Subglacial Lake Ellsworth CEE V2.Indd
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Proposed Exploration of Subglacial Lake Ellsworth Antarctica Draft Comprehensive Environmental Evaluation February 2011 1 The cover art was created by first, second, and third grade students at The Village School, a Montessori school located in Waldwick, New Jersey. Art instructor, Bob Fontaine asked his students to create an interpretation of the work being done on The Lake Ellsworth Project and to create over 200 of their own imaginary microbes. This art project was part of The Village School’s art curriculum that links art with ongoing cultural work. 2 Contents Non Technical Summary .................................................4 Personnel ............................................................................................ 26 Chapter 1: Introduction ...................................................6 Power generation and fuel calculations ....................................... 27 Chapter 2: Description of proposed activity..................7 Vehicles ................................................................................................ 28 Background and justification ..............................................................7 Water and waste ...............................................................................28 The site ...................................................................................................8 Communications ............................................................................... 28 Chapter 3: Baseline conditions of Lake Ellsworth .........9 Transport of equipment and personnel .......................................28 Location..................................................................................................9 Equipment and personnel removal ............................................... 28 Geophysical surveys and available data ...........................................9 Contingency plans .............................................................................29 Radio-echo sounding surveys .........................................................10 Safe Site Procedures .........................................................................29 Ice sheet surface ................................................................................ 11 Chapter 6: Identification or prediction of impacts, Lake surface and extent ................................................................... 11 including preventative or mitigating measures ...........30 Bed topography ................................................................................. 11 Methods and data used to predict impacts and mitigation measures ............................................................................................. 30 Englacial layering ................................................................................12 Impact on native flora and fauna within Lake Ellsworth........... 30 Lake-water depth ..............................................................................12 Microbial control at design stage ................................................... 31 Water circulation and lake hydrological balance........................ 12 Microbial control during construction, transport and Basal sediments.................................................................................. 13 deployment on site ...........................................................................31 Ice flow ................................................................................................13 Population Reduction Methods ..................................................... 32 Ice cores and lake geochemistry ................................................... 14 Verification and assessment ............................................................33 Surface accumulation ........................................................................ 14 Analytical methods ........................................................................... 34 Meteorological conditions .............................................................. 15 Developments planned by the Lake Ellsworth Consortium ... 34 Summary of lake access site ........................................................... 15 Impact to air .......................................................................................34 Microbial content of the lake ......................................................... 15 Impact to ice ...................................................................................... 35 Microbial content of the snow .......................................................16 Impact to native flora and fauna (on the ice surface) ...............37 Fauna and Flora ................................................................................. 16 Non recovery of equipment ...........................................................37 Protected Areas ................................................................................. 16 Impact on wilderness and aesthetics ............................................37 Chapter 4: Description of the technologies .................16 Cumulative impacts .......................................................................... 37 Hot Water Drill ................................................................................. 16 Programme and site management .................................................37 Deployment of instruments ............................................................ 21 Impact matrices .................................................................................38 Probe description .............................................................................. 21 Chapter 7: Alternatives ..................................................42 Probe mounted corer ......................................................................21 Lake access technique ......................................................................42 Instrumentation ................................................................................. 21 Alternative lakes ................................................................................42 Topside equipment ............................................................................ 22 Microbial control ...............................................................................42 Sediment corer ..................................................................................22 Not proceeding ................................................................................. 43 Thermistor string ..............................................................................22 Chapter 8: Assessment and verification of impacts Sampling strategy .............................................................................. 22 and monitoring ...............................................................44 Fieldwork analysis ............................................................................. 23 Monitoring .......................................................................................... 44 Laboratory analysis ...........................................................................24 Environmental Audit ......................................................................... 44 Microbiology ...................................................................................... 24 Chapter 9: Gaps in knowledge and uncertainties .......45 Biological analysis ..............................................................................24 Chapter 10: Conclusions ................................................45 Organic geochemistry ...................................................................... 25 References .......................................................................................... 47 Hydrochemistry ................................................................................ 25 Appendix 1: Access to Lake Ellsworth: blowout likelihood, risk analysis and mitigation.............................................................. 50 Sedimentology and palaeo-analysis ............................................... 26 Annex 1: Engineering Blowout Prevention Strategies ............... 55 Integration of in situ and laboratory data .................................... 26 Appendix 2: Subglacial Lake Ellsworth Program – Advisory Chapter 5: Description of the camp and the logistics 26 Committee ......................................................................................... 58 Camp overview and location ......................................................... 26 Non Technical Summary Introduction • To build a hot water drill capable of drilling cleanly through A draft Comprehensive Environmental Evaluation (CEE) has up to 3.5 km ice. been carried out by the British Antarctic Survey (BAS) for the • To construct a sampling probe capable of measuring and proposed investigation of Ellsworth Subglacial Lake in West sampling the water column and surface sediment. Antarctica (referred to hereafter as Lake Ellsworth). • To construct a sediment corer capable of retrieving a 1 m to This draft CEE has been prepared in accordance with 3 m sediment core. Annex I of the Protocol on Environmental Protection to the • To develop a communications tether that can be used to Antarctic Treaty (1998). The guidelines for Environmental lower the probe / corer and guide its measurement and Impact assessment in Antarctica (Resolution 4, ATCM XXVIII, sampling strategy. 2005) were also consulted. This draft CEE describes the • To design and