Republic of Croatia Gender Equality Ombudsperson
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REPUBLIC OF CROATIA GENDER EQUALITY OMBUDSPERSON OFFICIAL REPORT FOR 2004 Zagreb, March 2005 1 CONTENTS PART ONE INTRODUCTION ……………..…………………………………………………………………………………………….. 3 PART TWO WORK INDICATORS OF THE GENDER EQUALITY OMBUDSPERSON FOR 2004 II.1. GENERAL INDICATORS …………………………………………………….……………………………………………….... 4 II.2. STRUCTURE OF COMPLAINTS …………………………………………………………………………… ……………….. 5 PART THREE III.1. DISCRIMINATION IN THE AREA OF WORK AND EMPLOYMENT – COMPLAINTS …………..…. 9 III.2. DISCRIMINATION – OTHER COMPLAINTS ……………………… …………………………………….……………. 19 III.3. DISCRIMINATION IN THE AREA OF WORK AND EMPLOYMENT – JOB ADVERTISEMENTS.…… 21 III.4. REVIEW OF THE ELABORATION OF EU EMPLOYMENT GUIDELINES WITHIN THE 2004 NATIONAL ACTION PLAN FOR EMPLOYMENT OF THE REPUBLIC OF CROATIA ……………...…….. 28 PART FOUR IV.1. VIOLENCE IN THE FAMILY - COMPLAINTS …………………..……………………………………………………. 50 IV.2. VIOLENCE – OTHER COMPLAINTS …………………………….…………………………………… …………………… 64 IV.3 SHORT ANALYSIS OF MOST COMMON COMPLAINTS AND QUESTIONS FROM CITIZENS BY PHONE ………………………………………………………………. ……………………………..……………………………………… 65 IV.4. TRAFFICKING IN HUMANS …………………………….…………………………………………… ……………………. 67 PART FIVE V. ADOPTION OF OPERATIONAL PLANS FOR THE PROMOTION AND ESTABLISHMENT OF GENDER EQUALITY, PROTECTION OF EMPLOYEE DIGNITY – INTRODUCTION ……………………………………. 69 V.1. STATE BODIES ……………………………………………………… ………………………………………….………………… 70 V.2. PREDOMINANTLY STATE-OWNED LEGAL ENTITIES …………………………..… ….…….…………….. 71 V.2.1. APPENDIX – ANALYSIS OF GENDER EQUALITY IN ULJANIK GROUP COMPANIES …….. 74 V.3. LEGAL ENTITIES OWNED BY UNITS OF LOCAL AND REGIONAL GOVERNMENT ………….… 75 PART SIX VI. BUDGET INITIATIVE, A RECOMMENDATION TO STATE BODIES AND UNITS OF LOCAL AND REGIONAL GOVERNMENT ………………………………………………………………………………………………….………… 80 PART SEVEN VII. VISITS TO COUNTIES …… ……………………………………………………………………………….……………………… 81 PART EIGHT VIII.1.-4. PROMOTION OF THE GENDER EQUALITY PRINCIPLE IN EDUCATION ………………………… 99 VIII.5. ROMA WOMEN AND MEN IN EDUCATION ………………………………………………………………………… 108 PART NINE IX. COOPERATION WITH NGOs DEALING WITH ISSUES OF PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES …………. 120 PART TEN X. POLITICAL PARTIES ………………………………………..…………………………………………………… ………………… 123 PART ELEVEN XI. MEDIA …………………………………………………………….……………………………………………………… ………………. 124 PART TWELVE XII. STATISTICAL DATA ………………………………………………………….………………………………………..…………… 131 PART THIRTEEN XIII. INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION……………………………………………………………………….……….……………132 PART FOURTEEN XIV. MATERIAL AND FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT………………………………………………………………..……………133 2 PART FIFTEEN XV. CONCLUSIVE REMARKS …………………………………………….……………………………………………………………135 PART SIXTEEN XVI. APPENDICES ………………………………..…………………………………………………………………………………….. 136 LITERATURE ………………………………………………………….……………………………………………………………………. 137 IMPORTANT DOCUMENTS FOR MONITORING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF GENDER EQUALITY REGULATIONS ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………..…………….. 138 3 PART ONE INTRODUCTION In the Gender Equality Law (hereinafter: GEL) effective on July 30, 2003 (The Official Gazette 116/03), Croatia, taking the espoused constitutional principle of gender equality as one of the fundamental values of the constitutional order of the Republic of Croatia, established a special independent and autonomous body, the Gender Equality Ombudsperson, which: - monitors the implementation of the GEL and other gender equality regulations, - reviews cases of violation of the gender equality principle, cases of discrimination against individuals or groups of individuals committed by bodies of state administration, units of local and regional government and other public authority bodies, their employees and other legal and physical persons, - is authorized to request reports and other necessary information from the bodies of state administration, units of local and regional government, other public authority bodies and other legal and physical persons, and, when the request is not complied with, to ask for work inspection by a relevant body, - has access to documentation regardless of the level of confidentiality, - warns, proposes and gives recommendations in his or her scope of work, - files a complaint to the relevant state attorney's office, if he or possesses knowledge about violations of the GEL provisions with elements of a criminal act, - has the right to file a motion for initiating procedures of the evaluation of the constitutionality of laws and other regulations, if he or she determines that the principle of gender equality has been violated, - proposes initiation of procedures of regulative changes, if he or she determines that the principle of gender equality has been violated because of noncompliance with the GEL, - can request expert help from research and scientific experts and institutions. The Official Report on the work of the Gender Equality Ombudsperson is an annual report submitted to the Croatian Parliament by March 31 of the current year, in accordance with Article 21, para. 1 of the Gender Equality Law and Article 18 of the Rules of Procedure of the Office of Gender Equality Ombudsperson (The Official Gazette 29/04). 4 PART TWO WORK INDICATORS OF THE GENDER EQUALITY OMBUDSPERSON FOR 2004 II.1. GENERAL INDICATORS During 2004, the Gender Equality Ombudsperson took action in a total of 3739 cases, which are in this part of the report shown in a table, and later will be divided by areas of work of the Gender Equality Ombudsperson. Table 1 Area 2004 Received/opened Resolved Unresolved Discrimination in the 3 3 area of work and employment (The Law on Civil Servants)1 Discrimination in the 28 23 5 area of work and employment (The Labor Law)2 Total 01 31 23 8 Primary education 5 1 4 Education - other 41 21 20 Total 02 46 22 24 Parental care 9 6 3 Violence in the family 38 31 7 Total 03 47 37 10 Media contents 95 1 94 Conveying 1 1 statements/attitudes Media – other 4 4 Total 05 100 5 95 State bodies 27 2 25 Legal entities owned by 134 52 82 the state State and other bodies – 32 32 advertisements Total 06 193 86 107 Units of local and 1,140 857 283 regional government Legal entities owned by 1,901 350 1,551 units of local and regional government Units of local and 44 39 5 regional government – job advertisements Total 07 3,085 1,246 1,839 Other legal entities – 86 80 6 advertisements Total 08 86 80 6 Civil society 8 7 1 Total 09 8 7 1 Discrimination -other / 7 5 2 direct GE - other / indirect 2 2 1 The Law on Civil Servants (The Official Gazette 27/01) 2 The Labor Law (The Official Gazette 137/04 – full text) 5 Total 10 9 7 2 Total - Work of the 134 113 21 Office 11-14 TOTAL 01-14 3,739 1,626 2,113 The Gender Equality Ombudsperson took action in the above mentioned cases by monitoring the implementation of the GEL and other gender equality regulations. The structure of complaints shows that the priorities of the Gender Equality Ombudsperson were determined by and dependant upon deadlines prescribed by the GEL (Article 11 and 30 – adoption of operational plans for the promotion and establishment of gender equality). Without the implementation of these provisions, it is unreasonable to expect that the purpose of the Law will be achieved. The second priority was the need to present the idea of gender equality and implementation of the GEL and other regulations to as many legal and physical persons as possible, especially state bodies, legal entities with public authority, legal entities predominantly owned by the state and units of local and regional government, which must evaluate the impact of their work and behaviors on the position of women and men. That is why the Gender Equality Ombudsperson not only monitored the implementation of the GEL through numerous warnings, recommendations, public and media statements and meetings, but also promoted it. II.2. STRUCTURE OF COMPLAINTS In 2004, there were 88 complaints to the Gender Equality Ombudsperson, in the following areas: - family in 47 cases or 53.4 %, - work and employment in 31 cases or 35.2 % , - education in 1 case or 1.1 % and - other in 9 cases or 10.3 %. Graph 1 family 53,41% work and employment other areas 35,23% 10,23% education 1,14% 6 Structure of complaints by counties and the City of Zagreb in 2004 Table 2 County/City if Zagreb where Number of % the complainant complaints resides City of Zagreb 34 38.6 Zagrebačka 4 4.6 Karlovačka 5 5.7 Sisačko- 5 5.7 moslavačka Bjelovarsko- 1 1.1 bilogorska Virovitičko- 1 1.1 podravska Koprivničko- 3 3.4 križevačka Krapinsko- 2 2.3 zagorska Međimurska 1 1.1 Osječko- 4 4.6 baranjska Varaždinska 2 2.3 Požeško- 3 3.4 slavonska Brodsko- posavska 1 1.1 Vukovarsko- 2 2.3 srijemska Primorsko- 2 2.3 goranska Istarska 5 5.7 Zadarska 6 6.8 Ličko-senjska 0 0.0 Šibensko- kninska 0 0.0 Dubrovačko- 6 6.8 neretvanska Splitsko- 1 1.1 dalmatinska Total 88 100.0 The complainants by marital status: - married women in 43 cases or 48.8% , - singles in 11 cases or 12.5% , - married men in 1 case or 1.1% , - extramarital partnership in 5 cases or 5.8% , - widower in 1 case or 1.1% , - divorced men in 3 cases or 3.4% , - divorced women in 16 cases or 18.3%, - former extramarital partner in 1 case or 1.1% and - unknown in 7 cases or 7.9%. 7 Complainants by vocation/degree in education: - 19.4 % cases with university degree, - 6.8 % cases with college or vocational school, - 59.0 % cases with high school , - 7.9 % cases with primary school (unskilled labor) and - 6.9 % cases - unknown. Graph 2 secondary education 59.0% college or vocational school 6.8% unskilled workers 7.9% university education unknown 6.9% 19.4% In 44 cases or 61.3 %, the complainants