Abortion in Turkey: women in rural areas and the law

MATERNAL DEATHS AND country in the Middle East and one of the This paper aims to emphasise that the UNSAFE 20 most populous countries in the world. law for safe services may itself Worldwide, an estimated 529 000 girls and Women constitute 36.1 million of the represent a barrier to service provision for women die of pregnancy-related causes population, and half of this number is of all women of reproductive age. each year, about one every minute, and reproductive age. Each year approximately many times that number suffer long-term 1.5 million births take place and 728 –1000 REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH injuries and disabilities. Ninety-nine percent mothers die due to pregnancy-, delivery-, PRIORITIES IN TURKEY of all maternal deaths occur in the and birth-related complications. In Turkey, the reproductive health status of developing world. 1–5 Turkey has made progress in improving the population, particularly women, is low Direct causes of pregnancy-related reproductive health since the 1994 compared to other countries at the same deaths worldwide are: International Conference on Population level of development. In spite of improved and Development (ICPD), and the life expectancy, maternal and infant • severe bleeding, 25%; government has reflected the ICPD targets mortality rates are still above the regional • infection, 15%; and strategies in the country’s averages, as compared with Europe. Some • , 13%; Development Plan. Furthermore, a National findings of the 2003 Turkish Demographic • hypertensive disorders, 12%; Strategic Plan for Women’s Health and Health Survey (TDHS) may be significant in • obstructed labour, 8%; and Family Planning was developed, which explaining the low status of reproductive • other, 8%. highlights the need to reduce disparities health in the country: the level of unwanted between and within the regions and pregnancies is 11%, nearly one-fifth of Abortion is a sensitive and contentious between different population groups. 9–11 pregnant women do not receive antenatal issue with religious, moral, cultural, and Despite some progress achieved in the care, and one-fifth of births take place political dimensions. It is also a public area of primary mother –child health care outside health facilities. In addition, nearly health concern in many parts of the world. and reproductive health, there are still one-fifth of all births take place without the More than one-quarter of the world’s serious gaps in the availability of healthcare assistance of a doctor or trained health people live in countries where the services, particularly between urban and personnel. The use of modern procedure is prohibited or permitted only rural areas as opposed to towns and cities, contraceptives is low. Condom use among to save the woman’s life. Yet, regardless of and among the regions, especially for those married men is around 11%. 14 legal status, abortions still occur, and living in the poorer eastern part of Turkey Turkey is ranked 94th out of 177 nearly half of them are performed by an rather than in the west. countries according to the Human unskilled practitioner or in less than Induced abortion is a national problem in Development Index for 2005, based on sanitary conditions, or both. women’s health, as it is for the whole 2003 data. 15 The Human Development WHO defines an unsafe abortion as ‘a world, and unsafe abortion is one of the Report also indicates serious regional procedure for terminating an unwanted major causes of death among women of differences within the country. 16 pregnancy either by persons lacking the reproductive age in Turkey. necessary skills or in an environment lacking Despite the liberal nature of the abortion URBAN-RURAL DIFFERENCES IN the minimal medical standards, or both’. law, the number of legal abortions up to WOMEN’S REPRODUCTIVE When abortion is performed by qualified 10 weeks performed in the country has HEALTH SERVICES people using correct techniques in sanitary been sharply restricted by the requirement In Turkey, the proportion of women not conditions, it is very safe. Worldwide, nearly that the procedure be carried out only by or receiving any antenatal care is only 12% in one in 10 pregnancies ends in unsafe under the supervision of gynaecologists. 12,13 urban areas whereas the figure stands at abortion. But this is a global estimate, This factor is especially critical in rural one-third for those living in rural areas. combining countries where abortion is safe Turkey, where medical specialists of any Mothers living in urban settlements are and legal with those where it is restricted type are rare or non-existent. Many rural more likely to receive antenatal care from a and often unsafe. In low-income countries, health facilities that are without a trained doctor than those living in rural areas (84% women have an average of one unsafe specialist are excluded from providing and 58%, respectively). Many women in abortion during their reproductive lives. 3,6 –8 services. Consequently, a rural Turkish Turkey are aware of the importance of an woman seeking an abortion within the first early visit for antenatal care. More women COUNTRY PROFILE 10 weeks of pregnancy may not be able to in urban areas (80%) seek antenatal care Turkey is currently the most populous obtain one. before the sixth month of pregnancy

370 British Journal of General Practice, May 2008 Essay

compared to women in rural areas (52%). primary prevention of complications in where mid-level providers are government Antenatal care coverage exceeds 80% in developing countries. This technology trained and accredited to do first-trimester all regions except the east, where it was relies on the use of a simple syringe with a abortions. It was found that with received by 61% of mothers for the most plunger to generate negative pressure for appropriate government training, mid-level recent births in the 5 years prior to the uterine evacuation, and plastic cannulas of healthcare providers can provide first survey. Reflecting the greater tendency varying sizes. The amount of negative trimester MVA abortions as safely as among rural women to delay seeking care, pressure obtained with manual vacuum doctors can. 31 –36 the median duration of pregnancy at the aspiration (MVA) is similar to that generated In Turkey, induced abortion has always first antenatal visit is 2.6 months in urban with large, expensive, electrical pumps, been important in fertility regulation, even areas and 3.5 months in rural areas. which makes this method especially suited preceding it’s legalisation on socioeconomic This unmet need for family planning in for use in clinics, offices, and low-resource grounds in 1983 with the enactment of the Turkey fell from 10% in 1998 to 6% in settings. MVA also has the advantage that new Population Planning Law. In the early 2003, but this is higher among women the syringe can be cleaned, disinfected to a 1980s, the growing incidence of unsafe aged 15 –29 years and women living in rural high level, or sterilised and used repeatedly; abortion in Turkey and the resulting accommodation. Unmet need by region similarly, cannulas can be discarded or re- morbidity and mortality rates led the varies from 3% of women in the west to used after appropriate disinfection or government to liberalise the law further and 15% of women in the east. 14 sterilisation. is safer make abortion widely available. The Limited access to and low utilisation of than sharp curettage, and the WHO Population Planning Law in 1983 provided health services in the eastern and south- recommends vacuum aspiration as the safe abortion on request during the first eastern regions and rural areas throughout preferred method for uterine evacuation 10 weeks of gestation for every woman who the country is often related to the low before 12 weeks of pregnancy. 20,21 needed the service. 12 social status of families, especially of The vacuum aspiration method is also a Under this law, trained nurses and women. safe, effective, and acceptable treatment midwives are authorised to insert IUDs, for the treatment of first-trimester and GPs and family physicians with special SCOPE OF INDUCED uncomplicated incomplete abortion, as is training are allowed to provide abortions by ABORTIONS 600 µg oral . 22 –24 vacuum aspiration, under the supervision The international health community and MVA is faster, safer, more comfortable, of obstetrician –gynaecologists. 13,37,38 governments worldwide have repeatedly and associated with shorter hospital stay In rural areas of Turkey in particular, agreed that reducing deaths and injuries for induced abortion than sharp primary sometimes second-level from unsafe abortion is a high priority. 17 curettage. 25,26 Additional advantages healthcare facilities without obstetricians Although specific commitments have compared with sharp curettage are its ease have to refer their abortion cases, even been made toward achieving this of use as an outpatient procedure, the need those with severe bleeding, to a higher objective, progress to date has been for less analgesia and anaesthesia, 27 and its level facility, leaving most women unable to wholly inadequate. Significant progress lower cost per procedure, especially if done obtain emergency care in time. 39 cannot occur until all women of on an outpatient basis. 28 In countries with a Although the percentage of pregnancies reproductive age have much better access small number of physicians, vacuum that are ended through induced and unsafe to safe abortion care in their communities. aspiration can be safely and effectively abortion in Turkey have reduced, the level Abortion is safest when performed early in used by mid-level health service providers, remains high due to this legal obligation. a pregnancy. Menstrual regulation is such as midwives. 29,30 defined as any procedure which disrupts Studies from all over the world indicate DISCUSSION the intrauterine environment so that that a wide range of medical and All women should be entitled to safe embryonic implantation either cannot occur paramedical professionals can effectively pregnancy, safe delivery, and safe or cannot be maintained. 18 The technique is and safely provide MVA services. In a 2006 abortion. 40,41,42 also known as menstrual aspiration, study Warriner et al assessed whether the Access to safe abortion care can be a life , interception, and safety of first-trimester MVA abortion or death issue for women. These deaths uterine aspiration. 19 It can be performed performed by healthcare providers who are and injuries represent a social injustice of using drugs, physical agents, and surgical not doctors (mid-level providers) is tragic proportions, particularly because techniques. The advent of vacuum equivalent to that of procedures performed they are almost entirely preventable aspiration in the 1960s revolutionised the by doctors in South Africa and Vietnam, compared to other main causes of

British Journal of General Practice, May 2008 371 maternal deaths. Deaths of women related Experience from numerous countries health systems should treat abortion to pregnancy contribute significantly to the demonstrates that, with appropriate complications quickly and efficiently and greatest health disparity between rich and training, supervision, and support, many guarantee that medical care, family poor countries or regions. mid-level healthcare providers such as planning, and other reproductive Procedures and techniques for early nurses, midwives, clinical officers and healthcare services are available and induced abortion are both simple and safe. others can safely and effectively offer accessible to as many women as possible, When performed by trained healthcare abortion-related care that is both especially at the primary healthcare level. providers with appropriate equipment, accessible and highly acceptable to To make this a reality, legal mechanisms using accurate techniques and good women. Chaudhuri emphasised also that should be re-examined even if they sanitary standards, abortion is one of the menstrual regulation is safe, involves an support safe abortion services. In addition, safest medical procedures. In most cases easy operation and can be performed not governments should plan to increase the when women die or suffer permanent only by the doctors engaged in family number of service delivery sites offering disability, it is because they do not receive planning work but also by GPs after some abortion care and authorise all qualified medical treatment soon enough. 43 training. 46 healthcare personnel, regardless of their According to one study of Turkish The studies carried out at different points professional titles, to provide appropriate women whose abortions are legal and of time, at different places and in different elements of abortion care services. performed in medical clinics, mortality set-ups demonstrate that properly trained stands at 49 deaths per 100 000 paramedical personnel could also perform Fusun Artiran Igde, Rukiye Gul, procedures, while among women whose the procedure as safely and effectively as Mahir Igde and Murat Yalcin abortions take place outside medical physicians. The studies showed there is no clinics, the risk of death is four times as substantial difference between high, at 208 deaths per 100 000 complication rates of medical REFERENCES 1. AbouZahr C, Wardlaw T. Maternal mortality in 2000: 44 47 –50 procedures. professionals and paramedics. estimates developed by WHO, UNICEF and UNFPA Turkey has a socialised public health Unfortunately in Turkey authorisation to 2004. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health system that provides free primary health perform abortions and related procedures Organization, 2004. care to all citizens that require it, but are restricted to obstetricians. Mid-level 2. Ashford L, Clifton D. Women of our world 2005 . Washington DC: Population Reference Bureau abortion services and related procedures healthcare providers, family physicians, [PRB], 2005. are restricted to obstetricians and the lack and GPs may also conduct the procedure 3. World Health Organization (WHO). World health of obstetricians, especially in rural areas, but only under the supervision of an report 2005 . Geneva, Switzerland: WHO, 2005. limits women’s access to safe abortion obstetrician, even though they have been 4. United Nations Population Fund, UNFPA. State of services in time. Because of this, women in trained and certificated by the Ministry of world population 2005. The promise of equality: Gender equity, reproductive health and the Millenium rural areas who can afford competent Health. Significantly, family physicians and Development Goals. New York, NY: UNFPA, 2005. services are more likely than women in GPs are much more numerous, more 5. Tracy Geoghegan. State of the world’s mothers 2004. urban areas to have an abortion performed geographically dispersed and more likely Westport, CN: Save the Children, 2004. at a private doctor’s surgery rather than in to work in rural areas than obstetricians. 6. World Health Organization (WHO). Unsafe abortion: hospitals or clinics. However, many women If women’s lives are to be saved, global and regional estimates of the incidence of unsafe abortion and associated mortality in 2000. 4th edn . of low social and economic status face real women’s right to appropriate reproductive Geneva, Switzerland: WHO, 2004. dangers, such as death or permanent health services, including abortion care, 7. U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. disability. must be secured by ensuring that women Mortality and morbidity weekly review. In: In Turkey, there are no accurate, routine have access to these services in their Surveillance Summaries . Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2003. statistical data for unsafe abortions, but communities. According to Grimes et al : 8. Shah I, Ahman E. Age patterns of unsafe abortion in according to research conducted in 1997 developing country regions. Reprod Health Matters at 615 hospitals in 53 provinces that ‘Access to safe, legal abortion is a 2004; 12(24 Suppl): 9–17. determined the main causes of maternal fundamental right of women, 9. United Nations. Report of the International Conference mortality, 4% of women died because of irrespective of where they live. The on Population and Development, Cairo, 5-13 September 1994. New York, NY: UN, 1995. unsafe abortion complications (30.3% from underlying causes of morbidity and 10. Turkish Ministry of Health. Mother child health and haemorrhages, 15.5% from pregnancy mortality from unsafe abortion today family planning general directorate, National Women’s related hypertension, and 9.6% from are not blood loss and infection but, Health and Family Planning Action Plan . Ankara, infection). 15,45 However, because of rather, apathy and disdain toward Turkey: Turkish Ministry of Health, 1998 11. Turkish Ministry of Health. National Strategies and abortions being kept secret or women.’ 51 Action Plan 2005 –2015 for the Sexual Reproductive haemorrhage or sepsis being recorded as Health Sector . Ankara, Turkey: Mother Child Health the final cause of death, we cannot obtain In conclusion, all countries should have and Family Planning General Directorate, 2005. a complete picture. Despite this, unsafe a systematic plan and provide effective 12. Government of Turkey. Population planning law. abortion is clearly one of the major causes emergency medical care for women (Number 2827, sections 5 and 6). Official Turkish Gazette 27/05/1983 –18059. of maternal deaths in Turkey, as in other suffering from abortion complications. For http://www.mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/html/613.html. developing countries. efficient safe abortion care provision, (accessed 3 April 2008).

372 British Journal of General Practice, May 2008 Essay

13. Government of Turkey. Rules for service provision and 32. Karman H. The paramedic abortionist. Clin Obstet 49. Begum SF, Kamal H, Kamal GM. Evaluation of MR supervision of menstrual regulation and sterilization . Gynecol 1972; 15(2): 379 –387. services in Bangladesh . Dhaka, India: Bangladesh Ordinance No. 83/7395 of 14 November 1983, issued 33. Mtonga V, Ndhlovu M. Midwives’ role in Association for Prevention of Septic Abortion under Law No. 2827. Official Turkish Gazette management of elective abortion and post-abortion (BAPSA), 1987. 18/12/1983 –18255. http://www.mevzuat.adalet.gov.tr/ care. Zambian country report. Presented at: 50. Bhatia Sushum, Faruque ASG, Chakraborty J. html/5130.html. (accessed 3 April 2008). Expanding Access; Advancing the Roles of Midlevel Assessing menstrual regulation performed by 14. Hacettepe University Institute of Population Studies, Providers in Menstrual Regulation and Elective paramedics in rural Bangladesh. Stud Fam Plann Turkish Ministry of Health. Turkey Demographic and Abortion Care. Pilanesberg National Park, South 1980; 11(6): 213 –218. Health Survey (TDHS-2003) Report. Ankara, Turkey: Africa, 2 –6 December 2001. 51. Grimes DA, Benson J, Singh S, et al . Unsafe abortion: Mother Child Health and Family Planning General (http://www.ipasihcar.net/expacc/reports/ZRepF.PDF the preventable pandemic. Lancet 2006; 368(550): Directorate, 2004. accessed 3 April 2008). 1908 –1919. 15. United Nations Development Programme . Human 34. Freedman MA, Jillson DA, Coffin RR, Novick LF. Development Report, 2005: International cooperation Comparison of complication rates in first trimester at a crossroads: aid, trade and security in an unequal abortions performed by physician assistants and DOI: 10.3399/bjgp08X280353 world. New York: UNDP, 2005. physicians. Am J Public Health 1986; 76(5): 550 –554. 16. United Nations Development Programme. Human 35. Dovlo D. Using mid-level cadres as substitutes for Development Reports. Turkey — major sustainable internationally mobile health professionals in Africa. human development challenges in Turkey, 1995. A desk review. Hum Resour Health 2004; 2(1): 7. Anakara, Turkey: Human Development Report 36. Horrocks E, Anderson C, Salisbury A. Systematic Office, 1995. review of whether nurse practitioners working in 17. World Health Organization. Reduction of maternal primary care can provide equivalent care to doctors. mortality: a joint WHO/UNFPA/UNICEF/World BMJ 2002; 324(7341): 819 –823 Bank Statement. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO, 1999. 37. Greenslade Forrest C, Leonard AH, et al . Manual 18. Brenner WE, Edelman DA. Menstrual regulation: vacuum aspiration: a summary of clinical and risks and ‘abuses’. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 1977; 15(2): programmatic experience worldwide. Stud Fam Plann 177 –183. 1993; 25(1): 64. 19. Goldthorp WO. Ten-minute abortions. Br Med J 38. Hessini L. Abortion and Islam: policies and practice 1977; 2(6086): 562 –564. in the Middle East and North Africa. Reprod Health 20. World Health Organization. Safe abortion: technical Matters 2007; 15(29): 75 –84. and policy guidance for health systems. Geneva, 39. MClaurin KE. A pro-active approach: meeting Switzerland: WHO, 2003. women’s needs for abortion care in restrictive 21. Fortney JA, Vengadasalam D. Disposable menstrual environments. Presented at: 119th Annual Meeting of regulation kits in a non-throw-away economy. the American Public Health Association. Atlanta, Contraception 1980; 21(3): 235 –244. Georgia, 11 –14 November 1991. 22. Weeks A, Alia G, Blum J, et al . A randomized trial of 40. Safe motherhood fact sheets: Colombo Technical misoprostol compared With manual vacuum Consultation, October 1997 . New York: Family Care aspiration for incomplete abortion. Obstet Gynecol International, 1998. 2005; 106(3): 540 –547. 41. World Health Organisation (WHO). Reduction of 23. Macisaac L, Darney P. Early surgical abortion: an maternal mortality. A joint WHO/UNFPA/UNICEF/ alternative to and backup for . Am J World Bank statement. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO, Obstet Gynecol 2000; 183(2 Suppl): S76 –83. 1999. 24. Forna F, Gulmezoglu AM. Surgical procedures to 42. World Health Organisation (WHO). The Mother- evacuate incomplete abortion. Cochrane Database Baby Package: An Overview, WHO/FHE/MSM/95.5. Syst Rev 2001; (1): CD001993. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO, 1995. 25. Cates W Jr. Legal abortion: the public health record. 43. World Health Organisation (WHO). Complications of Science 1982; 215: 1586 –1590. abortion: Technical and managerial guidelines for prevention and treatment. Geneva, Switzerland: 26. Rogo K. Improving technologies to reduce abortion- WHO, 1995. related morbidity and mortality. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2004; 85(Suppl 1): S73 –82. 44. Ladjali M, Hammand J, et al . Unsafe abortion and sexual health in the Arab world: the Damascus 27. Iyengar K, Iyengar SD. Elective abortion as a primary Conference. London: International Planned health service in rural India: experience with manual Parenthood Federation, Arab World Region, 1993. vacuum aspiration. Reprod Health Matters 2002; 10(19): 54 –63. 45. World Health Organisation (WHO). Research of major maternal mortality causes of Turkey from the 28. Jowett M. Safe Motherhood interventions in low- hospital records Ministry of Health . Ankara, Turkey: income countries: an economic justification and Public Health Department of Hacettepe University, evidence of cost effectiveness. Health Policy 2000; 2000. 53(3): 201 –228. 46. Chaudhuri SK, and International Contributors. 29. Sibuyi MC. Provision of abortion services by Practice of fertility control: a comprehensive textbook. midwives in Limpopo Province of South Africa. Afr J 4th edn . New Delhi: B.I Churchill Livingstone, 1996. Reprod Health 2004; 8(1): 75 –78. 47. Laufe LE, Husman C, Kessel E, Briton LA. Menstrual 30. Westfall JM, Sophocles A, Burggraf H, Ellis S. Manual regulation: A new family planning service. Western vacuum aspiration for first-trimester abortion. Arch Pennsylvannnia Hospital Medical Bulletin 1974; 8(1): Fam Med 1998; 7(6): 559 –562. 3–8. 31. Warriner IK, Meirik O, Hoffman M, et al . Rates of 48. Laufe LE. Menstrual Regulation — International complication in first-trimester manual vacuum Perspective. In: Zatuchni GI, Sciarra JJ, Speidel JJ aspiration abortion done by doctors and mid-level (eds). Pregnancy termination, PARFR series on fertility providers in South Africa and Vietnam: a randomised regulation . Hagerstown, MD: Harper & Row, 1979: controlled equivalence trial. Lancet 2006; 368(9551): 78 –81. 1965 –1972.

British Journal of General Practice, May 2008 373