DALIT STUDIES This Page Intentionally Left Blank DALIT STUDIES
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DALIT STUDIES This page intentionally left blank DALIT STUDIES RAMNARAYAN S. RAWAT & K. SATYANARAYANA, EDITORS Duke University Press • Durham and London • 2016 © 2016 Duke University Press All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of Amer i ca on acid- free paper ∞. Designed by Courtney Leigh Baker and Typeset in Scala, Scala Sans, and Minion Pro by Westchester Publishing Services Library of Congress Cataloging- in- Publication Data Names: Rawat, Ramnarayan S., editor. | Satyanarayana, K., editor. Title: Dalit studies / Ramnarayan S. Rawat and K. Satyanarayana, editors. Description: Durham : Duke University Press, 2016. | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers:lccn 2015040886| isbn 9780822361138 (hardcover : alk. paper) | isbn 9780822361329 (pbk. : alk. paper) | isbn 9780822374312 (e- book) Subjects: lcsh: Dalits— India. | Caste— India. Classification:lcc ds422.c3 d2016 | ddc 305.5/688— dc23 lc rec ord available at http:// lccn . loc . gov / 2015040886 Cover art: Courtesy of Laxman Aelay, Secular Song, 2013. Acrylic on canvas, 72" × 48". Laxman Aelay is a contemporary artist from Telangana. To Dalit men and women who have dedicated their lives to the pursuit of human dignity This page intentionally left blank CONTENTS Acknowl edgments • ix introduction. Dalit Studies: New Perspectives on Indian History and Society • 1 ramnarayan s. rawat and k. satyanarayana 1 The Indian Nation in Its Egalitarian Conception• 31 gopal guru part i. Probing the Historical 2 Colonial Archive versus Colonial Sociology: Writing Dalit History • 53 ramnarayan s. rawat 3 Social Space, Civil Society, and Dalit Agency in Twentieth- Century Kerala • 74 p. sanal mohan 4 Dilemmas of Dalit Agendas: Po liti cal Subjugation and Self- Emancipation in Telugu Country, 1910–50 • 104 chinnaiah jangam 5 Making Sense of Dalit Sikh History • 131 raj kumar hans part ii. Probing the Present 6 The Dalit Reconfiguration of Modernity: Citizens and Castes in the Telugu Public Sphere • 155 k. satyanarayana 7 Questions of Repre sen ta tion in Dalit Critical Discourse: Premchand and Dalit Feminism • 180 laura brueck 8 Social Justice and the Question of Categorization of Scheduled Caste Reservations: The Dandora Debate in Andhra Pradesh • 202 sambaiah gundimeda 9 Caste and Class among the Dalits • 233 d. shyam babu 10 From Zaat to Qaum: Fluid Contours of the Ravi Dasi Identity in Punjab • 248 surinder s. jodhka Bibliography • 271 Contributors • 293 Index • 295 viii • contents AC KNOW LEDG MENTS Dalit studies has recently emerged as a new field of study in India. As we explain in the introduction to this volume, a number of factors have contrib- uted to the rise of this exciting field. Perhaps the most striking is the entry of Dalit intellectuals into academic institutions. Since the late nineteenth century there has been a long tradition of Dalit activist- scholars outside academia. This volume brings a new group of scholars and activist- scholars to academic attention in North Amer i ca and the West more generally. The rise of the field of Dalit studies has been propelled by the emergence of a new generation of Dalit activists and intellectuals since the 1990s. This develop- ment coincided with the discussions of caste inequities in the Indian media and academia. In Indian—or, more broadly, South Asian— academia, histori- cal and anthropological research in the first two de cades of the twenty-firs t century yielded information about previously unacknowledged struggles by Dalit groups, tribal people, women, and other marginal sections of Indian society. This period also coincided with new research in the disciplines of re- ligious and literary studies and in historical and contemporary fields, which further highlighted the role of marginal social groups in sustaining dif er ent forms of devotion and protest. The exciting new research in the past two de cades, especially the rise of Dalit studies and new attention paid to B. R. Ambedkar, also coincided with the formal end of the subaltern studies col- lective. It is in this new exciting moment that Dalit Studies raises a new set of questions, focusing on Dalits as subjects of study and on Dalit studies as a location of marginality to be studied in Indian history. The book seeks to draw attention to the per sis tence of practices that sustain caste inequality and its relationship with the unraveling of modernity in India. The last two hun- dred years of Indian history seems to suggest, as several essays in this volume argue, that commitments to equality can not only coexist, but can be made coeval, with regimes of caste inequality. This volume explores many ofth ese themes. A distinctive feature of the volume is that the contributors to the volume did additional new research and substantially rewrote their essays after presenting them as papers at the Dalit studies conference at the University of Pennsylva- nia in December 2008. The discussants, chairs of sessions, and audience at the conference played a crucial role in asking the right questions and enabling the contributors to further develop their research. The anonymous referees at Duke University Press provided solid feedback to all the contributors by asking insightful questions, which wer e specific but also addressed the overall theme of the volume. The volume introduces a new group of scholars who have addressed the concerns of Dalit studies in dif er ent regions of India. Most contributors to the volume belong to the marginal social groups in India. In- deed, many of us were deeply influenced by the po liti cal and academic debates in the 1990s following the Mandal commission report controversy in 1990. These debates were also shaped by the rapid rise of right-win g Hindu groups following the de mo li tion of the Babri masjid (mosque) in December 1992. We have addressed these concerns in the introduction to the volume. Our objective in writing a definitive introduction was to introduce Dalit studies to a diverse audience. It also provided us with a valuable opportunity to formulate the idea of Dalit studies as a critical location that allows the study of Dalits as marginalized subjects but also ofers a perspective for rein- terpreting Indian society and history. We wrote the introduction together in the fall of 2010 when K. Satyanarayana was a visiting fellow at the Center for the Advanced Study of India (casi) at the University of Pennsylvania. The introduction eventually became a bold statement on our part, motivating us to engage a variety of topics from several disciplines. Recognizing the merit of the introduction, the two anonymous referees of the book’s manuscript for Duke University Press became the most valuable interlocutors with their incisive comments and suggestions. Feedback from them has helped us con- siderably revise and rework parts of the introduction, making it sharper and clearer. Most of the comments by the two referees dealt with the introduction. We would like to thank the participants at the Dalit studies conference, where this volume began its journey. Nearly three hundred people submit- ted proposals for papers to be delivered at the conference. The conference brought together a new group of scholars and was instrumental in creating new friendships and collaborations. We are grateful to those who presented papers at the conference, who in the order of pre sen ta tion there are Nar- endra Jadhav, Chinnaiah Jangam, Gopal Guru, Sanal Mohan, Raj Kumar x • ac know ledg ments Hans, Rupa Viswanath, Sukdeo Thorat, Shailaja Paik, Laura Brueck, Jebroja Singh, Hugo Gorringe, M. S. S. Pandian, Sambaiah Gundimeda, Shyam Babu, Surinder Jodhka, Chandrabhan Prasad and Devesh Kapur, Karthik Muralid- haran, Katherine Newman, and Paul Attewell. We are especially thankful to the discussants at the conference for their valuable time and suggestions: Douglas Haynes, Lucinda Ramberg, Mrinalini Sinha, Sudipto Kaviraj, Steven Wilkinson, and Lant Pritchett. We are also grateful to the chairs at the confer- ence: Priya Joshi, Jamal Elias, Ania Loomba, Atul Kohli, and Gail Omvedt. We are extremely grateful to Barbara Savage and Tufuku Zuberi for participating in the African American and Dalit studies roundtable. This roundtable was another highlight of the conference because it attracted a large audience, nearly ninety people. casi provided substantial financial support for the conference, enabling us to invite a large number of scholars from India. In addition, it provided a small research grant to all contributors. Additional support was provided by the South Asia Center, the Department of South Asian Studies, and the Center for Africana Studies, at the University of Pennsylvania. Over the years we have accumulated boundless debts to friends, colleagues, and institutions, and we made new friends during the course of producing this volume. Most of all, we acknowledge our deep gratitude to Devesh Kapur, di- rector of casi, for his support to the conference and the volume. The confer- ence was his idea. The remarkably professional but kind staf at casi made the conference and the book pos si ble. Their commitment to the conference turned it into a choreographed festival of ideas. Our heartfelt thanks go to Juliana Di Giustini, deputy director of casi and a dynamic leader and person of ideas, who planned and executed the entire conference when Ramnarayan Rawat was in India on sabbatical. We are also very grateful to Tanya Carey, admin- istrative coordinator, for managing the conference with so much ease and a smile. Alan Atchison, the online editor and expert, was always around and ready with answers to our numerous questions. Our thanks go to Tan- maya Nanda. Several Penn undergraduates who worked part- time at casi con- tributed im mensely to the success of the conference. They include Katherine Maughan, Rahul Reddy, and Yashas Vaidya, all of the class of 2009. Thanks are also due to Maisha Philips and Paola Campos at South Asia Center.