SWISS REVIEW The magazine for the Swiss Abroad February 2021

How long since Switzerland’s women got the vote? 100, 75 or just 50 years? Rainforest man Bruno Manser – a momentous life portrayed on the big screen Cooking up a storm – how Betty Bossi became a fixture in Swiss kitchens

The publisher of “Swiss Review” is the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad RENDEZ-VOUS MIT DER SCHWEIZ Pünktlich um 5!

Die App für Schweizerinnen und Schweizer im Ausland

SWIplus_Inserat_halbmattgestr_194x63.5_DE_def_2.indd 1 17.12.20 15:33 Consular services anywhere, conveniently on your mobile devices

BACK TO OUR ROOTS WITH TISSOT, “INNOVATORS BY TRADITION”. www.fdfa.admin.ch Santo Domingo (2020) The Tissot story began in Le Locle, Switzerland, in 1853. Today, Tissot is the leading traditional Swiss watchmaker by volume. The brand is proud of its roots and has positioned itself as an ambassador abroad, representing values it holds dear, like tradition and innovation. Throughout its history, Tissot has put this dual stamp on all its products. By registering on the SwissCommunity network, Tissot thanks you, dear Swiss Abroad, ambassadors of our country all over the world, by offering you a 15% discount on the entire collection on its official website.

www.swisscommunity.org/tissot - Official website | Tissot (tissotwatches.com)

© Marina Kopp

The Organisation of the Swiss Abroad reinvents itself • new website Visit our new website • new online community www.SwissCommunity.org and • new online presence join our new community to forge for «Swiss Review» strong and lasting links with other • new design Swiss people from all over the world. • all-in-one

Our partners:

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 Contents Editorial 3

Delayed democracy

4 Focus The belated advent of women’s Hanna Sahlfeld-Singer is a Swiss Abroad. The 77-year- suffrage 50 years ago old, who lives in Germany, says she takes part in every federal vote – honouring time and again the legacy 8 Images that she herself helped to create. Sahlfeld-Singer is one Caran d’Ache – from small pencil of the many women who campaigned tirelessly for factory to global brand women’s suffrage in Switzerland. She was also one of the first handful of women ever to be elected to the 10 Report National Council 50 years ago. The cover of this edi- Mitholz – mountain village and tion of “Swiss Review” captures Sahlfeld-Singer’s big moment in 1971, when ticking time bomb she swore an oath to the constitution under the mighty dome of the Federal Palace. A telling anecdote: the freshly elected member of parliament had dif- 13 Literature ficulty getting to the ceremony in the first place, as she was initially told to How Germaine de Staël infuriated use the visitors’ entrance. Napoleon Bonaparte Everyone else got there before us, be it Australia (women’s suffrage since 1902), Azerbaijan (1918), Albania (1920), the Central African Republic (1946), 14 Society or Cyprus (1960). Why did Switzerland of all countries – one of the world’s oldest democracies – insist on excluding half of its population, i.e. women, Betty Bossi – the cook who is found from political life for so long? Both world wars triggered natural social up- in every Swiss kitchen heaval in other countries. However, men in Switzerland long continued to News from your region believe that giving women the right to vote was reckless, unnecessary and even went against the natural order. The male half of the country simply re- 17 Politics fused to budge, suggests the historian quoted in this edition’s Focus article. The Responsible Business Initiative – On another important but completely different topic, the second wave of popular but unsuccessful the Covid-19 pandemic has hit Switzerland hard. People normally get to- gether during the festive season. Not in 2020. Tens of thousands of Swiss A controversial alternative to the Abroad were unable to visit friends, family and old haunts in their country password jungle of origin over Christmas. The only way to catch up was by video call, as we 20 Profile were once again reminded that the wonders of technology are no substitute for a roomful of actual human beings. MARC LETTAU, EDITOR-IN-CHIEF On the big screen – Bruno Manser’s rainforest crusade

22 Covid-19 pandemic PS: The online version of “Swiss Review” has been repackaged and is now available via the Second wave hits Switzerland hard swisscommunity.org information platform. From now on, the revamped swisscommunity.org website will also house all other content produced by our publisher, the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad. 24 SwissCommunity Furthermore, the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad itself will appear increasingly under the The big verdict – results of the “SwissCommunity” label in future. “Swiss Review” reader survey

29 Mailbag 31 News

Cover photo: The swearing-in of National Councillor “Swiss Review”, the information magazine Hanna Sahlfeld-Singer before the Federal Assembly for the “Fifth Switzerland”, is published by the on 13 December 1971. Photo: Keystone Organisation of the Swiss Abroad.

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 4 Focus

It was no accident that women’s suffrage came late to Switzerland

It was only 50 years ago in 1971 that Swiss women gained the right to vote and stand for election – after a century of campaigning. Hanna Sahlfeld-Singer was one of the first women elected to the federal par- liament. “It was a marathon, not a sprint,” recalls the former National Councillor, who now lives abroad.

SUSANNE WENGER band’s home country, Germany. When she was elected to The exact date on which Swiss women became fully fledged the National Council, Sahlfeld-Singer, a qualified theolo- citizens of their own country was 7 February 1971. It was on gian, was 28 and the mother of a one-year-old child. “My this day that a momentous referendum saw the female pop- first day in parliament was exciting,” says the now 77-year- ulation gain the right to vote and stand for election at the old. On entering the Federal Palace for the first time, she federal level. was told to use the visitors’ entrance. She can laugh about In other words, women could now participate in elec- it now. However, the anecdote shows how much opposition tions and popular votes, run for parliament, and sign she had to overcome. ­petitions for referendums and popular initiatives. Notably, She was a woman pastor with the Reformed Church men decided that this could happen, because they alone who wanted to make a difference in politics. On top of that, had exercised full political rights until then. Women had she was a working mother married to a foreigner. “This been denied the right to vote and stand for election ever was too much for many people.” In 1970, Sahlfeld-Singer since the creation of the federal Swiss state in 1848. made speeches on Swiss National Day calling for women’s In 1959, most of Switzerland’s men wanted to keep pol- suffrage. They caused quite a stir. Criticism rained down, itics exclusively male, with almost 70 per cent voting but not necessarily on her. “People knew that I would not against women’s suffrage at the federal level. But the flood- be swayed.” Her husband, himself a church minister, was gates opened twelve years later. “We are not asking you, we on the receiving end instead. But her spouse always sup- are telling you!” announced Emilie Lieberherr at a large ported her. rally on Berne’s Bundesplatz (Lieberherr would later be- come a member of the Council of States for the canton of Forced to give up her church duties Zurich). Two thirds of Swiss men obliged by voting yes. The first-ever national elections with female participation took Hanna and Rolf Sahlfeld wanted to share parenting and place as early as autumn 1971. Eleven female National work responsibilities – an approach that broke the mould. Councillors and one female member of the Council of However, Sahlfeld-Singer, who came from a working-class States were “honourably elected”, said the weekly news- family, had to give up her church position in order to take reel. up her role as National Councillor. That was what the law said – a relic from cultural struggles between church and The story of a pioneer state. She says it was a ruling aimed at Catholic priests. “For a hundred years, no one thought it would be of rele- Two of these female pioneers are still alive: Gabrielle vance to a young lady like me.” To ensure that she could Nanchen from Valais and Hanna Sahlfeld-Singer from the work in Berne, Sahlfeld-Singer played the pastor’s wife in- canton of St. Gallen – both from the Swiss Social Democratic stead – a role that is traditionally unpaid. As National Party (SP). Hanna Sahlfeld-Singer now lives in her hus- Councillor, Sahlfeld-Singer fought for such issues as bet-

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 5

ter social security for women and reducing the speed limit give women the vote. In her 2020 book “Jeder Frau ihre Hanna Sahlfeld-Singer on roads. Stimme”, historian Caroline Arni argues that women in on her first day in the National Council – Sahlfeld-Singer had an indirect impact outside the Switzerland were deliberately deprived of political rights, with SP member of the chamber simply by virtue of the fact that women were now and that this status quo was reinforced time and again. Council of States entering parliament. She had her second child in 1972 – the “This was no accident,” she writes. Matthias Eggenberger first-ever National Councillor to give birth while in office. Political scientist Werner Seitz believes that Switzer- (lighting up) and SP National Councillor The press covered the story, mentioning that her children land’s “male chauvinist culture” had a part to play, influ- Rolf Weber in attend- were not Swiss citizens on account of their foreign father. enced by the old myths and legends surrounding the na- ance. Sahlfeld-Singer herself had had to apply to remain Swiss tion’s founding fathers. An entrenched idea of gender roles Archive photo: Keystone, 1971 when she was married. This discrimination against women riddled all social classes too – as lawyer Emilie Kempin- affected many binational families. The ruling was abol- Spyri found out to her dismay back in 1887 when she was ished in 1978. “After that, many Swiss women living abroad could also make their children Swiss citizens,” she says.

“Both novel and audacious”

Switzerland, Portugal and Liechtenstein were the last Eu- Half a century later – ropean countries to give women political rights. Germany a round of applause introduced women’s suffrage in 1918, France in 1944 – to- for Hanna Sahlfeld- wards the end of a world war in both cases. Switzerland, Singer in the National Council chamber spared the convulsions of war, imposed the referendum during a special event hurdle instead. Yet this does not completely explain why devoted to women. it took so long for one of the world’s oldest democracies to Archive photo: Keystone, 2019

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 6 ­

Women with a foot in the The striking motif of a carpet beater. A campaign poster from political door the 1947 Zurich referendum on women’s suffrage. Photo: Keystone It is 50 years since women in Switzerland were first entitled to vote and stand for election. Female political participation is growing, but a little more effort is necessary to ensure a proper gender balance.

Argument from the Yes camp – “A free people need free women” EVA HIRSCHI (1946) Some 84 women were elected to the National Council in Zurich Museum of Design, poster collection 2019 – 20 more than in 2015. This is the biggest increase since the introduction of women’s suffrage in 1971. At 42 per cent, female representation in the National Council has never been as high. In the Council of States, where the fe- unable to work as a judge because she lacked full civil male contingent had been dwindling over the previous 12 rights. Kempin-Spyri took her case to the Federal Supreme years, the proportion of women climbed to a record 26 per Court – and lost. She argued that the constitution’s provi- cent. “This sends a strong message and was well overdue,” sions on suffrage also pertained to women. The presiding says Kathrin Bertschy, Green Liberal National Councillor judges called this reasoning “both novel and audacious”. for the canton of Berne. “It reflects a new zeitgeist, of which the women’s strike was symptomatic.” Bertschy is co-chair A personal price to pay of alliance f, a cross-party umbrella organisation of wom- en’s associations that are campaigning for better gender bal- At the turn of the 20th century, more and more women – ance in parliament. Alliance f is behind the “Helvetia ruft” and men – began campaigning for women’s suffrage. The campaign, which aims to help more women get into poli- government in Berne was slow to act, while certain can- tics. tons took matters into their own hands. Social change at “Not only have we urged political parties and those re- the end of the 1960s finally brought the matter to a head at sponsible for nominating candidates to put women on party the federal level. In 1990, Appenzell Innerrhoden became lists where they have good chances, but we have also organ- the last canton to introduce women’s suffrage, on the or- ised workshops and mentoring programmes for female can- der of the Federal Supreme Court. didates,” explains Flavia Kleiner, co-initiator of “Helvetia “Again, it was a marathon, not a sprint,” says Sahlfeld- ruft”. “It is not about achieving fairness, it is about accu- Singer, who was emphatically re-elected in 1975 but later rately reflecting Switzerland’s demographics. Women ac- resigned. Sahlfeld-Singer’s husband was no longer able to count for half of our population after all.” find work in eastern Switzerland because of his wife’s po- litical career. The family left Switzerland and made a new Catching up on 170 years start near Cologne. Sahlfeld-Singer is one of the women who blazed a trail for future generations of female politi- But why has it taken 50 years for parliament to suddenly cians in Berne. Commemorative plaques today adorn their become noticeably more female? “Men have had a 170-year old seats in parliament. “Our fight was worth it,” she con- head start, while women have been trying to play catch-up,” cludes, even if she and her husband paid their own per- says Kleiner. “So we need a little time.” Swiss politics has sonal price. People now take equality for granted in many been a man’s world until now, says Bertschy: “When they areas of life, she adds. “But women must hang on to what gave women the right to vote, they forgot to ensure that we they have achieved, otherwise they may lose it again.” were adequately represented to the same extent as the can- tons and the language regions are in the National Council. More information on 50 years of women’s suffrage in Switzerland: But the Confederation does love dealing in quotas – I tick www.ch2021.ch one of their boxes as a woman from Berne.”

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 7 ­

However, not only have women been poorly represented in faced each other in an election run-off for the Aargau can- parliament for a long time, but there has traditionally been tonal government in 2019, Sigg voted for the male candi- a dearth of female candidates. Flavia Kleiner believes that date. “The SVP were entitled to the seat, plus I think Gallati societal constraints are the main factor hindering female was better suited for the job. Voting along party or gender involvement. “It is not easy to reconcile a political career lines – which is more important? Party lines in my view. But with family life. Meetings and events often take place in the I would naturally have been very happy if the SVP had nom- evening or at weekends. In addition, Swiss political culture inated an able female candidate.” is still male-dominated with its attendant rough and tum- Flavia Kleiner says ble. And then we have the media, who are less forgiving to- Non-party politics that women are play- ing catch-up: wards women.” “Men have had a 170- With political office therefore less of a draw for women, Standing for election is one thing, voting is another. Swiss year head start.” more of an effort is needed to convince would-be candi- women have tended to be slightly reluctant voters. Accord- dates to put themselves forward, says Sarah Bütikofer, a po- ing to the Swiss Election Study (Selects), there was a 49 per litical scientist who is conducting a study on female politi- cent turnout among male voters in the 2019 federal elec- cal participation. Bütikofer believes that political parties tions. Female voter turnout was only 41 per cent. are best placed to act: “Switzerland’s political parties are Could it be that woman are turned off by the institu- organised along cantonal lines. They have the power to put tionalised nature of politics? After all, the 2019 woman’s women’s names forward on promising party lists.” strike, which saw hundreds of thousands of female protest- Anyone who wants to be elected to the National Coun- ers take to the streets, showed that women are more than cil or the Council of States normally needs experience at willing to speak up when they want. Lisa Gafner: “I took cantonal level. Very few people are catapulted directly into part in the women’s strike myself. For the past two years, I the federal parliament. “It is in the national arena where a have also been involved in the EKdM [Eidgenössische Kom- party’s political leaders are active,” says Bütikofer. “Hence, mission dini Mueter] – a pressure group that we set up af- women must be given opportunities at cantonal and mu- ter the women’s strike to get a better deal for working moth- Katrin Bertschy on nicipal level, so that we have a conveyor belt of female pol- ers.” the increasing pro- portion of women in iticians who are ready for higher office.” Gafner, 38, has consciously decided not to join any po- parliament: “This litical party. “I have no wish to get drawn into petty infight- sends a strong mes- Too cautious? Or less confident? ing, personality cults, or toeing the party line. The issues sage and was well are what matter to me.” Gafner’s pressure group is lobby- overdue.” Yet, it is precisely at cantonal level where Switzerland is still ing on these issues. “What the EKdM is doing is one thing. a long way from achieving gender equality. In 2019, women But run for a political office? Never. A structured environ- accounted for 25 to 29 per cent of politicians in the cantonal ment like that has no appeal. And it would be too hard to parliaments. Basel-Stadt managed to increase the propor- reconcile work and family life.” tion of females in its cantonal parliament to 42 per cent at National Councillor Kathrin Bertschy is in favour of al- the end of October 2020. But meanwhile Aargau again ternative forms of political participation. Nevertheless, she elected a cantonal government comprised exclusively of adds: “It is important that women are represented in par- men. The proportion of women in Aargau’s cantonal par- liament instead of just leaving the decisions to men. Be- liament even fell. cause parliament is where women can bring about the most For Martina Sigg, leader of the FDP women’s group in change by improving the legislation and parameters that Aargau, this is an unsatisfactory state of affairs. “We are ac- matter.” Sarah Bütikofer: tually finding it quite hard to recruit women in some dis- “The political parties have the power to tricts of Aargau,” she says. “Women are a lot more cautious put women’s names and less sure of their political abilities. We often have to forward.” make the first contact and persuade them ourselves. They rarely come to us.” Which is why Sigg believes campaigns like “Helvetia ruft” are important. However, when Jean- Pierre Gallati from the SVP and Yvonne Feri from the SP EVA HIRSCHI IS A FREELANCE JOURNALIST BASED IN LAUSANNE.

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 8 Images

From small pencil factory to global brand

“Hopefully every Swiss living abroad will soon be using Swiss Caran d’Ache pencils to support the economy back home,” wrote the “Correspondenzblatt für die Schweizer und Schweiz- ervereine im Auslande” in 1925. Geneva-based pencil manu- facturer Caran d’Ache – still a fledgling company in those days – had just opened a shop in Berlin. This was the beginning of a success story that saw Swiss writing and colouring products become a global hit. Freelance author Ralph Brühwiler tells the story of Caran d’Ache in a new, lavishly illustrated book. His evocatively written chronicle contains a wealth of facts and details. Company founder Arnold Schweitzer, an industri- alist from eastern Switzerland, features prominently – Brüh- wiler describing him as a kindly businessman who experienced his fair share of setbacks. The author also explains why the company name transliterates the Russian for pencil, how the company’s laboratories and workshops became a conveyor belt for new products, and why Caran d’Ache pencils are just as popular among Swiss school children as they are among famous artists. Caran d’Ache is a global brand these days, and is still owned by three Swiss families. SUSANNE WENGER

“Die Caran d’Ache Saga. Von Genf in die Welt.” The Neocolor wax pastel crayon was brought to market in 1952. (The Caran d’Ache Saga – the story of a global Genevan brand) NZZ Libro 2020 (in German), 264 pages; CHF 49 Artist Pablo Picasso soon began using it for his sketches. (CdA company archive)

“A contemporary writing fashion statement” – the ballpoint pen that Caran d’Ache developed the Prismalo watercolour colouring pencil in the 1930s. came to be known as 849 from the 1960s onwards. (CdA company archive) The cases containing multicoloured rows of pencils were popular among generations of Swiss children. (RB)

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 9

Pencil rocket – Caran d’Ache went on an advertising offensive at the end of 1920s. (CdA company archive)

The iconic Caran d’Ache pencil-sharpening machine was a common feature in Swiss school classrooms during the post-war years. (CdA company archive)

Caran d’Ache patented the Fixpencil in 1930. This new form of mechanical The Ecridor – millions of these luxurious hexagonal pens were sold from 1953. (CdA pencil was particularly popular among technical illustrators. (CdA company archive) company archive)

Photos taken from “Die Caran d’Ache-Saga”, Brühwiler. 2020 © NZZ Libro, Schwabe Verlagsgruppe AG, Basel

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 10 Report

The most explosive place in Switzerland

For over 70 years, Mitholz in the Bernese Oberland has been home to a mountain bunker containing thousands of tonnes of live ammunition dating back to the Second World War. Now the bombshell: the armoury needs to be cleared and the village residents evacuated. Will Mitholz become a ghost town?

JÜRG STEINER The villagers returned to their houses the underground facility. A new re- The chalet-style houses bask serenely just one year later, although the cause port in summer 2018 said that the risk in the winter sun that illuminates a of the explosions remains unclear to to roads, housing, rail infrastructure, narrow valley floor flanked by steep this day, as journalist Hans Rudolf and, by extension, to people was now mountains on both sides. Mitholz, a Schneider explains in his book “Die “unacceptable”. Mitholz suddenly be- village with 200 inhabitants, is situ- Swiss Schreckensnacht von Mitholz” (Hor- came Switzerland’s most explosive ated on a level stretch of the Kander e tremes ror in Mitholz). Despite this, the au- village. Valley. It has one remaining restau- thorities announced in the 1940s that According to the Kandergrund rant, but its last local shop closed for the damaged depot, in which around mayor, Roman Lanz, the village was good a long time ago. Higher, further, faster, half of the original 7,000 tonnes of plunged into a state of paralysis after Winding their way through more beautiful? munitions still lie buried, no longer hearing the news in June 2018. It took Mitholz are the railway line and the In search of the some- presented a danger to the local popu- another one and a half years for Fed- road leading to the Lötschberg tunnel what different Swiss lation. eral Councillor Viola Amherd to an- records. This edition: car train that takes passengers to Val- A visit to the most This view changed when army nounce that the only way to nullify ais. This Alpine village is no stranger explosive place in commanders began toying with the the danger was to clear the ammuni- to natural perils such as rockslides, Switzerland. idea of building a secret data centre in tion. She said it would be a highly landslides, floods and avalanches. “We are used to natural hazards,” says Ro- man Lanz, mayor of the Kandergrund municipality that encompasses Mitholz. “We have never seen them as a reason to move away.” But is Mitholz too dangerous for its residents? This question suddenly arose two years ago. And the matter was deadly serious. The reason is that located deep in the cliffs overlooking the village thousands of tonnes of live munitions – including 50-kilo aircraft bombs – remain in a partially col- lapsed Second World War weapons depot. Tragedy hit Mitholz in 1947, when three violent explosions occurred in the depot one night just before Christ- mas, not long after the underground facility had been built. Debris rained from the sky, as munitions, mountain rocks and pressurised air blasted out Debris in the village of the entrances to the depot, destroy- after the 1947 explo- sions – nine people ing much of the village. Nine people died and many houses died in one of the biggest accidents in were destroyed. Swiss army history. Archive photo: Keystone, 1947

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 11

complex operation involving robots livelihoods are on the line. Lanz Samuel Künzi’s farm that the government will decide not – the first operation of its kind any- stands in front of the reinforced is situated on a rocky to spend so much money after all and ledge. Thousands of where in the world. However, this northern entrance to the depot, tonnes of old ord- everything will remain the same. will increase the detonation risk to where ammunition and explosives nance are buried in Emotions are one thing, money is such an extent that the 170 inhabit- used to be transported into the the rocks below. another. What about compensation? ants will have to be evacuated from depths of the cliff by rail. Just a Photo: Danielle Liniger What will the value be of houses that their village for around ten years, stone’s throw away is a farmhouse. It are likely to be left to the army during starting in 2031. The whole exercise belongs to the Künzi family, who the evacuation period, then possibly will cost one billion Swiss francs. rear cattle on the slopes surrounding “Mitholz, the ghost town.” The the depot. For decades, they have news came like a bombshell. Lanz, been farming land that is now sup- who works as a manager at a car body posed to be in the danger zone. You repair business, was suddenly giving cannot just decamp from one place interviews to foreign television sta- to another with cows. The Künzis tions and attending meetings with will have to build a completely new federal councillors in his capacity as life somewhere else. mayor. Mitholz was on everyone’s Lanz is in touch with locals like lips. “But the people I talk to here in the Künzis practically every day. the village still find it hard to grasp,” “Few people from outside the village The news was “hard says Lanz. “It’s almost surreal to will appreciate what the past two to grasp” and “al- them.” Mitholz residents live just as years have been like for us since they most surreal” for many people in the near to the depot as they did before. announced the news.” He explains village, says mayor But now these people have an un- that reality has been slow to dawn Roman Lanz. certain future ahead of them. Their on some residents, who still hope Photo: Danielle Liniger

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 12

returned to their former owners after standing empty for years? And, of course, the elephant in the room: why is so much dangerous am- munition stored near a village where people live? “Connected by railway, the Mitholz munitions store was in an ideal location for implementing Swit- zerland’s redoubt strategy in the Sec- ond World War,” says historian and former professor at the Military Acad- emy at ETH Zurich, Rudolf Jaun. In summer 1940, General Henri Guisan decided to move most of his troops back into the Alpine interior. This was where the main front would be after delaying actions to keep any invading force out of the Central Plateau were The Mitholz depot World War to protect the population, their part of the country, people exhausted. Munitions were stockpiled has an inconspicuous ironically became a ticking time bomb. would be on the street every day. entrance but has in a number of secret armouries in- been a ticking time Before we criticise, we need to re- “The view among most residents is cluding Mitholz. It was from Mitholz bomb for decades. alise that people viewed the armed that we cannot put it off any longer,” that weapons would have been sup- Photo: Danielle Liniger forces differently back then, says mil- says Lanz. People are prepared to go plied to the southern front in Valais. itary historian Jaun. “No one had any through the anguish of evacuating This never transpired. Not a single quibbles about the army doing what it Mitholz if this means that the next shot was fired in anger with weapons did.” People took risks as a necessity. generation can return without the from the Mitholz cache. On the con- For example, thousands of tonnes of risk of an explosion ripping through trary, depots like Mitholz were used defective or unwanted ammunition the village. “We won’t be waving our after the war as a convenient place to were openly discarded in Lake Thun pitchforks in Berne, provided they dump unused ammunition. The and Lake Brienz. The munitions still treat us correctly.” Mitholz store, built before the Second lie underwater. “It was also the In his mind’s eye, the mayor can cheapest way to get rid of it”. see a revitalised Mitholz flourishing The Mitholz munitions Today, the lake water is analysed one day in the distant future. He can store is situated in regularly for signs of pollution. The imagine the former munitions depot direct proximity to houses, roads and a army is overseeing an extensive becoming a museum. And thanks to busy railway line. clean-up programme. Nowadays, it the constant temperatures deep un- Reproduced by permission of stores its munitions at smaller, derground, the site could make an the Federal Office of Topography, swisstopo (BA200186) high-security sites. But until 2018 the ideal storage facility for maturing army had always steered well clear of cheese. the collapsed depot in Mitholz. Journalists from French-speak- ing Switzerland often ask Lanz why he and his fellow villagers have ac- cepted their fate so stoically. They say JÜRG STEINER IS A JOURNALIST AND EDITOR FOR that if the same scandal broke in THE “BERNER ZEITUNG”

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 Literature 13

The woman who put Napoleon in his place

Germaine de Staël, of Genevan origin, was a woman of letters and a leading intellectual who lived in Paris but had to flee to exile in Switzerland more than once.

CHARLES LINSMAYER Europe’s liberal conscience When asked whom he thought was the most important woman of all time, Napoleon incurred Germaine de Staël’s Napoleon’s anger was understandable, because this trib- wrath. “The woman who breeds the most offspring,” he re- ute to poetic Germany was in reality a beautifully dis- plied. Madame de Staël, a Genevan born in Paris in 1766, guised protest against cultural repression in France, could have almost vied for this title, having given birth to proving to him like no other work how eloquent an ad- five children herself. Although she married a Swedish versary de Staël had become. For France’s potent dictator, baron in 1786, de Staël was anything but monogamous. Madame de Staël had long become the embodiment of Hardly anyone knew which lover fathered which of her Europe’s liberal conscience. But these were not the only children. works that annoyed Napoleon. The emperor went as far Madame de Staël certainly did not cover herself in glory as penning an anonymous, scathing critique of “Del- as a mother. Instead, she will be remembered for her bril- phine”, while “Corinne ou l’Italie” enraged Napoleon sim- liant intellect, for her unbending determination to affirm ply because the novel, despite being written in the year of herself as a woman, and, not least, for her pointed letters his Italian coronation, failed to that earned European notoriety and infuriated the self-ap- mention him at all. pointed emperor, Napoleon. Madame de Staël survived the Revolution of 1789, to “A work of interest” which she was initially well disposed, in her country ref- uge in Coppet near Geneva. However, after the fall of Robe- When Germaine de Staël passed spierre she returned to Paris in 1794, where she hosted sa- away on 14 July 1817 at the age of 51 lons for the conservative intelligentsia. She warmed to after a life full of emotion, passion Napoleon initially, but fell out with him over France’s in- and sensual experiences, her Pa- vasion of Switzerland and the subsequent creation of the risian salon had long since reo- Helvetic Republic. pened in all its old splendour while Napoleon had been ban- Italy and Germany ished to Saint Helena forever. There, he confessed to his confi- Madame de Staël’s literary successes are based on trips dant Las Cases in August 1816, af- “Oh society, society! How hard it abroad that she made despite the precarious times in ter reading de Staël, that his rival makes the heart, how frivolous which she lived. “Corinne ou l’Italie” (Corinne, or Italy; and “Corinne” preyed on his mind. the mind! How it leads us 1807) is both the story of a love affair between a British “I see her, I hear her, I feel her. I to live only for what others will peer and the beautiful Corinne, and an ardent homage to want to flee from her, and I throw the culture and history of Italy. “De l’Allemagne” (Ger- the book down. I had a happier say of us! If human beings many), the book in which de Staël famously calls Germany recollection of the book than I do could but meet freed from that the “country of poets and thinkers”, is based on the au- today. I will nevertheless perse- influence which all collectively thor’s visits to Berlin and Weimar in 1803 and 1804, dur- vere – I want to know how it ends. exercise upon each other, how ing which she came into contact with Goethe and Schiller. It does still seem to me to be a pure the air that would pene- Napoleon banned the first edition of this work from work of interest.” France in 1810, ordering manuscripts and printing plates trate into the soul! What new to be destroyed before forcing the author to retreat to Cop- Bibliography: “Über Deutschland”, the ideas, what genuine emotions pet. Madame de Staël still felt unsafe in Switzerland, so German translation of “De l’Allemagne”, is available as a Reclam paperback. would refresh it!” she fled to England in 1812, where “De l’Allemagne” was published in 1813. (Excerpt from “Corinne ou l’Italie”, CHARLES LINSMAYER IS A LITERARY Germaine de Staël; 1807) SCHOLAR AND JOURNALIST IN ZÜRICH

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 14 Society

The timeless influencer

Switzerland’s fictitious national cook, Betty Bossi, came into her own during the Covid lockdown.

DÖLF BARBEN The “Betty Bossi Post” was published for the first time in Betty Bossi probably felt a bit like Helvetia this year. She was 1956, as a newsletter (printed on both sides) available free on hand when people needed her during the pandemic. As of charge in grocery stores. “What shall I cook today?” was restaurants closed, we retreated to our own homes and re- the title of its first-ever article. It looked like Betty Bossi had acquainted ourselves with the nation’s favourite housewife. written it herself. Her beaming face adorned the cover. Her Recipes from some 120 Betty Bossi cookbooks – normally signature was at the bottom of the piece. hidden behind a digital paywall – were made freely avail- able online, showing us all how to fry burgers and bake ba- This publication already contained nearly all the ingredi- nana bread. Successfully, it goes without saying. And the ents – excuse the pun – that make Betty Bossi the house- ploy worked. Once again. The Swiss visited the Betty Bossi hold name that she is today. To her readers she was a friend website over ten million times. In one month. who did not simply spoon-feed her audience, but wanted to empower them. She encouraged people to create their own meal plan, so they could eat a good, varied diet, not waste any food, and have some money left over at the end of the week. And she showcased half a dozen recipes, in- cluding this one for bread pudding with apples: 300 g left- over bread; 0.5 l milk; 3 eggs; 60 g Astra-10; 300 g apples; 80 g sugar; 2 tbsp. sultanas; grated lemon peel.

“Astra-10”? Betty Bossi not only wanted to be the friend of every housewife; she also wanted to market the fats, oils and margarines of Astra – a Unilever subsidiary that oper- ated a factory in Steffisburg near Thun. -Es sentially, Betty Bossi was a fictitious char- acter from the outset. Her purpose was a reciprocal one of give and take. She was an influencer before the word had even been invented. Betty Bossi and Helvetia have one thing in common in that neither actually exist. Yet both are synonymous with Swit- Betty Bossi was invented by ad writer Emmi zerland. Helvetia appears on our one- and two-franc coins. Creola-Maag, who was inspired by the pop- She stands upright, armed with a spear, amid a circle of ular US women’s magazine “Betty Crocker”. stars. Betty Bossi, on the other hand, has forever and a day Based on her American namesake, Betty been helping us to answer one of life’s trickiest questions: Bossi took Switzerland by storm. According what shall I cook today? to historian Benedikt Meyer, cars, televisions and new hair styles were not the only spoils of For almost 65 years, Betty Bossi has been part of our na- the post-war economic miracle. Home cooking was also “What shall I cook to- tional psyche. It is about time that we asked what her tire- transformed – with electric ovens, blenders, mixers and day?” This was Betty Bossi’s first question less cooking over a hot stove has actually achieved. Have kneaders among a new generation of kitchen utensils, and – then thousands of her cook books really left a “lasting mark” on Switzerland’s a veritable conveyor belt of new products available in the cooking and baking households, as it says in the Historical Dictionary of Swit- shops. Meyer: “The Swiss needed someone to help them recipes followed. zerland? Would we still be smothering our veggies in a negotiate all this technology. And Betty Bossi was their Photo provided flour-based sauce if Betty Bossi had never existed? saviour.”

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 15

Lemon drizzle cake – the most popular Betty Bossi recipe, attracting almost half a million clicks a year

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 16 Society

It was a huge success story. “Betty Bossi” magazine, which later became a subscription publication, continues to be read by hundreds of thousands of people. When tiramisu was first introduced as a dessert in 1984, tubs of mascar- pone quickly sold out around Switzerland. The first-ever Betty Bossi cookbook was published in 1973. Since then, 35 million Betty Bossi cookbooks have been sold, the most suc- cessful of these a book on baking cakes (1.35 million copies). If all the Betty Bossi cookbooks that have been sold were put in a line one after the other, they would stretch from Switzerland to the USA. Food photographers serve up appetising images of “influencer” Consider your own home. When you Betty Bossi’s cooking feats. tidy your kitchen drawers, do you al- ways seem to find one of her cook- books, magazines or recipe cuttings hidden away somewhere? Or do your Betty Bossi in figures rolling pin guides, your pastry cutters, or – worst case – your waffle maker Around 2,500 new recipes are created every year come tumbling out when you open ternative – it is hard to contradict Betty Bossi spokeswoman at the Betty Bossi kitchens in Basel and Zurich. one of your cupboards? Yes, Betty Viviane Bühr when she says that life is completely different “Betty Bossi” magazine is published ten times a Bossi also excels in producing and sell- now from 60 years ago. People are less active. They no longer year and has a print run of 540,000, making it ing kitchen utensils such as these. The want to stand in the kitchen for two hours every day either. Switzerland’s biggest paid-for publication. The saviour of lonely households, the all- As Bühr points out, the Swiss like to follow global food and Betty Bossi website is visited three million times in-one cure for food boredom, the lifestyle trends. Those hearty flour-based sauces belong to per month, but this number has been much guardian of the holy grill. Whatever yesteryear. The “Bettys and Bossis”, as Bühr calls the com- higher since the beginning of the Covid-19 you like to call her, Betty Bossi is alive pany workforce, identify and incorporate these trends into pandemic. People also view Betty Bossi recipes and kicking. new recipes and food products. To continue to exist in fu- via a daily email newsletter that goes out to ture, she says that they need to move with the times like all 520,000 different addresses. (DB) As a business, Betty Bossi has always companies. This philosophy has worked a treat so far. “We been cutting edge. From television are doing really well for a company of our size. Betty Bossi cookery shows to online platforms, to is in a great place,” she says. gluten-free food. In 2012, she became a 100 per cent subsid- iary of Coop, one of Switzerland’s two supermarket giants. Certainly, no one would resent Betty Bossi for trying to stay Betty Bossi AG employs 120 people in Basel and Zurich. The relevant. At least being an ageless, made-up character gives company generated net sales of 89 million Swiss francs in her an advantage. But how will she master this quest? What 2019. You will see Betty Bossi around any Coop supermar- does the future hold? Her competitors are lining up – how ket. The brand comprises over 600 different products. In will they respond? No one had heard of food blogs when addition to baking items, Betty Bossi also offers a range of Betty Bossi began her career as an influencer. Cookbooks convenience foods such as salads, sandwiches and ready- were nowhere near as common as they are now. Are classic made meals. recipes such as lemon drizzle cake and pork fillets still enough for Betty to hold her own? For decades, Betty Bossi taught Swiss households the art of cooking. Suddenly she now wants to serve us fast food. Is that not a gigantic contradiction? There is probably no al- DÖLF BARBEN IS AN EDITOR FOR “DER BUND”

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 Politics 17

No liability regulations for Swiss multinationals

The Responsible Business Initiative failed to win a cantonal majority. Nevertheless, Swiss companies are under increasing pressure to act in an ethically responsible manner abroad.

duct due diligence regarding child la- bour and sourcing minerals from war-torn regions. Companies that give false information or fail to re- port risk fines of up to 100,000 Swiss francs. “The authors of the initiative have something to show for their ef- forts after all,” said Keller- Sutter. However, the people behind the initiative are disappointed. They view the measures as inadequate. Federal Councillor Karin Keller-Sutter’s “Self-policing without effective con- conciliatory message: trols or liability clauses is not enough “The authors of the to ensure that all companies respect initiative have some- international environmental stand- thing to show for their efforts after all.” ards and human rights,” lamented Photo: Keystone law professor and co-chair of the in- itiative committee Monika Roth, THEODORA PETER Sutter (FDP) adopted a conciliatory adding that her coalition of support- Despite losing at the ballot box, the tone after the vote. The justice minis- ers would continue to campaign for authors of the initiative “for respon- ter had stood shoulder to shoulder greater corporate accountability. sible companies – protecting human with industry groups to oppose the This is why Swiss firms should still rights and the environment” (Respon- initiative during a referendum cam- expect their overseas business activ- sible Business Initiative) achieved a paign that was hard fought on both ities to be scrutinised by a watchful respectable result. A narrow major- sides. Swiss companies must also re- civil society in future. ity of voters (50.7 per cent) voted yes spect human rights and the environ- on 29 November. However, the initi- ment abroad, that’s a given, she said. Voters reject ban on investments ative was unable to obtain the can- “We voted differently, but we all want in weapons manufacturers tonal majority required for any con- the same thing.” Switzerland rejected the popular initiative stitutional amendment, with only “For a ban on financing war material manufactur- nine out of 26 cantons voting in fa- Due diligence to prevent child labour ers”, with around 57 per cent of the electorate vour. In the context of Swiss direct voting no. The authors of the initiative wanted to democracy, it is extremely rare for an With the Responsible Business Initi- halt Swiss investment in the global arms indus- initiative to achieve a popular major- ative having been rejected, an indi- try. The Federal Council and parliament believe ity and fail to win a cantonal major- rect counterproposal approved by that existing bans on the funding of nuclear and ity. It shows how well disposed voters parliament last summer automati- chemical weapons as well as cluster munitions were to the initiative, which was cally comes into force. Unlike the in- are sufficient. A decision is still to be made on backed by an alliance comprising 120 itiative, the counterproposal does a cross-party initiative calling for a ban on the relief agencies as well as churches and not include a liability clause. How- export of arms to war-torn regions and to environmental and human rights or- ever, it does oblige major companies countries in which systematic human rights ganisations (see “Swiss Review” to report every year on human rights, violations are taking place. (TP) 5/2020). environmental and anti-corruption Federal Councillor Karin Keller- standards compliance and to con-

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 18 Politics

Controversial alternative to the password jungle

The Federal Council and parliament want to introduce an electronic identity (e-ID) scheme that would make it easier and more secure for us to use online services. But the plan is controversial. It will be put to the people on 7 March.

EVELINE RUTZ tronic IDs. “We want to regulate the particularly sensitive data, e.g. health You can have six, sometimes eight way people log in,” said Federal Coun- information or in relation to online characters, sometimes more. A jumble cillor Karin Keller-Sutter in parlia- tax statements or online voting. In- of letters and numbers. If you spend a ment, adding that people who use on- deed, e-voting could become fully dig- lot of time on the internet, you will line services must be confident that ital through e-ID. In other words, all doubtless have to enter countless statutory parameters are protecting official voting papers and access data passwords, not to mention other login them. What it certainly is not is a dig- would be available online. Authorities data like your name, email address or ital passport. would no longer have to send PINs by customer number. It’s the same rigma- Scratch the scratch card post, as was the case during the previ- role for anyone who wants to pay on- A way to conduct e-voting to see your PIN, then ous, now-aborted e-voting scheme. enter the code manually. line, although security procedures of- E-voting providers as well as voters You can say a lot of ten vary depending on the website. E-ID is designed to make it easier and things about recent at- would, in any event, be free to choose In 2019, parliament approved new more secure to carry out online trans- tempts to introduce whether to make use of this govern- legislation aimed at “clearing the pass- actions and use e-government appli- e-voting to Switzerland, ment-approved identity scheme. word jungle” and setting out clear cations, preventing confusion and of- but completely digital is Implementation of the scheme not one of them. rules. The Federal Act on Electronic fering protection against hacker would see the public and private sec- A government-controlled Identification Services (E-ID Act), attacks. It incorporates three security electronic identity tor work together. The government which will be put to voters on 7 March levels. The highest of these, facial rec- scheme would change would check and register people’s 2021, establishes the basis for elec- ognition, would be used for sharing this. Photo: Keystone identity and identifying characteris- tics. Private companies would issue e-IDs, as would cantonal and munici- pal authorities. Identity providers (IdP) would be responsible for cards, USB sticks and e-ID applications. An independent panel of experts, the Fed- eral E-ID Committee (Eidcom), would approve and monitor IdPs.

Better solutions from the private sector?

By allocating responsibilities in this way, the Federal Council and a major- ity in parliament hope to ensure that e-services are workable and consum- er-friendly. They argue that the pri- vate sector has greater customer prox- imity and can respond more flexibly to advances in technology. Karin Keller-Sutter: “Experiences in other countries show that exclusively gov-

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 19

ernment-driven solutions are less ef- out prior consent. Selling such infor- How much money would E-ID fective and successful, because the mation would be against the law. private sector chooses not to use The Federal Data Protection and cost the government? them.” Information Commissioner, Adrian Implementing e-ID would involve a one-off This form of cooperation is not Lobsiger, believes that the E-ID Act of- outlay of 7.9 million francs. This money would without its critics. It is the reason why fers benefits with regard to data pro- fund development of the system as well as the Digital Society Switzerland, the cam- Data protection expert tection compliance. He explains that establishment of a federal service in charge of paign group Campax, the signa- Adrian Lobsiger: the E-ID Act would make things sim- E-ID would comply transmitting identity and verification informa- ture-gathering platform WeCollect, pler, because banks, companies and with data protection tion. According to the Federal Office of Justice and civil society organisation Pub- authorities would no longer have to requirements. (FOJ), operating the system is likely to cost licBeta have forced a referendum. develop their own secure login sys- around 3.5 million francs a year. However, this They say that the government is fail- tems. “It would lead to uniform statu- would be covered by administrative fees and ing in one of its key responsibilities tory standards being applied to tech- would therefore have no effect on the govern- and “bowing to the interests of the pri- nical security and data protection,” he ment’s balance sheet. (ERU) vate sector”. Big banks, insurers, and says. Lobsiger says that the good thing firms with government links would be about what is being proposed is that “acting like a passport office”. The ini- the private sector would be funding nopoly, what would you call the gov- tiators of the referendum believe that and operating the e-ID scheme but the ernment?” A number of providers granting the private sector access to Minister of Justice government would be setting the from the private sector competing to sensitive data is risky. In their opinion, Karin Keller Sutter: rules. If voters rejected it, Switzerland develop their own applications is ex- exclusively government- companies primarily look out for their might have no other option but to rec- actly what we want, she said. driven solutions are own interests and cannot be trusted. less effective. ognise e-IDs offered exclusively by the E-ID is a cornerstone of the digital The government would have relatively private sector – also including provid- transformation, say supporters of the little power to control them. Oppo- ers unable to ensure the same type of E-ID Act. Switzerland cannot afford to nents of the new legislation also have data protection, e.g. Apple and Google. miss the digital boat and not make up doubts as to how voluntary the Lobsiger mentions that some cantonal ground on other countries. Switzer- scheme would be. They fear that on- authorities are already collaborating land is indeed lagging behind compa- line services could pressure people with SwissSign. These authorities use rable countries in e-government. It into using e-ID. The SP and the Greens the company’s SwissID digital key to risks falling even further behind, have already represented this view in provide access to online government warn experts. This is Switzerland’s parliament. It is a view which is shared Critic Anita Fetz: services. very last chance to keep control of its by the Pirate Party, Switzerland’s pub- a private monopoly is citizens’ identification data, declared the last thing that lic-sector trade union VPOD/SSP, sen- Ruedi Noser (FDP/Zurich) in the Switzerland needs. Monopoly? ior citizens’ organisations, and other smaller chamber, adding that any de- bodies. SwissSign Group is part of a joint ven- lay would play into the hands of Apple, ture involving Swiss Post, SBB, Swiss- Google, Facebook and Amazon. Switzerland’s top data-protection com, Six and a number of major banks official supports the E-ID Act and insurance companies. It would be On 10 July 2020, the Council of the Swiss Abroad keen on issuing its own e-ID – but (CSA), referred to as the “Parliament of the Fifth Switzerland”, decided to back the new legislation Supporters of the new legislation dis- sceptics such as Anita Fetz (SP/Ba- and vote yes in the referendum. However, with miss these security concerns, insist- sel-Stadt) are critical. In a parliamen- 37 to 26 in favour (and 18 abstentions), the decision ing that the government will not lose tary debate, the former member of the was far from unanimous. control of the people’s data. They say Council of States said that a private that the E-ID Act goes above and be- monopoly is the last thing that Swit- yond current provisions. For example, zerland needs. Justice Minister Karin EVELINE RUTZ IS A FREELANCE JOURNALIST BASED personal information cannot be used Keller-Sutter dismissed these com- IN WINTERTHUR. SHE MAINLY WRITES ABOUT for other purposes or forwarded with- ments as “illogical”. “If that is a mo- POLITICAL, SOCIAL AND SCIENTIFIC ISSUES.

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 20 Portrait

Dying to save the forest, the adventure of Swiss hero Bruno Manser

“Paradise War – The story of Bruno Manser” tells of the Swiss-born activist’s passion for the primary forests of Borneo and their inhabitants, the Penan. Filmed against an epic backdrop, the Swiss film could win an award at the Golden Globes.

STÉPHANE HERZOG ting two hours and 20 minutes had ing to die in here” warns the canoeist Valentin Greutert, producer of the sold 3,000 tickets in four days before who brings him to the middle of the film “Paradise War – The story of the cinemas closed. In Switzerland, forest) until his disappearance in Bruno Manser” finds himself in a “Paradise War” has been watched by 2000. At that time, the efforts of this confusing situation. His film, released more than 200,000 viewers in the ci- conscientious objector, shepherd and in Switzerland at the end of 2019, was nema and at home. The budget ran to alpinist to stop or slow the destruc- nominated by the Hollywood Foreign 6 million Swiss francs, setting this na- tion of the Malaysian forests had been Press Association for the Golden Glo- tional coproduction amongst the in vain. The filming was an adventure Sven Schelker, in the bes. There is bound to be a huge audi- costliest films ever produced in Swit- in itself. A team of 150 people lived in centre of the shot, ence at the ceremony, set for 28 Feb- zerland. the middle of the jungle for three played the role of en- vironmental activist ruary 2021. An award would get this “Paradise War” tells the story of months. “We slept on the ground, on Bruno Manser on biographical film noticed around the the extraordinary life of adventurer mats. Having to conduct the filming screen. Nick Kelesau, world. But, on the other hand, the and conservationist Bruno Manser, in a foreign language was also parti- Elizabeth Ballang, producer from Basel saw his film blo- who was born in 1954 in Basel. The cularly difficult,” explains Greutert. Matthew Crowley, Da- vid Ka Shing Tse were cked in Germany and Austria at the film covers the period stretching In 1992, the producer from Basel met the other main actors. beginning of November due to the from his arrival in the Malaysian Bruno Manser when the environ- Photo provided. lockdown. In Germany, this tale las- state of Sarawak in 1984 (“You’re go- mental activist visited his school to

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 21

talk about tropical forests. On set, the mily. “In Borneo, I saw why Bruno inhabitants told of the life of Bruno was so happy here, with the Penan, at Manser and their fight to prevent the least until the illegal logging began,” destruction of their natural habitat. he explains. The economist, who The majority of those involved come chairs the Commission for Sustain- from a Borneo tribe called the Day- able Development for Basel Kanto- aks, located in Indonesia, because nalbank and Banque Cler, finds that filming in Malaysia was prohibited the film “really shows the systematic by the authorities of the state of Sa- connections between our economic rawak. system and those of the tribes of the primary forests, as well as how the Actors playing themselves motive of profit develops new me- thods for accessing natural resour- To stay as true as possible to the story, ces”. In this configuration, “the ene- director Niklaus Hilber from Zurich mies of the forest are everywhere, convinced eight members of the Mal- and they don’t even know it,” notes aysian Penan tribe (the tribe with Roger Graf, the director of the Bruno which Bruno Manser had lived) to Manser Fund (BMF) in the film. participate in the film. This choice The film presents a romanticised meant flying via Jakarta, as the Indo- version of a life story worthy of a no- nesian Dayak tribe live 200 kilome- vel. There is the love affair between tres away from the Penan. Amongst Manser and a member of the Penan the actors in this tribe, were Nick Ke- tribe, for example. The meeting in lesau, who plays the role of Along New York between Manser and the Sega. This Penan chief had adopted Secretary-General of the United Na- Bruno Manser and described him as tions, Boutros Boutros-Ghali, never “a child in an adult’s body”. Kelesau took place. Ditto for the attempt to knew Manser when he was a child. obtain the International Tropical The actor Sven Schelker, who plays Timber Organization (ITTO) label, Bruno Manser and speaks in the restation being written into the glo- Environmental acti- which would protect the forests of Penan language, touched the heart of bal political agenda.” The strength of vist Bruno Manser Borneo. “Bruno Manser had contact during the time he the adventurer’s sister, Monika Nie- the film is built on the actors’ identi- lived with the Penan with the ITTO, but he didn’t believe derberger. “At times, I really saw fication with their own story. As such, in Borneo. in labels,” explains Lukas Straumann, Bruno standing in front of me, even scenes where the Penan construct Archive photo: Keystone, 1990 director of the BMF, who asked do- if Sven is taller and slimmer,” she barricades led the actors to relive nors to help complete production. says. She remembers her excitement moments they had effectively expe- “The film allows young people to dis- when Bruno would take her on walks rienced in their own lives. cover Bruno Manser, a modern-day through the forests of Basel, lifting In the jungle of Borneo, one mem- hero,” he says. up rocks to find insects or a lizard. ber of the team had known Manser Regarding the Sarawak forests, “This film is my life’s work,” states well: Kasper Müller, an economist 90 per cent of them have disappea- Valentin Greutert. “It tells the story and former president of Ethos, a red since the 1970s. The timber pro- of humanity. We discover how the Swiss foundation for sustainable de- duced represents a value of over 50 nomadic Penan tribe have lived for velopment. Originally from Basel, billion dollars, according to the BMF. thousands of years and how capita- Müller became close friends with Is all lost? No. Secondary forests have lism, hungry for resources, has swal- Manser towards the end of the 1990s. regrown. And the tribes of Borneo lowed their forest. It’s also the legacy Since Manser’s disappearance in now defend their living space using of a man, as it is the commitment of 2000, this man has represented the geographical maps, ­notably created Bruno Manser which has led to defo- rights of the adventurer and his fa- with support from the BMF.

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 22 Society

How the pandemic spiralled out of control in Switzerland

During the second Covid-19 wave, the Confederation and cantons long remained set on a middle course between shutting the economy and preventing the spread of the virus. They failed to bring the situation under control. An abnormally high number of elderly people died.

SUSANNE WENGER the population “without public life and the economy suf- The first people in Switzerland will have received the fering unnecessary collateral damage”. Restaurant indus- Covid-19 vaccine by the time this edition of “Swiss Review” try association GastroSuisse and the economiesuisse busi- is published in February – a key step towards curbing the ness ­federation signalled their relief. The authorities pandemic. But as I write before the festive season, the situ- wanted to halve the number of cases every two weeks un- ation looks bad. After surviving the first wave relatively -un til Christmas – a strategy that worked initially as the curve scathed, Switzerland has unexpectedly become one of Eu- dipped in November. rope’s Covid hotspots in the second wave. Seldom has there been so much wrangling over what to do. This in Switzer- Hospitals at breaking point land, where everything is meant to go like clockwork. How has it come to this? Time to reconstruct the events of recent Yet Switzerland could not extricate itself from the danger months – in the knowledge that things will have changed zone, not least because German-speaking cantons did lit- again by the time we go to press. tle to combat the pandemic – much to the Federal Council’s The emergency powers allowing the Federal Council to dismay. Our small country of 26 cantons and half-cantons make unilateral decisions ended in early summer and the ended up with a confusing, contradictory hotchpotch of re- onus switched back to the cantons, not the government, to strictions. Fatigue set in among the general public. By the manage the crisis. Responsible for healthcare within Swit- start of December, infections had flatlined at a high level zerland’s federal framework, the cantons wanted to resume or were beginning to increase again in nearly every canton. control given the sharp fall in infections. The Federal Coun- Hospitals and care homes were feeling the strain. Inten- cil took a back seat – even as Covid-19 rates began to surge sive-care units were filling up. A disproportionately high again in October. With the curve initially steeper in some number of elderly people were dying of Covid-19, as the sec- regions than others, the consensus was that local cantonal ond wave left its tragic mark. measures were better than national ones. Despite a world-class healthcare system, Switzerland’s coronavirus mortality rate was high compared to other Switzerland going its “own way” countries. The majority of victims were over 80, said ­Finance Minister Ueli Maurer during a radio interview in Infections rose dramatically, however, with daily new cases mid-November. According to Maurer, the government had reaching a record of almost 10,000 at the start of Novem- had to “weigh the various implications”. In protest at what ber. The Federal Council intervened at the end of October, announcing nationwide restrictions, e.g. an extension to the rule on face coverings and a ban on public events of over 50 people. More significantly, it decided against the type of partial lockdown already introduced by French-speaking cantons with particularly high infection rates. Restaurants and shops were allowed to stay open, subject to limitations. Despite a comparatively high number of cases per 100,000 people, Switzerland’s response differed to that of neigh- Finance Minister Health Minister President of the Swiss bouring countries. Ueli Maurer – Alain Berset – Confederation Health Minister Alain Berset (SP) said Switzerland was weighing the various Switzerland going its Simonetta Sommaruga going its “own way”. The Federal Council wanted to protect implications “own way” Photos: Keystone

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 23

they saw as indifference among policymakers and the pub- ment; uncoordinated federalism; a failure to develop a pre- lic, activists in Berne lit candles outside parliament. By ventive strategy against the second wave; the opinions of Christmas, the virus had claimed well over 6,000 lives. lobbies taking precedence over science; fear of the financial consequences of a lockdown – these were reasons used in Warnings from experts Switzerland to explain the debacle. Surprise at the govern- ment’s more relaxed approach to tackling the pandemic The more the situation escalated, the more heated the was expressed abroad. The World Health Organization ­arguments became. Epidemiologists were now not alone in slammed the country’s response, while renowned US mag- advising the government to do more. Economists also azine “Foreign Policy” headlined with “Switzerland is joined in, saying it was a false economy for shops and res- choosing austerity over life”. German news magazine “Der taurants to remain open if customers were falling ill. After Spiegel” said Switzerland believed in its own invincibility backing the Federal Council’s decisions last spring, Swit- – an attitude that had historical roots.

Cartoonist Felix Schaad on the sharp increase in deaths. First published on 21 November 2020, www.tagesanzeiger.ch zerland’s political parties could no longer contain them- Pressure on the Federal Council was growing. In the mid- selves during parliament’s winter session. The SP and dle of December, Switzerland’s large hospitals sounded the Greens called for stricter measures and a more generous alarm. The government then stepped in, introducing ­financial package for beleaguered businesses, whereas the stricter nationwide rules. It instructed restaurants, sports FDP and SVP opposed sweeping restrictions – ensuring venues, museums, and leisure facilities to close, and in- Swiss ski resorts stayed open, as neighbouring countries creased its compensation fund by 1.5 billion Swiss francs. were seeking a multilateral agreement to prohibit winter “The rate of infection has to drop, this is imperative for the sports. entire country,” said the president of the Swiss Confedera- The media grew more critical of the government’s “mid- tion, Simonetta Sommaruga. However, the measures lacked dle course”. “Minimalism on Covid, and ski resorts to open consistency in places and still fell short of those in other over Christmas. Has Switzerland lost its moral compass?” European countries. Shops remained open, as did Alpine asked online magazine “Republik”. Even the “Neue Zürcher ski resorts. Meanwhile, the World Economic Forum (WEF) Zeitung” noted it would be “fatal to wait”. The newspaper announced that its annual gathering of political and busi- generally agreed with Switzerland’s liberal and regionally ness leaders in Davos would move to Singapore in 2021. varied approach to fighting the pandemic. Yet it was a mis- Concerns about the spread of the virus in Switzerland had take in hindsight for the government and cantons not to act led the WEF to take this decision. earlier against the rise in cases, commented the broadsheet. The limits of individual responsibility in a highly con- tagious pandemic; Switzerland’s sluggish system of govern- Up-to-date information: www.sciencetaskforce.ch

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 24Switzerland in figures SwissCommunity

Beard business Readers give “Swiss Review” good marks – and have a 50 clear idea of what they want Trimmed beards for better security! From 1 November 2020, police officers guarding the Federal Palace are only allowed to have beards of up to 50 millimetres in length. Longer beards are a “security issue”, A very large proportion of “Swiss Review” readers rate our says the Federal Security Service. Facially hirsute policemen have since ­magazine as “good” or even “very good”. Many of them also been transferred to other posts. have clear ideas as to how we could improve the publication. These are the results of our reader survey. 380 However, length is not the only thing that matters at the so- called International Alpine Beard Festival. Pius Sidler, reigning champion in the “Natural Alpine Beard” category, not only sports a 380-mm beard, he also cuts a very authentic and dignified fig- MARC LETTAU ure. Anyone who wishes to put up a challenge will have to wait How would readers describe “Swiss Review”? We are a trustworthy, until the next festival on 3 October 2021 in Seewis (Grisons). informative magazine that provides unbiased reporting on relevant issues in a clear and comprehensible manner. This is the overriding consensus among those who took part in our reader survey in sum- mer 2020. The Research Center for the Public Sphere and Society (FÖG) 1750 – the University of Zurich’s independent body specialised in media re- Incidentally, a flowing beard made by hand in Switzerland from real buffalo search – conducted the survey. According to social scientist and sur- hair costs up to 1,750 Swiss francs and is a product beloved of St Nicholas vey coordinator Jörg Schneider, one specific quality stands out in the lookalikes across the country. Switzerland’s many dedicated St Nicholas results: “A very high percentage of readers think that ‘Swiss Review’ associations make tens of thousands of visits to families every year, but is a trustworthy publication”. they had a hard time of it in 2020. Demand for their services fell amid the The verdict from our highly diverse, multilingual, worldwide read- pandemic. At least they had plenty of time to care for their beards instead. ership was positive overall, with 42 per cent giving the magazine top marks (“very good”) and 38 per cent scoring us as “good”. A further 17 per cent are more or less satisfied, while under 3 per cent marked us as poor or very poor. 46 But this is just a rough snapshot. Marks varied – albeit marginally However, healthcare workers are anything but idle at the moment. for the most part – depending on gender, age, and country of domicile. “Clapping for carers” is all well and good, but no other profession For example, the under-25s and the over-65s share a slightly more is currently haemorrhaging as many people as healthcare. Around positive view of our magazine compared to age groups in between. 46 per cent of all qualified personnel change careers, often at a And we consistently received slightly better marks from women than young age. The main reason that leavers give is that they are from men. Geographical distance also played a role, with people liv- chronically overworked due to staff shortages – a situation exac- ing in places like South America or Australia more inclined than EU erbated every time one of their colleagues calls it a day. expatriates – our main readership community – to score us higher. According to our readers, “Swiss Review” also has weaknesses. Around 10 per cent believe that its visual appearance can be improved. 1 000 000 This opinion came more from online readers than from readers of the print edition. “Swiss Review” is politically biased, according to 12 per In these turbulent times, it’s the little things that count. Take the cent of readers, half of whom accuse us of being too govern- Swiss-invented REX peeler. Dating back to 1947, it is the epitome of ment-friendly and too afraid to speak our mind. The other half accuse frugality, sleek design, and timelessness. Zena Swiss has been us of exactly the opposite, saying that we are too critical of Switzer- producing and selling a million of these patented kitchen utensils every land, and that our position verges on “socialist”. According to Schnei- year since 1969. If you want to know how useful this humble peeler is, der, this relatively small contingent – and the views they ask Betty Bossi (see page 14). express – confirm, if anything, that our magazine has, in his words, a FIGURES COMPILED BY MARC LETTAU “good command of controversial political issues”.

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 25

Wish list The only source of information for many readers

Readers used the survey to tell us how they thought we could improve “Swiss Review” is one of many media channels. However, 44 per cent the magazine. People want to see more articles on nature and the en- of readers say that the magazine essentially meets all their Swiss news vironment – a theme that featured at the top of most readers’ wish and information needs. Some 28 per cent say that “Swiss Review” pro- lists. This call was loudest among young readers as well as readers who vides their only source of news and information from Switzerland. are past retirement age, although other age groups also think that Readers who access Swiss-related news and information from sources green issues should be given clear priority, followed by sociopolitical other than “Swiss Review” make use of Swiss newspaper and maga- topics. Readers would like to see even more report-style pieces, while zine websites (41 per cent), read the international press (39 per cent), “useful information” also features prominently among people’s pref- visit swissinfo (19 per cent) or consult Swiss government websites erences: over a third of respondents want more practical, clear advice (11 per cent). and tips from both the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad and the fed- Our website contains a number of frequently asked questions eral authorities. about “Swiss Review” (revue.ch/en/faq). For additional information, visit [email protected]. Differences between print and online readers

There was very little difference, if any, in scoring between those who read the printed version of “Swiss Review” and those who read on- line. Both groups also said very similar things about how to improve the magazine. However, one significant divergence is that a large pro- portion of print subscribers “consume” the magazine intensively, i.e. they read many, if not all, of the articles and often discuss the content of these articles with others in their private and professional lives. On- line readers consume much less intensively, both reading less and spending less time doing so.

Emotional connection

The survey results also reveal an emotional connection to the maga- zine, with 70 per cent of readers saying that “Swiss Review” strength- ens their ties to Switzerland. “This is the most significant soft factor,” says Schneider. “Two thirds of readers also view the magazine as a sort of ‘guide’ to contemporary Switzerland.”

The survey in figures

Some 17,000 people took part in the “Swiss Review” reader survey coordinated by the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad, with around 14,000 completing the questionnaire in full. Around 5,500 people also gave a written answer to our open-ended question “What are you missing from ‘Swiss Review’?” This feedback and the completed questionnaires have helped us to assess reader satisfaction and gain an insight into what people would like to see in the magazine in future. (MUL)

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 26 SwissCommunity

New website for OSA, New events in 2021: online offers Youth Service and “Swiss Review” to accompany the traditional summer and winter camps

The Organisation of the Swiss Abroad (OSA) – which since 1 January This year, the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad, under the name also goes under the name of “SwissCommunity” – launched a new, SwissCommunity, is organising a summer camp and a winter camp, combined website at the beginning of the year. and for the first time will be providing online offers for young Swiss All OSA, “Swiss Review” and Youth Service content can now be Abroad aged between 15 and 25. found at www.swisscommunity.org. Readers of our magazine can still Due to the global health situation (Covid-19 pandemic), the visit www.revue.ch, which will redirect automatically to the new Organisation of the Swiss Abroad has taken the difficult decision to shared website. reduce the number of camps originally planned for 2021. Just two The new website not only features fresh content and advice – it camps will be organised: one in the Vaud Alps and one in the Pennine will also be our community hub allowing the Swiss Abroad to inter- Alps. The summer camp will take place from 10 to 23 July 2021 in Châ- act, share knowledge, opinions and information, get helpful tips, and teau-d’Oex and the winter camp will be from 27 December 2021 to 5 announce events online. January 2022 in Grächen. This revamp has been in the pipeline for a long time but has now Of course, the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad is closely moni- taken on added significance since the beginning of the Covid-19 pan- toring the evolution of the pandemic in the world. Any change which demic, says OSA Director Ariane Rustichelli. “The pandemic has may impact the organisation of the camps will be announced on the shown us how important it now is to stay connected,” she says. The website www.swisscommunity.org. aim of the new website is to help ensure that people stay in touch. “Not only will it strengthen people’s connection and attachment to Switzerland, but it will also provide the Swiss Abroad with additional opportunities to interact.” However, online interaction is no substi- tute for face-to-face contact. Rustichelli: “Ultimately, people still need to meet each other. That goes without saying.” Which is why our tra- ditional Swiss expatriate associations have nothing to fear from in- creased digitalisation. On the contrary. “Digitalisation will help them to enhance their profile.” Strengthening and underscoring their role and objectives within this highly interconnected community is the challenge they face. (MUL)

Enjoying fondue at the 2019 Sainte-Croix sports and holiday camp – before face coverings and social distancing

Summer camps for children aged 8 to 14 Given the uncertainty surrounding the organisation of the camps, Swiss children living abroad will have an opportunity to get to know Switzerland and its the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad is pleased to be able to offer culture – and have a great time with around 40 other children from around the world – at young Swiss living abroad an alternative. For the first time, the Or- a series of two-week summer camps from the end of June to the end of August 2021. ganisation of the Swiss Abroad will be providing online offers, com- There are still some free spots available on our holiday camps. For further details on the bining learning, fun and new encounters. All offers can be found at www.swisscommunity.org. 2021 summer season as well as the relevant application form, visit www.sjas.ch/en/camps/.

(LR) Foundation for Young Swiss Abroad (FYSA), Alpenstrasse 26, 3006 Berne, Switzerland; For more information: tel.: +41 31 356 61 16; fax: +41 31 356 61 01; email: [email protected], www.sjas.ch Organisation of the Swiss Abroad, Youth service, Alpenstrasse 26, 3006 Bern, Switzerland, telephone +41 31 356 61 24, email: [email protected], www.swisscommunity.org

Organisation of the Swiss Abroad Our partners: Alpenstrasse 26 CH-3006 Berne Tel. +41 31 356 61 00 Fax +41 31 356 61 01 educationsuisse Foundation for Young Swiss Abroad [email protected] Tel. +41 31 356 61 04 Tel. +41 31 356 61 16 Fax +41 31 356 61 01 Fax +41 31 356 61 01 www.revue.ch [email protected] info@sjas www.swisscommunity.org www.educationsuisse.ch www.sjas.ch

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 27 SwissCommunity

“It would be a great first step if we had 40 per cent women”

Better representation of women is an objective shared by the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad (OSA). The elections to the Council of the Swiss Abroad (CSA) offer a tangible opportunity in this regard. What is OSA Director Ariane Rustichelli’s view on the matter?

INTERVIEW: MARC LETTAU Diversity always enriches our lives A worldwide election and is one of the keys to better and Some 44 women and 76 men represent the more broadly based decision-making. Between January and June 2021, Swiss expa- Swiss expatriate community in the “Parlia- triates around the world will vote to determine ment of the Fifth Switzerland”, the CSA. Reflecting social diversity is not solely the composition of the Council of the Swiss The proportion of women is too low in your about ensuring better representation of Abroad (CSA), referred to as the “Parliament of opinion. women. the Fifth Switzerland”. The CSA has 140 dele- Yes, it is too low for the simple reason Correct. We should not forget to en- gates, of whom 120 represent Swiss communi- that women represent the majority of gage with all age groups either. Basi- ties abroad and 20 live in Switzerland. Not all people in the “Fifth Switzerland”. cally, we need to get young people countries share the same procedure for elect- OSA Director Women account for 54 per cent of the more involved. ing CSA delegates, so the vote will not be cen- Ariane Rustichelli: 770,000 Swiss who live abroad. But it trally coordinated. Everything you need to “Better female rep- is more than just a question of per- Apart from appealing to voters, what else know about the elections will appear in your resentation is necessary can the OSA do to ensure better female at all levels and in all centages. A council should reflect the regional edition of “Swiss Review”, courtesy of decision-making bodies.” community it represents as closely as representation? the Swiss association or umbrella organisation possible. Proper female representa- We have to do more than just appeal to in your area. (MUL) tion also translates into a different voters. Better female representation is way of going about things in terms of necessary at all levels and in all deci- the political agenda, the culture of de- sion-making bodies. In particular, this This is all still hypothetical, because direct bate and identifying solutions for ex- applies to the Swiss associations and elections will not be taking place in 2021. ample. We are currently seeing this umbrella organisations that run the This is true. The best direct elections in Switzerland. The women’s strike CSA election process in each region. If are when everyone can vote online. and other initiatives are factors that these bodies are also serious about im- However, the suspension of e-voting resulted in more women being proving female representation, the in Switzerland has set us back. No elected to the federal parliament in number of candidates will increase. other government solutions are avail- 2019. We can now see the substantive And if more women stand for election, able. Consequently, we are pinning outcome. more women will be elected. our hopes on an alternative e-voting system. We have already evaluated it, The National Council is made up of 42 per In future, the OSA wants all Swiss Abroad but procuring and rolling it out takes cent women. Women account for 36 per cent in any given country to be able to participate time. Nevertheless, our efforts under- of people who sit on the CSA. Does the in CSA elections, regardless of whether score how important introducing di- percentage of women in the CSA need to they are registered with a Swiss associa- rect elections remains. Essentially, di- increase to over 40 per cent? tion or not. Would direct elections such as rect elections would provide the CSA Looking at it pragmatically, yes. It these help to further the female cause? with greater legitimacy and political would be a great first step if we had Women’s chances increase if more of leverage. 40 per cent women. them can vote and stand for election. At least that is the theory. However, ex- And what would be the second step? perience shows that a change of sys- The actual aim is 50 per cent or more, tem on its own is not enough. We need because again we want the CSA to re- an environment that encourages flect the diverse Swiss expatriate com- women. Women often still feel less munity as accurately as possible. By empowered to stand for office. Per- the way, this is not an end in itself. haps they need fresh role models.

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 28 SwissCommunity

Gaining work experience Federal votes in Switzerland The Federal Council determines voting pro- posals at least four months before the voting educationsuisse gives advice on all matters related to education in Switzerland as date. well as tips on gaining initial work experience in Switzerland. Everything you need to know about voting proposals (voting pamphlets, committees, rec- Would you like to work as a language assistant at Would you like to help out on a farm in ommendations by Parliament and the Federal a Swiss upper secondary school or a vocational Switzerland for several weeks? Council etc.) is available at www.admin.ch/ school for a year? Agriviva, www.agriviva.ch, is an association votes or via the Federal Chancellery’s VoteInfo Young students or recent graduates from that organises placements lasting several app. countries whose official national language weeks for young people aged up to 25 and is English, German, French, Spanish or Ital- from around the world. In return for free On 4 November 2020, the Federal Council de- ian can gain teaching experience in Swit- board and lodging and a small amount of cided that there will be three federal propos- zerland. As native speakers, they enrich pocket money, you will help a farming fam- als submitted to the people on 7 March 2021: language lessons and exemplify cultural as- ily with their daily work. These placements pects of their country of residence. Lan- are ideal for young people who like to be ac- ■■ Popular initiative “Yes to a ban on full guage assistants receive a salary which just tive, love the outdoors, and are keen to get facial coverings” covers their living costs in Switzerland. Ap- to know a new family and experience life ■■ Federal Act on Electronic Identification plications for the 2021/22 school year are be- on a Swiss farm. (RG) Services ing accepted until the end of March 2021. ■■ Federal Decree on the approval of a eduationsuisse offers young Swiss Abroad specific ­comprehensive economic partnership For detailed information about the Language Assistants advice on all matters related to education in Switzerland. agreement between the EFTA member programme, please consult ogy.de/movetia or send an Its employees speak German, French, Italian, Spanish states and Indonesia email to [email protected]. and English and are available to answer your questions via email, telephone, Skype or in the office in Berne. Would you like to work as an au pair in Popular initiatives Switzerland? educationsuisse, Education in Switzerland, Working as an au pair for a family with chil- Alpenstrasse 26, 3006 Berne, The following federal popular initiative had dren can be a good opportunity for young Switzerland, Tel. +41 31 356 61 04 ­already been launched at the time of going to Swiss Abroad to get to know their country [email protected] press (deadline for the collection of signatures of origin better. The salary is nothing to www.educationsuisse.ch in brackets): write home about, but they receive free board and lodging and enough spare time ■■ Federal Popular Initiative to attend a language course, for example. “Pay 7,500 francs to every Swiss citizen (Helicopter Money Initiative)” (20.04.2022) Various organisations arrange au pair placements. Please contact educationsuisse for a list of addresses. The list of pending popular initiatives is available in German at: www.bk.admin.ch > Politische Rechte > Volksinitiativen > Hängige Volksinitiativen

Language assistant Leslie Schmid, Swiss Abroad from Canada, at work Photo provided.

Responsible for the FDFA official communications: Consular Directorate Innovation and Partnerships Effingerstrasse 27, 3003 Berne, Switzerland www.eda.admin.ch, email: [email protected]

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 Mailbag 29

The elections to the Council of the Swiss Abroad What a fantastic research, congratulations to the researchers and the “Swiss Review” for this wonderful publication. As an An election where only the members of certain associations agroecologist and soil scientist I think we can promote this ap- can vote is a bit like no one apart from registered members of proach in soil research in Brazil. political parties being able to determine the composition of the GILSON WALMOR DAHMER, MATINHOS, PARANÁ, BRAZIL National Council. Surely it should be easy to record every Swiss citizen living abroad – the various diplomatic missions should have everyone’s address. To be a truly representative council, Implications for the framework agreement the CSA needs to get Switzerland’s embassies to conduct the after voters reject the “limitation initiative” elections. SEBASTIAN RENOLD, BRNO, CZECH REPUBLIC A “resounding ‘yes’ to the bilateral re- The CSA elections are for an exclusive club. It says in the last is- lationship with the EU” is by no means sue that “Any Swiss Abroad is entitled to vote, provided that a yes to an agreement that states that they belong to a recognised Swiss association”. Yet Swiss one party – the European Court of Jus- Abroad affiliated to associations are a clear minority among tice – would adjudicate disputes be- Swiss living abroad. Therefore, delegates elected by association tween Switzerland and the EU. That members cannot claim to “represent the interests of all Swiss would be like a child’s father settling a Abroad”. A democratically elected “Parliament of the Fifth Swit- quarrel with someone else’s child. No, Switzerland – your sov- zerland” would be different to what we have now. ereignty is more important than bowing to diktats from Lux- ARTHUR MEYER, VIENNA, AUSTRIA embourg. I am grateful that a party like the SVP are opposed. They are still Switzerland’s biggest party, so less of the schaden- freude, please. JÜRG SCHWENDENER, PHUKET, THAILAND What does our home soil sound like? History has shaped the political framework of Swiss democ- A noisy soil is a healthy soil! There is more bio- racy, which is heavily influenced by our country’s unique diversity under than above the surface. These mountain geography. This is why the Swiss people alone must organisms are responsible for the environmen- continue to have the final word on how Switzerland’s law- tal benefits soils provide us. Very nice publica- makers run the country. If there is to be any rapprochement tion by the “Swiss Review”. And important to with the EU, Switzerland must insist on having special status. grow awareness about the soil, usually not val- DORIS THUT, MUNICH, GERMANY ued by people... seen by many as just dirt! Con- gratulations! CRISTINE MUGGLER, MINAS GERAIS, BRAZIL It is quite interesting to see that most of the reader comments here are critical of the EU. In no way do they reflect political at- Thank you for this very interesting piece. There is indeed a titudes among the wider Swiss expatriate community. Anyone noticeable difference between organically and intensively cul- who thinks that their nationalistic, backward-looking outlook tivated land – the latter is devoid of life! What a fascinating is the answer to all our ills is in cloud cuckoo land. study. ALAIN BONET, KIBBUTZ TZE’ELIM, ISRAEL CHRISTOPH TWERENBOLD, COLOGNE, GERMANY

A new-found miracle of nature – incredible! And something from which we can all learn. Many thanks for this article. MARIANNE SFINAROLAKI-BÜHLER, CRETE, GREECE

IMPRINT: are fully responsible for the content of and Partnerships, responsible for Swiss Abroad, Alpenstrasse 26, All Swiss Abroad who are registered CHANGE OF ADDRESS: Please advise “Swiss Review”, the magazine for the advertisements and promotional inserts. news.admin.ch 3006 Berne, Tel.: +41313566110. with a Swiss representation receive your local embassy or consulate. Do not Swiss Abroad, is in its 47th year of This content does not necessarily EDITORIAL ASSISTANT: Sandra Krebs Account: IBAN CH97 0079 0016 1294 the magazine free of charge. write to the editorial office in Berne. publication and is published in German, represent the opinion of either the TRANSLATION: SwissGlobal Language 4609 8 / KBBECH22 Anyone else can subscribe to the French, English and Spanish in editorial office or the publisher. Services AG; LAYOUT: Joseph Haas, Email: [email protected] magazine for an annual fee 14 regional editions. It has a total EDITORS: Marc Lettau (MUL), Zürich; PRINT: Vogt-Schild Druck AG, (Switzerland: CHF 30 / abroad: CHF 50). circulation of 431,000, including 253,000 Editor-in-Chief; Stéphane Herzog (SH); 4552 Derendingen Subscribers are sent the magazine electronic copies. Regional news appears Theodora Peter (TP); Susanne Wenger POSTAL ADDRESS: Publisher, editorial COPY DEADLINE for this edition: direct from Berne. four times a year. The ordering parties (SWE); Consular Directorate, Innovation office, advertising: Organisation of the 29 November 2020 www.revue.ch

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 30 Books Sounds

Voting day Life after the Lovebugs

“It was going to be the best possible day. Vreni There has been no media fuss, nor is it official didn’t care about the fog that had been smoth- yet, but the Lovebugs – one of the most suc- ering the farm since Friday...”. Farmer’s wife cessful Swiss pop acts of the last 25 years – are Vreni is supposed to be making sandwiches quietly disbanding. Or, shall we say, they are for the ballot counters, as she does on every putting the project on ice. Indefinitely. voting day. But this year is very different, be- And what has the frontman been doing to cause she must travel to Berne for an opera- while away the time during this potentially tion. Her daughter Margrit, who works in the ADRIAN SIEBER: permanent interruption? He has recorded a “You, Me & Everything Else”, city as a secretary, is due to meet her there. But solo album. Adrian Sieber made his epony- Phonag, 2020 Vreni ends up having to come to her daugh- mous debut 12 years ago, and now the singer CLARE O’DEA: ter’s aid before going under the knife. Margrit has doubled up during the Covid lull with “Voting Day” ISBN 978-2-9701445-0-2 is being sexually harassed by her boss and un- “You, Me & Everything Else”. 119 pages, CHF 20 able to stop his advances. Sieber has already shown that he can While in hospital, Vreni gets to know write great melodies – Lovebugs hits like “Bit- cleaning lady Esther and her boss Beatrice. Es- ter Moon” and “Music Makes My World Go ther was taken from her Yenish family and put into care as a child. Round” are Swiss pop gold. The lead singer of Basel’s favourite band Now her own son has been taken away and put into a foster home. The is now back at his melancholic yet optimistic best, with a memorable boy works at Vreni’s farm. Beatrice is a middle-class single woman collection of songs that create a sound that is both euphoric and vul- who is devoted to her job as an administrator at the hospital. She has nerable on the one hand and raw and multi-layered on the other. also been putting her heart and soul into the yes campaign for wom- Talking of sound, analogue synthesisers and drum machines are en’s suffrage – the issue on which the country is voting on this par- conspicuous throughout – as opposed to guitars from Sieber’s band ticular Sunday in 1959. years. Opener “The Soft Revolution” features an airy, anachronistic In “Voting Day”, author Clare O’Dea devotes a chapter to each of synth rhythm, pimped computer beats and naturally a catchy melody these four very different women whose paths cross – and life trajec- – an aesthetic that runs through the entire album. The style is unmis- tories change – on this day in 1959. It is an important day for all Swiss takably 1980s – “The school disco music of my youth in Fricktal,” says women, because Swiss men are voting for the first (but not the last) Sieber, tongue firmly in cheek. time on whether women should get the right to vote. O’Dea tells the For years, Sieber was able to live out his dream as a professional story as seen through the eyes of these four women, all of whom have musician. He is now a 47-year-old father and primary school teacher, different social backgrounds. She adroitly intertwines the characters’ hence the album addresses themes such as growing older, relation- respective life stories to highlight the situation of women in Switzer- ships going sour, chemistry between people, and life in the real world. land at the end of the 1950s. The author writes in a simple yet very af- Some of the lyrics are wistful, but – typical Sieber – hope and happi- fectionate way, recounting the fate of women who want to take con- ness still shine through in every song. trol of their own lives. This is a good album. Now all that is left for Sieber to do is perform Clare O’Dea was born in 1971 in Dublin, where she went on to study his new tracks on stage when the pandemic is over one day. And, who languages and work as a journalist. She has lived in Switzerland in knows, maybe the Lovebugs will also get back together. the canton of Fribourg since 2003, on the invisible line where the MARKO LEHTINEN French- and German-speaking cultures meet. She is an author, a jour- nalist and a translator. Her acclaimed non-fiction book “The Naked Swiss” was published in 2016. “Voting Day” is O’Dea’s short debut novel, available in the original English as well as in German, French and Italian. RUTH VON GUNTEN

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 Top Pick News 31

Livia Leu

No turns to yes SVP doyen and former Federal Councillor Christoph Blocher will receive a 1.1-million-franc pension. After being ousted from the Federal Council in 2007, the billionaire publicly declared that he would not draw his ministerial pension entitlement. But he made a U-turn in July 2020 by demanding a backdated pension worth 2.7 million. The gov- ernment has now decided to pay him 1.1 million francs – and do everything in its power to prevent similar episodes in future. (MUL) Serious allegations against Darius Rochebin Star journalist Darius Rochebin featured in the last issue of “Swiss Review”. However, serious allegations were made against him shortly after we went to press. According to the newspaper “Le Temps”, employees at French-language Swiss broadcaster RTS have made sexual harassment com- plaints against a number of executives. One of those ac- cused is Darius Rochebin. Gilles Marchand, director gen- eral of the Swiss Broadcasting Corporation and previously head of RTS until 2017, admitted mistakes and called for an Livia Leu has the hardest job in Swiss diplomacy. The Federal Coun- urgent investigation. We await further details. (MUL) cil has appointed her as the new chief negotiator for further talks with the EU on the Swiss-EU framework agreement. Leu has a monumen- The CVP remove their Christian label tal task ahead of her – a nut that was too hard to crack for her prede- The Christian Democratic People’s Party (CVP) are ditch- cessors. However, this 59-year-old leading diplomat has overcome ing the “C”, having decided in November that their new other notable challenges during her long career. In 2008, the then For- name will be “The Centre” from 2021 onwards. They say eign Minister Micheline Calmy-Rey appointed Leu the new Swiss am- that removing the adjective “Christian” from their name bassador to Iran – making her the first-ever female head of a foreign will make it easier to appeal to urban voters in the middle diplomatic mission in Tehran. Leu also represented US interests in of the political spectrum. The CVP, whose conservative and Iran during her time in this role (Iran and the USA have had no for- Catholic origins date back to the 19th century, have been mal diplomatic relations since 1980). For example, she helped to se- represented in the Federal Council since 1891. (MUL) cure the release of three young American tourists who had been held at the notorious Evin prison for two years on suspicion of spying. The BDP merge with the CVP After almost five years in Iran, Leu returned with her family to In future, Swiss politics will have one party less. The Con- Berne, where she subsequently headed the Bilateral Economic Rela- servative Democratic Party (BDP), founded in 2008, will tions Division within the Federal Administration. She then took on also be part of “The Centre”. That is to say, it is merging the prestigious role of Swiss ambassador to France in 2018, before be- with the CVP. Both parties have stood shoulder to shoul- ing reassigned to the Federal Department of Foreign Affairs by Fed- der at federal level in recent years. The CVP are strongest eral Councillor Ignazio Cassis last autumn. Now the government is in Catholic areas of the country, while the BDP performs pinning its hopes on Leu to break the Swiss-EU logjam. Speaking to best in the cantons of Berne and Grisons. (MUL) the media for the first time in her new post, she said that she was “look- ing forward to this big challenge”. On how much bargaining scope “Marriage for all” becomes a reality there was in Brussels, Leu – ever the diplomat – gave little away to jour- Switzerland has paved the way for same-sex marriage. In nalists. But she did say that “creative solutions” were needed. In other December, the Council of States ratified the National Coun- words? “More than just a plan A or a plan B.” THEODORA PETER cil’s decision to allow same-sex couples to tie the knot. Les- bian couples wanting to start a family will also be able to receive sperm donations. (MUL)

Swiss Review / February 2021 / No. 1 We need our first snow taxi. Les Giettes, Valais, © Ivo Scholz Les Giettes, Valais,

We need Switzerland.

Discover Winter now: MySwitzerland.com/firsttime Tell us about your favourite experiences using #IneedSwitzerland

126_21d_01_ins_aso_schweizer_revue_jan.indd 1 18.12.20 15:59