A Short History of Anglo-Saxon Freedom. the Polity of the English
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ma LIBRARY THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA SANTA BARBARA PRESENTED BY MRS. JOSEPH HOWARD BARNARD A SHORT HISTORY OF ANGLO-SAXON FREEDOM A SHORT HISTORY OF ANGLO-SAXON FREEDOM THE POLITY OF THE ENGLISH-SPEAKING EACE OUTLINED IN ITS INCEPTION, DEVELOPMENT, DIFFUSION, AND PRESENT CONDITION BY JAMES K. HOSMER Propkssob in Washington University; Author op "A Lipb of Samuel Adams," "A Life of Young Sir Henry Vane," etc. NEW YORK CHARLES SCRIBNER'S SONS 1903 COPYRIGHT, 1890, BY CHARLES SCRIBNER'S SONS. PREFACE. In this book an effort has been made to compress a sketch of constitutional history for a period of nearly two thousand years, from the time of the Teu- tons of Csesar and Tacitus to the British Empire and the United States of 1890. It is not the polity of any single people that is outlined, but that of the English-speaking race, that body to-day perhaps one hundred and twenty millions strong, scattered in sev- eral nationalities actual or incipient, which upon all the continents and all the great islands of the world, stands now so in the foreground of attention. It is a polity one and the same in its essence in England, in the United States, in Australia, in Canada : one and the same in its essence, moreover, as viewed in the institutions of to-day and in those of the North Germans of the time of Christ. As Sir Francis Pal- " grave says : The new building has been raised upon the old the institutions of one groundwork ; age have always been modelled and formed from those of the preceding, and the lineal descent has never been interrupted or disturbed." Anglo-Saxon freedom is most simply and comprehensively stated in the phrase " of Abraham Lincoln, government of the people, by the people, and for the people." In its long history VI PREFACE. there have been periods of temporary submergence, adaptation to the needs of ever vaster multitudes and higher civilizations, manifold development and elabo- ration : one spirit, however, has survived through all, apparent in the deliberations of a modern Congress or Parliament, as also it was apparent in the ancient folk-moots, where the free ceorls chose their army leadei-s and regulated the life in their marks. While works upon the con^itutional history, both of England and America, abound, they for the most part appeal, both as to style and size, rather to the scholar and the statesman, than to the general reader and the youthful student. Moreover, in such works it has too seldom happened that the constitutional his- tory of the English-speaking race has been regarded en solidarite : but in this way it is both proper and expedient to regard that history. England and Amer- ica are mother and child; the polity of the latter in its origin is a mere outflow from that of the former, the two constitutional streams since the divergence flowing constantly parallel and mutually reacting. Our frequent complaint is that Englishmen fail to us fail to them. understand ; just so, we understand Says the Westminster Review^ for March, 1889: "Eng- land's sternest, coldest, most critical censors, I have found descendants of the old settlers among ; surely they retain something of ancient Puritan bitterness. The source of estrangement I am inclined to trace largely to the fact that the average American reads no history but United States history, and he can hardly be said to study that." Certainly, to set right the "average American," and also the average Eng- lishman, is a task worth essaying. There ought to be PREFACE. Vll room for a book succinct and simple in its terms, which should tell to busy men and to youth in the of freedom for as class-room, the stoiy Anglo-Saxon ; " James Bryce has said : It is a matter of the first con- sequence that the relation to one another of the two branches of the English-speaking race should be more fully understood and realized." In the execution of such a task the difficulties are not small. How to preserve a proper historical per- spective while viewing upon so reduced a scale such a multitude of events and figures ? What guides to select in threading one's way through the long ages ? There is no period through which one must not pro- ceed with care, and the embarrassments are perhaps as great with respect to times close at hand as with respect to times remote. While this book was in preparation, the establishment of the County Councils has restored to the English shires their ancient local since it was for the self-government ; ready printer six Commonwealths have been added to the American Union as it awaits its an ; publication, Anglo-Saxon protectorate extends itself more and more widely over Africa, and the federation of Australia may become any month an accomplished fact. These are all events noteworthy in the history of Anglo-Saxon freedom, as are still others of wliich the newspapei-s weekly give report. How to catch them accurately and in due proportion ? As to remote ages, the darkness due to the remoteness is further deepened by the con- troversies of scholars. The employment of represen- tation has commonly been held to be characteristic of societies in the most distant Anglo-Saxon epochs ; but this honor is now denied to them by authorities Viu PREFACE. deserving of high respect, who find no good evidence of the existence of a representative system until after the Norman conquest. Mr. Frederic Seebohm, in his " English Village Communities," fails to see that the Anglo-Saxon invaders brought with them any free- dom at all, as they set up their tuns and scires in their new home : in the settlements that were estab- lished a lord ruled as master, with a society under in a condition of the free com- him villenage ; village munity was by no means the type, but from the first a marked feudalism in which the mass of men were serfs. Still more sweepingly, Mr. H. C. Coote, in his "Romans of Britain," will have it that the Anglo- Saxons transmitted to us not only no freedom, but nothing else. They were simply a horde of invading savages, exercising for a time dominion over a people they had conquered, who much surpassed them in civilization, a horde which was at length annihi- lated by the Danes, leaving no trace of itself or its influence; for, thinks Mr. Coote, all that we have called Anglo-Saxon, in blood, tongue, or institutions, ought to be ascribed to a different stock, and has received the name only through mistake. While at the two extremes of the subject embarrassments thus abound, certain intermediate periods are scarcely more free. In the English colonization of America, for instance, the extent to which the new country followed the precedents of the old is not a matter " upon which all are agreed. The new historical school," of which E. A. Freeman may be regarded as the founder, and of which the most characteristic publications in America are the historical and politi- PREFACE. IX cal tracts of Johns Hopkins University, edited by Prof. Herbert B. Adams, is inclined to trace in mi- nute detail in American societies the usages of the old world, a course for which it has been sharply censured, sometimes by scholars of reputa- tion. Under these circumstances, if a time were ever likely to arrive when doubtful questions will be any less in doubt, it would be prudent to defer the execution of such a task as the present one until that time. What probability is there, however, that the mighty march of Anglo-Saxondom will in these ages, ever press less confusingly upon the contemporaneous chronicler; or that as regards the past, the discord of authorities will ever be harmonized ? The task is worth execu- the time as as that is to ting ; propitious any likely arise. The present writer, fortifying his judgment as he could, has written his book, following the lead of the scholars most accepted. The numerous foot- notes Avill show, he trusts, that he has not been negli- gent in his reading. However open to question his conclusions may sometimes appear, they are not, at any rate, hap-hazard, but referable to respectable sources. The writer desires to express his obligation to a number of helpers. He is indebted to Mr. Goldwin Smith and to Mr. James Bryce for letters expressing sympathy with the main idea he has had at heart, to illustrate, namely, the substantial identity of the great English-speaking nations, in stock, and in the spirit of their social and political institutions, as as in and the that these well tongue ; expediency nations should, in John Bright's phrase, become one X PREFACE. people. The writer has received such a letter also from the venerable Sir George Grey of Auckland ,at different times formerly, governor-general of New- Zealand, of an Australian province, and of South Africa, and in those high positions so honorably iden- tified with the rise of an English-speaking world in the South Pacific. Dr. W. G. Hammond, Dean of the St. Louis Law School, Hon. Mellen Chamberlain, late librarian of the Boston Public Library, and Prof. W. W. Folwell of the Univereity of Minnesota, have given the writer the benefit of their criticisms upon several of his chapters, and helped him to important books which he could not otherwise have obtained. To Messrs. Houghton, Mifflin, & Co., owners of the " " " copyright of the Life of Samuel Adams and Life of Young Sir Henry Vane," the writer is under obli- gation, for permission to quote from earlier work of his own bearing upon the present subject.