DOCSLIB.ORG

Gomal Zam Command Area Development Project Midterm Performance Evaluation

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Gomal Zam Command Area Development Project Midterm Performance Evaluation GOMAL ZAM COMMAND AREA DEVELOPMENT PROJECT MIDTERM PERFORMANCE EVALUATION DECEMBER 9, 2019 This publication was produced for review by the United States Agency for International Development. It was prepared by Management Systems International, A Tetra Tech Company. GOMAL ZAM COMMAND AREA DEVELOPMENT PROJECT MIDTERM PERFORMANCE EVALUATION Contracted under Order No. AID-391-C-15-00004 Performance Management Support Contract DISCLAIMER This report is made possible by the support of the American people through the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). The contents are the sole responsibility of the Management Systems International and do not necessarily reflect the views of USAID or the United States Government. ABSTRACT In 2015, USAID/Pakistan joined the Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to implement the Gomal Zam Command Area Development Project. The project sought to improve the agricultural and livestock productivity and incomes of 30,000 farm families by helping them fully realize the benefits of a perennial source of irrigation water. The project is far behind schedule, however, thus deferring much-anticipated benefits. The evaluation focused on producing recommendations to accelerate implementation and identifying lessons learned to improve the design and implementation of future government-to-government projects. To address this purpose, the evaluation team reviewed a rich set of documents, interviewed a wide range of stakeholders and beneficiaries, and drew from secondary sources to triangulate findings. The evaluation concludes that a poorly managed design process failed to produce a design document specific enough to effectively guide implementation. Furthermore, staffing and compensation issues embedded in the design left the project without the skills and experience necessary to effectively manage project activities. Because the project has made little meaningful progress on its foundational activities, it generated few benefits. Nevertheless, the evaluation concludes that completing the project has the potential to sustain benefits achieved so far and enhance them substantially. Recommendations for accelerating implementation focus on bolstering the project’s management capacity, producing detailed work plans, filling staffing gaps, reassessing the suitability of consultants, and managing contracts more tightly. In future government-to-government projects, USAID should take a more hands-on approach to project design and implementation, reserving a role in approving design documents and selecting key personnel and providing short- or long-term technical assistance as necessary. GOMAL ZAM COMMAND AREA DEVELOPMENT PROJECT – MIDTERM PERFORMANCE EVALUATION iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The evaluation team greatly appreciates the open and collaborative attitude with which project staff, government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa officials, and USAID personnel approached this evaluation. Your interest in the evaluation outcomes, honest and thoughtful appraisal of the project’s strengths and challenges, accessibility to the evaluation team, and patience made our job interesting and satisfying. We also need to thank the many beneficiaries, stakeholders, and others who consented to interviews. We appreciate your time and valuable insights. The staff of the Project Implementation Unit deserve a special thank you for facilitating the evaluation team’s work in D.I. Khan and the command area. We also wish to recognize USAID, and particularly the Economic Growth and Agriculture Office and the Performance Management Unit, for their invaluable support, guidance, and assistance. Thank you. Douglas Krieger, team lead Jamshed ul-Hasan, subject-matter specialist (government/project management) Muhammad Qasim Jan, subject-matter specialist (agriculture) Samar Erum Nadeem, subject-matter specialist (gender) Muhammad Noman Ali, assignment manager Bawar Khan, field researcher Lubna Nisar, field researcher GOMAL ZAM COMMAND AREA DEVELOPMENT PROJECT – MIDTERM PERFORMANCE EVALUATION iv CONTENTS Acronyms .......................................................................................................................... vii Glossary ..............................................................................................................................ix Project Summary .............................................................................................................. x Executive Summary .......................................................................................................... 1 Evaluation Purpose and Questions .................................................................................. 6 Project Background .......................................................................................................... 6 Development Hypothesis .................................................................................................................. 8 Evaluation Methods and Limitations ............................................................................... 8 Data Collection and Analysis ............................................................................................................ 9 Findings and Conclusions................................................................................................ 10 Design Process and Design ............................................................................................................. 10 Implementation .................................................................................................................................. 17 Project Benefits .................................................................................................................................. 25 Sustainability ........................................................................................................................................ 36 Recommendations .......................................................................................................... 38 Recommendations for Immediate Implementation ................................................................... 38 Recommendations for Improving Future G2G Projects .......................................................... 41 Annexes ............................................................................................................................ 42 Annex 1: Statement of Work ......................................................................................................... 42 Annex 2: Assignment Work Plan ................................................................................................... 79 Annex 3: Project Components and Status of Activities ......................................................... 103 Annex 4: Bibliography ..................................................................................................................... 106 Annex 5: Data Collection Instruments ....................................................................................... 114 Annex 6: List of Interviews............................................................................................................ 156 Annex 7: Data Analysis Plan .......................................................................................................... 160 Annex 8: Design Milestone Dates ............................................................................................... 161 Annex 9: CADP Budget Reallocation ......................................................................................... 162 Annex 10: Cultivated Area Maps ................................................................................................. 163 Annex 11: Chashma Right Bank Canal Impact Evaluation Data ........................................... 168 Annex 12: Evaluation Team Biographies .................................................................................... 170 Annex 13: Conflict of Interest Declarations ............................................................................. 172 GOMAL ZAM COMMAND AREA DEVELOPMENT PROJECT – MIDTERM PERFORMANCE EVALUATION v List of Tables Table 1: Project Summary................................................................................................................................. x Table 2: Contract Procurement Timelines ................................................................................................. 18 Table 3: Effect of Canal Water on Production Indicators ...................................................................... 28 Table 4: Farmers’ Concerns About Watercourses and Outlets ........................................................... 35 Table 5: Project-Reported Activity Data .................................................................................................. 104 Table 6: Number of Interviews by Module and Type ............................................................................ 156 Table 7: Interview Subjects........................................................................................................................... 157 Table 8: Data Analysis Plan ........................................................................................................................... 160 Table 9: Design Process Milestone Dates ................................................................................................. 161 Table 10: CADP Budget Reallocation (Rs. millions) ..............................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Pakistan Public Expenditure Management, Volume II
    Report No. 25665-PK PAKISTAN Public Expenditure Management Accelerated Development of Water Resources and Irrigated Agriculture VOLUME II January 28, 2004 Environment and Social Development Sector Unit Rural Development Sector Unit South Asia Region Document of the World Bank CURRENCY EQUIVALENTS Currency Unit = Pakistan Rupee US $1 = PKR 57.8 FISCAL YEAR July 1-June 30 ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS ADB Asian Development Bank MIS Management information system ADP Annual Development Plan MOWP Ministry of Water and Power AWB Area Water Board MTEF Medium Term Expenditure Framework BCM Billion cubic meters MTIP Medium Term Investment Plan CCA Canal command area NDP National Drainage Program DMP Drainage Master Plan NDS National Drainage System EFR Environmental Flow Requirement NSDS National System Drainage Study EIRR Economic internal rate of return NWFP North West Frontier Province FATA Federally Administered Tribal Areas NWP National Water Policy FGW Fresh groundwater OFWM On-farm water management FO Farmer organization O&M Operations and Maintenance GDP Gross development product PIDA Provincial Irrigation and Drainage Authority GIS Geographic Information System POE Panel of Experts GOP Government of Pakistan PRHS Pakistan Rural Household Survey HYV High yielding variety PSDP Public Sector Development Program IBIS Indus basin irrigation system PV Present Value IDA International Development Association RAP Revised Action Plan IPPs Independent Power Producers RBOD Right Bank Outfall Drain IRSA Indus River System Authority SCARP Salinity control
    [Show full text]
  • Curriculum Vita Ee
    CCuurrrriiccuulluumm VViittaaee PERSONAL INFORMATION Name: Prof. Dr. Muhammad Niamat Ullah Father’s Name: Jumma Khan Date Of Birth: May 06, 1968 N.I.C. No: 12101-0964847-1 Religion: Islam Nationality: Pakistani Domicile: Dera Ismail Khan (Khyber Pakhtunkhwa) Languages Spoken: English, Urdu, Pashto, Seraiki Marital Status: Married Postal / Permanent Address: Director, Institute of Social Sciences/Coordinator Graduate Studies and Research Director ORIC/ Chairman, Department of Agricultural Economics, Faculty of Agriculture, Gomal University, Dera Ismail Khan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Pakistan Phone & Mobile No: Res → 0966-720519, 03347239233, Office→ 0966-750087 Fax No: Office→ 0966-750087 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Page 1 of 17 EDUCATIONAL RECORD Level of Date of Obtain Division/ Institution / Education / obtaining Marks/ Grade/ Specialized Board / Examination Certificate / Total or Distincti Field University Passed Degree CGPA on Matriculation Peshawar 535/850 10.08.1983 1st / B Science Board F. Sc Peshawar 652+20= 1st / B Pre- 03.08.1985 Board 672/1100 (Adj) Engineering NWFP, 3973/ B.Sc (Hons)/ Agricultural 4700 1st / A Agriculture M.Sc University, 29.08.1989 CGPA Economics Peshawar 3.87/4.00 814/1000 1st / A Agriculture NWFP, CGPA Ist Class Economics Agricultural M.Sc (Hons) / 3.91/4.00 Ist & University, 05.10.1991 M.Phil Position Rural Peshawar Sociology Department CGPA of 3.45/4.00 1st / B Economics, Ist Class Economics Ph.D Gomal 21.01.2011 Ist (Agric. University, Position Economics) Dera Ismail Khan Topic of M.Sc(Hons): Economic Significance of Tubewell Irrigation and Agriculture Development in District Dera Ismail Khan. Topic of Ph.D: Determinants of Agriculture Production and Supply Price along with Non-Price Response of Major Crops in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (HEC Recognized Supervisor in the Field of Economics/Agric.
    [Show full text]
  • 10-35 Waterworldwaterday 22 March 2014Water and Anex Izharul
    World Water Day 22nd March, 2014 10 WATER ENERGY NEXUS By Dr. Izhar ul Haq1 SYNOPSIS Pakistan has on the average about 145 MAF of surface flows per annum. Out of this on average 103 MAF is diverted for irrigation at various barrages, 10 MAF is the system loss and 32 MAF goes down the last barrage into sea every year. Mangla and Tarbela two mega Dams were built as a part of the replacement works of the Indus Basin Plan. Their storage capacity has reduced due to sedimentation. There are about 100 small to medium dams on tributaries but their storage capacity is small. Pakistan has presently storage capacity of 10% of annual flows against 40% World average. Construction of Kalabagh Dam is stalled due to non consensus of the provinces. Diamer Basha Dam, having the approval of Council of Common Interest and Political Consensus, is ready for construction since 2008 and is still awaiting the financing arrangement for construction. These are only a couple of mega storage sites on main river Indus. Pakistan must build storage dams not only for food self sufficiency but also for cheap hydropower and flood mitigation. Pakistan has hydropower potential of 60,000 MW out of which it has exploited only 11%. The share of hydropower has reduced from 60% to 32% of the total power generated. The dependence on the imported fossil fuel (oil) has pushed the power tariff upwards. Pakistan has 18 small to medium hydel stations and only 3 stations greater than 1000 MW. The hydel power produced by Mangla and Tarbela has been the main stay in the economy of Pakistan.
    [Show full text]
  • Irrigation System, Arid Piedmont Plains of Southern Khyber-Paktunkhwa (NWFP), Pakistan; Issues & Solutions
    Irrigation System, Arid Piedmont Plains of Southern Khyber-Paktunkhwa (NWFP), Pakistan; Issues & Solutions Muhammad Nasim Golra Javairia Naseem Golra Department of Irrigation, AGES Consultants, Government of Khyber-Paktunkhwa, Peshawar Peshawar IRRIGATION POTENTIAL Khyber-Paktunkhwa (Million (NWFP) Acres) Total Area (NWFP+FATA) 25.4 Cultivable Area 6.72 Irrigated Area Govt. Canals 1.2467 Civil Canals 0.82 Lift Irrigation Schemes 0.1095 Tube Wells/Dug Wells 0.1008 Total 2.277 Potential Area for Irrigation 4.443 Lakki Marwat 0.588 D.I. Khan 1.472 Tank 0.436 Total 2.496 Rest of Province 1.947 Upper Siran Canal Kunhar River Siran River Lower Siran Canal Icher Canal Haro River Irrigation System , KP (NWFP) Indus River Daur River Khan Pur Dam Sarai Saleh Channel L.B.C R.B.C Mingora 130 miles 40 miles 96 miles Swat River Tarbela Dam P.H.L.C Ghazi Brotha Barrage Topi Bazi Irrigation Scheme Pehur Main Swabi Swan River Amandara H/W Indus River Chashma Barrage Machai Branch U.S.C Taunsa Barrage Lower Swat Kalabagh Barrage Kabul River Mardan Nowshera D.I.Khan Kohat Toi CRBC Kohat Munda H/W Panj Kora River Peshawar Main Canal L.B. Canal CRBC 1st Lift 64 Feet Tanda Dam K.R.C CRBC 2nd Lift 120 Feet Warsak Canal Bannu CRBC 3rd Lift 170 Feet Warsak Lift Canal Tank Civil Canal Kurram Ghari H/W Kurram Tangi Dam Marwat Canal Baran Dam Gomal River Kurram River Tochi Baran Link D.I. Khan-Tank Gomal Zam Dam Area Kaitu River Tochi River Flood Irrigation Vs Canal Irrigation Command D.
    [Show full text]
  • Curriculum Vitae A
    Curriculum Vitae A. PERSONAL INFORMATION Name: Engr.Dr. Muhammad Yousaf Ali Khan Father’s Name: Saeed Ahmad Khan Date Of Birth: 20 Aug 1983 C.N.I.C. No: 12101-2467572-7 Religion: Islam Nationality: Pakistani Domicile: KPK Languages Spoken: English, Urdu, Seraiki, Punjabi, Korean Marital Status: Married Postal / Permanent Address: Basti Ustrana North, Opp of Govt Primary School, Dera Ismail Khan. Phone & Mobile No: 0331-5799007 Fax No: N.A Email: [email protected] Page 1 of 6 B. EDUCATIONAL RECORD Level of Date of Marks Institution / Division/ Education / obtaining Obtain/ Specialized Board / Grade/ Examination Certificate Total Field University Distinction Passed / Degree SSC Federal Board 1998 649/850 Ist/A Science HSSC Federal Board 2001 736/1100 Ist/B Pre-Engg BSc Engg UET, Peshawar 2006 861/1160 Ist/A Electrical CGPA. Electrical Hanyang Uni, MS Engg 2010 3.25/4.00 Ist/A+ and Korea Electronic Hanyang Uni, CGPA Electronic PhD Engg 2017 Ist/A+ Korea 3.44/4.00 Systems Topic of M.Phil/ M.Sc(Hons): Sensor Fusion based navigation for outdoor Mobile Robots Topic of Ph.D: A NOVEL PARTIAL DISCHARGE DIAGNOSTICS USING CAPD WITH NEURAL NETWORK TO IDENTIFY THE VITAL DEFECTS IN XLPE CABLE SYSTEM UNDER DC STRESS C. JOB DETAILS -TEACHING AND RESEARCH EXPERIENCE Job Title, Period of Service S.N0 Job Duties/ Responsibilities and Address of Employer 1. Assistant Professor, FET, Gomal Teaching University, D.I.Khan w.e.f. Aug 2014 to Date 2. Lecturer, FET, Gomal University, Teaching D.I.Khan w.e.f Dec 2012 to Aug 2014 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Legal Practitioners & Bar Councils Act, 1973
    144 Pakistan Bar Council Legal Education Rules, 2015 PAKISTAN BAR COUNCIL NOTIFICATION December 19, 2015 S.R.O. 1265(1)/2015.—Whereas the “Pakistan Bar Council Legal Education Rules” earlier promulgated and notified by the Pakistan Bar Council way back in 1978 do not cater present day’s needs, require to be reformed and updated; And whereas the existing three sets of Rules on the subject of legal education i.e. the “Pakistan Bar Council Legal Education Rules, 1978”, the “Affiliation of Law Colleges Rules” and the “Pakistan Bar Council (Recognition of Universities) Rules, 2005” are to be reviewed and consolidated in one set of uniformed Rules; And whereas the constant deterioration of standard and quality of legal education because of mushroom growth of law colleges and even the Universities, in private sector, necessitates strict check and control over the Universities and degree awarding Institutions, imparting legal education, and the private law colleges; Therefore, the Pakistan Bar Council in exercise of powers conferred upon it under Sections 13(j) & (k), 26(c) (iii) and 55(q) of the Legal Practitioners & Bar Councils Act, 1973 and all other enabling provisions in that behalf, hereby promulgates and notifies the following Rules: THE PAKISTAN BAR COUNCIL LEGAL EDUCATION RULES , 2015 CHAPTER I PRELIMINARY 1. Short title and commencement:- (i) These Rules may be called the “Pakistan Bar Council Legal Education Rules, 2015”. Pakistan Bar Council Legal Education Rules, 2015 145 (ii) They shall come into force at once. 2. Overriding effect:- The provisions of these Rules shall have overriding effect notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith contained in any other law and Rules for the time being in force.
    [Show full text]
  • PAKISTAN WATER and POWER DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (April
    PAKISTAN WATER AND POWER DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (April 2011) April 2011 www.wapda.gov.pk PREFACE Energy and water are the prime movers of human life. Though deficient in oil and gas, Pakistan has abundant water and other energy sources like hydel power, coal, wind and solar power. The country situated between the Arabian Sea and the Himalayas, Hindukush and Karakoram Ranges has great political, economic and strategic importance. The total primary energy use in Pakistan amounted to 60 million tons of oil equivalent (mtoe) in 2006-07. The annual growth of primary energy supplies and their per capita availability during the last 10 years has increased by nearly 50%. The per capita availability now stands at 0.372 toe which is very low compared to 8 toe for USA for example. The World Bank estimates that worldwide electricity production in percentage for coal is 40, gas 19, nuclear 16, hydro 16 and oil 7. Pakistan meets its energy requirement around 41% by indigenous gas, 19% by oil, and 37% by hydro electricity. Coal and nuclear contribution to energy supply is limited to 0.16% and 2.84% respectively with a vast potential for growth. The Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA) is vigorously carrying out feasibility studies and engineering designs for various hydropower projects with accumulative generation capacity of more than 25000 MW. Most of these studies are at an advance stage of completion. After the completion of these projects the installed capacity would rise to around 42000 MW by the end of the year 2020. Pakistan has been blessed with ample water resources but could store only 13% of the annual flow of its rivers.
    [Show full text]
  • Curriculum Vitae
    Professor Dr. Shadiullah Khan DEAN & Chairman Faculty of Arts Department of Public Administration Gomal University Dera Ismail Khan NWFP Pakistan Telephone: (Off) 0966-750122 (Res) 0966-750334 (Cell) 03467860906 (Fax) 0966-750255 Email: [email protected] [email protected] Personal Data: Date of Birth January 03, 1960 Domicile/Place of Birth Bannu, N.W.F.P Country of Nationality Pakistan Religion Islam Marital Status Married, having 3 children National Identity Card No: 11101-1526398-9 Education: 2007-08 Post Doctoral School of Social Sciences (Politics) the Research University of Manchester UK Mentors: Drs. Jill Lovecy and Francesca Gains Research Titled: ‘Women Participation in Local Governance’ the Pakistan Experience 2002-2006 PhD Management Studies, Gomal University D.I.Khan Pakistan Thesis Titled: ‘Decentralized Governments and Participatory Rural Development: the Case Study of District Government in Northwestern Pakistan’ Supervisor: Professor Dr. Bahadar Shah 1984 MA Political Science, Gomal University D.I.Khan Pakistan Courses included: Political Thoughts, Political Systems, and Public Administration in Pakistan 1982 MPA Public Administration, in First Division, Department of Public Administration, Gomal University D.I.Khan Pakistan Courses included: Fundaments of Public Administration, Principles of Management, Public Policy Analysis, Organizational Theory and Behaviour, Personnel Administration, Labour Relations and Labour Laws and Principles of Marketing 1979 BA Political Science, Gomal University D.I.Khan Pakistan Courses included: English, Political Science and Islamic Studies 1977 FA Humanities, in First Division, Board of Intermediate & Secondary Education Peshawar Pakistan Courses included: English, Political Science and Islamic Studies 1975 SSC Humanities, in First Division, Board of Intermediate & Secondary Education Peshawar Pakistan Courses included: English, Urdu, Islamic Studies and General Science Employment: 2008 - Continued Professor, Department of Public Administration, Gomal University, D.I.Khan.
    [Show full text]
  • Explore New Business in the Middle East and North the Courage and Valour to Succeed in All of Our Endeavours
    Preface Environmental & Public Health Engineering Sector 28 04 Services Architecture & Planning Sector 22 03 Fields of Activity Transportation Engineering Sector 16 02 Contents List of Major New, Ongoing & Dam Engineering Sector Completed Projects 37 14 Water Resources Sector Information Technology & GIS Sector 34 10 Energy Sector Oil, Gas & Industrial Sector 32 06 Activity Fields of Water Resources Planning, Drainage, Implementation Strategies, Policy Salinity Control and Land Reclamation, Formulation, Residential Communities, Dams and Barrages, Irrigation and Urban/Rural Development Planning, Drainage Systems, Groundwater Advocacy Planning, Preparation of Resources Development, Flood Zoning Regulations and Bye-laws, Management and Forecasting/Warning Tourism Planning, Regeneration, Re- Systems and Institutional and Social settlement and Renewal Planning Development Water Supply, Sewerage, Stormwater Power Transmission and Distribution, Drainage, Solid Waste Management, Substations, Hydropower, Thermal Plumbing, Water and Wastewater Power, Nuclear Power, Rural Treatment Electrification, Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) and Site Characterisation/Baseline Data for Telecommunications and Oil and Gas Environmental Impact Assessment, Environmental Risk Assessment, Motorways, Highways, Urban Roads, Environmental Planning and Rural Roads, Grade-separated Management, Environmental Health and Interchanges, Bridges and Flyovers, Safety, Air and Noise Pollution Control, Subways and Underpasses, Tunnels, Contaminated Site Assessment
    [Show full text]
  • Download Download
    GOMAL UNIVERSITY JOURNAL OF RESEARCH Gomal University, Dera Ismail Khan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan ISSN:1019-8180 (Print) ISSN: 2708-1737 (Online) Website www.gujr.com.pk HEC Recognized Social Sciences PAKISTAN-TURKEY RELATIONS DURING COLD WAR DECADES: BEYOND RELIGION AND CULTURAL DIMENSIONS Rahat Shah The School of International & Public Affairs, The Jilin University, Changchun, CHINA ARTICLE INFO ABSTRACT Keywords: This study explores the bilateral relationship between Pakistan and Pakistan, Turkey, Turkey during the Cold War, in which the bilateral relationship had Ottoman Empire, developed gradually. To understand why it had developed? We must Pakistan-Turkish, Cold transcend cultural and religious factors. The study argues that the War, Kashmir, Cyprus, development of bilateral relations was mainly due to the interest of the Friendship Treaty Western Allies and the strategic consensus between Islamabad and Ankara. Although the Cold War was dominated by bipolarity, in which Article History: two superpowers pursued their power and influence globally including Date of Submission: the Middle East, it is by no means that other regional powers acted 13-01-2020 nothing role. Turkey had played a central role in getting Pakistan to Date of Acceptance: join the regional pact, which was in West's strategic interest. Besides, 18-12-2020 Pakistan and Turkey stood out prominently in terms of the strategic Date of Publication: consensus since 1965. Strategic consensus between them has helped 31-12-2020 to forge cooperation on key issues such as Kashmir and Cyprus. Our analysis shows that relationship between the two countries was caused by these two factors, in which cultural and religious factors are either ineffective or have little impact.
    [Show full text]
  • Physiochemical Analysis of Water and Soil from Gomal Zam Dam Of
    American-Eurasian J. Agric. & Environ. Sci., 15 (6): 1182-1185, 2015 ISSN 1818-6769 © IDOSI Publications, 2015 DOI: 10.5829/idosi.aejaes.2015.15.6.94241 Physiochemical Analysis of Water and Soil from Gomal Zam Dam of Khajuri Kach in South Waziristan Agency of Pakistan, with Special Reference to Their Impact on Fish Growth and Survival 1Hameed-Ur-Rehman, 23 Zubia Masood, Shagufta Saddozai, 4Wali Muhammad Achakzai, 3Fariha Mengal, 3Saima Durrani, 53Huma Tareen, Farhana Khan and 3Humara Zahid 1Department of Chemistry, Kohat University of Science and Technology, Kohat District, KPK Province, Pakistan 2Department of Zoology, University of Karachi, Karachi, Pakistan 3Department of Zoology, SardarBahadur Khan Women University, Quetta, Pakistan 4Department of Zoology, University of Balochistan, Quetta, Pakistan 5Department of Chemistry, SardarBahadur Khan Women University, Quetta, Pakistan Abstract: A study on physicochemical parameters of water and soil was carried out on Gomal Zam Dam situated in Khajuri Kach of South Waziristan Agency in Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) of Pakistan,with special reference to its impact on fish growth and survival. The physicochemical characteristics of both water and soil analyzed in the present study includes i.e., color, odor, elasticity,temperature, pH, conductivity (EC) and total dissolved solids (TDS). The results of present analysis revealed that the temperature of dam water and soil was above the tolerable range of fishes, hence not suitable for fish survival and growth, whereas the remaining other parameters like color, odor, elasticity, pH, EC, TDS were found in suitable range, which indicates the better quality of water and soil of Gomal Zam dam. Therefore, from the result of the present study, it was concluded that GomalZam dam is good to support the survival and production of aquatic life, especially fish fauna.
    [Show full text]
  • Sc-Judgment-On-Legal-Education
    IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN (Appellate Jurisdiction) PRESENT: MR. JUSTICE MIAN SAQIB NISAR, HCJ MR. JUSTICE UMAR ATA BANDIAL MR. JUSTICE IJAZ UL AHSAN CONSTITUTION PETITION NO.134 OF 2012 AND CIVIL MISC. APPLICATION NO.1864 OF 2010 IN CONSTITUTION PETITION NO.9 OF 2005 AND CIVIL MISC. APPLICATIONS NO.1939 OF 2014, 5959 OF 2016, 4095, 1793, 2876, 2996, 3014 AND 6672 OF 2018 IN CONSTITUTION PETITION NO.134 OF 2012 AND CIVIL MISC. APPLICATIONS NO.3034, 3048, 3051 AND 6247 OF 2018 IN CIVIL MISC. APPLICATION NO.1864 OF 2010 Const.P.134/2012: Pakistan Bar Council through its Chairman v. Federal Government through Establishment Division and others C.M.A.1864/2010: Article by Aredshir Cowasjee in Daily Dawn dated 27.06.2010 titled “Looking the Future” regarding standards of professional ethics in the legal profession. C.M.A.1939/2014: Application by Pakistan Bar Council for Impleading Universities as respondents. C.M.A.5959/2016: Application in Respect of Shaheed Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto University of Law (SZABUL) through its Registrar v. Federal Government through Establishment Division and others C.M.A.1793/2018: Impleadment application by Muhammad Amin Sandhila C.M.A.2876/2018: Concise Statement by KPK Law Colleges in reply to show cause notices issued vide order dated 6.3.2018. C.M.A.2996/2018: Impleadment application by Pakistan Bar Council through Chairman Legal Education Committee v. The Federal Government thr. Secretary Establishment and others Const. P. No. 134/2012 2 C.M.A.3014/2018: Impleadment application by Islamabad Bar Council C.M.A.3034/2018: Concise Statement on behalf of respondent No.2 College of Legal & Ethical Studies (Coles), Abbottabad.
    [Show full text]