DOCSLIB.ORG

Remaining in the Shadows: Parliament and Accountability In

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Remaining in the Shadows: Parliament and Accountability In Remaining in the Shadows Parliament and Accountability in East Africa Tundu Lissu Remaining in the Shadows – Parliament and Accountability in East Africa By Hon. Tundu Lissu Berlin and Tienen, August 2020 Remaining in the Shadows- Parliament and Accountability in East Africa Copyright © Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung ISBN 978-9966-021-22-9 Year of publication 2021 Design and Printing by: Lino Typesetters (K) Ltd. Email: [email protected] The pictures on the cover page are those of Parliament Buildings of Uganda (left), Kenya (centre) and Tanzania (right). Remaining in the Shadows – Parliament and Accountability in East Africa iii Table of Content Acknowledgements ...........................................................................................................v List of Abbreviations .......................................................................................................vii List of Statutes .................................................................................................................ix Publisher’s Note .............................................................................................................xiv Foreword .........................................................................................................................xvi Summary ............................................................................................................................1 Introduction – The Long Road for Parliamentarism in East Africa ..........................16 Part I – Kenya: ‘Constitution We Did Not Want’? The Parliamentary Road to Kenya’s Democracy ........................................................................................................46 CHAPTER ONE: THE NEW CONSTITUTION AND ITS TENSIONS ..........49 CHAPTER TWO: DEVOLUTION OR MAJIMBO? ...........................................66 CHAPTER THREE: INDEPENDENCE AND THE RISE OF IMPERIAL PRESIDENCY ........................................................................................................79 CHAPTER FOUR: DEMOCRACY MAKES A COME-BACK .........................95 CHAPTER FIVE: CONSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENTS SINCE 2010 ...107 Part II – Uganda: ‘End of the Road for Federation’? Federalism, Parliamentarism and Presidentialism in Uganda’s Long March to Democracy ..................................119 CHAPTER ONE: IN THE BEGINNING THERE WAS BUGANDA… .........122 CHAPTER TWO: THE UGANDA ORDER IN COUNCIL 1902 ....................135 CHAPTER THREE: THE STILL-BIRTH OF FEDERAL UGANDA .............143 CHAPTER FOUR: 1967 CONSTITUTION AND ‘THE CREEPING DICTATORSHIP’..................................................................................................153 CHAPTER FIVE: OBOTE’S HEIRS AND THEIR INHERITANCE .............176 CHAPTER SIX: THE EMPEROR UNCLOTHED: THE CONSTITUTION AND THE PRESIDENCY ...................................................................................184 Part III – Tanzania: Déjà-Vu? Parliamentary Democracy and the Challenge of Imperial Presidency in Tanzania .................................................................................192 CHAPTER ONE: THE POISONED CHALICE OF COLONIALISM ...........192 iv Remaining in the Shadows – Parliament and Accountability in East Africa CHAPTER TWO: INDEPENDENCE AND ITS INHERITANCES ................199 CHAPTER THREE: END OF THE HONEYMOON ........................................206 CHAPTER FOUR: THE DEMOCRATIC RECOVERY ...................................225 CHAPTER FIVE: THE NEW CONSTITUTION-MAKING ...........................233 CHAPTER SIX: DÉJÀ-VU OR DEMOCRATIC RETREAT? .............................255 Conclusion – How Far Have Our Parliaments Come? ..............................................260 Bibliography ..................................................................................................................273 Remaining in the Shadows – Parliament and Accountability in East Africa v Acknowledgements This book started on a very modest scale. Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung (KAS) which provided the grant that made it all possible, demanded of me to produce a 30-40 page monograph with ‘standard pages’, i.e. “typewritten pages with 30 lines of 60 keystrokes each….”! This modest assignment was to be undertaken over a period of seven months, a rather generous timeframe given the scope of the contract. However, the contract also stipulated that I had “... to depict the subject matter exhaustively in a publication-ready version.” I signed the contract very quickly. Over time, however, it dawned upon both KAS and myself that a study of parliaments of three different countries with different historical, social and political contexts, could not be ‘depicted’ exhaustively in a 30 to 40 standard page monograph. As a result, what should have been a monograph eventually morphed into this book. And so, I must register my gratitude to KAS, especially its Subsahara-Africa Department, for not only making the grant possible but also for hosting me and organizing meetings with German government officials, members of the Bundestag and other stakeholders on the numerous occasions that I visited in Berlin in the course of researching and writing of the book. Special mention is due to Stefan Friedrich, the Head of the Subsahara-Africa Department, Stefanie Brinkel, Stefanie Rothenberger, Mathias Kamp, Tillman Feltes and Miriam Fischer, for their patience, persistence and encouragement which ensured this book sees the light of day. Much of the published material for the Kenya and Uganda studies was procured from Nairobi by Maria Leti ‘Nyailanda’; while those from Tanzania were made available by my brothers Alute Mughwai in Arusha and Ikoti Lissu in Dar es Salaam. All this material found its way to Tienen by way of Berlin, thanks to my great friend Daniel El-Noshokaty, formerly Country Director of KAS Tanzania. To all of them I owe a great fraternal debt of gratitude. Dr. Willy Mutunga, former Chief Justice and President of the Supreme Court of Kenya, generously went through the manuscript in its semi-finished stage, and made typically critical and valuable comments which enabled me to polish some of my arguments. Ndugu Mutunga also gave of his time to write an incisive Foreword to the book. For this I am grateful, as I have always been for his exemplary commitment to human rights and social justice in his native Kenya and in Tanzania where he spent his undergraduate student years. Finally, I owe a huge emotional debt to my family, my wife Alicia and children Tino and Eddie. They have never said much, publicly or privately, but one can only imagine the horrors they went through during the past three years, starting with that fateful vi Remaining in the Shadows – Parliament and Accountability in East Africa Thursday afternoon on 7th September, 2017. Their selfless love, unswerving devotion and unstinting friendship did not only see me through those dark days, it has always been a great source of strength for me. Tundu Lissu Tienen, December 2020 Remaining in the Shadows – Parliament and Accountability in East Africa vii List of Abbreviations AIM African Independence Movement AMNUT All Muslim National Union of Tanganyika ANC African National Congress ASP Afro-Shiraz Party BBI Building Bridges Initiative CCM Chama Cha Mapinduzi CHADEMA Chama Cha Demokrasia na Maendeleo CKRA Constitution of Kenya Review Act CKRC Constitution of Kenya Review Commission CoE Committee of Experts EBC Electoral and Boundaries Commission ECK Electoral Commission of Kenya IEBC Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission GEMA Gikuyu, Embu and Meru Association KADU Kenya African Democratic Union KANU Kenya African National Union KASA Kenya Socialist Alliance KPU Kenya People’s Union KY Kabaka Yekka NARC National Rainbow Coalition NCC National Constitutional Conference NEC National Electoral Commission NEP National Enterprise Party NRA National Resistance Army NRC National Resistance Council NRM National Resistance Movement viii Remaining in the Shadows – Parliament and Accountability in East Africa NUTA National Union of Tanganyika Workers ODM-K Orange Democratic Movement – Kenya PCK People’s Commission of Kenya PCP People’s Convention Party PDP People’s Democratic Party PSC Parliamentary Select Committee SRB State Research Bureau TANU Tanganyika African National Union TFL Tanganyika Federation of Labour TISS Tanzania Intelligence and Security Service UKAWA Umoja wa Katiba ya Wananchi UNLF Ugandan National Liberation Front UPC Uganda People’s Congress UTP United Tanganyika Party Remaining in the Shadows – Parliament and Accountability in East Africa ix List of Statutes TANZANIAN STATUTES The Deportation Ordinance, 1921 The Expulsion of Undesirables Ordinance, 1936 The Emergency Powers Order in Council, 1939 The Legislative Council (Elections) (Amendment) Ordinance, 1959 The Legislative Council (Power & Privileges) Ordinance, Chapter 359 of the Laws of Tanganyika The Constitution of Tanganyika Act, 1961 The Constituent Assembly Act, 1962, No. 66 of 1962 Republican Constitution, 1962 The Republic of Tanganyika (Consequential, Transitional & Temporary Provisions) Act, 1962 The Preventive Detention Act 1962, No. 500 of 1962 The United Republic (Declaration of Name) Act, 1964, Act No. of 1964 The Interim Constitution of Tanzania Act, 1965, Act No. 43 of 1965 The National Assembly (Alteration of the Number of Constituency Members) Act, 1968, Act No. 56 of 1968 The Interim Constitution of Tanzania (Increase in the Number of Regional Commissioners) Act, 1971, Act No. 29 of 1971 The Interim Constitution
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Majadiliano Ya Bunge ______
    NAKALA YA MTANDAO (ON LINE DOCUMENT) BUNGE LA TANZANIA ___________ MAJADILIANO YA BUNGE ______________ BUNGE LA KUMI NA MOJA ___________ MKUTANO WA KWANZA Kikao cha Kwanza - Tarehe 17 Novemba, 2015 (Bunge lilianza Saa Tatu Asubuhi) DKT. THOMAS D. KASHILILAH - KATIBU WA BUNGE: Naomba tukae. TANGAZO LA RAIS LA KUITISHA MKUTANO WA BUNGE DKT. THOMAS D. KASHILILAH - KATIBU WA BUNGE: Waheshimiwa Wabunge, kwa mujibu wa masharti ya Katiba, Mkutano huu wa Kwanza unaanza kwa Rais kuuitisha. Naomba kuchukua nafasi hii kusoma Tangazo la Rais kama ambavyo tumelipokea. Tangazo la Serikali Na. 513 la tarehe 6 Novemba, 2015. Kwa mujibu wa Katiba ya Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania Sura ya Pili, hati iliyotolewa kwa mujibu wa Ibara ya 90(1). Hati ya Kuitisha Mkutano wa Bunge Jipya. KWA KUWA, Uchaguzi Mkuu ulifanyika tarehe 25 Oktoba, 2015 katika Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania, kwa mujibu wa Katiba ya Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania ya mwaka 1977; NA KWA KUWA, masharti ya Ibara ndogo ya kwanza ya Ibara ya 90 ya Katiba ya Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania ya mwaka 1977, yanamtaka Rais wa Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania kuitisha Mkutano wa Bunge Jipya kabla ya kupita siku saba tangu Tume ya Uchaguzi kutangaza matokeo ya Uchaguzi Mkuu; NA KWA KUWA, matokeo ya Uchaguzi Mkuu uliofanyika tarehe 25 Oktoba, 2015 yalitangazwa na Tume ya Taifa ya Uchaguzi tarehe 29 Oktoba, 2015; HIVYO BASI, mimi John Pombe Joseph Magufuli, Rais wa Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania, kwa mamlaka niliyonayo chini ya Ibara ya 90(1) ya 1 NAKALA YA MTANDAO (ON LINE DOCUMENT) Katiba ya Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania ya mwaka 1977, naitisha Mkutano wa Bunge Jipya la Jamhuri ya Muungano wa Tanzania, ufanyike katika ukumbi wa Bunge uliopo Mjini Dodoma tarehe 17 Novemba, 2015 kuanzia saa tatu asubuhi.
    [Show full text]
  • Escalating Land Conflicts in Uganda
    ESCALATING LAND CONFLICTS IN UGANDA A review of evidence from recent studies and surveys By Margaret A. Rugadya 1 June, 2009 For the International Republican Institute (IRI) (Funder) And the Uganda Round Table Foundation (Implementer) Abstract : Despite progress made to address land-related legislative issues, the land sector in Uganda faces several challenges that include insecurity of tenure, overlapping and conflicting land rights, and glaring inequity in access to and ownership of land. Conflicts that are a consequence of colonial legacy are exacerbated in the majority of cases by competition over access, use and transfer of scarce land and natural resources, ever increasing population densities, largely driven by the high population growth rate, unsustainable agricultural practices, and policy and institutional weaknesses. Possibility of increasing conflict is largely driven by competition for influence and power which comes with demonstrated control over land matters such as ownership, allocation and access especially as regards overlapping land rights. Structurally, Uganda’s population is growing at a high rate of 3.2 per cent and is projected to shoot up to 39.3 million in the year 2015 and 54.9 million in 2025 due to high fertility rate, set next to deficits in land governance, corruption and ignorance of the law, the automatic escalation of land conflict to phenomenal levels, is not only well deserved but is clearly foretold. 1 Research Fellow at Maastricht Graduate School of Governance, University of Maastricht and Director, Associates Foundation; a public policy research foundation, Email: [email protected] , Tel. 041-4541988 i CONTENT 1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 OVERVIEW OF FINDINGS .................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Bunge Newsletter
    BungeNe ewsletter Issue No 008 June 2013 New Budget Cycle Shows Relavance For the first time in recent Tanzania history the engage the government and influence it make sev- Parliament has managed to pass the next financial eral tangible changes in its initial budget proposals. year budget before the onset of that particular year. This has been made possible by the Budget Commit- This has been made possi- tee, another new innovation by Speaker Makinda. ble by adoption of new budget cycle. Under the old cycle, it was not possible to influence According to the new budget cycle, the Parliament the government to make changes in budgetary allo- starts discussing the budget in April as opposed to cations. That was because the main budget was read, old cycle where debate on the new budget started on debated and passed before the sectoral plans. After June and ends in the first or second week of August. the main budget was passed, it was impossible for the MPs and government to make changes in the When the decision was taken to implement the new sectoral budgets since they were supposed to reflect budget cycle and Speaker Anne Makinda announced the main budget which had already been passed. the new modalities many people, including Mem- bers of Parliament, were skeptical. Many stakehold- These and many other changes have been made possi- ers were not so sure that the new cycle would work. ble through the five components implemented under the Parliament five years development plan. “Govern- But Ms Makinda has managed to prove the doubt- ment and Budget Oversight and Accountability is one ers wrong.
    [Show full text]
  • Paper No. Makerere University Makerere
    PAPER NO. MAKERERE UNIVERSITY MAKERERE INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL RESEARCH COMMUNAL CONFLICTS IN THE MILITARY AND ITS POLITICAL CONSEQUENCES By Dan Mudoola MAKERERE INSTITUTE OF SOCIAL RESEARCH Paper Presented to the Seroinar on "INTERNAL CONFLICT IK UGANDA", 21st - 26th September, 1987; Sponsored by International Alert London; MaJcerere Institute of Social Research, MaJcerere University; International Peace Research Institute, Oslo; and The United Nat Lons University, Tokyo. Views and opinions in this paper are the sole responsibility of the Author, not the sponsors' nor those of the organisation the author oomes from. the civil service and the judiciary, were defined. On the first Independence anniversary the constitution was amended to provide for a ceremonial president to replace the Governor-General. On the occasion of opening the first Independence. Parliament the Queen's representative, the Duke of Kent, members of the coalition UPC-KY government and, to some extent, members of the Opposition were in a sanguine self-congratulatory mood. The Duke of Kent promised thai his Government "would foster the spirit of tolerance and goodwill between all the peoples of Uganda - It would - pay due heed to the traditional beliefs and customs of the diverse peoples of Uganda. It would respect individual rights of the oommon man. It' would recognise the special status and dignity of the Hereditary Rulers of the Kingdoms and of the Constitutional Heads of the Districts". In equal measure, the Prime Minister, Apolo Milton Obote:, believed that "'traditional institutions would form a firm foundation upon which our newly independent state could be _ 3 advanoed." The leader of the Opposition, Basil Bataringays however, oautioned against "'tribalism and factionalism, our: two most deadly enemies - and unless we sen .acquire - • a sense of common purpose? - we can never be sure that our future path vri.ll be; entirely smooth1^- - Within a space of less than four years another actor v/ho had never been pert of the political calculations leading to independence- came to the scene.
    [Show full text]
  • The Appointment, Tenure and Removal of Judges Under Commonwealth
    The The Appointment, Tenure and Removal of Judges under Commonwealth Principles Appoin An independent, impartial and competent judiciary is essential to the rule tmen of law. This study considers the legal frameworks used to achieve this and examines trends in the 53 member states of the Commonwealth. It asks: t, Te ! who should appoint judges and by what process? nur The Appointment, Tenure ! what should be the duration of judicial tenure and how should judges’ remuneration be determined? e and and Removal of Judges ! what grounds justify the removal of a judge and who should carry out the necessary investigation and inquiries? Re mo under Commonwealth The study notes the increasing use of independent judicial appointment va commissions; the preference for permanent rather than fixed-term judicial l of Principles appointments; the fuller articulation of procedural safeguards necessary Judge to inquiries into judicial misconduct; and many other developments with implications for strengthening the rule of law. s A Compendium and Analysis under These findings form the basis for recommendations on best practice in giving effect to the Commonwealth Latimer House Principles (2003), the leading of Best Practice Commonwealth statement on the responsibilities and interactions of the three Co mmon main branches of government. we This research was commissioned by the Commonwealth Secretariat, and undertaken and alth produced independently by the Bingham Centre for the Rule of Law. The Centre is part of the British Institute of International and
    [Show full text]
  • Notes and References
    Notes and References 1 The Foundation of Kenya Colony I. P[ublic] R[ecord] O[ffice] Kew CO 533/234 ff 432-44. Kenya was how Johann Krapf, the German missionary who was in 1849 the first white man to see the mountain, transliterated the Kamba pronunciation of the Kikuyu name for it, Kirinyaga. The Kamba substituted glottal stops for intermediate consonants, hence 'Ki-i-ny-a'. T. C. Colchester, 'Origins of Kenya as the Name of the Country', Rhodes House. Mss Afr s.1849. 2. PRO CO 822/3117 Malcolm MacDonald to Duncan Sandys. Secret and Personal. 18 September 1963. 3. The new rail routes in question were the Uasin Gishu line and the Thika extension. M. F. Hill, Permanent Way. The StOlY of the Kenya and Uganda Railway (Nairobi: East African Railways and Harbours, 2nd edn 1961), p. 392. 4. Daily Sketch, 5 July 1920, p. 5. 5. Sekallyolya ('the crane [or stork] looking out on the world') was first printed in Nairobi in the Luganda language in 1921. From time to time it brought out editions in Swahili and for special occasions in English. Harry Thuku's Tangazo was the first Kenya African single­ sheet newsletter. 6. Interview with James Beauttah, Fort Hall, 1964. Beauttah was one of the first English-speaking African telephone operators. He claimed to be the first African to have electricity in his house. 7. PRO FO 2/377 A. Gray to FO, 16 February 1900, 'Memo on Report of Law Officers of the Crown reo East Africa and Uganda Protector­ ates'. The effect of the opinion of the law officers is that Her Majesty has, by virtue of her Protectorate, entire control over all lands unappropriated ..
    [Show full text]
  • Revisiting the Media Freedom Debate at Uganda's Independence Golden Jubilee
    REVISITING THE MEDIA FREEDOM DEBATE AT UGANDA'S INDEPENDENCE GOLDEN JUBILEE Michael Kakooza REALITY CHECK Revisiting the media freedom debate at Uganda’s independence golden jubilee Written by Dr. Michael Kakooza The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung and Uganda Media Development Foundation but rather those of the author. REVISITING THE MEDIA FREEDOM DEBATE AT UGANDA’S INDEPENDENCE GOLDEN JUBILEE i REALITY CHECK Revisiting the media freedom debate at Uganda’s independence golden jubilee Published by: Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung, Uganda 51. A Prince Charles Drive, Kololo P.O. Box 647, Kampala, Tel. +256 414 254611 www.kas.de ISBN: 978 9970 153 08 4 In partnership with: Uganda Media Development Foundation Plot 976 Mugerwa Road. Bukoto P.O.Box 21778 Kampala, Tel. +256 414 532083 www.umdf.co.ug © Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung e.v. 2012 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, without the prior written permission of the Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung. ii REVISITING THE MEDIA FREEDOM DEBATE AT UGANDA’S INDEPENDENCE GOLDEN JUBILEE Table of Contents Foreword ...................................................................................... 1 Preface ............................................................................................3 Profile of the Author ....................................................................... 6 Acknowledgements .......................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • @Bernadette A. Da Silva Montreal. Qu,Bec
    f - .. ,. , lI' .. 1 , l" i j• • McGUL UNIVERSITY 1 THE POST-COLONIAL STATE: UGAIDA 1962 - 1971. A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE . FACULTY OF GRADUATE STUDIES AND RESEARCH -IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQl1IREMEMS FOR THE DEGREE OF MiSTER OF ARTS BI @Bernadette A. Da Silva Montreal. Qu,bec August 1985. 1 s • • ABSTRACT u .. • . The lIubJect of th!. thesie 18 the nature ot the poet- oolonial ita te in Atriea as exe.pl1tled by the proeusee ot ..tate for •• tion in Uganda ,during the 1962-71 periode It h the contention of the theeh thaet an 9bderetanding or, thele • proceeeu le neceeearl for an underetandlng of the poet­ colonial etate. state for ..tion ie a direct r.sponee on the part of poli tical leader.' to the preesuree and proble.s created bl eoc1eta(l. tCJt'oes. Thue, a study of these proeellee will shed turther ~léht on the ralationshlpe betw.en varloue , , eoeietal toroes.... ae _11 ae betlleeri eocletal forcee and the • ta te. Thie Ihould, in turn, enable us ta &see 8 e th, nature of the atate, in part1cular vhe~her It existe at aIl, and if la whether i t playl an Instru.ental role or whether l.t i8 art autotlQaous to'rce. On the buie ot the U,anda aaterlal, the f thesis telte the varloue hlpothe818 re,ardlng the funct1011B of \ the etate and concludee tha~.whlle it do~ndeed exiet, the ·f at•. t. ".(acII ~any eonltra1nta on He autono.y, a eondition re­ , tll"Cted in the poli~ee puraued bl the poli tical leaderehip ot the country.
    [Show full text]
  • Journal of Eastern African Studies Rethinking the State in Idi Amin's Uganda: the Politics of Exhortation
    This article was downloaded by: [Cambridge University Library] On: 20 July 2015, At: 20:55 Publisher: Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: 5 Howick Place, London, SW1P 1WG Journal of Eastern African Studies Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/rjea20 Rethinking the state in Idi Amin's Uganda: the politics of exhortation Derek R. Peterson a & Edgar C. Taylor a a Department of History , University of Michigan , Ann Arbor , MI , 48109 , USA Published online: 26 Feb 2013. To cite this article: Derek R. Peterson & Edgar C. Taylor (2013) Rethinking the state in Idi Amin's Uganda: the politics of exhortation, Journal of Eastern African Studies, 7:1, 58-82, DOI: 10.1080/17531055.2012.755314 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17531055.2012.755314 PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the “Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content.
    [Show full text]
  • Autocratic Courts in Africa by Fiona Feiang Shen-Bayh A
    Autocratic Courts in Africa By Fiona Feiang Shen-Bayh A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philsophy in Political Science in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Leonardo Arriola, Chair Assistant Professor Aila Matanock Professor T.J. Pempel Professor Jason Wittenberg Professor Saira Mohamed Spring 2018 Abstract Autocratic Courts in Africa by Fiona Feiang Shen-Bayh Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science University of California, Berkeley Professor Leonardo Arriola, Chair This dissertation examines how judicial institutions in sub-Saharan Africa were used to both legitimize repression and maintain autocratic survival during the postcolonial period, as well as the enduring legacies of these tactics on post-autocratic rule of law. When autocrats turn to courts, these moves are often heralded as signs of democratic opening. However, courts can also become forums of repression, where political rivals are criminally prosecuted for anti-regime behavior. Despite these trends, courts remain relatively understudied in repression research. In fact, conventional definitions of repression are almost exclusively extrajudicial, defined as the arbitrary use of coercive violence to threaten or intimidate its target. While a separate scholarship on authoritarian judiciaries draws attention to the autocratic functions of law and order, these findings tend to be disconnected from research on repression. This has limited theory-building on how and why courts are used to contain democratic dissent. To analyze the politicization of courts in comparative and historical perspective, I develop a theoretical framework that extends beyond conventional notions of judicial independence, re- conceptualizing judicial power along the following three dimensions: jurisdiction, function, and compliance.
    [Show full text]
  • Portugal in the Great War: the African Theatre of Operations (1914- 1918)
    Portugal in the Great War: the African Theatre of Operations (1914- 1918) Nuno Lemos Pires1 https://academiamilitar.academia.edu/NunoPires At the onset of the Great War, none of the colonial powers were prepared to do battle in Africa. None had stated their intentions to do so and there were no indications that one of them would take the step of attacking its neighbours. The War in Africa has always been considered a secondary theatre of operations by all conflicting nations but, as well shall see, not by the political discourse of the time. This discourse was important, especially in Portugal, but the transition from policy to strategic action was almost the opposite of what was said, as we shall demonstrate in the following chapters. It is both difficult and deeply simple to understand the opposing interests of the different nations in Africa. It is difficult because they are all quite different from one another. It is also deeply simple because some interests have always been clear and self-evident. But we will return to our initial statement. When war broke out in Europe and in the rest of the World, none of the colonial powers were prepared to fight one another. The forces, the policy, the security forces, the traditions, the strategic practices were focused on domestic conflict, that is, on disturbances of the public order, local and regional upheaval and insurgency by groups or movements (Fendall, 2014: 15). Therefore, when the war began, the warning signs of this lack of preparation were immediately visible. Let us elaborate. First, each colonial power had more than one policy.
    [Show full text]
  • No. 1. Makhan Singh
    Makhan Singh Every Inch A Fighter Reflections on Makhan Singh and the Trade Union Struggle in Kenya By Shiraz Durrani Presentation in Nairobi. Saturday August 3, 2013 Notes & Quotes Study Guide Series No. 1 (2014) Nairobi 1 Every Inch A Fighter Reflections on Makhan Singh and the Trade Union Struggle in Kenya By Shiraz Durrani Nairobi. Saturday August 3, 2013 Highlights of the presentation at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CByviTH5HC0&t=0s Notes & Quotes Study Guide Series No. 1 (2014) ISBN 978-1-869886-02-8 http://vitabooks.co.uk London. UK Photo: Makhan Singh, Nairobi, 1947. Photo by Gopal Singh Chandan a quote here.” 2 Every inch a fighter Reflections on Makhan Singh and the Trade Union Struggle in Kenya Nairobi. Saturday August 3, 2013 December this year will mark Makhan Singh's 100th birthday. To mark this anniversary and reflect on his life and contribution to Kenya’s liberation, Mau Mau Research Centre invites you to a lecture celebrating the life and work of Makhan Singh on 3rd August 2013 from 1.30pm to 4.00pm. The highlight of the day will be a presentation by our invited speaker, Shiraz Durrani titled: “Every inch a fighter Reflections on Makhan Singh and the trade union struggle in Kenya”. The lecture will take place at the Professional Centre, St John’s Gate, Parliament Road. This Study Guide is based on the presentation made at that event. Highlights of the event can be see on YouTube at the following link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CByviTH5HC0&t=0s 3 Life and times of Makhan Singh Born 27-12-1913, Gharjakh, India 1927: Came to Kenya 1931: Worked in printing press 1939: To India 1940-45: Detained in India 1947: Returned to Kenya 1950-61: Imprisoned in Kenya 4 Makhan Singh, the trade unionist March, 1935: elected Secretary of the Indian Trade Union; Aug 1949: President Influenced ITU to change to Labour Trade Union of Kenya: open it to workers irrespective of race, religion, colour.
    [Show full text]