Zhang Yuan (1885-1919): Constructing a Public Garden in Cosmopolitan Shanghai

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Zhang Yuan (1885-1919): Constructing a Public Garden in Cosmopolitan Shanghai Zhang Yuan (1885-1919): Constructing a Public Garden in Cosmopolitan Shanghai A thesis presented to the faculty of the College of Fine Arts of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Master of Arts Jinyi Liu August 2017 © 2017 Jinyi Liu. All Rights Reserved. 2 This thesis titled Zhang Yuan (1885-1919): Constructing a Public Garden in Cosmopolitan Shanghai by JINYI LIU has been approved for the School of Art + Design and the College of Fine Arts by Marion S. Lee Associate Professor of Art Elizabeth Sayrs Interim Dean, College of Fine Arts 3 ABSTRACT LIU, JINYI, M.A., August 2017, Art History Zhang Yuan (1885-1919): Constructing a Public Garden in Cosmopolitan Shanghai Director of Thesis: Marion S. Lee This thesis studies Zhang Yuan 张园 (Zhang Family Garden), a public garden in semi-colonial Shanghai founded by Wuxi merchant Zhang Shuhe 张叔和 (1850-1919). Opened in 1885 and closed in 1919, Zhang Yuan, along with other Chinese public gardens, was one the most popular venues for the public to experience the newly imported Western-style practices and ideas in urban Shanghai. However, scholarship on the urban history of Shanghai overlooks this critical field and focuses instead on Western-style schools, companies, and print industry. I propose that commercialized entertainment gardens, such as Zhang Yuan, better illustrate the negotiation between the established and the imported which marked the permeation of changes in late 19th and early 20th century Shanghai. In addition, this thesis approaches Zhang Yuan as a fluidly constructed social space to reveal the interconnections between changes in various integrated social areas. I frame the garden within the geopolitical transformation of semi- colonial Shanghai, map its architectural design in relationship to the developing built environment, and understand it through the ever-changing leisure pursuits. As a garden evolving with the urban culture of the city, Zhang Yuan illustrates the disappearing boundary between participating in the newly imported entertainments and advocating for sociopolitical reform. Such an interchangeability between popular culture and political discourse underlined the fluidity of changes in late Qing and early Republican Shanghai. 4 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to extend my deepest gratitude to my advisor, Dr. Marion Lee, for her continuous guidance throughout this project and her tireless dedication to explore my potential in conducting research. Her compassion, generosity, and immense knowledge constantly inspire me. I would also like to thank my committee members Dr. Joshua Hill, Dr. Brian Collins, and Dr. Samuel Dodd for their courses, which shaped my interest in history, space, and architecture, and for their valuable comments. Additionally, I thank Dr. Yan He and Nancy Story from Alden Library who provided me with ready support about research materials as well as Kathy Devecka and Yi-ting Wang from the Graduate Writing Center who helped me improve my writing skills. I am indebted to the “College of Fine Arts Dean’s Graduate Award of Merit” for providing me with funds to carry out the field and archival research in Shanghai during the summer of 2016. I thank Zang Jianmin, Wang Hong, and Huang Guorong from Shanghai Library for lending me rare unpublished maps of semi-colonial Shanghai. I also acknowledge Yang Jiguang and Liu Hongye from Jing’an District Cultural Heritage and Historical Records Institution in Shanghai for generously sending me books on primary materials about Zhang Yuan. Lastly, I extend sincere appreciation to my parents and, especially, my husband who constantly encouraged and supported me throughout this journey. 5 A NOTE ON TRANSLATION All translations in this paper are done by the author, unless otherwise noted. 6 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Abstract ............................................................................................................................... 3 Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................. 4 A Note on Translation ......................................................................................................... 5 List of Figures ..................................................................................................................... 8 Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 10 Chapter 1: Building Zhang Yuan in the International Settlement .................................... 20 A Brief History of the Foreign Settlements ................................................................ 20 About Urban Construction .................................................................................... 22 About Expanding Territories ................................................................................ 25 Boulevards, Promenades, and Courtesans .................................................................. 26 “Testing Electric Lights on the Double Ninth Festival” ............................................. 30 Chapter 2: Acadia Hall and the Expansion of Zhang Yuan .............................................. 35 The Construction of Acadia Hall ................................................................................ 36 “An Up-to-Date Tea-House” ................................................................................ 36 “The Architecture of Spectacle” ........................................................................... 40 Courtesans, Acadia Hall, and Mass Media ........................................................... 42 A Vibrant Garden: Landscape of Zhang Yuan after Expansion ................................. 44 Expansions and the Open Landscape .................................................................... 45 A Vibrant Space and Popular Recreational Sports ............................................... 49 Chapter 3: Zhang Yuan: Fashioning the Leisure Pursuits ................................................ 53 Some Early Activities in Zhang Yuan since 1885 ...................................................... 54 Fireworks Displays ............................................................................................... 54 Photographic Studios ............................................................................................ 55 Flower Expositions and Flower Appreciations ..................................................... 57 A Theme Park: Leisure Activities in Zhang Yuan after the 1890s Expansions ......... 59 The 1907 “International Fair and Fête:” A Charity Fair on a “Global” Scale ............ 63 Zhang Yuan: A Most Suitable Site ....................................................................... 65 A Comparison with Other Large-scale Social Events in Shanghai ...................... 67 “Merchant Bureaucrats” and Organization of the Local Events ........................... 69 Chapter 4: Reform in and out of Zhang Yuan .................................................................. 72 7 Reform in Different Aspects of City Life as Seen in Zhang Yuan ............................. 75 Catching up with Global Trends: The “International Fair and Fête” .................... 75 Reforming the Traditions: “Civilized Weddings” in Acadia Hall ........................ 78 Participating in Public Events: Women Seen in Zhang Yuan .............................. 80 A Public Space: Political Demonstration and Public Meetings in Zhang Yuan ......... 83 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 88 References ......................................................................................................................... 93 Glossary .......................................................................................................................... 140 Appendix: News Reports on Zhang Yuan ...................................................................... 141 8 LIST OF FIGURES Page Figure 1. A map indicating Jin’an Temple Road in the International Settlement in Shanghai, 1860 ................................................................................................................ 100 Figure 2. A reconstructed map showing locations of five treaty ports in semi-colonial China ............................................................................................................................... 101 Figure 3. A map of the walled city and the foreign settlements in Shanghai, 1885 ....... 102 Figure 4. A reconstructed map indicating the expansion of the foreign settlements in Shanghai .......................................................................................................................... 103 Figure 5. Promenading on Jing’an Temple Road, 1880s. ............................................... 104 Figure 6. Shanghai Race Club, C. E. Darwent, Shanghai: A Handbook for Travellers and Residents to the Chief Objects of Interest in and around the Foreign Settlements and Native City, 1903. ........................................................................................................... 105 Figure 7. Shanghai Country club, C. E. Darwent, Shanghai: A Handbook for Travellers and Residents to the Chief Objects of Interest in and around the Foreign Settlements and Native City, 1903. ........................................................................................................... 106 Figure 8. Social
Recommended publications
  • Hwang, Yin (2014) Victory Pictures in a Time of Defeat: Depicting War in the Print and Visual Culture of Late Qing China 1884 ‐ 1901
    Hwang, Yin (2014) Victory pictures in a time of defeat: depicting war in the print and visual culture of late Qing China 1884 ‐ 1901. PhD Thesis. SOAS, University of London http://eprints.soas.ac.uk/18449 Copyright © and Moral Rights for this thesis are retained by the author and/or other copyright owners. A copy can be downloaded for personal non‐commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge. This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the copyright holder/s. The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. When referring to this thesis, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given e.g. AUTHOR (year of submission) "Full thesis title", name of the School or Department, PhD Thesis, pagination. VICTORY PICTURES IN A TIME OF DEFEAT Depicting War in the Print and Visual Culture of Late Qing China 1884-1901 Yin Hwang Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the History of Art 2014 Department of the History of Art and Archaeology School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London 2 Declaration for PhD thesis I have read and understood regulation 17.9 of the Regulations for students of the School of Oriental and African Studies concerning plagiarism. I undertake that all the material presented for examination is my own work and has not been written for me, in whole or in part, by any other person.
    [Show full text]
  • The Silk Roads: an ICOMOS Thematic Study
    The Silk Roads: an ICOMOS Thematic Study by Tim Williams on behalf of ICOMOS 2014 The Silk Roads An ICOMOS Thematic Study by Tim Williams on behalf of ICOMOS 2014 International Council of Monuments and Sites 11 rue du Séminaire de Conflans 94220 Charenton-le-Pont FRANCE ISBN 978-2-918086-12-3 © ICOMOS All rights reserved Contents STATES PARTIES COVERED BY THIS STUDY ......................................................................... X ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ..................................................................................................... XI 1 CONTEXT FOR THIS THEMATIC STUDY ........................................................................ 1 1.1 The purpose of the study ......................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Background to this study ......................................................................................................... 2 1.2.1 Global Strategy ................................................................................................................................ 2 1.2.2 Cultural routes ................................................................................................................................. 2 1.2.3 Serial transnational World Heritage nominations of the Silk Roads .................................................. 3 1.2.4 Ittingen expert meeting 2010 ........................................................................................................... 3 2 THE SILK ROADS: BACKGROUND, DEFINITIONS
    [Show full text]
  • © 2013 Yi-Ling Lin
    © 2013 Yi-ling Lin CULTURAL ENGAGEMENT IN MISSIONARY CHINA: AMERICAN MISSIONARY NOVELS 1880-1930 BY YI-LING LIN DISSERTATION Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Comparative Literature in the Graduate College of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2013 Urbana, Illinois Doctoral committee: Professor Waïl S. Hassan, Chair Professor Emeritus Leon Chai, Director of Research Professor Emeritus Michael Palencia-Roth Associate Professor Robert Tierney Associate Professor Gar y G. Xu Associate Professor Rania Huntington, University of Wisconsin at Madison Abstract From a comparative standpoint, the American Protestant missionary enterprise in China was built on a paradox in cross-cultural encounters. In order to convert the Chinese—whose religion they rejected—American missionaries adopted strategies of assimilation (e.g. learning Chinese and associating with the Chinese) to facilitate their work. My dissertation explores how American Protestant missionaries negotiated the rejection-assimilation paradox involved in their missionary work and forged a cultural identification with China in their English novels set in China between the late Qing and 1930. I argue that the missionaries’ novelistic expression of that identification was influenced by many factors: their targeted audience, their motives, their work, and their perceptions of the missionary enterprise, cultural difference, and their own missionary identity. Hence, missionary novels may not necessarily be about conversion, the missionaries’ primary objective but one that suggests their resistance to Chinese culture, or at least its religion. Instead, the missionary novels I study culminate in a non-conversion theme that problematizes the possibility of cultural assimilation and identification over ineradicable racial and cultural differences.
    [Show full text]
  • Montreal Architectural Review
    Montreal Architectural Review Between Dream and Shadow: The Aesthetic Change Embodied by the Garden of Lion Grove Hui Zou University of Florida Abstract During the late 18th century, the Chinese emperor Qianlong ordered the construction of the Garden of Lion Grove and the Western Garden within his garden complex of Yuanmingyuan in Beijing. His Garden of Lion Grove was an imitation of the original Garden of Lion Grove in Suzhou, which was well known for its rockery labyrinth. Comparing the original Lion Grove and its replicas through poetry and architectural representation, Qianlong sought for truth of the cosmic world. My previous research has uncovered the cross-cultural history regarding the design of the Western Garden within the Yuanmingyuan. This essay translates and interprets the poems and garden records of the Lion Grove in Suzhou to reveal the aesthetic change of the garden from the original Buddhist Chan (Zen) idea of the Yuan dynasty to the secular labyrin- thine ecstasy of the Qing dynasty. The labyrinthine theatricality of the Lion Groves, including the original one and its replicas, was well documented by Qianlong through his poems and his frequent reference to master painter Ni Zan’s painting scroll of the Lion Grove in Suzhou. The essay draws a conclusion that the MAR Volume 5, 2018 6 Hui Zou | Montreal Architectural Review : Vol. 5, 2018 aesthetic transition from Buddhist Chan (Zen) to labyrinthine ecstasy at the Lion Grove in Suzhou took place in a particularly historical age, namely the Ming dynasty, when the philosophical issues of dream and fantasy became trendy in Chinese gardens and garden literature.
    [Show full text]
  • Reflections on Place and Place-Making in the Cities of China
    Blackwell Publishing LtdOxford, UKIJURInternational Journal of Urban and Regional Research0309-1317© 2007 The Author. Journal Compilation © 2007 Joint Editors and Blackwell Publishing Ltd200731225779Original ArticlesReflections on places and place-making in ChinaJohn Friedmann Volume 31.2 June 2007 257–79 International Journal of Urban and Regional Research DOI:10.1111/j.1468-2427.2007.00726.x Reflections on Place and Place-making in the Cities of China JOHN FRIEDMANN Abstract This article is about the small spaces of the city we call ‘places’. Places are shaped by being lived in; they are spaces of encounter where the little histories of the city are played out. They are, of course, also shaped by the state through planning, supervision, ordinances, and so forth. The patterns and rhythms of life in the small spaces of the city are therefore not simply a straightforward projection of civil life. Places are also sites of resistance, contestation, and actions that are often thought to be illegal by the (local) state. After introducing the concept of place, the remainder of this article is a reflection on places and place-making (but also place-breaking) in urban China. Because the patterns and rhythms of urban life have continuity, however, my approach to their study was historical. The story told here is roughly divided into four major periods: Imperial China, Republican China, the People’s Republic under Mao Zedong, and the reform period from about 1980 onward. I then return to the concepts of place and place-making with which I began, summarizing my findings and suggesting some topics for further research.
    [Show full text]
  • SSA1208 / GES1005 – Everyday Life of Chinese Singaporeans: Past and Present
    SSA1208 / GES1005 – Everyday Life of Chinese Singaporeans: Past and Present Group Essay Ho Lim Keng Temple Prepared By: Tutorial [D5] Chew Si Hui (A0130382R) Kwek Yee Ying (A0130679Y) Lye Pei Xuan (A0146673X) Soh Rolynn (A0130650W) Submission Date: 31th March 2017 1 Content Page 1. Introduction to Ho Lim Keng Temple 3 2. Exterior & Courtyard 3 3. Second Level 3 4. Interior & Main Hall 4 5. Main Gods 4 6. Secondary Gods 5 7. Our Views 6 8. Experiences Encountered during our Temple Visit 7 9. References 8 10. Appendix 8 2 1. Introduction to Ho Lim Keng Temple Ho Lim Keng Temple is a Taoist temple and is managed by common surname association, Xu (许) Clan. Chinese clan associations are benevolent organizations of popular origin found among overseas Chinese communities for individuals with the same surname. This social practice arose several centuries ago in China. As its old location was acquisited by the government for redevelopment plans, they had moved to a new location on Outram Hill. Under the leadership of 许木泰宗长 and other leaders, along with the clan's enthusiastic response, the clan managed to raise a total of more than $124,000, and attained their fundraising goal for the reconstruction of the temple. Reconstruction works commenced in 1973 and was completed in 1975. Ho Lim Keng Temple was advocated by the Xu Clan in 1961, with a board of directors to manage internal affairs. In 1966, Ho Lim Keng Temple applied to the Registrar of Societies and was approved on February 28, 1967 and then was published in the Government Gazette on March 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Globalization and Shanghai Model: a Retrospective and Prospective Analysis
    Journal of International and Global Studies Volume 4 Number 1 Article 5 11-1-2012 Globalization and Shanghai Model: A Retrospective and Prospective Analysis Linsun Cheng Ph.D. University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.lindenwood.edu/jigs Part of the Anthropology Commons, Critical and Cultural Studies Commons, Environmental Studies Commons, and the Sociology Commons Recommended Citation Cheng, Linsun Ph.D. (2012) "Globalization and Shanghai Model: A Retrospective and Prospective Analysis," Journal of International and Global Studies: Vol. 4 : No. 1 , Article 5. Available at: https://digitalcommons.lindenwood.edu/jigs/vol4/iss1/5 This Essay is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Digital Commons@Lindenwood University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of International and Global Studies by an authorized editor of Digital Commons@Lindenwood University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Globalization and Shanghai Model: A Retrospective and Prospective Analysis Linsun Cheng University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth [email protected] AAbstractbstractAbstract Intended to shed light on the debate on the results of globalization and provide better understanding of the influences of globalization upon China as well as the world, this article traces the history of Shanghai’s economic globalization over the past 170 years since 1843 and demonstrates the benefits and problems Shanghai received from (or connected to) its
    [Show full text]
  • Integrating Chinese and Western Pursuit of Excellence
    2021 4th International Workshop on Advances in Social Sciences (IWASS 2021) Integrating Chinese and Western Pursuit of Excellence Jing Zeng1, Huijun Shen2 1Arts College of Sichuan University, PhD student 2College of Forestry, Sichuan Agricultural University, Wenjiang 611130, China Keywords: Shanghai furniture, Chinese and western combination, “innovation and progress” Abstract: “ShangHai furniture” was born under the combined effect of the localization of Western-style furniture and the westernization of faithful furniture. It is the most representative fusion of China and the West. This article analyzes the contribution of “Shanghai style furniture” to the fusion of Chinese and Western furniture and its positive effect on China's modern furniture innovation based on the four stages of “Shanghai style furniture”: “germination”, “development”, “rejuvenation” and “innovation”. 1. Introduction ShangHai furniture is the product of ShangHai culture, which generally refers to the combination of Chinese and Western style furniture. It is a combination of the advantages of Western-style furniture. During the Republic of China, the beach was born and the place where all the nations came together, thus forming this vast and profound furniture. Shanghai style furniture is the product of the collision between Chinese and Western cultures, and it is partially integrated, so it has dual characteristics of Chinese and Western cultures. Although it is ordinary daily necessities, it is the bearer of China's historical culture. Since ancient times, the Chinese nation has firmly believed in the idea of “harmony and difference” and “tolerance is greater”. Among the furniture, no one can better interpret the harmony culture than Shanghai furniture. Therefore, since its birth, it has become the spokesperson for the fusion of Chinese and Western furniture.
    [Show full text]
  • Suburban Development in Shanghai: a Case of Songjiang
    CARDIFF UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF CITY AND REGIONAL PLANNING Suburban Development in Shanghai: A Case of Songjiang Jie Shen Supervisor: Professor Fulong Wu Thesis for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy December 2011 ABSTRACT Since 2000, a new round of suburbanisation characterised by mixed-use clustered development has begun to unfold in China. This research aims to explore the dynamics of recent suburban growth in China and also provide an empirical case for enriching suburban theory. It is held that suburbanisation in China in its current form is by no means a spontaneous process, but results from capitalism’s creation of a new space to facilitate accumulation. Based on this view, the study examines the underlying forces of contemporary suburban growth with regard to three questions: what is the role of suburbanisation in China’s contemporary capital accumulation regime? How are the suburbs developed under coalitions of different actors? And how is suburban development shaped by demand-side actors? The study is founded on an intensive case study of Shanghai and one of its suburban districts, Songjiang. Both qualitative and quantitative research methods are used. Firsthand data from interviews and a questionnaire survey and a wide variety of secondary data were collected, providing a rich fund of knowledge for the research. While similar forms and functions to (post)-suburban settlements that have recently emerged in Western countries are found in Chinese suburbs, suburbanisation through new town development in China is a strategy of capital accumulation in response to a range of new conditions specific to China’s local context. New towns deal with the recentralisation of both fiscal and land development powers on the one hand, and accommodate the increasing housing demands of a diverse labour force on the other.
    [Show full text]
  • Title Negotiating Religion in Modern China: State and Common
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by HKU Scholars Hub Negotiating Religion in Modern China: State and Common Title People in Guangzhou, 1900-1937, by Shuk-wah Poon. Hong Kong: The Chinese University Press, 2011. X+208 pp. Author(s) Palmer, DA Citation The China Journal, 2013, v. 69, p. 232-234 Issued Date 2013 URL http://hdl.handle.net/10722/195629 Rights Creative Commons: Attribution 3.0 Hong Kong License Negotiating Religion in Modern China: State and Common People in Guangzhou, 1900-1937, by Shuk-wah Poon. Hong Kong: The Chinese University Press, 2011. X+208 pp. Book review by David A. Palmer PRE-PUBLICATION VERSION Published in The China Journal 69 (2012): 232-234. Recent scholarship on state-religion relations in China has highlighted the continuities between republican-era and PRC anti-superstition campaigns and state management of religion, as well as the creative adaptation of religious groups within an unfavourable regulatory environment. Negotiating religion is an excellent addition to this literature, using the case of Guangzhou fron the late 19th century to the 1930s. The first reform to affect the traditional religious ecology was the “convert temples to schools” movement, which began in 1898. It was the large Buddhist and Daoist monasteries that were the first targets of this campaign, rather than the more numerous territorial temples. An important reason was that territorial temples were owned and managed by entire local communities, represented by their local elites, rather than by small numbers of socially stigmatized monks and nuns.
    [Show full text]
  • Singapore Airlines Flies
    JOURNALS china A N E T Following in M O the footsteps of China’s ancient P U roving royalty, TOM O’MALLEY E R discovers how the inspection R tours of old helped establish a O O template for travel in the Middle R’ F Kingdom today. S C H I N A A pedestrian bridge over West Lake cuts A a fine silhouette against a backdrop of stormy skies and undulating mountains in Hangzhou. 70 | SILVERKRIS.COM SILVERKRIS.COM | 71 JOURNALS china nlookers in scroll painting. Qianlong sacrifices and generally fine robes line was the sixth emperor of remind the provinces the edge of the the Qing Dynasty, ruling who’s boss. water as the from 1735 to 1796 in what Strictly speaking, a tourist magnificent was considered a golden is defined as one who travels Obarge cuts through the canal. age, where he beefed up for pleasure, but Qianlong In the background I spy grand China’s economy, expanded clearly had plenty of business pagodas and walled gardens its borders, and enhanced to take care of on route. And overhung by native ornamental cultural and intellectual life. yet, both Kangxi and Qianlong scholar trees. Elaborate He’s also, to my mind, China’s commissioned a set of 12 theatrical performances unfold greatest tourist. humongous scrolls – surely on stages along the shore, Qianlong and his the 18th century equivalent and the great Chang Gate in grandfather Kangxi revived of travel photography – to Suzhou, the Venice of the East, an Imperial tradition that recount the story of this stands ready to receive its most had fallen out of favour with ultimate pleasure cruise.
    [Show full text]
  • White Paper Report
    White Paper Report Report ID: 111862 Application Number: HD-51828-14 Project Director: Patrick Manning ([email protected]) Institution: University of Pittsburgh Reporting Period: 7/1/2014-6/30/2015 Report Due: 9/30/2015 Date Submitted: 11/10/2015 “World-Historical Gazetteer” Report type: White Paper Grant Number: HD-51828-14 Title of Project: World Historical Gazetteer Name of Project Directors: Patrick Manning (Pitt) and Ruth Mostern (UC- Merced), Co-PIs Name of grantee institution: University of Pittsburgh Abstract: The project for a World-Historical Gazetteer is a cross-disciplinary collaboration of researchers and developers from various academic and professional institutions that are working towards creating a comprehensive, online gazetteer of world-historical places for the period after 1500 CE. This paper describes the main objectives of the project, outlines several different work plans, and reports on developments from the World-Historical Gazetteer Workshop that took place in September of 2014. During the workshop, participants worked to establish a criteria and standards for a world-historical gazetteer and reported on currently available gazetteer resources. A consensus arose among participants to begin the work of developing a “spine” gazetteer, based on a world-historical atlas, which is to be linked to other gazetteer resources. While the initial development work on the spine has already commenced, additional activities will continue through December of 2015. The product of the start-up project is displayed on the CHIA
    [Show full text]