DOCSLIB.ORG

Blogger's Site Gets Hammering | Stuff.Co.Nz

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Blogger's Site Gets Hammering | Stuff.Co.Nz 4/15/13 Blogger's site gets hammering | Stuff.co.nz Blogger's site gets hammering MARTIN VAN BEYNEN Last updated 10:55 13/04/2013 Christchurch residents have hammered an offshore website holding a leaked Earthquake Commission (EQC) email as lawyers debate the legal issues the saga raises. As indicated by social media and comments to The Press website, droves have visited the website to see the sensitive information about their properties. On Tuesday the High Court in Wellington granted EQC an injunction prohibiting release of the email but since then a blogger, who is a former EQC employee, has released parts of the email and an overseas website has obtained it. It is now easily available. The email saga began last month when EQC accidentally released an email containing details on 83,000 properties damaged by the earthquakes of 2010 and 2011. Many have discovered discrepancies between amounts reached by EQC estimators and the true cost of repairs. One homeowner found EQC had allocated about $50,000 for his repair when it was well over $120,000. The original recipient of the email, businessman Bryan Staples of Earthquake Services Ltd, said the email should be most interesting to those EQC had "cash settled". "They will be able to see if they got a fair settlement or whether EQC played hardball and screwed the estimated amount down," he said. Yesterday, police said they were still assessing a complaint against Staples by EQC and had not received a further complaint about the blogger. Media law expert Steven Price said the court ruling granting the EQC injunction contains shocking omissions. "I think there may be good grounds for the injunction. "But I am shocked that the court has failed to address basic aspects of the law," he said on his blog. The most glaring omission was the court's failure to address the fact EQC had to show, "it is in the public interest to enforce secrecy". Justice David Collins had also completely neglected to mention the public interest defence claimed by the blogger. "Nor did the judge apply the Bill of Rights, despite the fact that he cannot by law grant an injunction that affects free speech rights unless he finds that to do so is demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society. "I would have thought there was a fair case to be made that the free speech interests here are strong ones: the blogger has alleged the email reveals incompetent and biased claims assessment. ". in the absence of a proper analysis of the legal principles, he (the judge) provides no reason for us to be confident that he's got it right." Christchurch lawyer Margo Perpick, a partner of Wynn Williams, added to the controversy yesterday by saying the Ombudsman had already supported EQC's position "that information about homeowners' EQC claims can be withheld from the homeowners concerned". "In February 2012, the Ombudsman Dame Beverley Wakem decided EQC was justified in withholding the costs estimates within EQC's scope of works documents for some earthquake affected properties. For properties which had claims between $10,000 and $100,000 damage being www.stuff.co.nz/auckland/local-news/national-news/8547039/Bloggers-site-gets-hammering 1/2 4/15/13 Blogger's site gets hammering | Stuff.co.nz managed by Fletcher EQR, and where agreements had not yet been reached with contractors to carry out the repairs, the EQC refused to release the cost estimates. The Ombudsman said that EQC was justified in doing so." EQC had argued the costs estimates needed to be kept confidential until a contract was agreed and awarded, in order to ensure that all quotes were independently arrived at." The Ombudsman accepted that position, Perpick said. Prominent Auckland lawyer Mai Chen said EQC may be powerless to stop private information from the leaked email spreading through social media. EQC was running up against the "limits of the law" in trying to get a practical outcome, she said. Chen said that if individuals "willfully disregard the law", then EQC could have to sue "potentially dozens or hundreds of people" for breach of confidence or contempt of court. "The problem is, sooner or later if the information is distributed widely enough, it will lose its confidential character, and at that point EQC will no longer be able to enforce confidentiality." - © Fairfax NZ News www.stuff.co.nz/auckland/local-news/national-news/8547039/Bloggers-site-gets-hammering 2/2.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Its All Happening Just When You Thought Things Were Winding Down
    Its All Happening Just when you thought things were winding down for the year and there would be only holiday racing to concentrate on, a couple of recent important announcements have rather re-focussed the mind. First of all, and definitely most importantly, a successor to Edward Rennell has been announced. As I’ve said earlier, Edward leaves a massive pair for shoes to fill, and I know that, for years to come, his legacy will be felt in many different ways. My main concern about his replacement was that it would be someone who didn’t have the same passion and love for harness racing that he undoubtedly possessed. It was with relief then, that Peter Jensen was selected to take the reins, because he is yet another whose passion for our industry is without question. Having known Peter on both a personal and business basis for many years, he will bring skills and experience to the role that will be sorely needed in the difficult times ahead. Having attended a number of meetings he has had with the Trainers & Drivers Greater Canterbury Branch since he took over at Addington, it is clear that he made a favourable impression on some folk in our game who are not easily impressed, with his considered approach and willingness to at least listen to concerns, at the same time making no promises. The other announcement, this time from the Government, was the naming of those to be involved in the Ministerial Advisory Committee. Fearing that this body would be heavily slanted in favour of our sister code, it was pleasing to see that, with the obvious exception of Sir Peter Vela, that doesn’t appear to be the case.
    [Show full text]
  • CERA Inquiry Final Report
    CERA Inquiry Final Report CERA: Alleged Conflicts of Interest Inquiry for State Services Commissioner Final Report dated 31 March 2017 In accordance with Principle 7 of the Privacy Act 1993, a statement received from Mr Gallagher and Mr Nikoloff is attached at the end of the Report. Michael Heron QC Page 1 of 46 CERA Inquiry Final Report TABLE OF CONTENTS 1) Introduction 2) Summary of Conclusions 3) Applicable Standards 4) Discussion - PIML 5) Discussion - 32 Oxford Terrace – Mr Cleverley Appendix 1 – Terms of Reference Appendix 2 – Prime Minister’s letter and Jurisdiction Appendix 3 – Process and Documentation Appendix 4 – Applicable Standards Appendix 5 – Interviewees Appendix 6 – Canterbury DHB chronology Page 2 of 46 CERA Inquiry Final Report 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 The Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Authority (CERA) was established under the Canterbury Earthquake Recovery Act 2011 to assist with the Government's response to the devastating Canterbury earthquakes of 2010 and 2011. After five years of operation, CERA was disestablished on 18 April 2016. 1.2 Within CERA, the Implementation/Central City Development Unit (CCDU) set out to drive the rebuild of central Christchurch. The Investment Strategy group sat within that unit and was responsible for retaining, promoting and attracting investment in Christchurch. 1.3 In early 2017, investigative journalist Martin van Beynen published a series of articles on alleged conflicts of interest within CERA and CCDU. Due to the serious allegations raised, the State Services Commissioner appointed me to undertake this Inquiry on his behalf on 7 February 2017 pursuant to sections 23(1) and 25(2) of the State Sector Act 1988.
    [Show full text]
  • Fairfax/NZME – Response to Questions Arising from the Conference
    1 PUBLIC VERSION NZME AND FAIRFAX RESPONSE TO COMMERCE COMMISSION QUESTIONS ARISING FROM THE CONFERENCE ON 6 AND 7 DECEMBER 2016 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1. During its recent Conference held on 6 and 7 December 2016, the Commissioners asked the parties to follow up on a number of points. This paper sets out the parties' responses on those questions, and also provides answers to some further follow-up questions that the parties have received since the Conference. 2. The main points that this response covers are as follows: (a) Inefficient duplication of commodity news (external plurality): The Commissioners asked the parties to produce examples of "commodity" news coverage as between the five main media organisations being similar ("digger hits bridge" was provided as an example of where all the major media organisations covered effectively the same point). Reducing that duplication will be efficiency enhancing and will not materially detract from the volume or quality of news coverage. (b) A wide variety of perspectives are covered within each publication (internal plurality): The editors provided the Commission with examples of how each publication covers a wide variety of perspectives, as that is what attracts the greatest audience. This is true both within and across each of the parties' publications. The Commission asked for examples, which are provided in this response, together with additional material about why those incentives do not change post-Merger. (c) Constitutional safeguards on editorial independence: The Commissioners asked about what existing structures protected editorial independence and balance and fairness in reporting. This was asked both in the context of a possible future sale of Fairfax's stake, and in the context of the protections available to those subject to negative reporting seeking fairness and balance.
    [Show full text]
  • Tess-Mcclure-Robert
    Robert Bell Research Summary, 2017 FIGHTING THE BEHEMOTH Sustaining Hyper-Local Public Interest Journalism in the Digital Age T McClure Contents Introduction: Where are we now?............4 The structure of this report…………..8 Part One………..9 Solving the Problem of Trust………...9 Membership Models and Reader Engagement…………..9 What’s caused our crisis in trust?.………..10 Membership Models…………14 Case Study: De Correspondent..………..15 Possible Applications: reFining the ofFering..………..17 Local Application Case Study: The SpinoFF Auckland..………..17 Possible applications: enhancing audience engagement..………..19 Case Study: The Farenthold Method…………..19 Possible Applications: Hyperlocal Membership…………..21 Case Study: The Lens.…………..21 Part Two…………..24 Solving the Problem of Local…………..24 State Models and Content Agreements…………..24 Case Study: The Local Democracy Reporters…………..25 Possible Applications: Local Reporting as Wire Service…………..25 Part Three…………..27 2 Solving the Problem of SurFace Area…………..27 Databases, ResurFacing and Wiki Models…………..27 Case Study: The Messenger…………..29 Local Applications: Databases and ResurFacing…………..31 Conclusion………..35 3 Introduction: Where are we now? Both globally and locally, the journalism industry is experiencing unprecedented levels of convergence and financial pressure. Nowhere is it felt more than at a local level. The global trends are toward shrinking local newsrooms, and a re-concentration of reporters out of local papers and toward national or international digital platForms. Census data shows that the number of print journalists [the census does not record a digital journalist category] in New Zealand dropped an enormous 61 percent between 2006 and 2013. Meanwhile, those leFt in journalism face an increasingly dominant PR industry - closely corresponding with the drop in print journalists have been a 56 percent increase in numbers of PR proFessionals, between 2006 and 2013.
    [Show full text]
  • Christchurch Journalists' Collective Trauma Experience and The
    July 1, 2014 Quake aftermath: Christchurch journalists' collective trauma experience and the implications for their reporting. A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Ph.D in Journalism by Sean Scanlon -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- University of Canterbury Christchurch New Zealand 2014 1 Abstract: On February 22, 2011, Christchurch-based journalists were jolted out of their normal work routine by a large 6.3 magnitude earthquake that killed 185 people, wrecked the city and forced reporters to reappraise their journalism. This study considers how the earthquake affected journalists’ relationship to the community, their use of sources and news selection. A theory of collective trauma is used to explain the changes that journalists made to their reporting practice. Specifically, Christchurch journalists had a greater identification and attachment to their audience post-earthquake. Journalists viewed themselves as part of the earthquake story, which prompted them to view sources differently, use those sources differently and see advocacy as a keystone of their news work after the disaster. This study adds to a growing scholarship about journalists and trauma, but focuses on what the event meant for local reporters’ choice of sources and news selection rather than measuring rates of psychological distress. 2 Acknowledgments I have many people to thank for helping me complete this study. Being a journalist by training and not an academic has made the experience an interesting one, which required the guidance of many more people than I can name. First, thanks to my patient and wise supervisors Jim Tully and Donald Matheson. I asked for critical feedback and always appreciated your honest responses and guidance.
    [Show full text]
  • New Murder Probe
    Monday, April 6, 2020 Since Sept 27, 1879 Retail $2.20 Home delivered from $1.40 THE INDEPENDENT VOICE OF MID CANTERBURY Siren’s birthday lockdown Life’s a beach FULL STORY P3 P4 New murder probe BY MATT MARKHAM formation available to them and going Kirsty grew up in. [email protected] that step further as well to ensure they Also, along with Detective Inspec- A new investigation into the unsolved gained as bigger picture as possible for tor, Greg Murton, who was handed the murder of Ashburton teenager Kirsty the investigation. Bentley file in 2014, they walked the Bentley in 1998 has revealed new de- “The problem with the Kirsty Bentley same track Bentley had near the Ash- tails and information around one of case is that it’s been pretty well raked burton River and visited the site in the New Zealand’s most prolific cold case over, so finding that point of difference Rakaia Gorge where her body was dis- murders. was always going to be the key for us,” covered two weeks after she went miss- Released on news website Stuff at the Ensor told the Guardian yesterday. ing. weekend, the investigation, dubbed “We spent a fair amount of time in- “That was really important for us, to Killer Blow, was undertaken by Fairfax itially just going over all the Fairfax be down in Ashburton and seeing such investigative journalists Blair Ensor and news stories on the case and from that significant areas in the case in real life Martin van Beynen and was the result we felt like we had enough information and not trying to do it all from the com- of months of interviews, research and for a really strong story, but we wanted fort of the office in Christchurch.
    [Show full text]
  • NZME LIMITED and FAIRFAX NEW ZEALAND LIMITED COMMERCE COMMISSION CONFERENCE 7 DECEMBER 2016 9.30 Am Plurality
    1 1 NZME LIMITED AND FAIRFAX NEW ZEALAND LIMITED 2 COMMERCE COMMISSION CONFERENCE 3 7 DECEMBER 2016 4 9.30 am 5 6 Plurality ...................................................................................................... 2 7 8 ___________________________________________________________________ 9 10 CHAIR: Welcome back to day two of the conference on the Fairfax NZME merger. I'm not sure 11 whether I have to redo the health and safety comments I did yesterday, but out of an 12 abundance of caution I'll give you my truncated version of it and, that is, if a siren sounds 13 you'll be ushered out to an assembly point and if there's an earthquake it's crouching and 14 holding in here until such time as it's safe to go outside, don't go rushing outside, I think 15 those were the two key points. 16 One other matter of housekeeping, the draft of the transcript for yesterday's public 17 sessions are available and they'll be published on the website today. That will appear on 18 our NZME Fairfax project page. 19 Today is going to be exploring some wide-ranging views initially on plurality and 20 there'll be just a bit of traffic and organisation because not only will we hear from the 21 executives of the company, but we are keen today to hear from journalists with different 22 voices and I assume they are present in the room today and will come in, some on the 23 phone as well. So we just have to be very careful for the record to make sure that 24 everybody is identifying themselves and speaking clearly into a source that can be heard by 25 the stenographer.
    [Show full text]
  • EERI-Recon-Rpt-111316 NZ Tsunami Final
    EERI Preliminary Notes on Tsunami Damage and Response: Tsunami Generated by M7.8 Kaikoura, New Zealand, Earthquake on November 14, 2016 Compiled by Rick Wilson and Laurie Johnson December 2016 A product of the EERI Learning From Earthquakes Program EERI Notes on Tsunami Response and Damage: Tsunami Generated by M7.8 New Zealand Earthquake on November 13, 2016 Page 1 1 PURPOSE The Earthquake Engineering Research Institute (EERI) supports gathering and sharing information about the effects and damage caused by tsunamis as well as the lessons learned about tsunami evacuation and response activities. This report summarizes the damage and response outcomes of the tsunami which was generated by the M7.8 Kaikoura, New Zealand earthquake on November 14, 2016 (November 13, 2016 for U.S.) (Figure 1). Although EERI-related field teams were not deployed for the tsunami, the report provides information compiled by the authors from various references, colleagues, and their own experiences during and after the event. Laurie Johnson was a member of the Geotechnical Extreme Event Reconnaissance team supported by the National Science Foundation to investigate geotechnical effects of the earthquake. The information presented should be considered preliminary; for updates, the authors recommend readers visit the scientific and emergency management websites discussed herein. Figure 1 The epicentral area of the November 14, 2016, earthquake. The authors who compiled this information include: § Rick Wilson, Senior Engineering Geologist with the California Geological Survey § Laurie Johnson, Laurie Johnson Consulting/Research The authors’ objectives for this paper include: 1. Summarizing the physical tsunami effects and damage from the event. 2. Documenting tsunami notification and response activities both in New Zealand and elsewhere.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 2011-2
    Australasian Journal of Disaster and Trauma Studies Volume 2011–2 SPECIAL ISSUE - A FOCUS ON THE CANTERBURY EARTHQUAKES Contents How the 2010 Canterbury (Darfield) earthquake affected earthquake risk perception: Comparing citizens inside and outside the earthquake region John McClure, Celine Wills, David Johnston & Claudia Recker 3 Sleeplessness, Stress, Cognitive Disruption and Academic Performance Following the September 4, 2010, Christchurch Earthquake Simon Kemp, William S. Helton, Jessica J. Richardson, Neville M. Blampied & Michael Grimshaw 11 Early Disaster Recovery: A Guide for Communities Suzanne Vallance 19 Rapid response research in Christchurch: Providing evidence for recovery decisions and for future theoretical research Felicity Powell, Abigail Harding, Jared Thomas & Kate Mora 26 The Management of Portable Toilets in the Eastern Suburbs of Christchurch after the February 22, 2011 Earthquake R Potangaroa, S Wilkinson, M Zare & P Steinfort 35 Animal welfare impact following the 4 September 2010 Canterbury (Darfield) earthquake Steve Glassey & Thomas Wilson 49 COMMENTARY ARTICLE Caring for the Carers: the emotional effects of disasters on health care professionals Peter Huggard 60 1 trauma.massey.ac.nz 2 trauma.massey.ac.nz Australasian Journal of Disaster and Trauma Studies Volume 2011–2 How the 2010 Canterbury (Darfield) earthquake affected earthquake risk perception: Comparing citizens inside and outside the earthquake region John McClure1 Canterbury. Christchurch participants also reported Celine Wills1 damage suffered in the earthquake. Expectations of 2 David Johnston an earthquake occurring in Canterbury were low before Claudia Recker1 the Darfield earthquake in all three samples and rose 1 Victoria University of Wellington significantly after that earthquake. Palmerston North 2 Massey University / GNS(Science), expectancies of an earthquake in their own city also Joint Centre for Disaster Research.
    [Show full text]
  • Earthquake Could Be Cause of 'Shock Hair Loss'
    Earthquake could be cause of ‘shock hair loss’ Jo McKenzie-McLean [email protected] Red-tape Girls as young as eight are losing their hair to stress after the Canterbury earthquakes. Janine Antram, a government- approved wig provider, said about 100 girls and women from Canter- bury had contacted her since last October wanting wigs because holdups they were suffering from alopecia. ‘‘I have an inquiry from a Christchurch resident experienc- ing hair loss almost every day,’’ she said. Ministry of Health figures show 218 people in Canterbury had claimed grants for wig and stymie hairpiece services for temporary hair loss since September 4. Only 83 people had applied for the grant for the year between September 2009 and September 2010. Antram, of Cambridge, has alopecia and said she did not have any Christchurch clients until builders after the September 4 quake, and now they made up about 50 per Martin van Beynen cent of her business. [email protected] ‘‘There is huge hair loss going on in Christchurch,’’ she said. ‘‘I Christchurch builders say they are don’t know if it is related to the running out of work as insurance earthquake, but I do know alopecia difficulties halt urgent projects is related to stress, and clients and slow the Christchurch rebuild have said [alopecia] has come on to a crawl. since the earthquakes.’’ Clarkville builder Gideon Her youngest client was an Couper said he and his two-man eight-year-old, and most of her crew had about a week of work on clients were aged between 10 and the books before he ran out of jobs.
    [Show full text]
  • Christchurch Journalists' Collective Trauma Experience and the Implications for Their Reporting
    MEDIANZ VOL 14 NO 1 • 2014 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.11157/medianz-vol14iss1id108 - ARTICLE - Quake Aftermath: Christchurch Journalists' Collective Trauma Experience and the Implications for Their Reporting Sean Scanlon• Abstract On February 22, 2011, Christchurch-based journalists were jolted out of their normal work routine by a large 6.3 magnitude earthquake that killed 185 people, wrecked the city and forced reporters to reappraise their journalism. This study considers how the earthquake affected journalists’ relationship to the community, their use of sources and news selection. A theory of collective trauma is used to explain the changes that journalists made to their reporting practice. Specifically, Christchurch journalists had a greater identification and attachment to their audience post-earthquake. Journalists viewed themselves as part of the earthquake story, which prompted them to view sources differently, use those sources differently and see advocacy as a keystone of their news work after the disaster. This study adds to a growing scholarship about journalists and trauma, but focuses on what the event meant for local reporters’ choice of sources and news selection rather than measuring rates of psychological distress. The 22 February 2011 Canterbury earthquake provides an opportunity to consider how a traumatic event affects local journalists’ perception of their role in society, and their relationships to their audience and sources. From seeing the deadly results of the initial shake to interviewing those who lost loved ones, Christchurch-based journalists across print, radio and television faced difficult situations that they would not ordinarily encounter. These conditions presented unsual challenges for local journalists who shared the disaster experience with their audience.
    [Show full text]
  • Housing in Post-Quake Canterbury: Human Rights Fault Lines Natalie Baird
    NEW ZEALAND CENTRE FOR PUBLIC LAW Te Wānanga o ngā Kaupapa Ture ā Iwi o Aotearoa NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL PUBLIC OF AND INTERNATIONAL 15 VOL 1 NO LAW NZCPL OCCASIONAL PAPERS New Zealand Journal of 1 Workways of the United States Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg 2 The Role of the New Zealand Law Commission Public and International Law Justice David Baragwanath 3 Legislature v Executive – The Struggle Continues: Observations on the Work of the Regulations Review Committee Hon Doug Kidd 4 The Maori Land Court – A Separate Legal System? Chief Judge Joe Williams 5 The Role of the Secretary of the Cabinet – The View from the Beehive Marie Shroff 6 The Role of the Governor-General Dame Silvia Cartwright 7 Final Appeal Courts: Some Comparisons Lord Cooke of Thorndon 8 Parliamentary Scrutiny of Legislation under the Human Rights Act 1998 Anthony Lester QC 9 Terrorism Legislation and the Human Rights Act 1998 Anthony Lester QC 10 2002: A Justice Odyssey Kim Economides 11 Tradition and Innovation in a Law Reform Agency Hon J Bruce Robertson 12 Democracy through Law VOLUME 15 ▪ NUMBER 2 ▪ DECEMBER 2017 Lord Steyn 13 Hong Kong’s Legal System: The Court of Final Appeal Hon Mr Justice Bokhary PJ 14 Establishing the Ground Rules of International Law: Where to from Here? Bill Mansfield THIS ISSUE INCLUDES CONTRIBUTIONS BY 15 The Case that Stopped a Coup? The Rule of Law in Fiji Debra Angus Joanna Mossop George Williams 17 The Official Information Act 1982: A Window on Government or Curtains Drawn? Eve Bain Sascha Mueller Steven Price Natalie Baird
    [Show full text]