Transforming Fiveways Croydon Factual Consultation Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Transforming Fiveways Croydon Factual Consultation Report March 2018 Contents Executive summary ................................................................................................................ 4 Summary of prominent issues raised during consultation ................................................... 4 Responses from stakeholders ............................................................................................ 5 Campaigns and petitions .................................................................................................... 5 Conclusion and next steps .................................................................................................. 5 1. About the proposals ...................................................................................................... 6 1.1 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 6 1.2 Purpose ................................................................................................................... 6 1.3 Detailed description ................................................................................................. 7 1.4 Road layout changes ............................................................................................... 8 1.5 New and upgraded cycle facilities .......................................................................... 12 1.6 Pedestrian and public space improvements ........................................................... 12 1.7 Potential impacts of the scheme ............................................................................ 13 2. About the consultation ................................................................................................ 16 2.1 Purpose ................................................................................................................. 16 2.2 Potential outcomes ................................................................................................ 16 2.3 Consultation history ............................................................................................... 16 2.4 Who we consulted.................................................................................................. 17 2.5 Dates and duration................................................................................................. 17 2.6 What we asked ...................................................................................................... 17 2.7 Methods of responding .......................................................................................... 18 2.8 Consultation materials and publicity ....................................................................... 19 2.9 Consultation Equalities Assessment ...................................................................... 21 2.10 Analysis of consultation responses ........................................................................ 22 3. About the respondents ................................................................................................ 24 3.1 Number of respondents ......................................................................................... 24 3.2 How respondents heard about the consultation ..................................................... 24 3.3 Methods of responding .......................................................................................... 25 3.4 Postcodes of respondents ...................................................................................... 26 3.5 Respondent type and location ................................................................................ 27 4. Summary of all consultation responses ....................................................................... 30 4.1 Overall support – Summary of responses to Question 1 ........................................ 30 4.2 Summary of responses to Question 2 .................................................................... 36 2 4.3 Summary of responses to Question 3 .................................................................... 38 4.4 Summary of responses to Question 4 .................................................................... 39 4.5 Summary of responses to Question 5 .................................................................... 40 4.6 Summary of responses to Question 6 .................................................................... 41 4.7 Summary of responses to Question 7 .................................................................... 41 4.8 Summary of responses to Question 8 .................................................................... 42 4.9 Summary of stakeholder responses ....................................................................... 42 4.10 Petitions and campaigns ........................................................................................ 54 4.11 Summary of comments from events ....................................................................... 57 4.12 Comments on the consultation ............................................................................... 58 5. Conclusion and next steps .......................................................................................... 60 Appendices .......................................................................................................................... 61 Appendix A: All comments by frequency ........................................................................... 61 Appendix B: Detailed analysis of comments ..................................................................... 72 Appendix C: Consultation questions ................................................................................. 98 Appendix D: Consultation letter ...................................................................................... 100 Appendix E: Letter and Plan Distribution Map ................................................................. 106 Appendix F: Consultation Leaflet .................................................................................... 107 Appendix G: Additional letters to residents ..................................................................... 110 Appendix H: Exhibition materials .................................................................................... 113 Appendix I: Press release ............................................................................................... 118 Appendix J: Customer emails ......................................................................................... 120 Appendix K: Stakeholder emails ..................................................................................... 121 Appendix L: Advert in local press .................................................................................... 123 Appendix M: Copy of online consultation ........................................................................ 124 Appendix N: Journey Time impacts ................................................................................ 140 Appendix O: Notable online posts ................................................................................... 145 Appendix P: LCC campaign website ............................................................................... 146 Appendix Q: Stafford Road Action Committee petition .................................................... 149 Appendix R: Response from Waddon Ward Councillors ................................................. 152 Appendix S: List of stakeholders..................................................................................... 156 3 Executive summary Working in partnership with Croydon Council, we consulted on our proposed major changes to the road layout on the A23 and A232 at Fiveways in Waddon. The consultation ran for ten weeks; opening on 10 July and closing on 18 September 2017. This report is a factual analysis of the responses received. On 10 July 2017, we published detailed information about our proposals on our website, which we publicised using a number of channels, including the distribution of leaflets across a wide area, targeted email campaigns and news stories in regional and local media. The consultation sought feedback on the proposals from those who may be affected by or interested in the proposals, including, but not limited to; local residents, businesses, employers, transport users and other relevant stakeholders. We also contacted those who responded to the initial consultation on the scheme, which took place in early 2015, to invite their further comments. We received 431 direct responses to the consultation, including 27 from stakeholder organisations. Of these responses, 63 per cent supported or supported most elements of our proposals, 19 per cent opposed all or most elements of our proposals, and 18 per cent did not give an opinion or were not sure. Of the 431 direct responses, 285 were from local residents, where 72 per cent of respondents supported or supported most elements of our proposals. In addition to questions asking respondents for their general level of support for the proposals, we also asked for comments on the three main scheme components. Summary of prominent issues raised during consultation Our detailed analysis of responses is included as Appendix B. 1. Support for dedicated provision for cyclists across the whole scheme area. The provision of better links north-south on the A23 Purley Way was of particular concern; there was also support for continuing the cycle track