rejoicing of the hope firm unto the power which' ’ the’ —Christ ■ - refused end. to receive at his hands, during his Christianos. LETTER FROM BIRMINGHAM. To the Editors of the Messenger of the Churches. 18 Edward St., Birmingham, But the real question at issue between the March 14th 1866. disciple and the sects, is not, what do we re Dear Brethren,—Pennit us to reply in a quite from them? But, what do they require few words to the criticism of M in the March from us? What do they cover under their Messenger. If the writer of it will look at assumed names? Are they willing to throw the context of the quoted sentence, he will off those things which their names cover, see that a sound reason is given for our state- i that are contrary to the Word of God, and went. “ Partizan names are always to be 1 commence with the first principles of the fowid identified with partizan teaching." faith ? Certainly, the vital queston is, do you i For an instance of what we would wish to believe “ the things concerning the kingdom be understood by our statements, let us take of God, and the name of Jesus Christ; and the first, because the most recent of the sects have you obeyed His requirements.” named by the brother “M.” In order to be Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 62 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. April 1,18?6, a “ cbristadelphian,” what are we required Noth by Editors.—It has been suggested to believe ? that the propriety of the appearance of the 1. “ The things concerning the Kingdom name of H, Brittain in these pages, and par- of God, and the name of Jesus Christ.” ticulary in the above capacity may be quest 2 “ That Jesus of Nazareth is the King ioned by some who have been unfavourably raised up to sit on David’s throne, &c,—not impressed regarding him through certain pub therefore the king in the ordinary sense in lished statements. We therefore give onr which a king is the head of a human authority for his brotherhood.—In the Mess dominion, but the root and cause, and main enger of MsLy 1864.—Is the following state spring of the whole matter, and therefore ment :—“ we have been compelled to put in comprehensively spoken o f as “ the kingdom force the discipline of the church against of our father David,'" (Mark xi. 10), which brother H. Brittain, as he is living contary to in him came nigh “ 1800 years ago, not for the faith and practice of the gospel of the development, but for offer by proclamation kingdom.”—W. J. B. Of which this inter as an individual inheritance.” pretation is given in June.—“In sending 3. That “ Human nature is the devil.” that communication to the Messenger of 4. That, “ It is obvious that we misunder May last, as secretary of the church, 1 had no stand the mission of Christ if we misunder intention of charging Henry Brittain with stand the devil ; and hence a scriptural immoral conduct, as no such charge was understanding of the doctrine of the devil is brought against him at the church meeting, essential to unity in the faith, andfellowship. but simply to make known the fact that he The doctrine of the devil is in fact one of the was no longer with us ; having been cut off first principles of the doctrine of Christ.” from our communion for pursuing a course we, 5- That days in prophetic utterance are as a community, could not approve.”—W. J, “equivalent” to years. Bailey. Unasked, we have since received Whosoever believeth all these things is of the following testimony “ Allhough brother the “cbristadelphian ” faith. We, knowing Brittain was excluded from the Christa ALL IS VANITY. Earth’s’pleasures adieu 1 But shadows they are, and but shimmering No longer my soul shall be fettered by you ! glass, The burdens so heavy ye laid on my heart, But perishing vessels, and bubbles that pas, I spurn, and 1 bid them for ever depart 1 Foul figures in tinsel embroidery drest, I tear myself free, for I see in their quest, Vain glory at best. Vain glory at best. Say, what are my rears, Say, what shall I call As each after each,A !..in the past disappears?J y The things which the wordling deems fairest Say, what are rmy care, and my labour and of all! Church of God General Conference:pain, McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ fcs. April 1, 1836. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 63 My sorrow, my gladness, the dreams of my I A phantom that springs into life for an hour, brain, And fades when the breath of the tempest Say. .what are my toiling and moiling has power, distressed ? Once seen in the sunshine, then darkly Vain glory at best. suppressed, Vain glory at best. 0, riches and gold ! Earth’s idol compounded of glistering mould ? O, friendship aud truth ! Of worldly delusions both brightest and worst, Forgetting so oft the devotion of youth ! Increasing, decreasing, seductive (accursed— Yexv beautifulucuuuiui traitors,uiuwn, withwim smilessumes on youryoui lips, How wretched the slave who obeys your Desertingt il.the - spirit------x —in sorrow-8_ _ V ’s eclipse, ; behest, m Too” sadly* I name you, from many a test, Vain glory at best. Vain glory at best. O, honour, what are 0, carnal delight! Thy crowns and thy garlands that glitter so So loathsome within, yet so outwardly bright! fair ? The gleam of thy visage, the charm of thy The demons of envy are close at my back, spell To tarnish thy jewels, thy footsteps to track, Are changed in the end, to the torments of With downfall to lower the pride of thy crest, hell! Vain glory at best. Though golden thy cup, its contents are con fess’d 0, favour and grace ! Vain glory at best. How speedy your rise, and how fleeting your race ! From the Danish of Bishop Kingo, 1670. Intelligence, Notes, &c- Crossgates—Another addition has be»n and kept aloof from their assembly. The made______to the number of ___the brethren here,... in attendance at the ordinary meetings of the the person of Thomas Cunningham (miner), church has been good, and the general aspect son of" John’ '___ Cunningham," ‘____ ’______who having’ madeof the church is to all appearance healthy. tte good confession, was immersed into The winter series of lectures is now closed, • Christ on 11th March. Also, two persons fourteen in all having been delivered. who had withdrawn have returned to fellow ship. The brethren have now removed to a At the suggestion of some who desire to right place of meeting, having hired a room, see it, we append the programme of the social and fitted it up for their own use. The meeting:—Programme—Sunday, March 25, church, though now numbering only seven 1866. J. Lawrie will see to the programme persons, is in perhaps a better condition than being carried out. Part I.— Anthem, ‘God ever. We desire for them, above all things, be merciful unto us ’ Thanksgiving and that they, being firmly knit together in Prayer, J. Davidson. Service of Sandwiches, love, and abounding in every good work, may Tea, Cake, &c. Anthem, ‘ Blessed be God.’ grow up into the likeness of Christ, and be Collection to defray expenses. Thirteenth ready for his appearing. annual report by the secretary, G. Dowie. Edinburgh.—On 12 th March, George Thirteenth Annual Report by the Treasurer, Shaw (railway porter), by his own desire, J. Cameron. The Sunday Morning Class, W. was immersed into the name of the Lord, in Norrie. ^Observations upon the Reports. order to the remission of sins, and bearing Anthem, ‘ 0 praise the Lord.’ Address, that name, in which alone is life : forthwith 1 Our mutual relations aud responsibilities,’ he was numbered with the saints. On W. Laing.„ Anthem,... ‘ Be patient, brethren.’ Sunday, March 25, the brethren held their j Interval of a quarter of an hour. Part II.— tillVthirteenth’fazar»fl» ormianniversary, oAroortr celebratingv»r» ifit Odas iloilolusual RarvtDOService aofF C.filrAcake andUTtfl fruit. Anthem, HOW ty fl fA/violsocial moal'nremeeting invn thefKa afternoon;aftamAAn • atof , beautiful ntVlnupon tllAthe TYIAimf'JllTl.Clmountains. *’ IGeneral which were delivered a report of«r the-k,. past...... t conversation—‘The best method of dealing year, with addresses and conversations on with applicants for baptism or for fellowship. many excellent topics. The report shews The subject to be introduced by J Cameron. oj the present number to be 5^ having had ten Anthem, ‘ Thou wilt perform.’ Narrative, additions during the year, two removals, and ‘ Bethsaida Common,’ G. Dowie. Anthem, one death —that of David Wilson, a youug • Pray for the peace of Jerusalem ’ Sanctus, brother who died at Cupar on March 1st of No. 4,, ‘Holy, holy, holy.’__ Prayer______and this year—for a long time previous however thanksgiving, W. Wilson. The brethren he had alienated himself from the brethren and sisters will assemble at half past two. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 64 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 1,1866. Mumbles.—On Sunday, March 18th, Mrs Publications. Lloyd, Richard Gee, and William Michael, were immersed in the name of the Lord THE DISCIPLES’ CHORAL SERVICE Jesus, and afterwards received into fellowship OF BIBLE THEMES, with the chnrch here. We earnestly hope A collection of Christian Songs,—the that both they and we may so live as to be subjects selected from the Holy Scrip accounted worthy of an abundant entrance tures, and set to suitable music (in both into the everlasting kingdom of our blessed' notations), arranged for four voices. Thia Saviour Jesus Christ. book, got up expressly for the use of the brethren in their social services, and suitable either for the church or the fireside, Tranent.—Brother George Kerr, from the Is now reduced in price. village of Elphinstone, in this neighbourhood, One Shilling in a neat printed cover; One is about to sail for Nova Scotia, where he and Sixpence cloth boards, post free. May hopes to be able to prosecute his business as be had of G. Dowie, 88 Nicolson Street, a miner, to greater advantage than at home. Edinburgh. We cordially commend him to the brethren in Halifax or elsewhere. Also may be had of G. Dowie, The Messenger of the Churches, Turriff—Our lectures were well attended First Series, for 1861, 1862, 1863, 1864; in by a most respectable and attentive audience, single volumes, sewed, Is.; or the four to- We shall begin another course as soon as gether,11 in cloth,l r,‘ 1lettered, 4s. 6d. mThe' two health will permit. On the 4th of March, first Nos. of the vol. for I860 are out of print, James Boyd (tailor), havingig made the good but a few copies of the others are still on confession, was baptized; amid having’ „ thus .put hand, and may be had at Id. each. Postage on the Lord, was received into the church by in all cases extra—for single vols., 2d.; for the right hand of fellowship. He stayed a the cloth vols., 6d. week with us, and unexpectedly left for As it is inconvenient to keep up stock so Aberdeen in search of employment. Since long, it is desired of those wishing to procure then our brother and sister Harvey have also any back numbers or volumes of the Messen- , left; the former going to Aberdeen, the latter ger, 1st Series, to apply before April 15th, as\ to her father’s, for the recruiting of her health. at that time the whole remainder will be dis We hope that our loss will be their gain. posed of some other way. The following may be had from W. Norrie, 9 Ingliston Street, Edinburgh. The Letter from Halifax, N. S., has been The Destiny of the British Empire duly received, and forwarded to the person Revealed in the Scriptures. Price fid. who issued the pamphlet in question; with The Contrast between Protestantism which pamphlet we are not in the least degree and the Gospel ; 36 pp- 8vo, 6d. identified: having really as little connection What is the Gospel? 4 pp. 12mo, Is 6dper with it as brother Lithgow himself hundred. The Kingdom of God. 1 page, 8vo, Is. per The Treasurer acknowledges receipts for hundred. the Messenger from Birmingham, Cupar, The Gospel Witness. 16pp. 8vo, complete Leeds, and Scarborourgh, Halifax, Wishaw. in 12 Nos. at 2d. each. Single Nos. On and after May 25th, the address of G- (except No. 5) may be had to complete sets. Dowie will be as formerly, 12 Beaumont Saving Faith. 20 pp. 8vo. Id. Place. 1 The Bible. 8 pp. 12mo, 2s 6d per hundred. The Messenger is Registered for Transmission Abroad. Articles should be sent in by the 15th of the month, and items of intelligence not later than the 24th ; all papers meant for insertion, or notes of intelligence, may be forwarded to George Dowie, 88 Nicolson Street; and all business communications to James Cameron, 12 Calton Hill, Edinburgh, to whom money orders should be made payable. AND W. R WILSON, PRINTERS, HIGH STREET, EDINBURGH. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. ♦ “ I SPEAK AS TO WISE MEN, JUDGE YE WHAT I SAY." No. 5. May 1, 1866. New Series. Vol. II. CALVARY AND ZION. Sacred places indeed. Bible places, ing that Jesus died for our sins, that Places never to be forgotten. Places he is the lamb of God who beareth never to be remembered but with away the sin of the world, that the tears of gratitude and songs of joy. good shepherd laid down his life for Places which remind us always that the sheep. Jesus is the Christ, and that he, the To preach or believe in Calvary Christ, died for our sins. and Zion is to preach and believe in Christ died for our sins in the the Cross. I mean in the cross of place called Calvary. Christ will the Bible: in the true cross. On reign over all nations on the mount that cross you see Jesus wounded, called Zion. These two places are pierced, nailed to the tree, bleeding, represented by these two words Christ fainting, dying, dead, And then crucified. CChrist anointed : why above his head you read, this is Jesus anointed ? To be God’s King on his the king of the Jews. And so Cal holy hill of Zion. Crucified. Why vary itself, you see, points you forward crucified ? To put away our sins by to Zion. the sacrifice of himself. That Jesus died for our sins in To preach Calvary and Zion is to Calvary is a great Bible and gospel preach the two great truths of the truth. That Jesus will reign on gospel. Preaching Zion is preaching mount Zion is also a great Bible and that Jesus is the Christ, that he is gospel truth. Faith in the one is as the king of the Jews, that he is the essential to salvation as faith in the lion of the tribe of Judah, that he other. This is saving faith to believe is the great shepherd of the sheep—of with all1 our hearts and souls that the ancient fold of Israel; of other Christ™ ‘ died’’ for our sins in the place sheep who being gathered out of called Calvary. And this is saving many other folds are to be brought faith to believe with all the joy of into that ancient fold of Israel. And, our hearts and souls that he is com- besides that, ultimately of every fold ing to reign on Zion. In other or flock of sheep that shall be any words, it is saving faith to believe where in all the world, this is Zion, both that Jesus is the Christ, and Christ on Zion. that the Christ died for our shis, And preaching Calvary is preach- that he is the lamb of God, and the Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 66 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. May 1,1’Gfr lion of the tribe of Judah; that he is for his Son from heaven, whom he the great shepherd who laid down raised from the dead. Just you his life for the sheep. compare this for a moment with the He who knows these things will second psalm. What do you see in see Calvary and Zion in many scrip- that psalm, That the Lord’s Christ tures wherein another would not see is to "be his king on the holy hill of them. As for instance in Bev. i. 5, Zion. That to this end he is begotten 8, “Unto him who loved us and the Son of God, from the dead. That ' washed us from our sins in his own therefore we. should' be wise, serve blood.” There I see Calvary. “ And God with fear, and join trembling hath made us kings and priests unto with our mirth; and kiss the Son God and his Father; to him be glory lest we perish from the way, when and dominion forever and ever. his wrath is kindled in a little while. Amen.” There I see Zion. It is on I see both Calvary and Zion in • Zion that the Son of man shall reign many scriptures where they are not over all nations. There he shall re named. But I will only mention ceive the kingdom, and the dominion, one other example. Gal. i. 4. 5. and the glory, that all people, nations, Who gave himself for our sins that and languages may serve him. And he might deliver us from this present there, as washed in his blood, we shall evil age, according to the will of God, reign with him on and over the and our Father ; to whom be glory earth. For “ behold he cometh with forever and ever. Amen. Our Lord clouds and every eye shall see him, Jesus Christ gave himself for our sins. they also who pierced him ; and all There is Calvary. It was on Calvary families of the earth shall wail be that he gave himself for our sins. cause of him. Amen.” So be it, and That he might deliver us from this soon may he come. present evil age. Because his king Again I see Calvary and Zion in dom is not of this world. This evil 1. Thess. i. 9, 10. “ And how ye age will come to an end. It will be turned to. God from your idols to succeeded by another blessed, and serve the living and true God, and wise, and righteous age. Then in to wait for bis Son from heaven, the regeneration the Son of man will whom he raised from the dead ; even come and sit upon his glorious throne, Jesus who delivered us from the and make all things new, and judge wrath to come.” Here is Calvary. the twelve tribes of Israel. And Jesus rose from the dead. Therefore there you may see mount Zion. he died. He died in the place called Now cursed is he who keeps back Calvary. And when he died there half of the truth. he delivered us from the wrath to That Christ died on Calvary is come; for he died for our sins. just half the truth. Separated from Died that onr sins might be all for the other half, that he is coming to given. And there is no wrath to reign on Zion, it is another gospel come to him .who has remission of than that preached by our Lord and sins. And here is Zion. To serve his apostles. the living and true God, and to wait D. L. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ M*y 1,1898. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 67 THE LITTLE HORN. Duration. The duration of the power of the tion from astronomy, we shall as> little horn, as regards the covenant, attention to prophetical times already is said by Daniel, ix. 27, to be fulfilled, and see what foundations for one heptade, or seven years. For there is in scripture, and history, for one half of this heptade, Dan. ix. this prophetic time. 27 ; or, for a time, times, and the We would have preferred taking dividing of time, Dan. vii. 25 ; the scriptures first, but, as we are or, for a time, times, and a half, Dan. not aware that past fulfilments of xii. 7 ; or, for forty-two months, prophetical times have met with Rev. xiii. 5 ; this little horn is to any fulfilment but natural ones, or, hold tho saints in complete sub that any allegation is made to the jugation ; killing also whom he contrary, we are constrained to begin will. This™---'-x-x forty-two------monthsa. being with the astronomical question first. also generally admitted to be equal'In astronomical works we meet to the twelve hundred and sixty with the terms lunar time, solar days of Rev. xi. 3, and Rev. xii. time, sidereal time. A lunar day, 6. It will have doubtless been a solar day, and a sidereal day, so to noted, that we accept the statement speak, are all of equal length, name of the scriptures literally, days to us ly, twenty-four hours. But lunar meaning days, naturally; years, and solar time, regulated by sidereal natural years, and so on But one time, both vary when we pass from of the most common and prevailing days to months, and from months to teachings concerning these periods, years, assuming twelve months equal is that they are not to be measured to a year. It is into the cause of by our usual standard of time, but this difference we have to inquire, by another standard, named pro for therein, if there he any, must be phetic time. In prophetic time, a found the foundation. natural day represents a prophetic First, then, as to lunar time, re year ; a natural year, 360 prophetic gulated by the moon, “ the faithful years; and in a similar manner, witness in heaven.” It is well other sub-divisions of natural years, known that the moon revolves round represent corresponding prophetic the earth. Let us suppose that we sub-divisions. were present when the moon ’com But why does a natural year re menced its first revolution, noting, present 360 prophetic years ? From by means of some fixed star or con whence is 360 derived? In answer, stellation, its startingpoint, in relation we are informed that time, prophetic to the sun and the earth. Now, we ally, is regulated by lunar time, and should imagine that as soon as one not solar. After all, then it appears revolution was complete, precisely that a professed natural, yet repre the same position would be occupied sentative basis, is the foundation foi- by her between the sun and earth, obtaining this prophetic time. The as when she started. But this.is not question then, for us to ask, is, is the case. The earth having also this foundation substantial 1 After journeyed on in its orbit, has carried seeking for an answer to this ques the moon with it, so causing a change Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 68 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. Mayl,i85«. of position in relation to the sun. Again, it is well known, that the Now the time occupied by the moon earth revolves on its own axis. Let in revolving round the earth, is 27 us suppose a spectator at any given days, 7 hours, 43 minutes, 11 ‘5 secs. place on the earth’s surface, noting at This being also the time occupied in mid-day the precise point in the returning to its position in relation heavens occupied by the sun, opposite to a fixed star or constellation, or its to himself. He would at once, infer sidereal time. But the time occupied that precisely at mid-day on the ■ in returning to its first position be following day after one revolution, tween the earth and the sun is 29 he would come opposite to the sun days, 12 hours, 44 minutes, 2-87 sec. at the same point in the heavens. This period being named a lunar But he would soon find out that this month, lunation, or a synodic period. would not be the case. The length Twelve of the former are equal to of the day reckoned by the sun would 327 days, 22 hours, 38 minutes, 18 be sometimes longer, at other times secs.; and twelve of these latter, to shorter, than at first, that is, solar 354 days, 8 hours, 48 minutes, 34'44 days are of unequal lengths. But if secs. Thirteen of the former exceed the mean or average of all the solar ing the lunar year by only 21 hours, days be taken in the year, a mean 32 minutes, 55'06 secs. Also, the solar day will be obtained consisting mean of the former, or so to speak, of“ twenty-four’ “ 1 hours.• 'TNow,— itis sidereal year, and the lunar year, by the number of mean solar days, being equal to 341 days, 3 hours, 43 that the time occupied by the moon’s minutes, 2-7*22 secs. The. prophetic revolution round the earth, and of time, then, finds no support for its the earth round the sun, that their 360 days here. revolutions are computed. We have now to turn to the earth. The moon, in conjunction with The time in which the eai-th com the earth, revolves round the sun in pletes a revolution round the sun, •365 days, 5 hours, 48 inutes, 49'7 having relation to a fixed point secs. The moon round the earth, among the stars, that is to say, its fulfils in the same period, 12 luna sidereal time, is equal to 365 days, tions, lunar months, or synodic 6 hours, 9 minutes, 9'6 secs. But, periods and 10 days, 21 hours, 0 the real or tropical year is 365 days, minutes, 15'26 secs., of the thirteenth 5 hours, 9 minutes, 49'7 secs. What lunation, so that an equal number is the cause of this difference 1 It is of lunations do not represent the well known that the apparent pass solar year. Endeavouring to obtain age of the sun across the equinox 360 days, the mean or average of determines the seasons. But the: twelve lunations of the moon, and equinox, participating in a slow the time of the earth’s revolution movement of the earth’s axis, meets, round the sun, has been taken,' But as it were, the sun approaching it, even this11 ’ only1 equals1 "359rn days, 19 before the sidereal circuit is com hours, 18 minutes, 42'07 sees. In pleted. The space of time thus spite of ingenious attempts, we are gained by the earth is equal to 20 compelled, on the strength of astrono minutes, 19-9 secs. ; which, if de mical calculations, which acknowledge ducted from the sidereal year, will no such mean or average, to look give the real, or tropical year, and upon the 360 days as a.delusion, a also the solar year, This then is mockery, and a snare. equal to 360Church days. of God General Conference:Let McDonough,us now turn GA; to fulfilled scrip- Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ M»y 1, isos. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. J ture prophecies, and see what kind of senting 360 prophetic years be time is observed, natural or pseudo- applied” 1 with‘ 1 safety” ' Jto these pro natural. phecies ? As they cannot, why, con trary to revelation and nature, apply Days them to unfulfilled prophetic times I Gen. vii. 4, the deluge to be forty The one exception we allude to, days and forty nights. being the seven months’ burial Will Gen. xl. 13, 19, dreams of butlei’ those who contended for these 360 and baker to be fulfilled in three day-years stand by their dogma days. when we apply it to this unfulfilled Jonah iii. 4, Nineveh to be over period ? The house of Israel to be thrown in forty days. 210 years burying the slain ! We Matt. xii. 40, Jesus to be three “speak as to wise men, judge ye days and three nights in the heart of we^y? the earth. —We -have purposely refrained from Luke ix. 22, the Son of man to noticing Number's xiv. 34. “After be raised the third day. the number of the days in which ye John ii. 19, “ Destroy this temple searched the land, forty days, (each and in three days I will raise it up.” day for a year,) shall ye bear your Kev. ii. 10, “Ye shall have tribula inquities, forty years.” And, Ezekiel tion ten days.” iv. 5, 6. “ For I have, laid upon Months :— thee the years of their iniquity, Ezek. xxxix. 12, the house of according to the number of the days, Israel to be seven months burying t}lree hundred and ninety days i so the slain. shalt thou bear the iniquity of the Times :— house of Israel. And when thou Dan. iv. 16, 23, 34, seven times hast accomplished them, lie again or to pass over Nebuchadnezzar. thy right side, and thou shalt beai Years :— the iniquity of the house of Judah Gen. xv. 13, the Israelites to be forty days. I have appointed the< afflicted four hundred years. cavileach uajday, for a jcai.year. ” (luaigiU)(Margin, “ a Gen. xli. 29, seven years of plenty, day for a year, a day for a year.”) and seven years of famine. The— days... of search, as well as the 1 Kings xvii. 1 ; Luke iv. 25, no days in which Ezekiel lay on eithei rain or dew for three years and six side, were natural days. The forty months. years in both instances and the three - Kings viii. 1, seven years famine hundred and ninety years also> were upon the land. fulfilled- — - in natural years. Yes, it Isaiah xxxviii. 5, fifteen years to will be said, proving conclusively be added to Hezekiah’s life. that a day does mean a year in pro- Jer. xxix. 10 j Dan. ix... 2,~ seventy p}lcCy. several things have to be years’ captivity in Babylon.“n . noted before such conclusion can be Jer. xxviii. 16, Hananiah to die drawn. In neither passage, does it “ this year.” state, that a day is equal to a year. Other instances could be given, But, it is after the number of the but we apprehend that these will be days,” “ according to the number of sufficient for the scripture student. the days.” The days were represent Were not all the periods named ful- ative of the years in these instances, filled, (save one) in literal years ? but this does not prove that the days Can the rule of a natural year repre- are equal to years because they were Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 70 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. May 1,1856. representative. And note well, that must be equal to 354 natural years, the days in both instances were not others to 383. Again we urge upon prophetic days, but natural days; the reader, whether this day equalling consequently, could not be equal to a year theory, does not completely years at all. But the years in both refute itself? instances were prophetic years, so What is the testimony of history that, if a day were equal to a year,- concerning the commencement, &c., then each of these prophetic years of the assumed 1260 years ? The would be equal to as many natural following historical testimonies, in years, as there are days in a natural answer, are submitted to the year. attentive consideration of the reader. We have shown that there is no The first record of the decree of such a year known, in astronomical Phocas, which is said to have con or chronological periods, equal to 360 ferred the title ‘ head of all the days. . If a day equals a year, pro churches,’ on the Bishop of Borne, is phetically, then a prophetical year in the year a d. 780, one hundred, must be equal to 365 natural years and seventy-four years, after the year for three times in succession, and 606, in which it is said to have been every fourth time, be equal to 366. given. This record was made by Why so? Because 365 days are Paul the deacon. reckoned for every three years, and Between the period 606-608, the 366 for the fourth or leap year. In following empires or kingdoms ex the face of these plain truths, how isted : — Lombardy, Spain, three Jis it‘ 1 ______possible*1 1 . J.to *1believe _ 1? )1_1that _a .1day in kingdoms in France, six in England, scripture means anything else than a the eastern, empire, and the Persian day, a year, and so on ? empire. It will be said, that the Jewish The first Pope, whose tiara was year was measured by lunations. It ornamented with a triple crown (said is true that 12 synodical months to prove that the Pope subdued usually composed the Jewish year three kingdoms), was Boniface IX., The months were alternately 29 and in a d. 1389, nearly 800 years after 30 days in length. But, in order 606. to keep the Jewish festivals in their Louis I., Emperor of Germany, proper seasons, it was found absolute in a.d. 815, exacted an apology from ly necessary to add a thirteenth Leo III., Bishop of Borne, for having month, lunation, or synodical period, exercised civil judicial power in to the usual year ; generally, every Rome. three years, and sometimes, at the In a.d. 1061, Harold’s brother, end of two years from last added Tostig,xosug, martEarl uiof numiuuiuenium,Northumberland, thirteenth month. This added month accompanied Aldred, Archbishop of was Ve-Adar. There is therefore, no York, to Bome, and compelled the proof here that 360 days were re Pope to confirm his appointment to garded equal to a year by the Jews ; the see of York, by threatening to stop and it is on twox — prophecies,i--:— which the payment of Peter's pence. affected the Jews only, and fulfilled In a.d. 1234 Gregory IX. was concerning them only, that we are driven from Bome by the senate and asked to believe that a day is equal ] citizens, who resisted his temporal to a year; if it is so, then these pro . power, and seized his revenues. phetic years must be reckoned in j In a.d. 1296, a papal bull was J ewish time. Some prophetic years issued forbidding ecclesiastics to pay Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ May 1, ISM. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES, 71 taxes imposed by temporal princes. What saith the scripture as to the The kings of England and France duration of the little horn’s suprem resisted this bull. The first, by acy over the saints. The saints shall placing out of the protection of the be given into his hand until a time law those who refused; and the and times, and the dividing of time. second, by stopping the export of Power was given him to make war money from his dominions. forty-two months, and it was given Such historical evidence as this him to make war with the saints, and might easily be accumulated. Need to overcome them. Yea, Lord, thy we say more 1 Is not the testimony word is truth! of astronomy, history, and chrono logy utterly at variance with the Christianos. year-day dogma ? JESUS CHRIST AND HIM CRUCIFIED. 1 Cor. ii. 1, 2. Concluded from Page 37. These are the two things Pauli the earth. This is believing that determined to know among the Cor- \ Jesus is the Christ according to such inthians for their salvation, Jesus... as. scriptures,.. . as 1 Sam. ii. 10, and Ps. the Christ, and Jesus crucified, ii., &c. And as there are scriptures which ___And to believe that Christ died prove that we are saved by believing foroursins according tothe scriptures, that Jesus is the Christ, such as 11 is to believe that he died not merely John v. 1 ; Gal. iii. 26; John viii. that our sins might be forgiven, but 24 ; and’ John’’ xx. 31o. : so. there ---- are j'- also,1-* •thatLl--X we— being washed----- 1 ,x from’ -lour scriptures which as cclearly1— 7prove------■v sins’ ~ K1in— his— blood,‘~1-A might be —made that we are saved by believing in kings and priests unto God, and him” as crucified, such as Rom. iii. reign with him------onn the------earth over alln 25, and 1 Cor. xv. 1-4. nations, when he cometh with clouds From this last scripture, we learn ] and every eye shallT see him. This 'that one of the first 1things’ ’ of” the” 1 is’ ’believing ’ " _ that ™Christ died for our gospel is, how that ChristJhrist died for ' sins according to such scripturessorintures i as our sins; that we are saved by be Rev. 1-7, and v, 9, 10. But, doubt lieving the gospel; and that there is less Paul refers to the ancient holy such a thing as believing the gospel scriptures, such as, Ps. xl., xxii., Is. in vain. We believe the gospel in liii, &c. Therefore, let us see in the vain if we believe without know first place how Christ died for our ledge. To be saved, we must believe sins according to these scriptures. that Jesus is the Christ, and that he According to Ps. xxii., Christ was died for our sins according to the to die the death of the cross, as it is scriptures. written, “ They pierced my hands Now, to believe that Jesus is the and my feet.” And ,the fact that Christ according to the scriptures, is Christ was crucified, is very closely to believe that God has anointed connected with the fact that, he died him to be his king upon his holy hill for our sins, even as Paid observes of Zion, there to reign over Israel, in Gal. iii., that “■ as many as are of and over all nations to the ends of the works of the law are under the Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 72 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. Mayl.lSM. curse; for it is written, Cursed is shall reign over all nations with every one that continueth not in all Christ when he comes and appears things which are written in the in his glory. This is believing that book of the law to do them.” That Christ died for our sins according to is, we are all cursed. No one has the scriptures. And unless we believe continued in all things which are he died for our sins according to the written in the book of the law to do scriptures, we believe that Christ them. But, behold, “ Christ hath died for our sins in vain. Some redeemed us from the curse of the believe that Christ died for our sins law, being made a curse for us; for in order that we might reign with it is written, Cursed is every one that him in kingdoms beyond the skies. hangeth on a tree.” This is believing that Christ died for It is well to notice both what is, our sins in vain; for it is not believ and what is not written. It is ing that Christ died for our sins written, Cursed is every one that according to the scriptures. To hangeth on a tree. It is not written, believe that Christ died for our sins Cursed is every one who is slain by according to the scriptures is to the sword. Why 1 Because the believe that he died to the end that scriptures foreseeing that Christ we might realize all the exceeding should die for our sins, and that his great aud precious promises which death should be the death of the God has given to his people in all cross, preached the gospel before ages. That the creature itself may unto the Jews, saying, Cursed is be delivered from the bondage of every one that hangeth on a tree. corruption; that he who scattered Christ died for our sins, accord- Israel may. wgather them, and keep ing to Is. liii. In consequence of them as a shepherd doth his flock; his dying for Israel and all nations, that the tabernacle of God may be he is made king of Israel and of all planted among men, and the nations nations. He was wounded for our of them that are saved may walk in transgressions, &c. Therefore will the light of it; that all nations may. I divide him a portion with the be blessed in Abraham and in his great, &c. How wise, and holy, and seed; that every good thing which just, is this. That he who died for God hath spoken may come into ex all, should be the king over all. istence and stand forever. That is One might have died for all, and believing how that Christ died for another might have been king over our sins according to the scriptures. all. But how much better that he We are often twitted with 1 Cor. who gave his life for the sheep should xv. 1-4, as though it was against be the great shepherd of the sheep. salvation by faith in the things con It is Christ that died. cerning the kingdom of God. I But Christ died for our sins accord have tried to show how we may turn ing to such a scripture as Rev. v. 9, the tables upon those gainsayers, and 10. Thou wast slain and hast re beat them w'ith their own chosen deemed us to God by thy blood out weapon. It will be well for them if of every kindred and tongue, and they be put to silence for their own people and nation; and hast made true and everlasting welfare. May us to our God kings and priests, and God add his effectual blessing. we shall reign over the earth. We D. L. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ May 1,18M. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 73 THE WITCH OF ENDOR. In an article on Miracles in The principally to the second view, as Messenger, for last month, the writer they, along with our reasons for the (page 66) makes such allusion to the third view, if correct, will also serve incident of the King of Israel con as sufficient ground for rejecting the sulting the woman who had “ aii first; and because the second view familiar spirit,” as to suggest the ii seems more worthy of attention, as idea of requesting a ['place— in these— >i we believe that it is “ God, who pages, for a statement of the results I raiseth the dead ” ; and if Samuel of a careful examination of the j rose at all, it was Jehovah, not the narative, in the 28th chapter of 1st | Adversary, who brought him to life. Samuel. There are three opinions ■ Will the reader then notice, in the which we have seen stated regarding first place, that God had expressly the remarkable incidents connected forbidden his people to resort to such with Saul’s visit to “ The Witch of persons as this woman ; had declared Endor.” First, that which “Christi-; such persons to be “ an abomination anos” seems to hold, viz., that this unto him,” and commanded that they woman had. the supernatural power should be put to death, for reasons, from some evil being, by permission ■ we shall afterwards notice, see Lev. of God, of summoning the dead from i xx. 27, Deut. ix. 14. their graves, and obtaining from ■ Secondly, Jehovah had instituted them information regarding future ' in the midst of his people means by events, and that she really brought which they might learn his purposes, up the prophet Samuel from his rest so far as he saw fit to reveal them. ing place, who delivered the state These means were the high priest, ments ascribed to him in the passage dreams, visions, and prophets, see under consideration. Secondly, an Ex. xxviii. 30, Numb. xxviiL 18 21. other idea more commonly held is, 1 Sam. xxviii. 6. that the woman was really an im- Thirdly,------j, ------God had -- refused to give poster: that she had no such power | any response to the inquiries of SauL as she pretended, from God or devil; through any of these appointed but, that on this occasion God, for means. “ When Saul inquired of some wise end, did really, and to the Lord, the Lord answered him the amazement of the woman herself, not, neither by dreams, nor by Urim, raise Samuel from the grave, to de- nor by prophets,” v. 6. The hypo liver his last message to the rejected j thesis that, in this instance, God King of Israel. Thirdly, a good | raised Samuel from the dead, to com- many thoughtful men, and these not I munieate his purposes to Saul, in- all the most incredulous, have come vol ves the startling conclusion that to the conclusion that the King of ! Jehovah countenanced a practice Israel was duped by the skilful i which he declared to be an abomina- artifice of a cunning woman. Thisltion uuto trim; and, while refusing last view seems to us the most to answer the king’s inquiries through warrantable of the three; and we his own appointed media,heanswered shall endeavor to put our readers in him through, or while resorting to, possession of OUr reasons for so con- means whieh he had strictly pro eluding. hibited. Even should it be admitted W 9 shall state our objections J that the woman had nothing to do Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 72 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. Mayi.isa. curse; for it is written, Cursed is shall reign over all nations with every one that continueth not in all Christ when he comes and appears things which are written in the in his glory. This is believing that book of the law to do them.” That Christ died for our sins according to is, we are all cursed. No one has the scriptures. And unless we believe continued in all things which are he died for our sins according to the written in the book of the law to do scriptures, we believe that Christ them. But, behold, “ Christ hath died for our sins in vain. Some redeemed us from the curse of the believe that Christ died for our sins law, being made a curse for us; for in order that we might reign with it is written, Cursed is every one that him in kingdoms beyond the skies. hangeth on a tree.” This is believing that Christ died for It is well to notice both what is, our sins in vain ; for it is not believ and what is not written. It is ing that Christ died for our sins written, Cursed is every one that according to the scriptures. To hangeth on a tree. It is not written, believe that Christ died for our sins Cursed is every one who is slain by according to the scriptures is to the sword. Why 1 Because the believe that he died to the end that scriptures foreseeing that Christ we might realize all the exceeding should die for our sins, and that his great aud precious promises which , death should be the death of the God has given to his people in all cross, preached the gospel before ages. That the creature itself may unto the Jews, saying, Cursed is be delivered from the bondage of every one that hangeth on a tree. corruption• that he who scattered Christ died for our sins, accord Israel miay gather them, and keep ing to Is. liii. In consequence of them as a shepherd doth his flock; his dying for Israel and all nations, that the tabernacle of God may be he is made king of Israel and of all planted among men, and the nations nations. He was wounded for our of them that are saved may walk in transgressions, Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ May 1, I85C. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 73 THE WITCH OF ENDOR. In an article on Miracles in The principally to the second view, as Messenger, for last month, the writer they, along with‘ ’ l our reasons for the (page 66) makes such allusion to the third —view, if'c correct,**" will also serve incident of the King of Israel con as sufficient ground for rejecting the sulting the woman who had “ a first; and because the second view familiar spirit,” as to suggest the seems more worthy of attention, as idea of requesting a place in these we believe that it is “ God, who pages, for a statement of the results raiseth the. dead”; and if Samuel of a careful examination of the rose at all, it was Jehovah, not the narative, in the 28th chapter of 1st Adversary, who brought him to life. Samuel. There are three opinions Will the reader then notice, in the which we have seen stated regarding first place, that God had expressly the remarkable incidents connected forbidden his people to resort to such with Saul’s visit to “ The Witch of persons as this woman; had declared Endor.” First, that which “Christi such persons to be “ an abomination anos” seems to hold, viz., that this unto him,” and commanded that they woman had the supernatural power should be put to death, for reasons, from some evil being, by permission we shall afterwards notice, see Lev. of God, of summoning the dead from xx. 27, Deut. ix. 14. their graves, and obtaining from Secondly, Jehovah had instituted them information regarding future in the midst of his people means by events, and that she really brought which they might learn his purposes, up the prophet Samuel from his rest so far as he saw fit to reveal them. ing place, who delivered the state These means were the high priest, ments ascribed to him in the passage dreams, visions, and prophets, see under consideration. Secondly, an Ex. xxviii. 30, Numb, xxviii. 18 21. other idea more commonly held is, 1 Sam. xxviii. 6. that the woman was really an im Thirdly, God had refused to give postor : that she had no such power any response to the inquiries of Saul, as she pretended, from God or devil ; through any of these appointed but, that on this occasion God, for means. “When Saul inquired of some wise end, did really, and to the Lord, the Lord answered him the amazement of the woman herself, not, neither by dreams, nor by Urim, raise Samuel from the grave, to de nor by prophets,” v. 6. The hypo liver his last message to the rejected thesis that, in this instance, God King of Israel. Thirdly, a good raised Samuel from the dead, to com many thoughtful men, and these not municate his purposes to' Saul, in all the most incredulous, have come volves the startling conclusion that to the conclusion that the King of Jehovah countenanced a practice IsraelT 1 was duped1—J by xlthe - skilful which he declared to be an abomina artifice of a cunning woman. This tion unto him; and, while refusing last view seems to us the most to answer the king’s inquiries through warrantable of the three; and we his own appointed media, heanswered shall endeavor to put our readers in him through, or while resorting to, possession of our reasons for so con means whieh he had strictly pro cluding. hibited. Even should it be admitted We »hall state our objections that the woman had nothing to do Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 74 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. Kayl.m with the communication given, still I tures who deny that such persons Saul evidently believed that she had; and practices had “ a positive ex- indeed, if the appearance was real, istence,” so that in this view of the the woman had to do with it either statement quoted, it is quite un directly or indirectly; for had the necessary. We however take ‘ Christi king not applied to her there is no anos ’ to mean that, if such persons reason to believe that the prophet as this woman did not really perforin would have been “ disquieted,” or what they pretended to do, it is im that the communication would have possible and improbable that God been received; so that we are shut would makelaws against them. If they up to the conclusion that Jehovah really had not “ familiar spirits," answered the request of the king by then it is “ impossible and impro or in consequence of his resorting to bable that God should make laws this woman, while he refused to re against them.” We would in charity spond to him by prophets, by dreams, presume that the writer has not or by Urim. The circumstance sufficiently pondered his declaration; would become known in Israel very for the same sort of reasoning would soon ; and there is every likelihood make the objects of heathen worship that the woman’s trade would be realities, in the same sense. Jehovah greatly promoted, so that this forbad his people to bow down before “ abomination to the Lord ” would the gods of the nations, or serve become exalted in Israel, through them, therefore these objects of wor- the action of J ehovah himself directly ship must have been really gods, or indirectly. Is not the conclusion since “ it is impossible and improb tremendous ? yea, blasphemous? Yet able that God should make laws it seems inevitable on this hypo against that which had no existence.” thesis. Should our government command Certainly this much will be granted, that “all spiritual mediums” be that if the appearance of Samuel was banished from the country, would it real, then G od while refusingto answer be fair to infer that these creatures Saul by a prophet, really did answer were not impostors ; or that the him by a prophet; God refused to re government acknowledged their pre spond by a living prophet, yet he tensions 1 Assuredly not. The God raised one from the dead to deliver a of Israel, in prohibiting these message that might have been given practices in question, used the terms through “the Urim,” a “dream,” or concerning them by which they were “ a prophet,” already living. commonly denominated ; and every ‘ Christianos’ writes “ Saul by con one can see the propriety of his doing sulting with familiar spirits had only so, whether these practices were bona made himself again an abomination to fide what they professed to be, or the Lord. And, it is impossible and only impostures. Either way these improbable that God should make practices were dishonouring to God, laws against that which has not a and injurious to his people. To see positive existence.” (Mess. p. 60). this we have only to revert to the This language is somewhat ambigu terms in which they arq spoken of in ous. God had forbidden his people to the law of Moses. “When thou art consult such women as that to which come into the land which the Lord the King of Israel had recourse in thy God giveth thee, thou shalt not the case before us ; and we are not learn to docio afteratt< the abominations of aware of any who receive the scrip-1 those nations,, there shall not be Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ May 1,1486. THE MESSENGER OF THE'CHURCHES. 75 found among you any one that that we have not held that position. . maketh his son or his daughter to These considerations, however, ap- pass through the fire, or that useth pear so serious that we feel shut up divination, or an observer of times, to understand the language of the or an enchanter, .or a witch, or a narrator as simply descriptive of the charmer, or a consulter with familiar i events as they appeared to Saul; spirits, or a wizard, or necromancer;; and there are not wanting, either for all that do these things are an in the scriptures, or other faith- .abomination unto the Lord ; and j' ful^>.1 narratives, instances, in "wlllclt because of these abominations the j events are described according as Lord thy God did drive them out‘ they appeared to the spectators, before thee. Thou shall be perfect and not as they actually happened. before the Lord thy God. For these For the reasons already alleged, as nations which thou shalt possess, well as for others to be submitted, hearkened unto observers of times, we have been led so to regard the and diviners ; but as for thee, the narrative before us. The reader Lord thy God hath not suffered thee will judge for himself which is the so to do,” Deut. xviii. 9-14. wisest alternative. Jehovah had, as formerly mention The defence of the third idea, that ed, instituted means amongst his the transaction on the part of the people by which they might learn woman was apretence,wemustreserve his will; and as the arts specified for another occasion ; meanwhile we were practised by idolators, and pro would conclude with this observation, fessedly associated with idol worship, That whether Samuel really appeared those who had recourse to them de or not, the transactions, as narrated, spised the oracle of God, and paid give no countenance to the idea of homage to the gods of the nations. th e conscious existence of disembodied The evil effects of such conduct spirits. There is no mention what among the chosen people of God are ever of “thespirit” of Samuel. It easily perceived, whether ‘the divina-1 was Samuel who is alleged to be tions’were pretended or real. Among “disquieted” and “brought up” “an such a people the pretension ifbelieved old man,” decently attired “with a in and resorted to, was as deleterious mantle.” . Neither Saul nor the as the reality ; consequently the pro woman seems to have had the idea of hibition was as proper in the one consulting “ naked spirits,” invisible case as in the other. ghosts, who made themselves mani In favour of the hypothesis we are fest by “ raps,” or strange noises. objecting to, it is urged that the She did not “call up spirits from the narrative ‘asserts that Samuel spoke vasty deep,” but disturbed the repose to Saul, vers. 15, 16. This is true ; of the dead, and brought them out of and we admit that the circumstance their graves, ere she could obtain is very strong evidence in favour of from them the desired information. • the reality of the appearance; and it Truly “ The dead know not any is only because we are driven from it thing.” by the considerations formerly stated W. L. Now-a days we have many hedze-breakers, very few to make up the breach and Jet down few hedge makers; many openers of gaps, the sluices, that the gushing stream of God’s few stoppers; many makers of breaches to let vengeance may be stayed.—Arthur Dent, in the flood ofChurch God’s wrathof God upon General us, butConference: I1607. McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 76 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. IMS. PERSISTENCE OF OLD BIBLE NAMES. The transmission, through so many centuries, teronomy iii. 11), as Philadephia, are ex of the Biblical names of places in the Holy amplesA of this tenacity„ of the East in assertinga Land, is a standing monument of the truth of the rights of its own language, and rejecting the Bible. It is hard to extirpate the foreign innovations. Indeed, these ,.kchanges----- aboriginal names of a country. 'I he race appear never to have been current among the which is spreading over British India, at the natives of the country, and ceased as soon as present day, when they plant a new town the power which had imposed them was now and then give it a new name. T he old broken. In the few instances in which towns . places on the contrary retain their old names. in Syria have Greek names at the present The Romans who extended their arms over time, as Antioch, Tubariyeh, and some others, Gaul, Britain, and parts of Germany, origin it will be found, almost universally, that the ated but few, very few, of the names now towns were of Greek origin, or founded by borne by the cities and villages in these those in the Greek or Roman interest, and, countries. Even when the earlier inhabitants consequently, had no previous name of which have disappeared before the new comers, as they could be dispossessed. in the case of the Etruscans in Italy, or the The chief requisites for establishing the Indians in some parts of America, they have identity of a place are that the modern name left traces of their language behind them. be the same as the ancient one, or deducible Our own (American) mountains and rivers, from it, and that the situation agree with with their Indian appellations,are not more en what is said or implied on that point in the during than the proofs that an older race in Scriptures. The geographical notices of the habited these shores before our forefathers Bible, even in regard to places very ancient came to them. . If, then, the records of the and comparatively obscure, are sometimes Old Testament are true, the successive waves remarkably specific. Thus, in Judges xxi. of conquest that have swept over Palestine 19, it is said that Shiloh, where the ark of cannot have obliterated all the marks of early the covenant was kept, in the days of the times. If the towns, mentioned as existing Judges, was “ on the north side of Bethel, on there in the age of Abraham, Joshua, or the east side of the highway that gocth up David, existed really, it must be possible to from Bethel to Shechem, and on the south of identify many of them still. As, on the one Lebonah ’’ I lodged at Bethel on the night hand, the impossibility of finding any trace of the twenty-eighth of April; on the next of them now would discredit the sacred day, at the distance of a few hours north ot historians, so, on the other, the discovery of Bethel, I turned aside to the right to visit the same names applied to existing localities, bhihiu, or Shiloh, and soon after passed on their preservation, notwithstanding so many the left, El Lebbun, the Lebonah of Scripture, invasions of Babylonians, Egyptians. Greeks as I pursued '* the highway ” to Nablus, the Romans, Persians, Saracens, Crusaders, and ancient Shechem. The identification of this Turks, who have overrun the country at last place is made out with entire certainty by a different times, becomes a striking witness process of historical combination, and in a to the truth of" the Scriptures. I will not different way, therefore, from that adoptedin undertake to state numerically how large a most cases, and described above. At Main, 1 proportion of the towns mentioned in the the Maon of Nabal, (I Samuel xxv. 2), near history of Joshua’s conquest of Canaan occupy Hebron, the traveller has in view, at once, at their ancient site; but, considering the least seven, not improbably nine, different antiquity of the record, it is surprisingly places which retain their ancient names but great. To these, of so early a date, should slightly modified. Among these, besides be added others, first noticed in the Old Maon, are Semua, Attir, Anab, Schuweikeh, Testament or the New, at a later period. .Yuttah, which correspond respectively to They bear the same names as in ancient times, Kshtemoa, Jattir, Anob, Socoh, and Juttah, slightly changed, in conformity with Arabic, all mentioned in the early book of Joshua. the spoken language of the East. Even in Besides the foregoing examples, in order cases where, during the reigns of the Seleucidre to show more fully the nature and the extent and the Ptolemies, some of the Scripture of the resemblance between the ancient and places received Greek names, they generally modern names, I subjoin the following list, lost them, in course of time, and regained placing those with the modern or Arabic their proper oriental appellations. Hamath, orthography On the left, those with the (Joshua xix. 35), known in the age ot the Hebrew or Greek on the right. Greeks asEpiphania; Tadmor, (2 Chronicles Anata...... Anathoth. viii. 4), as Palmyra; Rabbath Ammon,(Deu Akka,...... Aoco. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ May 1, 1868. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 77 Askulan, .. Askelon. Solam,...... Shunem. Beit Sur, .. Beth Zur. Tekua .. Tekoa, Beit Lahm, .. .. Bethlehem. Tubartyeh, (of Greek origin), .. Tiberias. Beit Ur, .. Beth Moron. Urtas, (probably) .. Etam Beisan,,.. .. Bcth-Shean. Yafa, ...... Joppa. Bireh,...... Beer, Beeroth Yalo .. Ajalon. Demaskh...... Damascus. Zerln,...... Jezreel.t Deburieh, .. Daberath. Endur, .. Endor. I mention the foregoing as examples only Esdud, .. Ashdod of the similarity which they illustrate, and Gazur, .. Gesur. mention these in preference to others, that Ghuzzeh, .. G aza. Gib...... ;. Gibeon would be equally pertinent, because they Hulhul .. Halhul. happen to be among the places which it was Huinmam, .. Hammath. my good fortune to visit or to have a sight of. J ebn a,...... Jabneh. What is worthy of special note is, that many Jeba,...... Geba Jelbon, .. Gilboa. of these names have been brought to light Jebah...... Gibeab. recently. Some of them have hardly been Jenin, (probably), .. .. En-Ganim. mentioned in books since they were last Jufna, (probably), .. Ophni. Kana, (unchanged), .. Kana. mentioned in the Bible, till the present cen Khurmul, ., Carmel. tury, or the last. Geographers and tourists Libnan,.. .. Lebanon. have traversed the land, and, as they have Ludd, .. Lydda. asked the inhabitants to tell them the names Mejdel,...... Magdela, Migdol, of their villages, have had the old Scripture Mucmas, .. Michmash. names given back to them from the mouths Nasirah, Nazareth. of the people.—Hackett. Nein," ’ ,...... Nail) Ram,...... Rameh. f I cannot refrain from bearing testimony here to BamehRameh...... Ramah. the very great value of the •' List of Arabic Names Riha,*Rih a,*...... Jericho. of Places” appended to the third volume of the SaidaSaida...... ‘idon. •‘Biblical Researches. ” They were collected and Salim, Salim or Sha- arranged by the Rev. Dr. Smith, of Beirut, as the lim fruit of inquiries made in the course of various Sarafend, Sarepta. journeys in all parts of Palestine, during a period Selwan, ...... Siloam. of several years. '1 he traveller, who would obtain Sur, Tyro. a knowledge of the ancient and modern topo •Though these words appear so unlike to the eye, graphy of th»t country, whatever other helps he the ear finds them quite the same: as Riha has a may forego should not omit to carry with him strong guttural pronunciation. This remark ap a copy of those “lists” so remarkably foil and plies to some of the other names. accurate. THE GOSPEL OF THE KINGDOM OF GOD. Tn last number L. has adduced instances it is admitted that the most learned critic in of the phrase, “ and saying” being used to the world is at his best estate altogether introduce a sentence explanatory of a preced fallible. ing one. He also asks if there is “any scrip I suggested that “ those Jews who rejected ture where this phrase, standingas it does in the gospel did not believe in the kingdom.” the above scriptures, (those quoted) is used In replying to this, L affirms that “as a as introducing something additional.” Sup nation, they (the Jews) did not believe the posing there happened to ba none, what then ? gospel.” There is a fallacy lurking here in Why, simply that the usage pled for by L. the use of the phrase “as a nation.’’ L. wiaybe the rule for Marie i. 14, 15. But what evidently uses it to denote the mass of the is needed for a proof text is not that it may Jews, the common people. But what is the be read in a given way, but that it must be testimony. “ Then went out to him (John read in that way and in no other. As the the Baptist) Jerusalem and all Judea and all language may naturally be read as an addition the region round about Jordan, and were to what precedes, any argument based upon baptized of him in Jordan, confessing their it one way or the other is reduced to a per- sins.’’ We surely have here the masses, and adventnre. that as distinguished from the Pharisees and As to Grieshach as an authority I have no Sadducees whom John met with well merited objection, so long as it is clearly understood rebuke. Again—“ All the people that heard that a proof text which is employed to sustain him and the publicans, justified God, being any position is notindebted to the critical sciz- baptized with the baptism of John. But the zors for mutilation before it can speak with the Pharisees and lawyers rejected the counsel of necessary authority, and above all so long as God against themselves, being not baptized Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 78 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. May 1,1888- of him.” It is thus testified that masses of of this class, who “received” Jesus by be the Jews confessed their sins in being lieving in his name,” in Andrew, Simon baptized. They must have obeyed the com Peter’s brother, who told the latter, referring mand— “ Repent.” And it is doing them to Jesus—“We have found the Messias.” nothing more than bare justice to conclude And immediately afterwards we have an that they repented for the right, reason—“for emphatic recognition of him by Nathanael in the kingdom of God is at hand.” But what these terms—“ Rabbi, thou art the Son of of the Pharisees and lawyers? Did they either God, thou art the King of Israel,’’ John i 42, confess, repent, or believe in the king 50. Tin words of Jesus to Nicodemus shew dom ? Their kingdom was the kingdom of the necessity that existed even at that early God in its then overturned condition, sub period of our Lord’s ministry, for believing in jected to a foreign yoke, under which they his name. ‘ God so loved the world that he were permitted to enjoy a little brief authority, gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever which, with its paltry emoluments they doubt believed in him, should r.ot perish but have less viewed as a bird in hand worth any everlasting life. For God sent not bis Son number in the bush. Hence “our place” into the world to condemn the world, but that formed their primary consideration in the the world through him might be saved. He event of the Romans coming to enforce their that believeth on him is not condemned, but endangered supremacy, John xi. 48. he that believeth not is condemned already, But if the Jews “as a nation ” rejected because he hath not believed in the name the gospel, and yet the gosped was believed of the only begotten Son of God.” John iii. by the common people, how is the phrase 16, 18. It is thus evident that to become a “as a nation,” to be understood.” Simply disciple of Christ during his personal minis as an organised body acting in a national try, and an heir of everlasting life, it was as capacity tlirou h its proper functionaries. necessary to believe in his name, although In this sense the Jews as a nation rejected never ,publicly ... preached, as it was to believe the glad tidings concerning the kingdom of concerning__ * il.the - 1_kingdom_ 1 . — of.T /""tGod. » A And4 — A it*x was God, no matter how many of the people be as necessary to believe this unpreached ele lieved. And not only so, but there is no ment of the gospel at that time, as it was reason to believe that the rulers had any afterwards when Peter proclaimed it to genuine faith in the future existence of the assembled thousands on the day of Pentecost, kingdom of God under the Messiah, either at or when Philip evangelized it in the city of hand or distant. And it was the rulers who Samaria. alone could perform a truly national act or This appears to me to be what constituted give expression to the national faith. The the difference between the mass of the Jew nation of Israel was not a republic, in winch ish people, as a nation, and the disciples of public opinion conld be expressed, through a Jesus. “ He came to his own, and his own chief magistrate the elect of the people, aud received him not ”—that is, in the character the popularr. r__ will______thus ___find _____embodiment ______in a which pertained to him as the Messiah. The national act. It was an absolute monarchy, chief priests and rulers declared they had whose laws even were beyond the touch of no king but Cresar—thus manifesting their king or parliament, except to be justly admin disloyalty to their own kingdom, and casting istered. in their lot with Gentile usurpation. In But while it is evident that the mass of the conformity with this spirit, they had long people believed the gospel as publicly preach before “ agreed that if any man did confess ed by John, Jesus, and the other apostles, that he (Jesus)-was Christ, he should be which was identically the same announce put out of the synagogue.” After the raising ment, comparatively few became the disciples of Lazarus, however, many “ believed on of Jesus, and continued faithful. The reason him,” (Jesus), and the rulers resolved upon of this is obviously because faith in something his destruction. Even this could only be not publicly preached was requisite to consti carried into execution by7 bribing Judas, and tute a true disciple. It was necessary to be arranging to effect Jesus’ apprehension “in lieve that Jesus is the Christ, or in other the absence of the multitude.” words to believe in his name. “ He came un In reply to A. F’s questions I would say to his own and his own received him not; first,—When the word mello is used by God but as many as received him to them gave he through any o h:s inspired servants, it al power to become the sons of God, even to ways denotes future certainty. Second,— THEM THAT BELIEVE IN HIS NAME ”, John i. Mello does not always denote nearness or 11, 12. “ When he was in Jerusalem at the proximity. Third,—I am not sufficiently passover, in the feast day many believed in learned in the precise meanings of all his name, when they saw the miracles which the original words in the Old and New he did,” John ii. 23. We have an example | Testaments as to name those that may Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ May 1, 1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 79 denote closer proximity than this word coming in glory necessitated his going away ; Mello. for be could not come so long as he continued In support of my answer to No. 2, which to be present. Here tbeu was a third im is the most essential, 1 would refer to one in portant event to intervene. stance where mello does not denote nearness The simple fact is that mello, like many or proximity. I refer to Matt. xvi. 27. “ For other words, seems to have more than one the Son of man shall come in the glory of meaning. According to the Polymicrian his Father, with his angels, and then he Gr ek lexicon, “It corresponds to the auxili shall reward every man a cording to his aries will, shall, must, and may sometimes works.” The words “ shall come,” here re- be expressed by to in tend,” &c. Hence the present mello in the Greek. TheT'.„ event____ ‘ translators of the common version had a referred to,, is not the nearest or most proxi choice of renderings and in the exercise of mate in relation to the Lord. He had just their own judgment in the case inserted the intimated his approching death and resurrec- word..„.ri “ will.'’ tion. These were events nearer at hand The question as to whether the common than bis coming in the glory of his Father, versioni or the Diaglott is absolute correct is with bis angels to reward every man accord- , thusVIIUO leftICIV vpun,open, and noIIV V.IVone OI.vruiMshould WVVseek tort ing to his works, and yet he does not use ■: sustain a position by adducing a questionable niello in intimating them. Besides, his 1 authority. J. C. THE POWER OF GOD IN HIS WORD. No human intellect,—we boldly priding themselves on the perfection venture the assertion,—no human in of their ethical philosophy, announc tellect, and no amount of human ing the resurrection of the body when learning yet gathered, are competent the select thinkers were soaring in to the task of accounting, on any their Platonic spiritualism, and a new known natural principles, for the and heavenly life for the soul when strange existence in our world of a the vulgar herd of. Epicurus were series of writings, and corresponding filling the air with the swinish noise influences, so unearthly in their of their sensualism,—triumphing power, yet so human in their form— alike over the Senecas and the Neros, so deep in the world’s thought, yet the Antonines and the Domitians, so constantly in conflict with all con overthrowing the giant power of temporary thinking, and therefore, ancient Paganism, driving it from at each period of its existence so that last stronghold of conservatism utterly opposed to any idea of devel it had sought in the philosopliic revi opment,—teaching the absolute unity val of the early myths, shedding a of God through all the black night holy light during the long period of of the Western‘ polytheism,’ ■’ • the” vivid‘ ‘ Barbarian and Mediaeval darkness, personality of God in the denser■ breaking forth with new splendour darkness of the Eastern pantheism, at the Reformation, and yet filling the holiness of God amid every men’s minds with fear, or sustaining where surrounding forms of worship them in heavenly hope, irt the face of so impure that they cannot be de a war that never raged so fiercely as scribed, the unrepresentable essence in these days when naturalism and of God when the world was full of a criticism combined, as they were monstrous idolatry or a foul Egyptian never combined before, are doing symbolism,—proclaiming salvation their utmost to shake the authority by the Cross when the schools were ij of its divine mission.—Dr Lewis. Intelligence, Notes, &c- Crossgates—Since last notice there has | confession of his faith, was immersed into been another addition in the person of a Christ, and joined the fellowship of the Church. second son of brother Cunningham, who made Edinburgh.—On April Sth, James Dowie, Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ A 80 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. (son of brother G. Dowio) made confession of his faith in the gospel of God’s dear Son, and Publications. was forthwith immersed into Jesus Christ. THE DISCIPLES’ CHORAL SERVICE On the following Sunday he was received in OF BIBLE THEMES, to the fellowship of the Church. This is the youngest disciple we have had introduced to A collection of Christian Songs,—the us—as he is not quite 15 years of age ; but subjects selected from the Holy Scrip withal of a clear judgment and staid manner. tures, and set to suitable music (in both This addition makes up the whole list of notations), arranged for four voices. This names on the roll to 66, including two in book, got up expressly for the use of the Australia, two in South America, and one brethren in their social services, and suitable atpresentin Cumberland ; last month’s state either for the church or the fireside, ment was therefore incorrect. Is now reduced in price- Glasgow.—“Sister Mrs Allen (late Miss One Shilling in a neat printed cover; On® Mason) came here from London a month ago, and Sixpence cloth boards, post free. May and was admitted to the Church, having pre be had of G. Dowie, 88 Nicolson Street, viously given a satisfactory statement of her Edinburgh, faith, and presented a communication from the brethren in London, recommending her Also may be had of G. Dowie, to our fellowship. The brethren propose remaining another The Messenger of the Churches, year (should the coming of their Lord not in 1st SERIES. tervene) at their present address, 38 Bath A few copies are retained in hand for a Street,, where they will be glad to see any of short7time longer, and1 can be supplied to the- like faith, who may be sojourning in the lo- brethren' at the price before announced, viz : cality. Owing to certain matters that have —The four volumes, 1861, 1862, 1863, 1864, happened in the Institution, the brethren will stitched and in paper covers, Is. each; or the be obliged to close the doors for a limited four in one volume, cloth lettered, 4s. 6d. time during the hours of worship, but this Postage of single vols. 2d. of cloth vols Cd. will form no barrier to any one, attending at vol. 1, (I860) is imperfect; but single num the proper hours—Which are 11 a.m. and bers of 4-12, may be had at one penny each. 2 pm. The Inquirer—“ Will any of your The following may be had from W. Norrie, scholarly friends please inform me, through 9 Ingliston Street, Edinburgh. your pages, what is the real value of that ex The Destiny of . the British Empir® pression in 1 Cor. xv. 52 “at the lost trump.’’ Revealed in the Scriptures. Price 6d. Does the phrase implv that there is no trump The Contrast between Protestantism et to be sounded after it, or is it only a and the Gospel ; 36 pp. 8vo, 6d. trumpet sounded at the end.? What is this Gospel? 4 pp. 12mo, ls.6d.per Also, please say how “ Christ was raised hundred. from the dead by the g'ory of the Father,” as The Kingdom of God. 1 page, 8vo, Is. per stated in Romans vi. 4.—Q. hundred. The Treasurer acknowledges receipts for The Gospel Witness. 16 pp. 8vo, complete the Messenger from Glasgow, Mumbles, in 12 Nos. at 2d. each. Single Nos. London, and Nottingham. . .(except---- r------No. 5), —may be had to completesets.. , On and after May 25th, the address of G. Saving Faith 20 pp. 8vo. Id. Dowie willbeasformerly,l2 Beaumont Place. I The Bible. 8 pp. 12mo, 2s 6d per hundred. The Messenger is Registered fob Transmission Abroad. Articles should be sent in by the I5th of the month, and items of intelligence not later than the 24th ; all papers meant for insertion, or notes of intelligence, may be forwarded to George Downs, 88 Nicolson Street, till 25th May, afterwards 12 Beaumont Place; and all business communications to James Cameron, 12 Calton Hill, Edinburgh, to whom money orders should be made payable. ’ A» A.7SD W. Ba WILSON, PRINTERS, HIGH STREET, EDINBURGH. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ ' THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. ♦ “ I SPEAK AS TO WISE MEN, JUDGE YE WHAT I SAY.” No. 6. June 1, 1866. New Series. Vol. II. LET BROTHERLY LOVE CONTINUE. Let brotherly love continue ! opinion; shall we fight for the power Why should it not? Our affection of ignorance—mere word-force; shall is no mere rmaudlin 11‘“ sentiment ~~pro- we curse Jthat’1"i weak brother in our voked by the intoxicating excitement heart because he cannot walk as fast of a conviction which, though strong or as far as we can 1 Shall we envy enough at first, has no power to keep that strong man who scorns our petty it in life and vigour. Nay: we know jabberings ? No: they both have and are sure that God has loved us ; greater hearts than we; they are aye, and still loves us; therefore, if ready to accord with us, and the it were once right to love one another counsel they heartily give is, Let because God has loved us, it is always brotherly love continue ! right. Let us not forget our first Let brotherly love continue ! love, its warmth, its intensity, its Some whom we have loved have purity,andforbearance. Letbrotherly proved unfaithful and unkind. Why love continue ! should this dispirit us 1 Where had Let brotherly love continue, though we been had God dealt with us we do not see everything alike. It is according to our deservings. Like • when the Lord brings again Zion as a father shews compassion on his that Israel shall see eye to eye; it is children, even so the Lord has had when that which is perfect is come pity on us : and if those children are that we shall see face to face, and shall sometimes pettish, sometimes angry, know even as we are known. Mean sometimes ungrateful, so have we while when we, through the weakness been; but the mercy of the Lord is as well as the diversity of our minds from everlastingtoeverlastingtoward dodifferinourprospectof thingswhich those that fear Him, and trust in his we see through the glass—obscurely, mercy. If any brother walk dis we are not free to set at nought or orderly, and not according to the despise our brother, and he has no apostolic word, note that man, and right to despise us. We are but have no company with him, that he learners, scholars, disciples, all im may be ashamed; yet count him not perfect ; and some of us stand on as an enemy, but admonish him as a this side the tutor, and some on that: brother. Let brotherly love continue? sh^ll we quarrel for difference of Let brotherly love continue 1 If Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ A 82 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. June 1, 1865. the fire is allowed to go out we shall he hath seen how can he love God all be chilled. Should we cause whom he hath not seen. How can ourselves to suffer because another he? The sweet fragrance of this who has come in will not do as affection is pleasant to the God and much as we ? To spite him shall we Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, punish ourselves ? This suicidal Behold how good and how pleasant conduct blesses nobody : that un it is for brethren to live together in thankful churl of a brother is made unity! It is like the precious more churlish, and we shiver with ointment poured on the head of the cold we have ourselves induced. Aaron, which flowed over his beard, We have rather need to do more—to and to the skirts of his garment; like heap on more fuel, to keep up the the dew of Hermon, or that distilling fire of love in our own hearts, that on the hill of Zion, where God it may prevent us being affected by commands the blessing—even life for this freezing guest, and also that we evermore; therefore Let brotherlylow should thaw him. There is no reason continue ! why the coldness or the indifference Let brotherly love continue ! God of others should overpower us—be has called us to it. When we owe not overcome of evil, but overcome all to Him, it is a pleasant way to evil with good: Let brotherly love pay our debts in loving one another. continue 1 Our Lord taught that it is a little Let brotherly love continue ! If matter to love them who love us; it was the first of virtues, it is also we should be able to love our the last; for he who adds to his faith enemies. Yet all that is herein courage, knowledge, temperance, demanded of us is to love those who patience, and godliness, must needs are our dearest friends. Paul has fill up the perfect measure with told us to owe no man anything but brotherly kindness, and love. When love one to another. If this be in we, having put away all malice, and us, and live, and abound, we shall envy, and hate, and the filthy attire be blessed; for he who does the will of unrighteousness, re-clothe ourselves of God is blessed in the deed, and his with peace, and joy, and long suffer commandment is not grievous. For ing, the uppermost garment is love, this reason also we ought to love one even the love of the brethren—for if another. Therefore let brotherly love any man love not his brother whom continue ! G. Dowie. THE WITCH OF ENDOR. (Second Paper.) We proceed now to state the argu- narrative in 2 Samuel xxviii, 4-25; r ments fiPg/the"" ‘ third------theory-■’ ■regarding“ andalsowith our remarksin the former the transactions between the woman article, we would solicit his attention at Endor and the kingw of Israel— to the following observations :— viz., That the woman was a cunning First, Let the distracted condition impostor, who, by her arts, imposed of the king’s mind be remembered. on the excited and fearful mind of “ The Philistines gathered them the king. If the reader has made selves together, and pitched in himself familiar with the scripture Shunem; and Saul gathered all Israel Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ June i, 1860. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 83 together and pitched in Gilboa; and I this term, a word signifying Ventrilo- 0 when Saul saw the host of the quist, in the plural Ventriloquists, I ...... Philistines ’he was afraid,“ ‘ and his‘ and the probability is that it was by heart greatly trembled.” vs. 4, 5. means of this art that this woman Time was, when he would have and such like, played on the credulity courageously met the foe, but now of those who consulted them ; pass his heart was feeble, and trembled ing off the modulations of their own greatly. This tremor no doubt arose voice, as the voices of the dead. from, or at least was greatly enhan The English reader should, at least, ced by the knowledge that he was understand that the Hebrew word under the ban of the Almighty— for “ spirit ” does not occur where that Jehovah had rejected him from our translation gives “familiar spirit” being king—and that his successor or “familiar spirits,” but the term had been chosen. The consciousness ob, in the plural oboth, which the of his hapless condition was greatly LXX. render by a term equal to our intensified by the fact, that Jehovah word Ventriloquist or Ventriloquists, had ceased to acknowledge his re as the case may be. quests, or give him counsel. “ When Observe now, the behaviour of the Saul inquired of the Lord, the Lord woman towards Saul. She pretends answered him not, neither by dreams, not to know him till she had seen nor by Urim, nor by prophets.” v. 6. the alleged apparition. Yet there Thus brought to his wit’s end, he, in are good reasons for believing that stead of meekly submitting to the she knew him from the first. Saul had determinate counsel of God, in his indeed disguised himself, but there h desperation made himself still more was that about him which he could ? obnoxious to the Divine curse, by not conceal. “ From his shoulders resorting to practices which Jehovah and upward he was higher than any had declared to be abominations to of the people " chap, ix, 2. him. How terribly daring and From” the acute, observant charac foolish it is to run against the bosses ter necessary in a woman of her of Jehovah’s buckler! In this frenzi stamp, she was not likely to be im- ed state of mind Saul presented him- posed on by any disguise which Saul self before the woman “ who had a might assume; and his extreme familiar spirit; ” and demanded of height would render suspicion cer- her that she should divine unto him tain. It was however of the utmost by the familiar spirit; and bring him moment that she should conceal her up whom he should name, v. 8. The knowledge of his person till her own Hebrew term rendered “ familiar safety was secure. She saw Saul be- spirit,” is “ ob ” a word which is not fore her disguised—he who command- easily rendered intelligible without ed her fraternity to be banished from explanation. It is used for a leather- the land; and there was room for her en bottle or water skin, in some in suspicion that he was laying “ a snare stances, but is most frequently applied for her life.” The assurance which to such persons as the woman in the Saul gave her of her security, set her case before us, who professed to call mind at rest on that point; and was up the dead, and obtain from them also of such a nature as to confirm her information regarding future or belief that no other than the king of doubtful events. It is a circumstance Israel stood before her, “ Saul sware worth knowing, that the Septuagint to her by the Lord saying, there translation gives as the equivalent of shall no punishment happen to thee Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 84 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. June 1, is® for this thing, v. 10. Thus assured description of what she pretended to ofher own safety, she inquires “Whom have seen; not from ocular vision by shall I bring up unto thee ? ” The the king himself. Hence Saul en- answer was, “ Bring me up Samuel.” quires “What sawest thou?” To At this point there is a break in the. this first question she vaguely an- narrative; we have no account of the swers, “I saw gods (elohim) ascend- process of “ bringing up.” The next ing out of the earth.” Then the sentence introduces us to the result king inquires, “ What form is he of that process. The woman no of? And she said “ An old man doubt had retired within her recess cometh up; and he is covered with a and performed her incantations before mantle.” The woman purposely she uttered the loudcry mentioned in avoids identifying the pretended ap- verse 12. This scream was, it seems parition ; her— —wish--1 1being ----- to allow" to us, a part of her performance. the king to do that himself; and The king was standing alone waiting knowing that he was expecting her the result of his desperate conduct, to raise Samuel, it was enough for her trembling with emotion ; to increase tox" describeJ---- ’’------him accordingu:------to his usual> his agitation, and prepare his mind appearance, of which she was doubt better for her deceptions—she cries less aware, either by personal obser out with loud voice, as if stricken vation or description from others. with terror also. The phrase “ When The “ mantle ” was the upper gar the woman saw that it was Samuel ment, oi’ robe, longer.and fuller than she cried, &c.,” does not imply that the common one, but without sleeves, the sight of Samuel was the cause of worn chiefly by men of rank or office, her terror, as some believe ; for the as kings, princes, priests, and pro alleged cause of her terror was stated phets ; such a robe as Samuel com by the woman herself to be the know monly wore ; so that the description ledge that her inquirer was Saul. which the woman gave of the appa Such was the impression made on rition, which she affirmed she had the king’s mind, also, regarding the seen, at once convinced Saul that the source of her terror. 11 The woman prophet had risen. There is no mention said to Saul why hast thou deceived in the narrative of Saul seeing any me? for thou art Saul. And the thing. “ Saul said unto her, “ What king said to her, Be not afraid.” (vs. form is he of? And she said, An 12, 13.) The words “When the old man cometh up ; and he is cover- woman saw that it was Samuel,”' ed with a mantle, and Saul perceiv- are, as formerly suggested, used by ed that it was Samuel.” the narrator as descriptive of the That the king’s perception was mode in which the deceptions were produced by the woman’s description, practised. The woman pretended to and not by his own vision, is noi have succeeded in her incantations ; only apparent from the scope of tht and pretended that by these means narrative, but is also borne out bj she had learned that her visitor was the use of the Hebrew verb renderec the king of Israel. “ perceived.” It is not the verl Let it now be observed that Saul (raah) to see, as in verse 13, bu did not see the apparition. We are (yada) to know, to perceive with th told, indeed, that Saul “ perceived. mind, which is used in verse 14 that it was Samuel ” ; but the narra-- The conviction, however, which wa«■» tive informs us that the king’s per- produced in the king’s mind was ev ception was derived from the woman’s dently as strong as if it had resulte Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ June 1,1860. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES, 85 from actual vision; and, therefore, I and become thine enemy. And the “ hehp stoopedstooned with his face totn the I Lord hath done to him (rathter, see ground and bowed himself.” jmargin) done for himself)i as he Having the king thus completely spoke by me; the Lord hath’rent under her spell, it was easy for the the kingdom out of thine hand, and woman, either by her own ventril- given it to thy neighbour, even to oquial powers, or those of an accom David; because thou obeyedst not plice to imitate the voice of the pro- the voice...... of, the TLord, , nor executed, 1 phet. As yet, however, she was ig- his fierce wrath upon Amalek, therethere- norant of the matter on which Saul fore hath the Lord done this thing wished to consult Samuel; and it unto thee this day.” was necessary she should learn this The concluding portion of the before proceeding further ; but as she oracle may be thought to militate was not to give the king what infor- strongly, if not, inevitably, against mation he wanted, it would of course our hypothesis; and, there can be no have been imprudent in her to have doubt that this part of the narrative questioned him as to the matter on would favour the idea that Samuel which he desired to be informed, really was the speaker; yet we think She therefore, very cunningly, makes that it is capable of being harmonized Samuel demand, “Why hast thou with the view we are supporting. disquieted me to bring me up 1 ” Let us see—It runs thus : “ More The king’s reply gave her all the over the Lord will also deliver Israel information she required. “ fSaul with thee into the hands of the answered, I am sore distressed; for Philistines; and to-morrow shall thou the Philistines make war against me; and thy sons be with me, the Lord and God is departed from me, and shall also deliver the host of Israel answereth me no more, neither by into the hand of the Philistines.” prophets, nor by dreams, therefore This prediction was speedily fulfilled. have I called thee that thou mayest How could the woman know that make known .unto me what I shall these events were to happen i Ven do.” Having learned the hapless triloquism would not enable her to condition of the king from his own penetrate the future. Most assuredly lips, it was an easy matter for the not; and yet it is no un-common woman to put into the mouth of the thing for mere fortune-tellers to have prophet the prediction of the down- their predictions verified ; sometimes fall of Saul, and the selection of they are very accurate in their state David in his stead (see chaps, xiii. ments, and it is doubtless owing to 13, 14; xv. 28.) Those predictions, that circumstance that their success and the fact that David was the man in trade, in a great measure, depends. chosen by God to receive the king The accuracy of the prediction in dom, were matters no doubt familiar this case is very remarkable, on the to many in Israel; and were not supposition that it was the simple likely to escape the notice of the product of the woman’s mind; and observant and intelligent class . to yet no one can deny that it might which this woman belonged. We not be, after all, neither more nor need not, therefore, be astonished less than a happy hit; and that the that she was able to quote so accu prediction was simply hazarded. rately what had formerly been spoken There are not wanting, however, by the prophet to the same person. evidence in the narrative that the “ The Lord is deputed from thee woman had within her knowledge Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 86 LTHE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. Junel, law. certain data which, in a greatmeasure, recourse to practices which were would assist her in foretelling the abominable to the Almighty, and, in speedy downfall of her royal visitor, doing so, became the victim of a She knew that his ruin had been cunning and deceitful woman. How predicted by his own God—Jehovah, far our conclusions are borne out by she had heard from his own lips that the circumstances of the case, the his God had ceased to answer him— intelligent reader will, of course^ she was also aware of the strong determine for himself. force which the Philistines had In addition to the animadversions brought against him; and from his we made in the first article, on the great constem ation she would perceive supposition that the prophet really his consciousness of weakness to face was brought out of his grave and his long inveterate enemy, is it too spoke to Saul, we would submit that, much to believe that a woman of such from that view of thematter itappears perception, and careful observation very strange that the prophet should as, from the nature of her occupation utter no rebuke to Saul for resorting she necessarily required to be, was to practices so displeasing to God. aware of the fact, from the past The only rebuke rendered is, history of Israel, that when Jehovah “ Wherefore then dost thou ask of me manifested his disapprobation towards seeing the Lord hath departed from them,ii or . itheir • i leaders,t on .ithe eve ofnil. thee, ____and.1 * is1. become______- i.tthine * ______enemy! ftt)” a battle, their defeat was certain ? Not a word about the sin of seeking Surely not. Supposing, then, that to those that “ peep and muttei’,” and she was, or had not even a clair- have oboth. Samuel, before his death, voyante en rapport, with the fated would not have dealt thus with the monarch, which really may have King; and it is difficult to understand been the case—there was sufficient his silence regarding this abomination, ground for her concluding that the if it be the case that he really rose fulfilment of his predicted overthrow from the dead. We would rather was about to descend on the terror- have expected, to quote the words of stricken king—and that the impend- TTantyHenty Fit?.,Fitz, “Burning words, tri ing battle would decide his fate. It bulation, indignation, and wrath, for is due to the reader unacquainted so high-handed, and heaven-daring with the Hebrew to mention that an offence, as Saul’s last act must be the term translated “ to-morrowf in branded, to have burst from the lips verse 19, has a wide latitude of of the prophet, instead of the recital meaning; and is sometimes used in of an old prediction, and an inquiiy the sense of “ hereafter.” It occurs to learn the cause of his being in this sense in Gen. xxx. 33 ; Ex. disquieted? We might also have xiii. 14; Jos. ix. 6. 21., so that the reasonably expected such a rebuke defeat of Israel, and death of Saul, to be followed by an absolute refusal by the Philistines’ arms on any future to give any information. : occasion would have fulfilled the It is also a strange looking circum woman’s prediction. stance that the prophet, if he really Such is the light in which the had been raised, while knowing what transactions between the woman at was shortly to befall the fated king, Endor and the king of Israel appear should be ignorant of Saul’s reason for to us. Saul, madly and foolishly bringing him up. On the hypothesis suffering under the curse of Jehovah, we have defended, this alleged added yet more to his sin by having ignorance has been accounted for; Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ June 1,1864. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 87 but, it will be difficult to explain it sons. If Samuel returned to heaven, or the supposition of the reality of i the king of Israel and his sons went Samuel’s appearance. I there also, “ To-morrow shalt thou As formerly observed, which ever and thy sons be with me,” v. 19, “A way we view the narrative, it affords happy change” indeed 1! We are no tsupport to the common belief that carefiil to state the matter thus for good men, at death, go to heaven. two reasons, First—to shew those who Samuel speaks of being disquietedaisquieiea takevaise the narrative under considera- like one who had been asleep. Of'tioni as a proof of the conscious being “ brought up,” not down ; and existence of men between death and in the scriptures heaven is always resurrection, that it.affords them no • spoken of as being above, not below. support—And secondly, to shew that Manifestly the language gives the re a person may believe that Samuel presentation of Samuel rising, or being was really raised from the dead, and caused to rise, out of the earth, and yet believe that, without a resurrec- that he was to return thither to be tion, “ the dead know not anything.” joined on the morrow by Saul and his W. L. THE PROXIMITY OF THE KINGDOM. A. F.’s Second Paper. I am not satisfied with the replies of J; C. an’se from the Hebrew idiom, or depend to mymv mwrinnc,questions. HeHe, says “" melloi ’’ like solely on the usus locquendi of the New many other words seems to have more thani Testament writers.’’ With these rules one meaning, and this seeming„ .she beforecalls “us,the let us turn over to mello and see simple fact* * IJ claniilrlshould hovnhave likedlilrorl a sampleoamnlo what is the primary meauing ; here it is— of the “ many other words ” which have a “to be about to do,” “be on the point .of- plurality of meaning;-;r »t. specially—------if they were3 doing. ’’ There are no derivatives given, so common verbs of our own language. How ■ that the garbled extract of J. C. follows; ever, we are plainly told that meilo denotesi which does not give the meaning, but only future certainty, when God makes use of it the words which represent mello in the Eng through his inspired servants. I hope there lish translation ; then follow the participle are few of the readers of the Messenger who form, which I transcribe, thus, “to come, will endorse such a sentiment. If words future, Match, iii. 7, Luke xiii. 9, and in when spoken by God were to mean one other texts ; to be always, as it were, about thing, and the same words when spoken by to do, to delay, linger, Acts xxii. 16.” men were to mean another thing, then the 1 now leave the reader to judge the value Bible would not be worth the paper it is of the simple fact of what meaning mello seems printed on. What reliance can be put on to have; and I will now state some facts about God’s word if we have a doubt about its its meaning: I have been at great pains, meaning? And if verbs, which are the searching the best authorities I could get most important of all words, have not one these two weeks past. The word is used primary and definite meaning, there can be and applied to what is impending, or what no rational faith nor obedience exercised. may be imminent, jind hence there is not a J. 0., has made an improper use of the Greek lexicon which does not give “ to be “ Polymicrian Lexicon,” by quoting a very about to,” “to be on the point of’’ doing, as small part out of the centre, and making it its radical meaning. Mello has. no corres appear as the meaning: whereas the Poly ponding word in our language; and that is micrian in its preface lays down the following the reason why it is so variously rendered. rules for its own guidance—“ In defining the It does not have a variety of meanings; it words, those significations are placed first has one uniform signification, but our Eng which are either primary or accord with lish language cannot exactly express it, hence Greek usage; and then follow, in regular our translators have been obliged to leave it gradation, the derivative senses, whether out altogether (Acts xiii. 34, xxiii. 30). tropical, metaphorical, &c., or those which And while the notion of futurity is inherent Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 88 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. Jnne 1, I860. in this verb, as it is also in our verb to hope, had to intervene, is of no force against Patil’s it does not on that account have any relation announcement of the day of judgment, some to certainty—as J. C. has affirmed. There twenty years after all these events were ful is no certainty about mello, even when used filled. Besides, these three events were by God’s inspired servants: as an instance, accomplished in less than sixty days, and look at the last quoted from the “Polymi- they did not stand in the way of Jesus pro crian,’’ “ Why tarriest thou.” There can claiming '* The kingdom of God is at hand,” be no future certainty in tarrying. See also although he well knew that kingdom could Matth. xi. 14, “And if ye will receive it, not come until more than sixty days were this is Elias which was for to come.’’ Here gone by. mello is represented by the words “which The bold assumption of J. C. in the Feb was for,'’ and the idea of future certainty is ruary number, that there was no proximity utterly excluded. I do not think it possible in Paul’s announcement of the day of judg to produce a clearer instance, which could ment, led me to put the questions, with the more effectually contradict the statement of hope that he might be led to retract it to J. C., that this word “always denotes future some extent. His replies convince me of certainty when used by God through his in the inutility of continuing the subject. I spired servants.” I therefore conclude that feel myself unfit to cope with him. I re the answer to my first question is both ferred to the Diaglott, because many readers ■ illusive and untrue. of the Messenger possess it, and it is free With regard to the supports of No. 2. from bias on the subject of proximity. I had It is not correct to say, “ the words sh all held it in contempt since ever 1 saw its first come here represent mello.” And the argu number, and read Matth. iii. 2: but since ment that Jesus did not always use mello in seeing it frequently of late I now come to speaking of his death goes for very little ; in like some parts of it very much. It is a the very next chapter (Matth. xvii. 12) he great deal better, than I had thought. If I does make use of it regarding his sufferings. have adduced a questionable authority it was The argument that there could not be near not the Diaglott, but J. C. I adduced. ness understood concerning the coming of the Son of man, so long as three important events A F. THE LITTLE HORN. Satan. In the paper which we submit to j him.” The article the is supplied the consideration of the reader, we in thithis passage, as it occurs in the would ask his attention to a few orginal. statements of scripture relative to Various titles are'here given—the Satan : making it rather a continua great dragon—the old serpent—the tion of the one on “ miracles,” than accuser—the adversary, to one and dependent solely on itself. the same person. Person? Why,there It is stated in Rev. xii.; “ And is no such thing, it will be said, as there was war in heaven: Michael a personal adversary, independent and his messengers fought against of, and not to be identified with, the dragon; and the dragon fought man ; or, supernatural. The ques- and his messengers, and prevailed tion thus raised is a simple one. It is not; neither was their place found this, is “the accuser” or “adversary,” any more in the heaven. And the a principle or a person ? Or, is the great dragon was cast out, that old accuser sin in the flesh, seen em serpent, the accuser (diabolos), and bodied in man; or, briefly, human the adversary (6 satanas), which nature 1 deceiveth the whole habitable: he Before inquiring into the teaching was cast out into the earth, and of any other portions of the scrip- his messengers were cast out with J ture, "let; us notice other statements Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ June 1,1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. in this chapter xii. of the Revelation, selves on earth. But, there is not At the 10th verse, it begins, And one word in these passages, to inform I heard a loud voice in the heaven, us, that the saints were cast out of the saying, Now is come the salvation, heaven in order to be overcome on and the power, and the kingdom of the earth by the dragon-energized our God, and the authority of his beast. Anointed: for the accuser of our Again, other passages of scripture brethren is cast down, which accused teach us, that Michael is not a human them (or, the one accusing) before person, or embodied principle. In our God day and night. And they Dan. x. 13, it says, “ Michael, one overcame him by the blood of the of the chief princes came to help Lamb,” &c. And, in the 12th verse, me.” and verse 2, “and there is none “Woe to the inhabiters of the earth that holdeth with me in these things, and of the sea ! for the devil is come but Michael your prince.” In Dan. down unto you, having great wrath, xii. 1, “ and at that time shall because he knoweth that he hath Michael stand up,” Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 90 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. June 1, i&jft same verse, previously. Further, I elude, that “ the accuser ” was other if “ the accuser ” is nothing else I than a person not of or in the flesh ? than a human being, then must Again, it is said of Judas, “and after “the Son of man” be nothing else the sop, the adversary entered into than a human person also. Such is him.” (John xiii. 27, o satanas; the position, which deniers of the Luke xxii. 3, satanas). Judas was existence of “the accuser” inde human nature, or, in him, sin was pendent of man, must consistently embodied. If the adversary or the take. And such position is entirely accuser is sin embodied or human at variance with the teaching of this nature also, are we to understand passage of scripture. in this matter of fact account, that Let the reader next notice the human nature, or sin embodied era- principal features in “the tempta- tered into itself * Such must be the tion,” after comparing the accounts way this occurrence is to be under given in Matthew iv.; Mark i.; and stood, if the accuser is not a person. Luke iv. Jesus is conducted into And, if this be so, how could or did the wilderness by the spirit to be satan enter into himself, or, in other tempted by “the accuser,” says words, Judas into himself? Matthew and Luke, (upo tou dia- The only consistent ground deniers bolon), or, by the adversary, (upo of the existence of “ the accuser,” or tou satana), says Mark. At the con “ satan,” as a person independent of clusion of ’ the temptations, “ the human nature, can take is, either accuser,” (o diabolos, Matthew and that of the Sadducees of past ages, or Luke; satana, Matthew iv. I10), ‘‘ I the Rationalists of the present. It leaves him, and the messengers come is said in Acts xxiii. 8, “ For indeed and minister to him, (Matthew and the Sadducees say, there is no resur- Mark). In this narrative we have rection, nor angel, nor spirit.” And three distinct personalities present, one of the most recent writers of the —Jesus, the accuser, and the mess- Rationalistic school makes the follow- engers. Jesus was a human being, ing statement: “Jesus on this point certainly. Was the accuser? If so, differed in no respect from his com- who— was---- he-l.9 ? If so, who ------werep arithei0Ils . jje believed in the devil, messengers? They must have been whom he regarded as a kind of evil human also, for, denial of “ super genius,” (reference given in proof of natural” existence of one, involves this, Matt. vi. 13), “and he imagined, denial of “supernatural” existence like all the world, that nervous of the other. You admit existence maladies were produced by demons, of messengers obedient to the will of who possessed the patient and agitated God, and not human. Why deny ex him. The marvellous was not the istence of the accuser as anon-human exceptional for him, it was his normal being; as there are such in existence. state. The notion of the supernatural, Say these messengers were human, with its impossibilities, is coincident then who were they, and those men with the birth of experimental tioned in John i. 51, and various science. The man who is strange to other passages. But, let it be noted, all ideas of physical laws, who believes that, in the account of the tempta that by praying he can change the tion, there is not the slightest hint of path of the clouds, arrest disease, and the presence of any other person in even death, finds nothing extra the flesh than Jesus himself. By ordinary in miracles, inasmuch as what authority then are we to con the entire course of things is to him Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ Junel, 18M. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 91 the result of the freewill of the If human nature, or sin’s flesh, are Divinity. This intellectual state the same as the accuser; then, in other was constantly‘that of Jesus.” And words, they must be interchangeable. again, “ In him ” (Jesus) ” was con In any passage, we should be able to densed all that is good and elevated substitute the one for the other, in our nature. He ■was not sinless ; without any violation of its sense. he has conquered the same passions Let us take one. Heb. ii. 14-16; that we combat; no angel of God “ Forasmuch then as the children are comforted him, except his good con partakers of the accuser, he also science ; no satan tempted him, ex himself likewise took part of the cept that which each one bears in same; that through death he might his heart.”* Comment is needless. destroy him that had the power of We are content to say, that the death, that is, human nature; and position taken by this writer opposed deliver them who through fear of to scripture teaching as it is, is the death were all their lifetime subject only consistent one that can be taken to bondage. For verily he took not' by the deniers of the “supernatural,” on him the nature of messengers and “its impossibilites,” so called. (what kind of messengers are these?) But, it is said, that, by alleging but he took on him the accuser.” the existence of such an accusing In this instance “ flesh and blood,” spirit, we make God copartner with and “ the seed of Abraham,” being him, and to have created enormous human nature, are also the accuser, multitudes of mankind for no other and “the devil” is also human nature. destiny than eternal torment. This We think a few trials of this inter is, however, only another infidel changeable method will be sufficient argument, in a slightly modified to prove whether the accuser is shape. Infidels allege, that God can human nature or not. not be a merciful, loving, or good Much more might be written upon being, to condemm multitudes of this subject: should future opportuni mankind to eternal torments, because ty present itself, we will give ‘a 1list’~L the first human pair committed sin of the occurrences of the words, the by eating the fruit of a tree, and for accuser, the adversary, accusers, this cause, punishing others, not prince of the power of the air, and guilty of this act, with death. What so on. For the present, we would ever answer it may be, they, who say notice, that the Hebrew word, ren- they are of the faith, would give todered...... devils in ~Levit xvii. 7 ; Deut. this infidel statement, it will be also xxxii 17; 2 Chron. xi. 15; Psalm the answer which we would give in cvi. 37; Isa. xiii. 21, and xxxiv. 14, reply to the reason of the existence should have been translated goats. of the accuser. It is certain, that no The statements made in the Revel scripture teaches, that any of human ation are as follows : family were ever destined to eternal The accuser or the dragon gives fire or torments ; yet, it is equally hisills power andauu hisuus throne,inruirc, andana great certain, that the scripture does teach authority,” '' "to the- antichrist,i • , or the that the wicked will depart into fire Little Horn, who makes war against age-lasting, which was prepared for the saints for a short season, or forty- the accuser and his messengers. two months. Rev. xii. xiii. The accuser, or the dragon, or the * “ Life of Jesus,” by Ernest Renan—59. old serpent, or the adversary, is bound for a thousand years, Rev. xx. 60, 310. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 92 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. June 1,1886 The adversary or the accuser is power is terminated by being cast loosed at the end of the thousand into the lake of fire, Rev. xx. years, deceives the nations, but his Christianos. IS THE PROXIMITY OF THE KINGDOM OF GOD The ‘‘.Gospel ” Preached by Jesus 1 This is a subject which has perplexed the for the kingdomigdom otof heaven is at hand. ” —Did minds of a few of the brethren this good John the Baptist preach the gospel of the number of years; and consequently requires kingdom ? I, without hesitation say, he did a strict investigation, before we accept or re not 1 as I hope to prove.:. "What was it then, ject it. I presume, that we have all experi that John preached ? Let us turn to Luke iii. ence enough now, or ought to have at least, 3, and there we shall see that the subject of to understand that, in the investigation of John’s preaching was, “the baptism op be- such subjects, our only sure guide is to com PENTANCE FOB THE REMISSION OP SINS.’’ This pare one part of scripture with another; and is explicit: there is no room for mistake here. not to base a theory upon one or two texts, It is evident that the saying, “ Repent ye for about which there is great room for doubt as the kingdom of heaven is at hand,” is but a to their real meaning. mere superaddition to the preaching, as an With regard to the gospel preached by impetus, or warning for the people then to Jesus and his apostles to Jew and Gentile, receive this '• baptism of repentance,” and so being expressed in the sentence “ The king prepare themselves for the manifestation of dom of God is at hand,” I find that a writer, him of whom John was the precursor. L. has wiitten largely upon the subject. But I have already asserted that John the upon examination of L’s writings, I think it Baptist did not preach the gospel of the king is evident, that he is sadly perplexed himself dom of God : it remains for me now to prove in the matter, for his proofs are very meagre, this. Turning to Mark i. 14, 15, we read, and ill to the point. His principal proof is —“Now after that John was put in prison, Mark i 14, 15. “ Now after that John was Jesus came into Galilee preaching the gospel put in prison, Jesns came into Galilee, of the kingdom of God.” It is evident from preaching the gospel of the kingdom of God; this, that John finished his mission before and saying, the rime is fulfilled, and the Jesus began his preaching. Keeping this kingdom of God is at hand; repent ye, and steadily in mind, we read in Acts x. 36, believe the gospel.” This he calls a “ stand 37, and see this fact further illustrated and ard proof text,'' and considers it a sure and confirmed. Mark well the words of Peter— clear proof that the gospel preached by Jesus “ The word which God sent unto the children at first, is the good news that t he kingdom of Israel, preaching peace by Jesus Christ, of God is at hand. He insists that the (he is Lord of all). That word, I say, ye phrase “ and saying ” is explanatory of what know, which was published throughout all precedes it; or in other words, that ‘'preach Judea, and began from Galilee, after the ing the gospel of the kingdom of God.” is baptism which John preached.” See also just saying, “ the time is fulfilled, and the Heb. ii. 3. It is certain from this, that kingdom of God is at hand." He denies J esus began to preach a certain “ word ” that the two latter propositions are super in Galilee after John had finished his mission; added to the preaching of the gospel of the and it is further evident, that this word had kingdom as an impetus or warning to repent not been previously preached in that age by ance ; and cites Mat. xix. 3 ; Mat. xxii. 35, any one else. Now, the question is, what 36; Luke ii. 13 ; Luke iv. 41, as parallel “word” is this? Paul calls it “the great cases in which the phrase “and saying” is salvation which at the first began to le used explanatory of what precedes it. He spoken by the Lord himself.” No one asks,—is there any scripture where the phrase, amongst us will deny I think, that this standing as it does in the above scriptures, is “ word ” is, “ the gospel of the kingdom of used as introducing something additional, God." Seeing then that John the Baptist and not as explanatory of what precedes it ? did not preach the gospel of the kingdom of To this I answer, undoubtedly there is God ; and that he used the saying, “ the In Matt. iii. 1, 2, we read,—“In these days kingdom of God is at hand," it follows that came John the Baptist, preaching in the this saying, or its equivalent “ the kingdom wilderness of Judea, and saying, repent ye of God is at hand," is not the gospel, nor a Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ June 1,1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 9g part of the gospel, but merely superadded by ■ we do not have the same faith that Abraham John and J esus to their respective preachings, had, we cannot be his seed and heirs, accord as an impetus to repentance. ing to the promise made to him and his seed. Paul’s definition of “ the Gospel ” in Gal. Has God made any other promise to man ? iii. 8. will not suit this at hand gospel theory: Let us now compare the gospel preached but L. disposes of this difficulty by simply to Abraham with that preached by Jesus, asserting that this saying of Paul,—“in thee, and see if we can identify them. The gospel (Abraham), shall all nations be blessed,’’ is preached to Abraham is summarily comprised only gospel in a secondary sense. A writer m the sentence,—“In thee shall all nations (J. U.) in the Messenger has well observed be blessed.” The question then is, what is this assumption, which observation, has called the nature and extent of this blessing? I forth the following from L____ “ One maj' dare say it will be admitted by all of us, that ask, what then do you make of Gal. iii. 8 ? it is a complete deliverance of the human race Does not Paul here define the gospel to be from the evils to which it is now subjected, the blessing of. the nations in Abraham? even death itself: and a deliverance of the Paul says that this good message was preached earth from the curse brought upon it by the before , to Abraham. That is before he was disobedience of Adam. Or, in other words,— circumcised, as in the paralied passage of‘ The great salvation which God has in store Rom. iv. But the question is r.ot, what is for the earth, and for man. In Heb. ii. 3. the good message preached so long ago to Paul speaks of a great salvation which began Abraham; but what is the gospel or good to be spoken by the Lord himself. This is message which God hath in these last days none else than the great salvation which is spokeu unto us by his Son ?” We have here set before ns in the gospel of the kingdom of two assumptions. The first is,—“preached God, which is a complete deliverance, to all before the gospel unto Abraham,” means who will receive it, from the bondage of cor before Abraham was circumcised. This is ruption to enjoy the glorious liberty of the • not an assumption that involves any great sons of God ; and to be constituted nation- consequence, that £ can see at present, but blessers with Abraham; and a deliverance of not so with the second. L. has never at the whole creation from the bondage of cor tempted to prove the assumption which J. C. ruption under which it now groans. This is has observed; but seems to think he should “ The great salvation which God has in store get out of the difficulty by further asserting, for the earth, and for man.” Thus we see that the gospel preached so long ago to that the gospel preached to Abraham, and Abraham, is not the question with us. But 1 he gospel preached by Christ and his apostles, I maintain that it is the questionitiou with which are one and the same gospel. I sincerely we have to do ; fox- if the gospelspel preached by hope that L. will candidly consider what I Christ and his apostles be a<"different“_1 o gospel have said; and that he will see that the view from that preached to Abraham,un, it is evident he has taken of the at hand matteris erroneous. we -must have a different faith from that of Abraham. It is further evident, that if Glasgow. J. L. SACRED CRITICISM. . From Gaussen’s “ Theopneustia.” Learning is a doorkeeper< who only will you find inscribed by the conducts you to the temple of the hand of God on all its walls that scriptures. Never forget, then, that God fills it, and that he is every she is not the God, and that her where there, but, further, you will house is not the temple. In other receive the proof of it experimental terms, when you study sacred criti ly. There you will behold him cism, beware of keeping to that, even everywhere; there-you will feel him as regards learning. She leaves you everywhere. In other terms, when in the street; you must enter. And one reads God’s oracles with care, now for the argument. he not only meets with the frequent IfIx youyuix penetrate,pcxxcuxavc, inxxx xauv,fact, intoxxxuv theoxxc declarationucuxxxx Intelligence, Notes, &c- Brooklyn, U. S.—We do not think baptized on 27th April, and on Sunday 29th confidence is in any way violated by yielding were added to the church—May they be pre- to the request of some brethren, and: puuiinii-publish served, soul, body, and spirit, blameless unto ing the following extract from al"letter of the coming of the Lord.” D. W. brother James Forman’s,—“I was glad’ ’ toi Edinburgh,—During the past month we see ‘ the Rochester address ’ in the Msssewjer; have received from Aberdeen, brother and and that it was fully endorsed by the church. sister Alexander Black, who have come to I think the beautiful spirit of that address reside with their family iu the city. In should be carried out. It really is time that balance of this accession, brother Alexander those bickerings were done away, and the Davie has removed to Dundee, to be followed effect of the gospel of peace were tried on the by sister Davie as soon as her health will alienated world. The longer 1 live, and the permit. Brother Robert Archibald has also more I see of the character of God revealed moved to Innerleithen, Peeblesshire. in his works and in his.word the more I am Glasgow,—“On Sunday the 12th May, persuaded that it is the goodness of God that James Pettigrew, of Benhaur Oil Works, bringeth men to repentance, and that the (near Crofthead), was immersed, and added opposite course estranges. Our little meet to the church here, his wife (a daughter of ing in Brooklyn goes on and prospers, and no D. Culbert, once well known among the root of bitternessbitternsss has sprung up. among us— brethren in the west); intends soon to follow we1— keepi------the unity ------ofrn the------spirit:x in the bond of his example, and would indeed have accom peace. Our minds and hopes are set upon panied him but for bad health. May she the glorious appearing of our tLL.elder brotherL soon be able to obey the dictates of her con- from the far country, and believe he will soon sience, when by so doing she follows the will «come—„ to build again thathe tabernacletabernacle ofof DavidDavid ofof the the Lord.Lord.”” C. E. G- which is fallen down. Our number is about Halifax, N. S.—Brother George Kerr, 16—we,meet every first day, to worship, and (from Tranent, Scotland), has arrived at his memorialize■K“ the deathrUafh ofnf theth a Messiah.Moaotah ’”’ destination in safety;safety; he is reported to be Dvunuta,undee,—— “Robertavmmch. Cameron,vamoivu, (mason,yiuuouii, 202ivz “"quitequite hearty after his long andaud stormy PerthT ’ ~Road); ”, John' ’ Menzies,” ’ . (mason), and—2 voyage.” his wife (Ure Street), on.on confessing their Liverpool, —“Dear Brother Dowie, I faith in the things concerning the kingdom of sail to-morrow (May 22), in the steam ship CodGod ™dand thothe namoname of JJesus oc a; Christ were I Marathon, (Cunard line). She seems clean, Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 96 THE MESSENGER OF THE1HE CHURCHES. June 1, I860, and shows some attempt at ventilation, which, and weepeth, bearing precious seed, shall to say the least, is not always the case. _ I doubtless come again with rejoicing, bringing, think any brother passing through Barrow-in- his sheaves with him.” J. R. Furness will find a friend of truth in John Barrow, blacksmith, Chuich Street.”—G. The Brethren are reminded that the Westgarth. Thus has terminated the short circumstances of brother James Robertson, residence of brother Westgarth in England. (37 Chapel Street), Turriff, are still straitened, We presume he returns to Illinois. the ill health referred to above, as well as much • Turriff.—“ Dear brother, once more I more he has had before, indicates also poverty; take up my pen to give you a few lines of by this time his rent should have been paid. intelligence. After being very poorly for Help, either directly, or through our treasurer, some weeks, and making no progress in will be very thankfully received. strength, I arranged to go to Buchan among the brethren, to see if I would improve, and The Treasurer acknowledges receipts for might do them some good.g The following is the Messenger from Birmingham, Bradford- the result:—My health is much improved, on-A von, Halifax. N. S-, Liverpool, Turriff. after three weeks’ stay, during which time J lectured eight times, and offered three exhor tations on Sundays 8th, 15th, 22d of April. Publications. On the afternoon of the 8th I baptized THE DISCIPLES’ CHORAL SERVICE Euphemia Fraser; after which she had to OF BIBLE THEMES, forsake father and mother so as to-save her life; but, having cleaved to the Lord with A collection of Christian Songs,—the full purpose of heart, she immediately found subjects selected from the Holy Scrip a home among the brethren, and is now tures, and set to suitable music (in both engaged for the summer six months. She is notations), arranged for four voices. This sixteen years of age, and, like Nicodemus, I book, got up expressly for the use of the taught her by night, when she was here with brethren in their social services, and suitable her sister Mrs W. Harvey. The same week either for the church or the fireside, I baptized Ann Clark, (youngest daughter of 7s now reduced in price. brother J. Clark of Balfaton), she has been favourably disposed to the truth for some One Shilling in a neat printed cover; One time, but could not intelligently make it her and Sixpence cloth boards, post free. May own until I taught her in company with the be had of G. Dowie, 12 Beaumont Place, former, her age is fourteen, the youngest I Edinburgh. have baptized. These were both received Also may be had of G. Dowie, into fellowship on the 15th April. On the The Messenger of the Churches, 6th of May, Helen Clark, (another daughter of brother Clark’s) was baptized here, at 1st series. Turriff, and the same day received into the A few copies are retained in hand for a fellowship of the church. These all go on short time longer, and can be supplied to the their way rejoicing. The brethren are re brethren at the price before announced, viz : freshed, and I have the comfort of hope that —The four volumes, 1861, 18 62, 1863, 1864, there may be yet a few more additions soon, stitched and in paper covers, Is. each; or the as the result of the good seed, the word of four in one volume, cloth lettered, 4s. 6d. the kingdon, sown on former occasional visits; Postage of single vols. 2d. of cloth vols 6d. and may therefore realise to some extent the vol. 1, (I860) is imperfect; but single num saying that is written “ He that goeth forth i bers of 4-12, may be had at one penny each. The Messenger is Registered for Transmission Abroad. The price Of the Messenger is 2d. a Number, or by post to any part of Great Britain, United States, or the Colonies, 3d- When four or more Nos. are taken they are supplied post free in Britain. Articles should be sent in by the 15th of the month, and items of intelligence not lattr than the 24th ; all papers meant for insertion, or notes of intelligence, may bo forwarded to George Dowie, 12 Beaumont Place; and all business communications to James Cameron, 14 Calton Hill, Edinburgh, to whom money orders should be made payable. ChurchA. AND of W. God R, WILSON, General PRINTERS, Conference: HIGH McDonough,STREET, EDINBURGH. GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES- ♦ “ I SPEAK AS TO WISE MEN, JUDGE YE WHAT I SAY.’* Np. 7. July 1, 1866. New Series. Vol. II. THE LORD’S PROPHECY. We here present, for the readers’ Then saith he unto them, nation shall rise attentive perusal, a harmonized against nation, and kingdom against kingdom, and great earthquakes shall be in divers account of the prophecy of our Lord, places; and there shall be famines, pestilences, contained in the twenty-fourthi and troubles; and fearful sights and great chapter of Matthew, the thirteenth signs shall there be from heaven,. All these chapter of Mark, and the twenty- are the beginning of sorrows. But take heed to yourselves!. For before first chapter of Luke. all these, they shall lay their hands on you, And Jesus went out, and departed from and persecute you, and deliver you np to the temple, and hisdisciples came to him for councils, and to the synagogues, and into to shew him the buildings of the temple, and prisons, to be afflicted; and in the synagogues some spoke, how it was adorned with goodly ye shall...... be beaten ; and ye shall be broughtt stones and gifts; and one of his disciples beforev“1-’------rulers’------andJ kings rfor— ------my name’—’s sake- ; saith unto him, Master, see what manner of and they shall kill you: and ye shall be stones and what buildings are here ! And hated of all nations for my name’s sake, and Jesus answering, saith unto him, See ye not it shall turn to yon for a testimony against all these things ? these great buildings ? them. But when they shall lead you, and Verily I say unto you, as for these things deliver you up, be not anxious beforehand which ye behold, the days will come, in the what ye shall speak. But whatsoever shall which there shall not be left here one stone be given you in that hour, that speak ye: upon another, that shall not be thrown down. for it is not ye that speak, but the Holy And as he sat upon the Mount of Olives, Spirit. Settle ye, therefore, in your hearts, over against the temple, the disciples, Peter not to premeditate to make a defence. For and James and John and Andrew come unto I will give you a mouth and wisdom, which him privately, and asked him, saying, Master, all your adversaries shall not be able to but tell us, when shall these things be, and gainsay nor resist. And then shall many be what the signs when all these things shall offended, and shall betray one another, and come to pass, and be fulfilled ; And what the hate one another. Now the brother shall sign of tny coming, and of the end of the betray the brother to death, and the father age? And Jesus answered and said unto the son; and children shall rise up against them, Take heed that no man deceive you. their parents, and shall cause them to be put For many shall come in my name, saying, I to death. And ye shall be betrayed both by am the anointed, and the time draweth near, parents, and kinsfolks, and friends; and and shall deceive many. Go ye not, there some of you they will put to death. But fore, after them. And ye shall hear of wars, there shall not a hair of your head perish. and rumours of wars. And when ye shall In your patience possess ye your souls. And hear of wars, and rumours of wars, and com many false prophets shall rise, and shall motion, see that ye be not terrifiedor troubled: deceive many, and because the lawlessness for all these things must first come to pass, will abound, the love of the many shall wax but the end is not yet. cold. But he that shall endure unto the end, Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 98 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. July 1, 1868, the same shall be saved : and this glad the heaven will be shaken. And then shall tidings of the kingdom shall be preached in appear the sign of the Son of Man in the all the habitable, for a testimony unto all heaven: and then shall all the tribes of the nations, and then shall the end come. earth mourn, and they shall see the Son of And when ye, therefore, shall see Jerusalem Man coming upon the clouds of the heaven compassed______.J __withSxU ____armies,*__ xl ______thenI-** know-___ xl that___x xl.the with power and great glory. And then shall desolationA M A ■ AA X— —— A.A XT~thereof AA AAA. AA £ —is A— A*nigh, “ A—Ta audA --3 Xthe T. AA abomina-AA 1a AA A A „ A he send his messengers with a great sound of tion of the desolation,, spoken of by Daniel a trumpet and they shall gather together his the-prophet, standing where it ought not, in chosen from the four winds, from the one end the holy place, (wh THE PERSONALITY OF SATAN. This topic has been chosen for tural truths; we wait for light, and remark in the present case, not be shall be glad to be put in possession cause it is of peculiar interest, or of solid reasons, either in confirma regarded as of paramount importance, tion of what we hold, or reject. The in the estimation of the writer. It question has never appeared to us of has been to him for a good many much practical importance : so long years a subject surrounded with as the Lord Jesus Christ is believed great difficulties. The arguments in as the destroyer of sin; and the for, and against the personality of vanquisher of all evil beings—so long the Devil, or Satan, have been as there exists a determination to frequently weighed by him, with crucify the flesh—to be separate from the result that he finds it much all sin, and eschew all inducements easier to urge objections against both, to evil, it seems to us of little practi than to satisfy himself with argu cal moment whether the devil of ments for either. This much, how scripture be a person or a principle. ever, must be acknowledged, that Of late, however, this question has the language of Scripture, in many received an importance of the first instances, seems unable to sustain, magnitude, among brethren in certain if fairly treated, the non-personal i_quarters : so much so, that the belief view, yet that language needs only that the devil of scripture isa person, is to be quoted, to state the idea, that thought to nullify any faith a person the devil is a person. Indeed, it,is may have regarding the kingdom of impossible to express the non-per God, or the Lord Jesus Christ. sonal view in the simple language Brethren have been denied the ame of the Bible, while it seems, simply, nities of Christian fellowship, because, to express the opposite. It is because in addition to their believing these of this circumstance, that the writer things, they hold that the Satan of is prepared in the meantime to accept the Bible is not a principle, but a the latter view, with all its difficulties, person. Without passing any ver as the scriptural one. Still our mind dict on the propriety of such conduct, is not so satisfied as on other scrip in the meantime, it may be per- Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 100 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. July 1,1885. mitted us to say, that it surely said to spring.” The manner in becomes those who attach so much which he discharges this “impera importance to belief in the non-per- tive ” duty is somewhat astonishing. sonality of the devil, to demonstrate The first passage he puts up .is that idea from the scriptures; not Jude, verse 6th, “The angels which merely giving interpretations of kept noc their first estate, but left scripture in favour of their own idea, their own habitation, he hath reserved but, also, patiently and candidly, in everlasting chains under darkness examining those passages which are unto the judgment of the great day." supposed to teach that the devil is a . On these words he remarks:— being; and show how the use of such “The word ‘ reserved ’ presents the idea that language can be otherwise accounted these angels are still alive, and will at some for. This we have not seen fairly, future day come up for judgment. The' and fully done. The latest attempt original text, however, conveys no snob, at this sort of thing, we have seen, impression. It declares that Jehovah has kept them with, or consigned them to, per- presented itself to us in the form of ~>etual chains, under thick or intense darkness. , a pamphlet, bearing the sensational, _Iow can they ever be released from ’perpetual if not elegant, title of “ The Devil bonds?’ How can they ever rise to judg and Hell.” * There is much in the ment from the perpetual chains of death, in the ‘ thick darkness ’ of which they are kept ? pamphlet with which we agree ; and From this, and that passage in 2 Peter, ii. 4, it is only in so far as it relates to the it is inferred that the devil was one (the chief) non-personality of the devil, that we of these disobedient angels therein men have to do with it in the meantime. tioned. But this cannot be, seeing that they all are in perpetual death, or in other words, The author avers that it is not from for ever put out of existence. Wherever, “ a wish to gratify sceptical or vul therefore, the king of the' lake of burning gar ambition,” but “ the settled brimstone may come from, it is evident bis conviction of the vast consequences descent is not from the angels spoken of by of right or wrong understanding, Jude and Peter.” p. 7. relative to the devil and hell, that In a prefatory note the author has induced ” him to call attention acknowledges his “ indebtedness to to these matters. It was therefore John Thomas, M.D.” for enabling . with some interest and expectancy him “to set before the public the we turned to his demonstration ; but things contained ” in his pamphlet; the result has been far from satis but the foregoing extract must have factory. The author has allowed been drawn from another source. his native turn for humour to blunt It asserts boldly that these angels his causality, so that his remarks are not reserved unto judgment at have more fun than force in them ; some future day; but are already and his performance seems open to 11 for ever put out of existence”; the charge of flippancy. while the verdict of Dr Thomas is, Setting out with the assumption, that they shall be “ judged in the day that the devil of scripture is not a of Christ ” ; for he has written :— person, but a principle, the writer “ But what is to become of the Evil of the pamphlet honestly acknow Angels in everlasting chains of darkness, and ledges that it is “ imperative ” on who shall be their judge ? Jude says, they him “ to appeal to those particular were committed, 1 for the Judgment of the passages whence the devil-theory is Great Day.’ ’’ He alludes to this great day in his quotation of the prophecy of Enoch, saying, ‘ Behold the Lord cometh with ten * The Devil and Hell; By Edward Tur thousand of his Holy Ones (angels of bis ney : Nottingham. 26 pp. price 3d. might, 1 Thess. 1. 7.) to execute judgment Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ July 1, 1856. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 101 upon all,’ &c. This coming of the Lord to king of Babylon. A simple reference judgement is' termed by Paul ‘ The Day of to verse 4th would have been suffi Christ ’—‘ a day in which he will judge the world in righteousness, by Jesus Christ,’— cient. for that -purpose, as the. -prophet - Muuugduring whichnmuu the oaiius,saints, withwuu ungcisangels luuusier-minister- is; there told tow “take up this proverbv - Jing nor Iinirtunto fV»OTV»them, havingliovinrr Kvra/Ilived again,OA-oJn will reignrnirrn against the Ixiwxr*king of TJaIvrrBabylon, 1 An ” of with Christ a thousand years on the earth. which proverb, verse 12th forms a This is the Great Day of Judgment, a period of one thousand years, in which Christ and part. These are the only passages his saints will govern the nations righteously, which our author thinks fit to ex and award to the rebel angels the recompense amine, “ whence the devil-theory is awaiting their transgression. ‘Know ye not,’ said to spring.” “ A few other tes saith Paul, ‘ that we (the saints) shall juage angels ? How much more things that per timonies,” he avers, “ might be ex tain to this life? ’ From these data wo con amined that are supposed to support clude that these angels will be judged in the the common devil notion; ” these Day of Christ by Jesus and the saints.’’ he dismisses by the short and easy Elpis Israel., p. 10. method of asserting that they are We think it a pity that Mr Tur “ in reality no support at all! ” ney has preferred his own judgment Is this fair 1 1 loes the author of to that of Dr Thomas, in this in this pamphlet really believe that he stance, as the latter has - adhered has discharged the imperative duty more closely to “ the original text,” of examining the proof passages as well as to the obvious sense of alleged by the believers in a per the English translation. But grant sonal devil ? If so, he must be very ing this to be the case, what is the ignorant of the arguments in favour worth of this passage as a proof that of the theory he opposes; his read the devil, or Satan, is a being 1 None ing on the subject must have been whatever. . The term “ devil ” or very one-sided indeed. We rather “ Satan ” does not occur in the pas take this view of the' case, as we sage ; and while these angels are cannot suppose that it is either reserved, or kept in perpetual bonds through want of courage or honesty until the judgment of the great day, that he has entirely evaded the ex the devil is not to be bound till amination of those passages of scrip during the “ thousand years,” after ture which are thought to sustain which he is to be cast into the lake the' belief that the devil of the Bible of fire. We therefore quite agree is a person. By so doing, his work with the writer of “ the Devil. and must prove a failure in convincing Hell,” that Satan is not one of the those who are intelligently, though, angels spoken of by Peter and Jude it may be, mistakenly persuaded of in the passages alluded to; and we that idea.' presume that few. who believe in the The same ignorance or oblivious personality of the devil, will feel ness of what is really held by those their position much weakened by who believe that the terms, “ the the same. The other passage which devil ” and “ Satan ” are applied in our author cites as an talleged ” proof scripture to a particular being, char- of the personality of Satan, --is IsaiahT—acterises the whole of the reasoning xiv. 12, “ How art thou fallen from of the pamphlet before us. Its heaven, O, Lucifer, son of the morn author seems to have drawn his ing ! how art thou cut down to the picture of the devil he demolishes ground, which didst weaken the from certain grotesque representa nations ! ” which he is at some pains tions which are exhibited in book to shew is spoken concerning the sellers’ windows at a particular season Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 102 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. Juiyi.w of the year, which have their origin <*devil, there would be little left, of in the conceits of Scandinavian my- argument or ridicule, against the idea thology—not from a perusal of such of his personality. writings as treat of the personality Perhaps the author’s reason for of the devil, as a doctrine of scrip treating the question thus, is be ture. So that we can hold our be cause he considers the existence of lief in the personality of Satan, and the devil to involve, necessarily, his yet walk along with our friend when indestructibility. He evidently does he “ ventures to affirm, that though view’ the' matter so. “ The Bible,” there is a devil often spoken of in he writes, “ speaks only of two scripture, he is no relation to the natures, one the human, the other gentleman above described,” p. 6. divine. The first is corruptible, the There is yet another point on last deathless. Seeing, then, that which we can agree with our author, the devil of the Bible was not of the and yet retain our belief, namely, divine or deathless, it follows that that the devil is not indestructible— he must be of the corruptible, or that he shall be destroyed. Most human, and this conclusion is esta decisively do the scriptures speak on blished by the mission of Jesus to this point, and most cordially do destroy or put him to death,” p. 9. we believe that the Son of God was The logical sequence of this quota- manifested . to destroy “ not only ” tion is, that the devil must be a the works of the devil, but also human being ! We have no wish to “ that through death he might de dispute that idea at present; but stroy him that had the power of that is not the conclusion which the , death—that is, the devil,” Heb. ii. writer wishes to be drawn. It is 14, 15. this—If the devil be of another So far, then, we are at one. We order of being than the human, he agree that the two passages cited in must therefore be indestructible. this pamphlet as proofs of- the per This is a proposition we cannot sonality of Satan, are silent on the admit on such authority. Suppos- point. We also agree that the portraits ing that the devil of scripture is5 a commonly given of the devil, do not 1being ~ —------supposing~ * 1him ‘ ’to ’be a— wicked:-’- belong to the person so named in angel, how does it follow that he is scripture; and that the devil of indestructible? Are all beings in scripture is doomed to destruction God’s universe self existent but by the Son of God, who, by his man ? Does not the highest obedience until death, has received order of creatures, whatever that a name that is above every name.' order may be, owe its existence to Yet admitting all this, the real ques God? And if he gives an angel tion at issue remains untouched. being, and sustains that being, can Is that which in scripture is called he not, by his word, deprive that the devil and Satan, a person or a angel of life ! Can God create super principle ? This simple view of the human beings, but not destroy them? matter is scarcely alluded to in this Surely not; and if not, how does it pamphlet. The shafts of the author’s follow that if the devil be else than reasoning are almost entirely pointed human, he is indestructible ? against the immortality or indestruc In a subsequent paragraph, the tibility of the devil; so that if we writer modifies his statement regard- erase fromf its pages all that is spoken ing the indestructibility of the devil, against the indestructibility of the if he be an angel. “ But how could Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ July 1, 1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 103 Jesus destroy the devil 1 How could a name that is above every name ; mortal vanquish immortal ? For the that at the name of Jesus every knee Son of God, who took not on him should bow of things in heaven, and the nature of angels, but took on things in earth, and things under the him the seed of Abraham, who was earth, and every tongue confess that in ail things made like unto his Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of (mortal) brethren, for him, I say, to God the Father.” crush the devil, was absurdly impos Our friend has yet something sible.” These are bold startling terible in reserve for those who words. We earnestly hope that the believe that the devil is a being : he writer of them will think again ; for states it thus :— he has written, what seems to us, “ A little consideration must convince any .dishonouring - to the .Son of God. It person of common sense, that not only was is, however, only with the logic of it impossible for the Son to dispatch the grim the statement that we have to deal. monster, but the Father himself could not Simplified, it resolves itself into this, put him out of existence. ' It is evident that the devil must have existed-by the consent of- “ Jesus was a man, therefore he can God, or against his will. If by his consent, not destroy an angel.” Why not, then God and the devil are friends, and there if God empowers him to do so? is no reason in the theory which makes God And God has given to him “all cast him out of heaven into hell, or in anyway antagonize his extensive operations. But if POWER IN HEAVEN AND ON EARTH.” on the other hand, he exists against His will, Yea, blessed be his name for ever then it follows that God is weaker than he.” and ever1—This man, Christ Jesus, our brother, is, by far, superior to We shall readily admit that if the the angels, “He hath by inheritance devil exists against the will, i.e, obtained a more excellent name than permission of God, then must the they.” Already, he is exalted to a devil be stronger than God ; but we, seat of honour, to which no sangel by no means can allow that, if God shall attain—“The right hand 'of permits the devil to exist, the devil the Majesty on high.” Angelsj and God must be friends—If “ any announced his birth, and ministered[ person of common sense” admit that, to him in the days of his flesh, and it must be because he has given the when he comes again into the world proposition very “ little considera “ all the angels of God shall worship tion” indeed; that is to say, unless he him.” Nay more 1 not only he, but be an atheist. The permission of those of the human race, who, by his evil, and evil things, by God, has grace, are called “ his brethren,” perplexed . many a mind; it may shall in the age to come, “judge seem strange to us, who are “ of angels,” How much more shall he, yesterday and know nothingbut who is the brightness of his Father’s if we believe in God, and have our glory, and the express image of his eyes open, or have faith in the words person—vanquish all the enemies of of history, human and divine, we God and gcodness, be they men or cannot help seeing that God does devils ! But the Son of Man took permit evil beings to live, and to do part of flesh and blood, “that through a fearful amount of mischief; yet we death he might destroy the devil.” are far from believing that these Yea, indeed, he “became obedient workers of iniquity are in friendship unto death, even xthe death of the with God. We feel tempted to cross, wherefore God also hath !subject the reasoning just quoted, to highly exalted him, and given him 1the reductio ad absurdum; but we Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 104 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. July 1,1808. feelconfidentthatthemostof reflective him; but fondly hope that our uivuufriend,, persons will easily perceive that the who has faith in God and his gospel, reasoning of our author is as appli- will, on deeper thought, see that the cable to “ sin in the flesh,” as to sin sword he has here employed has two in the devil. It matters not whether edges, and cuts equally keen, whether sin be' perpetuated in a seriess of the devil of the Bible be a very long- . beings, or in one individual existence lived person, or principle. —the relation in which the Almighty The space already occupied warts stands to the permission of continued us to close for the present, but we evil, through either of these modes trust that what we. have advanced is exactly the same. We have often shall be of service, either in correcting heard the argument used by the wrong notions, or suggesting some secularist against the idea of Deity ; thoughts more beneficial. andwefeltsomedifficultyin satisfying W. L. ' WHAT IS THE TRITE AGE OF THE WORLD? In round numbers, 6000 year’s, say 1.000 years’ reign, and from its sup those who base their chronology on posed consistency with the com the Hebrew scriptures. Nay, say monly received age of the world, those who adopt the Greek version based on the Hebrew Old Testa- as their guide, the world is upwards ment, as being not yet 6000 years. of 7400 years old 1 It has even been elevated to the A tradition is said, on good position of a base-line of prophetic authority, to have been current chronology, periods and dates being among both Jews and Gentiles of interpreted so as to suit its dimen ancient times, that the world should sions with the greatest nicety. exist for 6000 years in a state of As there are weighty reasons for evil, to be followed by 1000 years thinking the chronology, founded on in a state of good. This tradition x1the * SeptuagintL------version,‘— ------more~~~ accur appears to rest upon nothing more ate than that based on the Hebrew, solid than an analogy derived from I propose to submit a few facts to the six days of creation, followed by shew the true state of the case. the seventh day of rest. It has no These are happily of. a very simple foundation in the scriptures, so far nature, being for the most part con as the 6000 years is concerned, fined to the ages of the patriarchs, which is the essential part of it ; from AdamA to. Noah, before the as the Millenium, or- 1000 years’ flood, anda from Shem to Abraham reign of Christ and the saints, men- after it.. Thus, reckoning from the tioned in the Bevelation, is not ie- birth of one patriarchy to the birth presented as sustaining any chrono- of his first-born son, aud so down to logical relation to the milleniums, the 600th year of Noah, there is, few or many, that may have pre according to the Hebrew, a period ceded it. Notwithstanding the from the Creation to the Deluge, of silence of scripture regarding the 1656 years. This period, calculated subject of this human tradition, it in the same way, is, according to the still finds favour among writers on Septuagint, 2242 years, being 586 prophecy, from its seeming to sup years longer than the Hebrew. port the doctrineChurch of Godconcerning General Conference:the Proceeding McDonough, on the GA; same principle, Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ July 1,1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 105 the period from the Flood to the was born, making the age of the birth of Abraham, is, according to world at the birth of Enos, 235 the Hebrew, 292 years, while accord years—thus, 130 + 105 = 235. ing to the Septuagint, it is 1072 According to the Septuagint, the years, 780 years longer than the age of the world at the birth of Hebrew. The difference is caused Adam’s grandson, Enos, would be in both lists mainly by a number of 435 years, the age of Adam at the the generations being just 100 years birth of Seth being 230, and the age longer in the Septuagint than in the of Seth at the birth of Enos being Hebrew. x 205 years. Having thus briefly stated the The omission of Cainan diminishes discrepancy between the Hebrew and the age of the world by 130 years, Greek chronological data, and shewn this being, according to the Septua in what it consists, I will now men gint, the age of Cainan at the birth tion a few facts to enable the reader of his son Sala. to judge for himself on which side From these two periods, then, the the truth is to be found. commonly received chronology is First, then, the list of patriarchs, diminished by 1366 years, and the from Shem to Abraham, has one world is older by this number of more in the Septuagint than in the years if the Septuagint is found in Hebrew, namely, Cainan. More this point to be more reliable. over, he is also included in' the There is another period in which genealogy given by Luke, chap. iii. the commonly received chronology Our common version, which follows is shortened, even when judged by the Hebrew, says, “ Arphaxad . . . the Hebrew itself. This is the period begat Salah ... . and Salah begat from the Exodus to the foundation Eber,” Gen. xi. 12, 14. Luke says, of Solomon’s Temple. The marginal “ Heber, who was the son of Sala, dates in the common version make who was the son of Cainan, who this period extend from 1491 to 1011 was the son of Arphaxad,” Luke iii. before Christ, being a period of 480 35, 36. Here it will be at once ob years, as indeed it is expressly stated served that Cainan is represented by to be in 1 Kings vi. 1. Without Luke as the son of Arphaxad, and entering minutely into this period, I consequently grandson of Shem. content myself with stating that the This is confirmed by the Septuagint data in the book of Judges, as to the version, which says, “ Arphaxad periods of foreign servitude, and as begatJ — ..J. Cainan,_ *______and- 1 Cainan______1begat______l X*to thexl intervening*._j______ruleT_ ofZ* 11the 2judges, J _ Sala.” The absence of this patri taken in connection with Paul’s arch from the Hebrew text, and his statement of the total period of the presence in the Septuagint and judges, contained In Acts xiii. 20, Luke’s genealogy are'circumstances make it evident that upwards of 100 decidedly in favour of the superior years are here abridged from the accuracy, on this point, of the Greek. true age of the world. Hence 1 In order to explain the mode in Kings vi. 1. must be erroneous. which the chronology is deduced There are several circumstances from the data in question, it may be mentioned in the patriarchal history mentioned that Adam being, accord which, but for the lengthened chron ing to the Hebrew account, 130 ology contained in the Septuagint years old at the birth of Seth, and version would be very difficult of Seth being 105 years old when Enos explanation. For example it is said Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 106 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. July 1, ,1869. that in the days of Peleg the earth temporaries—Noah 58 years, Shem was divided—Gen. x. 25. Now, 210, Arphaxad 148, Salah 178, Eber the Hebrew, as may be seen from 239, Peleg 48, Reu 78, Sarug 101, the common version (Gen. ix. 28; representing nine preceding genera xi. 10-19), makes Noah, Shem,. tions, their ages ranging from 950 Arphaxad, Salah, and Eber, all con down to 230 year's. Nay, more, temporary with Peleg. A.nd not Abraham was outlived by Shem, only so, but these five patriarchs all Salah, and Eber, representing re survive Peleg—Noah 10 years, Shem spectively the ninth, seventh, and 162, Arphaxad 100, Salah 130, sixth generations of his ancestors. In and Eber 171. Whatever is meant these circumstances it is difficult to by the earth being divided in the see how Abraham could be said to days of Peleg, (and it must have die in a good old age 1 On the other had an intimate relation to him, see hand, the Greek version makes Abra ing that his name is derived from it), ham the survivor of all his ancestors, that event took place as truly in the and thus presents another strong days of his great, great, great grand collateral testimony to its own ac father Noah, who was not only his curacy. At the same time the Greek contemporary during his whole life version shews a more gradual short time, and outlived him 10 years, but ening of the life of man than the must have been looked up to as the Hebrew does. most important personage in the The data contained in the writings world. This anomaly has no exis of Josephus are substantially identical tence if the Greek version be followed; with the Septuagint version, and this Noah dying 520 years before Peleg, shows not only that that version is Shem 368, Arphaxad 330, Salah the more accurate, but also that the 170, and Eber 69. This has at least corruption of the Hebrew text had the appearance of a natural course of not taken place until at least the events, and leaves Peleg chief patri first century; for it can hardly be arch. after the death of his father for conceived that if the discrepancy had 69 years. Whether the division of then existed, Josephus would have the earth took place in his infancy preferred the Septuagint without or during his patriarchate, or atf1 any giving* - 1his -- -~~reasons.------other period of his life, it may be As I have referred to the corrup difficult to determine ; but the force tion of the Hebrew text, I will only of the facts just mentioned remains mention here that the most eminent undiminished, as clearly pointing to chronologists agree in thinking that the superior accuracy of the Greek the Septuagint and Josephus are version. correct, and that the Hebrew text Another anomaly may be here has been tampered with by the Jews mentioned, shewing the extreme un- during the early centuries _ of the likehood of the Hebrew being free Christian era, in order to escape the from corruption. Abraham was told, force of the arguments of the Chris “ Thou shalt go to thy fathers in tians that Jesus is the Christ, because peace; thou shalt be buried in a he had appeared at a time which good old age.” And it is recorded tradition had indicated. that he “ died in a good old age, an The age of the world, then, may old man and full of years.” Now be said to be in round numbers 7500 according to the Hebrew text Abra years instead of 6000, the traditional ham died agedChurch 175, ofand God had General for con- Conference:millenium McDonough, of sabbatic GA; rest being Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ July 1,1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 107 consequently a myth, and already put in his own power.” That power numbered among the years of the will yet be exercised in blessing the past. But the old truth remains— world with the “ rest which re- “ It is not for you to know the times maineth for the people of God.” or the seasons which the Father hath J. C. FAMILIAR SPIRITS. In Deut. xviii. 9 to 22; warning is clean spirits to pass out of the given to the children of Israel to land.” avoid certain practices, which other “ Or a consulter with familiar nations followed after, but which are spirits.” In Levit xx. 27, it is declared to be an abomination to the declared, that “a man, also, orwoman, Lord. Had these things a positive that hath a familiar spirit, or that is existence among the nations 1 Most a wizard, shall surely be put to death.” assuredly, or they would not have In Levit. xix. 31; “Regard not them been practised by them. The ques that have familiar spirits.” There tion we have to ask, is not, whether are two distinct parties named in they were founded on falsehood or the these passages. On the one hand, truth, or a mixture of both, but, the “ consulter,” “ a man,” or whether they actually existed. In “woman,” and “them.” On the the passage of scripture we are other, the “ familiar spirit,” or referring to, a list of them is given, “ spirits.” It will be admitted that which we will give, with other scrip the first named had a positive exis ture references, so that the reader tence. But, will it be said, that they may decide for himself, whether they are also the same as the second actually existed or not. named. If so, the scripture should “ His son or his daughter to pass read, “ Or a consulter who is a through the fire”—Compare Levit. familiar spirit;” and, “ a man, also, xviii. 21 ; 2 Kings xvi. 3; 2 Kings or woman, that is a familiar spirit;” xxi. 6; 2 Kings xxiii. 10; Jer. xix. and, “ Regard not them that are 5 ; Ezek. xx. 3. |I familiar spirits.” “Or that useth divination, or an In the Scripture, commonly called observer of times, or an enchanter, the New Testament, we meet with or a witch, or a charmer, or a wizard, expressions, as in the following or a necromancer.” Compare Exodus passages : Matt. x. 1, “He gave them vii. 11, 22; viii. 7, 18; Gen, xli. 8; power over unclean spirits.” Matt, Num. xxii. 7; 1 Sam. vi. 2; 2 Chron. xii. 43, “ When the unclean spirit is xxxiii. 6 ; Daniel i. 20; ii. 2 ; iv. 7 ; gone out of a man,lie walketh through v. 7; Isaiah xliv. 25; xlvii. 13; dry places, seeking rest and finding Matthew ii. 1; Acts xix. 9. none; then he saith, I will return “ Falseprophets,” 15 to 22 v. Com unto my house whence I came out, pare Deut. xiii. 1 to 5; 1 Kings xviii. Then goeth he, and taketh with 19; 1 Kings xxii. 6, 22; Ezek. xiii. himself seven other spirits more 16; xiv. 9; and Zech. xiii. 1 to 5. wicked than himself, and they enter In this last passage, it is declared, in: and dwell there.” Mark i. 23, that, in that day, the Lord “ will “There was in their synagogue a man cause the prophets and the un with an unclean spirit—and when Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 108 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. July 1,1m the unclean spirit had torn him, and about Paul, but as the words contain cried with a loud voice, he came out nothing about a human spirit, the of him.” passage is excluded from consideration Acts v. 16, “sick folks, and them at this time,” so that we are fully which were vexed with unclean justified, by the testimony of scrip- spirits;” viii. 7, “For unclean spirits, ture, in believing that familiar spirits crying with loud voice, came out of exist, and, that it is impossible and many that were possessed ; ” xvi. 16, improbable that God should make “A certain damsel possessed of a laws against that which has no spirit of divination (or of Python). positive existence. But Paul being grieved, turned and The case of Samuel is the only one said to the spirit, I command thee in on record of a man being brought the name of Jesus Christ, to come up from the dead by a consulter with out of her;” xix. 12, “And the familiar spirits. There is no proof diseases departed from them, and the that the Witch of Endor, or any evil spirits came out of them;” and, similar persons ever had the power xix. 16, “and the man in whom the to summon the -dead from their evil spirit was leaped on them,” graves, so that the scripture student These are only a few of numerous is not required to believe that which passages to be found in the scriptures. is not written, or to understand, that Will it be asserted that persons those possessed with familiar spirits, possessed by unclean or evil spirits, could summon the dead to answer were the unclean or evil< spirits any inquiries, at any time. themselves. If so, why do the scrip The scriptural account of SamueFs tures make a distinction between appearance is to be found in 1 Sam. spirits and persons. The persons xxviii. But another version, accord- exist, so-did the spirits, if scripture ing to modern interpretation, should testimony is to be accepted as true. be1 substituted in its place. It runs If these spirits were the spirits of somewhat as follows:— those whom they possessed, then, “ Then ' said the ventriloquist whenever they came out, in obedience woman,* “ whom shall I bring up to the command of the Lord and the unto thee?”, and he said, “bring up apostles, the possessed would cease to Samuel.” And when the woman did live ; for, the spirit of a man, accord not see Samuel, she made pretence ing to scripture, is always to be to have brought him up, and cried identified with the man himself. with a loud voice, or screamed, and It is well observed by a recent spake to Saul, pretending then to writer,* when remarking on Job, recognize him for the first time, iv. 15, that, “while Eliphaz declares although she must have known him he saw in vision “ a spirit,” he does from the first, saying, “why hast not say it was a human spirit, and thou deceived me, for thou art Saul.” who would affim that “ a spirit” and And the king said unto her, “ be “ a human spirit ” are the same not afraid; for what sawest thou ? ” things ?” And again, on Acts, xxiii. And the woman said unto Saul; 9, “ but if a spirit (pneurna) or an (this however being only a pretence angel hath spoken to him, let us not of the woman), “ I saw gods ascend- fight against God.” So spoke “scribes ing out of the earth.” And he said that were of the Pharisees’ part,” * The -writer first saw the ventriloquist explana tion, some twelve years since, in Faber’s “Many *W, G. Moncrieff, on Spirit, pp 24, 43, 44. Mansions of My Father’s House.” Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ July i, 1865. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 109 unto her, “ what form is he of ?” and Amalek, therefore hath the Lord she said, knowing that Samuel did done this thing unto thee this day.” wear a mantle or robe, (as did other And, continued the ventriloquist prophets), either from personally see woman, speaking from her probable ing him, or from description of others acquaintance with the past history “ an old man cometh up ; and he is of Israel, and shrewdly guessing the covered with a mantle.” And Saul, result of a conflict between Saul’s although he perceived or knew that forces, and those of the Philistines, it was Samuel, yet did not see with while Saul suffered under the Lord’s his own eyes that it was Samuel, but displeasure :—“ Moreover the Lord only knew from the woman’s pre will also deliver Israel with thee tended description of that which she into the hand of the Philistines ; and did not see, that it was Samuel; yet at some time to' come, either to he stooped with his face to the morrow or hereafter, shalt thou and ground, and bowed himself. thy sons be with me ; the Lord also Then the ventriloquist woman, or shall deliver the host of Israel into an accomplice, imitating the voice of the' 'hand ' of' 'the "Philistines...... ”’ And Samuel, whose voice she had prob the woman, without one word of ably not heard in her life,—and for rebuke to Saul, who knew that he getting that it would appear strange was under the displeasure of the to make a man, said to be brought Lord, and would incur his dis- up from the grave, ignorant of events pleasure more so for consulting with that had transpired since his death familiar spirits, (which' -1--1- Saul himself and burial, spoke thus :—“ Why hast had put down in Israel), ceased thou disquieted me to bring me up ?” imitating the voice of Samuel. Then and Saul answered, “ I am sore dis Saul fell straightway all along on tressed ; for the Philistines makei the earth, and was sore afraid, be war against me, and God is departed cause of the words of the ventrilo from me, and answereth me no more, quist woman, who had imitated the neither by prophets, nor by dreams ; voice of Samuel. And there was therefore I have called thee, that no strength in him, for he had eaten thou mayest make known unto me no bread all the day, nor all the what I shall do.” night. The woman having thus cunningly Which is the true account 1 The obtained the knowledge of the matter Scriptural or the modern? The on which Saul desired to be informed; reader is left to decide for himself. and from her probable knowledge of The writer prefers the Scriptural, the rejection of Saul, and selection For he believes, that, “ literalism is of David, to be king over Israel, the God honouring acceptance of His again imitating the voice of Samuel, word,” and prefers receiving “ the said, “ Wherefore then dost thou ask unaltered words of Scripturebefore of me, seeing the Lord is departed any interpretation which modern from thee, and is become thineenemy? science may be pleased to put upon and the Lord hath done for himself, them. as he spake by mine hand; for the It is true that the Lord did not Lord hath rent the kingdom out of answer Saul previous to this, either thine hand, and given it to thy “ by Urim, or by dreams, or by pro neighbour, to David; because thou phets.” But there is not one sentence obeyest not the voice of the Lord, to prove that the Lord did not intend nor executedst his fierce wrath upon to answer at a future time. And, we Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/city of the Samaritans enter ye not; expressly mentioned fact that they but go rather to the lost sheep of the announced, not the near approach of house of Israel; and as ye go preach, the day of Christ as a new thing, but saying, The kingdom of heaven is only stirred up the minds of the at hand.” Luke ix. 2 and 6, should brethren by way of remembrance. 2 be viewed in connection with this Peter iii. The passage, 2 Thess. ii. quotation from Matth. x. 5, 6, 7. 2, is an exception only by a false Luke says that Jesus sent the twelve translation. The original word for to preach the kingdom of God. But “ at hand ” is everywhere else ren- Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ 24 THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. February 1,18EB. dered “ present,” or “ come.” Paul that the primary meaning of the term blames not the Thessalonians for be gospel is,—The fact of the kingdom lieving that the day of Christ was at of God being at hand. This is the hand; but for believing it had come. ground of gospel repentance. On no [Clement, Paul’s fellow-labourer, in other point are the teachings of Jesus one of his epistles to the Corinthians, more frequent or solemn, Matt. xxiv. expressly declares that the apostles, 42-51 ; Mark xiv. 24-37 ; Luke xii. after the ascension of Messiah, went 35-48, &c., &c. And with the re- abroad among all nations, preaching ception or rejection of no other truth that the kingdom of God was at did the Lord ever more solemnly hand.] connect the salvation or condenma- In the New Testament, the fact of tion of men, Matt. x. 14, 15 ; Mark the kingdom being at hand, made, xvi. 15, 16. L. from Matthew to Revelation, the main ground of repentance. Jesus * [The above article had lain over a month, in consequence of some doubt as to the pre began by saying,—“ Repent, for the cise meaning of the writer. Upon being re. kingdom of God is at handand ferred to, he furnished the following in ex this doctrine is carried onward to the planation :—“ With regard to the kingdom end by his apostles, till it is again being at hand, when I said that this was, in the strict original meaning of the term, The taken up by himself in the Apoca Gospel, I just meant what I said. . . . That lypse. But nowhere do we perceive the kingdom of God is at hand—is a great the least vestige of this doctrine,— scriptural truth, the meaning and bearings of “ Repent, for the kingdom of God is which have only to be fully explained, to show the propriety of its being entitled to the ap ■ come.” On the contrary, the coming pellation of “ The Gospel.” Matt. x. 7, U, of the kingdom puts an end to the 15, and Mark xvi. 15, 16, very clearly show space for repentance. The kingdom that man’s eternal condition was suspended being come, instead of repent (reform upon his reception of it. That Jesus is the Christ, is also a very important scriptural or amend your lives), the awful sen truth ; the Christian Church is built upon it; tence goes forth,—“ He that is un to believe and confess it, is essential to salva- „just, .... ., let______him be.. unjust__v still,; and______he tion. Yet all this may be true without mak- which is filthy, let him be filthy ing it out to be The Gospel, in the strict pri- still,-----” —Rev. xxii. - 11. ----When - themary sense of the term. The scriptural gos pel, or good news, is the gospel of, or concern Lord is come, and the righteous are, ing the Kingdom. Now, the good news for the first time, invited to enter which Jesus preached concerning the king into his kingdom, then shall the king dom,' was just this, that it was at hand. say to the wicked, not, repent, but, Jesusdid not preach the kingdom itself to the Jews: the prophets did that. Neither did “ depart from me, ye cursed, into Jesus, as a general thing, preach to the everlasting fire; prepared for the Jews, that He was the Messiah : and he par devil and his angels.” ticularly enjoined his apostles, more than It is true, indeed, that 1800 years once, not to do so; while their daily employ ment was to preach the gospel. have elapsed since it was said, “ The Hence, that Jesus is the Messiah, is not kingdom of God is at hand.” Hence the original gospel; yet it is very closely con ignorant scoffers have, as was pre nected with it; for the fact, that the Messiah dicted, arisen, “ walking after their has come in the flesh, that be has appeared as the seed of David, that he has been reject own lusts, and saying, Where is the ed and crucified, as was before written; that he promise of his coming 1” But “one has sat down at the right hand of God, that day is with the Lord as a thousand he is therefore ready to come—as it were— years, and a thousand years as one at amoment’a warning:—all this is comprised day.” in the proposition, that Jesus is the Christ. On the whole, then, we conclude I * This appendix also appeared in the Reflector. Church of God General Conference: McDonough, GA; Digital Archives Library; https://coggc.org/ February 1,1866. THE MESSENGER OF THE CHURCHES. 25