Dimensional Analysis
11. 3. 2014
Hyunse Yoon, Ph.D. Assistant Research Scientist IIHR-Hydroscience & Engineering e-mail: [email protected]
Dimensions and Units
β’ Dimension: A measure of a physical quantity β system: Mass ( ), Length ( ), Time ( ) β system: Force ( = ), Length (L), Time (T) ππππππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ β2 πΉπΉπΉπΉπΉπΉ πΉπΉ ππππππ β’ Unit: A way to assign a number to that dimension
Dimension Symbol SI Unit BG Unit Mass kg (kilogram) lb (pound) Length m (meter) ft (feet) ππ Time s (second) s (second) πΏπΏ ππ
2 The Principle of Dimensional Homogeneity (PDH) β’ Every additive terms in an equation must have the same dimensions
Ex) Displacement of a falling body
1 = + 2 2 π§π§ π§π§0 ππ0π‘π‘ β πππ‘π‘ = + πΏπΏ πΏπΏ 2 πΏπΏ πΏπΏ ππ β 2 ππ β : Initial distance at = 0 ππ ππ β : Initial velocity π§π§0 π‘π‘ ππ0
3 Nondimensionalization
β’ Nondimensionalization: Removal of units from physical quantities by a suitable substitution of variables β’ Nondimensionalized equation: Each term in an equation is dimensionless
E.g.) Displacement of a falling body Let: = = = = β1 β β 0 Substitute into the equation,π§π§ πΏπΏ ππ π‘π‘ πΏπΏππ ππ π§π§ 0 Μ π‘π‘ 0 Μ π§π§ πΏπΏ π§π§1 πΏπΏ = + β 2 β 2 β π‘π‘ π§π§0 π‘π‘ π§π§0 Then, divide by , 0 0 0 π§π§ π§π§ π§π§ ππ 0 β ππ 0 1ππ ππ 0 = 1 + + , = π§π§ 2 β β β2 ππ0 π§π§ π‘π‘ π‘π‘ πΌπΌ 2πΌπΌ πππ§π§0 4 Dimensional vs. Non-dimensional Equation
β’ Dimensional equation 1 = + 2 2 or π§π§ π§π§0 ππ0π‘π‘ β πππ‘π‘ , , , , = 0 β 5 variables
πΉπΉ π§π§ π§π§0 ππ0 ππ π‘π‘
β’ Non-dimensional equation 1 = 1 + β β β2 or π§π§ π‘π‘ β π‘π‘ , , = 0 β2πΌπΌ 3 variables β β ππ π§π§ π‘π‘ πΌπΌ 5 Advantages of Nondimensionalization
= 2 ππ0 πΌπΌ πππ§π§0 Dimensional: (a) fixed at 4 m/s and Non-dimensional: (a) and (b) are (b) fixed at 10 m combined into one plot ππ0 6 π§π§0 Dimensional Analysis
β’ A process of formulating fluid mechanics problems in terms of non-dimensional variables and parameters 1. Reduction in variables = , , β¦ , = 0, = dimensional variables = , , β¦ , = 0, = non-dimensional parameters πΉπΉ π΄π΄1 π΄π΄2 π΄π΄ππ π΄π΄ππ 2. Helpsππ Ξ 1inΞ understanding2 Ξ ππ<ππ physicsΞ ππ 3. Useful in data analysis and modeling 4. Fundamental to concepts of similarity and model testing
7 Buckingham Pi Theorem
β’ IF a physical process satisfies the PDH and involves dimensional variables, it can be reduced to a relation between only dimensionless variables or βs. ππ ππ Ξ β’ The reduction, = , equals the maximum number of variables that do not form a pi among themselves and is always less than or equal to the number of dimensionsππ ππ β describingππ the variables.
= Number of dimensional variables = Minimum number of dimensions to describe the variables ππ = = Number of non-dimensional variables ππ
ππ ππ β ππ
8 Methods for determining Ξ βs
1. Functional relationship method a. Inspection (Intuition; Appendix A) b. Exponent method (Also called as the method of repeating variables) c. Step-by-step method (Appendix B)
2. Non-dimensionalize governing differential equations (GDEβs) and initial (IC) and boundary (BC) conditions
9 Exponent Method (or Method of Repeating Variables)
β’ Step 1: List all the variables that are involved in the problem. β’ Step 2: Express each of the variables in terms of basic dimensions. β’ Step 3: Determine the required number of pi terms. β’ Step 4: Select a number of repeating variables, where the number required is equal to the number of reference dimensions. β’ Step 5: Form a pi term by multiplying one of the nonrepeating variables by the product of the repeating variables, each raised to an exponent that will make the combination dimensionless. β’ Step 6: Repeat Step 5 for each of the remaining nonrepeating variables. β’ Step 7: Check all the resulting pi terms to make sure they are dimensionless. β’ Step 8: Express the final form as a relationship among the pi terms, and think about what it means.
10 Example 1
11 Steps 1 through 3
β’ Step 1: List all the variables that are involved in the problem.
= , , ,
β’ Step 2: Express each of theΞ variablesππ ππ π·π· inβ termsππ ππ of basic dimensions.
Variable
Unit N/m2 m m m/s Nβ s/m2 Ξππ π·π· β ππ ππ Dimension β1 β2 β1 β1 β1 β’ Step 3: DetermineπππΏπΏ theππ requiredπΏπΏ number of πΏπΏpi terms. πΏπΏππ πππΏπΏ ππ = 5 for , , , , and = 3 for , , ππ π₯π₯π₯π₯ π·π· β ππ ππ = = 5 3 = 2 (i.e., 2 pi terms) ππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ β΄ ππ ππ β ππ β 12 Step 4
β’ Select a number of repeating variables, where the number required is equal to the number of reference dimensions (for this example, = 3).
ππ β’ All of the required reference dimensions must be included within the group of repeating variables, and each repeating variable must be dimensionally independent of the others (The repeating variables cannot themselves be combined to form a dimensionless product).
β’ Do NOT choose the dependent variable as one of the repeating variables, since the repeating variables will generally appear in more than one pi term.
β ( , , ) for ( , , ), respectively
π·π· ππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ ππ 13 Step 5
β’ Combine , , with one additional variable ( or ), in sequence, to find the two pi products π·π· ππ ππ Ξππ β = = ππ ππ ππ ππ β1 ππ β1 β1 ππ β1 β2 1 Ξ π·π· =ππ ππ Ξππ πΏπΏ πΏπΏππ πππΏπΏ =ππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ ππ+1 ππ+ππβππβ1 βππβππβ2 0 0 0 ππ πΏπΏ ππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ Equate exponents: Mass( ): + 1 = 0 Length( ): + 1 = 0 ππ ππ Time( ): 2 = 0 πΏπΏ ππ ππ β ππ β
Solve for, ππ βππ β ππ β = 1 = 1 = 1 Therefore, ππ ππ β ππ β = = β1 β1 Ξππππ Ξ 1 π·π·ππ ππ Ξππ ππππ 14 Step 6
β’ Repeat Step 5 for each of the remaining nonrepeating variables.
= = ππ ππ ππ ππ β1 ππ β1 β1 ππ 2 Ξ π·π·=ππ ππ β πΏπΏ πΏπΏππ = πππΏπΏ ππ πΏπΏ ππ ππ+ππβππ+1 βππβππ 0 0 0 ππ πΏπΏ ππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ Equate exponents: Mass( ): = 0 Length( ): + + 1 = 0 Time(ππ): ππ = 0 πΏπΏ ππ ππ β ππ Solve for, ππ βππ β ππ = 1 = 0 = 0 Therefore, ππ β ππ ππ = = β1 0 0 β Ξ 2 π·π· ππ ππ β π·π· 15 Step 7
β’ Check all the resulting pi terms. β’ One good way to do this is to express the variables in terms of , , if the basic dimensions , , were used initially, or vice versa. πΉπΉ πΏπΏ ππ Variable ππ πΏπΏ ππ Unit N/m2 m m m/s Nβ s/m2 Ξππ π·π· β ππ ππ Dimension β2 β1 β2 πΉπΉπΏπΏ πΏπΏ πΏπΏ πΏπΏππ πΉπΉπΉπΉπΏπΏ = = = β2 Ξππππ πΉπΉπΏπΏ πΏπΏ 0 0 0 Ξ 1 Μ β2 β1 Μ πΉπΉ πΏπΏ ππ ππππ πΉπΉπΉπΉπΏπΏ πΏπΏππ = = = β πΏπΏ 0 0 0 Ξ 2 Μ Μ πΉπΉ πΏπΏ ππ π·π· πΏπΏ 16
Step 8
β’ Express the final form as a relationship among the pi terms.
= or Ξ 1 ππ Ξ 2 = Ξππππ β ππ ππππ π·π· β’ Think about what it means. Since ,
Ξππ β β = Ξππππ β where is a constant. Thus, πΆπΆ β ππππ π·π·
πΆπΆ 1
Ξππ β 2 π·π· 17 Problems with One Pi Term
β’ The functional relationship that must exist for one pi term is
=
Ξ πΆπΆ where is a constant.
πΆπΆ β’ In other words, if only one pi term is involved in a problem, it must be equal to a constant.
18 Example 2
= , ,
ππ ππ π·π· ππ πΎπΎ
19 Steps 1 through 4
Variable
Unit 1/s m kg N/m3 ππ π·π· ππ πΎπΎ Dimension
β1 β2 β2 ππ πΏπΏ ππ πππΏπΏ ππ = 4 for , , , and = 3 for , , ππ ππ π·π· ππ πΎπΎ
ππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ = = 4 3 = 1 (i.e., 1 pi term)
β΄ ππ ππ β ππ β repeating variables = , ,
ππ π·π· ππ πΎπΎ 20 Step 5 (and 6)
= = ππ ππ ππ ππ ππ β2 β2 ππ β1 Ξ π·π·=ππ πΎπΎ ππ πΏπΏ ππ ππ=πΏπΏ ππ ππ ππ+ππ ππβ2ππ β2ππβ1 0 0 0 ππ πΏπΏ ππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ Equate exponents: Mass( ): + = 0 Length( ): = 0 ππ ππ ππ Time( ): 1 = 0 πΏπΏ ππ β 2ππ or, ππ β2ππ β 1 1 = 1 = = 2 2 ππ β ππ ππ β
= = 1 1 β β1 2 2 ππ ππ β΄ Ξ π·π· ππ πΎπΎ ππ π·π· πΎπΎ
21 Steps 7 through 8
= = β1 β1 2 = ππ ππ ππ πΉπΉπΏπΏ ππ 0 0 0 Μ β3 Μ πΉπΉ πΏπΏ ππ Ξ π·π· πΎπΎ πΏπΏ πΉπΉπΏπΏ β’ The dimensionless function is
= ππ ππ π·π· πΎπΎ πΆπΆ where is a constant. Thus,
πΆπΆ = πΎπΎ ππ πΆπΆ β π·π· Therefore, if is increased will decrease. ππ
ππ ππ 22 Example 3
= ,
Ξππ ππ π π ππ
23 Example 3 βContd.
Variable Unit N/m2 m N/m Ξππ π π ππ Dimension β1 β2 β2 πππΏπΏ ππ πΏπΏ ππππ
= 3 for , ,
ππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ = = 3 3 = 0 β No pi term?
β΄ ππ ππ β ππ β
24 Example 3 βContd.
β’ Since the repeating variables form a pi among them:
= = β1 β2 Ξππππ πππΏπΏ ππ πΏπΏ 0 0 0 Μ β2 Μ ππ πΏπΏ ππ ππ ππππ should be reduced to 2 for and . β2 ππ ππππ πΏπΏ
25 Example 3 βContd.
Select and as the repeating variables:
π π ππ = = = Thus, ππ ππ ππ β2 ππ β1 β2 0 0 0 Ξ π π ππ Ξππ πΏπΏ ππππ πππΏπΏ ππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ : + 1 = 0 : 1 = 0 ππ ππ : 2 = 0 πΏπΏ ππ β or, ππ β2ππ β = 1 and = 1 Hence, ππ ππ β = Ξππππ Ξ ππ 26 Example 3 βContd.
β’ Alternatively, by using the system
πΉπΉπΉπΉπΉπΉ
Variable
Unit N/m2 m N/m Ξππ π π ππ Dimension β2 β1 πΉπΉπΏπΏ πΏπΏ πΉπΉπΏπΏ = 3 for , , and = 2 for and ππ Ξππ π π ππ
ππ πΉπΉ πΏπΏ = 3 2 = 1 β 1 pi term
β΄ ππ β
27 Example 3 βContd.
With the system:
πΉπΉπΉπΉπΉπΉ = = = Thus, ππ ππ ππ β1 ππ β2 0 0 0 Ξ 1 π π ππ Ξππ πΏπΏ πΉπΉπΏπΏ πΉπΉπΏπΏ πΉπΉ πΏπΏ ππ : 1 + = 0 : 2 + = 0 πΉπΉ ππ or, πΏπΏ β ππ β ππ = 1 and = 1 Hence, ππ ππ β = Ξππππ Ξ ππ
28 Common Dimensionless Parameters for Fluid Flow Problems
β’ Most common physical quantities of importance in fluid flow problems are (without heat transfer):
Length Velocity Density Viscosity Gravity Surface Compre Pressure tension ssibility change
πΏπΏ ππβ1 ππβ3 βππ1 β1 ππβ2 ππβ2 βπΎπΎ1 β2 Ξβ2ππ β2 πΏπΏ πΏπΏππ πππΏπΏ πππΏπΏ ππ πΏπΏππ ππππ πππΏπΏ ππ πππΏπΏ ππ = 8 variables = 3 dimension ππ = - = 5 pi terms ( , , , , ) ππ β΄ ππ ππ ππ π π π π πΉπΉπΉπΉ ππππ ππππ πΆπΆππ 29 1) Reynolds number
= ππππππ β’ Generally of importance in all typesπ π π π of fluid dynamics problems ππ β’ A measure of the ratio of the inertia force to the viscous force
Inertia force = = = Viscous force 3 ππ πππΏπΏ ππ β ππππ πΏπΏ ππππππ ππ 2 ππππ ππ πΏπΏ ππ β If 1 (referred to as βcreeping flowβ), fluidπΏπΏ density is less important β If is large, may neglect the effect of viscosity π π π π βͺ β’ π π π π distinguishes among flow regions: laminar or turbulent value varies depending upon flow situation π π ππππππππππ
30 2) Froude number
= ππ πΉπΉπΉπΉ ππππ β’ Important in problems involving flows with free surfaces β’ A measure of the ratio of the inertia force to the gravity force (i.e., the weight of fluid)
Inertia force = = = Gravity force 3 ππ 2 ππππ πππΏπΏ ππ β ππ 3 πΏπΏ πΎπΎππ ππππ πΏπΏ ππππ
31 3) Weber number
= 2 ππππ πΏπΏ ππππ β’ Problems in which there is an interfaceππ between two fluids where surface tension is important β’ An index of the inertial force to the surface tension force
Inertia force = = = Surface tension force 3 ππ 2 ππππ πππΏπΏ ππ β ππππ πΏπΏ πΏπΏ ππππ ππππ ππ β’ Important parameter at gas-liquid or liquid-liquid interfaces and when these surfaces are in contact with a boundary
32 4) Mach number
= = ππ ππ ππππ ππβππ ππ β’ : speed of sound in a fluid (a symbol is also used) β’ Problems in which the compressibility of the fluid is important β’ Anππ index of the ratio of inertial forces toππ compressibility forces
Inertia force = = = Compressibility force 3 ππ 2 ππππ πππΏπΏ ππ β ππ 2 2 2 2 πΏπΏ 2 ππππ πΏπΏ ππππ πΏπΏ ππ (Note: Cauchy number, = = ) β’ Paramount importance in high speed 2flow2 ( 2) β β’ If < 0.3, flow can be consideredπΆπΆπΆπΆ ππas incompressibleππ ππππ ππ β₯ ππ ππππ 33 5) Pressure Coefficient
= Ξππ πΆπΆππ 2 β’ Problems in which pressure differences,ππππ or pressure, are of interest β’ A measure of the ratio of pressure forces to inertial forces
Pressure force = = = Inertia force 2 2 ΞπππΏπΏ ΞπππΏπΏ Ξππ 2 3 ππ β’ Euler number: ππππ πππΏπΏ ππ β ππππ πΏπΏ = ππ β’ Cavitation number: πΈπΈπΈπΈ 2 ππππ = ππ β πππ£π£ πΆπΆπΆπΆ 1 2 2ππππ 34 Appendix A: Inspection Method
β’ Steps 1 through 3 of the exponent method are the same:
= , , ,
Ξππβ ππ π·π· ππ ππ ππ
Ξππβ π·π· ππ ππ ππ β3 β4 2 β2 β1 πΉπΉπΏπΏ πΏπΏ πΉπΉπΏπΏ ππ πΉπΉπΏπΏ ππ πΏπΏππ = = 5 3 = 2
ππ ππ β ππ β
35 Appendix A: Inspection Method β Contd.
β’ Let contain the dependent variable ( in this example) Then, combine it with other variables so that a non-dimensional product will result: β’ 1 β Ξ Ξππ To cancel , = = πΉπΉ β3 Ξππβ πΉπΉπΏπΏ πΏπΏ To cancel , Μ β4 2 Μ 2 ππ 1 πΉπΉπΏπΏ ππ 1 ππ 1 ππ = = Ξππβ πΏπΏ Then, to cancel , 2 Μ 2 β1 2 Μ ππ ππ ππ 1 πΏπΏππ πΏπΏ πΏπΏ = = Ξππβ 0 2 π·π· Μ πΏπΏ Μ πΏπΏ ππππ πΏπΏ = Ξππβπ·π· β΄ Ξ 1 2 ππππ 36 Appendix A: Inspection Method β Contd.
β’ Select the variable that was not used in , which in this case , and repeat the process: 1 Ξ ππ To cancel , = = πΉπΉ β2 2 ππ πΉπΉπΏπΏ ππ πΏπΏ To cancel , Μ β4 2 Μ ππ1 πΉπΉπΏπΏ ππ 1 ππ = = ππ 2 ππ πΏπΏ Then, to cancel , Μ β1 Μ πΏπΏ ππ ππ 1 ππ πΏπΏππ1 πΏπΏ = = ππ 0 Μ πΏπΏ Μ πΏπΏ ππππ π·π· πΏπΏ = ππ β΄ Ξ 2 ππππππ 37 Appendix B: Step-by-step Method*
*by Ipsen (1960). The pi theorem and Ipsen method are quite different. Both are useful and interesting. 38 Appendix B: Step-by-step Method β Contd.
39 Appendix B: Step-by-step Method β Contd.
40