Calculation Sheet 5010.65
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Private Fuel Storage, L.L.C. "P.O.Box C4010, La Crosse, WI 54602-4010 Phone 303-741-7009 Fax: 303-741-7806 John L. Donnell, P.E., Project Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission June 19, 2000 ATTN: Document Control Desk Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 SUBMITTAL OF COMMITMENT RESOLUTION LETTER #34 INFORMATION DOCKET NO. 72-22 / TAC NO. L22462 PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE FACILITY PRIVATE FUEL STORAGE L.L.C. Reference: PFS Letter, Donnell to U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Commitment Resolution Letter # 34, dated June 2, 2000 In the referenced letter, Private Fuel Storage (PFS) committed to provide the NRC with information on tipover of a cask transporter, propane vapor cloud dispersion, and a revised calculation package associated with bearing capacity and sliding stability of the cask storage pads and the Canister Transfer Building. This letter provides the informational commitments and the calculation package. Attachment 1 contains the calculation package that addresses bearing capacity and sliding stability analyses of the cask storage pads and the Canister Transfer Building. The package consists of the following three calculations which have been revised to address issues discussed in the referenced letter: PFSF Calculation No. 05996.02-G(B)-4, Stability Analysis of Storage Pad, Rev. 6, Stone & Webster. PFSF Calculation No. 05996.02-G(B)-5, Bases for Geotechnical Parameters Provided in Geotechnical Design Criteria, Rev. 2, Stone & Webster. PFSF Calculation No. 05996.02-G(B)-1 3, Stability Analyses of the Canister Transfer Building Supported on a Mat Foundation, Rev. 3, Stone & Webster. IQ rPL~s)jCb U.S. NRC 2 June 19, 2000 Attachment 2 provides the results of an evaluation of the stability of the cask transporter when carrying a storage cask, assuming it is subjected to the PFSF design basis ground motion, or to the design tornado-driven missile. The evaluation concludes that the cask transporter and the storage cask will remain upright and not tip over when subjected to these events. Attachment 3 contains the results of analyses of postulated propane releases from the relatively large propane storage tank(s) that will be located a minimum distance of 1,800 ft south or southwest of the Canister Transfer Building, considering dispersion and delayed ignition. The analyses assessed several different postulated propane leakage scenarios, including rupture of a 20,000 gallon propane tank, rupture of a 5,000 gallon propane tank, severance of a 2 inch vapor line at the tank, and severance of a 2 inch liquid line at the tank. As discussed in Section 8.2.4 of the PFSF SAR, propane vapor will be supplied from the storage tank(s) to the Canister Transfer Building and Security and Health Physics Building, using a compressor to provide the motive force. Based on building heating requirements, a 2 inch line is adequate for this purpose. Analysis of a 2 inch propane liquid line rupture was included for completeness, but liquid propane will not be supplied from the tank(s). It was assumed that variable winds were directed towards the Canister Transfer Building and cask storage area under stable atmospheric conditions (atmospheric stability class F), to minimize dispersion of the propane vapor in the plumes. In the analyses of plume formation for the postulated 2 inch line ruptures, wind speeds were varied between 1 to 5 meters per second to determine the wind speed that resulted in a concentration of gas at the lower explosive limit (LEL) approaching nearest to the Canister Transfer Building and cask storage area. A wind speed of 3 meters per second, combined with atmospheric stability class F, maximized this explosive concentration travel distance and was considered to represent the worst case meteorology. In all cases analyzed, with the exception of postulated rupture of a 20,000 gallon tank, propane-air concentrations diminished to below the LEL at distances much shorter than the 1,800 ft minimum distance from the tank(s) to the Canister Transfer Building and the nearest storage casks. However, in the case of postulated rupture of a 20,000 gallon tank, explosive concentrations of propane traveled to distances beyond 1,800 ft under the worst case meteorological conditions evaluated. Therefore, PFS will design the propane storage for supplying propane to heat the Canister Transfer Building and Security and Health Physics Building with 4 separate tanks, with each tank having a capacity of less than or equal to 5,000 gallons for a total capacity of not more than 20,000 gallons. The 4 tanks shall be separated by missile walls to ensure that a single missile driven by the design tornado can not rupture more than one tank. The design will assure that it is not credible that more than one of the tanks could rupture at any given time. Each propane tank shall have an excess flow shutoff valve that automatically isolates upon sensing high flow that could be due to a downstream line rupture or large leak. In U.S. NRC 3 June 19, 2000 addition, a single excess flow shutoff valve shall be located on the 2 inch piping header that supplies propane to the Canister Transfer Building and Security and Health Physics Building, downstream of the connection points of the lines from the 4 propane tanks. This valve shall also be designed to automatically close upon sensing high flow conditions indicative of a line rupture or large leak. This system of automatic isolation valves will serve to automatically isolate pipeline ruptures, thus preventing significant leakage of propane in the vicinity of the Canister Transfer Building or Security and Health Physics Building. The analyses provided in Attachment 3 also assess overpressures that could occur from postulated propane vapor cloud explosions, assuming ignition occurs near the center of the plumes for each of the 4 propane release cases evaluated. The effects of explosions were analyzed using the TNT energy equivalent methodology, described in PFSF SAR Section 8.2.4. In all cases analyzed, with the exception of postulated rupture of a 20,000 gallon tank, overpressures decreased to less than 1 psi prior to reaching the Canister Transfer Building and nearest storage casks. The PFSF license application will be updated as required to reflect the above information, and that included in the attachments to this letter, and submitted to the NRC by June 23, 2000. If you have any questions regarding this response, please contact me at 303-741-7009. Sincerely • Donnell Project Director Private Fuel Storage L.L.C. Attachments U.S. NRC 4 June 19, 2000 Copy to: Mark Delligatti-1/1 John Parkyn- 1/0 Jay Silberg-1/1 Sherwin Turk- 1/0 Asadul Chowdhury- 1/1 Murray Wade- 1/0 Scott Northard- 1/0 Denise Chancellor- 1/1 Richard E. Condit-1/0 John Paul Kennedy-i/0 Joro Walker- 1/0 ATTACHMENT 1 CALCULATION PACKAGE ADDRESSING BEARING CAPACITY AND SLIDING STABILITY ANALYSES OF THE CASK STORAGE PADS AND THE CANISTER TRANSFER BUILDING STONE & WEBSTER ENGINEERING CORPORATION CALCULATION TITLE PAGE *SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON REVERSE SIDE A SAll fi4 (FRCIThJT CLIENT & PROJECT PAGE I OF •14(ASA, CALCULATION TITLE (Indicative of the Objective): OA CATEGORY ( •-NUCLEAR- SAFETY RELATED 0F11 O 11 ___ OTHER CALCULATION IDENTIFICATION NUMBER CURRENT. OPTIONAL OPTIONAL J.O. OR W.O- NO. DIVISION S GROUP CALC. NO. TASK CODE WORK PACKAGE NO. ,0•- 0 *APPROVALS - SIGNATURE , DATE REV. NO. SUPERSEDES CONFIRMATION PREPARER(S)/DATE(S) REVIEWER(S)/DATE(S) INDEPENDENT OR NEW * CALC. NO. *REQUIRED(V\ REVIEWER(S)/DATE(S) CALC NO. OR REV. NO. YES NO \ka~ NVR~~-- C60 0 18-9? -4.R -T -I-F V_ L - _,jt S.N• ,q- ?AOL,4J'R1k5 . 24 _ _ __0 +13019 -7 '•Au'L3.--%oeAv Nil'zi'T. ,€4,4,.,F,,-., DISTRIBUTION* I OPY copy & LOCATION I SENT GROUP I NAME & LOCATION I SENT GROUP I NAME I (Vi I I (vi RECORDS MGT. I I I FIRE 1%~ -D•E•JCP. III FILES (OR (FRONI FILE IF NONE) A 5010 64-I I I I. , I.L I I I II II SI I I STONE F, WEBSTER ENGINEERING CORPORATION CALCULATION TITLE PAGE *SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON REVERSE SIDE A 5010.64 (FRONT) CLIENT & PROJECT PAGE iA/OF CALCULATION TITLE (Indicative of the Objective)- QA CATEGORY (v') ~~ThJ~~1:9-10~~~~$ O T A.-,(s ' NUCLEAR SAFETY RELATED O3 Inj _ OTHER CALCULATION IDENTIFICATION NUMBER J.0. OR W.0. NO. DIVISION F. GROUP CURRENT OPTIONAL OPTIONAL CALC. NO. TASK CODE WORK PACKAGE NO. *APPROVALS - SIGNATURE &.DATE REV. NO. SUPERSEDES CONFIRMATION PREPARER(S)/DATE(S) REVIEWER(S)/DATE(S) INDEPENDENT OR NEW * CALC. NO. *REQUIRED (V% PREPARER(S)/DATE(S) REVIEWER___/DAT_(S) REVIEWER(S)/DATE(S) CALC NO. OR REV. NO. YES NO '6 L_ 0-o4IX V,.• -o9<•T, L.G a,. _." 5 ,? PP~vu. L2. $\KCAI Z DISTRIBUTION* II COPY IIcopy GROUP I NAME &.,LOCATION SENT GROUP NAME F. LOCATION ISENT I Avv RECORDS MGT. IslI .o,••. IIY.I COP13ST I CP FILES(OR FIREI FILE IF NONE)* I I I I( REODIG . I = e. II I=• FIEIORFR I I I FLIFNN) I I I I -~S~I 'I I I I I I I .I I STONE E. WEBSTER ENGINEERING CORPORATION CALCULATION TITLE PAGE *SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON REVERSE SIDE A 5010.64 (FRONT) CLIENT & PROJECT PAGE IOF CALCULATION TITLE (Indicative of the Objective)- QA CATEGORY (VA ov E(l -NUCLEAR SAFETY RELATED E13I mnl _0 OTHER CALCULATION IDENTIFICATION NUMBER i CURRENT OPTIONAL OPTIONAL J. 0. OR W.O. NO. DIVISION & GROUP CALC. NO. TASK CODE WORK PACKAGE NO. o5q (o. 02-&6. 04 AAPPROVALS - SIGNATURE E.DATE REV. NO. SUPERSEDES CONFIRMATION PREPARER(S)/DATE(S) REVIEWER(S)/DATE (S) INDEPENDENT OR NEW * CALC.