Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Spring/Printemps 2021 — No. 50 An occasional Newsletter for members and friends of The Monarchist League of Canada The Monarchist League of Canada / La Ligue Monarchiste du Canada, PO Box 1057, Lakeshore West PO, Oakville, Ontario, Canada L6K 0B2 905-855-7262 (800) 465-6925 www.monarchist.ca THE MONARCHIST LEAGUE OF CANADA – 51th ANNIVERSARY 1970-2021

ELIZABETH II at 95 our Queen, Friend & Head of the Nation PAYETTE DEPARTURE DAMAGING L.A. CELEB CULTURE FOR HARRY, IN THRALL TO OPRAH QUEEN, CHARLES, CAMILLA, WILLIAM, CATHERINE, LIEUTENANT GOVERNORS DO THEIR DUTY

Report and commentary by The Monarchist League of Canada here are two distinct kinds of celebrity these days. One is occasionally distorted by sensation-seeking media pandering to Tself-seeking, often financially rewarding, embraced and en- an under-informed audience. Happily, the long arc of history abled by even “serious” media. Frequently it is also selfish, and sober second thought dub it valuable for humans and civi- short-lived and shallow. lizations alike as the stuff of lasting happiness, the bulwark of The other is selfless, not focused on monetary gain, more than greatness. So, let’s ask a few questions.

THE PAYETTE FIASCO: DAMAGING TO OUR CROWN Who on earth briefed Julie pols and bureaucrats over the and so on ad nauseam. In the birthplace nor its roots, maybe Payette as to the expectations years to permit the “Household” restrictive climate of isolated it’s time for a new one. that apply to any Governor Gen- at Rideau Hall to become a re- households, COVID-restrictions, Not that much considered eral, yet still allow plenty of volving door, with employment fatigue and worry, rumour and re publican opinion exists that room for particular enthusiasms eventually the locus of abusive, sensation abound and gain a cur- The Queen’s 95th and a Platinum and causes? If indeed “someone” unhappy behaviour recently doc- rency beyond proportion. Jubilee might not remedy: true, did so, how could the message umented in excruciating detail? Then, too, a fallback argument yet shallow in implication. And have been so misunderstood? How could a clearly brave, tal- of some monarchists has been the mere notion of an Aus- Who did due diligence prior to ented and intelligent woman for “Well, if you don’t care for the tralian- debate/re ferendum her selection, no great talent in whom the country initially wish- ‘British’ roots of our Monarchy, down the road is appalling – as HR being needed to suggest it ed only success, and which ad- in fact day-to-day it is our fellow Canada would then be reduced to might begin with recent employ- mired her journeying through Canadians, the GG and LGs, who enduring a permanently-dimin- ers. And who imagined that al- the vast depths of space, have “are” the Crown.” Clearly, if the ished and partisanally-de bated lowing her to import her Private been allowed to steer her Ottawa Royal soap opera is unappealing Monarchy in a state of endless Secretary into the particular cul- course so off-chart? And what is for some, to find its supposedly- controversy, a so called “Crown - ture once a source of pride at the plan to rebuild the deraci- worst feature transplanted by ed Republic” a term used by Rideau Hall could end happily? nated and depopulated talent scandal at home is anything but some Down Under “monar- What indifference caused many pool at Rideau Hall? The lack of helpful. Logic then follows: if the chists” who should know better! a seasoned, loyal team to run The system is not ideal in either its Queen’s Canadian Home was a recipe for any GG to run into problems. Remediating that ab- McCOWAN NAMED GG SECRETARY sence is as important as choosing Jan 28 saw the Prime Minister tence to enable the next Gover- “the right” person to represent bring new leadership “to restore nor General to share particular our Sovereign. There is good rea- a healthy work environment” at interests while conforming to son to believe that newly-ap- Rideau Hall by plucking Ian Mc- the dignity, norms and historic pointed Secretary to the Gover- Cowan from a senior position at expectations of anyone who rep- nor General Ian McCowan is the Privy Council Office to be- resents The Queen. well equipped for the enormous come Secretary to the Governor challenge facing him. General. Ottawa insiders praised The Payette fiasco is damaging the appointment, calling him “a to the Canadian Crown for sev- good fit” – “intimately acquainted : let down eral reasons, beginning with folk with the ways of Ottawa, he can Queen and country wondering how the appointment call anyone and get action imme- could go do wrong, and asking diately,” Considered probably the whether even the government best qualified to serve since the thinks it is of little importance? revered Esmond Butler, his early As well, knowledge of Civics, recruitment to Rideau Hall of while improved since the sixties former staffers from the halcyon and seventies, remains lament - days of augured ably shallow, and allows for a well, as does his good under- worried citizenry, egged on by standing of the personal role he no-nothing media and their has to play as Secretary. It is “polls”, to declare the Monarchy hoped that McCowan restores a irrelevant, the sky about to fall high level of loyalty and compe-

2 – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 left, Oprah: allowed allegations without names WHY DO WE FEEL SO CONFLICTED ABOUT HARRY? above, Harry – once our Harry! The Royals mirror our own fami- brother and their wives. grandmother yet implying she pre- lies, wherein we have favourite sib- So, with his Grandfather gravely sides over but unaware of some lings and loved elders, along with ill, the world rocked by COVID, the racist conventicle. She who has been unique rituals and hallowed tradi- sacrifices to “normal” life being em- the soul of the multi-racial Com- tions, all jockeying for place with braced by his family and the Realms, monwealth, with countless Black naughty uncles and unemployed how could he have allowed himself Prime Ministers, many having em- cousins. And not infrequently a dot- on Commonwealth Sunday, no less, erg ed from colonial rule, esteeming ing parent will “excuse” a child’s to become part of Oprah’s travelling her as confidante and friend. And fault, a loving granny slip him a few circus of celebrity, with Canada ret- Oprah – hitherto a much-admired bucks and his kin agree that the rospectively nothing more than a interviewer of substance – abandon- (5th) job or the (3rd) wife will surely way-station on the road to Holly- ing journalistic standards in favour be his salvation. Love is wonderful, wood? of mutual tear-shedding; giving vir- foregiveness admirable and patience At once both hurtful to our Royal tually nary a tough challenge to the the gift of the saints. Family and injurious to the Crown endless references to “they said”, However, most of us are not in a way that made the peregrina- “them”, “the firm” and other un- saints – secular or sacred. tions of a sad Duke of Windsor seem identified objects of criticism; not to Harry, O Harry. We will never as nothing by comparison, the man- mention adding supposed cuteness forget that brave boy – our brave boy ifesting of grievance culture on US by doting on the now best-known – walking the long and lonely miles television by two children of privi- chickens in California. Pace Win- behind his Mother’s coffin, so alone lege, at least one of whom should ston: Some chickens! But whose even as billions watched. The have known better, is lamentable. necks were actually being wrung? Hooray Henry years succeeded Let’s be clear about one thing: We’ll opine one likely result of quickly by heroism, the maturity to any one who says she feels depressed this woeful misadventure: greatly- give up the in-theatre military ser- or suicidal should be listened to, be- increased odds on Barbados deter- vice he loved so that his mates lieved and found professional help. mining that its future lies in becom- would not be threatened. The deep However, the narrative of how these ing a republic. Of course that is for concern of all he had learned encap- feelings were apparently not dealt Barbadians to decide. Many of the sulated in his founding the Invictus with is beyond belief – Harry says island monarchies across the Carib- Games. Our pride at his Canadian he was “ashamed” to confide in his bean have at different times con- courtship, where he could move family. In other words, his amour pro- templated what Barbados is calling through streets freely, buy pre trumped his duty to his wife? the end of the colonial era, but none a panini at the local Italian bakery Any other resource failing, he could has acted on it. One might imagine and spend a weekend without the have gone to his father, his brother, various scenarios leading such a intrusion of media. The happiness at his grandmother – and in short country to ditch the Crown: an au- his marriage, bi-racial and bi-conti- order the best medical assistance thoritarian leader bent on accruing nental, set to stand for a new normal would have been procured. untrammelled power; a scandal at of diversity and devotion, perfect The rest was deplorable: a farrago the vice-regal level; perception of for his role as Commonwealth Am- of venting, of slamming family in Royal indifference to a natural dis- bassador. His anticipated partner- public including two of our future aster. Or indeed, some rational dis- ship in a life of service with his Kings, of simpering over love of cussion engaging debate on the topic and then persuading the pub- IN THIS EDITION OF CMN lic of the advantages of a republic. But if The Queen’s Sov ereignty is terminated in Barbados now, the Shout-out to the Essay on Princess world will know who sent the storm Lieutenant Governors 4-5 Elizabeth Gift Book 1935 11-13 that brought the end of the reign of the only monarch Barbados ever en- New bilingual flyer: Au Secours joyed. The Case for the Crown 7-10 la Monarchie 16 continued on page 4

Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 – 3 time of infection. Who could not admire Her Hon- our, the Lieutenant Governor of New Brunswick’s solution to the impossibility of a New Year’s Day Levee inside Government House. The public was as always bade wel- come as Ms Murphy and her partner exchanged masked greetings and distributed treats through the win- dows of attendees’ cars. Bien que son programme soit res treint par le virus, Son Honneur le lieutenant-gouverneur du Québec, J Michel Doyon, a continué de faire sentir la présence de la Couronne, que ce soit en entreprenant la re- mise de la Médaille du lieutenant Our Queen: admired Head of gouverneur pour mérite exception- multi-racial Commonwealth QUEEN, CHARLES, catholic taste in books with a public nel au Centre de la Famille Valcartie, for whom tv and internet have di- l’Inauguration de l’ancienne pou- CAMILLA, WILLIAM, minished literary pursuits. Hardly drière française de la Citadelle de CATHERINE glamorous work this – but her en- Québec ou accueillant jeunes du thusiasm and persistency is the ad- camp de jour citoyen de l’Assemblée How The Queen keeps calm and mired stuff of the working royals. nationale du Québec. carries on is beyond imagination. No less has this constancy been Across the Rockies, despite the What a Monarch! Within days of the true of William and Catherine. How added burden of renovations to cannonade from California HM was we loved Will’s utterly spontaneous Government house, BC’s Lieutenant showing her newly-acquired ease in rejoinder to the media jackals: “The Governor launched the Victory Zoom calls. Smiling and seemingly Royal Family is very much not a Over Covid-19 Garden. Inspired by imperturbable in her 95th year, she racist family.” Called out by the the victory gardens of WWII, the can joke with an Australian Premier brother who, one might have first year of its operation eased food about a new statue honouring her as thought, was joined to him by the insecurity of the vulnerable by pro- easily as she celebrated British Sci- most indissoluble ties of bereave- ducing, harvesting and distributing Queen’s Zoom call with South ence Week. Care, concern for others, ment and hurt, in the past, and by an incredible TON of vegetables, Australia Governor & Premier the supportive bonds and excite- ranging from kale to garlic. Ms ment of shared service into the fu- Austin’s Household collaborated ture. He is evidently possessed of with Premier Horgan’s team and the emotional maturity to encour- government partners to develop a age his children on the UK equiva- safe approach to install the new lent of Mothers’ Day to write cards Cabinet following the 2020 provin- to the grandmother they had never cial election. The unique solution known. And Catherine of her own adhered to all public health regula- volition attended the “banned” vigil tions while complying to all legal for Sarah Everard, the young woman and protocol requirements of our murdered as she walked alone at democracy in an engaging event. night in London, the Duchess’ un- Space doesn’t allow for the entire precedented presence speaking record of vice-regal service by all, loud er than any TV show, and testi- including Their Honours Janice fying to her spot-on judgement – Fillmon’s ongoing Tree Project in what a Queen she shall be! Manitoba to Liz Dowdeswell’s Zoom calls and partnering with Tourism A BIG SHOUT-OUT Ontario to produce a number of agri-tourism adverts for various TO OUR parts of the sector. www.dropbox. LIEUTENANT com/sh/1xi2tp9ovwhmgf8/AABK GOVERNORS gAXcI-Ui6zS7R1mfWGbXa?dl=0 a pitch-perfect statement on the The point is: how well The Queen controversy – what an example for ...how well The Queen is represented by is represented by all her Canadian the rest of us who grumble about all her Canadian vice-regals. And how well vice-regals. And how well they serve, isolation or standing in lines for served by them are we as citizens... doing their duty at trifling expense. shots and shopping! Less covered by the media, and Charles, however stricken at his provided with far fewer resources AND FINALLY: fatherhood being panned even as than the Royals, The Queen’s his own father was ill and hospital- Can adian representatives in the OF POLS, POLLS ized, showed some of his Mother’s provinces have continued to do & PUNDITS… phlegm by managing a laugh when their duty in the face of varying re- reporters shouted questions about strictions on socializing and move- Prime Minister Trudeau replied to re- the interview as he left an engage- ment, and to invent imaginative porters’ questions with calm neu- ment. Camilla, who well under- ways to undertake outreach and trality rather than affirmative sup- stands the nature of the British tabs, tweak tradition to meet the exigen- port for the Monarchy in Canada. “If went on to continue her useful cam- cies of social distancing and all that people want to later talk about con- paign for reading, sharing her goes with being a good subject in continued on page 6

4 – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 Our Lieutenant Governors at Work

Outside Government House, NS Lieutenant Governor How many dogs have their own page on Arthur J LeBlanc makes a Vice-regal website? Meet MacDuff official draw for Family SOS, Austin-Chester, Vice-Regal Canine a charity providing support Consort to Their Honours at Government to families in the Halifax House, Victoria - and a delight to all he area. greets there (except for his “righteous indignation” when squirrels, rabbits, crows or deer appear). The tradition of the Vice-regal’s best friend continues with a very distinguished canine!

Newfoundland & Labrador’s Lieutenant Governor and His Honour ’s Lieutenant Governor, Janet Austin, with Shxwtitostel, a red cedar canoe carved by the Howard Foote adapt to COVID realities, including a series of virtual visits to Honourable Steven Point, 28th Lieutenant Governor of British Columbia, which served as inspiration for the raise spirits at long-term care homes throughout December, assisted by their BC Reconciliation Award, for furthering reconciliation with the Province’s Indigenous peoples, or inspiring dog Sailor Girl, a big hit with the residents! others to continue reconciliation efforts. The first recipients will be honoured in April 2021. Le lieutenant-gouverneur du Québec, J Michel Doyon, dépose une fleur pour marquer le 11 mars, la Journée de commémoration nationale en mémoire des victimes de la COVID-19.

The Queen’s York Rangers visit with their Colonel, the Lieutenant Governor of Ontario

Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 – 5 POLS, POLLS stitutional change and shifting our media have had a field day with the school system, were perpetrated by & PUNDITS... system of government, that’s fine. Payette-Interview dislocation of the the Canadian state, not the British. continued from page 4 They can have those conversations. Canadian Crown, with as usual, sane Reconciliation has always been But right now, I’m not having those and extreme positions jockeying for Canada’s responsibility, and it has conversations.” However, we are in- attention, the former usually be- always been within our power to formed reliably that he has no in- coming more prevalent as time achieve… It is, of course, true that tention whatsoever of touching the passes while the vitriol appears Canada could become a republic, issue. rather more quickly. We thought the while retaining the system of gov- Opposition Leader Erin O’Toole has editorial in the National Post of ernment we inherited from Great been a supporter of the Monarchist March 13 struck the right balance; Britain. But getting rid of the mon- League of Canada, and remains a positive, reasoned – but not adula- archy would entail sweeping consti- convinced monarchist. tory, either. tutional reforms that would require NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh took ad- …The credit for this country’s tremendous effort and huge ex- vantage of the post-interview cli- legacy of stable government, free- pense, with very little benefit. It mate to re-assert his republican po- dom, democracy, justice and the would also necessitate a historic sition, contrary to the long tradition rule of law rests chiefly with the agreement between Canada’s in- of democratic socialist support for Crown, but we rarely hear this ac- creasingly disparate regions and na- the Crown exemplified by figures knowledged by our politicians or tionalities that could very easily tear such as Jack Layton and Allan Blak- the chattering classes… While the country apart. Far better to stick eney. He told CTV’s Question Period racism is always inexcusable, this with a system that has proven re- that “I don’t see the relevance of it, controversy is no more an admon- markably stable and successful for and I don’t think that most Canadi- ishment of the Crown than the over 150 years, and a Queen who has ans do.” The party is holding a Vir- actions of our prime minister are a served us extremely well for nearly tual Convention in April 9-11. At repudiation of Parliamentary 70. Long may she reign. press time it was unclear if a ru- democ racy… the monarchy itself is What more can we say? This has moured republican resolution had more than just a group of individu- not been a tempest in a teapot. Nor been proposed and, if so, whether it als. It is an ideal. An ideal that holds will it prove the undoing of the would be selected for consideration that a country is more than just the Crown’s representing “all that is best by delegates. sum of its parts; more than just the and most admired in the Canadian Without any recent statement of people who run it or its institutions. ideal.” Annamie Paul’s position, the Green … a monarchy can rise above the There is sadness, and much to be Party Leader previously indicated rough-and-tumble world of politics, reflected on, not least that when we she had “no position” on the offering stability and serving as a speak from choler and disappoint- Monarchy, in sharp contrast to the beacon of the ideals we strive to up- ment, we perhaps deepen the divi- support enthusiastically given by hold. The royals themselves will not sions of all who hear us: family, her monarchist predecessor Eliza- always live up to those ideals, be- country, Commonwealth – albeit we beth May. cause they too are human. But the may imagine our venting to be sat- The pollsters have been hard at Crown transcends even those who isfying. work questioning Canadians about wear it… getting rid of the monar- But there is also joy: the example their views on the Crown. Unfortu- chy would not fix any of the prob- of our Queen and her succeeding nately, some persist in inviting neg- lems faced by Aboriginals, or settle generations; the gifts of unsung ative opinion by asking leading any of the disputes between First heroes ranging from first respon- questions about whether the coun- Nations and the federal govern- ders to Lieutenant Governors; the try should continue to have ties to ment. It would only add legal com- calmness of our national life despite “the British Monarchy” which of plications since many First Nations pandemic. The long view is surely course suggests ours is a foreign have treaties that were signed di- promising, as Clough reminds us, monarchy, alien to these shores. rectly with the Crown. And a lot of for although the sun seems to They might as well ask if we should the injustices inflicted on Aborigi- emerge so slowly, “But Westward, continue with “the Papua New nal people, such as the residential look: the land is bright.” Guinean Monarchy” or “the New Zealand Monarchy.” That said, all polls showed a significant shift in THE CASE FOR THE CROWN greater negative attitudes towards The next four pages of CMN in English and in French – the Crown. Of course we’d rather see refreshed or greater support in is the League’s newest flyer, designed to summarize these surveys, as the contrary makes major arguments for Canada’s constitutional monarchy. news and implicitly suggests change You can find it online in the publications section of our is inevitably in the air. But we know website – monarchist.ca – or request colour copies from that all polling is naturally condi- [email protected] – surely all readers can think of three tioned by the news of the day – and people to whom they could give a copy! we can expect they will begin to re- bound as the country considers BIEN FONDÉS DE LA MONARCHIE more fully the truth of what it has heard of late, and celebrates The CONSTITUTIONELLE Queen’s 95th birthday, Prince Les quatre pages suivantes du NMC en anglais et en français – Philip’s 100th, and the unique cele- est le plus récent dépliant de la Ligue, avec les principaux bration of a Platinum Jubilee in arguments pour notre monarchie. Vous pouvez le trouver en 2022. Indeed the same sort of happy events turned around the polls after ligne – “publications” de notre site Web – monarchist.ca – the long nightmare of the disinte- ou demander des copies de [email protected]. Sans doute gration of Charles and Diana’s mar- tous nos lecteurs peuvent penser à trois personnes à qui riage. ils pourraient donner un exemplaire! Pundits in traditional and social

6 – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 LA LIGUE MONARCHISTE DU CANADA THE MONARCHIST LEAGUE OF CANADA monarchist.ca CP 1057, RPO Lakeshore West, Oakville, ON L6K 0B2 [email protected] BIEN-FONDÉ DE LA MONARCHIE CONSTITUTIONELLE 9 avantages-clés

CHEF DE NATION VERSUS CHEF D’ÉTAT Jour après ARBITRES DU FÉDÉRALISME : ONZE 1jour nos représentants élus démocratiquement sont 3COURONNES Le Canada est un État fédéral : au cœur de débats profitables à propos desquels il y notre Constitution donne le pouvoir de légiférer a parfois de la controverse. C’est bien. Cela encourage la dans certains domaines à Ottawa et dans d’autres recherche de la réussite et la réalisation d’accomplisse- domaines aux provinces. Les gouvernements exercent ments pour des objectifs à la fois partisans et personnels. ce pouvoir au nom de la Reine. Ainsi, il existe 11 Le Premier ministre est tour à tour le Chef du gouverne- couronnes au Canada - légalement appelées « La ment et « leader » d’un parti politique suscitant parfois Reine du chef du Canada » ou « La Reine du chef » certaines divergences. Le Souverain représente, quant d’une province. La Reine est représentée par un à lui, l’unité au sein de la nation et ses représentants Lieutenant-gouverneur. Les premiers ministres, dont ont la confiance de tous les Canadiens. La monarchie le séparatiste René Lévesque, ont souligné l’importance protège et rassemble à la fois tous ce que les Canadiens de la Couronne dans leur Déclaration constitutionnelle recherchent et demeure constante malgré les élections clé de 1978. Puisque la monarchie donne l’autorité à et les changements au pouvoir : c’est-à-dire une société chaque entité législative, elle garantit également que tolérante et responsable. En présidant plusieurs événe- l’État de droit sera respecté dans le traitement des ments dont les Jeux Olympiques, la célébration de la différends entre Ottawa et les provinces. Ces faits Confédération canadienne sur la colline parlementaire, expliquent le fort soutien des provinces à l’institution la Reine et sa famille soulignent l’importance d’une par- de la monarchie, qui réconcilie l’identité régionale ticipation non-partisane mettant ainsi l’emphase sur le avec l’unité nationale. pouvoir unificateur de ces grands rassemblements, lui - IDENTITÉ NATIONALE, STABILITÉ & FIERTÉ conférantainsi une autre dimension. 4La proximité géographique, les échanges commer- GARDIEN DE LA LIBERTÉ Le Parlement, la Reine, ciaux, les accords militaires ainsi que la facilité 2le Sénat et la Chambre des Communes. Aucune loi, avec laquelle nous pouvons être envahis par les médias aucun règlement ou dépense n’est autorisé sans américains peuvent affecter notre identité nationale. l’assentiment royal. Le Parlement est élu et dissous Notre gouvernance favorise la loyauté et l’appartenance avec son accord et en son nom. C’est également en à un monarque plutôt qu’à une person nalité politique ou son nom que sont élus les représentants officiels et une idéologie. Cette différence nous apporte une culture les diplomates; que les accords sont rectifiés et les distincte, à la fois dynamique et paisible. La monarchie commissions d’enquêtes formées. En temps normal constitutionnelle – version canadienne – procure la ce n’est qu’une formalité. Toutefois la prérogative stabilité. Cet état de fait est confirmé chaque année dans « royale » s’assure que l’accord des lois prévaut en le « Rapport sur le dévelop pent humain » produit par apportant une garantie de neutralité non-violente les « Nations Unies » et dans lequel le Canada figure et non-partisane – pouvant éteindre les débuts régulièrement au sein des premiers pays. Les change- d’incendies constitutionnels tel qu’expliqué par ments sont cependant inévitables et la plupart sont pour Frank McKinnon un politicien scientifique de le mieux au gré des politiciens et des événements qui se l’ – si le débat politique devait dégénérer. succèdent. Les Canadiens ont voté dans non moins de Ainsi même un gouvernement populaire ne pourrait vingt-deux élections depuis l’avènement d’Élizabeth II! déclencher des élections simplement pour justifier La monarchie amène une stabilité malgré tous les un point de vue ou une démarche quelconque. changements. La souveraine possède plusieurs années d’expérience et constitue une figure de référence importante vu son parcours presque sans faille.

Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 – 7 SERMENTS : UTILES ET PERSONNELS La loyauté connaissance du système monarchique comme forme 5la plus profonde des humains est envers les autres de gouvernement. En 1867, les Pères de la Confédération êtres humains. Les serments sont prêtés à la Reine ont dès lors unanimement opté pour la forme d’une par nos nouveaux compatriotes, les législateurs, les monarchie constitutionnelle pour le Canada. En 1982, juges, les membres des FC et de nombreux autres la nouvelle Constitution du Canada a entériné la fonctionnaires. Faire leur promesse à la Souveraine Couronne de sorte que seul un accord unanime entre plutôt qu’à un politicien montre que leur loyauté ultime les paliers provinciaux et le fédéral pourrait changer n’est pas envers des figures élues, mais envers les lois la donne. Enfin, le Parlement a adopté unanimement qui constituent le tissu de la société civilisée. Ces en 2013 la « Loi sur la succession au Trône » qui Serments soulignent que le respect de l’État de droit supprime les barrières indépendamment du sexe applicable à tous doit prévaloir sur la partisanerie – pour statuer du futur monarque. agir pour promouvoir le bien-être d’un segment étroit COMMUNAUTÉ, BÉNÉVOLAT, de la société. Les Serments à la Reine reflètent RECONNAISSANCE Dans leurs déplacements également l’accent mis par le Canada sur l’importance 8 constants, la Reine, les membres de la famille de la personne, de la dignité et de l’égalité de chaque royale et ses représentants au Canada apportent leur individu : dès que les nouveaux citoyens prêtent le soutien aux communautés et aux secteurs bénévoles : serment de citoyenneté, ils deviennent des membres à une partie vitale de notre existence nationale. Ils part entière de la famille canadienne. Chaque Canadien inspirent de nombreuses personnes à rendre des prête allégeance à la Reine, rendant ainsi hommage à services similaires. Ils créent et décernent des ses décennies de service à l’ensemble du Canada. distinctions honorifiques non politiques à des UNE MONARCHIE PARTAGÉE Les Canadiens concitoyens exceptionnels. Ces activités royales et 6possèdent une grande chance d’avoir à leur tête vice-royales ne figurent pas souvent dans les une Souveraine dont la figure emblématique est programmes d’information nationaux. L’ouverture immédiatement et mondialement reconnue. La Reine d’une nouvelle bibliothèque, la visite d’une salle de ainsi que tous les membres de la famille Royale tissent la Légion, un discours à un cours d’éducation civique un lien unique sans caractère militaire affiché entre tous dans une école ou un déjeuner avec un club de service les membres de notre population dans toute sa diversité local ne sont pas dans le collimateur des médias. avec le reste du Commonwealth. Les nations issues de la Mais ils constituent la base de notre société civile Nouvelle-Guinée jusqu’au Bélize, de la Nouvelle-Zélande et apportent une grande fierté et une aide importante jusqu’à l’Inde, reflètent également la richesse du Canada aux communautés du Canada. d’aujourd’hui. En 2010, notre Reine s’envola de Toronto UNE RÉPUBLIQUE : DISTRAYANT & INDÉSIRABLE vers New York pour s’adresser aux Nations-Unies. Personne n’a encore proposé un autre système La veille au soir, la Reine annonça fièrement lors d’un 9 de gouvernement pour le Canada qui refléterait diner officiel à Toronto : « Je voyagerai de ce Royaume de la même manière l’histoire de notre nation et serait nordique en tant que Reine du Canada ». Le Gouverneur supérieur à la monarchie constitutionnelle en termes Général et les Lieutenants-gouverneurs représentent de fonctionnement quotidien de l’État canadien. Les la Reine et assument les responsabilités qui leur Canadiens se souviennent des débats constitutionnels incombent au nom de la Souveraine. Cette disposition déchirants du siècle dernier. De tels arguments n’ont permet à notre pays de faire partager des traditions rien fait pour aider les objectifs essentiels de la d’une ancienne monarchie dont hérite l’histoire du population : l’environnement, les salles de classe Canada, alors que, dans le même temps, nous nous surpeuplées, l’accès aux soins de santé et le soutien aux remémorons des services offerts par des concitoyens familles monoparentales et à faible revenu. Un système illustres. Ne pensons qu’au Major-Général Georges présidentiel ferait en sorte que le Canada ressemblerait Vanier, Lincoln Alexander, et Lynda davantage aux États-Unis, combinant le rôle de chef Haverstock pour n’en nommer que quelques-uns qui ont d’État avec celui de chef de gouvernement. Comme nos servi la Couronne et notre pays avec grande distinction. amis américains l’ont redécouvert lors des processus de UNE RÉFLEXION SUR NOTRE PROPRE HISTOIRE destitution dans l’administration Trump, cela s’avère 7 ET NOTRE DÉVELOPPEMENT La Monarchie parfois une combinaison malheureuse. Alternativement, d’aujourd’hui puise sa source dans les racines l’élection d’un président ou d’un Gouverneur général du passé. Beaucoup des premiers peuples de Canada créerait simplement un autre homme politique, offrirait choisirent des chefs de tribu dont les rôles s’inspirèrent un autre niveau d’ambition personnelle, nécessiterait davantage des guides du temps passé. L’établissement de une autre série d’élections et rendrait le titulaire de colonies françaises et anglaises au Canada a aussi nourri ce poste redevable aux intérêts des différentes factions sa propre expérience de la monarchie. Les différentes et groupes auxquels le résultat devrait être rendu. vagues d’immigration ont connu leur lot en matière de

8 – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 THE MONARCHIST LEAGUE OF CANADA LA LIGUE MONARCHISTE DU CANADA monarchist.ca PO Box 1057, RPO Lakeshore West, Oakville, ON L6K 0B2 [email protected] THE CASE FOR THE CROWN 9 Key advantages

NATIONAL IDENTITY, STABILITY & PRIDE: GUARANTOR OF FREEDOM: Parliament – 1Easy travel to and from the USA, trade and 3The Queen, the Senate, the elected Commons. military alliances and American media can No bill, regulation or spending is authorized muddle Canada’s distinct identity. Our governance without the Royal Assent. Parliament is summoned focuses loyalty via allegiance to a monarch rather and dissolved in The Queen’s name. Also in her name, than to a politician or ideology. This difference public officials and diplomats are appointed, treaties underlies our distinct culture, energetic and yet approved, cabinets commissioned. Normally, this is a tranquil. Constitutional monarchy – the Canadian formality. However, “the Royal Prerogative” ensures way – provides stability. This is confirmed each year that the rules of law prevails, and provides a non- in the United Nations’ Human Development Index, partisan, non-violent safeguard – a constitutional which regularly ranks Canada high up in the fire extinguisher as Alberta political scientist Frank countries the world. Change is inevitable, and MacKinnon has put it – should usual democratic much of it good; political leaders also come and go. processes ever be threatened. For example, even a Canadians have voted in 22 federal elections during popular government could not simply dispense The Queen’s reign! The Crown provides constancy with holding an election! amidst so much change. The Sovereign has the REFEREE OF FEDERALISM: ELEVEN experience of decades, without the taint of a CROWNS – Canada is a federal state: our personal agenda. Such continuity constitutes 4 Constitution gives law-making power in an important anchor in our society. certain areas to Ottawa, others to the provinces. HEAD OF THE NATION VS HEAD Governments exercise this authority in the name of 2OF GOVERNMENT: Day to day our The Queen. Thus 11 Crowns exist in Canada – legally democratically elected representatives referred to as “The Queen in right of Canada” or engage in healthy partisan debate on issues about “The Queen in right of” a province. The premiers, which Canadians disagree. That is good. It encourages including the separatist René Levesque, underlined striving for partisan goals and personal success. the importance of the Crown in their key 1978 The Prime Minister is our head of government and Constitutional statement. Since the monarchy leader of a political party. As such, his actions are gives authority to each law-making entity, it also often controversial. The Sovereign, however, is a guarantees that the rule of law will be followed in force of unity as head of the nation, and with her dealing with disputes between Ottawa and the team of representatives is trusted by all Canadians. provinces. These facts explain the strong support by The monarchy protects and exemplifies the things the provinces for the institution of monarchy, which Canadians agree about, and remain constant, reconciles regional identity with national unity. regardless of an election: a notably tolerant, mature OATHS: USEFUL & PERSONAL: The deepest society, By presiding at events such as the Montréal loyalties of humans are to other human beings. Olympics and Canada Day celebrations on Parliament 5 Oaths are taken to The Queen by our new Hill, The Queen and her family emphasize the non- fellow Canadians, legislators, judges, CF members and partisan, unifying nature of great national occasions.

Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 – 9 many other public officials. Making their promise to Canada’s form of government. In 1982, Canada’s the Sovereign rather than to a politician shows their new Constitution entrenched the Crown so that ultimate loyalty is not to elected figures, but to the only unanimous federal-provincial agreement could laws that make up the fabric of civilized society. ever alter it. Parliament unanimously passing the Such Oaths underline that following the rule of law Succession to the Throne Act in 2013 removed barriers applicable to all must prevail over partisanship – of gender in determining our future monarchs. acting to promote the well-being of a narrow COMMUNITY, VOLUNTEERISM, segment of society. Oaths to The Queen also reflect RECOGNITION – In their constant round Canada’s emphasis on the importance of the person, 8 of travels, The Queen, members of the Royal and of the dignity and equality of each individual: Family and her Canadian representatives bring the moment new citizens take the Citizenship Oath encouragement to the communities and volunteer they become full members of the Canadian family. sectors: a vital part of our national existence. They Each Canadian gives allegiance to The Queen, so inspire many to similar service. They create and reciprocating her decades of service to all Canada. award non-political honours to outstanding fellow A SHARED MONARCHY: Canadians are citizens. These Royal and vice-regal activities do not 6fortunate to have as our monarch an instantly often feature on national news programs. Opening a recognizable world figure. The Queen and new library, visiting a Legion Hall, speaking to a members of the Royal Family link our diverse school civics class or lunching with a local service population to a far-flung Commonwealth, unique in club are not on the media’s radar. But they constitute that it seeks no military advantage. These nations – the basis of our civil society, and bring significant from New Guinea to Belize, from New Zealand to pride and assistance to Canada’s communities. India – mirror the rich diversity of today’s Canada. A REPUBLIC = DISTRACTING & In 2010, our Queen flew from Toronto to New York, UNDESIRABLE – No one has yet proposed an where she addressed the United Nations. The night 9 alternative system of government for Canada before, The Queen proudly told an Official Dinner in which would in the same way reflect our nation’s Toronto that “I shall be travelling from this Northern history and be superior to constitutional monarchy Realm as Queen of Canada”. The Governor General in terms of the day-to-day functioning of the and the Lieutenant Governors represent The Queen Canadian state. Canadians remember the wrenching and perform most of the constitutional functions of constitutional debates of the last century . Such the Sovereign in her name. This arrangement allows arguments did nothing to help practical concerns: our country to share in the traditions of an ancient the environment, crowded classrooms, access to monarchy stemming out of Canada’s history, while at health care and support for single-parent and low- the same time we enjoy the services of distinguished income families. A presidential system would make fellow citizens – think of Major-General Georges Canada more closely resemble the United States, Vanier, Lincoln Alexander, David Lam and Lynda combining the role of head of state with head of Haverstock, to name but a few – who served Crown government. As our American friends re-discovered and country with great distinction. during impeachment processes in the Trump A REFLECTION OF OUR HISTORY administration, this proves an unhappy combination. 7& DEVELOPMENT: Today’s monarchy stems Alternatively, the election of a president or governor from our history. Many of Canada’s first general would simply create another politician, peoples chose chieftains whose role was much like offer another level of personal ambition, necessitate that of other leaders in ancient times. Settlement by another set of elections and make the holder of French and British people brought to Canada their that office beholden to the interests of the different own experience of monarchy. Many subsequent factions and groups to which the result was owed. immigrants have also known the monarchical system of government. In 1867, the Fathers of Confederation monarchist.ca unanimously chose constitutional monarchy as

10 – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 The Princess Elizabeth Gift Book, 1935 an Essay in celebration of the 85th anniversary of its publication and the 95th birthday of Elizabeth our Queen, BY ALASTAIR GLEGG

n 1914 Princess Mary’s Gift Princess, at nine Book was published to you’ve taken a Iraise funds for the wartime ‘Queen’s Work for people for your Women Fund’. Authors and artists were invited to friend, Let love be contribute stories, poems, so unshaken until or pictures, and some of the best-known did so. your journey’s end… Twenty years later a simi- lar project was undertaken, this time to support the moving of the Princess Elizabeth of York Hospital This essay is quite unlike for Children from Hack- anything CMN has printed ney to a more appropriate before. It traces with wit and location in the country. erudition the fruits of an era That was 85 years ago, and when reading was a common as the then Princess Eliza- pastime, and children’s books beth celebrates her 95th were at once popular and birthday this year I demanding, whimsical and thought it an appropriate serious, not beneath the occasion to recall the con- talents of some of the finest tributions made by many pens in the land, nor reliant famous authors of the day, on much illustration save the several of whom had writ- imagination of the brain. In ten pieces for the earlier such a world our Queen grew volume as well. up. And how lovely to think of James Barrie’s piece these authors’ inventing new comes first, appropriately stories for her 10th birthday, enough, as it concerns a and to the benefit of the children’s hospital in a Hospital that bore her name. chateau previously occu- We thought that the 95th pied by the Germans dur- birthday of The Queen was the ing the First Battle of the ideal occasion for our reader Marne in 1915. He de- so settle back and feel the scribes it as “an odd little masterstroke of the essayist hospital that was mine” open “the realms of gold”. – Ed (he donated the funds to establish it) where a vol- unteer staff cared for local children who had been se- riously wounded by shell- Alastair Glegg was born in fire or bombs. One night a Zeppelin was brought London in 1940 and grew up in down by gunfire in the Southern Rhodesia. After teaching grounds: it had been on languages in Rhodesia, Barbados, several bombing runs, but and Canada he joined the University Barrie felt sure that “the airmen had no idea there of Victoria Faculty of Education were these small people where for 25 years he lectured and below.” He says that in retrospect but the porcupine refused to be published numerous articles on the hospital seemed gay, but it was combed and slashed Ham with his Educational History and not always so: however, as his most spiny tail instead of saying Thank- Administration. famous creation Peter Pan might You. Ham asked Noah for the lid of have said, “If we cannot always be a big biscuit tin – (‘Ararat Biscuits’ – gay we can always make pretend”. I missed the pun the first time I Rudyard Kipling wrote a new Just- read it, but parents of small children So Story about the Porcupine and the in the 1930s would probably have Hedgehog: Noah’s son Ham was got it) – and next time the porcu- grooming the animals on the Ark, continued on page 12

Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 – 11 THE PRINCESS pine tried to slash him he used it as papers, in which their comic strips ELIZABETH a shield and told him that for being played an important part, but they GIFT BOOK... so fretful he would have to go and united for a good cause. Teddy Tail of continued from page 11 live in a hole in the ground in Africa the Daily Mail first appeared in 1915 when the Ark came ashore. Because and the author, Una Lascot, con- his little cousin the hedgehog had tributed a story about Teddy and his been so good and polite he would be friends putting on a circus.1919 had allowed to go and live in England seen the arrival of Uncle Oojah the “all among gardens and box-borders elephant in the Daily Sketch, and 16 and slugs where people will be glad years later Flo Lancaster told how to see you”. Kipling died in 1936, as his friends watched the Silver Ju- did Barrie, and perhaps these were bilee. The long-running comic strip Rudyard Kipling the last pieces they wrote. of Pip, Squeak and Wilfred also first ap- Animal stories have always been peared in 1919 in the Daily Mirror and favourites with children, and Fran- “Uncle Dick” (B. J. Lamb) submitted in sunset fires cis Brett Young, author of over 30 a piece on how they got their names. The children told me that, novels, described how three hungry That strip ran until 1956, outlasted aloof, alone, cuckoos, finding no more food in only by Rupert the Little Bear who first Dwelt the Good Grocer, whom the desert conditions of a South appeared in the Daily Express in 1920, I had not known… African winter, followed their friends and whose author Mary Tourtel To you dear children of old days, the swallows and storks and flew all contributed an account of his ad- I send the way to England to a village in venture with robbers and giants. This apologia to your early friend. Worcestershire where they settled Walt Disney sent two colour car- happily. Algernon Blackwood turned toons of Mickey Mouse and his ‘ret- However, I think it unlikely that from his tales of mystery and horror inue’ arriving for the party, com- any of the children had ever read to relate the story of Alexander III, plete with top hat and an ermine the original book, perhaps best a black chow dog, who did not in- cape for Minnie. known as it contains his poem The tend to be left at home when his Enid Bagnold, who had served as Rolling English Road. family went to watch the Jubilee a nurse and driver in France during As might be expected of that pe- Procession but set off on his own to the War and is best known as the au- riod there are some cautionary and see the King and Queen where he thor of National Velvet and The Chalk moral tales: the prolific Compton ‘exchanged pleasant and friendly Garden, wrote a piece about story- Mackenzie put aside the sense of glances with his fellow monarchs’. L. telling at bedtime, and there are also humour evident in Whisky Galore to A. G. Strong, perhaps best known for tales whose popular heroes are now tell of a Fairy Washerwoman who his Inspector McKay detective sto- probably long forgotten: one about occasionally appeared on a He- ries, told how two country gentle- Woolly Bear, contributed by Shirley bridean isle and could be heard by men were concerned about the Cooke, and another about Hepzibah the stream beating out the dirt from plight of small animals trapped in Hen, by Olwen Bowen who pub- tweeds and blankets with a heavy the middle of the corn field when it lished numerous children’s books in mallet as the crofters did. Big Hec- is cut, and arranged with a seagull to the 1920s. W. H. Davies the Welsh tor ignored the warnings of the old see that they could escape in time. poet who in 1908 wrote Autobiogra- women, and captured the fairy who Herbert Asquith, son of the wartime phy of a Supertramp based on his own agreed to look after his farm for a Prime Minister and brother of Vio- world-wide wanderings, which even year if he promised to release her let Bonham Carter, wrote a poem included losing a leg while jumping then. The farm prospered, and Hec- called Come and Change in which a a railroad car in Canada, sent a verse tor became very rich, but he would wizard invites children to choose about Street Criers. not let her go after a year and cursed their favourite animal into which he I was initially puzzled by G. K. her, whereupon she vanished along will magically transform them: Chesterton’s contribution,The Good with his good fortune. He died Grocer (An Apology). Then I discov- alone and in poverty, and “there is Everything you choose is here, ered that twenty years earlier not even so much as a nettle grow- Zebra, armadillo, deer, Chesterton had written The Flying ing green nor a loose stone to mark Every kind of dog and cat, Inn, a satire based on the premise where once upon a time that un- Pard and panther, mouse and bat, that Prohibition had come to Eng- grateful man lived”. Wild horse that knows not bit land and that all the friendly pubs Denis Mackail, James Barrie’s offi- or shoe, were effectively closed. Grocers cial biographer and Rudyard Kip- Toad and tapir and kangaroo. were allowed to sell alcohol, but ling’s cousin, wrote about Rather Greedy Little Hugh who dreamed each The echoes of Shakespeare’s rhy - The wicked Grocer groces in night of having everything he want - thms and themes reoccur in Walter spirits and in wine, ed, but on his birthday could not De La Mare’s poem Stars: Not frankly or in fellowship wake up from a dream in which he as men in inns do dine; had to go on and on playing with If to the heavens thou lift But packed with soap and sardines the train he had said he wanted so thine eyes and carried off by grooms, badly, even though he desperately When winter rules our For to be snatched by Duchesses wanted to stop. “Terrible, wasn’t it. northern skies, and drunk in dressing rooms. Are you feeling sorry for him? Well, And snow-cloud none the but he was rather greedy, you know, zenith mars He offered the subsequent Apology and he had said “I shan’t” and “I At Yule-tide midnight these for The Song against the Grocers because won’t,” and “Go away!” One oughtn’t thy stars. to say that kind of thing, ought one? …where far off in the warm Not even in a dream.” In the 1930s there was fierce com- western shires James Hilton contributed another petition among the popular daily Steep sloping woods are dipped chapter of Goodbye Mr. Chips to re-

12 – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 should never fly when one could walk”, but to their horror the Prin- cess was once late for lunch because she had been talking to a boy who had written a poem for her. They took back their original gifts and re- placed them with Good Looks and a Sense of the Ridiculous, which they claimed had brought many prin - cesses to a bad end. She married the poet, and their children did not Walter de la Mare have Fairy Godmothers. Poetry and prophesy have often gone together. In 1934, when contri- mind the reader of the importance butions to this fund-raising book of honour and kindness, because were invited, King George V, Prin - “even when you are fighting systems cess Elizabeth’s grandfather, was just …there are human beings behind 69 years old, although not in good those systems”. Hugh Walpole, the health, and her uncle Edward was author of Rogue Herries and other his- heir to the throne. Her father, the torical novels, recalled his child- Duke of York, was next in line (as- hood when “it was considered good suming Edward produced no heirs) for children to do what they dis- but few could have foreseen that he J M Barrie liked”. He was forbidden to enter his would be crowned king just two grandmother’s drawing room, or to years later, following his father’s touch her little gold chair: of course death and Edward’s abdication, and he did so, and accidentally damaged that the next monarch would be a it. He was sent to bed without sup- Queen. per, and “for weeks moved in a Lord David Cecil, professor of dreadful thick never-shifting cloud”. English Literature at Oxford, con- There are, naturally, several pieces tribut ed a poem about another Prin - about princesses. Margaret Irwin cess Elizabeth who would have to wrote historical novels, specializing face a similar challenge: in the Elizabethan period, and she contributed a one-act play about the But sometimes through little Princess Jeanne d’Albert who a leaded pane in 1541 was forced to marry a much Or stepping down the older man for reasons of state. Per- spacious stair haps not the most suitable topic, but I seemed to see another child happily in her fictional version the Who lived there once in days wedding was cancelled at the last that were… minute. She paused, she sighed, Joyce Anstruther, who wrote she clenched her hands, under the name of Jan Struther and The knuckles through her created the delightful character of rings showed white, Mrs. Miniver, contributed a poem Then turning as in stately dance called Princess Jane of London Town Moved sad and splendid about a young girl who sees no rea- out of sight. G K Chesterton son to be jealous of a real princess: I own no marble palace, but the The last poem in the collection is Marble Arch is there: by the author and playwright John Drinkwater who also looked into While as for crystal fountains – the future, accurately foreseeing the The Princess well, I’ve got Trafalgar Square… respect and affection with which Elizabeth Gift I keep no golden coaches: the young Princess Elizabeth con- Book.(1935) I always use instead tinues to be regarded: In aid of the Princess My stately motor buses, of Elizabeth of York a rich majestic red; Princess, at nine you’ve taken Hospital for Children. And miles of secret passages a people for your friend, Hodder & Stoughton: go winding underground Let love be so unshaken until London. With steely steeds to carry me your journey’s end… wherever I am bound. Still may the bells be ringing © Alastair Glegg when we are dust and dead, Victoria, BC, Canada The Unromantic Princess is the title To tell a princess singing March, 2021 of a charming story by Elizabeth because her heart is wed Bowen. As was the custom, fairy To ages all between the tale god mothers were invited to her of ninety or nineteen, christening, but they were “full of Or nine as any nightingale modern ideas” and gave the princess at noon among the green. the gifts of Punctuality and Com- monsense. Their surprisingly green and contemporary motto was “One

Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 – 13 League Notes

WILLIAM (BILL) 1:30 pm Eastern. Moderated by sonals in the Globe & Mail; and to CHARLES CHAMBERLAIN Jonathan Brickwood and emceed by advertising in weekly community SILVER, RIP him with Jon Bradshaw, the ZOOM papers, well appreciated, carefully platform will host up to 100 League read and their ad rates far more rea- May 10, 1924 – March 13, 2021 members. A highlight will be the sonably priced. So far we have plac - The death of Bill Silver, at the participants’ spending time in some ed ads in eight such papers in the great age of 96, marks a loss of an ar- virtual rooms to engage in conver- Greater Ottawa area, as well as dent monarchist and significant sation with other fellow monar- several others in Alberta and Nova benefactor of the League from its chists. We’ve also invited some spe- Scotia. early days, as well as a pillar of its cial guests to bring greetings – and A considerable response to this Ottawa Branch. No one could meet are excited that so far we will be campaign – in terms both of re- Bill without feeling impressed by welcoming the Deputy Prime Min- quests for our literature and new his ebullient spirit, fierce loyalty ister of Canada (Hon Christine members – is encouraging us to spoken gently, innate modesty and “Bill” Silver Freeman) and His Honour the Lieu- continue as we spread more of our kindness. He had a phenomenal tenant Governor of Nova Scotia. message around the country – and memory, practical wisdom and a Limited “space” available; so do ask investigate other types of publica- natural bonhomie. Raised in Tor- to participate as quickly as you can tions as well. onto, at 18 Bill enlisted in the North when the email invitation lands in Nova Scotia Highlanders and was your inbox about two weeks before- BENEFACTOR ROBARTS part of the D-Day landing in Nor- hand FUNDS LEAGUE mandy – his stint as a Prisoner of EDUCATIONAL War in Germany is a story he shared ADVERTISING BOOKLET REPRINT only many years later. Back in CAMPAIGN LAUNCHED Canada, Bill began what was to be a Fed up with the distorted narra- life long career with the Bank of tives about the Crown being ped- Nova Scotia. This is where he also dled in recent months, the League met the love of his life, Betty. Bill determined it was time to take the and Betty were avid travellers, loved offensive by widening our normal cottaging in the summer, but most communication strategy to paid ad- importantly treasured spending vertising in newspapers. When in time with their family. Indeed 1970 the League began it work, Chaucer might have had fore- papers were widely read, and adver- thought of Bill in describing one of tising – expensive but affordable – his characters as a “very parfitt gen- drove membership recruitment with tle knight.” May his generous spirit no small success. Such adverts now rest in peace, and his memory be a are hideously expensive, but they blessing and example to us all. command a measure of seriousness – JLA,WG and do reach that still-considerable QUEEN’S 95th BIRTHDAY part of the population who do not – LEAGUE TO CELEBRATE: linger all day before a computer or smart phone. A NATIONAL Thanks to the generous support VIRTUAL LUNCH of members, February found the ON SUNDAY APRIL 18 League re-entering these waters, To celebrate our Queen’s 95th with punchy notices appearing in birthday (April 21) the League is or- the National Post, Ottawa Citizen, Hali- The League will not ganizing a national Virtual Lunch fax Herald and Victoria Times-Colonist. For over a decade now, our great dictate you eat Kale! on Sunday, April 18 commencing These gave way to the National Per- friend and benefactor Richard Ro- barts, of Windsor, Ontario, together with his wife Donalda, have fi- nanced the design and printing of monarchy: our English educational booklets. THE BEST POLICY? You can view them online via the Publications section of the League Canada’s Crown: essential website. These are colourful and pic- ture-packed, intended for teachers to our governance and way of life and students roughly age 9 through high school. The greatest distribu- tion of the tens of thousands dis- GET THE FACTS tributed over the years has been through Members of Parliament. The Monarchist League of Canada We write all federalist MP’s at the beginning of each Session of Parlia- will send you The Case for the Crown. ment, and offer them free copies to Request it from [email protected] take on their visits to schools and other community organizations within their constituencies. We ap- monarchist.ca proached Dick as our supply ran PO Box 1057, RPO Lakeshore West, Oakville, ON L6K 0B2 down in the Spring, our reprint

14 – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 League Notes being the more urgent as the former MEMBERS CHOOSE Governor General appeared on the LEAGUE TARTAN: cover. Our call was once again met SCARVES TO COME! unhesitatingly. We ask League mem- bers to consider passing on a copy to One happy fact of life in an often- classroom teachers, 4-H club ad- polarized world is that so many peo- ministrators, leaders in the various ple of differing backgrounds con- Scouting organizations, cadet sider themselves honorary Scots. groups. Thanks to the Robarts and You can see kilts and hear the skirl you, the League pays the postage, of bagpipes in India and Pakistan and is happy to send them without through North America and many charge. other places across the globe. Thus when our member and benefactor THANKS TO OUR Dr Oscar Vicente generously offered MEDIA REPRESENTATIVES to register a League Tartan, we threw FROM CHAIRMAN FINCH the design open to members – and were surprised to find no less than Recent months have proved busy, 50 entries! Narrowed down by sev- and not always easy, for our media eral rounds of voting among Dr Vi- spokesmen across Canada. They cente, Chairman Finch and Domin- have delivered clear explanations of ion HQ, four tartans were placed the importance of our Crown, and before the membership. Many hun- kept their cool when provoked. It is dreds of votes later, the design de- a great band of volunteers, some- picted here was chosen, designed by BY THEIR times shrunk by a move, or other Carol Martin, of Beaverlodge. Alberta. commitments or – believe it, and The League is now consulting wool LAST WILL & TESTAMENT shame on them – employers’ asking manufacturers with a view to having them not to speak out – “too toxic/ our tartan scarf available in the Au- Make Sure The Work Goes On! too controversial.” So all the more tumn for use in 8-9 months of the heartfelt appreciation to Barry Mac- year. Pre-orders will be taken once Kenzie, John Yogis, Karim Al-dah- we have all details and pricing ar- Members who would like to ensure the continuation dah, Étienne Boisvert, Jonathan ranged. Brickwood, Darcie Axelstierna, Josh of the work of the Monarchist League of Canada in the Traptow, Keith Roy and Bruce Hall- NEW BRUNSWICK years ahead, so that generations of the future may know sor. Apologies to anyone inadver- BRANCH: GAINS VICE- the benefits of the Monarchy, are urged to consider the tently omitted. REGAL PATRONAGE League’s needs in making their wills. A suggested form BRANCH ORGANIZATION Congratulations to Branch Chair- of bequest is as follows: PLAN SOON TO man James Wilson, who recently re- ceived word that Her Honour, the I give and bequeath to the BE RELEASED Lieutenant Governor, was graciously Chairman Finch writes: I am cur- pleased to grant her Patronage to Monarchist League of Canada, rently putting the final touches on the Branch. Ms Murphy also very PO Box 1057, Lakeshore West Station, the League’s new Branch Organiza- kindly recorded a filmed greeting to tion plan. It is designed to jump- members in New Brunswick. Oakville, ON L6K 0B2, start branch activities as the country the sum of ______. opens up and COVID restrictions TRIENNIAL COST ebb. It will provide a clear road plan OF CROWN SURVEY The Monarchist League of Canada gratefully remembers for branches – with expectations UNDERWAY those departed members whose bequests over the years have and goals, self-challenges and the We’re delighted to report that the like: lots of encouragement and assisted to provide for the maintenance of the League’s work 8th Edition of The Cost of Canada’s across Canada. Among late members whose bequests have ideas for programming; plenty of Constitutional Monarchy will appear freedom to experiment, measure this Fall, composed for the third been received in the last several years are success and occasionally fall flat as time by Jonathan Bradshaw of Tor- we all do; high expectations and lots onto. Once lauded in Macleans, this Vera Olive Booth, Toronto, ON of support. All focused never on authoritative survey shows how Annie Monique Daguet, Victoria, BC clubby-self-satisfaction or meetings much Canadians benefit from the for the sake of meetings, but on Crown at relatively little expense. Lois Humphrey, Kingston, Ontario OUTREACH & EDUCATION. Stay Its reporting will be adjusted to ac- tuned for its release in the Spring! count for the impact of COVID dur- Joyce Kirby, Victoria, BC NEW LEAGUE ing the current triennium. Madeline McCue, Halifax, NS Canadian Monarchist News FLYER: Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada Alexander Ray Paton, Victoria, BC Special Issue – Autumn-Winter 2 An occasional Newsletter for members and friends of The 019 — No. 47 THE CASE FOR The Monarchist League of Canada Monarchist League of Canada PO Box 1057, Lakeshore W – La Ligue M est PO, Oakville, Ontario,onarchiste Canada du L6K Canada, 0B2 905-855-7262 (800) 465-6925 w THE MONARCHIST LEAGUE OF CANADA – 49th ANNIVERSARY 1970-2019 Frank Price, Winnipeg THE CROWN ww.monarchist.ca ←Read or per Canadian 7th Edition – 7e édition – 2017-2018 For information and $1.68 Commissioned by the Monarchist League of Canada: par Canadien Complete revision of a Survey issued triennially since 1999 download Erik Searight, Burnaby, BC Étude commandée par la Ligue monarchiste du Canada extra copies of this latest The Cost of Canada’s ConstitutionalRévision complète d’une étude publiée tousMonarchy les trois ans depuis 1999 the current John Middleton Sturgess, London, Ontario ● This edition of the SURVEY HIGHLIGHTS League flyer, see the publi- Constitutional MonarchyCost Of Canada’s edition at ● The total annual cost of the service of the general cost of the Canadianestimates Crown that the Lieutenant Governors, and their in 2017-2018 was House of Commons ( $62,438,557 Offices, to The Queen and the nation $13.23 $1.68 or Senate ( ), the cations section of our web- per Canadian. In constant dollar was $0.28 $2.85) and the Canadian terms, this represents an approximate cents per capita. Broadcasting Corporation ( monarchist.ca ● The Queen’s vice- regal representatives increase of a little over 4.5 per cent. ● The Monarchy cost residents$32.97 of the). Alison Watson, Regina, SK in Canada collectively undertook ● As The Queen of Canada’s United Kingdom a total of £76.1 million approximately representative, The Governor General, 4,378 engagements pounds ($128.5M), or site at monarchist.ca – see in 2017-2018. $1.93 and her office served this country’s resident in 2017-2018. However, per UKthe under ● By way of comparison the Canadian population of 37,058,856¹ at an annual Queen returned to the Treasury Monarchy cost Canadians far less than, cost of £228.3 million ($381.5 million) to the $0.63 for example, other national institutions per person. Treasury or $5.74 per UK resident, such as the per capita costs of the it on pp 7-10 of this issue. from the revenue surplus of the publications Le coût de la monarchie constitutionnelleCrown Estate. au Canada La présente étude a pour but de dresser un portrait clair, unique et global des dépenses ordinaires liées à la couronne canadienne et de souligner l’utilité de cette institution pour ce pays. Le texte en français ci-dessous reprend les points forts de l’étude intégrale.

● En 2017-2018, le coût global de la FAITS SAILLANTS DE L’ÉTUDE couronne canadienne a été de En général, la plus grande proportion 62,438,557$ Canadian Monarchist News 15 des coûts liés à la couronne au Canada , soit 1.68$ par Canadien. qu’a passées Sa Majesté sur le Trône. – Spring/Printemps 2021 – ● La gouverneure générale, en tant que sont encourus par les bureaux du gou Même si le Canada serait une répu représentante de la Reine, a servi la ver neur général et des lieutenants blique, que l’on nommerait toujours des gouverneurs dans l’exercice quotidien de - population canadienne au coût global chefs d’État non exécutifs lesquels leurs pouvoirs et de leurs responsabilités annuel de 0.63$ vivraient dans les résidences historiques par personne en au nom de la Reine: coûts comme sécu- accueillante plus de 335 000 visiteurs qu’occupent actuellement les représen rité, transports, bureaus et d’entre et invités aux résidences officielles tantes de la Couronne. Si des arguments des résidences, les régimes de distinc- - (Rideau Hall et la Citadelle de Québec) tien pour une république existent on ne tions honorifiques D ● L 10 dh saurait l f Au Secours de la Monarchie Porte parole au Québec de la Ligue monarchiste du Canada.

Par Karim Al-Dahdah tapis rouge, ni fanfare ni trompettes. nom de la Reine du Canada. Son re- Corrigez moi si je me trompe, mais présentant, le gouverneur-géneral, On assiste depuis quelques se- pour un chef d’Etat(de facto), on ne est un citoyen Canadien. Le comble: maines à un déluge de contenu anti- peux pas faire plus simple ni plus un article paru récemment dans le monarchiste dans les médias québé- modeste. Journal de Montréal, qui qualifie les Ca- cois. C’est comme si soudain, depuis Onéreuse? Dans les démocraties nadiens de “citoyens britan- le départ de Mme Payette, cette ins- parlementaires comme le Canada, niques”.De telle inexactitudes ne titution qui a si bien servi le Canada les poste de chef d’Etat et de chef de contribuent qu’à attiser les vieilles depuis sa fondation, était accusée de gouvernment sont séparés, et c’est rancoeurs, réveiller les démons du tous les maux. Car quand il s’agit de tant mieux comme ça. Il n’y a qu’à colonialisme et entretenir la notion monarchie, les mythes et les accusa- regarder chez nos voisins du sud erronée que le Canada serait tou- tionsabondent: inutile, dépassée, chez qui cette fonction est combi- jours inféodé à l’Angleterre. Dans un pompeuse, onéreuse, étrangère au née pour pousser un soupir de sou- monde pré-Covid où j’allais à la ren- Canada.Regardons de plus près. lagement. Ceci dit, il faut bien un contre des Québécois, nombreux Inutile et dépassée? Je ne re- budget pour un chef d’Etat. Au Ca- étaient ceux qui me disaient: “la mo- viendrai pas sur le rôle de garde-fou nada, ce budget n’est pas très élevé narchie, celà fait aussi partie de et d’arbitre du monarque dans une par rapport à d’autres pays(autour du notre Histoire. Arrêtez d’essayer de monarchie constitutionelle, il y a prix d’un café Tim Horton’s par ha- nous la retirer”. L’autre jour, une col- déjà assez d’articles à ce sujet, et je bitant). Et quand bien même le Ca- lègue de ne suis ni académicien ni constitu- nada devait un jour devenir une ré- bureau originaire de Mascouche tionaliste. Mais je sais que tout pays publique, il y a fort à parier quece me disait: “notre Hisoire est pré- est fait de traditions, de symboles, budget resterait le même, sinon se- cieuse, il faut la conserver”. de protocole et de gravitas qui sont rait plus élevé. La sécurité d’un Pré- Pour finir, il convient de le réaf- importants pour son identité et le sident de la République, les fonc- firmer: la brève et malheureuse épo- plus souvent reflètent son histoire tions officielles, l’entretient des pée de Mme Payette ne devrait pas et ses origines: le discours du Trône, résidences patrimoniales (on s’en- servir d’alibi pour accuser de tous les les noms des régiments, les distinc- tend que personne n’aimerait que maux une institution mal connue et tions honorifiques, les armoiries sur les deux résidences officielles, Ri- mal-aimée mais qui a si bien sû rem- notre passeport, l’effigie du mo- deau Hall et la Citadelle de Québec plir son rôle depuis plus d’un siècle; narque sur notre monnaie, le ser- ne tombent en désuétude) et tout ce mais l’occasion de la solidifier et la ment de citoyenneté; autant de qui constitue la majorité du budget faire redécouvrir à une population belles traditions que l’on cherche si de la monarchie au Canada, tout celà souvent mal informée mais qui ne ardemment à abolir. serait toujours là. Et non, le Canada demande pas mieux que de la Pompeuse? Il y a quelques an- ne paye pas de taxe à la Reine, ne connaître.Elle constitue un gage de nées, je me promenais dans les jar- couvre pas son train de vie ni le coût stabilité et de continuité dans un dins de Rideau Hall à Ottawa. Ri- de ses chapeaux. L’argument écono- monde en mal de repères et une for- deau Hall, ce n’est ni Buckingham mique ne tient tout simplement pas. midable connection avec l’Histoire. Palace ni le château de Versailles. Etrangère? Oui, si l’on en croit la Car la monarchie, c’est l’Histoire du C’est une grande demeure à la dé- majorité des médias qui ne cessent Canada. Une Histoire non pas enfer- cointérieure somme toute assez de répéter les termes “monarchie mée dans un musée, sclérosée; mais contemporaine, entourée d’un britannique” et “Reine d’Angleterre” bien vivante, dynamique, à l’oeuvre. grand parc ouvert à tous. Les gens y pour qualifier une institution typi- Les monarchistes aujourd’hui, viennent se balader en famille. Ce quement canadienne qui, depuis le contrairement aux idées reçues, ne jour-là, j’avais croisé un grand-père traité de Westminster de 1931, est sont pas de vieux anglos nostal- sympatique qui promenait son constitutionellement et juridique- giques de l’empire britannique, mais chien en compagnie de son épouse. ment séparée de la Couronne bri- des Canadiens d’aujourd’hui, de tous Il m’avait fait un grand sourire en tannique. Sur les portraits, la Reine âges et de toutes origines, qui ai- passant àmes côtés. Ce monsieur, se tient devient le drapeau du Ca- ment ce pays, son histoire et ses ins- j’allais l’apprendre, c’était David nada, porte la médaille de l’Ordre du titutions. Pour ceux qui rejetent Johnston, gouverneur-général du Canada, et quand j’ai fait mon ser- l’idée de la monarchie, c’est souvent Canada et prédécesseur de Mme ment de citoyenneté _l’un des plus l’idée même du Canada qu’ils reje- Payette. Ni escorte sécuritaire, ni beaux jours de ma vie_ je l’ai fait au tent. Mais ça, c’est un autre débat.

“I DON’T HAVE EMAIL/A COMPUTER” IN THE NEXT EDITION OF CMN Please go to your local library where you can get help to sign up for a free email account which you can check whenever you visit – easy to use! ○ New Governor General SALES FOR “ONCE YOU’RE A ‘CONNECTED’ MONARCHIST YOU CAN appointed (we hope) SUBJECTS Receive regular Ecomms full of news, views, returns on the events, projects, quizzes, special offers ○ How some Monarchists celebrated The Queen’s back page. Learn how to bid in the Annual Silent Auction In the meantime Sign up for bi-monthly Royal Round-Up, news 95th birthday; be sure not often reported in Canadian media to send a brief account enjoy purchasing via Renew or donate online – saving you and League postage and a picture to the League Store When you have signed up, be sure to send your email [email protected] online at address to [email protected] monarchist.ca

16 – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021