Project A+ Serving Students with Autsm Spectrum Disorder in the Academic Library
This project was made possible in part by the Insttute of Museum and Library Services [RE-31-16-0129- 16] Laura Bush 21st Century Librarian Program, Category 2 Research and Florida State University ©2018 Introducton
Introducton
Project A+ is a research study that discovered solutons to serving academic library users with autsm spectrum disorder (ASD). The research protocol included working with three diverse academic libraries, librarians, disability services personnel, and students on the autsm spectrum to gather data on the types of library setngs, actvites, services, and materials that students with ASD prefer. This resultng manual for academic librarians is intended to assist them in reducing library anxiety and supportng success in students with ASD and their use of the library.
This manual from Project A+ also builds on the successful Florida State IMLS-funded Project PALS (Panhandle Autsm Library Services) a set of four online self-paced professional development chapters, available on WebJuncton, that provide practcal strategies for librarians in all types of libraries to implement. The PALS exit survey revealed further informaton – that training, strategies, and real-world models are needed in order for librarians to fully support patrons with ASD at the highest levels, partcularly in college and university libraries.
2 Introducton
A Note on Approaches Used
The research leading to the development of this training manual used the social model of disability studies, allowing for voices of students with ASD to be presented in their own words, not as mediated by parents, caregivers, or the perceptons of faculty and staf of their lived experiences. The social model also provides the framework for librarians and libraries to adapt services, not students, with ASD adaptng to suit neurotypical-centric services.
Though the social model advocates for ability frst language (e.g. “autstc person”), this manual is presented using person frst language (“person with autsm”) to place the person before the disability. The study authors acknowledge that this is an ongoing debate, and that there will be disagreement over the correct terms to use. Please understand that this was a thoughtul choice, made afer much discussion between study authors and stakeholders. A good resource to learn more about identty frst language can be found on the Autstc Self Advocacy Network.
Similarly, the study authors acknowledge that there are many esteemed sources of informaton about autsm and seek to cite these sources widely. While all sources cited within this document contain, what the authors believe to be valuable informaton, we also acknowledge the controversy that surrounds involvement of informaton not created by self- advocates or those who identfy as having autsm. As such, the authors strive to include all points of view and include frst person accounts when possible. Informaton on People First Language can be further explained at htps://www.cdc.gov/ ncbddd/disabilityandhealth/disability-strategies.html
How to Use the Manual
This training manual was developed with busy librarians and library staf in mind, so you are able to access each chapter as needed. For those who are interested in digging deeper into partcular topics, a bibliography is provided at the end of each chapter, as well as a comprehensive bibliography at the conclusion of the manual.
We suggest that you open this manual in sofware such as Adobe Reader. You also have the opton to print and view it at your convenience. Many of the templates and tools throughout might be helpful to print and have available as ready reference for staf at the front desk.
Throughout this document, you will fnd empty boxes like the one to the lef. These are fllable blanks that you may use to type responses to the refecton and brainstorming actvites. If you are using a supported pdf reader, then you just need to click inside the box to begin typing.
3 Introducton
Chapters at a Glance
These six chapters have been designed to provide helpful informaton and strategies for academic librarians and library staf interactng with individuals with autsm. The chapters include objectves, content informaton, videos, checklists, examples, and links to additonal resources. The following is a descripton of each of the chapters: 1. About Autsm: provides informaton about ASD, life with ASD on college campuses, and why understanding it is important for librarians and library staf. 2. The Library Environment: explores the importance of the library environment and how, by understanding and organizing the environment, you can support students with autsm. 3. Communicaton: describes common social communicaton behaviors of students with ASD.
4. Social Interacton: explains opportunites librarians can create for social interacton among students with ASD, as well as difusion techniques for negatve interactons. 5. Technology: examines how libraries can enhance the social and vocatonal independence of individuals with ASD by harnessing the power of technology. 6. Employment: discusses employing students with ASD in the library in various roles, as well as improving hiring practces for all members of this populaton.
Project A+ Team
Project A+ is a research study led by Dr. Nancy Everhart of Florida State University’s School of Informaton and Dr. Juliann Woods of FSU’s School of Communicaton Sciences and Disorders, and managed by Dr. Amelia Anderson, also of the School of Informaton. This project was made possible through the IMLS Laura Bush 21st Century Librarian Program Category 2 – Research.
Dr. Nancy Everhart Dr. Juliann Woods Dr. Amelia Anderson Co-Principal Investgator Co-Principal Investgator Project Coordinator
Curt Fulwider Kriste Escobar Graduate Assistant Research Assistant
4 Introducton
Advisory Board
The Project A+ Board of Advisors provided virtual feedback on the research results. They assisted in the research process and interpretng results from their unique perspectves as those on the autsm spectrum, librarians, autsm experts, researchers and librarians with autsm. This feedback was necessary in designing an implementaton guide that is valuable to librarians as well as impactul to those on the autsm spectrum.
Melissa is a researcher at the Blake is the Florida Collecton and Florida State University School of Outreach Librarian at the State Informaton. Her research focuses Library of Florida. Blake also served on the role academic libraries as a valued advisory board member play in neurotypical high school for Project PALS and is on the students’ transiton to college. autsm spectrum. Dr. Melissa Gross Blake Robinson
Lisa is a professor and coordinator Suzanne is PI, Targetng Autsm for Informaton Literacy Services IMLS LB21 Grant Project and and Instructon at the University of Associate Director, Library Illinois Urbana-Champaign campus Automaton & Technology for the library. Illinois State Library
Dr. Lisa Hinchlife Suzanne Schriar
Adria is an ASD self-advocate and Paul is the Distance Educaton founder of Adria’s Village, which Librarian at the University of provides training to those who Minnesota, Mankato and is on the work or interact with individuals autsm spectrum. with disabilites.
Adria Nassim Dr. Paul Wyss
Charlie is the Electronic Resources and Serials Librarian at the University of Tennessee at Chatanooga and is on the autsm spectrum.
Charlie Remy
5 About Autsm on Campus
1 About Autsm on Campus
"In truth, I am accustomed to spaces that were clearly designed without someone like me in mind. My sensory integraton difcultes, my spatal confusion, my social anxiety: all are consttutve of neurological atypicality that puts me at a systematc disadvantage in a society structured around a rather specifc human ideal. Yet while I generally antcipate that most of the places I go will be less than accommodatng, this is not the case for libraries. Throughout my life and into the early stages of my library career, I have come Emily Lawrence, to expect more of these insttutons. My expectatons are ted up with a concept of the librarian and autsm library as “safe space,” as well as with the core principals of the feld. So, when the library self-advocate fails to live up to such expectatons – grounded as they are in our stated commitments as librarians – it is important to ask what has gone wrong and how we might go about fxing it" (Lawrence, 2013, p. 98).
6 About Autsm on Campus
Over the past two decades the prevalence of ASD has risen signifcantly and is currently the fastest growing disability in the United States. A recent report from the Centers for Disease Control and Preventon (2018) confrms that ASD is present in approximately 1 child in every 59.
Prevalence of ASD within the general populaton is refected in the growing number of college and university students with this disability (Barnhill, 2014; Gelbar, Smith, & Reichow, 2014; Pinder-Amaker, 2014) and their challenges. Many adolescents and adults with autsm report dependence on their families, no close friends, and few recreatonal actvites (Howlin & Magiat, 2017). More students with ASD are registering for support services than ever before, but that does not account for those who either do not see themselves as in need of disability services or do not have a formal diagnosis and atempt to forge the academic journey alone. College atriton rates are higher for college students with ASD than for neurotypical college students due to the lack of supports that were available K-12 and other unique characteristcs of this populaton including high rates of anxiety disorder, challenges during periods of transiton, and difculty adaptng to social and behavioral norms (Drake, 2014). Academic library usage correlates to college retenton for college students as a whole, giving reason to believe that academic librarians are in a unique positon to help support the success of college students with ASD (Murray, Ireland, & Hackathorn, 2016).
What is Autsm?
ASD has been defned by the American Psychiatric The range of symptom presentaton, severity levels, Associaton (2013) as a complex neurodevelopmental and other conditons contribute to the complexity of disorder that is characterized by impairments in social identfcaton, interventon, and successful socializaton for communicaton and interacton and by restricted, repettve those with ASD. paterns of behavior and interests. ASD afects how an individual interacts with others, communicates, learns, and behaves. The phrase, “If you’ve met one person with autsm, you’ve met one person with autsm,” emphasizes the breadth of the diferences between individuals with "More people than ever before are being the diagnosis. diagnosed with ASD. It is unclear how much of this increase is due to a broader ASD is further specifed for each individual by indicatng defniton of ASD and beter eforts in whether the diagnosis is: diagnosis. However, a true increase • with or without accompanying intellectual in the number of people with an ASD impairment; cannot be ruled out. The increase in ASD diagnosis is likely due to a combinaton • with or without accompanying language of these factors.“ (CDC, 2017, para. 3). impairment; • or associated with a known medical or genetc conditon or environmental factor.
7 About Autsm on Campus
Persons with autsm do not exhibit common physical Prevalence of ASD characteristcs that would identfy them. The manifestaton Whether you knew it at the tme or not, you have likely of symptoms in each individual with ASD also varies greatly. already interacted with or assisted a student on the autsm spectrum. The most recent informaton provided by the Approximately 30% of individuals with ASD experience Centers for Disease Control states: intellectual and adaptve disorders; however, it is social and communicaton impairments that limit their opportunites for community partcipaton, independence, and the quality of their lives most signifcantly. This is where libraries can make a diference.
Observable Characteristcs of ASD Various observable behaviors of individuals with ASD may occur while they use in the library and these may assist you in providing support. Recogniton is the frst step in supportng interacton and satsfacton within the library environment. Students on the autsm spectrum might have partcular sensitvity to fuorescent lights, or might show signs of sensitvity to noisy library interactons, such as instructon sessions or other events. They might be uncomfortable making eye contact when requestng materials or assistance, or might have difcultes engaging in conversaton.
Can you tell which of the students below have autsm?
8 About Autsm on Campus
Experts believe there are many explanatons for the Adult Diagnosis increase in the prevalence of autsm (Wright, 2017). Though early diagnosis for autsm is more and more common, many individuals with ASD do not receive a • Public awareness of the disorder has increased. diagnosis untl adulthood. As described by Charlie Remy, a • There have also been signifcant advances librarian on the autsm spectrum: in diagnostc eforts, most recently in early identfcaton. • The defniton of ASD has broadened in recent “I was diagnosed at the age of 23 when I years and includes more individuals who functon was in library school. Several years earlier autonomously, with litle or no support while in my parents suggested I read Beyond the school or in the community. Wall by Stephen Shore. It’s a memoir • Record keeping has improved. writen by an adult on the spectrum. My parents immediately thought of me • The number of people with ASD is simply when they read it and I concurred with increasing. them! It described a lot of experiences For many reasons, ASD is becoming more and more similar to those in my childhood (intense pervasive. As an informaton professional, you will likely special interests, social awkwardness, have the opportunity to serve members of this growing sensory sensitvites, etc” (Eng, 2017). populaton, making it crucial to be knowledgeable of the disorder and of strategies to students with ASD in their partcipaton in library and campus actvites. Though exact numbers are unknown, it is estmated that up to two percent of enrolled college students may have ASD, with or without a diagnosis (White, Ollendick, About Asperger Syndrome & Bray, 2011). Self-diagnosis can be common, as described by Remy: Asperger syndrome was formerly ascribed to some individuals on the autsm spectrum and was marked by no signifcant verbal delays and less severity in “By the tme I received the diagnosis, it characteristcs. However, with the publicaton of the was just a confrmaton of what I already ffh editon of the Diagnostc and Statstcal Manual knew. I just wanted to make it ofcial in of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) in 2013, diagnostc case I needed accommodatons in the propertes for the autsm spectrum changed, future. It also felt somewhat awkward incorporatng the separate diagnosis of Asperger to partcipate in autstc organizatons syndrome into the broad umbrella of ASD. Though without an actual diagnosis. Learning Asperger syndrome is no longer given as a diagnosis, about autsm in my early 20s was you might hear some adults on the spectrum stll comfortng because I now understood identfy with the term. the why for many things in my life” (Eng, 2017).
9 About Autsm on Campus
Neurodiversity Autsm can be considered through the lens of neurodiversity, or the idea that we all have neurological diferences that should be recognized and respected.
The concept of neurodiversity is one that has recently gained some popularity, though it is not without controversy. Proponents say that neurodiversity celebrates neurological diferences, and that there is perhaps no such thing as one standard, “normal,” brain (Robertson & Ne’Eman, 2008; Silberman, 2015). In this sense, autsm is seen as a diference and not a disability. However, some claim that this is a simplistc argument, and one that favors individuals with more mild or so-called “high-functoning” characteristcs of ASD (Jaarsma & Welin, 2011; Kapp, Gillespie-Lynch, Sherman, & Hutman, 2013).
"Writng about acceptance got me to think, 'I know what acceptance feels like in the present—equal employment opportunites, policies of inclusion, being surrounded by a real community, and people that care about or love me…' But what does acceptance look like in the future? How will 'autsm' be defned in Diagnostc and Statstcal Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) 14, which, based on prior publicaton dates, should arrive around the year 2122? Or will my and others’ behavioral diferences simply disappear from the DSM because they are then thought of as natural, commonplace extensions of the human experience?" (Carley, 2018, para. 4).
You might see or hear the term “neurotypical” used. This is a term that can be used for individuals who are not neurodiverse – in other words, a neurotypical person is someone who is not on the autsm spectrum him or herself. Views on this terminology are constantly evolving, and there are many frst-person accounts on discussion board forums, social media pages, and video channels discussing the merits of the neurodiverse movement. Learn more by watching Elisabeth Wiklander describe how she views her autsm through the lens of neurodiversity. htp://bit.ly/2l3fUP
10 About Autsm on Campus
Transiton from High School to College their own or with roommates for the frst tme in their lives. While students with ASD may be academically successful in high school and intellectually prepared for One study looked specifcally at the challenges students college, many fnd themselves in a new school, during a faced during the transiton from high school to college period of major transiton, with self-care and independent found: “the reducton in social supports, the academic living skills lacking. Parents of students making the transiton stress, and the difculty managing intense emotons were from high school to college have described concerns that their greatest challenges…Another major concern reported students might lack the ability to self-advocate for services was balancing the overwhelming number of daily living afer leaving the familiar structure of the K-12 environment responsibilites and social demands while focusing on (Morrison, Sansot, & Hadley, 2009). Some address this by school” (White, Elias, Salinas, Capriola, Conner, Asselin,…& atending college close to home and fnding comfort in Getzel, 2016). some aspect of “sameness” in their lives, which can be an efectve strategy. Primary needs identfed by needs analysis across online surveys and focus groups. In an interview with NPR, one student describes Over-arching construct Specifc facets that “the challenge… is that in college, unlike in high school, it's a student's responsibility to ask Social integraton Navigatng social interactons for help” (Donovan, 2017). Finding social support NPR’s All Things Considered: Navigatng Life on Campus When Handling confict with others
You’re on the Autsm Spectrum Self-determinaton Finding transiton services
Self-advocacy Periods of transiton, such as the transiton from high school to college, are partcularly stressful for individuals Time management with autsm (Adreon & Durocher, 2007; Pinder-Amaker, Sustaining or developing social motvaton 2014; VanBergeijk, Klin, & Volkmar, 2008; Zager & Alpern, 2010). Students are expected to learn the norms and Goal atainment cultures of a new insttuton, meet new people, abide by Self-awareness and knowledge a new set of rules and policies and, in many cases, live on Independent living skills Managing social, daily living, Self-regulaton and social concerns Navigatng inconsistencies and changes in routne
Managing intense emotons Executve functoning (e.g., managing inatenton) Coping with academic stress (White et al., 2016)
11 About Autsm on Campus
The College Experience
Postsecondary insttutons are working to best support Charlie Remy, an academic librarian, describes his ASD the needs of college students with ASD, who ofen require manifestatons as follows: diferent services and supports than other students with special needs. Though individuals on the autsm spectrum are ofen academically successful in college, they do tend to face difcultes in social situatons and with communicaton skills. However, these challenges manifest very diferently in every person. One student with ASD might have trouble speaking up during class, while another student with ASD might not know when to stop talking and sharing opinions during class. As everyone with the disorder displays diferent characteristcs, there is not a one-size-fts-all approach for ofering support. Furthermore, characteristcs of the disorder are ofen invisible, leading to challenges in htps://bit.ly/2qRxkNN ofering targeted support (Barnhill, 2014). Adding to the challenge is that not all individuals with ASD register with Take a moment to refect on these characteristcs. the disability ofce on their campus. Some try to make it Can you recall occasions where you may have on their own without any supports or are not provided interacted with a student on the autsm spectrum? adequate guidance during the registraton process, so they Additonally, how do you think the library could fail to notfy the disability ofce of their diagnosis or their be a benefcial space for a student displaying potental need for support. Similarly, some individuals manifestatons of ASD? do not receive supports because they are undiagnosed, though showing characteristcs of ASD (White, Ollendick, & Bray, 2011).
Characteristcs of College Students with ASD Students with ASD have diferent methods of learning, interactng, and processing informaton. They are ofen able to do well academically and might earn high GPAs. Students with ASD can be found in every discipline, though many fnd their stride in the STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math) majors. They might seem aloof, though this does not mean that they do not need or seek connecton.
12 About Autsm on Campus
Executve Functoning Impacts Students in College Executve functoning poses its own set of issues for students with ASD. View the following image, and try saying the color, not the word:
Now imagine if this is what you were faced with every day! Students with ASD can have trouble with organizaton functons, including working memory, atenton span, problem solving, cognitve fexibility, and verbal reasoning. They also might struggle with cognitve fexibility and regulaton functons such as inhibiton, initaton, and monitoring (Cai & Richdale, 2016). As illustrated by one student with ASD:
“[I am] really disorganized. I try to be organized but it’s this uphill impossible struggle. It’s a wharf of chaos. Everything is just so random, chaotc, and I’ll try to be organized but it’s not going to end up being organized. I’ll just try to make it not as disorganized. Trying to minimize the damage” (Cai & Richdale, 2016).
htp://bit.ly/2bvsxuD
13 About Autsm on Campus
College Retenton Comorbid Conditons Up to two percent of the college populaton could be Perhaps the most signifcant symptom for a student on the autsm spectrum (White, Ollendick, & Bray, 2011) – with ASD may be anxiety or stress. Studies show the and are at a greater risk of not completng a college degree. frequency of comorbid conditons presented along with Students with ASD have lower rates of completon than ASD, including anxiety, depression, and atenton defcit the study body as a whole, with fewer than 40 percent hyperactvity disorder (ADHD) (Bauman, 2010). Sensory graduatng over the span of six years (Shatuck et al., 2012). processing and assimilaton challenges can also lead to These students may be intellectually capable and achieve heightened stress levels for students who are already under academically at the same levels or higher than their peers pressure to achieve academically. One college graduate without ASD and would likely succeed in college with the described he had “...the ability to ‘fake out people and appropriate supports (Jackson, Hart, Brown, & Volkmar, that allowed him to ‘rely on my raw intellect to do what I 2018). need to do. And most of the tme it worked when I applied myself’" (Cox et al., 2016).
“It’s hard to explain why college didn’t work for me. First thing that comes to mind is that I was taking too many classes at the same tme. And these were difcult classes. Too much at once. When I frst enrolled, I signed up for 5 classes. I ended up dropping them. Then I signed up again and dropped them again. Some of the class sizes were very large, and some were smaller. For some reason, high school seemed to be easier. Teachers told us what to do. We had schedules and assignments. Another issue was the tme of my classes. I prefer to sleep late. One of the college classes I took was public speaking. I really didn’t enjoy that one. I dropped out afer 3– 4 weeks in. I didn’t feel comfortable getng up in front of a group. I don’t know why I signed up for that one. Afer dropping classes at FIU twice, I lost my scholarship. I signed up at Miami Dade to take some classes but didn’t stck with it. It’s been 4 -5 years since I atempted college. In high school I was in the 98th percentle but didn’t do well in college” (Cox, Thompson, Anderson, Mintz, …& Wolz, 2016).
14 About Autsm on Campus
Strengths of Students with ASD
The neurodiversity movement has played a role in recognizing that, along with facing some challenges, individuals with ASD also display many strengths.
“The philosophical vision of neurodiversity applies essental principles of society’s embrace of diversity in ethnicity, natonality, religion, and sexual orientaton toward people embodying diverse human neurology. Although autstc people acknowledge great challenges with being autstc, they also recognize that autsm presents important strengths, talents, abilites, and gifs, such as comfort with structure and consistency, a knack for repetton, and a detailed, intricate world understanding” (Robertson & Ne’eman, 2008).
Faculty members have also described students with ASD as having passionate interests, an interest in being right, and adhering to rules and school policies (Gobbo & Shmulsky, 2014).
In her popular blog “Musings of an Aspie,” author Cynthia Kim describes her strengths and superpowers (2012):
Superpowers and Strengths Superpowers Strengths • Perceptve • Nonjudgmental • Determined • Curious • Smart • Honest • Cool-headed • Loyal • Dependable • Sincere • Disciplined • Principled • Problem Solver
15 About Autsm on Campus
Students with Autsm in the Academic Library
Some individuals with ASD may exhibit observable The Role of Student Disability Services characteristcs while they are in the library that may assist Though student disability and student support services you in providing support. Recogniton is the frst step to on college campuses are valuable resources for students encourage interacton and satsfacton within the library who need extra assistance, these services ofen go environment. Look for students who seem to prefer to unrealized for the student with ASD who has an invisible be alone, look away when speaking to you, or reluctant disability. The common expectaton on campuses is for self- to engage in conversaton. They might be uncomfortable disclosure. For these services to be implemented, a student making eye contact when requestng materials or assistance must frst have a proper diagnosis and then be willing to or might have difcultes engaging in conversaton. A disclose that diagnosis to student support services. student might display repettve behaviors or show focused interest in one topic. Throughout the rest of this A+ manual, more characteristcs and descriptons will be introduced and expanded upon to help you beter understand how to identfy and beter support students with ASD in your library.
The Associaton of Specialized and Cooperatve Library Agencies (ASCLA) division of the American Library Associaton has addressed some solutons in a toolkit “Autsm Spectrum Disorders”. Use the tps included here that can be used for working with all ages of library users.
“Colleges are not required to think about the social, communicatve needs of any students, let alone those with autsm. Those things are not considered reasonable accommodatons. But if autsm is indeed a social disability, then Additonally, support needs vary signifcantly for denying the social needs of autstc students with ASD as compared to traditonal student students is inherently unreasonable” disability services. Examples of traditonal student support (Finnegan & Finnegan, 2016). includes note takers or extra tme for exams, while students with ASD typically need more social and emotonal, rather than academic, support.
16 About Autsm on Campus
Existng College Support Programs for Students with ASD Many colleges and universites are beginning to recognize the importance of creatng awareness and support for students with ASD and are creatng targeted programs to increase their chances of success. Check out College Autsm Spectrum as a startng point for understanding practces at insttutons of higher educaton. Conduct a search online for your state or region to see what processes are in place nearby, leading to possible opportunites for collaboraton. Read quotes from librarians within some of these targeted programs who are fnding a role to play in student success:
“We have a training… it’s kind of like the LGBTQ safe space movement in terms of providing a safe environment where people with autsm can see that emblem and know, ok, this person’s been trained to at least know something about how ASD afects somebody’s life and some practcal ways in which they can communicate with someone on the spectrum… we provide that to our librarians here on campus.”
“I think as the library there are a lot of things we can ofer students (on the spectrum); not just the spaces but potentally even for those of us who have subject liaison dutes that we could more closely work with students in our specifc discipline areas to maybe meet with them one-on-one, or work with them via email or via the phone, whichever avenue is most comfortable for them, to make sure that they have access to the resources that they need so they can be successful.”
Does your campus have a targeted ASD program? If so, work to make a connecton with its director and see “I have been working with our how the library can be a partner. If not, working with the instructonal services librarian and Disability Ofce is a great startng point. we’ve been trying to incorporate things like interactve learning, and “I would recommend a stronger Universal Design Learning, and connecton between disability services hands-on exercises into the lesson and the library. We have a commitee plans so that’s what we do basically actually on campus that’s just a faculty in class. I really encourage them to advisory commitee for students with come in for individual research help, disabilites and it’s comprised of a lot of and at these individual sessions we diferent allies from departments across kind of go more in depth.” campus, one being library services.”
17 About Autsm on Campus
Campus Collaboraton Despite being willing and able, some individuals Emily Mann, Research & Informaton Services Librarian with ASD fnd it a challenge to partcipate in community at Florida State University, describes their Diversity and actvites due to social and communicatve difcultes. The Inclusion collecton: library, typically a cornerstone in the campus community, is an obvious facilitator to support these individuals’ partcipaton and involvement in their communites.
What opportunites can your library support? While this will vary widely based on people and resources, litle things can be amazing catalysts.
htps://bit.ly/2IeTZ0G
“Cultvatng acceptance and support resources for autstc college students will also involve transforming a campus community's broader culture. Colleges and universites can host gatherings and events focused on learning more about autstc college students and the neurological diversity they contribute to their campus environment. Many colleges and Many libraries partner with other campus organizatons universites have held week-long community and departments to provide training and additonal gatherings focused on appreciatng the diversity services. Asking local autsm experts to come into the of their community's diferences in ethnicity, library and give a workshop about autsm — whether natonality, sexual orientaton, and religion. current research, local services, or otherwise — will help A neurodiversity-focused expansion of these to increase ASD awareness on your campus. Librarians diversity events would integrate actvites have a great responsibility to support opportunites for focused on embracing the diversity of autstc learning. Think about book clubs you could host featuring people and other neurodiverse populaton ASD protagonists – could you invite a faculty member groups. Neurodiversity-focused events might to help facilitate the discussion? There are many other include flm festvals, art galleries, poster opportunites for building a culture of awareness and sessions, essay writng contests, symposia, and acceptance, all of which will have a positve impact on readings of poetry and stories writen by autstc support for this populaton within the community. people” (Robertson & Ne’eman, 2008).
18 About Autsm on Campus
Recommended Readings
19 About Autsm on Campus
Sources of Informaton about Autsm
As academic librarians, you might be asked to provide sources for informaton about autsm. Faculty might be interested in current research, staf and administraton might want sources of informaton to provide beter support and services for students on campus, and students with autsm might use the library as a resource when they have questons or are seeking a confrmaton about their diagnosis. Visit the Natonal Network of Libraries of Medicine website to read the criteria they designed to evaluate health websites.
When helping library users seek informaton about autsm, teach them to ask themselves the following questons: • Why did the person or organizaton create the page? • Does the person or organizaton have anything to gain from sharing the informaton? • Is the person or organizaton trying to make a proft?
Additonally, you might direct students to the “Trust it or Trash it” site, developed through a Creatve Commons license by Project Miso for quick tps on whether to trust online autsm and health informaton sources. As students with ASD are literal thinkers, this straightorward educatonal tool could be helpful for them as they work to evaluate sources of informaton.
Because of its increased prevalence, members of the library community are beginning to address opportunites for working with individuals with ASD. Listed below are some of the services and supports that might be useful in working with this populaton in a library setng. • AMERICAN LIBRARY ASSOCIATION • ASSOCIATION FOR COLLEGE AND RESEARCH LIBRARIES • LIBRARIES AND AUTISM – WE’RE CONNECTED • PROJECT ENABLE • PROJECT PALS • FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF MEDICINE • TARGETING AUTISM
20 About Autsm on Campus
References
American Psychiatric Associaton. (2013). Diagnostc and statstcal manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing. Burgess, R. (2017, May 25). Understanding autsm part one – Jack and Rosie. The Guardian. Retrieved from htps://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/picture/2017/may/25/understanding-autsm-part-one-jack- and-rosie Cai, R. Y., & Richdale, A. L. (2016). Educatonal experiences and needs of higher educaton students with autsm
spectrum disorder. Journal of Autsm and Developmental Disorders, 46(1), 31–41. Carley, M. J. (2018). “Acceptance” is a start, not a fnish. The Oaracle. Retrieved from htps://researchautsm. org/acceptance-is-a-start-not-a-fnish/ Cassidy, S., & Rodgers, J. (2017). Understanding and preventon of suicide in autsm. The Lancet Psychiatry, 4(6), e11. Centers for Disease Control and Preventon. (2017). Autsm Spectrum Disorder (ASD). Retrieved from htps:// www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/autsm/research.html Cox, B. E., Thompson, K., Anderson, A., Mintz, A., Locks, T., Morgan, L., … Wolz, A. (2016). College experiences for students with autsm spectrum disorder (ASD): Personal identty, public disclosure, and insttutonal support. Journal of College Student Development, 58(1), 71–87. Donovan, C. (2017). Navigatng life on campus when you’re on the autsm spectrum. All Things Considered. Retrieved from htps://www.npr.org/2017/11/28/566788182/navigatng-life-on-campus-when-youre- on-the-autsm-spectrum Drake, S. (2014). College experience of academically successful students with autsm. Journal of Autsm, 1(1), 5. Eng, A. (2017). Neurodiversity in the library: One librarian’s experience. In the Library with a Lead Pipe. Retrieved from htp://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2017/neurodiversity-in-the-library/ Finnegan, E., & Finnegan, M. (2016). Students on the spectrum. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from htps://www. insidehighered.com/views/2016/09/13/making-college-work-students-autsm-essay
21 About Autsm on Campus
Gelbar, N. W., Smith, I., & Reichow, B. (2014). Systematc review of artcles describing experience and supports of individuals with autsm enrolled in college and university programs. Journal of Autsm and Developmental Disorders, 44(10), 2593-2601. Gobbo, K., & Shmulsky, S. (2014). Faculty experience with college students with autsm spectrum disorders: A qualitatve study of challenges and solutons. Focus on Autsm and Other Developmental Disabilites, 29(1), 13-22. Howlin, P., & Magiat, I. (2017). Autsm spectrum disorder: Outcomes in adulthood. Current Opinion in Psychiatry, 30(2), 69–76.
Jaarsma, P., & Welin, S. (2012). Autsm as a natural human variaton: Refectons on the claims of the neurodiversity movement. Health Care Analysis, 20(1), 20-30. Jackson, S. L., Hart, L., Brown, J. T., & Volkmar, F. R. (2018). Brief Report: Self-reported academic, social, and mental health experiences of post-secondary students with autsm spectrum disorder. Journal of Autsm and Developmental Disorders, 48(3), 643-650. Kapp, S. K., Gillespie-Lynch, K., Sherman, L. E., & Hutman, T. (2013). Defcit, diference, or both? Autsm and neurodiversity. Developmental Psychology, 49(1), 59. Kim, C. (2012). Aspie strengths and superpowers. Musings of an Aspie. Retrieved from htps:// musingsofanaspie.com/2012/12/21/aspie-strengths-and-superpowers/ Lawrence, E. (2013). Loud hands in the library: Neurodiversity in LIS theory & practce. Progressive Librarian, 41, 98-109. Murray, A., Ireland, A., & Hackathorn, J. (2016). The value of academic libraries: Library services as a predictor of student retenton. College & Research Libraries, 77(5), 631-642. Newman, L., Wagner, M., Knokey, A.-M., Marder, C., Nagle, K., Shaver, D., & Wei, X. (2011). The post-high school outcomes of young adults with disabilites up to 8 years afer high school. A report from the Natonal Longitudinal Transiton Study–2 (NLTS2). NCSER 2011-3005. Natonal Center for Special Educaton Research. Pinder-Amaker, S. (2014). Identfying the unmet needs of college students on the autsm spectrum. Harvard Review of Psychiatry, 22(2), 125-137.
22 About Autsm on Campus
Robertson, S. M., & Ne’eman, A. D. (2008). Autstc acceptance, the college campus, and technology: Growth of neurodiversity in society and academia. Disability Studies Quarterly, 28(4). Shatuck, P. T., Narendorf, S. C., Cooper, B., Sterzing, P. R., Wagner, M., & Taylor, J. L. (2012). Postsecondary educaton and employment among youth with an autsm spectrum disorder. Pediatrics, 129(6), 1042– 1049. Silberman, S. (2015). Neurotribes: The legacy of autsm and the future of neurodiversity. New York, NY: Penguin. White, S. W., Elias, R., Salinas, C. E., Capriola, N., Conner, C. M., Asselin, S. B., … Getzel, E. E. (2016). Students
with autsm spectrum disorder in college: Results from a preliminary mixed methods needs analysis. Research in Developmental Disabilites, 56, 29–40. Wright, J. (2017) Autsm rates in the United States explained. Spectrum News. Retrieved from htps:// spectrumnews.org/news/autsm-rates-united-states-explained/ Zager, D. B., Wehmeyer, M. L., & Simpson, R. L. (Eds.). (2012). Educatng students with autsm spectrum disorders: Research-based principles and practces. New York, NY: Routledge.
23 2
2 Library Environment
Students with autsm ofen enjoy coming to libraries Research shows.... and consider them to be comfortable and safe. Libraries are generally organized, calm, self-directed, and consistent. Many students with ASD describe using the library While no two individuals with autsm are the same, many as an escape from busy campus actvites. In a study individuals with autsm beneft from the predictable rules analyzing discussion board posts between individuals and systematc layout of the materials found in libraries. with ASD, it was found that, “library as escape is This porton of the manual describes some of the ways a ofen mentoned in advice that one user will give to student with autsm might face difcultes in a traditonal another, typically in ofering suggestons as to how to college library setng and how library staf can work to get away from a roommate or other unpleasant living improve these students’ experiences. situaton” (Anderson, 2018).
24 Library Environment
Scanning Your Library’s Environment
Through a process of multple library site visits and incorporatng research based best practces, the Project A+ team created an environmental rubric that will help you observe elements in your own library that are either working well, or areas that need improvement (Associaton of College and Research Libraries, 2006; Everhart, Woods, Anderson, & Delehanty, 2016). Use the checklist to walk through your library and record your observatons. We recommend using this as a place to begin conversatons with your staf and administraton about modifying the physical library environment to beter serve all users, not just those on the autsm spectrum. You might ask an outsider, such as a non-library user, to use the checklist and record their observatons with a fresh pair of eyes.
What changes do you want to make in your library? What do you think you are already doing well that you could highlight or promote to your users? We encourage you to use the strengths, weaknesses, opportunites, and threats (SWOT) template to assist in your organizaton’s strategic planning. A SWOT analysis can be helpful to determine how your library is already serving its patrons or students with ASD and ways in which it can improve. Refer to the SWOT template for ways to incorporate those changes into your long-term library plans.
25 Library Environment
Strategic Planning and SWOT Analysis
Use this SWOT (strengths, weaknesses, opportunites, and threats) template to assist in your organizaton’s strategic planning. A SWOT analysis can be helpful to determine how your library is already serving its students with ASD, and ways in which it can improve. Create additonal lines as necessary.
Strengths Weaknesses Think of strengths as internal assets. If your library Weaknesses are also internal but are areas which has great seatng optons, or a great health informaton need improvement. If your library does not have private collecton, those are examples to list here. study spaces, that might be an example to list here. 1 1
2 2
3 3
Opportunites Threats Opportunites are external factors which your library Threats are also external, but these are factors which might take advantage of. If your library is centrally might be harmful to your library. If library funding is in located on campus, this could be an example to list here. jeopardy, this is an example to list here.
1 1
2 2
3 3
26 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: Visual Consideratons
Sensory atypicalites, a feature of ASD as identfed by the DSM-5 (APA, 2013), can include both extreme sensitvity and under sensitvity to sensory stmuli related to the fve senses. Previous studies have identfed sensory overload, or acute sensitvity to the sensory environment, as a barrier to college success for students with ASD (Madriaga, 2010; Van Hees, Moyson, & Roeyers, 2015). The following pages will discuss sensory issues for students in the academic library, and practcal solutons.
Issue: Fluorescent lights present a partcular challenge to individuals with ASD, as they can ofen hear them buzz and are sensitve to fickering.
Soluton: Subdued task lightng can support a sense of calm and focus. Lightng should be designed in a way that is invitng – features that are also important for the general populaton. Research shows.... • If possible, reduce fuorescent lightng by replacing Students with ASD report lower levels of anxiety fuorescent bulbs with LED bulbs. If you must when given the ability to dim lights that seem too retain fuorescent lightng, make sure the bulbs are bright: “In the previous design of the autsm suite… replaced ofen or use light covers to help reduce instructors rated the students’ anxiety seven out of irritaton. ten, with ten being the most distress, because of the • Turn of some of the lightng, or try to replace with brightness of the lights. The ability to adjust the light sofer lightng optons, if your situaton allows. levels to achieve a comfortable brightness with the Providing a dimmer for individual study rooms is dimming controls eliminates the behavioral problems also helpful for students to adjust lightng to their and stresses caused by high light levels” (Long, 2010, own needs. p. 45). • Daylight is terrifc, but intense, direct sunlight and the resultng glare can be problematc. People Do you have some areas where lightng could be a who are hypersensitve do not do well with direct concern? sunlight, so window blinds and strategic window placement can help. The library could also provide inexpensive pairs of sunglasses. Some vendors ofer these for free, and they could be made available at the front desk.
27 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: Visual Consideratons
Issue: A strength of many libraries is the use of signage to label collectons and provide directons. Individuals with ASD are ofen visual learners, so the use of signs can help them independently access resources and services. However, be careful that your visual aids are truly necessary; too many signs can create cluter and be a source of sensory overload.
Soluton: Visual supports can take many forms. A visual support is any picture, sign, or item that can guide an individual toward the completon of a task or routne. Common visual supports that are already present in your library might include signs over the restrooms and circulaton desk. Another example may be a library map that greets incoming visitors.
Mike Meth, Associate Dean, Research and Learning at Florida State University Libraries, describes modifying library signage:
htps://bit.ly/2KxUwsM
Visual actvity schedules and supports have been found to be highly efectve in helping people with ASD transiton between actvites, prepare for changes in routne, and increase their independence. It is even beter when the monitor displays simple print that is easy to read.
At Florida State University, rotatng digital signage provides At the University of West Florida, a digital display allows updated actvites and opportunites for engagement. library visitors to view policies and library usage in real tme as they enter from the frst foor.
28 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: Time as a Consideraton
Creatng clear and consistent signage is important not This is reiterated by another librarian at a large just for students with ASD but for all students in the library. university, who says... As one librarian notes,
"...being in such a large environment…. "...making sure signage is clear is very we can’t always ofer those super important. I know that we’ve had some individualized things. So, what we need questons recently with newly admited to be considering is how we can make students trying to fnd things and if we the environment much more conducive. have people asking, that means that I was thinking our signage, because you there are a lot more people not asking." know what? Even students that don’t have autsm, they are asking about the printers and the copiers..."
Visual supports do not need to be expensive or tme-consuming to create. The following have been shown to be helpful for individuals with ASD:
• A visual schedule of library hours, people on-duty to help, checkout procedures, and maps. • Accessible calendars for planning visits and library actvites. • A detailed agenda emailed to individuals in advance if patrons with autsm are taking classes in the library. Stcking to the agenda will reduce confusion. • Writng materials close at hand (whiteboards, notepads, pencils and clipboards with paper, or stcky notes). • Library staf being identfable with name badges.
List more strategies that would be useful in your library.
29 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: Visual Consideratons
Even in a relatvely small library, assessing all signage may be a dauntng task. The frst step in identfying problematc or unnecessary signage is conductng a signage inventory. Mandel and Johnston (2017), “have developed and feld tested a method for conductng an expert signage inventory…to illustrate signage issues and good signs” (3). Their checklist allows librarians to efciently inventory their signage and take stock of the diferent types and locatons of signs to identfy areas for improvement or reducton of signage. Use the table below and the checklist on the following page to take inventory of your library’s signage. With the data you collect, frst address signs with functonal issues (damage, incorrect placement, etc.), then consider reducing repettve or inefectve signage.
Main Subcategory Defniton Main Subcategory Defniton Category Category Name of the sign derived from Sign is unclear because of font Sign Name Issues Unclear text on the sign size, sign size, etc. Sign that is not where it be- Floor B Lower level Locaton longs 1 First level Outdated Sign that is outdated 2 Second level Damage - Sign Sign that is damaged 3 Third level Damage - Signs that indicate directon by Sign holder that is damaged Category Dir. - → Mount use of arrows Signs that indicate directon by Other Any other issue Dir. - Text use of text Any comments or elaboraton Regulatory signs that indicate Notes Reg. - L necessary library rules Regulatory signs that indicate Reg. - O non-library rules
Informaton All other signs
Locaton Table Sign on a table or desk
Stack-end Sign on the end of a bookstack
Shelf Sign on a shelf
Wall Sign on a wall
Hanging Sign hanging from the ceiling
Other Sign in another locaton
Adapted from “Evaluatng Library Signage: A Systematc Method for Conductng a Library Signage Inventory,” by L.H. Mandel and M.P. Johnston, 2017, Journal of Librarianship and Informaton Science, Copyright 2017 by Mandel & Johnston. Adapted with permission.
30 Sensory Issues and Solutons: Visual Consideratons
FLOOR CATEGORY LOCATION ISSUES
Dir. Reg. Damage B 1 2 3 → L O Text
SIGN NAME Informaton Table Stack-end Shelf Wall Hanging Other Unclear Locaton Out-dated Sign Mount Other NOTES
Adapted from “Evaluatng Library Signage: A Systematc Method for Conductng a Library Signage Inventory,” by L.H. Mandel and M.P. Johnston, 2017, Journal of Librarianship and Informaton Science, Copyright 2017 by Mandel & Johnston. Adapted with permission. Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: Visual Consideratons
Issue: Persons with ASD ofen have trouble with tme percepton; therefore, they have difculty gauging and tracking tme. Some exhibit an ability to focus on an object or actvity for hours with unusual intensity because the student is unaware of how much tme has passed. On the other hand, tme percepton may be a strength for other students on the spectrum and they want to be sure that events begin and end precisely on tme. They may follow very rigid schedules.
Libraries ofen provide useful verbal reminders or announcements. With these announcements, it is helpful to share any steps that a library visitor will need to complete. For example: “The library will be closing in thirty minutes. Please take any materials you need to check out to the front desk.” This will help all students, and especially Soluton: There are techniques used to support those with ASD, prepare for the transiton, understand individuals with ASD during changes in or disruptons to what is about to occur, and decide what actons they need actvites, setngs, or routnes. The techniques can be used to take. before a transiton occurs, during a transiton, and/or afer a transiton, and can be presented verbally, auditorily, or Take this tme to survey your library – how many visually. Placing clocks strategically throughout the library clocks do you see? Are they visible from study areas? environment helps those with ASD feel more in control of their surroundings.
It may be helpful for individuals with ASD to “see” how much tme remains in an actvity, such as an instructonal session, before they will be expected to transiton to a new locaton or event. Timers on a PowerPoint presentaton can be used for this.
32 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: Visual Consideratons
Issue: It is not enough to simply provide access to spaces; a student with ASD must know that the spaces exist and be able to prepare in advance for a trip to the library. Librarian Q: "If we were to post when our busiest hours are on our website, do you think that would be helpful?" Adria Nassim: "Yeah, that would! At least I know it would for me."
Providing virtual reference is another alternatve for students who are deterred from visitng at the busiest tmes. As noted by one librarian, “with VR, we have that for a number of diferent hours. Since we’re a university campus and [our library] is open so late and so early they could always come at diferent tmes that aren’t quite peak tmes.” Soluton: Providing study rooms is a great frst step for students who need a quiet, private space. However, think about how students might know about availability of the rooms themselves, or how to – or if it is even possible to – reserve them in advance. As one librarian interviewed by Project A+ says, “So even though we provide access, especially to those quiet spaces, I’m not sure students are fnding those as accessible when they need them.” At another library, a library administrator describes a strength of his library’s environment in having “various study rooms that we have that are bookable and reservable” through their website so that a student will know that a dedicated space is available for him when he arrives.
33 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: Auditory Consideratons
Issue: Even if you consider your library to be a quiet environment, it may not feel this way to students with ASD. What might be a minor annoyance to a librarian or neurotypical student could be such a distracton for a Research shows.... student with ASD that he or she is unable to concentrate. One student with ASD describes the distracton of “I’ve stopped asking people, ‘Do you hear that?’ When I hearing other students in this unedited discussion pick up on some unexplained faint sound. The answer is board post: “Anyways how do you, ask a person to inevitably ‘No.’ Autstc people tend to have very sensitve stop humming especially if theyre on the other side of hearing,” says writer Cynthia Kim (2015, p. 111). the building, no where near you and stll are annoying with their actons? And how do you explain that to a person... seriously.. “I am sorry could you please stop humming, i can hear you from my locaton in the library?” aaah i just feel soo irritated n have no idea what to do...” (Anderson, 2016, p. 51).
Soluton: What can you do to improve the auditory environment? Providing private, more soundproofed study rooms is a start. You might also consider the efect that carpetng or a strategically placed rug might have in reducing noise in your library. One librarian noted the positve efects of putng carpetng down on the interior bridges between library buildings, and said it “kind of quiets, dampens the sound.”
Noise canceling headphones can greatly aid in library visits for those with ASD. Individuals with autsm sometmes have difculty processing noise, and headphones can be a great comfort for them. Headphones may be ofered for use with the library’s computer or with a patron’s own electronic device. They can also be worn on their own as a source of comfort.
34 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: Auditory Consideratons
Issue: Students with ASD may have the assumpton that libraries are always quiet. Though this was once collectvely true, the modern library typically has areas for both quiet study and louder collaboratve spaces. These more modern academic libraries allow for optonal interacton and typically provide some comfortable, lounge-style seatng. Some simple accommodatons can be made for students who may beneft from a quiet space away from this stmulaton.
Soluton: Provide optons for students to step away and provide fexible seatng optons. Think about ofering chairs that can be rolled together or apart for diferent levels of privacy – the key here is providing optons.
A comfortable Study carrels or chair placed in A designated space Individual study cubicles in quiet an area free of where extra help is rooms that students areas. distractons with available. can reserve online. sofer lightng.
Sometmes a quiet corner is not enough to escape from sensory overload.
"Students with ASD would beneft from a calming room, where he or she could step away from overstmulaton. You might think of this as a type of meditaton room." Adria Nassim, A+ Advisory Board Member
35 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: General Overload
Issues: Many academic libraries are making the shif to Research shows.... one desk that provides multple services such as circulaton and informaton. Before incorporatng this trend into your “College students with ASD describe anxiety in library’s layout, consider that these “mega-desks” with approaching librarians or library staf behind the many services are chaotc to those with sensitvites— desk” (Anderson, 2016). not just those with ASD - but also students who are shy or easily overwhelmed. Though characteristcs difer in Soluton: If you already use “mega-desks” in your every person with ASD, librarian Charlie Remy describes library, are there other, smaller desks where a student manifestatons of his ASD as including high anxiety overall could receive access to the same services? Think about and being easily overwhelmed (Eng, 2017) – both of which alternatve ways a student could get help without requiring could present challenges in approaching a busy desk with him or her to approach the potentally overwhelming all- multple service points and staf members. in-one service point.
Does your library have a self-checkout staton? By using self-checkout, an individual with ASD can likely avoid waitng in a long line and not have to go through the additonal stress of unnecessary interacton and communicaton. If your library does not have an in-house self-checkout system, there are mobile app systems such as meeScan which is being used at the University of Chicago and University of Manitoba. Librarians could also provide disposable ear plugs or at partcularly busy locatons use white noise machines at the checkout desk.
Research shows.... “From what I understand, typical people have a sensory processing system that operates like a fancy shower head. They can adjust the temperature and pressure and how the water fows untl it’s just right. People with atypical sensory processing, on the other hand, have a fre hydrant valve where that shower head should be. We get lots of data, all at once, all the tme. Adjustng the fow of data ranges from difcult to impossible to totally unpredictable” htp://bit.ly/2kMKWKg (Kim, 2014).
36 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: General Overload
Issue: When feeling overwhelmed, it is possible that a student with ASD will “stm” as a coping mechanism. “Stmming” is a commonly accepted term for self-stmulatory behavior and refers to actons that those experiencing sensory overload will take to soothe themselves. This can include behaviors such as fdgetng, rocking, or hand fapping, and might be a clue to you that a student needs assistance locatng materials, navigatng the environment, or fnding a quiet space away from distracton.
Soluton: Providing stm or fdget tools within the library for students might help them if they should experience sensory overload. You might already be familiar with the popular fdget spinners or stress balls; you can also search online for other low-cost optons to keep available at the front desk, computer statons, or in study rooms.
Students might also beneft from more large scale self-soothing optons; one example of this can be seen with the Fit Desks installed at the University of West Florida’s Pace Library. These statonary bikes allow students to pedal while reading or simply pedal between study sessions. Are Fit Desks not in your current budget? It’s likely that you already have some optons for students who need a physical outlet. Do you have rocking chairs? Think beyond the traditonal rocking chair – many libraries now incorporate chairs that have a back that leans back slightly when pressed or legs with a slight curve at the edges.
37 Library Environment
Sensory Issues and Solutons: General Overload
Issue: Though many academic libraries are making the shif toward a learning commons environment, this might be overwhelming to individuals with ASD who ofen value clear boundaries in the physical space.
Soluton: Visual parameters are important in the library setng to help individuals with ASD understand boundaries and expectatons within the physical environment. Think about your help desks, checkout statons, or other areas where individuals may congregate for access to materials or for assistance from a librarian. Labeling these areas and defning where lines form might help not just those with autsm but assist everyone in understanding where to wait in line (rather than crowding the desk for library services).
Research shows.... “It is also important to bear in mind that certain shifs in academic libraries towards open 'learning commons' environments may be helpful to some users, but can prove intmidatng or overwhelming to others” (Lawrence, 2014).
38 Library Environment
A Librarian’s Perspectve
A librarian, advocate, and individual with autsm, Lawrence illustrated an example of how neurological diferences created a “systematc disadvantage” in the library. The difcultes with sensory integraton, spatal confusion, and social anxiety resulted in the following:
"The entrance to the library spilled into reference and circulaton desks, self-checkout machines, a whirl of human actvity. As I stood there, atemptng (and failing) to get my bearings … constant moton was my only defense against the milieu of the library. It can be difcult to know where my limbs are in space or to antcipate how others will move, but walking quickly in whatever directon stll mutes the fear of human interacton and the anxiety generated by spatal disorientaton. It is also a more socially acceptable—though less efectve— coping mechanism than hand fapping or spontaneous vocalizaton.
Afer a few haphazard turns and loops around the frst foor, I found an elevator to the stacks, where yellow fuorescent lightng buzzed overhead, vibratng through my eyes and into my brain. Dizzy and nauseous, I marched around several foors of the library with a kind of mock purpose…" (Lawrence, 2013).
To get an idea of how this might feel, you can visit Carly’s Café where you will experience autsm through a young woman’s perspectve. Think about how Carly’s experiences in the café might translate to a student’s experiences in the library.
htp://bit.ly/2jxEM0s
What is one area in your library that might be overwhelming for Carly? How might that area be improved?
39 Library Environment
Universal Design
Universal Design was frst introduced as an architectural concept for interior design. This concept is not to be confused with Universal Design for Learning (UDL), an approach based in instructon, which is covered in chapter 4.
We ofen hear the term Universal Design when describing accessible spaces for individuals with disabilites, but what does this really mean? Universal Design is the idea that services and supports are designed with all users in mind – in essence, these approaches are partcularly helpful for diverse populatons, but meant to be accessible by the greatest number of individuals, to the greatest extent possible (Follete Story, Mueller, & Mace, 1998; Mcguire, Scot, & Shaw, 2006).
Principles of Universal Design
Equitable: The design is useful and marketable to people with Tolerance for Error: The design minimizes hazards and adverse 1 5 diverse abilites. consequences of accidental or unintended actons.
Flexible: The design accommodates a wide range of individual Low Physical Efort: The design can be used efciently, 2 6 preferences and abilites. comfortably and with minimum fatgue.
Simple and Intuitve: Use is easy to understand, regardless Size and Space: Appropriate size and space is provided for 3 of the user’s experience, knowledge, language skills, or 7 approach, reach, manipulaton, and use regardless of user’s concentraton level. body size, posture, or mobility.
Perceptble Informaton: The design efectvely communicates 4 informaton, regardless of ambient conditons or the user’s Click each principle to read more. sensory abilites.
Research shows.... Dr. Sheryl Burgstahler, Ph.D. with the University of Washington’s Disabilites, Opportunites, Internet, and Technology (DO-IT) program have developed the Equal Access: Universal Design of Libraries checklist “for making libraries welcoming, accessible, and usable” (Burgstahler, 2012).
40 Library Environment
Now, consider how these principles translate to your library’s physical environment, especially with the knowledge you now have about students with autsm. The following are some suggestons to get you started thinking on this topic. All libraries are unique and will require diferent consideratons, so please use the following table as a startng point for your own brainstorming.
Consideratons for Students with Principle Our Library ASD
1: Equitable Use. The design is useful Integrated, adaptable seatng areas in library study rooms such as individual and marketable to people with chairs and tables with adjustable diverse abilites. privacy screens.
Checkout staton that ofers optons 2: Flexibility in Use: The design including self-checkout as well as accommodates a wide range of opportunites to interact with and be individual preferences and abilites. helped by a library staf member.
3: Simple and Intuitve Use: The design is easy to understand, Visual aids included on signage along regardless of the user’s experience, with text such as what noise levels knowledge, language skills, or current expectatons are for each area. concentraton level. While avoiding startling noises on 4: Perceptble Informaton: The the intercom system, provide gentle design communicates necessary verbal reminders to alert students informaton efectvely to the user, when the library is preparing to regardless of ambient conditons or close, in additon to already available the user’s sensory abilites. signage or writen reminders. The use of computer sofware that 5: Tolerance for Error: The design provides warnings when the student’s minimizes hazards and the adverse alloted tme is nearly up and periodic consequences of accidental or reminders to save work, helping unintended actons. those who may have lost track of tme and not saved important work.
Installing easy to use door handles 6: Low Physical Efort: The design can and/or touch butons for automatc be used efciently and comfortably door opening that do not require and with a minimum of fatgue. strong motor skills.
7: Size and Space for Approach and Creatng a barrier free library Use: Appropriate size and space entryway, using visual boundaries are provided for approach, reach, to delineate space as opposed to manipulaton, and use regardless of physical boundaries. user’s body size, posture, or mobility.
41 Library Environment
Equal Access: Universal Design of Libraries
The University of Washington’s DO-IT program provides a handy checklist that librarians can use to evaluate their spaces for various aspects of universal design.
Planning, Policies, and Evaluaton q Do elevators have auditory, visual, and tactle signals Consider diversity issues as you plan and evaluate and are elevator controls accessible from a seated services. positon?
q Are wheelchair-accessible restrooms with well marked q Are people with disabilites, racial and ethnic signs available in or near the library? minorites, men and women, young and old students, and other groups represented on your staf in q Are informaton desks and facilites such as book numbers proportonal to those of the whole campus returns wheelchair accessible? or community? q Is adequate light available? q Does the library have a writen policy and descripton q Are aisles kept wide and clear of obstructons for of services for patrons with disabilites, including the safety of users who have mobility or visual informaton on how to request accommodatons? impairments? q Is accessibility included in the procurement of library q Are there ample high-contrast, large print directonal holdings? signs throughout the library? Are shelf and stack q Does the library have a procedure in place that ensures identfers provided in large print and Braille formats? tmely response to requests for disability-related Are call numbers on book spines printed in large type? accommodatons and other special assistance? Is equipment marked with large print and Braille labels? q Are disability-related access issues addressed in your evaluaton methods? q Are private study areas available for patrons with disabilites who need to bring personal equipment, Physical Environments and Products who need the assistance of a reader, or who are Ensure physical access, comfort, and safety within an distracted by noise and movement? environment that is inclusive of people with a variety of abilites, racial and ethnic backgrounds, genders, and ages. Library Staf Make sure staf are prepared to work with all patrons. q Are there parking areas, pathways, and entrances to the library that are wheelchair-accessible and clearly q Are all staf members aware of issues related to identfed? communicatng with patrons of diferent races and ethnicites, ages, and abilites? q Are all levels of the library connected via an accessible route of travel, or are there procedures to assist patrons Adapted from “Equal Access: Universal Design in Libraries,” by S. with mobility impairments in retrieving materials from Burgstahler, 2009, DO-IT. Copyright 2018 by University of Washington. inaccessible locatons? Adapted with permission.
42 Library Environment
Equal Access: Universal Design of Libraries q Are staf trained in the use of the Telecommunicatons q Are resource delivery services available for patrons Relay Service, as well as assistve computer technology unable to leave their homes, retrement facilites, or provided in the library? hospitals? q Are staf trained in policies and procedures for providing q Are applicatons for the natonwide network of Talking accommodatons to patrons with disabilites? Book and Braille Libraries available for patrons with print-related disabilites? q Do staf members have ready access to a list of resources for patrons with disabilites? q In key publicatons and on your website, do you include a statement about your commitment to universal q Are staf knowledgeable about federally funded Talking access and procedures for requestng disability related Book and Braille Libraries and other organizatons that accommodatons? For example, “Our library’s goal is provide relevant services to patrons with disabilites? to make all materials and actvites accessible. Please q Do service staf wear large-print name badges? inform project staf of accessibility barriers you encounter and of accommodatons that will make q If there are staf members with sign language skills, are informaton resources accessible to you.” they identfed to other staf members so that, when available, they can assist patrons who are deaf? q Do videos developed or used in the library have captons? For more informaton, consult Creatng Informaton Resources and Technology Video and Multmedia Products That Are Accessible to Ensure that publicatons and websites welcome a People with Sensory Impairments. diverse group and content is accessible to everyone. q Are all printed library publicatons available (immediately or in a tmely manner) in alternate q Can the library’s electronic and informaton resources, formats such as Braille, large print, and electronic text? including web pages, online catalogs, indexes, and fulltext databases and CD-ROMs, be accessed with a q Are key documents provided in languages other than variety of adaptve computer technologies such as English? screen readers? q Do electronic resources, including web pages, adhere q Are librarians prepared to assist patrons with to accessibility guidelines adopted by your insttuton inaccessible electronic resources by providing or library? Secton 508 Standards for Accessible consultatons or materials in other formats? Electronic and Informaton Technology and Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) are most q Are reader and research assistants available to patrons commonly used. For general informaton about with visual impairments? making your website accessible to everyone, consult q Are reference and circulaton services available by both World Wide Access: Accessible Web Design video and phone and email? publicaton.
Adapted from “Equal Access: Universal Design in Libraries,” by S. Burgstahler, 2009, DO-IT. Copyright 2018 by University of Washington. Adapted with permission.
43 Library Environment
Equal Access: Universal Design of Libraries q Do you include a statement on your website afrming Events your commitment to accessible design? For example, Ensure that everyone feels welcome and can partcipate “We strive to make our website universally accessible. in events sponsored by the organizaton. We provide text descriptons of graphics and photos. Video clips are open captoned and audio-described, q Are events located in wheelchair accessible facilites? providing access to users who can’t hear the audio or Is the accessible entrance clearly marked? see the video, respectvely. Suggestons for increasing q Is informaton about how to request disability-related the accessibility of these pages are welcome.” accommodatons included in publicatons promotng q Is an adjustable-height table available for each type of events? workstaton to assist students who use wheelchairs or q Is accessible transportaton available if transportaton are small or large in stature? is arranged for other partcipants? q Do you provide adequate work space for both lef- and Adapted from “Equal Access: Universal Design in Libraries,” by S. right-handed users? Burgstahler, 2009, DO-IT. Copyright 2018 by University of Washington. Adapted with permission. q Is sofware to enlarge screen images and a large monitor available to assist students with low vision and learning disabilites? q Do you provide a trackball to be used by someone who has difculty controlling a mouse? q Are wrist and forearm rests available to assist some people with mobility impairments? q Are staf members aware of accessibility optons (e.g., enlarged text feature) included in computer operatng systems and of assistve technology available in the facility? q Are procedures in place for a tmely response to requests for assistve technology?
44 Library Environment
Planning for Renovatons
Use the embedded resources, including the SWOT template and Environmental Checklist, to help you prepare for any changes, large or small, you plan to implement in your library’s environment. Additonally, ensure that you are incorporatng feedback from stakeholders as you plan. Can you invite representatves from your ofce for Paul Wyss, A+ Advisory Board Member, Distance Learning disability services? What about an autsm awareness group Librarian, and autsm advocate. on your campus or educators and researchers in Special Educaton or Communicaton Sciences and Disorders? "I think it’s a very good idea to see how Most importantly, can you gather feedback from students someone approaches a complex library, with ASD themselves? Try placing QR codes that link to like libraries are these days. And also an anonymous survey in your library’s newsleter or link their verbal impressions of what they to the survey from your social media pages. Ask your encounter while they are going through stakeholders what changes they would like to see in your the library. Because I think what people library to make the environment beter for students with can do is, I’ve done this as well, is it’s ASD, as well as what helpful aspects of the environment very easy to guess what people are they think are already in place. thinking, but it’s very difcult to know Use this space to list stakeholder groups important for what they are thinking, or how they your planning. approach things."
Including stakeholders at the beginning of any project is especially important when funding is at stake. One librarian described a recent renovaton at her library, and how her new knowledge of students with ASD might have come too late:
"...trying to fnd more money in the budget to redo something that has One innovatve approach to gathering feedback from already been redone is going to be students with ASD is to give them a small video recorder difcult because they are like, we just such as a GoPro and ask them to tour your library with a did it a few years ago, we don’t have copy of the environment checklist. As they walk through the budget, we don’t have the tme, we the library’s environment, they can take notes on the need to fgure out…trying to fgure out checklist as well as verbalize their experience, discussing a fx, but depending on what it is, it may their observatons along the way. not be fxable."
45 Library Environment
Interactng with Library Resources
Though many individuals with ASD appreciate systematcally organized materials, transitoning from one classifcaton system to another can be a challenge for some who perhaps learned the Dewey Decimal system in public or school libraries and now must learn Library of Congress. As one college student laments, “Our library uses a really confusing cataloging system, too! Why can’t we just have the Dewey Decimal System?” and another states, “No I Philip Zupon (2013), a librarian with ASD, similarly don’t like using the library on campus. It’s really confusing suggests a proactve approach for librarians to assist with to try and fnd books for a start” (Anderson, 2016, p. 69). locatng materials:
Adria Nassim describes the challenges she faces when trying to fnd books on the shelves: "If a student in your library appears lost and at the same tme too afraid to ask "My learning disability afects my spatal for help, don’t be afraid to walk over to processing so being able to deal with them and nicely ask them if they need anything that’s abstract, lef right, can any help fnding anything." you count money, can you make change, so being able to fnd my way around a building is really hard." Additonally, you might consider implementng an online mapping system; Florida State University Libraries uses a program that, once a material is selected online, There are practcal solutons, both low and high tech, that displays the foor and shelving locaton on a clear map, can be used to address these concerns. As she contnues, leading to easier access of materials and less chance for frustraton. "...if you could maybe go get the books they need, or go get them all and have it waitng at the desk and say when you come here. If you know when they’re planning to come, or if they come and you just go get it and have it waitng at the desk, and they go sit down at the study carrel and do their research, and just do it that way instead of writng out a call number or whatever it is you do and saying, it’s in the 300s, look it up. That could help."
46 Library Environment
Next Steps
How else could you consider making your library a more welcoming place for people with ASD? Refer back to the SWOT template and use the space here to refect upon what you learned, what you want to achieve, and how you will get there.
Library Environment Goal:
OBJECTIVES AND STRATEGIES A good objectve will be quantfed (ted to specifc numbers), qualifed (where you describe the kind of change you want to see) and should have a set tme frame. If you don’t have all three of these components, it will be difcult to tell whether you have achieved your objectve.
If your goal was to have an online study room reservaton system, your objectve could be “By June of next year, we will have an online study room reservaton system available on the library’s website.” One strategy could include: “By January of next year, the IT department researches pricing and functonalites of potental room management systems and recommends a service to library administraton.”
You will fll in the objectves early in the training and the tactcs and tmeline at the end. OBJECTIVES STRATEGIES TIMELINE What are the changes you need to see What actvites will you need to conduct What is the tmeline for implementng in your library’s situaton to make your to make those changes happen? these actvites? Try to be specifc, environment goal possible? knowing you can change the schedule later.
1 2 3
1 2 3
1 2 3
47 Library Environment
References American Psychiatric Associaton. (2013). Diagnostc and statstcal manual of mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Publishing. Anderson, A. (2016). Wrong planet, right library: College students with autsm spectrum disorder and the academic library (Doctoral dissertaton). Retrieved from DigiNole. (htp://purl.fvc.org/fsu/fd/ FSU_2016SP_Anderson_fsu_0071E_13037) Anderson, A. (2018). Autsm and the academic library: A study of online communicaton. College & Research Libraries. Advance online publicaton. Retrieved from htp://crl.acrl.org/index.php/crl/artcle/
view/16763/18301 Associaton of College & Research Libraries. (2006). A student’s guide to evaluatng libraries in colleges and universites. Retrieved from htp://www.ala.org/acrl/issues/marketng/studentsguide Burgstahler, S. (2012). Equal access: Universal design of libraries. Disabilites, Opportunites, Internetworking, and Technology (DO-IT). Retrieved from htp://www.washington.edu/doit/equal-access-universal- design-libraries Eng, A. (2017). Neurodiversity in the library: One librarian’s experience. In the Library with a Lead Pipe. Retrieved from htp://www.inthelibrarywiththeleadpipe.org/2017/neurodiversity-in-the-library/ Everhart, N., Woods, J., Anderson, A., & Delehanty, A. (2016). Environment checklist. Project PALS. Retrieved from htp://learn.webjuncton.org/course/view.php?id=201 Follete Story, M., Mueller, J. L., & Mace, R. L. (1998). The universal design fle: Designing for people of all ages and abilites. North Carolina State University, Center for Universal Design. Retrieved from htp://fles. eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED460554.pdf Gleason, A. W. (2017). New methods of teaching and learning in libraries. London: Rowman & Litlefeld Publishers. Grantham, L. J. (2013) Self accommodaton. In E. Ashkenazy and M. Latmer (Eds.) Navigatng college: A handbook on self advocacy writen for autstc students from autstc adults (36-40). Washington, D.C.: Autstc Self Advocacy Network.
48 Library Environment
Kim, C. (2014) Sensory sensitvites and atypical sensory processing. Musings of an Aspie. Retrieved from htps://musingsofanaspie.com/2014/01/28/sensory-sensitvites-and-atypical-sensory- processing/#more-1883 Kim, C. (2015). Nerdy, shy, and socially inappropriate: A user guide to an Asperger life. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers Lawrence, E. (2013). Loud hands in the library: Neurodiversity in LIS theory & practce. Progressive Librarian, (41) 98–109. Long, E. A. (2010). Classroom lightng design for students with autsm spectrum disorders (Doctoral
dissertaton, Kansas State University). Madriaga, M. (2010). ‘I avoid pubs and the student union like the plague’: Students with Asperger Syndrome and their negotaton of university spaces. Children’s Geographies, 8(1), 39-50. Mandel, L. H., & Johnston, M. P. (2017). Evaluatng library signage: A systematc method for conductng a library signage inventory. Journal of Librarianship and Informaton Science. Mcguire, J. M., Scot, S. S., & Shaw, S. F. (2006). Universal design and its applicatons in educatonal environments. Remedial and Special Educaton, 27(3), 166–175. htps://doi.org/10.1177/07419325060 270030501 Riley-Huf, D. A. (2012). Web accessibility and universal design: A primer on standards and best practces for libraries. Library Technology Reports, 48(7), 29–35. Staines, G. M. (2012). Universal design: a practcal guide to creatng and recreatng interiors of academic libraries for teaching, learning and research. Oxford: Chandos Publishing. Van Hees, V., Moyson, T., & Roeyers, H. (2015). Higher educaton experiences of students with autsm spectrum disorder: Challenges, benefts and support needs. Journal of Autsm and Developmental Disorders, 45(6), 1673-1688. Wilkof, W. L.; Abed, L. W. (1994). Practcing universal design: An interpretaton of the ADA. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold. Zupon, P. (2013). Academic libraries and college students with autsm spectrum disorder: How can we help? Retrieved from htps://blogs.wayne.edu/turninginformatonintoknowledge/2013/03/12/academic-
libraries-and-college-students-with-autsm-spectrum-disorder-how-can-we-help/
49 Appendix A: Environmental Rubric
Baseline Environmental Rubric
Directions: can the li rar s ph sical en iron ent to assess or ease o se or st dents ith a tis . core each ite ro to and total all pages at the end.
Not Addressed (0) Partially Addressed (1) Addressed (2) Well Addressed (3) Exceptionally Well Addressed (4) Score
There are multiple signs The building is centrally located, there There are one or more The building cannot be There are one or more directing user to the library are multiple signs directing user to the The library signs directing user to the found without asking for signs directing user to location, clear signage on the library location, clear signage on the building is easy library location, and clear help. library location library building itself, and the library building itself, and the building to find. signage on library building building (or signage) is (or signage) is identifiable from a itself. identifiable from a distance. distance.
Comments/
Action Plan
Entry is open, spacious enough Entry is open, spacious enough so that Entry to main so that lines do not form, and lines do not form, and easy to area is The entry way is small or The entry way has some Entry is open, spacious easy to physically navigate. physically navigate. There are no sufficiently cluttered, with barriers to barriers to entry (e.g. enough so that lines do There are no barriers to entry barriers to entry way, or there are spacious to entry (e.g. turnstiles turnstiles without not form, and easy to way, or there are explicit and explicit and highly visible directions for reduce crowding without adequate adequate signage). physically navigate. highly visible directions for navigating barriers (e.g. turnstiles). and easy to signage). navigating barriers (e.g. Welcoming staff is available at entry navigate. turnstiles). way.
Comments/
Action Plan
Floorplans are available at Floorplans are available at multiple Floorplans are available at multiple locations per floor, locations per floor, show detailed No floorplan is available multiple locations per Detailed floor show detailed information information (quiet floors, for example), (evacuation plans are not Floorplans are available floor, show detailed plans are (quiet floors, for example), and and are consistent and professional in considered a library near elevators or stairs. information (quiet floors, available. are highly visible. Floorplans format, avoiding jargon. Floor plans are floorplan). for example), and are are consistent and professional available in multiple formats – signage, highly visible. in format, avoiding jargon. print, and digital.
Comments/
Action Plan Appropriate signage is placed at “bump When you are in the points” and the library has been It is not easy to find your library, you can easily find Appropriate signage is placed When you are in deliberately arranged for ease of way around the library Library is difficult to your way around. at “bump points” and the the library, you navigation. Additionally, directional due to little/no/bad navigate but you can Appropriate signage is library has been deliberately can easily find signs are placed strategically and only directional signage, or figure it out. placed at “bump points”1 arranged for ease of your way around. as needed (no unnecessary signage) obstacles. and there are no navigation. and staff are eager to help navigate the obstacles. building.
Comments/
Action Plan
Signage is hard to read Signage is either hard to Signage is professional, Signage is easy to (color, bold, italics, etc), read (color, bold, italics, consistently formatted, and read, consistently Signage is easy to read, inconsistent, and located etc), inconsistent, or strategically located formatted, and consistently formatted, Signage is a model for other libraries in inconsistently (if at all) located inconsistently (if throughout facility. Signage located and located throughout both design and terminology. throughout the facility. at all) throughout the avoids professional jargon and throughout facility. Signage uses negative facility. Signage uses idioms/metaphors/etc. and facility. terminology. negative terminology. uses positive terminology.
Comments/
Action Plan
Hours are posted at or on the front The library hours Hours are posted at or on the Hours are posted at or on door of all entrances, of operation are Hours are not highly front door of all entrances and No hours are posted. the front door of all circulation/information desk, online easy to read and visible. are highly visible with entrances. and as a handout and are highly visible clearly posted. professional signage. with professional signage. v
Comments/
Action Plan
Some individual seating Multiple types of individual Individual seating options are provided, Only one type of seating options such as desks, Multiple types of individual seating No individual seating options are but they are not easy to Individual seating option cubicles, work stations, soft options are provided and are easy to options are provided. provided. access, usually full, or is provided. chairs and study rooms are access and usually available. hard to find. provided are provided.
1 https://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/2012/03/20/directions-to-library-wayfinding/
Page Total: ______Comments/
Action Plan
There are barriers to use of individual work Multiple types of individual Multiple types of individual work Individual work spaces. For example, no work spaces are available with spaces are available with no barriers to spaces, such as empty study carrels, no no barriers to access. Work access. Work spaces have options for Individual work spaces study carrels and No individual work spaces options to provide spaces have options for customization according to need: for are available and there individual tables available. privacy, clutter, difficult customization according to example, individual lamps, privacy are no barriers to access. with seating, are to find within the library, need: for example, individual shades, or even “fit desks”. Signage available. or worn lamps, privacy shades, or even indicates where to locate types of work out/unwelcoming “fit desks”. spaces. furniture or spaces.
Comments/
Action Plan
Private rooms for Room/workspace Room/workspace reservation Room/workspace reservation are Room/workspace individual and reservation are Room/workspace are available, and guidelines available, and guidelines are posted in reservation unavailable group study are available, but there are reservation are available, are posted in area and either area and either online or other obvious (e.g. first come first available and no clear instructions or and guidelines are posted online or other obvious location (on a floor plan, for example). served) or no reservation directions are instructions are in area. location (on a floor plan, for Detailed instructions for information posted. clearly indicated. inconsistently placed. example). use/expectations are also posted.
Comments/
Action Plan
Rooms (such as Rooms and spaces are classrooms) and indicated by signage that rooms and spaces marked by room Rooms and spaces are Rooms and spaces are marked spaces are Rooms and spaces are not is not clear (e.g. rooms numbers, purpose, guidelines for use, marked by room numbers by room numbers, purpose, indicated by indicated by signage. named after donors, but and signage which is consistent and their purpose. and guidelines for use. clear, consistent no indication of their throughout facility signage. purpose).
Comments/
Action Plan
Page Total: ______Expectation for Expectation for noise Expectation for noise levels is Expectation for noise levels is clearly noise levels is Expectation for noise There are no signs that levels is clearly marked clearly marked with signage marked with signage and otherwise clearly marked levels is clearly marked denote appropriate noise with signage in some and otherwise noted (for noted (for example on floor plans) in with signage in with signage in level in the library. collaborative spaces, but example on floor plans) in collaborative spaces. Signage is clear, collaborative collaborative spaces. is not consistent. collaborative spaces. consistent and visually pleasing. spaces.
Comments/
Action Plan
Expectation for Expectation for noise Expectation for noise levels is Expectation for noise levels is clearly Expectation for noise noise levels is There are no signs that levels is clearly marked clearly marked with signage marked with signage and otherwise levels is clearly marked clearly marked denote appropriate noise with signage in some and otherwise noted (for noted (for example on floor plans) in with signage in quiet with signage in level in the library. quiet spaces, but is not example on floor plans) in quiet spaces. Signage is clear, spaces. quiet spaces. consistent. quiet spaces. consistent and visually pleasing.
Comments/
Action Plan
Visual boundaries are Visual boundaries are used Visual boundaries are Visual boundaries are used throughout used throughout Visual boundaries are throughout the library to Spaces for specific used inconsistently the library to clearly define space used the library to used throughout the clearly define space used for activities are not clearly within the library to for specific activities – multiple types of clearly define library to clearly define specific activities – multiple defined by visual define space used for boundaries are utilized (e.g. strategic space for specific space used for specific types of boundaries are boundaries (e.g. strategic specific activities (e.g. furniture placement, stanchions, floor activities (e.g. activities (e.g. strategic utilized (e.g. strategic furniture furniture placement). strategic furniture tape, etc) and boundaries are strategic furniture placement). placement, stanchions, floor placement). consistent and visually pleasing furniture tape, etc). placement).
Comments/
Action Plan
Page Total: ______Library work stations are free Library work stations are free of clutter, of clutter, provide helpful Library work stations are provide helpful items for students (such Library work stations are items for students (such as Library work free of clutter, and as staplers near the printing station), cluttered with items such Work stations are free of staplers near the printing stations are free provide helpful items for and have explicit directions for use as unnecessary fliers, clutter. station), and have explicit of clutter. students (such as staplers (such as printing instructions, microfilm trash, etc. directions for use (such as near the printing station). reader instructions, etc.). There are no printing instructions, microfilm barriers to access. reader instructions, etc.).
Comments/
Action Plan
Computer terminals are Computer terminals are available and Computer Computer terminals are available with no barriers to easily accessible. The space is logically terminals available but there are Computer terminals are Computer terminals are access. The space is logically organized for ease of use with no (OPACs) are some barriers to access available with no barriers not available. organized for ease of use with clutter such as unnecessary signage. available and (e.g. monitors turned to access. no clutter such as unnecessary Clear directions indicate how to use easily accessible. off). signage. computer terminals.
Comments/
Action Plan
Student accessed computer labs are Student computer labs Student computer labs are Student accessed available and easily accessible. Clear are available but not Student computer labs available and easily accessible. computer labs No computer labs signage/materials indicate expectations easily accessible are available and easily Clear signage/materials are available and available for student use. and policies. Website reflects number (barriers might include accessible. indicate expectations and easily accessible. of computers available at any given turnstiles, etc.). policies. time for advanced preparation.
Comments/
Action Plan
Names of some staff are posted, but are not Names, roles and contact Names, of staff are provided through Names of Names of frontline staff No names of staff are obvious (for example, on information of frontline staff nametags. Names, roles and contact frontline staff are are provided through publicly posted. their office doors, are provided through signage information of frontline staff are publicly posted. signage or nametags. online, or through in the library. provided through signage in the library. business card displays).
Page Total: ______Comments/
Action Plan
Clear, consistent signage Some signage indicating Clear, consistent signage indicates Signage indicates indicates where in-house where materials should Clear, consistent signage where in-house materials should be where in-house No signage indicating materials should be returned be returned after use, indicates where in-house returned after use. Signage is materials should where materials should after use. Signage is but uses jargon, is materials should be professional and turn-in locations AND be returned after be returned after use. professional, OR turn-in unclear, or is returned after use. consistently placed throughout the use. locations are consistently inconsistently placed. library. placed throughout the library.
Comments/
Action Plan
As least one At least one library book At least one library book Book drop is accessible 24 Multiple book drops are accessible 24 library book drop No library book drop is drop is open and drop is accessible 24 hours a day, marked as such, hours a day, marked as such, in is always open visible. accessible when the hours a day. and in a prominent location. prominent locations. and accessible. library is open.
Comments/
Action Plan
Visual supports Schedules of classes and Schedules of classes and such as calendars Visual supports such as Schedules of classes and Schedules of classes and calendars calendars posted in only calendars posted in two and class calendars and schedules calendars posted on a bulletin posted on a bulletin board, flyers one location (bulletin locations (bulletin board, schedules are are not available or are board, flyers available in print available in print and online, with board, flyers to take flyers to take home, available and in not up to date. and online. interactive links. home, online, etc). online, etc.) multiple formats.
Comments/
Action Plan
Page Total: ______Classes are posted in at Classes or Classes are posted in at least one location or Classes are posted in at least Classes are posted in at least one programs have least one location or format. Classes or one location or format. Classes location or format. Classes or programs clear No classes or programs format, but do not have programs have one of the or programs have two of the have all of the following: clear descriptions, a are evident. descriptions, a syllabus, following: clear following: clear descriptions, a descriptions, a syllabus, and list of syllabus, and list or guidelines attached. descriptions, a syllabus, or syllabus, or list of guidelines. guidelines. of guidelines. list of guidelines.
Comments/
Action Plan
Equipment checkouts available but some Equipment Equipment checkouts available Equipment checkouts available and barriers exist (e.g. Equipment checkouts checkouts and and posted through highly posted through highly visible signage in No equipment checkout is materials only available available and posted expectations for visible signage in multiple multiple places - online, in house, or as available. with payment; for in- online, in house, or as a use are clearly places - online, in house, or as a handout. Expectations for use are house use only, etc) or handout. delineated. a handout. clearly delineated. information about this service is hard to find.
Comments/
Action Plan
Headphones are available to checkout or Headphones are available to checkout Headphones are use in the library but Headphones are available Headphones are available to or use in the library with no barriers to available to No headphones are there are barriers to use to checkout or use in the checkout or use in the library use. Clear signage indicates availability, checkout or use available for checkout. (e.g. headphones only library with no barriers to with no barriers to use. Clear and clear procedures for attainment in the library. available with payment; use. signage indicates availability. and use. for in-house use only, etc).
Comments/
Action Plan
Restrooms are clearly Restrooms are Restrooms are not clearly Restrooms have highly visible signage Restrooms have Restrooms are clearly designated and located clearly designated/are hard to in multiple formats and are able to be limited/obscure signage. designated. consistently throughout the designated. find. seen from a distance. library.
Page Total: ______Comments/
Action Plan
Lighting can be adjusted in some spaces, including Lighting can be adjusted in many Lighting can be adjusted multiple forms of light spaces, including multiple forms of light Lighting can be Lighting can be adjusted in some spaces, including switches or dimmers, natural switches or dimmers, natural light with adjusted in Lighting is universal to the in some spaces, but it is multiple forms of light light with blinds, or individual blinds, or individual table lamps. designated building. not consistent, and no switches or dimmers, table lamps. Signage indicates Signage indicates this both at the spaces. signage indicates this. natural light with blinds, this at the location or on the location AND on the floor plan, online, or individual table lamps. floor plan, online, or within or within handouts. handouts.
Comments/
Action Plan
Multiple Multiple entrances or entrances or Only one entrance and Multiple entrances or exits are exits are available (for exits are Only sliding doors are exit area (this refers to Multiple entrances or exits are available, including alternatives to example, one access point available, available as entrance the area itself, not available, including sliding doors. Clear signage from from the parking lot and including and/or exit. whether there are alternatives to sliding doors. campus or parking lots indicates one access point from the alternatives to multiple doors). locations. main campus). sliding doors.
Comments/
Action Plan
Entrances and exits are clearly Entrances and Entrances and exits are Entrances and exits are clearly Entrances and exits are Entrances and exits are designated, and clear signage indicates exits are clearly designated but not with designated with clear, not clearly designated. clearly designated. locations and they are located on floor designated. consistent signage. consistent signage. plans/materials within the library.
Comments/
Action Plan
Page Total: ______Employment and volunteer Employment and Employment and volunteer Employment or Employment and opportunities at the library for students volunteer No employment or opportunities at the library for volunteer opportunities volunteer opportunities are posted in multiple places (on the opportunities for volunteer opportunities students are posted in multiple on campus for students at the library for students website; as a sign; as handouts, etc.). students are for students are posted. places (on the website; as a are posted. are posted. Signs are highly visible, and welcoming posted. sign; as handouts, etc.). and inviting for students to apply.
Comments/
Action Plan
Library policies Library policies posted in all three are available in Library policies posted in Library policies posted in all formats – signage, print, and digital – No comprehensive library Library policies posted in multiple formats format – signage, print, three formats – signage, print, and highly visible upon entrance into policies posted two formats. – signage, print, or digital. and digital. the library and featured prominently on and digital. the website (not buried).
Comments/
Action Plan
Some clocks are Clocks are consistently Clocks are available throughout the available throughout the Clocks are consistently available available No clocks are available Clocks are available library as visual cues for library as visual cues for time throughout the library as visual cues for throughout the throughout the library as throughout the library as time management, but management (e.g. placed in time management (e.g. placed in the library as visual visual cues for time visual cues for time placement is the same spot on each floor) same spot on each floor) and are cues for time management. management. inconsistent, or clocks OR are clearly visible/easy to clearly visible/easy to read. management. are hard to find. read.
Comments/
Action Plan
Cataloging explanation Cataloging explanation Cataloging explanation posted posted on at least one posted consistently on Cataloging explanation posted consistently on endcaps or endcap (or their endcaps or equivalent consistently on endcaps or in other Education their equivalent throughout equivalent) as signage throughout the library relevant places throughout the library provided to the library (Library of Congress No cataloging education (for example Library of (Library of Congress or (Library of Congress or Dewey or other familiarize or Dewey or other provided. Congress poster or key Dewey or other comprehensive system used). students with comprehensive system used). to specific sections such comprehensive system Education also available in at least cataloging Education also available in at as fiction or government used). Education also three of the following: online, as a system. least two of the following: documents), online, as a available online, as a class, through handouts, or on floor online, as a class, through class, through handouts, class, or through plans. handouts, or on floor plans. or on floor plans. handouts.
Page Total: ______Comments/
Action Plan
Self-checkout, or other alternative Self-checkout, or other Self-checkout, or other Self-checkout, or other alternative checkout alternative checkout alternative checkout method, checkout method, is clearly identified, Self-checkout, or method, is clearly No self or alternative method, is clearly is clearly identified, and step- and step-by-step instructions for use alternative checkout identified, and checkout available identified, and step-by- by-step instructions for use are are posted in a clearly visible location. method, is available. step-by-step step instructions for use posted in a clearly visible Staff are proactive in suggesting these instructions for are posted. location. methods. use are posted.
Comments/
Action Plan
Multiple areas Multiple areas marked Multiple areas clearly marked with Only one large, Multiple areas marked for Multiple areas clearly marked marked for for communication with highly visible, consistent signage for intimidating desk for communication with with highly visible, consistent communication library staff, but main communication with library staff. interaction with library library staff (no signage for communication with library staff point of contact is Roving librarians are available. Areas staff. “megadesk”). with library staff. (no “megadesk”). “megadesk.” are welcoming with no clear barriers.
Comments/
Action Plan
Sufficient staff is available to help and Staff is available at more Staff are available throughout are particularly welcoming. Additional Sufficient staff is No staff is available to Staff is available at than one desk throughout library – both at desks, and services are offered, such as the available to help. help. circulation desk. the library. roving. opportunity to reserve staff time for consultations, etc.
Comments/
Action Plan
Page Total: ______Communicaton
3 Communicaton
Listening, cooperatng, and communicatng efectvely is described in one study as “the most prominent area of difculty” for postsecondary students on the autsm spectrum (Elias & White, 2017), and can manifest in “I got an email from a lecturer once. I asked negatve interactons not just socially, but also in the him, I’ve done this, is that okay or do I classroom (Cai & Richdale, 2016). need to do this? He said, no what you did is fne. But what he meant was, no what you Students with ASD may draw unwanted atenton did isn’t fne, and you need to do this. (…) to themselves because of their atypical speech or Sometmes people say something but mean conversatonal paterns, such as defcits in intonaton, or something else and [people with autsm] rate, tone, and volume of speech. For example, someone don’t understand the connecton between with ASD may speak louder than expected, with more vocal an innuendo and a follow on statement” intensity than is typical, or have mechanical, monotone (Cai & Richdale, 2016, pp. 34-35). speech.
60 Communicaton
ASD students may understand informaton in the spaces, materials, informaton, staf and other students. abstract but experience grave difcultes in responding Students with ASD should be able to partcipate in all that to similar situatons in real life. They can ofen state the the library has to ofer both educatonally and socially. In correct response but have difculty changing their behavior this chapter, we will describe some of the communicaton to match environmental expectatons. In other instances, challenges for students with ASD and strategies to facilitate these students might say things that are considered communicaton. inappropriate or may appear disinhibited or lack a flter. Take a minute now to refect on your own greatest Additonally, they might face difculty understanding communicaton strength and your greatest others’ perspectves. Conversaton can be difcult, and communicaton challenge and some strategies you use individuals with ASD might not know when and how to to compensate for your challenges. initate or close a conversaton, read cues, or shif topics.
With communicaton as one of the main areas of difculty for individuals with ASD, it is essental for library professionals to be prepared to support their communicaton skills in ways that promote access to library
Communicaton Characteristcs and Support Strategies
ASD is not an easily recognized disorder, as there are no communicaton difcultes and may avoid conversatons obvious physical signs. While behavioral observatons are and interactons with others in both social and academic widely used, the outward signs of ASD may be subtle and actvites. As library consumers, they are less likely adults may be experienced at compensatng to circumvent to ask librarians for help, to engage other students in identfcaton. They learn to use strategies to appear social conversatons or partcipate in study groups. neurotypical, ofen making it harder to know when and how to ofer support. The following is an exploraton of common Strategies: Some students may choose to seek communicaton characteristcs with consideratons and individualized or small group support services like those strategies to support students with ASD. ofered through Student Disability Services, the University
Conversaton Characteristcs: Common conversatonal defcits identfed in individuals with ASD include difcultes with initatng (i.e., startng conversatons and introducing new topics), maintaining and extending topics of conversaton by commentng and asking follow-up questons, and sustaining reciprocal responses or multple turns within conversatons. These conversatonal difcultes may vary widely across individuals with ASD. In the college setng, students are generally aware of their
61 Communicaton
Speech and Hearing Clinic, or counseling programs on Support Strategy: It is important not to assume that campus to address social communicaton and interacton. if students are not making eye contact, they are not In additon to individualized services, general strategies interested in communicaton. Just because students are that result in improved social-communicaton competence looking away this does not mean that they are no longer in everyday setngs such as the library are very important. seeking your help. It may be anxiety, or a calming strategy Strategies to support conversatons are described in the used to increase atenton and focus on your words by following sectons. minimizing atenton to your face.
A librarian can also provide opportunites to share Eye Contact atenton on the same object, instead of forcing eye contact Characteristcs: Many people with autsm have with a student that seems uncomfortable. This may mean repeatedly shared that eye contact for them can be looking at the same computer screen together to locate an uncomfortable, unnatural, overwhelming, or even painful. artcle as opposed to students researching by themselves. Studies at Massachusets General Hospital (Carter, William, Conversatonal variatons may include limited eye gaze or Minshew, & Lehman, 2012) examined the subcortcal gaze shifs. systems in the brains of both neurotypical subjects and subjects with ASD. These subcortcal systems are areas What is a Meltdown? that play a role in emotonal percepton, are responsible A melt-down is an intense response to for babies’ natural atracton to human faces, and are overwhelming feelings. It happens when someone actvated with eye contact. becomes completely overwhelmed by their current situaton and temporarily loses behavioral control. The autstc partcipants’ subcortcal systems went It is important to recognize that, for individuals with into overdrive when they had to look at eyes. These ASD, it is generally related to stress. Potental stressors results support what people with autsm have been saying include change, uncertainty, sensory/personal contact, all along: they avoid eye contact not because they are food-related actvites, social interactons, and changes indiferent but because it is overwhelming. in routnes. The frequency and intensity of melt downs decrease with age as does their ability to manage In a current study of adults with ASD, researchers stressful situatons. found that “atenton to the experimenter’s face was If someone is having a meltdown, or not responding signifcantly reduced in the autstc adults compared to to you, don’t judge them. It can make a world of the neurotypical adults when the experimenter looked diference to someone on the autsm spectrum and directly at the partcipant,” suggestng a hesitancy to make their careers. Give them some tme as it can take direct eye contact with a person who is actvely seeking a while to recover from an informaton or sensory this engagement (Freeth & Bugembe, 2018). Eye-tracking overload. Calmly ask them if they’re OK and give them studies of individuals with ASD support this asserton, more tme to respond than you might expect. Make and a meta-analysis within this body of work describes a space by trying to create a quiet, safe space as best signifcant reducton in social atenton to not only other’s you can. Ask onlookers to move along and not to stare, eyes, but also other facial features as well (Chita-Tegmark, turn of loud music, and turn down bright lights. Try 2016). whatever you can think of to reduce the informaton overload.
62 Communicaton
With a peer, try having a conversaton without making eye contact. Stand next to one another and focus on the same object. In the space below, record what you found easy or difcult about the conversaton. What was missing that made it challenging to carry on the conversaton?
such as gestures and understanding the interactons of two of more people. Because up to 80% of communicaton and social interactons are nonverbal this impacts all aspects of life.
Individuals with ASD may misinterpret body language and social cues, and some might have difculty understanding the concept of personal space. For example, they may not realize that an interacton is over because they did not read their conversaton partner’s nonverbal communicaton such as turning his or her body away, looking at his or her watch, or leaving the area.
Support Strategy: Several techniques can be helpful here. When librarians are aware of this lack of understanding of body language or social cues, they can simply be very direct and explain feelings and directons. For example, a librarian can say, “I will check in with you later. Right now, I need to assist another person.”
Students with ASD may not be able to take in all of the htps://bit.ly/2EgqyW0 informaton given to them during a reference interview if Body Language and Social Cues they are focused on reading your body language. Write Characteristcs: Research on the brain has found down what was discussed during the conversaton, so that, in individuals with ASD, the area that processes students can refer to this informaton later. Allowing for dynamic nonverbal communicatons is underactve. This alternate means of communicaton, such as through chat results in extreme difcultes in following eye gaze and reference or though email, also removes the body language understanding facial expressions and body movements, barriers some students with ASD might face.
63 Communicaton
might experience. Slang is easily misunderstood, and Research shows.... humor is ofen too abstract. Even suggestons can get lost “Instructors commented that students with ASDs in translaton. appear to miss the nonverbal social cues of their teacher and peers at tmes. They may not notce Figuratve language, including the use of metaphors, when a discussion subject has changed, when it is idioms, and ironic statements, might manifest in both tme to turn of their computers, or when and how to conversatons in the library and through visual supports. contribute to a group actvity. Missed social cues can What might seem to be a wity sign or directve on the lead to behavior that violates norms, and focus group library’s website could instead be more confusing than respondents provided many observatons of such helpful to a literal thinker who sees things concretely. behavior” (Gobbo & Shmulsky, 2014 p.17).
“As a teenager and young adult I had to use concrete symbols to understand abstract concepts such as getng along with people and moving on to the next steps of my life, both of which were always difcult. I knew I did not ft in with my high school peers, and I was unable to fgure out what I was doing wrong. No mater how hard I tried, they made fun of me. They called me "workhorse," "tape recorder," and "bones" because I was skinny. At the tme I was able to fgure out why they called me "workhorse" and Social cues can be even more challenging in large "bones," but "tape recorder" puzzled me. Now groups, in which a person must make sense of group I realize that I must have sounded like a tape dynamics. Try communicatng one-on-one when possible recorder when I repeated things verbatm over to alleviate this concern. and over” (Grandin, 2006, p. 17).
Placing an interestng object as a focal point behind the reference desk will allow a student with ASD to have Research shows.... somewhere to look as he is communicatng. This might “You know, I learned from experience not to ask “Can relieve some of the pressure to read nonverbal signals. I pet your baby?” I learned to ask “Can I rub your baby’s back?” One thing I did that helped was I just Literal Language: told people “Hey, I don’t understand,” “Hey, what Characteristc: Many individuals with ASD are literal does it mean when you said this?” And I found in thinkers. This is a challenge as typical conversatons or college people were prety willing to explain it” exchanges make use of various types of language, such (Donevan, 2017 para. 14). as irony, sarcasm, or fgures of speech. If you tell literal thinkers that presentng to the class might give you buterfies in your stomach, imagine the confusion they
64 Communicaton
Support Strategy: Remember to speak literally, graphic for checkout would also be helpful, not only to avoid confusing fgures of speech, and use direct those with ASD, but other library patrons as well. Analyze language to be very clear in your directons. Be the library’s signage, training manuals, and other materials careful to use straightorward language in printed to look for unnecessary jargon. Make a systematc efort to materials, on the website, and on library signage. replace it. Use the template below to begin brainstorming areas in your library where you can improve existng signage. Shif your gaze from the student's face to an object of joint interest to reduce the pressure on the student to Literal language can actually be a strength when return directed eye gaze to you. Alternatng gaze between communicatng with students with ASD. One college the student and the object shows your contnued interest student with ASD describes how her straightorward while reducing stress. language is valued by her friends: “Friends ofen come to me to tell me their story. A lot of my friends say…that they talk to me easily because we can have an open conversaton. I am free of bias, in the sense that I just honestly tell them the way things are. I do not beat around the bush, I am not unfriendly, just honest (Rosa, aged 21, university)” (Van Hees, Moyson, & Roeyer, 2015, p. 1682).
With a peer, have a simple conversaton where one of you uses body language to express an emoton. Take turns decoding one another’s body language. Try to express diferent emotons (i.e. anger, happiness, sadness). In the space below, record what actons led you identfy the emoton behind the words.
Current Signage: Can be Replaced with... Circulaton Checkouts and Returns Book Drop Return Books Here Reference Research Help
Libraries can provide signage that is based on real world meanings rather than terminology that is library specifc. For example, the connotaton of “circulaton” in a library is diferent than the more general term of circulaton. Using a sign that says “checkout” is clearer and specifc. A simple htps://bit.ly/2EeqTIx
65 Communicaton
Asking and Answering Questons • Be patent and ofer a great deal of wait tme afer Characteristc: If a librarian is ofering to help a asking a queston. student it is only natural to start by asking a queston or • Simplify the queston into a “yes or no” format. This two. Ofen this becomes a reference interview. Questons may reduce the richness of the interacton but may that are general or open ended may increase anxiety in an help decrease the processing load. individual with ASD who is focused on a very specifc topic • Reduce the use of fguratve language and the or request. Rather than helpful, the reference interview overall length of the questons if possible. may become anxiety inducing. People with ASD may repeat words from a queston, change the subject to something • Utlize a semi-structured script of queston and more comfortable or relevant to their interest, or ignore answer choices. a query they do not understand. Each of these responses can result in a communicaton breakdown between the Research shows.... librarian and student. “Using concrete language and unambiguous questons can help students who are less adept at One librarian spoke about the reference interview for abstract thinking “ (Gobbo and Shmulsky, 2012 p.20). students with ASD:
Use the following table to rewrite questons you “If you go up to someone and you start asking commonly ask patrons using the tps above. all kind of open-ended questons you could stress someone out. And so, yeah, being Instead of Asking... Try Asking... cognizant of (the) reacton to what you’re Do you need a book, doing. So if it seems like you’re stressing What type of informaton journal artcle, or other the patron out, then try and switch tactcs, do you need? type of resource? don’t just keep with open ended questons, maybe just try something and see how that Tell me more about your What have you found goes. And if that doesn’t work, try something topic? already? else!”
Support Strategies: Some strategies for initatng conversatons and helping individuals respond: • Start with a comment such as “Welcome. I see you are looking at the reference computer.” Pause to see the student comments. If not, follow up with a focused queston. “Do you have a queston?” • Ofer a choice rather than an open-ended queston (“May I help you fnd a journal artcle or a book?”). • Keep visual supports nearby during a reference interview (a small whiteboard or pencil and paper) for the visual learner.
66 Communicaton
Refect in the spaces below how you might use the You see a student standing by a table full of books questons you wrote above to approach the situatons leaning down, with his hands in pockets, staring presented in the following scenarios. If you think of other blankly. You say: “What could I do to help you?” questons while reading the scenarios, add them to your The student responds by talking rapidly about the list above. topic of the books on the table. He has limited facial expression or gaze shifing to you. You notce he is You see a young man who is reluctant to speak to curling the page corners of a book. What do you say others and looks down or away when others pass. next? What else could you say or do? He is quiet and seems not engaged or productve. He is keeping his hands in his pockets, and though he is reminding himself to smile, it seems forced. What would you do?
Within these scenarios, several things could occur. You may get no response, or you could increase the student’s frustraton to the level of a meltdown. You may get no response because students think deeply about the queston and need tme to process what the right answer is. If you give them an open-ended queston, there is no right answer, or they might respond literally. If you ask, “What could I do to help you?” don’t be surprised if the answer is “Write my paper for me!” Beter optons are to use short, declaratve sentences and provide clear choices. It is good to have a backup plan such as ofering a quiet space to sit in and talk or suggest they write their requests or you write them as the students dictate to you.
67 Communicaton
Echolalia people talk themselves through informaton processing. If Characteristc: Echolalia, or repeatng the words it seems that the student needs help fnding an item and and phrases of another person, is a common language is talking through that process, you might ofer assistance. characteristc that is shared by many people with autsm. For example, when students are repeatng a call number, It was initally believed to be a nonfunctonal, automatc this is a wonderful opportunity to help them fnd the item response or a behavior used to relieve anxiety or stress needed. (such as hand movements, like wringing or twistng fngers, or twirling papers or small objects does). In fact, it is more than a stress reducer. Echolalia serves a communicatve With a peer, take turns imagining a task you’d like to functon for people with autsm. Repeatng a word can serve accomplish in the library, choose a word or phrase as a “fller” to keep the speaker’s atenton while giving related to that task, then see if the other person the individual a moment to process and fnd the words can help decipher the task. Only the word or phrase they want. These fllers can keep a conversaton going chosen may be said, but props could be included. In when the listener is interested or realizes a response is an the space below, list other clues that one might use to expectaton, and it can also be a confrmaton of a request. infer the patron’s need. A general awareness and understanding of echolalia will be helpful when working with students with ASD.
Support Strategies: Students may echo words and phrases in response to a queston they do not understand because they know that you are expectng an answer. You might let students know that they do not need to give you an answer immediately. Allow them tme to process and tell them you will check back in later at a specifed tme.
Students with ASD might echo an answer to show afrmaton. For example, if asked, “Are you ready to check out your books?” an individual may respond, “Check out your books,” to show that he or she is, indeed, ready. If a student is showing afrmaton, you can simply accept this communicaton as a response and contnue your interacton. No interventon should be necessary.
Echolalia can also be used as a processing strategy to help increase one’s own understanding. Hearing your own voice say a phrase out loud may help your comprehension. Echolalia can also be thought of as a form of verbal rehearsal, as we all do upon entering a store without a list. In the library, you might hear a student repeat a call htps://bit.ly/2uK4EuE number or list the books he or she wants to check out. Many
68 Communicaton
Predictable Outcomes Requestng items from their home via the online Characteristc: Individuals with ASD tend to thrive catalog is another opton that will allow students with ASD in predictable situatons in which they know what the prepare in advance. Many academic libraries have this outcome will be. While not every possible stressor can be system already in place and will send an email when the identfed, here are some library-specifc examples of issues item is ready to be picked up. that might arise for this unique populaton of individuals who enjoy a predictable outcome.
A hallmark feature of autsm is an intense interest in a highly specifc topic or topics, which makes the library an ideal place for unearthing informaton and enriching literacy development. Individuals may experience stress when they want a book or piece of media that is currently unavailable, or a student may come to the library expectng to sit in his or her favorite chair, only to fnd that the chair is occupied.
htps://bit.ly/2q3tdgs Support Strategies: Communicaton is critcal to ensure that students with ASD are well prepared for any Students with ASD who have a favorite place to sit unexpected situatons they might face in the library. To that is already occupied, or one with a favorite computer communicate what to do when an item is not available, currently being used by someone else, could beneft from you might have a list of procedures that can be followed a plan of acton that entails a visual to decrease the stress to obtain the item through interlibrary loan, along with of an unantcipated outcome. For example, the student a very concrete tme frame for obtaining the item. could have a printed foor plan of various places to sit or other computer work statons. You library might already have an app with this informaton on it that a student Are you responsible for library instructon session? It could use. Think about how you might provide access to is important to ensure predictability there as well. As one these services, and how you might let students know of its ASD program manager describes, existence.
If your library has any of these services already “One of the things that we’ll suggest available, how are students being informed of these is that if there’s any major changes, optons? In what ways could more atenton be changes in locaton or anything to brought to services like the ones described above? that efect, then you just notfy them ahead of tme so the student is aware of any major changes that are going to happen and they can process that informaton accordingly.”
69 Communicaton
Communicaton with Student Workers Characteristc: Libraries employ student workers as inital points of contact, but students with ASD may not be comfortable approaching their peers for help. “(In college) I considered many of the librarians to be my mentors. Being socially Students are ofen valued library employees, helping awkward with unique interests, I didn’t their peers navigate library services and serving as the partcipate much in the collegiate social frst access point for assistance. Studies support this scene, so the library was where I did a lot of approach and show that college students ofen prefer to my socializing” (Eng, 2017 para. 7). seek informaton from peers rather than approaching a teacher or authority fgure (Manuel, 2002). “Anecdotally, we have observed that when both a student worker and a Support Strategy: Student workers might not librarian are at the desk, student patrons will almost always understand the nuances in communicatng with a peer who approach the student worker frst,” (Gardner & Eng, 2005). is on the autsm spectrum, resultng in an uncomfortable situaton and missed opportunites for proper assistance.
A tered approach to reference is common in academic libraries and is likely already incorporated into your process working with student employees. “Since students feel more comfortable approaching a peer, it makes sense to try a tered approach to reference services. Well-trained student workers can answer basic reference questons to make patrons feel more comfortable about initally approaching the reference desk; and if the queston is too advanced for the student worker to handle, it can then be referred to a librarian” (Garner & Eng, 2005). In training student workers to understand this tered approach, make sure they frst know the basics of how to identfy and communicate with an individual with ASD – Students on the autsm spectrum might feel providing them with this manual would be a frst step! Next, uncomfortable approaching a peer, and could prefer make sure that employees know to approach a librarian to communicatng with a professional librarian instead. contnue the conversaton, if it seems that would beneft One study found “that some students with ASDs seem to the student with ASD. Librarians can serve as important respond beter to instructors than peers. Students may allies and mentors for students on the spectrum, and prefer working ideas through with instructors to working student workers should never feel that they are giving up on them with peers as the social roles and boundaries are by allowing a librarian to contnue the interacton; instead, more clearly defned and comfortable” (Gobbo & Shmulsky, it is an opportunity for support. 2014).
70 Communicaton
Addressing Challenging Situatons What do you currently provide in your library Characteristc: The library should be welcoming for all for students who use alternatve forms of users, and all eforts to avoid negatve situatons should be communicaton? What can you start doing now to made. In Chapter 2, we discuss various ways to physically supplement your current oferings? structure the library environment to facilitate the most positve experience possible for students with autsm. Despite your best eforts, it is stll possible that students with ASD will have a stressful and anxious moment, resultng in the occurrence of a challenging situaton for both student and staf.
Using a quiet, calm voice when communicatng with students with ASD who appear anxious or are displaying challenging behavior is important for supportng the individual to partcipate and self-regulate. As with many individuals in uncomfortable or frightening situatons, quick movements, loud voices, or physical contact may increase anxiety and challenging behaviors rather than be helpful. Ofering the opton of a quiet place to move to can Support Strategies: Ofering students alternate ways also be helpful. to communicate can allow for rich interactons; read the following descripton from a successful college graduate on the autsm spectrum: “I was unable to express most of my thoughts verbally; so many professionals such as teachers and doctors were unable to see how intelligent I was. Then at 18 years old, I had a communicaton breakthrough when I began to use an iPad. I was fnally able to express my personal thoughts and share what I know, graduatng from high school at age 21. Afer years of being told I would never go to college, I just fnished up my freshman year” (Zimmerman, 2017). htps://bit.ly/2fmEAdv
71 Communicaton
Understand that it can be hard for students with ASD to • Don’t get frustrated if they respond in a seemingly process high levels of informaton as it is difcult for them inappropriate way. They may not use some of the to flter out which informaton is not essental. This can expected polite social conversaton forms and ofen lead to extreme anxiety, so be thoughtul about reducing will not realize that they are appearing rude or informaton shared during these anxious periods. hurtul. • Reduce pressure to communicate. It is natural to want to explain a situaton, comfort a • Try to choose a quiet place to have your person, or distract them from their distress. However, conversaton. They may have trouble processing ofering more verbal or emotonal informaton to process what you are saying and will be put of by too much to a person who is already overwhelmed is not helpful. background noise.
If communicaton is not progressing, be prepared to • If you sense they’re beginning to feel uncomfortable alter expectatons in the moment and ofer alternatves. or anxious ask if they would like to sit in a quiet It could be that something about the current situaton place for a while. Aferwards, you can resume your just does not feel right to the student. You might also conversaton. This ofen helps to relieve the anxiety. improve communicaton by trying to rephrase your • Be aware of your physical presence. words, experimentng with diferent ways of expressing • Be aware you may be standing too close and they the same informaton untl you are sure that the student may not like shaking hands or being pated on the understands what you are saying. Finally, take the tme to back. You can ask them if it is fne to shake hands. listen. The rewards of more efectve communicaton will • For some people with ASD, using pictures or be enormous for both you and the student with autsm. diagrams to help get your point across can be helpful.
Spend some tme with a peer asking one another questons you ofen ask during a normal day. Try allowing extra tme for the other person to answer by countng to fve in your head before contnuing. Also, see how many of the above points you can utlize. Which ones were harder to include? Which ones were surprising to you? htps://bit.ly/2Jk2LrY
Take a moment to view the video “10 Ways to Make Communicaton Easier.” In summary, the narrator suggests the following: • Calmly queston. Use clear, short sentences when giving informaton or instructons to someone with autsm. • Give them tme to answer you. They may take some tme to process what you are saying and then create a response.
72 Communicaton
Communicaton Breakdowns Awareness and Understanding
Even with knowledge and understanding of communicatve paterns in students with ASD, there is always the possibility for breakdowns in communicaton – with both library staf and with other students. If you are observant, and you can help in the library, you may notce a student becoming an easy target for bullying or perhaps actng like a bully himself by appearing overly atentve. A student with ASD may be teased, even quietly. Perhaps you see other students moving chairs or books or playing other simple pranks. Other students might notce he is irritated by noises and add a few extra just for “fun.” Though individuals with ASD may want to ft in with their peer group, they might be focused on themselves and their own agenda. It is easy for students with ASD to overreact or be over zealous, so they might respond to atenton from peers with too much atenton, misreading the cues from their peers.
The library is a place where students with ASD should be able to go and be welcomed. Though communicaton can be difcult for students with ASD, there are clear strategies to beter support successful interactons in the library. Challenges ofen arise from a lack of understanding or miscommunicaton. By educatng yourself and your htps://bit.ly/2GxgYnu fellow library staf members on how to best support interacton with those persons with ASD, your library will Try the following with a peer: Pretend to address a serve as a welcoming and understanding environment in bullying situaton. What do you say to the students which challenging situatons are much less likely to occur. both doing the bullying, and the student on the receiving end of the bullying? Creatng an efectve communicaton environment is about attude and understanding – you do not need to be an expert, but, instead, be observant and responsive. Recognize the signs and signals and appreciate the communicatve diferences that these students exhibit.
73 Based on the support strategies you have learned so far, use the atached rubric to assess Communicaton Adaptatons communicaton adaptatons you might make in your library for students with ASD.
Communication Adaptations to Consider for Students with ASD
Excellent Good Fair Poor Very Poor