The Activation-Induced Deaminase Functions in a Postcleavage Step of the Somatic Hypermutation Process
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Brief Definitive Report The Activation-induced Deaminase Functions in a Postcleavage Step of the Somatic Hypermutation Process F. Nina Papavasiliou1 and David G. Schatz2 1Laboratory of Lymphocyte Biology, The Rockefeller University, New York, NY 10021 2Section of Immunobiology, Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT 06520 Abstract Activation of B cells by antigen fuels two distinct molecular modifications of immunoglobulin (Ig) genes. Class-switch recombination (CSR) replaces the Ig heavy chain constant region with a downstream constant region gene, thereby altering the effector function of the resulting antibodies. Somatic hypermutation (SHM) introduces point mutations into the variable regions of Ig genes, thereby changing the affinity of antibody for antigen. Mechanistic overlap between the two reactions has been suggested by the finding that both require the activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID). It has been proposed that AID initiates both CSR and SHM by ac- tivating a common nuclease. Here we provide evidence that cells lacking AID, or expressing a dominant negative form of the protein, are still able to incur DNA lesions in SHM target se- quences. The results indicate that an intact cytidine deaminase motif is required for AID func- tion, and that AID acts downstream of the initial DNA lesions in SHM. Key words: somatic hypermutation • AID • DNA double-strand breaks • B lymphocyte • Ig gene Introduction One of the hallmarks of the immune system is the ability to absolutely dependent on the presence of the Ig enhancers. recognize large numbers of antigens. In the mouse and hu- Because of this reliance on promoter and enhancer elements, man B cell repertoires, diversity is generated by two dis- it is has been suggested that the targeting step of hypermuta- tinct processes; the primary repertoire is generated in the tion is linked to transcription, although whether it is coupled bone marrow by V(D)J recombination (1). Its further di- to the transcription process per se or to a general require- versification involves the antigen-driven introduction of ment for locus accessibility remains unclear (4–6). point mutations into the V regions of Ig genes (1). This SHM was originally hypothesized to be a two-step pro- process of somatic hypermutation (SHM) gives rise to fam- cess, initiated by cleavage of the DNA within the mutating ilies of related mutant antibodies which are then selected region, and subsequently resolved by error-prone repair for their binding affinity to the immunizing antigen (2). (7). There is strong circumstantial evidence to suggest that During hypermutation, the V regions of Ig genes accu- the cleaved DNA intermediate is a DNA double-strand mulate single nucleotide substitutions and occasional inser- break, as V regions of hypermutating cells incur DSBs on tions and deletions. Many of the mutations occur at specific hotspots and at high rates (8, 9). Furthermore, the initiation residues (hotspots), suggesting that the sequence surrounding of DSB formation has been shown to require the same ele- a hotspot might be the target of a putative mutator complex ments which regulate the introduction of mutations (tran- (3). Yet whenever the V gene has been replaced with artifi- scription and the presence of the enhancer) (8, 9). These cial substrates, those substrates hypermutate successfully (3), hypermutation-associated DSBs are abundant in the G2 and so the sequence of the V gene itself does not initiate the (postreplicative) phase of the cell cycle, and thus it has been mutation process. Surprisingly, the specific V region pro- suggested that they are repaired by homologous recombi- moter can be replaced by heterologous promoters without a nation between sister chromatids (8). detrimental effect on hypermutation (3), but the process is Even though it has been extensively studied, little is known about the molecular mechanism of the SHM pro- cess. The only known protein whose loss of function leads Address correspondence to F. Nina Papavasiliou, Laboratory of Lympho- cyte Biology, The Rockefeller University, Box 39, 1230 York Ave., to a significant downregulation (if not total ablation) of hy- New York, NY 10021. Phone: 212-327-7857; Fax: 212-327-7319; permutation is the recently discovered activation-induced E-mail: [email protected] cytidine deaminase (AID) (10, 11). Yet, the function of 1193 J. Exp. Med. The Rockefeller University Press • 0022-1007/2002/05/1193/6 $5.00 Volume 195, Number 9, May 6, 2002 1193–1198 http://www.jem.org/cgi/doi/10.1084/jem.20011858 AID in somatic hypermutation is far from clear, and its ef- start Taq (QIAGEN) and combinations of the following primers: fect might not even be direct, as AID is thought to be an human AID, hAID left GTCCGCTGGGCTAAGGGTCGGCG RNA-editing enzyme (12). It has been postulated that AID hAID right GCACCCCGGCGCGGTGCAGCCG; and human edits the mRNA of the endonuclease responsible for the c-myc, c-myc left CCGCCCGCGGCCACAGCGTC c-myc DNA lesions in both CSR and SHM (10). Alternatively, right CGCCTCTTGACATTCTCCTCGGTGTC. Flow Cytometry and Cell Sorting. To purify germinal center B AID might be responsible in editing the mRNA of a factor cells, we pooled spleens from mice at 14 d after immunization (or factors) responsible for orchestrating DSB repair. Here with NP-CGG in alum (Biosearch Technologies, Inc.), and sepa- we report that SHM-associated DSBs are still present in rated the resting and activated lymphocytes on a Percoll gradient cells lacking AID, or expressing a dominant negative form (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech). Cells were stained with the of the protein. Our results indicate that AID acts down- pan-B cell marker B220 (phycoerythrin) and the B/T activated stream of the initial DNA lesions in SHM, possibly by edit- cell marker GL-7 (FITC) (both from BD PharMingen), and ing the RNA of a repair factor. sorted on a Becton Dickinson FACSVantage™. Sorted cells were immediately embedded in agarose for further analysis. For the cell cycle study, standard methods were used (16). All analyses of flow Materials and Methods cytometric data were performed using the FlowJo™ software Plasmid Constructs. The AID cDNA was amplified from Ra- package (Treestar). mos cDNA and the H56R/E58Q mutations in AID were intro- duced with the QuikChange™ kit (Stratagene). To generate the bacterial expression vectors, AID or AID DN were indepen- Results dently cloned into pET3d in frame with GST, to generate the An AID Catalytic Mutant Has No Deaminase Activity. wild-type GST-AID or GST-AID DN fusion gene, respectively. The primary sequence of AID shares highest sequence sim- The proteins were expressed in BL21 DE3 cells and purified with glutathione sepharose 4B resin, according to the manufac- ilarity with Apobec-1 (12) (Fig. 1 A), the prototypic RNA- turer’s instruction (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech). editing cytidine deaminase (14). Cytidine deaminases in To generate the retroviral expression vectors, the AID DN general share a conserved active site motif consisting of a ϩ cDNA was cloned into the pMSCV retroviral expression vector histidine and two cysteines which coordinate Zn2 , and a (CLONTECH), engineered to express either GFP or a puromy- glutamate which serves as a proton donor in the deamina- cin resistance gene from an internal phosphoglycerol kinase (pgk) tion reaction (17). Replacement of any of these four amino promoter. acids results in a catalytic mutant (18). We generated an Ϫ Ϫ Mice and Cell Culture. AID / (10) mice have been de- AID protein mutated in two of these residues (H56R/ scribed previously. The Ramos (RA-1) cell line was obtained E58Q) and expressed both the mutant and wild-type pro- from the American Type Culture Collection and grown as de- teins in Escherichia coli. The wild-type protein was active in scribed previously (13). For retroviral infections, pMSCV or pM- SCV-AID DN, along with the packaging plasmid pkat (14), were an in vitro deamination assay while the catalytic mutant cotransfected into 293T cells by calcium phosphate precipitation was not (Fig. 1 B). and viral supernatants harvested 48 h after transfection were used All except one of the known cytidine deaminases act as to infect cells. homodimers or homotetramers (19), and hence catalytic Deamination Assay. The deamination assay was performed as mutants can have a dominant negative effect (19, 20). A se- described previously (15). Briefly, 100 g of protein was added to ries of leucines in the carboxy terminus of Apobec-1 is a mix containing 25 mol Tris-HCl, pH 7.05, and 1 mole cyti- thought to be important for dimerization (20), and even dine (1 ml final volume). At different times, 100 l samples were though there is low sequence homology between AID and added to 900 l of 0.5 M ice-cold perchloric acid and the mix- Apobec-1 in that region, these leucines are conserved in ture was centrifuged. The absorbance of the supernatant was AID. Furthermore, secondary structure prediction algo- measured at 290 nm. Under these conditions, the difference in rithms (21) model the carboxy terminus as almost entirely the molar extinction coefficient between cytidine and uridine is ␣ 10.1 ϫ 106 cm2 per mol (15). -helical with a potential for coiled coil formation (Fig. 1 LM-PCR and RT-PCR. Cells were embedded in agarose C). Hence the H56R/E58Q mutant AID (henceforth AID and genomic DNA prepared as described previously (8). The DN) might display a dominant negative phenotype. sequences of gene specific primers not described in (8) were as AID DN Interferes with SHM. To determine the effect follows: mouse VH186.2, VH186.2 L1 TTCTTGGCAGCAA- of the putative dominant negative protein on SHM, we ex- CAGCTACAGGTAAGG VH186.2 L2 GCAGGCTTGAG- pressed the protein in the human Burkitt lymphoma cell GTCTGGACATATACATG probe GACATCCACTTTGC- line Ramos, which hypermutates constitutively in culture CTTTCTCTCCACAGGTG; mouse V1, V1 L1 GTT- (13).