DOCSLIB.ORG

The Problem with Eyewitnesses

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Problem with Eyewitnesses The Problem with Eyewitnesses 1. Read this article: Who was Jean Charles de Menezes? De Menezes was a 27-year-old electrician who was shot dead by police on 22 July 2005. Officers were hunting terrorists who had tried to bomb London the previous day, two weeks after the 7 July attacks in the capital killed 52 people. He was shot seven times in the head and once in the shoulder at point-blank range by officers from the Met police’s CO19 firearms unit. Why did police think he was a terrorist? In the early hours of that day, police traced a gym card found in one of the bags containing the failed bombs to an address at Scotia Road, south London. They believed it was being used by a suspected terrorist called Hussain Osman. A senior officer drew up a plan that anyone coming out of the address should be allowed to walk a short distance away so they were out of sight of anyone else in the flats, then stopped by armed police and their identity checked. After he left his flat, for some reason officers allowed him to board a bus towards Stockwell station, They followed him and shot him after he boarded a Northern line train at Stockwell. Rules of engagement introduced by the Met to deal with suicide bombers required armed officers to shoot and kill suspected bombers before they have a chance to detonate any explosives. But it was a case of mistaken identity. What did the police say in the aftermath of the shooting? The Met police commissioner, Sir Ian Blair, told a press conference that the dead man “was challenged and refused to obey police instructions”, while Scotland Yard said his “clothing and behaviour at the station added to their suspicions”. These claims were all later found to be false. Blair admitted the force had made a “serious mistake” in the immediate aftermath of the shooting. In 2009, the Met had to pay compensation believed to be just over £100,000 plus the family’s legal costs. In return the family agreed to end their legal (civil) action against Scotland Yard. Have the force or any of the officers involved ever been held accountable for the killing of De Menezes? In 2006, the Crown Prosecution Service said there was “ insufficient evidence to provide a realistic prospect of conviction against any individual police officer”. But the Met was successfully prosecuted under health and safety legislation the following year and fined £175,000. In 2007, the Independent Police Complaints Commission decided that no disciplinary action would be taken against any officers involved in the shooting. In 2008, an inquest jury rejected Scotland Yard’s claim that De Menezes was lawfully killed as part of an anti-terrorism operation, recording an open verdict, after being barred by the coroner from returning a verdict of unlawful killing. ​ Jean Charles De Menezes The aftermath of the shooting of Jean Charles de Menezes at Stockwell Tube station has shown that eyewitness testimony may not always be as reliable as it seems. On the day Mr Menezes was killed, a picture was quickly painted by eyewitnesses of a suspect who had vaulted over a ticket barrier, ran away from police, and had worn a bulky jacket that could have concealed a device. Scotland Yard did nothing to dispel that impression, saying that the shooting had been "directly linked" to anti-terrorism operations, that Mr Menezes had been challenged but had not obeyed, and that the victim's "clothing and behaviour" had added to suspicions. In the months following, the image of Mr Menezes' conduct was slowly dispelled, before being completely shattered by Independent Police Complaints Commission through documents leaked to ITV News. Identification Errors According to the documents, Mr Menezes was wearing a light denim shirt or jacket, walked through the barriers having picked up a free newspaper, and only ran when he saw his train arriving. It has left many scratching their heads as to how the witnesses could have got it so wrong. The reliability of eyewitness accounts of crime has proved a rich seam for psychologists and criminologists to mine over the years. Andrew Roberts, a lecturer in law at Leeds University specialising in evidence, said courts have recognised for a long time that eyewitness identification evidence is "inherently unreliable". Two cases helped change the view in British courts, he said. DISTORTING FACTORS Stress/ Emotion Presence of a gun/ weapon Conferring with others (interference) Leading questions Media coverage Misinterpretation/ Stereotyping In 1969, Laszlo Virag was convicted of stealing from parking meters and using a firearm while trying to escape police officers. Despite his alibi and other contradictions, he was identified by eight witnesses as the man who committed the crime. While he was in prison it was found another person had committed the crime and he was pardoned. In 1972, Luke Dougherty was convicted of shoplifting after two witnesses picked his face out of a police album. He was eventually cleared and both cases led to the Devlin Committee's investigation of identification evidence, which found that many witnesses overstated their ability to single out the right person. News Reports But it is not just the thorny issue of recognising a face that confuses witnesses. Witnesses' recollection of every aspect of an incident can be contaminated by what they hear from other people. Forensic psychologist Dr Fiona Gabbert has been working at Aberdeen University with Professor Amina Memon on the distortions in eyewitness recollection. "Memories are very vulnerable to error. If you witness a crime and then read a local news report everything can be combined in your memory at a later date," she said. 2. Write a 500 word article discussing whether or not eye-witness testimony should be used as evidence in a court room. Bring to your first psychology lesson in September. Without it you’ll not be admitted .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Aftermath of the Anti-Terrorism Police Raids in Forest Gate on 2 June 2006
    Scrutiny by the Metropolitan Police Authority of communication and media at the Metropolitan Police Service with particular reference to the handling of media and communications during the Forest Gate incident of June 2006 Aftermath of the Anti-Terrorism Police Raids in Forest Gate on 2 June 2006 Submission of Newham Monitoring Project 27 September 2006 Aftermath of the Police Raids in Forest Gate on 2 June 2006 1. Terms of Reference 1.1. On Friday 2 June, 2006 police carried out raids on 46 and 48 Lansdown Road, Forest Gate, London. In the weeks following these raids the Metropolitan Police Authority (MPA) amended its existing scrutiny programme of the Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) for 2006/7 to include the media and communications strategy of the MPS. 1.2. The stated objectives of this amendment to the MPA’s scrutiny programme is to : a) Assess the extent to which the MPS has the strategies, policies, protocols and processes in place to ensure efficient and effective communication, media and reputation management, particularly in the context of the 24 hour news environment. b) Undertake a detailed analysis of the handling of the media and communication during the Forest Gate incident in June 2006. c) Assess how effectively the MPS engages internally to manage communication to the media, Londoners and stakeholders, particularly during sensitive operations. d) Understand the culture of the MPS towards communication and media management and the impact this has on the delivery of an effective service. e) Evaluate the use of resources available to the MPS to deliver this key function, including understanding the division of resources and lines of accountability between central and local directorates.
    [Show full text]
  • Sir Ian Blair: Lecture on Police Reform
    Police, Lawyers and Public Service Reform Sir Ian Blair Lecture to Civitas, Monday 2 February 2004 On Friday, the Metropolitan Police Service delivered its response to the recent Home Office consultation paper, ‘Building Safer Communities’. I have to say that the document is pretty radical. What I thought I would do this evening is to run through the ways in which the police service have recently responded - and now intend again to respond to the reform of public services. I hope thereby to disprove George Bernard Shaw’s comment that, “in the end all professions are conspiracies against the laity.” I will also gently suggest that the legal profession might care to join us on that journey. This will not be an attack on lawyers but an invitation. The history of both professions, as a whole, has been largely conservative. While there have been many reforming and, indeed, radical lawyers, law develops slowly. For almost all of its history, the police service has been silent, an institution which, until the 1980s at the earliest, was an institution little affected by politics and largely separate from the impulses of reform in other parts of the public service. During the 1990s, however, and with increasing speed ever since, law enforcement, community safety, policing, call it what you will, has become a central component in the infrastructure of a modern or post modern society and thus a critical factor both in politics and in media debate. In the last round of local elections in England and Wales, this broad area of public concern was the most important issue to the focus groups of the various political parties: it is starting off as the most important issue in the London mayoral election.
    [Show full text]
  • Private Actors and Security Governance
    Private Actors and Security Governance Alan Bryden, and Marina Caparini (editors.) © 2006, LIT & DCAF Contents List of Graphs and Tables ix Preface xi Abbreviations xiii Part I: Introduction 1 Approaching the Privatisation of Security from 3 a Security Governance Perspective Alan Bryden Part II: The International Policy Context 2 Fragile Statehood, Armed Non-State Actors 23 and Security Governance Ulrich Schneckener 3 Private Sector, Public Security 41 Alyson Bailes 4 Insurgencies, Security Governance and 65 the International Community Albrecht Schnabel. 5 Reconstructing the Public Monopoly 87 of Legitimate Force Herbert Wulf Part III: Regional and National Perspectives 6 Bulgaria's Private Security Industry 109 Philip Gounev 7 The Commercialisation of Post-Soviet Private Security 129 Duncan Hiscock 8 Challenges of Security Privatisation in Iraq 149 David Isenberg 9 Implementing South Africa’s Regulation of 167 Foreign Military Assistance Act Raenette Taljaard Part IV: Challenges of Regulation 10 Regulating Military and Security Services 189 in the European Union Elke Krahmann 11 The United Nations and the Dilemma 213 of Outsourcing Peacekeeping Operations Victor-Yves Ghebali 12 Assessing the Relationship between Humanitarian 231 Actors and Private Security Companies Christopher Spearin 13 Private Security Actors, Donors and SSR 247 Peter Wilson Part V: Conclusion 14 Applying a Security Governance Perspective to 263 the Privatisation of Security Marina Caparini Annex International Organisations and the Governance of 285 Private Security
    [Show full text]
  • On the Morning of January 26, Sir Ian Reported Back to His Police Authority
    City Research Online City, University of London Institutional Repository Citation: Greer, C. & McLaughlin, E. (2011). "Trial by media": Policing, the 24-7 news mediasphere and the "politics of outrage". Theoretical Criminology, 15(1), pp. 23-46. doi: 10.1177/1362480610387461 This is the unspecified version of the paper. This version of the publication may differ from the final published version. Permanent repository link: http://openaccess.city.ac.uk/1986/ Link to published version: http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/1362480610387461 Copyright and reuse: City Research Online aims to make research outputs of City, University of London available to a wider audience. Copyright and Moral Rights remain with the author(s) and/or copyright holders. URLs from City Research Online may be freely distributed and linked to. City Research Online: http://openaccess.city.ac.uk/ [email protected] ‘Trial by Media’: Policing, the 24-7 News Mediasphere and the ‘Politics of Outrage’ Greer, C. and McLaughlin, E. (2011) ‘Trial by Media: Policing, the 24-7 News Mediasphere, and the Politics of Outrage’, Theoretical Criminology, 15, 1: 23-46. Abstract This article analyses the changing nature of news media-police chief relations. Building on previous theoretical work (Greer and McLaughlin, 2010), we use the concepts of ‘inferential structure’ (Lang and Lang, 1955) and ‘hierarchy of credibility’ (Becker, 1967) to examine former Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) Commissioner Sir Ian Blair’s ‘trial by media’. We focus on the collective and overwhelmingly hostile journalistic reaction to Blair’s declaration in 2005 that, (a) the news media are guilty of ‘institutional racism’ in their coverage of murders, and (b) the murders of two ten- year-olds in Soham, 2001, received undue levels of media attention.
    [Show full text]
  • 5Th Draft 12 October 2009-SB Performance Script Nov 28.Fdx
    THIS MUCH IS TRUE DRAFT 5 8/10/09 Written by Paul Unwin and Sarah Beck Locked pages Based on interviews, transcripts and recorded media. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED Tim Corrie UNITED AGENTS 12 - 26 Lexington Street London W1F 0LE [email protected] A traverse stage. Apparently a very simple setting of a table and chairs, it will turn out to be something of a magic box. The walls of the theatre will be used to carry projections both of footage and imagery. To begin with there are three actors. They wear dark suits, white shirts - it could be legal, it could be funereal, most importantly is that it is professional and asexual. ACTOR ONE - MALE, white early forties. ACTOR TWO - FEMALE, white late thirties. ACTOR THREE - FEMALE, not-Caucasian late twenties. They will be joined by three Brazilians. 1 10.06 AM 22/7/05 1 House lights still up, the three actors walk in front of the audience. ACTOR ONE (MALE) At approximately six minutes past ten on the morning of 22nd of July 2005 Jean Charles de Menezes, a twenty-seven year old Brazilian, was shot dead by British Police on an Underground train waiting at Stockwell Tube. This much is true. During this, the second actor holds a transcript from the INQUEST. She begins reading: ACTOR TWO (DUNWOODIE) (reading, without emotion) It’s a really odd thing to try to describe, because my memory is that right in the carriage where we were actually we were all very still, I think because it was so unexpected..
    [Show full text]
  • Toolbox for Implementing Restorative Justice and Advancing Community Policing
    TOOLBOX FOR IMPLEMENTING RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND ADVANCING COMMUNITY POLICING A guidebook prepared for the Office of Community Oriented Policing Services, U.S. Department of Justice By Caroline G.Nicholl Funded under Grant No. 98-CK-WX-0059 awarded to the National Victim Center by the Office of Community Oriented Policing Services, U.S. Department of Justice. Companion document to Community Policing, Community Justice, and Restorative Justice: Exploring the Links for the Delivery of a Balanced Approach to Public Safety. The opinions, find- ings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this document do not necessarily represent the official position or policies of the U.S. Department of Justice. SUGGESTED CITATION Nicholl, Caroline G. Toolbox for Implementing Restorative Justice and Advancing Community Policing. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Community Oriented Policing Services, 1999. See companion document: Community Policing, Community Justice, and Restorative Justice Acknowledgments There are many people to thank for making this project a reality. First, my colleagues and the communities in Britain who tolerated my experimenting with community policing and exploring restorative justice; in particular, Charles Pollard, Chief Constable of Thames Valley Police, and Ian Blair, now Chief Constable of Surrey Police, both of whom placed consider- able trust and faith in the work I was attempting to do while I was Chief Superintendent at Milton Keynes. I must also thank The Commonwealth Fund in New York, which awarded me a Harkness Fellowship in 1995-96, thereby providing an unusual and wonderful oppor- tunity to test and further develop my thesis in a different cultural context.
    [Show full text]
  • Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) Decision Notice
    Reference: FS50697913 Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) Decision notice Date: 24 April 2018 Public Authority: The Cabinet Office Address: 70 Whitehall London SW1A 2AS Decision (including any steps ordered) 1. The complainant submitted a request to the Cabinet Office asking for information about the meeting which took place on 21 July 2005 between Tony Blair and Sir Ian Blair, the then Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police. The Cabinet Office initially responded by explaining that although it held information confirming that this meeting took place, it did not hold any further information falling within the scope of the request. It subsequently amended this position and explained that it did hold further information falling within the scope of this request but it considered this to be exempt from disclosure on the basis of section 23(1) (security bodies), 24(1) (national security), 31 (law enforcement), 38 (health and safety) and 40 (personal data) of FOIA. The Commissioner has concluded that the withheld information is exempt from disclosure on the basis of section 23(1) or section 24(1) of FOIA. Request and response 2. The complainant submitted a request to the Cabinet Office on 17 July 2017 asking for information about the meeting which took place on 21 July 2005 between Tony Blair and Sir Ian Blair. A full copy of the request is attached as an annex to this notice. 3. The Cabinet Office responded to the request on 16 August 2017 and explained that: ‘We hold information confirming the meeting between Sir Ian Blair and Prime Minister Tony Blair took place on the 21st July 2005, alongside 1 Reference: FS50697913 other attendees such as the Home Secretary Charles Clarke.
    [Show full text]
  • Daniel Russell Tovey University of Sheffield
    A Study of Pulse Shape Discrimination in Scintillator Dark Matter Detectors Daniel Russell Tovey University of Sheffield A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the subject of Physics, October 1998. To Nan. Abstract The existence of `dark matter' throughout the universe is now well established but its form and origin remain one of the greatest problems for modern cosmology. Particle physics posits a solution to this problem in the form of `Weakly Interacting Massive Particles' (WIMPs) which are predicted to exist by many theories extending physics beyond the standard model. The discovery of such particles would consequently have profound implications for both disciplines. Many experiments around the world are now endeavouring to achieve this goal but currently the most successful are those using scintillator detectors. This thesis describes a study of the use of Pulse Shape Discrimination (PSD) techniques to reduce the rate of electron recoil background events in scintillator dark matter experiments. The development of new classes of detector with novel pulse shape properties is described and the results of tests using elastic scattering of monoenergetic neutrons to simulate nuclear recoil signal events are presented. Monte Carlo simulations have been used to assessthe performance of CASPAR, a particularly promising new technique, and the results presented here indicate that this has the potential to considerably improve dark matter sensitivity, particularly for spin dependent WIMP interactions. An analysis of 867 kg. days of data from an operational NaI(Tl) detector is described and the resulting evidence for a small population of events with anomalous pulse shape properties discussed.
    [Show full text]
  • THE COUNTERTERRORISM DIMENSION by Isaac Kfir*
    BRITISH MIDDLE EAST POLICY: THE COUNTERTERRORISM DIMENSION By Isaac Kfir* The emergence of Islamist terrorism has had a tremendous impact on the United Kingdom. The British government has pursued controversial domestic and foreign policies. This paper reviews some of the key measures and also the British involvement in Iraq and Afghanistan. It holds that the continuous clashes between the different branches of government has undermined Britain’s ability to contend with the threat raised by Islamic radicals, which is like no other. The British government decision to support to get technology is there.”3 Around the the U.S.-led “War on Terror” placed the same time, Metropolitan Police United Kingdom at the epicenter of the Commissioner Sir Ian Blair stated, in a campaign, forcing the adoption of policies, comment on the August 2006 transatlantic strategies, programs, and other measures to airline bomb plot, that “the apparent speed deal with the Islamists—even though with which young, reasonably affluent, initially there was no indication that the UK some reasonably well educated British-born was a target of al-Qa’ida.1 Unfortunately, people” had become radicalized and willing the threat became a reality on July 7, 2005, to commit mass murders through suicide when four British-Muslims undertook a attacks was worrying.4 Significantly, suicide bombing campaign that left more Manningham-Buller made it clear that due than 50 people dead across central London, to al-Qa'ida’s nature, the challenge faced by making July 7 the deadliest terror attack on the security forces was substantial. This British soil.
    [Show full text]
  • For Distribution to Cps MOD200011979
    For Distribution to CPs Witness Name: Kit Malthouse Statement no: First Exhibit: KM21 Date: 29 February 2012 THE LEVESON INQUIRY Exhibit KM21 to the Witness Statement of Kit Malthouse MOD200011979 For Distribution to CPs Those senior Met Police lunches and dinners witii Nev international: get the list | News | guardian.co.u'^ I'age 1 or y t'^eguardian Those senior M et Police lunches and dinners w ith N ew s In tern atio n al: get the l i s t John Yates and other senior Metropolitan Police officers had regular m eetings with News International staff over the last few years. Find out when » G e t t h e d a t a http ://www.guardian.co.ulc/news/datablog/2011 /j ul/13/j ohn-yates-meeting-news-iiiteniatioiial 2 2 / 0 2 / 2 0 1 2 MOD200011980 For Distribution to CPs liiose senior Met Police lunches and dinners with Ne’^s International: get the list | News | guardian>Go.nV; Page 2 of 9 Assistant Commissioner John Yates gives evidence to a Commons Home Affairs Committee on phone hacldng Photograph: /PA Boris Johnson will today be put under pressure to back calls for Met assistant commissioner John Yates to resign. Dee Doocev. a liberal Democrat member of the London assembly who is also a member of die Metropolitan Police Authority, released dates of dinners and lunches attended by senior Met policing figures over the past few years, including since allegations of phone hacking at the News of the World first surfaced - based on a freedom of information m em bers.
    [Show full text]
  • Standard Form
    Thames Valley Police Headquarters Chief Constable Francis Habgood QPM Oxford Road Kidlington Oxfordshire OX5 2NX Mr P Salmon Telephone: 101 Direct dial: 01865 846329 Email: [email protected] Our ref: HQ/PA/002578/16 26 September 2016 Dear Mr Salmon, I write in response to the above-referenced Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request submitted on 30 August 2016. Thames Valley Police has now considered this request, which for clarity, has been repeated below: Request Response I would like to request under the Freedom Thames Valley Police have engaged the of Information Act, a list of national policing following exemption in relation to your roles carried out by the following police request: officers who held the rank of Assistant Chief Constable or above for Thames Section 21: Information Reasonably Valley Police, and the dates for which they Accessible by Other Means were held. Please see below for further explanation. (a) Charles Pollard In relation to previous Chief Constables (b) Peter Neyroud there is no information held. You may wish (c) Sara Thornton to contact the National Police Chiefs (d) Francis Hapgood Council (NPCC) to see whether they hold (e) Ian Blair this information. Section 21: Information Reasonably Accessible By Other Means Section 21 is an absolute class based exemption and does not require a public interest test. Section 21 has been engaged as the national policing roles of our current Chief Constable can be found via the below link: http://www.npcc.police.uk/Publication/NPCC%20FOI/Information%20Management /089%2015%20NPCC%20National%20Policing%20Leads%20att%2001%20of%2 001.pdf www.thamesvalley.police.uk Thames Valley Police Chief Constable Francis Habgood QPM Complaint Rights If you are dissatisfied with the handling procedures or the decision made by Thames Valley Police, you can lodge a complaint with the force to have the decision reviewed within two months of the date of this response.
    [Show full text]
  • 100 Islamic Radicalism in Britain Isaac Kfir* Dame Eliza Manningham
    Islamic Radicalism in Britain Isaac Kfir* Abstract The paper explores some of the reasons behind the rise in Islamic radicalism in the United Kingdom. The author seeks to suggest some ideas as to how the government and British society best deal with this worrying trend. Dame Eliza Manningham-Buller announcement that the British security services are stretched to the limit in dealing with Islamic terror plots emphasised the great challenge of combating Islamist 1 militancy in the UK. Dame Manningham-Buller, the head of MI5, claimed that her organisation has identified 200 terrorist networks involving at least 1,600 people and 30 “Priority 1” plots to kill. It followed a statement by a senior Foreign Office counter-terrorism expert who when asked if al-Qa’ida was seeking nuclear technology to attack the West and Britain replied “No doubt at all… We know the aspiration is there, we know the attempt to get material is there, we know the attempt to get technology is there.” 2 Sir Ian Blair, the Metropolitan Police Commissioner, commenting on the transatlantic airline bomb plot stated that "the apparent speed with which young, reasonably affluent, some reasonably well educated British-born people” became not only radicalise but also willing to commit mass murders through suicide attacks in worrying.3 Significantly Manningham-Buller made it clear Alternatives: Turkish Journal of International Relations, Vol. 6, No.3&4, Fall & Winter 2007 100 that due to the nature of al-Qa'ida, the challenge faced by the security forces is substantial as seen with the Barot case, where the plot maybe forged in one part of the globe, approved in another and executed somewhere else.4 Overall, it is apparent that Britain is a key target of Islamic terrorism.
    [Show full text]