<<

E nDNOTES

10 , interview by Tony Trew, 37 Scott MacLeod, ‘: I Am Endnotes , 29 May 2015. No Prophet’, TIME, 26 February 1990. 11 Ibid. 38 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 8–9. 12 Ibid. 39 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 9. 13 NM in conversation with Richard Stengel, 40 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 9–10. Johannesburg, c. April/May 1993, CD 61, 41 NM to Winnie Mandela in Kroonstad NMF, Johannesburg. Prison, 1 February 1975, in Conversations 14 Ibid. With Myself (: Macmillan, 2010), 15 , interview by Padraig p. 212. O’Malley, 25 August 1992, O’Malley 42 Niël Barnard, Secret Revolution, pp. 24–5. Archive, Nelson Mandela Foundation. 43 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p.10. 16 Jessie Duarte interviewed by John Carlin, 44 Carl von Clausewitz, On War (Berlin, 1832). Frontline, PBS Frontline website. 45 Jonathan Hyslop, ‘Mandela on War’, in 17 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 3. The Cambridge Companion to Nelson Mandela, 18 Ibid. edited by Rita Barnard (Cambridge: 19 NM, televised address to the nation on the Cambridge University Press, 2014), p. 179. ABBREVIATIONS 9 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 1. 46 10 NM, , p. 651. murder of , 13 April 1993. NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 10. 20 47 ANCLH: ANC Luthuli House 11 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 1. Wilson Ngqose, interview by , , interview by Tony Trew, AP: 12 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 1–2. Johannesburg, 17 December 2016. , 19 September 2015. 21 48 NASA: National Archives of 13 NM in conversation with Richard Stengel, Agostinho Neto, ‘Haste’, Sacred Hope, Martin Challenor, ‘Victory for Alliance’, NCOP: National Council of Provinces Johannesburg, c. April/May 1993, CD 61, translated by Marga Holness (Dar es Daily News, 22 February 1994. 49 NEC: National Executive Committee (of the ANC) NMF, Johannesburg. Salaam: Tanzania Publishing House, 1974). Princeton Lyman, Partner to History: 22 NM: Nelson Mandela 14 Valli Moosa, interview by Tony Trew, NM, speech to the Angolan National The US Role in South Africa’s Transition NMF: Nelson Mandela Foundation , 8 September 2014. Assembly, Luanda, 29 April 1998. (Washington, DC: Institute of 23 NMPP: Nelson Mandela’s Private Papers 15 NM, Long Walk to Freedom, p. 751. Chris Hani, in They Shaped Our Century: Peace, 2002) pp. 171–9; Accord on Afrikaner SABC: South African Broadcasting Corporation 16 Václav Havel, source unknown. The Most Influential South Africans of the Self-Determination, 23 April 1994, O’Malley SAPA: South African Press Association 17 Barbara Masekela, interview by Tony Trew, Twentieth Century (Cape Town: Human & Archive. 50 TRC: Truth and Reconciliation Commission Cape Town, 28 August 2014. Rousseau, 1999), in NM, ‘The Presidential NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 10. 51 18 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 7. Years’, p. 3. Bill Keller, ‘The South African Vote: The 24 19 One such poll was Markinor’s November Overview; More Bombings Rattle South PREFACE NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 7–8. 20 Hugh Macmillan, The Years: 1992 survey sampling African, coloured and Africans’, Times, 26 April 1994. 52 1 All quotations from NM’s speech to the The ANC in Exile in 1963–1994 Indian communities in metropolitan areas James Baldwin, No Name in the Street, Fiftieth National Conference of the ANC, (Johannesburg: Jacana Media, 2013), p. 258. and whites nationally. (London: Michael Joseph, 1972), p. 82. 25 Mafikeng, 16 December 1997. NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 4. 26 CHAPTER TWO: NEGOTIATING NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 8. CHAPTER THREE: A FREE AND 27 CHAPTER ONE: THE CHALLENGE DEMOCRACY Weekly Mail, 30 April 1993. FAIR ELECTION 28 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 9. OF FREEDOM 1 1 Robin Denselow, When the Music’s Over: 29 Hermann Giliomee, The : David Yutar, ‘No-show Troopies may face 1 Ralph Waldo Emerson, ‘Self-Reliance’, in The Story of Political Pop (London: Faber and Biography of a People (London: C. Hurst & prosecution’, The Argus, 12 May 1994. 2 Essays (Boston: 1841). Republished in 1847 Faber, 1990), p. 276. Co, 2003), p. 646. Johann Kriegler, interview by Tony Trew, as Essays: First Series. 2 NM, address to a rally in Cape Town on his 30 , interview with Hermann Johannesburg, 2 February 2016. 3 2 ‘SA is Rendered Lawless and Ungovernable’, release from prison, Cape Town City Hall, Giliomee, 11 November 2002, in Hermann Ibid. 4 City Press, 18 April 2015. Cape Town, 11 February 1990. Giliomee, The Afrikaners: Biography of a Ibid. 5 3 NM, Long Walk to Freedom: The 3 Zoë Wicomb, ‘Nelson Mandela’, New Yorker, People, p. 646. S. Mbiti, African Religions and Philosophy Autobiography of Nelson Mandela (London: 16 December 2013. 31 Martin Luther King, Jr, ‘Nobel Lecture: (London: Heinemann, 1969). 6 Abacus, 1994; citations from 2013 edition), 4 NM, Long Walk to Freedom, p. 690. The Quest for Peace and Justice’, NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 12–13. 7 p. 626. 5 Scott Kraft, ‘ANC President Tambo Returns 11 December 1964. Robert Mattes, Hermann Giliomee and 4 C. L. R James, preface to The Black Jacobins to SA After a 30-Year Exile’, Los Angeles 32 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 9. , Launching Democracy in (London: Secker & Warburg, 1938). Times, 14 December 1990. 33 Ibid. South Africa: The First Open Election, April 5 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p.1, NMF, 6 NM, interview by James Lorimer and Des 34 Joseph R. Gregory, ‘P. W. Botha, Defender of 1994, edited by R. W. Johnson and Lawrence Johannesburg, 1998. Latham, Mandela’s home, Vilakazi Street, , is Dead at 90’, New York Times, Schlemmer, April 1994 (New Haven, CT: 6 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 1. Orlando West, , 15 February 1990, 1 November 2006. Yale University Press, 1996), p. 129. 8 7 Niël Barnard, Secret Revolution (Cape Town: Paddi Clay collection. 35 Hugh Robertson, ‘Intrigue Over “New” Johannes Rantete, The African National Tafelberg, 2015), p. 245. 7 NM, Long Walk to Freedom, p. 706. Offer to the Alliance’, Daily News, Congress and Negotiated Settlement in South 8 NMF, press release, ‘ 8 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 2. 2 March 1994. Africa (Pretoria: J. L. Van Schaik, 1998), Remembers Reuniting With Madiba After 9 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 3. 36 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 9. p. 243. His Release’, 13 February 2015. E nDNOTES

9 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 13–14. Johannesburg, 30 April 2015. 15 , interview by Sahm Venter, CHAPTER FIVE: NATIONAL UNITY 10 ‘“Dirty Tricks” Election Row’, The Argus, 33 Ibid. Cape Town, October 1994. 1 8 April 1994. 34 Ibid. 16 , interview by Tony Trew, Andries Nel, notes made on the day, 9 May 11 Ibid. 35 Ibid. Johannesburg, 10 September 2014. 1994, private collection. 2 12 , interview by Joel Netshitenzhe 36 Barbara Masekela, interview by Tony Trew, 17 Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, interview by Trevor Manuel, interview by Tony Trew, and Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 17 December Cape Town, 28 August 2014. Tony Trew, , 26 February 2016. Johannesburg, 10 September 2014. 3 2014. 37 NM, address to the people of Cape Town on 18 Mary Mxadana, interview by Sahm Venter, Ibid. 4 13 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 14–15. his election as president of South Africa, City Cape Town, October 1994. , interview by Tony Trew, 14 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 15. Hall, Cape Town, 9 May 1994. 19 NM, interview by Charlayne Hunter-Gault, Johannesburg, 12 September 2014. 5 15 Charles Oulton, ‘South African Elections: 38 Jessie Duarte, interview by Tony Trew, MacNeil/Lehrer NewsHour, PBS, 6 May 1994, Rapport, 31 July 1994, in David Welsh, Huddleston Casts His Vote and Rejoices’, Johannesburg, 15 July 2014. from ‘South Africa: Pres Elect Interview’, ‘Coalition Government’, in State of , 26 April 1994. 39 NM, statement at his inauguration as AP Archive, story no. W066632. Nation, p. 46. 6 16 Paul Taylor, ‘Historic Election Begins in president of the democratic Republic of 20 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 4–5. Nelson Mandela, interview by BBC, October South Africa,’ Washington Post, South Africa, Union Buildings, Pretoria, 21 Neal Chapman and Peter Wrighton, ‘Civil 1993, NMF tapes, BBC Tape M8, NMF, 27 April 1994. 10 May 1994. society: The Role of Business and the Johannesburg. 7 17 NM, Long Walk to Freedom, p. 742. 40 Adrian Hadland, ‘Let’s Build a Great SA’, Churches in Facilitating Transition’, in South Padraig O’Malley, Shades of Difference: 18 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 15–16. Business Day, Wednesday, 11 May 1994. Africa at 10: Perspectives by Political, Business and the Struggle for South Africa 19 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 15. 41 ‘F. W. de Klerk: Mandela Held My Hand for and Civil Leaders (Cape Town: Human & (New York: Viking Penguin, 2007), 20 This was said by Judge Johann Kriegler All to See’, City Press, 6 December 2013. Rousseau, 2004), p. 29. pp. 400–402. 8 as chair of the Independent Electoral 42 Adrian Hadland, ‘Let’s Build a Great SA’, 22 Tito Mboweni, interview by Tony Trew, Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Commission; Peter Harris, Birth: Business Day, Wednesday, 11 May 1994. Johannesburg, 12 September 2014. 1996, chapter six: The National Executive, The Conspiracy to Stop the ’94 Election 43 NM, speech at the luncheon following his 23 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 17–18. clause 89 (2). 9 (Cape Town: Umuzi, 2010), inauguration, Cape Town, 10 May 1994, 24 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 18. , interview by Padraig O’Malley, pp. 267–75. SABC, SABC Archive, SABC Information 25 Thabo Mbeki, interview by Tony Trew and 8 November 1994, O’Malley Archive. 10 21 F. W. de Klerk, The Last Trek – A New Library, Johannesburg. Joel Netshitenzhe, Johannesburg, and Adrian Hadland with Beginning: The Autobiography (New York: 17 December 2014. Moira Levy, Politics in my Blood, p. 197. 11 St Martin’s Press, 1999), p. 336. CHAPTER FOUR: GETTING INTO THE 26 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 18. , interview by Padraig 22 NM, victory speech upon the ANC UNION BUILDINGS 27 F. W. de Klerk, The Last Trek, in NM, O’Malley, 3 October 1995, O’Malley winning the 1994 election, Carlton Hotel, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 238. Archive. 1 12 Johannesburg, 2 May 1994. Jessie Duarte, interview by Tony Trew, 28 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 18–19. NM, interview by Patti Waldmeier, Union 23 NM, addressing guests during celebrations Johannesburg, 15 July 2014. 29 Trevor Manuel, interview by Tony Trew, Buildings, Pretoria, 1 July 1994, 2 following the ANC election victory, Carlton Fanie Pretorius, interview by Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 10 September 2014. Patti Waldmeier interviews, Historical Hotel, Johannesburg, 2 May 1994. Pretoria, 11 July 2014. 30 Ibid. Papers Research Archive, William Cullen 3 24 Jessie Duarte, interview by Tony Trew, President’s office staff, interviews by Sahm 31 Ibid. Library, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 15 July 2014. Venter, October 1994. 32 Ibid. Johannesburg. 4 13 25 Chris Streeter, interview by Tony Trew, William Ernest Henley, ‘Invictus’, A Book of 33 F.W. de Klerk, email interview by Tony Trew, Thabo Mbeki, interview by Joel Netshitenzhe Pretoria, 21 January 2015. Verses (London, 1888). 13 March 2015. and Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 17 December 5 26 ‘Time Now to Begin Anew: Mandela Joins NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 27–9. 34 Valli Moosa, interview by Tony Trew, Cape 2014. 6 14 Peace Prayers’, Cape Times, 9 May 1994. NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 22–3. Town, 8 September 2014; Jessie Duarte, SAPA, ‘NP to Fare Worse than in 1994 Poll, 7 27 Jessie Duarte, interview by Tony Trew, Barbara Masekela, interview by Tony Trew, interview by Tony Trew, Johannesburg, Says Mandela’, The Citizen, 26 June 1995. 15 Johannesburg, 15 July 2014. Cape Town, 28 August 2014. 15 July 2014; Trevor Manuel, interview with F. W. de Klerk, The Last Trek, p. 357. 8 16 28 NM, Long Walk to Freedom, pp. 401–2. Ahmed Kathrada in conversation with Tony Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 10 September F. W. de Klerk, email interview by Tony 29 Walter Sisulu, ‘We Shall Overcome!’, Trew and Joel Netshitenzhe, Johannesburg, 2014. Trew, 13 March 2015. 17 Reflections in Prison, edited by Mac Maharaj 2 December 2014. 35 F.W. de Klerk, The Last Trek, pp. 342–4; , Opposite Mandela: Encounters 9 (Cape Town: Zebra Press and Jakes Gerwel, president’s office submission to David Welsh, ‘Coalition Government, with South Africa’s Icon (Johannesburg: Museum, 2001), p. 85. the Presidential Review Commission, An Unwilling Marriage’, in State of the Jonathan Ball Publishers, 2014), p. 97. 18 30 Pixley ka Isaka Seme, ‘Native Union’, Imvo 25 September 1997. Nation, 1997/98, Bertus De Villiers (editor) AP Archive, ‘South Africa – de Klerk and 10 Zabantsundu, 24 October 1911, in Sheridan NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 19. (Pretoria: HSRC), pp. 37. Mandela Make Up’, story no. W019071, 11 Johns III, Protest and Hope 1882–1934, vol. 1 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 19–20. 36 Tim Cohen, ‘Mandela’s Saintly Reign a Case 20 January 1995. 12 19 of From Protest to Challenge: A Documentary Jakes Gerwel, interview by Aziz Pahad, of Hit or Myth’, Business Day, 11 May 1994. AP Archive, ‘Mandela Denies Rumours of History of African Politics in South Africa 21 July 2010. 37 Kader Asmal and Adrian Hadland with de Klerk’s Resignation’, story no. 15992, 13 1882–1964, edited by Thomas Karis and Memo from director general, Office of the Moira Levy, Politics in my Blood: A Memoir 13 October 1995. 20 Gwendolen M. Carter (Stanford, CA: President, state expenditure, November (Johannesburg: Jacana Media, 2011), p.193. F. W. de Klerk, The Last Trek, p. 353. 21 Hoover Institution Press, 1972), p. 71. 1997, Gerwel Papers (private collection). 38 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 23. NM to F. W. de Klerk, 26 September 1995, 14 31 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 40. Jan-Jan Joubert, ‘He Could See the Essential Gerwel Papers (private collection). 32 Sydney Mufamadi, interview by Tony Trew, Core’, City Press, 8 December 2013. DARE NOT LINGER E nDNOTES

22 Graça Machel, interview by Mandla Langa, 42 Statement by President Nelson Mandela on 64 Sydney Mufamadi, interview by Tony Trew, CHAPTER SIX: THE PRESIDENCY AND Johannesburg, 22 September 2016. changes in the Ministry of Arts, Culture, Johannesburg, 30 April 2015. THE CONSTITUTION 23 F. W. de Klerk, The Last Trek, p. 353. Science and Technology, 14 April 1995. 65 , interview by Padraig O’Malley, 1 24 F. W. de Klerk, email interview by Tony 43 Bob Drogin, ‘Winnie Mandela Quits Post, 14 April 2003, O’Malley Archive. NM, speech from the dock at the opening Trew, 13 March 2015. Criticizes Estranged Husband’, Los Angeles 66 NM, address to veterans at banquet, of the defence case, , Pretoria 25 Thabo Mbeki, interview by Joel Netshitenzhe Times, 18 April 1995. State House, Pretoria, 23 July 1994. Supreme Court, Pretoria, 20 April 1964. 2 and Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 44 Sunday Telegraph, 1 May 1994. 67 NM, statement in the National Assembly, NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 30. 3 17 December 2014. 45 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 23–4. Houses of Parliament, Cape Town, Johann Kriegler, interview by Tony Trew, 26 NM, address on the occasion of the 46 Khulu Sibiya, ‘Truly, Truly Unforgettable’, 28 March 1996. Johannesburg, 2 February 2016; NM President’s Budget Debate in the Senate, City Press, 15 May 1994, in NM, 68 Ibid. interviewed by David Dimbleby, Oxford, Houses of Parliament, Cape Town, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 24. 69 , interview by Tony Trew, 2002, NMF Tapes, NMF, Johannesburg. 4 18 June 1996. 47 Ibid. Somerset West, 1 December 2015. NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 29. 5 27 Jeremy Seekings, ‘Partisan Realignment in 48 Jerry Zremski, ‘Mandela Inauguration, 70 Alan Hirsch, Season of Hope: Economic Frene Ginwala, interview by Tony Trew, Cape Town, 1994–2004’, CSIR Working Spirit of Reconciliation Thrills Houghton’, Reform Under Mandela and Mbeki Johannesburg, 12 September 2014. 6 Paper, no. 111, December 2005. Buffalo News, 11 May 1994. (Scottsville: University of KwaZulu- AP Archive, ‘South Africa: Constitutional 28 Mangosuthu Buthelezi, interview by Tony 49 Marga Ley, ‘Wit, Swart Neem Mekaar as Press jointly with Ottawa: International Court Ruling on Election Boundaries’, story Trew, Durban, 28 November 2014. Gesinslede aan’ [White and Black Accept Development Research Centre, 2005), p. 93. no. 14965, 22 September 1995. 7 29 Jakes Gerwel, interview by Jan-­Jan Joubert Each Other as Family], Beeld, 11 May 1994, 71 Trevor Manuel, interview by Tony Trew, Statement by the President’s Office on the drawing on a 2010 interview, ‘Jakes Gerwel: in NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 31. Johannesburg, 10 September 2014. Browde Commission into South African Mandela Could See the Essential Core’, 50 Sarel van der Walt, ‘Goeie SA “kan kom uit 72 Graça Machel, interview by Mandla Langa, Rugby Union, 26 September 1997. 8 City Press, 10 December 2013. wittebroodstyd”’ [ South Africa “can 22 September 2016. AP Archive, ‘South Africa: Mandela 30 Mangosuthu Buthelezi, interview by Padraig emerge from the honeymoon period”], Beeld, 73 NM, reply to the NCOP debate on the Testifies in Court’, 19 March 1998. 9 O’Malley, 3 October 1995, O’Malley 11 May 1994, in NM, ‘The Presidential President’s Budget, Houses of Parliament, NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 29–30. 10 Archive. Years’, p. 31. Cape Town, 29 August 1997, Hansard, Statement by the Office of the President on 31 Mangosuthu Buthelezi, interview by Tony 51 Themba Khumalo, ‘Madiba’s World Coup: cols. 1551–2. the SARFU Case, 17 April 1998. 11 Trew, Durban, 28 November 2014. Leaders Flock to Pretoria’, City Press, 15 May 74 Sue van der Merwe, interview by Tony Trew, NM, opening address in the President’s 32 Mangosuthu Buthelezi, interview with Tony 1994, in NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 31. Cape Town, 8 April 2015. Budget Debate in the National Assembly, Trew, Durban, 28 November 2014; NM 52 ‘Sowetan Comment’, The Sowetan, 75 NM, notes prepared for a meeting of the Houses of Parliament, Cape Town, 21 April to Irene Buthelezi, 3 August 1979, in NM, 11 May 1994. NEC, 19 February 1996, NMPP 2009/8, 1998. 12 Conversations with Myself, pp. 170–2; NM 53 Ibid. box 7, file 11, African Bank 1995, pp. 1–7, Ibid. 13 to Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi, 3 February 54 Ken Owen, ‘To Our Rainbow Nation Finally NMF, Johannesburg. Andy Capostangno, ‘Black President for 1989, in NM, Conversations with Myself, United in Peace’, Sunday Times, 15 May 76 NM, reply to the NCOP debate on the Rugby’, Mail & Guardian, 22 May 1988. 14 p. 255. 1994, in NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 32. President’s Budget, 7 August 1998, Debates NM, Memorial Lecture, 33 Anthony Lewis, ‘Mandela the Pol’, New York 55 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 31–3. of the National Council of Provinces, 9 June 1995. 15 Times Magazine, 23 March 1997. 56 NM, note, NMPP 2009/8, Box 7, file 11, p. Hansard, 3 March to 12 November 1998, Kader Asmal and Adrian Hadland with 34 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 36. 48, NMF, Johannesburg. cols. 1807–15. Moira Levy, Politics in my Blood, pp. 108–9. 16 35 Mangosuthu Buthelezi, interview by Padraig 57 NM, notes for opening remarks at NEC 77 Trevor Manuel, interview by Tony Trew, Ibid, pp. 110, 125. 17 O’Malley, 3 October 1995, O’Malley meeting, box 4, folder 38, ANCLH, Johannesburg, 10 September 2014. , Odyssey to Freedom Archive. Johannesburg. 78 Ibid. (Houghton: Random House, 2007), p. 487. 18 36 Statement by President Nelson Mandela on 58 Yusuf Mohamed Dadoo, ‘Why the South 79 Ibid. Nicholas Haysom, ‘Negotiating a Sustainable the NP’s withdrawal from the Government Africa United Front Failed: Disruptive Role 80 Ibid. Political Settlement: Part 2 Legitimation – of National Unity (GNU), 9 May 1996. of the Pan Africanist Congress of Azania’, 81 Ahmed Kathrada in conversation with Joel Lessons from the South African Transition’ 37 SAPA, ‘Government Failed SA Says Winnie’, March 1962, in South Africa’s Freedom Netshitenzhe and Tony Trew, Johannesburg, (paper presented at Toward Inclusive and Citizen, 6 February 1995. Struggle: Statements, Speeches and Articles 2 December 2014. Participatory Constitution Making, 3–5 38 Statement on Deputy Minister Winnie Including Correspondence with Mahatma 82 Sydney Mufamadi, interview with Tony August, 2004, Kathmandu (Nagarkot)), Mandela’s apology, issued by the President’s Gandhi (London: Kliptown Books, 1990). Trew, Johannesburg, 30 April 2015. p.9; Hassen Ebrahim, The Soul of a Nation: Office, 14 February 1995. 59 NM, Long Walk to Freedom, p. 580. 83 John Higgins, ‘Living out our differences: Constitution-making in South Africa (Cape 39 Statement by President Nelson Mandela on 60 Graça Machel, interview by Mandla Langa, Reflections on Mandela, Marx and Town: Oxford University Press, 1998), changes in the Ministry of Arts, Culture, Johannesburg, 22 September 2016. My Country: An interview with Jakes pp. 134ff. 19 Science and Technology, 27 March 1995. 61 NM, address at birthday celebration for Gerwel’, Thesis Eleven, vol. 115, no.1, Sage Valli Moosa, interview by Tony Trew, Cape 40 AP Archive, ‘South Africa: Winnie Mandela veterans, Pretoria, 20 July 1996. Publications, 2013. Town, 8 September 2014. 20 Resigns From Government’, story no. 6108, 62 NM, address to veterans at banquet, 84 ‘“Unpredictable” Madiba Kept Bodyguards Thabo Mbeki, interview by Joel Netshitenzhe APTV, 17 April 1995. State House, Pretoria, 23 July 1994. on Their Toes’, City Press, 8 December 2013. and Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 41 Statement on the reinstatement of Mrs 63 Jay Naidoo, Fighting for Justice: A Lifetime of 85 Toine Eggenhuizen, interview by Mandla 17 December 2014. 21 Winnie Mandela, issued by the acting Political and Social Activism (Johannesburg: Langa, Johannesburg, 10 February 2017. , interview by Tony Trew, president, 12 April 1995. Picador Africa, 2010), p. 227. Johannesburg, 6 October 2014. DARE NOT LINGER E nDNOTES

22 George Bizos, Odyssey to Freedom, p. 508. Parliament, Houses of Parliament, Cape Senate, NMPP 2009/8, box 4, folder 1, in KwaZulu-Natal after being trained by 23 NM, notes for an address to the NEC, 23 Town, 17 February 1995. NMF, Johannesburg. apartheid security forces, in TRC Final February 1995, box 3, folder 29, ANCLH, 7 Statement by President Nelson Mandela on 28 NM, opening the National Assembly snap Report, vol. 6, section 3, chapter 3, p. 351, Johannesburg. portraits and works of art in Parliament, debate on events surrounding the shooting at presented to President Nelson Mandela, 24 NM, reply to the debate on the State of the 30 January 1996. Shell House, Houses of Parliament, 29 October 1998: Thula Bophela and Nation Address, 24 February 1995. 8 Graça Machel, interview by Mandla Langa, Cape Town, 7 June 1995. Daluxolo Luthuli, Umkhonto weSizwe: 25 Hassen Ebrahim, The Soul of a Nation, Johannesburg, 22 September 2016. 29 NM, closing address to the National Fighting for a Divided People (Johannesburg: p. 132; Cape Times, 29 April 1996; Mail & 9 Frene Ginwala, interview by Tony Trew, Assembly in the snap debate on the Shell Galago, 2005); see also ’s Guardian, 4 April 1996 and 10 May 1996. Johannesburg, 12 September 2014. House incident, Houses of Parliament, submission to the TRC, Amnesty Hearings, 26 NM, address to the Constitutional Assembly 10 Max Sisulu, interview by Tony Trew, Cape Town, 7 June 1995. , 29 September–3 October on the adoption of the new Constitution, Johannesburg, 15 April 2015. 30 NM, speech at the final sitting of the first 1997; and TRC Final Report, vol. 6, section Houses of Parliament, Cape Town, 11 Frene Ginwala, interview by Tony Trew, democratically elected parliament, Houses of 4, appendix, p. 583, presented to President 8 May 1996, Hansard, cols. 452–62. Johannesburg, 12 September 2014. Parliament, Cape Town, 26 March 1999. Nelson Mandela, 29 October 1998. 27 George Bizos, Odyssey to Freedom, p. 518. 12 Ibid; Max Sisulu, interview by Tony Trew, 31 Joseph Chiole, Second Reading Debate on 15 Sydney Mufamadi, interview by Tony Trew, 28 Langston Hughes, ‘Justice’, The Panther and Johannesburg, 15 April 2015. the Commission on the Remuneration of Johannesburg, 29 May 2015. the Lash (New York: Knopf, 1967). 13 Max Sisulu, interview by Tony Trew, Representatives Bill, 14 November 1994, 16 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 36–7. 29 George Bizos, Odyssey to Freedom, p. 518. Johannesburg, 15 April 2015; Ben Turok, Hansard, cols. 4256 and 4259. 17 NM, address to rally in Durban, 30 Constitution of the Republic of South interview by Tony Trew, Cape Town, 17 32 NM, speech at the final sitting of the first 25 February 1990. Africa, 1996, chapter 8: Courts and the March 2015; Sue van der Merwe, interview democratically elected parliament, Houses of 18 NM, in conversation with Richard Stengel, Administration of Justice, clause 174 (2). by Tony Trew, Cape Town, 8 April 2015. Parliament, Cape Town, 26 March 1999. Johannesburg, c. 26 April and 3 May 1993, 31 George Bizos, Odyssey to Freedom, p. 519. 14 NEC Minutes, 24 April 1995, box 5, folder CD 61, NMF, Johannesburg. 32 NM, speech at the inauguration of the 23, ANCLH, Johannesburg. CHAPTER EIGHT: TRADITIONAL 19 John Nkadimeng, broadcast Constitutional Court, 14 February 1995. 15 Mangosuthu Buthelezi, interview by Padraig LEADERSHIP AND DEMOCRACY from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, 18 November 33 NM, speech at a state banquet in honour of O’Malley, 27 November 1996, O’Malley 1986. 1 Chief Justice Corbett, 11 December 1996. Archive. Pixley ka Isaka Seme, speech at the founding 20 Mzala, Gatsha Buthelezi: Chief with A Double 34 NM, speech delivered on his behalf by the 16 NM, notes for a meeting with the ANC conference of the ANC, , Agenda (London: Zed Press, 1988), p. 64. minister of justice at the Johannesburg Bar Caucus, NMPP 2009/8, box 3, notebook 12, 8 January 1912. 21 NM, in conversation with Richard Stengel, 2 Council dinner in honour of Chief Justice pp. 20–1, NMF, Johannesburg. NM, ‘Clear the Obstacles and Confront the Johannesburg, c. 26 April and 3 May 1993, Mohamed, 25 June 1997. 17 NM, personal note, NMPP, box 4, file2, Enemy’, Reflections in Prison, p. 12. CD 61, NMF, Johannesburg. 3 35 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 29. 011–12, NMF, Johannesburg. Christopher S. Wren, ‘Foes of Apartheid 22 NM, address at the launch of the South 36 NM, speech at a banquet of the General 18 NM, notes for a meeting with caucus, 18 Hold Unity Talks’, New York Times, African Democratic Teachers Union, Council of the Bar of South Africa, 28 July August 1996, NMPP 2009/8, box 4, file 2, 10 December 1989. 6 October 1990, Shareworld, Shaft 17, 4 2000. pp. 1–2, NMF, Johannesburg. NM, note to Walter Sisulu, NMPP 2009/8, Johannesburg. 37 , We, the People: Insights of 19 Richard Calland, Anatomy of South Africa: box 5, file 5, NMF, Johannesburg. 23 NM, notes for an address to the NEC 5 an Activist Judge (Johannesburg: Wits Who Holds the Power? (Cape Town, Zebra NM, Participation of Traditional Leaders at meeting, 21 January 1995, NMPP 2009/8, University Press, 2016), p. 303. Press, 2006), p. 89. CODESA, statement issued by the ANC, box 4, file 2, pp. 174–5, NMF, Johannesburg. 20 Andries Nel, interview by Tony Trew, Cape 17 December 1991. 24 NM, Long Walk to Freedom, p. 689. 6 CHAPTER SEVEN: PARLIAMENT Town, 28 March 2015; SAPA, ‘Decision on NM, address to the youth, KaNyamazane 25 Walter Sisulu, interviewed on the sidelines in Army Slated’, Star, Stadium, Mpumalanga, 13 April 1994 of an Foundation function, 1 7 Ingrid Jonker, ‘The Child Who Was Shot Dead 1 February 1996. NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 34–8. NMF Tapes, BBC TV Collection, M18A, 8 by Soldiers in Nyanga’, The Heinemann Book 21 Sophocles, Fragments, edited and translated Allister Sparks, Beyond the Miracle: Inside the NMF, Johannesburg. of African Women’s Poetry, edited by Stella and by Hugh Lloyd Jones (Cambridge, MA: New South Africa (Chicago, IL: University of 26 ‘Under Fire in an Inkatha Stronghold’, Mail Frank Chipasula (London: Heinemann, 1995), Harvard University Press, 1996), p. 37. Chicago Press, 2003), p. 18. & Guardian, 5 May 1995. 9 p. 151, quoted by NM, during his State of the 22 André Brink, ‘Mandela a Tiger for Our Local Elections Task Group, Local 27 Ibid. Nation Address, Houses of Parliament, Cape Time,’ , 22 May 1999. Government Elections in South Africa 28 NM, closing address in the National Town, 24 May 1994. 23 ‘The Day the Truth Hit Home’, Sunday 1995/1996 (Pretoria: ABC Press, 1997). Assembly Debate on the President’s Budget, 2 10 NM, State of the Nation Address, Houses of Times Heritage Project. Valli Moosa, interview by Tony Trew, Cape Houses of Parliament, Cape Town, 3 May Parliament, Cape Town, 24 May 1994. 24 George Bizos, interview by Tony Trew, Town, 8 September 2014. 1995, Hansard, cols. 818–20. 3 11 Frene Ginwala, interview by Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 30 April 2015. NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 38–9. 29 Ibid. 12 Johannesburg, 12 September 2014. 25 NM, reply to the Senate Debate on the NM, address to rally in Durban, 25 February 30 Ibid. 4 , interview by Joel Netshitenzhe President’s Budget, 1 June 1995, Hansard, 1990. 31 Ibid. 13 and Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 11 September col. 1341. South African Institute of Race Relations, 32 Ibid. 2014. 26 Sydney Mufamadi, interview by Tony Trew, Fast Facts, March 1997. 33 NM, Senate debate on the President’s 5 14 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 20–1. Johannesburg, 30 April 2015. See the evidence to the TRC by Daluxolo Budget, Houses of Parliament, Cape Town, 6 NM, address on the occasion of the opening 27 NM, notes for a meeting with ANC officials Luthuli, a former member of MK who 1 June 1995, Hansard, cols. 1139–42. of the second session of the democratic after his remarks on Shell House in the became a commander of Inkatha hit squads DARE NOT LINGER E nDNOTES

34 7 June 1995, NMPP 2009/8, box 5, folder 4; 15 NM, notes for a meeting with SAPS officers, Africa, May 1996, section 51. Johannesburg, 24 November 2015. ‘Can 1000 Troops Stop the Carnage?’, 30 November 1996, NMPP/8, box 7, file 35 Louise Flanagan and Chandre Gould, 50 A former staff member of Jakes Gerwel’s Mail & Guardian, 25 August 1995. 11, African Bank 1995, pp. 89–93, NMF, ‘What Modise Didn’t Know About DCC’, office, in conversation with Tony Trew, 35 Sydney Mufamadi, interview by Tony Trew, Johannesburg. Weekly Mail, 17 June 1994. Cape Town, 8 August 2015. Johannesburg, 29 May 2015. 16 Ibid. 36 NM, opening address in the President’s 51 Barry Gilder, Songs and Secrets, p. 177. 36 NM, Two and a half years of democratic 17 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 40. Budget Debate in the National Assembly, 52 Ibid. government: prepared by President Nelson 18 Stephane Botha, ‘Commissioner of Police Cape Town, 21 April 1998. 53 , interview by Tony Trew, Mandela for the NEC, November 1996, box to Retire’, Business Day, 11 January 1995; 37 ‘Mandela Speaks to the Nation’, Johannesburg, 25 November 2015. 6, folder 58, ANCLH, Johannesburg. Sydney Mufamadi, interview by Tony Trew, The Sowetan, 11 November 1996. 54 Lansana Gberie, ‘Mandela’s Struggles for Johannesburg, 30 April 2015. 38 AP Archive, ‘South Africa: President Peace and Justice in Africa’, Africa Renewal CHAPTER NINE: TRANSFORMATION 19 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 40–2. Mandela Praises Outgoing Military Chief’, Online, December 2013. OF THE STATE 20 Research staff, South African Institute story no. 76476, 7 April 1998. 55 Barry Gilder, interview by Tony Trew, of Race Relations, Race Relations Survey 39 Trevor Manuel, interview by Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 24 November 2015. 1 One example of NM saying he had been on 1993/1994, South African Institute of Race Johannesburg, 10 September 2014. 56 NM, speech at the official opening of ‘a long holiday for twenty-seven years’ was Relations, Johannesburg, 1994, in NM, 40 Thabo Mbeki, interview by Joel Netshitenzhe Intelligence headquarters, 5 December 1997. when he revisited the site of his 5 August ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 42. and Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 17 December 57 , interviewed by 1962 arrest in Howick on 15 November 1993. 21 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 40–3. 2014. Padraig O’Malley, 30 November 1995, 2 Howard Fast, Spartacus (self-published, 22 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 45. 41 NM, State of the Nation Address, Houses of O’Malley Archive. 1951); Leo Tolstoy, War and Peace (1869); 23 Ian van der Waag, A Military History of Parliament, Cape Town, 9 February 1996. 58 Niël Barnard, interview by Tony Trew, Dee Brown, Bury My Heart at Wounded Modern South Africa (Johannesburg and 42 Defence Review Committee, South African Overberg, 17 November 2015. Knee: An Indian History of the American Cape Town: Jonathan Ball Publishers, 2015), Defence Review 1998 (Pretoria: Department 59 Jessie Duarte, interview by Tony Trew, West (New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, p. 287; Princeton Lyman, Partner to History, of Defence, 1998); Public protector, auditor Johannesburg, 15 July 2014. 1970); Edgar Snow, Red Star Over China p. 163. general and national director of public 60 Allister Sparks, Beyond the Miracle, p. 37. (London: Victor Gollancz, 1937). 24 Siphiwe Nyanda, interview by Tony Trew, prosecutions, Report to Parliament on the 61 Zola Skweyiya, O’Malley interview, 3 Luis Taruc, Born of the People (New York: Johannesburg, 25 November 2015. Joint Investigation into the Strategic Defence 30 November 1995. International Publishers, 1953). 25 Greg Mills, ‘The South African National Procurement Packages Undertaken by the 62 National Planning Commission, Institutions 4 Allister Sparks, Beyond the Miracle, p.18. Defence Force: Between Downsizing and Public Protector, Auditor-General and National and Governance Diagnostic (Pretoria: 5 NM interviewed by the BBC, October 1993, New Capabilities’, Naval War College Review, Director of Public Prosecutions, 13 November National Planning Commission, 2015), NMF Tapes, BBC M8, NMF, Johannesburg. vol. 52, no. 1, winter 1999, pp. 79–98. 2001. p. 11; and Geraldine Fraser-Molekei, 6 Zola Skweyiya, interviewed by Padraig 26 Siphiwe Nyanda, interview by Tony Trew, 43 South African Department of Defence, telephone interview by Tony True, O’Malley, 30 November 1995, O’Malley Johannesburg, 25 November 2015. Department of Defence Annual Report 29 July 2016. Archive. 27 AP Archive, 11 September 1994; Beeld 2001/2002 (Pretoria: Department of 63 Public Service Commission, State of 7 NM, note regarding an interview with archive, 10 September to 4 November 1994. Defence, 2002), p. 62. Representivity in the Public Service – Nomavenda Mathiane, NMPP 2009/8, box 28 NM, NMPP 2009/8, box 3, notebook 12, 44 Yvonne Muthien, ‘Democratic Consolidation Findings; Department of Public Service and 7, file 11, p. 39, NMF, Johannesburg. NMF, Johannesburg. in South Africa, 1994–1999’, Democracy Administration, A Strategic Framework for 8 Transitional Executive Council Act, 1993; 29 NM, NMPP 2009/8, box 3, notebook 12, South Africa: Evaluating the 1999 Election Gender Equality Within the Public Service Barry Gilder, Songs and Secrets: South Africa NMF, Johannesburg; AP Archive, (Pretoria: HSRC Publishers, 1999). (2006–2015): Consultation Document from Liberation to Governance (New York, 11 September 1994; Beeld Archive, 45 Charles Baudelaire, ‘The Generous (Pretoria: Department of Public Service and NY: Colombia University Press, 2012), 10 September to 4 November 1994. Gambler’, Figaro, 1864. Administration, 24 November 2006). pp. 156–7; Sydney Mufamadi, interview 30 Telex to Parks Mankahlana, Office of the 46 NM, the text at the beginning of the note 64 NM to Thabo Mbeki, 6 June 1994, DP Pres with Tony Trew, Johannesburg, 30 April President, from Amrit Manga of the New reads: ‘The President and two Deputy- Mbeki, box 002, folder 11/1/1 – President, 2015; Barry Gilder, interview by Tony Nation containing his transcript of an Presidents, the Ministers of Defence and of closed, NASA, Pretoria. Trew, Johannesburg, 24 November 2015; interview with President Mandela, Speeches: Safety and Security, Generals Georg Meiring 65 Zola Skweyiya, O’Malley interview, Siphiwe Nyanda, interview by Tony Trew, Youth Day 1996, President Mandela and Van der Merwe should be briefed by the 30 November 1995. Johannesburg, 5 November 2015. Communication, NASA, Pretoria. National Intelligence Service at the earliest 66 National Planning Commission, Institutions 9 Graça Machel, interview by Mandla Langa, 31 NM, note for a meeting of the NEC, 8–9 possible convenience on the following issues.’ and Governance Diagnostic, pp. 22–3. Johannesburg, 22 September 2016. December 1995, NMPP 2009/8, box 4, file NMPP 2009/8, NMF, Johannesburg. 67 NM, State of the Nation Address, Houses of 10 NM, notes edited for a speech prior to a 1, pp. 159ff, NMF, Johannesburg. 47 Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Parliament, Cape Town, 24 May 1994; NM, meeting with SAPS generals, NMPP 2009/8, 32 Siphiwe Nyanda, interview by Tony Trew, 1996, chapter 11: Security Services, debate on the President’s Budget (‘100 Days box 3, notebook 12, pp. 25–30, NMF, Johannesburg, 25 November 2015. clause 198 (a). Speech’), Houses of Parliament, Cape Town, Johannesburg. 33 Gert van der Westhuizen, ‘Mandela kap 48 Sandy Africa, ‘The Policy Evolution of the South Africa, 18 August 1994. 11 Ibid. voorstel teen Afrikaans’, [Mandela refuses South African Civilian Intelligence Services: 68 NM, State of the Nation Address, Houses of 12 Ibid. proposal against Afrikaans] Beeld, 1994-2009 and Beyond’, Strategic Review for Parliament, Cape Town, 17 February 1995. 13 Ibid. 1 February 1996. Southern Africa, vol. 34, no. 1, May 2012, 69 NM, State of the Nation Address, Houses of 14 Sydney Mufamadi, interview by Tony Trew, 34 Defence in a Democracy: White Paper on p. 103. Parliament, Cape Town, 9 February 1996. Johannesburg, 30 April 2015. National Defence for the Republic of South 49 Barry Gilder, interview by Tony Trew, DARE NOT LINGER E nDNOTES

70 Marion Edmunds, ‘Skills Crisis Knocks 19 Minutes of extended NWC, 7 September 34 Ibid. 7 ANC National Working Committee Public Service’, Mail & Guardian, 1995, ANCLHM, box 14, folder 111, NMF, 35 Mandla Langa in conversation with Antjie discussion document: TEC Sub-council 15 August 1997. Johannesburg. Krog during the writers’ conference Cité de on Finance, 27 April 1993, box 14, 112, 71 NM, opening address to the third session 20 NM, address to a rally in Cape Town on his Livre, Aix-en-Provence, 1997. ANCLH, Johannesburg. of Parliament, Houses of Parliament, Cape release from prison, Cape Town City Hall, 36 SA Times, London, 19 July 1995. 8 William Smith, interview by Tony Trew, Town, 9 February 1996. Cape Town, 11 February 1990. 37 Constand Viljoen, interview by Tony Trew, Pretoria, 11 July 2014. 21 Saths Cooper, ‘The Mandela I Knew: Prof. Pretoria, 19 September 2015. 9 NM, address at the National Assembly, Cape CHAPTER TEN: RECONCILIATION Saths Cooper’, Tributes for Madiba, Nelson 38 Ibid. Town, 28 March 1996. Mandela Foundation, 12 September 2013. 39 SAPA, 13 December 1996. 10 NM, State of the Nation Address, Houses of 1 NMF tapes, BBC Collection M2, NMF, 22 NM, Reply in Senate Debate on the 40 Niël Barnard, interview by Tony Trew, Parliament, Cape Town, 24 May 1994. Johannesburg. President’s Budget, 14 September 1994, Overberg, 17 November 2015. 11 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 52. 2 James Baldwin, No Name in the Street, p. 130. Houses of Parliament, Cape Town. 41 NM, televised interview on Face the Media, 12 Ibid. 3 Indres Naidoo, Island in Chains: Ten Years 23 NM, Toespraak van president by geleentheid 14 December 1997, SABC, tape 66676MT, 13 Native Life in South Africa Before and Since on Robben Island (Harmondsworth: Penguin van ’n onthaal deur die Burgemeester van SABC Archive, SABC Information Library, the European War and the Boer Rebellion Group, 1982). Pretoria [Speech by the president at the Johannesburg. (1916) (Johannesburg: Raven’s Press, 1982), 4 Michael Dingake, ‘Comrade Madiba’, Nelson occasion of a reception by the mayor of 42 Niël Barnard, interview by Tony Trew, p. 21. Mandela: The Struggle is My Life (London: Pretoria], 26 August 1994. Overberg, 17 November 2015. 14 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 52. International Defence and Aid Fund for 24 Gert van der Westhuizen, ‘Mandela praat 43 TRC Final Report, volume 2, chapter 1, 15 NM, preamble to the White Paper on Southern Africa, 1978), p. 223. met Afrikaners “Om kommunikasie oop te preface, presented to President Nelson Reconstruction and Development, Government 5 Mac Maharaj, ‘Profile’,Reflections in Prison, hou”’ [Mandela talks to Afrikaners to ‘keep Mandela, 29 October 1998. Gazette, notice no. 1954 of 1994, 23 p. 5. communications open’], Beeld, 29 June 44 Ibid. November 1994. 6 Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma describes how 1995; Kevin O’Grady, ‘Volk Meet Mandela’, 45 NM, opening address in the Special Debate 16 Ibid. ‘After the rendition by the ANC choir with Business Day, 29 June 1995. on the Report of the TRC, Houses of 17 NM, address to Parliament, Houses of Tambo conducting, there was a tumultuous 25 NM, Tydens ’n besoek aan die Afrikaanse Taal Parliament, Cape Town, 25 February 1999. Parliament, Cape Town, May 1994. standing ovation with Zambian President en Kultuur Vereninging (ATKV) [During a 46 Ibid. 18 Trevor Manuel, ‘Twenty Years of Economic Kenneth Kaunda insisting on an encore’, visit to the Afrikaans Language and Cultural 47 Human Sciences Research Council, Public Policymaking – Putting People First’, The in ANC Today, vol. 6, no. 43, Union], 17 August 1995; Beeld, Opinion on National Priority Issues (Pretoria, Oxford Companion to the Economics of South 3 November 2006. 18 August 1995. May 1999), p. 55. Africa, edited by Haroon Bhorat, Alan 7 ‘Mandela: The Man, the Image, the Brand’, 26 NM, Tydens ’n besoek aan die Ruiterwag- 48 NM, opening address in the President’s Hirsch, Ravi Kanbur and Mthuli Ncube City Press, 18 July 2012. Saamtrek vir jong Afrikaner-Leiers [During Budget Debate in the National Assembly, (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014), 8 ‘What Mandela’s Critics Could Learn From a visit to the Ruiterwag rally for young Houses of Parliament, Cape Town, p. 29; Alan Hirsch, Season of Hope, p. 69. Him’, by Obadias Ndaba, Huffington Post, Afrikaner leaders], 13 January 1996; Willem 15 April 1997. 19 NM, interview by the BBC, NMF December 2013. Pretorius, ‘Kies SA óf Afrikaner-Nelson’, tapes, Iqbal Meer Collection, #1, NMF, 9 George Bizos, Odyssey to Freedom, p. 278. Beeld, 15 January 1996. CHAPTER ELEVEN: SOCIAL AND Johannesburg. 10 NM, Long Walk to Freedom, p. 441. 27 NM, opening remarks at a meeting with ECONOMIC TRANSFORMATION 20 Cabinet minutes, 26 October 1994, 11 NM, meeting with the Afrikaner community Afrikaner organisations, 29 March 1996. Transforming the Public Sector: The GNU’s 1 in Pretoria, 15 April 1999. 28 Ibid. The Reconstruction and Development Contribution to the RDP, minute 7.4.2, 12 The , adopted at the 29 Constand Viljoen, interview by Tony Trew, Programme (RDP), ‘Building the Economy’, item 1.3 clause 4.1.1, 1994. 21 Congress of the People, Kliptown, Pretoria, 19 September 2015. Ibid. 2 Johannnesburg, 25–6 June 1955. 30 Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Ibid. 22 NM, preamble to the White Paper on 13 3 Zanele Mbeki in conversation with Mandla 1996, chapter 14, schedule 6: Transitional Layashi Yaker, Preliminary Assessment on Reconstruction and Development, Government Langa, c. 1996. Arrangements, section 20, clause 5. the Performance of the African Economy in Gazette, notice no. 1954 of 1994, 23 14 1994 and Prospects for 1995 – End of Year NM, interview by Oprah Winfrey, The Oprah 31 Peet Kruger, ‘Geheime gesprek lei tot November 1994. Statement, presented to the United Nations 23 Winfrey Show, Harpo Productions, 2000. deurbraak Onderhandelinge oor nuwe grondwet Patti Waldmeir, Anatomy of a Miracle: 15 Economic , Addis NM, address on the Senate President’s op koers’ [Secret talks lead to a breakthrough. The End of Apartheid and the Birth of the New Ababa, 15 December 1994. Budget debate, Houses of Parliament, Cape Negotiations about new constitution on South Africa (New York and London: 4 Town, 1 June 1995. course], Beeld, 20 April 1996; Peet Kruger, Cabinet minutes, 11 May 1994. W. W. Norton and Company, 1997), p. 213. 16 5 NM, closing address in the Senate Debate ‘NP en VF se pogings het saam tot toegewing ANC National Conference, Ready to Govern: 24 NM, election campaign, Lenasia, 19 April on the President’s Budget, 1 June 1995, oor kultuurkommissie gelei’ [NP and VF’s ANC Policy Guidelines for a Democratic South 1999, tape 66772MT, SABC, SABC Hansard, col. 1279. attempts have led to concessions over culture Africa Adopted at the National Conference, Archive, SABC Information Library, 17 AP Archive, ‘South Africa: President commission], 24 April 1996. 28–31 May, 1992 (Johannesburg: Policy Unit Johannesburg. of the ANC, 1992). 25 Mandela Issues Stern Warning to Leaders’, 32 Thabo Mbeki, discussions with Afrikaner Cabinet minutes, 26 October 1994, 6 story no. 23868, 8 March 1996. community, National Assembly, Houses of NM, address at the seventy-fifth anniversary Transforming the Public Sector: The GNU’s 18 Alex Marshall, Republic or Death! Travels Parliament, Cape Town, 24 March 1999. of the South African Communist Party, Contribution to the RDP, minute 7.4.2. 28 July 1996, SABC, SABC Archive, SABC 26 in Search of National Anthems (London: 33 NM, ‘Clear the Obstacles and Confront the Christo Volschenk, ‘Nuwe komitee kom Information Library, Johannesburg. Windmill Books, 2015), pp. 259–60. Enemy’, Reflections in Prison, p. 17. vandeesweek byeen oor mandate vir groeiplan’ DARE NOT LINGER E nDNOTES

[New committee will meet over the mandate 22 July 2016. Pretoria; Wyndham Hartley, ‘“Crackdown” 29 Ibid. on growth], Beeld, 3 August 1995. 46 Francois Lötter, ‘“Wit koerante” ignorer is No Idle Threat’, Natal Witness, 30 NM, address to the closing session of the 27 Cabinet minutes, 6 December 1995, Towa rds misdaadstatistieke – president’ [“White 3 March 1995. Fiftieth National Conference of the ANC, a National Growth and Development newspapers” ignoring the crime statistics – 13 Pamela Dube, ‘It Takes Two to Tango and 20 December 1997, Mafikeng. Strategy, 7.1. president], Beeld, 14 September 1998. Government is Learning the Communication 31 The Sowetan, 20 November 1996; Financial 28 Sagie Narsiah, ‘Neoliberalism and 47 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 62. Steps’, Sunday Independent, 8 July 2001. Mail, 22 November 1996. Privatisation in South Africa’, GeoJournal, 48 NM, opening the Morals Summit called by 14 Thami Mazwai, interview by Tony Trew, 32 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, p. 33. vol. 57, no. 1, May 2002, p. 3. the National Religious Leaders Forum, Johannesburg, 7 October 2015. 29 ANC, Fiftieth National Conference: 23 October 1998. 15 NM, note on an off-the-record conversation CHAPTER THIRTEEN: ON THE Resolutions, Economic Transformation, 49 Ibid. with the editor of Die Burger, NMPP 2009/8, AFRICAN AND WORLD STAGES Mafikeng, December 16–20 1997, clause 50 Allister Sparks, Beyond the Miracle, p. 16. box 4, folder 1, pp. 1–2, NMF, Johannesburg. 1 3.2.2. 51 NM, addressing the fifth national congress 16 Mandla Langa in conversation with Khulu Harriet Beecher Stowe, Uncle Tom’s 30 NM, Southern Africa Into the Next Century, of COSATU, 7 September 1994, SABC, Sibiya, June 2017. Cabin (Washington, DC, 1852); Booker Sixteenth Singapore Lecture, 6 March SABC Archive, SABC Information Library, 17 Jakes Gerwel, ‘The Day Mandela Was in T. Washington, Up from Slavery: An 1997, Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Johannesburg. Hustler’, Rapport, 9 June 2012. Autobiography (New York: Doubleday and Singapore, 1997. 52 NM, State of the Nation Address, National 18 NM, speech at the launch of the Canadian Company, 1901). 2 31 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 47–9. Assembly, Cape Town, 5 February 1999. Friends of the Nelson Mandela Children’s OAU Assembly of Heads of State and 32 Richard Calland (editor), The First Five 53 Ibid. Fund, SkyDome, Toronto, 25 September Government, Declaration on the Political Years: A Review of South Africa’s Democratic 54 NM, speech at the final sitting of the first 1998. and Socio-economic Situation in Africa and Parliament (Cape Town: IDASA, 1999). democratically elected parliament, Houses of 19 NM, address to the International Press the Fundamental Changes Taking Place in 33 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 52–3. Parliament, Cape Town, 26 March 1999. Institute Congress, Cape Town, the World, 9–11 July 1990, Addis Ababa. 3 34 NM, ‘The Presidential Years’, pp. 50–1. 14 February 1994. OAU, Assembly of Heads of State 35 South Africa in Transition, Findings Regarding CHAPTER TWELVE: NEGOTIATING 20 Khaba Mkhize, ‘Breakfast with Nelson and Government, Declaration on the Households, figure 6.1: ‘Changes in type of THE MEDIA Mandela’, Natal Witness, 19 August 1994; Establishment Within the OAU of a housing in which households live between Ray Hartley, ‘ANC Broadsides Against Mechanism for Conflict Prevention, 1 October 1995 and October 1999’ (Pretoria: Cameron J, Holomisa v. Argus Newspapers Press’, Sunday Times, 4 September 1994; Management and Resolution, Statistics South Africa, 2001). Ltd. 1996 (2) S.A. 588 (W). Thami Mazwai, interview by Tony Trew, 28–30 June 1993. 2 4 36 Jessie Duarte, interview by Tony Trew, NM, NMPP 2009/8, box 1, notebook 5, Johannesburg, 7 October 2015. NM, statement at the OAU meeting of Johannesburg, 15 July 2014. p. 17, NMF, Johannesburg. 21 The television interview is referenced in heads of state and government, Tunis, 3 37 Mandla Langa in conversation with Stephen Thami Mazwai, interview by Tony Trew, ‘Some Black Newsmen Rapped for Secret 13 June 1994. 5 Laufer, Johannesburg, 16 July 2016. Johannesburg, 7 October 2015. Agenda’, Business Day, 3 November 1996. Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, interview by 4 38 John Carlin, ‘ANC Boards the Gravy André Odendaal, The Founders: The Origins 22 Guy Berger, ‘Media and Racism in Tony Trew, Durban, 26 February 2016. 6 Train: John Carlin in Johannesburg on the of the African National Congress and the Mandela’s Rainbow Nation’, Prime Time NM, statement as chairperson of SADC at Underdogs Who Have Become Fat Cats in a Struggle for Democracy (Johannesburg: Jacana for Tolerance: Journalism and the Challenge the official opening of the summit of SADC Few Months’, Independent, 27 August 1994. Media, 2012), p. 147. of Racism: International Federation of heads of state and government, Blantyre, 5 39 NM, address on the anniversary of the NM, Long Walk to Freedom, p. 208. Journalists World Conference, Bilbao, Spain, 8 September 1997. 6 7 , 16 June 1994. Ibid, p. 316. 2–4 May 1997. Ibid. 7 8 40 NM, speech at the official opening of The Anthony Sampson, Mandela: The Authorised 23 NM television interview, 11 November SADC Heads of State and Government, Mandela Rhodes Foundation’s offices, Biography (London: HarperCollins, 1999), 1996, SABC, SABC Archive, SABC Summit, Gaborone, 28 June 1996. 9 Oxford, 13 April 2000, NMF Tapes, Iqbal p. 147. Information Library, Johannesburg; ‘Some NM, SADC Organ, 7 September 1997, 8 Meer Collection, Oxford 1 and 2, NMF, NM, Long Walk to Freedom, p. 492 and Black Newsmen Rapped for Secret Agenda’, NMPP notes, box 5, file 3, 074–86, NMF, Johannesburg. p. 502. Business Day, 3 November 1996; ‘Mandela Johannesburg. 9 10 41 NM, address at AIDS conference, Barcelona, NM, briefing editors and opinion makers, Slams Some Black Journalists’, Citizen, NM, notes on SADC summit in Maputo, 12 July 2002, NMF Tapes, Iqbal Meer Pretoria, 10 May 1999, NMF Tapes, BBC, 13 November 1996. 2 March1998, NMPP notes, box 4, file 2, Collection #8, NMF, Johannesburg. NMF, Johannesburg. 24 NM, note, NMPP 2009/8, box 4, file 1, 055–60, NMF, Johannesburg. 10 11 42 NM, briefing editors, 9 May 1999, NMF NM, address to the International Press 128–9. Quett Ketumile Joni Masire, Very Brave or Tapes, BBC collection, NMF, Johannesburg. Institute Congress, Cape Town, 25 NM, speech to the Fiftieth National Very Foolish?: Memoirs of an African Democrat 43 President Mbeki used the phrase in a funeral 14 February 1994. Conference of the ANC, Mafikeng, (: Macmillan Botswana, 2006), 11 oration for the late Alfred Nzo, Rehana Rossouw, ‘Everyone Wants a Piece of 16 December 1997. p.279. 12 22 January 2000. the President’, Mail & Guardian, 26 NM, note, NMPP 2009/8, box 4, p. 4, NMF, Deputy President Thabo Mbeki, statement to 44 NM, State of the Nation Address, National 15 March 1996. Johannesburg. the National Assembly on the situation in the 12 Assembly, Houses of Parliament, Cape NM, notes for a meeting with editors of 27 NM, note on response to the political report Democratic Republic of the Congo, Houses Town, 5 February 1999. KwaZulu-Natal newspapers, Cape Town, to the Fiftieth ANC Congress, December of Parliament, Cape Town, 21 May 1997. 13 45 Anne Kriegler and Mark Shaw, ‘Facts Show 2 March 1995, South Africa National 1997, NMPP 2009/8, box 4, folder 1, pp. Ibid; Aziz Pahad, interview by Tony Trew, South Africa Has Not Become More Violent Archive, Nelson Mandela Communication/ 1–2, NMF, Johannesburg. Johannesburg, 1 February 2016. 14 Since Democracy’, The Conversation, Speeches: March, April, May 1995, NASA, 28 Ibid. NM, notes following a meeting with DARE NOT LINGER

Comrade Kabila, Genadendal, 15 May 1997, 33 Ibid. NMPP 2009/8, box4, file2, pp.1–4, NMF, 34 Lyn Boyd-Judson, Strategic Moral Diplomacy: Acknowledgements Johannesburg. Understanding the Enemy’s Moral Universe 15 Acting President Buthelezi, Developments (West Hartford, CT: Kumarian Press, 2011); in , Statements to the National Khalil I. Matar, Robert W. Thabit, Lockerbie Assembly, 22 September 1998, Hansard, and Libya. cols. 6763–6778. 35 Lyn Boyd-Judson, Strategic Moral Diplomacy. 16 Cabinet minutes, 23 September 1998. 36 NM, address to the Congress of the People, In 1971 Nelson Mandela wrote a letter from Robben Island to his old friend Fatima 17 AP Archive, ‘South Africa: President Libya, 19 March 1999. Meer, in which he expressed doubt about memoirs – ‘What a sweet euphemism 37 Mandela Calms Concern Over his Health’, Jakes Gerwel, interview by Aziz Pahad, for self-praise the English language has evolved! Autobiography.’ And yet just four 27 September 1998, story no. 89970. 21 July 2010. 18 NM, State of the Nation Address, National 38 NM, statement on South Africa’s relations years later he had embarked on the first draft of what was to become his bestselling Assembly, Houses of Parliament, Cape with the Greater Chinese Region, 27 memoir Long Walk to Freedom. Town, 5 February 1999. November 1996, SABC, SABC TV Archive, 19 NM at the Southern tape 25459MT, SABC Information Library, As Mum Graça Machel indicates in the prologue to this book, the contingencies of Africa Economic Summit, Harare, 21 Johannesburg. time and struggle informed his decisions to write both LongWalk and the early sections May 1997, tape 71942MT, SABC, SABC 39 ‘Taiwan’s Minister Fails with Mandela’, Archive, SABC Information Library, United Press International Archive, of what has become this volume. The same contingencies ensured lengthy gestation Johannesburg. 4 December 1996. periods for both books – each book took almost twenty years to get published. 20 NM, address to the Mercosur Heads of State 40 NM, address at Beijing University, Beijing, Summit, Ushuaia, , 24 July 1998. 6 May 1999. Given the length of its gestation and the complexity of its provenance, Dare Not 21 NM, address at the Forty-ninth Session of 41 NM, interview by Phil Molefe and Antjie the General Assembly of the UN, New York, Krog, ‘Farewell Interview With the SABC’, Linger demands multiple acknowledgements. Mum Machel’s determination to see 10 October 1994. broadcast live from Qunu, SABC, it through, and her constant presence through the process, inspired us. Mandla 22 Ibid. 20 May 1999. Langa was almost too good to be true as a writer willing to work with a demanding 23 NM, address at the inaugural session of the Twelfth Conference of Heads of State or EPILOGUE collective. Joel Netshitenzhe and Tony Trew provided extraordinary research and Government of Non-Aligned Countries, analysis capacity, as well as generating the first narrativisation, drawing on both 1 Graça Machel, interview by Mandla Langa, Durban, 2 September 1998. Mr Mandela’s writing and the contents of ‘the archive’. Tony was tireless in trawling 24 Ibid. 22 September 2016. 2 25 NM, address to the Joint Houses of Congress NM to Winnie Mandela in Kroonstad multiple archival repositories. In this he was ably assisted by Janet Levy and the Nelson of the USA, Washington, DC, 6 October Prison, 1 February 1975. 3 Mandela Foundation archives team – Razia Saleh, Zanele Riba, Lucia Raadschelders 1994. Zelda la Grange, Good Morning Mr Mandela: and Sahm Venter. As always, Sahm, the team’s senior researcher, provided authority 26 NM, address to the Swedish Parliament, A Memoir (New York: Plume, 2015), p. 128. 4 Stockholm, 18 March 1999. While being interviewed by a panel, this of first and last resort on our founder’s life and times. Our chief executive, Sello 27 was Mandela’s answer to a question by ‘Mandela praises Gaddafi’,Sunday Times Hatang, was the glue holding the whole process together – he both opened doors and Foreign Desk, 20 May 1990; Fritz Joubert Phil Molefe who asks about his feelings ‘Mense in VSA vies vir Mandela’ [People in as he prepares to step down as president held them open. The support given to us by the executors of Mr Mandela’s estate was the USA are angry with Mandela], Beeld, of the ANC. NM, televised interview on indispensable. Special thanks are due to Judge Dikgang Moseneke. 24 May 1990. Face the Media, 14 December 1997, SABC, 28 Khalil I. Matar and Robert W. Thabit, tape 66676MT, SABC Archive, SABC In the early phases of the project, as Mr Mandela toiled with pen in hand, Zelda Lockerbie and Libya: A study in International Information Library, Johannesburg. 5 la Grange was the dynamo maintaining its momentum. She was supported Relations (London: McFarland & Company, NM, closing the ANC’s Fiftieth National Inc, 2004). Conference, Mafikeng, 20 December 1997. devotedly by Vimla Naidoo and Maretha Slabbert. Zelda also became critical to its 6 29 NM, Statement on Lockerbie drafted and NM, election campaign, 31 May 1999, tape being revived under the auspices of the Nelson Mandela Foundation after Madiba’s 66717MT, SABC, SABC Archive, SABC released in Tunis, NMPP 2009/8, box 6, file passing, and remained available for queries of all kinds until the end. Also playing a 8a, NMF, Johannesburg. Information Library, Johannesburg. 7 30 ‘SA Calls for Lifting of Sanctions on Libya’, NM, speech at the final sitting of the first role in the early phases was research assistant Thembeka Mafumadi. The Star, 22 October 1997. democratically elected parliament, Houses of 31 OAU, Declarations and Decisions adopted by Parliament, Cape Town, 26 March 1999. Our publishing partners have been a joy to work with. Special thanks to Geoff the Thirty-Third OAU Assembly of Heads of Blackwell, Rachel Clare, Kate Cooper, Jonny Geller, Cameron Gibb, Benjamin State and Government, Harare, Harris, Sloan Harris, Ruth Hobday, Jenny Moore, Georgina Morley, Terry Morris 2–4 June 1997. 32 NM visits Libya, October 1997, tape 66786, and Andrea Nattrass. Among other things, Andrea provided deep understanding of MT22, SABC, SABC TV Archive, SABC Mandla’s writing processes. Information Library, Johannesburg.

341