DOCSLIB.ORG

Search and Surveillance Powers

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Search and Surveillance Powers June 2007, Wellington, New Zealand | R e p o R t 9 7 SeaRch aNd SuRveillaNce poWeRS E3197 June 2007, Wellington, New Zealand | R E P O R T 9 7 SEaRch aNd SuRvEillaNcE POWERS The law commission is an independent, publicly funded, central advisory body established by statute to undertake the systematic review, reform and development of the law of New Zealand. its purpose is to help achieve law that is just, principled, and accessible, and that reflects the heritage and aspirations of the peoples of New Zealand. The Commissioners are: Right honourable Sir Geoffrey Palmer – President dr Warren Young – Deputy President helen aikman Qc Professor John Burrows Qc The General Manager of the law commission is Brigid corcoran The office of the law commission is at level 19, hP Tower, Featherston St, Wellington. Postal address: PO Box 2590, Wellington 6001, New Zealand document Exchange Number: sp 23534 Telephone: (04) 473-3453, Facsimile: (04) 914-4760 Email: [email protected] internet: www.lawcom.govt.nz National library of New Zealand cataloguing-in-Publication data New Zealand. law commission. Search and surveillance powers. (New Zealand law commission report, 0113-2334 ; 97) iSBN 978-1-877316-34-0 1. Searches and seizures—New Zealand. 2. Remote sensing —New Zealand. 3. Electronics in criminal investigation—New Zealand. i. Title. ii. Series: New Zealand. law commission. Report ; 97. 345.930522—dc 22 Report/law commission, Wellington, 2007 iSSN 0113-2334 iSBN 978-1-877316-34-0 This report may be cited as: NZlc R97 This report is also available on the internet at the law commission’s website: www.lawcom.govt.nz Search and surveillance powers ConTenTs letter of transmittal .......................................................................................................................................13 Foreword ....................................................................................................................................... 14 ACknowledgemenTs .................................................................................................................. 17 Terms oF reFerenCe ................................................................................................................... 19 summAry ......................................................................................................................................... 20 chapter 1 – introduction ...............................................................................................................................20 chapter 2 – values underpinning search and surveillance powers ............................................................20 chapter 3 – common issues ..........................................................................................................................21 chapter 4 – applying for and issuing search warrants ...............................................................................22 chapter 5 – Warrantless powers of entry, search and seizure ....................................................................22 chapter 6 – Executing search powers ...........................................................................................................23 chapter 7 – computer searches ....................................................................................................................23 chapter 8 – Search of persons .......................................................................................................................24 chapter 9 – Search of vehicles .....................................................................................................................25 chapter 10 – Production and monitoring powers ......................................................................................25 chapter 11 – interception and surveillance ................................................................................................25 chapter 12 – Privileged and confidential material .......................................................................................26 chapter 13 – Post-execution procedures ......................................................................................................27 chapter 14 – Remedies and immunities .......................................................................................................27 chapter 15 – Reporting on the exercise of search and surveillance powers ..............................................28 chapter 16 – implementation .......................................................................................................................28 ChApTer 1 ........................................................................................................................................ 30 introduction .........................................................................................................................................................30 The growth of search powers ........................................................................................................................30 The nature of the problem .............................................................................................................................31 Scope of report ...............................................................................................................................................32 discussion paper ......................................................................................................................................................... 32 approach taken in report ........................................................................................................................................... 33 Our report .......................................................................................................................................................34 ChApTer 2 ........................................................................................................................................ 36 values underpinning search and surveillance powers ......................................................................................36 introduction ...................................................................................................................................................36 human rights values and law enforcement values ......................................................................................37 Overview .................................................................................................................................................................... 37 human rights values ......................................................................................................................................37 introduction ................................................................................................................................................................ 37 Privacy ......................................................................................................................................................................... 38 Personal integrity ........................................................................................................................................................ 40 Property rights ............................................................................................................................................................ 40 Rule of law .................................................................................................................................................................. 41 law enforcement values ................................................................................................................................41 Search and Surveillance Powers Effectiveness ............................................................................................................................................................... 42 Simplicity .................................................................................................................................................................... 42 certainty ...................................................................................................................................................................... 42 Responsive to different operational circumstances .................................................................................................. 43 human rights consistency .......................................................................................................................................... 43 Reasonable expectations of privacy ..............................................................................................................43 Purpose of reasonable expectations of privacy enquiry ........................................................................................... 44 Reasonable expectations of privacy: what it covers and how it is assessed ............................................................ 44 challenges created by the reasonable expectations of privacy concept ................................................................... 46 Challenges .........................................................................................................................................................................................46 The solution
Load more

Recommended publications
  • An Analysis of the People and Forces Shaping the Development of New
    itl~i:t·~i~·. p~.rfu}~iHort·Jo r ;my:: ch'<!si ~ r ··,::1, t 1 t}:'ed •:" .·••~·:;;;/· Chef\ft.k ~ ~. hn~~E,\:S .,-} ~ :~~: Xa~: ~~;,;~,:~~ :~~........... .~. kolc10d. J6\Wct\0Nh'25' ............................. to be made aval lnble to reader:, in th,· Library under the coadfl:ions determined by the Librarian. I agree to my thesis, i ( a:::lz(,(\ for liy ,111\)t:her instHution, be':f.rig Sent away on temporary loan undl~r condition•; determined by the Lib.rarian. I also agree that my thesis may h~ copi~d for Library use. I do not wish my thesis, ent i tl,•d o • ♦ • ♦ ., • • • ~ " • ♦ ., • • '" e • ., • a· <t ., • • <I • " • " , • ~ • • ~ • .. ,. ~ "' " ,. ., " " i, • ., a 1' • • ♦ <\ • • ♦ • • _.,, "·•, • 4' • 1'+••4 .............. ,,. ......... ,. .............. ~~-~~•··•""""~··" .. "''*""""*"•·······"' • ') .. ♦ Ill ♦ II • ,. " • • • • ll • ., <t <0 • # ♦ ,._ 11 .. t • <> • ., " r t ~ • < • , ~ ~ "' -, ., * t, • • H ► II • • t, ,t 'II • • 4 .. ,. •• ''"* II ii' ,f ,;(' .,:•n1 to o~her ins ti tu:::i.ons 1 without my writtf•n Cl'llSCnt 1,1 i:i0 ,,: ,L, 11t·::t t1. r, yc,1rs. Sl 1;rn:\; ..~,,&~ ... ,........... iJ:1 tt· l o/. I.} 5$,$................... f~f Library l::f.assey University Fi1merston North, N.Z. copyright of this tb1;•sis bL•1c,ngs t,, 'ik 1'l1 '1,,r. l' ca(k rs n°us t :5 lgrt thl~ir name 1!.n ;cthe space below to show that they r.:,c..:,f,n i '.:c• , 11 i. : • TI1cy are asked to add their ;,Jbnanent address. Jlla:e .and Address j✓ ,, " ~ • • ,. • • • • "' • ,. '" • ~ ~ • • • lit • "' ♦ 11 " • • « ,. ., • • ~ • • ~ t " f- • '> " " • ~ ., .. " ,, ♦ "' • r " " I; • ii'- ti q • .. • It • I! "" ♦ • • ~ ft •--✓~ ,.C,, ',, \~,;~"_t:3•"•,*.•,:~',., .. , .. , ♦• ♦.-: *'i< 11.,dt 9,,~ ~ ♦"" f * ! ♦ .# ~. ♦ fy f-"'. 11"4 .
    [Show full text]
  • RONALD ROSS WATSON Ph
    Ronald R. Watson, Ph.D. Jan 2015 Page 1 RONALD ROSS WATSON, Ph.D. Curriculum Vitae CHRONOLOGY OF EDUCATION 1966 Bachelor of Science, Department of Chemistry, Brigham Young University. Major: Chemistry Minor: Mathematics & Spanish 1971 Doctor of Philosophy, Department of Biochemistry, Michigan State University Minor: Nutrition and Organic Chemistry 1971-73 Post-Doctoral Fellow, School of Public Health, Harvard University. Classes in Nutrition & Immunology 1983-84 Army Medical Corps, Advanced Officers Training, Part I & II, Command and General Staff Training at Fort Sam Houston Medical Center, San Antonio, Texas DISSERTATION 1971 Watson RR. Biosynthesis of Apiin Doctor of Philosophy Dissertation, Michigan State University. MAJOR FIELDS: Cancer prevention by nutritional immunostimulation, drug and alcohol abuse: Immunomodulation in mouse AIDS, immune and nutritional restoration, immune mechanisms of heart disease. CHRONOLOGY OF EMPLOYMENT 1982+ University of Arizona 2007-9 Interim Director, Division of Health Promotion Sciences. 2001+ Adjunct Professor, Department of Nutritional Sciences. 2000+ Professor, Mel and Enid Zuckerman College of Public Health, tenure 1987+ Professor, School of Medicine, Department of Family and Community Medicine. 1987-97 Researcher, (without compensation), Tucson Veterans Administration Medical Center, Director of the Alcohol-Immunology laboratory. 1983 U.S. Army Summer Faculty, Research in Science and Engineering (Summer) Program at U.S. Army Medical Research Institute of Infectious Diseases, Frederick, Ronald
    [Show full text]
  • An Annotated Bibliography of Published Sources on Christchurch
    Local history resources An annotated bibliography of published sources on the history of Christchurch, Lyttelton, and Banks Peninsula. Map of Banks Peninsula showing principal surviving European and Maori place-names, 1927 From: Place-names of Banks Peninsula : a topographical history / by Johannes C. Andersen. Wellington [N.Z.] CCLMaps 536127 Introduction Local History Resources: an annotated bibliography of published sources on the history of Christchurch, Lyttelton and Banks Peninsula is based on material held in the Aotearoa New Zealand Centre (ANZC), Christchurch City Libraries. The classification numbers provided are those used in ANZC and may differ from those used elsewhere in the network. Unless otherwise stated, all the material listed is held in ANZC, but the pathfinder does include material held elsewhere in the network, including local history information files held in some community libraries. The material in the Aotearoa New Zealand Centre is for reference only. Additional copies of many of these works are available for borrowing through the network of libraries that comprise Christchurch City Libraries. Check the catalogue for the classification number used at your local library. Historical newspapers are held only in ANZC. To simplify the use of this pathfinder only author and title details and the publication date of the works have been given. Further bibliographic information can be obtained from the Library's catalogues. This document is accessible through the Christchurch City Libraries’ web site at https://my.christchurchcitylibraries.com/local-history-resources-bibliography/
    [Show full text]
  • When Submitting Entries, It Will Be Necessary to Name Your First Three
    4. Twelve white Rose of Sharon, rare shrub, (990 kcs., 250 w., 6:00 a.m.); 4Y0, sturdy two-year-old stock. 5. Shhh! One large color photograph, guaranteed Dunedin, (1140 kcs., 150 w., 6:00 a.m.) ; highly desirable. No details. and 3YL, Christchurch, (1200 kcs., 250 w., 6. One trial membership in the UDXC, six months, all privileges. 6:00 a.m.). The times noted are closing 7. Twenty-five Indian Head pennies, assorted hour, American E.S.T. The stations close a years, superb, guaranteed by the U. S. govern- ment. half hour earlier from October to the end 8. One Philco doublet aerial, used, perfect condi- of April because of Summer Time. 4YZ tion, complete. will go up to 5000 watts in August, when When submitting entries, it will be a new regional station of the same power necessary to name your first three will open in Hawke's Bay. choices for prizes, and to name those "The National Commercial Service at which you especially do not want. present controls four stations which are This month, we are privileged to maintained by advertising. Their powers will be increased later. They are: 'present a very interesting letter from 2ZB, Wellington, (1130 kcs., lOOOw, 7:00 Mrv. Branks, 5 Dublin St., Invercar- a.m.); 4ZB, Dunedin, (1220 kcs., lOOOw, gill, New Zealand. 7:00 a.m.); and 3ZB, Christchurch, (1430 Radio In New Zealand kcs., lOOOw, 7:00 a.m.). "Once I read an article entitled 'New "There are four private stations left Zealand—the DXer's Paradise'.
    [Show full text]
  • The Social Organisation of Rugby Union in New Zealand
    i Unions, Leagues and Franchises: The Social Organisation of Rugby Union in New Zealand ________________________________________ A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Sociology at the University of Canterbury By Camilla Obel _________________________________________ University of Canterbury 2001 ii Til min mor og Matthew i ABSTRACT The amateur game of rugby union is analysed by focussing upon the struggles for control between national and local unions and players. Using historical material and interviews with administrators, current players in the New Zealand national team, the All Blacks, and Canterbury, a local provincial union, I show how the game of rugby union consolidated as the national game. I follow these actors through the shift to a global professional game sponsored by television networks and show how the local advantages in the New Zealand game come to be reconfigured in this context. In the first half of the thesis I argue that a contested and continuous process of indigenisation secured both the national popularity of the amateur game, against the threat of the rival code of professional rugby league, and maintained all-important competitive ties between the national team and Britain. Protection against threats from the rival code was secured by the centralised New Zealand Rugby Football Union (NZRFU) creating two national teams, the All Blacks (1905), composed of both ‘white’ and Maori players, and the New Zealand Maori team (1910) composed only of indigenous Maori players. Further, the establishment of a national challenge competition, the Ranfurly Shield (1902), and the formation of a national league, the National Provincial Championship (1976), secured local and national publics for the amateur game.
    [Show full text]
  • Tiki to Mickey
    TIKI TO MICKEY: THE ANGLO-AMERICAN INFLUENCE ON NEW ZEALAND COMMERCIAL MUSIC RADIO 1931-2008 A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Media and Communication by Brendan Reilly University of Canterbury Christchurch New Zealand 2011 Tiki to Mickey: The Anglo-American influence on New Zealand Commercial Music Radio 1931 -2008 (used with permission © Dick Frizzell 1991) Table of Contents ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...................................................................................................................... 7 ABSTRACT .......................................................................................................................................... 8 ABBREVIATIONS ................................................................................................................................. 9 CHAPTER ONE: OWNERSHIP AND THE QUESTION OF DIVERSITY ...................................................... 10 INTRODUCTION ...................................................................................................................................... 10 COMMERCIAL RADIO FOCUS ..................................................................................................................... 12 RADIO IN NEW ZEALAND .......................................................................................................................... 13 GROWTH IN THE LOCAL MARKET ...............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Here She Teaches on Television Production Management, Health and Safety, Copyright, Ethics and Employability
    CONTENTS 02 ABOUT MATERIAL REFLECTIONS Iain Taylor 04 MAKING ORDER OUT OF CHAOS Hilary Weston Jones 06 PATCH LEAD POSSIBILITIES Chris Mapp 08 MY VEGETABLE PEELER - 1989 Nicholas Gebhardt 10 A REASON AND A PURPOSE Tony Cordell 12 DEDICATED TO HAN SHAN Paul Whitehead 14 THE SOLID-STATE OF RADIO Sam Coley 16 MY NOTEBOOK Lee Grifiths 18 ONLY DANCING. AGAIN. Philip Young 20 THE ARCHITECTURE OF THE SAXOPHONE Joe Wright 22 'GIMME A CAN OF MISTER PRINCE ALBERT' Brian Homer 01 ABOUT MATERIAL REFLECTIONS Material Reflections is an ongoing project led by Dr Iain Taylor, within the Birmingham Centre for Media and Cultural Research (BCMCR) at Birmingham City University. It collects a series of short reflective pieces exploring the complex personal relationships that people form with material things. Bringing together perspectives from a range of academics, students, and cultural practitioners, the project seeks to highlight the breadth and plurality of ways in which material things impact upon our ideas, identities, research, and practice. For this second iteration of the BCMCR New Thinking series, we have drawn together a selection of these Material Reflections as a snapshot of the work and ideas emerging from the project. For more information on the project, to read more Material Reflections, or for more information about the BCMCR, please visit www.BCMCR.org 02 The Birmingham Centre for Media and Cultural Research (BCMCR) was established in 2009 to develop excellent research as a core activity within the Birmingham School of Media. Currently, BCMCR has over 30 research-active staff and 30 research degree students.
    [Show full text]
  • Te Oreore Monograph
    Tihei Oreore Monograph Series - INTERN REPORTS Tihei Oreore Monograph Series INTERN REPORTS Dec. 2005 - Volume 1, Issue 3 Dec. 2005 - Volume ISBN 1177-1860 ISBN 0-9582610-3-2 December 2005 - Volume 1, Issue 3 This monograph has been published by Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga The National Institute of Research Excellence for Māori Development and Advancement Contact details: Waipapa Marae Complex 16 Wynyard Street Private Bag 92019 The University of Auckland New Zealand www.maramatanga.ac.nz Explanation of Title: The title ‘Tihei Oreore’ heralds the awakening of indigenous peoples. This monograph provides a forum for the publication of some of their research and writings. ISSN 1177-1860 ISBN 0-9582610-3-2 © Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga holds copyright for this monograph while individual authors hold copyright for their own articles. This publication cannot be reproduced and sold for profit by others. NGĀ PAE O TE MĀRAMATANGA INTERN REPORTS Summer 2004—2005 Series Editor J.S. Te Rito Editors: Bruce Duffin, Phoebe Fletcher and Jan Sinclair Layout Design: Loes van der Laan Background on Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga Ngā Pae o te Māramatanga is one of seven Centres of Research Excellence that were funded by the New Zealand Government in 2002. It was established as The National Institute of Research Excellence for Māori Development and Advancement and is hosted by the University of Auckland. Its participating entities are spread throughout New Zealand. The Institute offers three distinct but intersecting programmes: Research, Capability Building and Knowledge Exchange. Whakataukī (Proverb) Ko te pae tawhiti arumia kia tata Seek to bring the distant horizon closer Ko te pae tata whakamaua But grasp the closer horizon Kia puta i te wheiao ki te aomārama So you may emerge from darkness into enlightenment The Māori name for the Institute means “horizons of insight”.
    [Show full text]
  • NEW ZEALAND GAZETTE Published by Authority
    No. 142 3249 THE NEW ZEALAND GAZETTE Published by Authority WELLINGTON: THURSDAY, 1 AUGUST 1985 Declaring Land in the Wellington Land District, Vested in the Wellington Education Board as a site for a school, shall be vested Wellington Education Board as a Site for a Public School, to be in Her Majesty the Queen, freed and discharged from every Vested in Her Majesty the Queen educational trust affecting the same, but subject to all leases, encumbrances, liens, or easements affecting the same at the· date hereof. DAVID BEATTIE, Governor-General A PROCLAMATION SCHEDULE PuRSUANT to subsection (6) of section 5 of the Education Lands Act 1949, I, The Honourable Sir David Stuart Beattie, the Governor­ WELLINGTON LAND DISTRICT-RANGITIKEI COUNTY General of New Zealand, hereby proclaim and declare that the land 1012 square metres, more or less, being Section 6, Block V, Town described in the Schedule hereto, being an area vested in the ofWaiouru, situated in Block IX, Moawhango Survey District. S.O. Wellington Education Board as a'site for a public school, shall be Plan 15363. vested in Her Majesty the Queen, freed and discharged from every educational trust affecting the same, but subject to all leases, Given under the hand of His Excellency the Governor­ encumbrances, liens, or easements affecting the same at the date General, and issued under the Seal of New Zealand, hereof. this 16th day of July 1985. K. T. WETERE, Minister of Lands. SCHEDULE [L.S.] GOD SAVE THE QUEEN! (L. and S. H.O. 6/6/1044; D.O. CL 36/109) WELLINGTON LAND DISTRICT-HuTT COUNTY 3/1 4047 square metres, more or less, being part Section 390, Hutt District, situated in Block VI, Akatarawa Survey District.
    [Show full text]
  • NEW ZEALAND GAZETTE Published by Authority
    No. 145 3323 THE NEW ZEALAND GAZETTE Published by Authority WELLINGTON: THURSDAY, 8 AUGUST 1985 CORRIGENDUM Appointing a Non-Elective Member of the Hauraki Catchment Land Acquired for Government Office Accommodation in Block Board IV, Thames Survey District, Thames-Coromandel District DAVID BEATTIE, Governor-General IN the declaration with the above heading published in New Zealand PuRSUANT to section 44 of the Soil Conservation and Rivers Control Gazette of 27 June 1985, No. 122 at page 2714, for the certificate Act 1941, I, The Honourable Sir David Stuart Beattie, the Governor­ of title reference for Lot 3, D.P. 30863 read "Volume 794, folio General of New Zealand, hereby appoint: 37", which appears in the original declaration signed on behalf of the Minister of Works and Development. Barry John Butcher, District Commissioner of Works, Hamilton (P.W. 90/68; Hn. D.O. 90/68/9) as a non-elective member of the Hauraki Catchment Board for a period of 3 years commencing on the 8th day of August 1985, in 10 place of Athol Kendrick Attwood, an officer oftheiMinistry of Works and Development. ' As witness the hand of His Excellency the Governor-General this CORRIGENDUM 5th day of August 1985. New Zealand Forest Service-Schedule of Contracts for Sale of FRASER COLMAN, Wood of $6,000 or More in Value Minister of Works. and Development. (P.W. 75/10) IN the contract with the above heading published in the New Zealand 10 Gazette of 18 July 1985, No. 132 at page 3071, before the Schedule there should be a heading which reads "Log Sale on Truck ,- (Clearfelling)".
    [Show full text]
  • Sounding out the Long-Time Listener: a Study of the Talkback Radio Audience That Doesn’T Talk Back in Aotearoa New Zealand
    Sounding out the long-time listener: A study of the talkback radio audience that doesn’t talk back in Aotearoa New Zealand Maureen Sinton A thesis submitted to Auckland University of Technology in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) 2020 School of Communication Studies Faculty of Design and Creative Technologies Abstract Talkback radio is a very popular medium in New Zealand with hundreds of thousands of people tuning in daily to listen to a huge variety of topics from politics to dreams to stain removal. Anything and everything are up for discussion. This Grounded Theory study of talkback radio listeners in Aotearoa New Zealand asks why do they make the choice to listen to talkback in a digital market place crowded with options. Stereotypes suggest that the talkback listener mirrors the talkback caller: older, right wing with a desire to vent their frustrations. This study finds that talkback listeners are more varied than this stereotype suggests, as are their reasons for listening. However, stereotypes do apply to the content which is in the main presented from te ao Pākehā, a Pākehā world view. Talkback radio listeners and producers and hosts from the industry were interviewed. Listener participants said they listened to learn what other members of their community were thinking at any one time. Talkback’s liveness assures them that what they are hearing is current as compared with prerecorded talk-based media. The participant’s choice of talkback did not indicate agreement with what they heard, nor did they expect to agree. They did not expect the content they heard on talkback radio to be factually correct.
    [Show full text]
  • Te Reo Paho: Maori Radio and Language Revitalisation
    Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and private study only. The thesis may not be reproduced elsewhere without the permission of the Author. TEREO pAHO Maori Radio and Language Revitalisation A thesis presented for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Maori Studies at Massey University Rangianehu Matamua Te Kunenga ki Piirehuroa Massey University 2006 ABSTRACT There is certainly a widely held belief among Maori working on the revitalisation of the Maori language that radio broadcasting has had a small, but significant, place for over half a century in bringing Maori language to both Maori and Pakeha audiences. Maori radio itself was established on the premise of Maori language and cultural transmission, maintenance and development. It was fo r this reason that many Maori organisations and individuals toiled towards Maori recognition within the radio arena. In 1988 Te Opoko 6 Te Ika, the first Maori radio station, went to air. With the restructuring of the broadcasting industry in the late 1980s and subsequent successful claims brought before the Waitangi Tribunal, provision was made fo r radio frequencies to be set aside by Maori, preferably with tribal endorsement. Since that time there has been a significant expansion in Maori radio. At present there are twenty-one Te Mangai Paho-funded Maori radio stations broadcasting in Aotearoa New Zealand. Yet after nearly twenty years of Maori radio, what has been the impact of the medium, and its contribution to Maori-Ianguage revitalisation? By using the five years of qualitative and quantitative research data collected by Te Reo Paho on Maori radio, and combining this with further research contained within this study, this thesis will answer the above questions.
    [Show full text]