Copyright by Shea Matthew Suski 2011
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Copyright by Shea Matthew Suski 2011 The Professional Report Committee for Shea Matthew Suski Certifies that this is the approved version of the following report: Cooperation between High-Speed Rail and Air Travel in the United States APPROVED BY SUPERVISING COMMITTEE: Supervisor: Ming Zhang C. Michael Walton Cooperation between High-Speed Rail and Air Travel in the United States by Shea Matthew Suski, B.A. Professional Report Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of The University of Texas at Austin in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Community and Regional Planning The University of Texas at Austin May 2011 Dedication This report is dedicated to my parents, who have given my decision to pursue a graduate degree their full support. I could not have done it without them. Abstract Cooperation between High-Speed Rail and Air Travel in the United States Shea Matthew Suski, MSCRP The University of Texas at Austin, 2011 Supervisor: Ming Zhang The United States as a whole is embarking on the historic task of implementing high-speed rail (HSR) throughout the country in an attempt to improve regional mobility, including congestion at some of the nation’s busiest airports. However, despite the wide overlapping of service that both air and HSR provide and the goal of reducing airport congestion, little discourse has occurred on the topic of how these two modes might interact in an intermodal context. This report explores how air travel and HSR might cooperate in the US, which is defined as an explicit attempt by the two modes to utilize each other in order to transport a passenger to their final destination. It will document potential benefits of cooperation, survey how cooperation works elsewhere in the world, and investigate the current climate within the US for cooperation, including a review of current HSR plans and analysis of v air travel data. This information will form the basis for suggested airports for the integration of HSR and air travel, and for how US airlines might utilize HSR. Lastly, lessons learned will form a list of best practices to follow in order to better insure a cooperative and successful relationship between HSR and air travel. vi Table of Contents List of Tables ...........................................................................................................x List of Illustrations ................................................................................................. xi INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................1 Chapter 1: Definition & Methodology ....................................................................2 Definition ........................................................................................................2 Scope ...............................................................................................................3 Case Studies and Findings ..............................................................................4 Cooperative Relationships in the US ..............................................................4 Chapter 2: Literature Review ..................................................................................6 Cooperation .....................................................................................................6 US Potential ....................................................................................................8 Chapter 3: Stakeholder Benefits of Cooperation ..................................................13 Airlines ..........................................................................................................13 Airports and the Nation’s Airspace ...............................................................14 HSR Operators ..............................................................................................15 Passengers .....................................................................................................16 CASE STUDIES & PRACTICES FROM ABROAD ......................................................17 Chapter 4: Cooperation in Europe ........................................................................18 France ............................................................................................................18 Germany ........................................................................................................22 The Netherlands ............................................................................................24 Spain .............................................................................................................25 Italy ...............................................................................................................26 Other Rail and Air Cooperative Examples ...................................................27 Chapter 5: Cooperation in Asia.............................................................................29 vii COOPERATIVE RELATIONSHIPS IN THE UNITED STATES .....................................31 Chapter 6: Current and Past Examples of Cooperation ........................................32 Chapter 7: Review of Current High-Speed Rail Plans ..........................................34 California ......................................................................................................34 Florida ...........................................................................................................36 Midwest.........................................................................................................36 Northeast Corridor ........................................................................................38 Southeast .......................................................................................................39 Other HSR Projects with Potential for Integration .......................................40 Chapter 8: Factors for Cooperation.......................................................................41 Airports Studied ............................................................................................41 Origin-Destination Pairs within Spatially-Competitive Markets ..................45 Chapter 9: Potential for Cooperation ....................................................................47 Best Airports for Cooperation .......................................................................47 Atlanta (ATL) ......................................................................................48 Chicago-O’Hare (ORD) .......................................................................49 Los Angeles (LAX) ..............................................................................50 Las Vegas (LAS) ..................................................................................52 Phoenix-Sky Harbor (PHX) .................................................................53 San Francisco (SFO) ............................................................................54 Charlotte (CLT) ...................................................................................55 Detroit (DTW) .....................................................................................56 Philadelphia (PHL) ..............................................................................57 New York-La Guardia (LGA) .............................................................58 Washington DC-Reagan National (DCA) or Baltimore (BWI) ...........60 Cleveland (CLE) ..................................................................................61 Other Airports to Consider ............................................................................62 Why Some Major Airports were not Selected ..............................................64 How US Airlines could Utilize HSR on their Networks ..............................65 viii AirTran .................................................................................................65 Alaska Airlines.....................................................................................66 Frontier .................................................................................................66 JetBlue..................................................................................................67 Spirit Airlines .......................................................................................67 Sun Country .........................................................................................68 USA 3000.............................................................................................68 US Airways ..........................................................................................68 Virgin America ....................................................................................69 Large Legacy Carriers ..........................................................................69 Southwest .............................................................................................70 Chapter 10: Best Practices to Ensure Beneficial Cooperation ..............................71 Seamless Integration .....................................................................................71 Frequent Service ...........................................................................................74 Customer Perception .....................................................................................75 Network Alignment ......................................................................................75