Raptors in the East African Tropics and Western Indian Ocean Islands: State of Ecological Knowledge and Conservation Status
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
j. RaptorRes. 32(1):28-39 ¸ 1998 The Raptor ResearchFoundation, Inc. RAPTORS IN THE EAST AFRICAN TROPICS AND WESTERN INDIAN OCEAN ISLANDS: STATE OF ECOLOGICAL KNOWLEDGE AND CONSERVATION STATUS MUNIR VIRANI 1 AND RICHARD T. WATSON ThePeregrine Fund, Inc., 566 WestFlying Hawk Lane, Boise,1D 83709 U.S.A. ABSTRACT.--Fromour reviewof articlespublished on diurnal and nocturnal birds of prey occurringin Africa and the western Indian Ocean islands,we found most of the information on their breeding biology comesfrom subtropicalsouthern Africa. The number of published papers from the eastAfrican tropics declined after 1980 while those from subtropicalsouthern Africa increased.Based on our KnoM- edge Rating Scale (KRS), only 6.3% of breeding raptorsin the eastAfrican tropicsand 13.6% of the raptorsof the Indian Ocean islandscan be consideredWell Known,while the majority,60.8% in main- land east Africa and 72.7% in the Indian Ocean islands, are rated Unknown. Human-caused habitat alteration resultingfrom overgrazingby livestockand impactsof cultivationare the main threatsfacing raptors in the east African tropics, while clearing of foreststhrough slash-and-burnmethods is most important in the Indian Ocean islands.We describeconservation recommendations, list priorityspecies for study,and list areasof ecologicalunderstanding that need to be improved. I•y WORDS: Conservation;east Africa; ecology; western Indian Ocean;islands; priorities; raptors; research. Aves rapacesen los tropicos del este de Africa yen islasal oeste del Oc•ano Indico: estado del cono- cimiento eco16gicoy de su conservacitn RESUMEN.--Denuestra recopilacitn de articulospublicados sobre aves rapaces diurnas y nocturnasque se encuentran en Africa yen las islasal oeste del Octano Indico, encontramosque la mayoriade la informaci6n sobre aves rapacesresidentes se origina en la regi6n subtropical del sur de Africa. E1 nfimero de publicacionesprovenientes de los tr6picos del este de Africa, declint despuesde 1980, mientras que aquellos del subtrtpico del sur del continente aumentaron. Con base en nuestra escala de valoraci6ndel conocimientosolo el 6.3% de las especiesresidentes en los tr6picosdel estedel Africa y el 13.6% de lasaves rapaces de islasdel Ocaano Indico puedenser consideradas como Bien Conocidas, mientrasque la mayoria60.8% del estede Africa y 72.2% de las islasal oestedel Octano Indico fueron clasificadascomo Desconocidas.La alteracitn de habitatsde origen antrtpico como resultadodel so- brepastoreoy los impactosde la agricultura son las principalesamenazas para las avesrapaces de los tr6picos del este de Africa, mientrasque la deforestaci6na partir de la quema y tala de bosqueses la amenaza mas i•nportante en las islasdel Octano Indico. Describimosrecomendaciones de conservacitn, identificamoslas especiesprioritarias para estudiare identificamoslas areasde entendimientoecoltgico que deben ser mejoradas. [Traducci6n de C•sar M•rquez] Raptors are an important tool to focus conser- web below them (Thiollay 1992). Becauseof their vation strategies locally, regionally, and globally top positionsin terrestrial and aquatic food webs, (Watson 1991). They can be used as "umbrella spe- raptorscan be used as indicatorsof worldwidepol- cies" because their large home ranges and low lution by pesticides(Newton 1979). Changesin nesting densities necessitatethat any protected ar- raptor distribution or abundance can serve as a eas encompassingviable populations or complete measure of our impact on landscapes,even in re- communities protect sufficient habitat and popu- mote areas (Reichholf 1974). Finally,raptors are lations of most, if not all, other speciesin the food popular and charismatic and several specieshave becomesignificant "flagships" for increasingpub- lic interest and support of conservationprograms • AlsoNational Museumsof Kenya,Nairobi and Leicester (Burnham et al. 1992, Thiollay 1992). University, U.K. This paper combines our collective knowledge 28 MARCH 1998 EAST AFRICAN AND WESTERN INDIAN OCEAN RAPTORS 29 of raptors in the east African tropics and western 1980 material. Pre-1980 titles were obtained from the b•b- Indian Ocean islandsas part of a worldwide review liography of Brown et al. (1982) and Fry et al. (1988). Post-1980 titles were obtained from a keyword search of their conservation and ecology. We chose to from 1980 through the first quarter of 1996 on the BIOS- combine these two regions in one paper to facili- IS (Biological AbstractsInc.) and RRTAC (Raptor Re- tate comparisonof island with continental situa- search and Technical AssistanceCenter, Boise, ID U.S.A ) tions in adjacent geographicareas. The eastAfri- computer databases.We assumedthat the material ob- tained representeda significantproportion of all articles can tropics (including all countries between the published in peer-reviewedjournals, and that these Tropicsof Cancerand Capricorn and eastof about sourcesaccurately reflect ecologicalknowledge based on 20øE, Zanzibar and Pemba islands) and the western scientific studies. Ad-hocaccounts published in newslet- Indian Ocean islands (comprising Madagascar, ters or magazinescan provide additional knowledgebut Mauritius, Seychelles,Reunion, and Comores) sup- they were not included in this review as they are difficult to find and their significanceto the understanding of a port roughly23% of the world'savifauna accord- species'ecology is difficult to assess. ing to specieslisted in Martin (1987), Langrand Based on a similar review of the statusand knowledge (1990), Perlo (1995), and Zimmerman et al. of Central and South American raptors (Bierregaard (1996). These areas contain a broad spectrum of 1995), we assigned scores to each species from 1 to 5 from our I4a•owledgeRating Scale (KRS) where I = an- habitats, from montane through lowland, dry, ecdotal, speculativeor unstudied; 2 = 1 nest or 1 year moist, and riparian forests,to open woodland, sa- low samplesize studies; 3 = multi-year,local area studies, vanna, scrubland, desert, marsh, mangroves,and <5 pairs; 4 = multi-year, >5 pairs; and 5 = >10 pairs, others. The eastAfrican tropicssupport 82 species >10 years,or regional studies.This wasrepeated for four of diurnal birds of prey and 23 nocturnal owls subject areas, factors affecting distribution and abun- dance, population trends, breeding biology, and feeding (Britton 1980, Brown et al. 1982, Fry et al. 1988). ecology. Scoresfor each subject were summed for each Three-quartersof theseraptors, or roughly20% of species (min. 4, max. 20), and speciesranked by score. the world's raptor species,breed within this area Specieswere then grouped into four categoriesof knowl- while the rest use the region as a migratory path- edge based on their scores:Unknown (score 4-6), Little Known (score 7-10), Known (score 11-13), and Well way.The Indian Ocean islandssupport 22 endemic Known (score 14 and above). Although these categories raptor species(15 diurnal birds of prey and seven were subjective,they simplified our review by separating nocturnal owls), five other breeding species,and speciesinto roughly common levels of knowledge. To two Palearcticmigrants. Although both theseareas compare between subject areas, we calculated a "study boast a tremendous diversityof birds that attracts index" (first line of Tables 1 and 2) by stunmingthe KRS for all specieswithin each subject, and converting the the attention of bird watchersworldwide, their rap- total to a percentage of the maximum possibleif all spe- tors are still poorly understood in many respects, cies had KRS of 5. Species' total scoreswere calculated ranging from basicbiology to the factorsaffecting by summing KRS for all speciesin all subject areas and distribution and abundance. Conserving raptors, expressedas a percentageof the maximum possibleif all specieshad KRS of 5. The conservation status of each or using them as a tool to achievebroader conser- species was compiled from two sources (Collar et al vation goals,is impossiblewithout a sound under- 1994, Bennun and Njoroge 1996). standingof their ecologicalrequirements. In this paper, we first give an overview of the R•St:LTS •ND D•SCt:SS•ON state of ecologicalknowledge and conservationsta- State of EcologicalKnowledge and Conservation tus of breeding raptors in the east African tropics Status. We found 251 and 295 articles in our pre- and the western Indian Ocean islands, based on 1980 and post-1980literature searches,respective- 546 published papers and recent listsof speciesin ly. During the pre-1980 era, raptor researchorigi- jeopardy. Second, we outline the main conserva- nated almostequally from countriesin the eastAf- tion issues,contrast threats to raptorson the main- rican tropics (36%) and subtropicalsouthern Af- land with those on islands, summarize information rica (39%), with 14% originating from tropical on causesof threats, and cite particular examples west Africa and 12% from north and central Africa. of problems.Lastly, we discusspriorities for further From 1980 through the first quarter of 1996, the studies and focus of conservation efforts. proportion of publications originating from sub- METHODS tropical southernAfrica increasedto 55% and de- creased to 25% from countries in the east African We reviewedthe literature in peer-reviewedjournals on 105 speciesin Africa, 79 of which breed in tropical east tropics, while they increasedfrom the western In- Africa, and 22 that are endemic to the Indian Ocean dian Ocean islands (10%) and decreased from •slands. The review was divided into pre-1980 and post- tropical west