DOCSLIB.ORG

Copyright © and Moral Rights for This Thesis Are Retained by the Author And/Or Other Copyright

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Copyright © and Moral Rights for This Thesis Are Retained by the Author And/Or Other Copyright Wimpelmann, Torunn (2013) The price of protection: gender, violence and power in Afghanistan. PhD Thesis. SOAS, University of London http://eprints.soas.ac.uk/16802 Copyright © and Moral Rights for this thesis are retained by the author and/or other copyright owners. A copy can be downloaded for personal non‐commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge. This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the copyright holder/s. The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. When referring to this thesis, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given e.g. AUTHOR (year of submission) "Full thesis title", name of the School or Department, PhD Thesis, pagination. The Price of Protection Gender, violence and power in Afghanistan Torunn Wimpelmann Thesis submitted for the degree of PhD in Development Studies March 2013 Department of Development Studies School of Oriental and African Studies University of London Declaration for PhD thesis I have read and understood regulation 17.9 of the Regulations for students of the School of Oriental and African Studies concerning plagiarism. I undertake that all the material presented for examination is my own work and has not been written for me, in whole or in part, by any other person. I also undertake that any quotation or paraphrase from the published or unpublished work of another person has been duly acknowledged in the work which I present for examination. Signed: ____________________________ Date: _________________ Abstract This thesis examines contestations over gender violence as points of entry into an analysis of gender, politics and sovereign power in contemporary Afghanistan. It explores the evolving parameters of what ‘counts’ as violence against women in Afghanistan, articulated in legal frameworks and practices, in public and media debates and in the interventions of political leaders, diplomats and aid workers. The thesis asks whether violence against women has become a governance issue in Afghanistan and what this means for the position of women and for broader relations of power. These questions are investigated through an examination of the origins and fate of a new law on violence against women, a series of controversies over women’s shelters, attempts to bestow recognition on informal justice processes and the trajectories of individual episodes of violence as they travelled through different and sometimes competing legal forums. I show how the outcome of these struggles have the potential to redraw boundaries between government and family domains, and to subordinate women to kinship power, or alternatively, constitute them as independent legal persons. The thesis further analyses negotiations over and interventions into violence against women as revealing of shifting domains and claims of sovereignty, of projects of power and of political technologies. The processes detailed in the thesis illuminate a landscape of plural and competing legal regimes that in specific times and places presided over individual episodes of gender violence The thesis also shows that far from operating as a singular bloc, Western forays in Afghanistan produced multiple and contradictory effects on women’s security and protection. Contents Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................................ 1 Abbreviations ......................................................................................................................................... 2 Introduction ........................................................................................................................................... 4 I. ‘The President is selling the people’s honour’ ............................................................................ 4 II. Situating the thesis ..................................................................................................................... 10 III. Chapters outline ......................................................................................................................... 13 Chapter 1: Gendered violations and sovereign claims ..................................................................... 15 I. Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 15 II. Gendered violations and sovereign power ................................................................................ 16 III. From gender relations to broader fields of power ..................................................................... 19 IV. Governmental assemblages, and their limits ............................................................................. 25 Chapter 2: Research on shifting ground ........................................................................................... 31 I. Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 31 I. Afghanistan during fieldwork: a snap survey of the political landscape ................................... 32 II. The extended case method ........................................................................................................ 39 III. Doing research in Afghanistan: Research trajectories, data access and ethics .......................... 41 Chapter 3: Intrusions, invasions and interventions: Historical lineages of gender, justice and governance in Afghanistan ................................................................................................................. 56 I. Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 56 II. Gendered boundaries and hierarchies ........................................................................................ 56 III. The emergence of a centralized legal system in Afghanistan ................................................... 66 IV. Legal reform after 2001............................................................................................................. 79 IV. International gender activism: post-2001 Afghanistan as a site of international gender expertise ............................................................................................................................................ 85 Chapter 4: ‘Good women have no need for this law’. The fortunes of the EVAW Law .............. 89 I. Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 89 II. The legal framework prior to the EVAW law ........................................................................... 91 III. The trajectory of the EVAW law ............................................................................................... 96 IV. ‘What is the basis for this law?’ Discursive strategies and hierarchies ................................... 101 V. Political ambiguity and discreet lobbying ............................................................................... 113 VI. Conclusions ............................................................................................................................. 119 Chapter 5: Between sanctuary and surveillance: The women’s shelters ..................................... 123 I. Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 123 II. The “run away woman” as a transgressor ............................................................................... 125 III. The Supreme Court directive on “running away” ................................................................... 130 IV. ‘What have been run by NGOs now belongs to the government.’ Attempts to “nationalize” the shelters: ............................................................................................................................................ 133 V. ‘What Happens if We Leave Afghanistan’: Bibi Aisha .......................................................... 135 VI. Nasto Naderi’s campaign against the shelters ......................................................................... 137 VII. Victory for the shelters ........................................................................................................... 140 VIII. Conclusions ........................................................................................................................... 145 Chapter 6: Seeking the “real” Afghanistan: The informal justice agenda ................................. 148 I. Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 148 II. Defining informal justice ......................................................................................................... 150 III. The ‘National Policy on relations between the formal justice system and disputes resolution councils’ (and its discontents) ......................................................................................................... 151 IV. Expert authority and Afghan reality .......................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Report on the 58 Session of the Commission on The
    Report on the 58th Session of the Commission on the Status of Women March 10 – 21 2014 © 2014 PeaceWomen of the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom Permission is granted for non-commercial reproduction, copying, distribution, and transmission of this publication or parts thereof so long a s full credit is given to the coordinating project and organization, editor, and relevant authors; the text is not altered, transformed, or built upon; and for any reuse or distribution, these terms are made clear to others. The PeaceWomen team is very grateful to all of you who represented WILPF during CSW 58 and helped us with the monitoring of a vast variety of Women, Peace and S ecurity related events. Thanks to: Shafferan Sonneveld, Cristina Chahine, Sandra Neuman, Abigail Ruane, Maria Butler, Barbara Trojanowska, Princes s Ayelotan, Dixie Hairston (US Practicum) Jenna Cooper (US Practicum) Alyssa Mounton, US Practicum) and Arielle Stephens (US Practicum). Report author: Sandra Neuman Editors: Abigail Ruane and Shafferan Sonneveld Design and Layout: Shafferan Sonneveld Cover Photo: Cristina Chahine Table of Contents List of Abbreviations 4 1. Introduction 8 2. Outcomes of CSW 58Women 9 3. WILPF at CSW 58 10 4. Background on CSW 58 and the Women, Peace and Security Agenda 12 5. Overview and Summaries from WILPFs Main Events at CSW 58 13 Summaries from WILPFs Main Events at CSW 58 14 Summaries from Women, Peace and Security Related Events at CSW 58 24 6. Useful Links 62 List of Abbreviations ARROW The Asi an-Pacific Resource and Research
    [Show full text]
  • “It Is Not Charity, It Is a Chair of Power” - Moving Beyond Symbolic Representation in Afghanistan’S Transition Politics?
    “It is not Charity, it is a Chair of Power” - Moving Beyond Symbolic Representation in Afghanistan’s Transition Politics? Andrea Fleschenberg Research Study Publication Series “Reviewing Gender Quotas in Afghanistan and Pakistan” 2016 “It is not Charity, it is a Chair of Power”1- Moving Beyond Symbolic Representation in Afghanistan’s Transition Politics? Research Study Publication Series “Reviewing Gender Quotas in Afghanistan and Pakistan” 2016 Andrea Fleschenberg 1 “It is not charity, it is a chair of power and when you are there, you have to get tough with all the vulnerability you face” (interview with MP Farkhunda Zahra Naderi, Kabul, April 2015). The Heinrich Böll Stiftung is a German foundation and part of the Green political movement that has developed worldwide as a response to the traditional politics of socialism, liberalism, and conservatism. Our main tenets are ecology and sustainability, democracy and human rights, self-determination and justice. We place particular emphasis on gender democracy, meaning social emancipation and equal rights for women and men. We are also committed to equal rights for cultural and ethnic minorities. Finally, we promote non-violence and proactive peace policies. To achieve our goals, we seek strategic partnerships with others who share our values. Our namesake, Heinrich Böll, personifies the values we stand for: protection of freedom, civic courage, tolerance, open debate, and the valuation of art and culture as independent spheres of thought and action. For further information on our country programs in Afghanistan and Pakistan please visit our websites: www.af.boell.org www.pk.boell.org Disclaimer: This comparative action research project and its publication series were prepared with the support of the Heinrich Böll Stiftung, Afghanistan office.
    [Show full text]
  • Armanshahr-23-24-En.Pdf (
    A periodical on human rights and civil society Special issue on women 4th Year, Issues 23-24, April 2012 Website: http://armanshahropenasia.wordpress.com/ E-mail: [email protected] Facebook: [email protected] Facebook Armanshahr Publishing: https://www.facebook.com/groups/Armanshahr.Publishing Armanshahr Foundation Armanshahr Foundation is an independent, not for profit citizen organisation based in Kabul and is not affiliated with any economic, political, religious, ethnic, groups or governments. The Foundation’s mission is to create proper forums to ensure citizen social demand for democracy, human rights, justice and rule of law and to create through cultural manifestations and publications a broad constituency of well-in- formed citizens. Armanshahr Foundation also actively promotes reflection and debate both inside Afghanistan, trans-regionally and internationally with the goal of ensuring solidarity, progress and safeguarding peace. This document has been produced with the financial assistance of the European Union. The contents of the document can under no circumstances be regarded as reflecting the position of the European Union. Some of the items and articles that are published in each issue of “Armanshahr” from other sources are intended to inform our readers, but their contents or positions do not necessarily reflect Armanshahr’s positions. Armanshahr, a periodical on human rights and civil society Issues 23-24 (Year IV) – On Women April 2012 Circulation: 20,000 All rights are reserved
    [Show full text]
  • Safeguarding Women's Rights in Afghanistan
    153 Oxfam Briefing Paper 3 October 2011 A place at the table Safeguarding women‟s rights in Afghanistan www.oxfam.org Participants from the Women for Women programme, Afghanistan. © Women for Women International. Women in Afghanistan have achieved real progress in areas such as political participation, the rule of law, and education since 2001, but these hard-won gains remain fragile. With the imminent withdrawal of international forces, there is a risk that the government may sacrifice women’s rights in order to secure a political deal with the Taliban and other armed opposition groups. The government and its international partners must do much more to support Afghan women’s efforts and uphold their rights while ensuring that women have a strong voice in any future negotiations and political settlements. Summary ‘Women want peace but not at the cost of losing our freedom again.’ Noorjahan Akbar, co-founder of Young Women for Change.1 Ten years on from the start of the Western intervention in Afghani- stan, Afghan women are facing an uncertain future. Women have strived for and made important gains since the fall of the Taliban in 2001, including in political participation and access to education, but these gains are fragile and reversible. The precarious situation for Afghan women is set against a backdrop of spreading insecurity across Afghanistan. Civilian casualties are in- creasing, with May 2011 the deadliest month of the war for civilians since 2007.2 As security deteriorates across the country, violence against women is also on the rise. Both the Afghan and US governments are attempting to engage in parallel talks with the Taliban to reach a political solution to the con- flict before international military forces withdraw by the end of 2014.
    [Show full text]
  • The Role of Women and Gender in Conflicts
    SPANISH MINISTRY OF DEFENCE STRATEGIC DOSSIER 157-B SPANISH INSTITUTE FOR STRATEGIC STUDIES (IEEE) GRANADA UNIVERSITY-ARMY TRAINING AND DOCTRINE COMMAND COMBINED CENTRE (MADOC) THE ROLE OF WOMEN AND GENDER IN CONFLICTS June 2012 GENERAL CATALOGUE OF OFFICIAL PUBLICATIONS http://www.publicacionesoficiales.boe.es Publishes: SECRETARÍA GENERAL TÉCNICA www.bibliotecavirtualdefensa.es © Author and Publisher, 2012 NIPO: 083-12-253-3 (on line edition) NIPO: 083-12-252-8 (e-book edition) Publication date: February 2013 ISBN: 978-84-9781-801-8 (e-book edition) The authors are solely responsible for the opinions expresed in the articles in this publication. The exploitation righits of this work are protected by the Spanish Intellectual Property Act. No parts of this publication may be produced, stored or transmitted in any way nor by any means, electronic, mechanical or print, including photo- copies or any other means without prior, express, written consent of the © copyright holders. SPANISH SPANISH INSTITUTE FOR MINISTRY STRATEGIC STUDIES OF DEFENCE Workgroup number 4/2011 THE ROLE OF WOMEN AND GENDER IN CONFLICTS The ideas contained in this publication are the responsibility of their authors, and do not necessarily represent the opinions of the IEEE, which is sponsoring the publication CONTENTS INTRODUCTION Soledad Becerril Bustamante Chapter I EQUALITY AND GENDER. BASIC CONCEPTS FOR APPLICATION IN THE FIELDS OF SECURITY AND DEFENCE M.ª Concepción Pérez Villalobos Nuria Romo Avilés Chapter II INTEGRATION OF THE PERSPECTIVE OF GENDER INTO THE
    [Show full text]
  • A Constitutional Reckoning with the Taliban's Brand of Islamist Politics
    Afghan Institute for Strategic Studies A Constitutional Reckoning with The Taliban’s Brand of Islamist Politics The Hard Path Ahead Peace Studies VIII © 2021 Afghan Institute for Strategic Studies Afghanistan Institute for Strategic Studies (AISS) is an independent research institute, founded on October 2012 with a goal of providing scientific and academic ground for assessment of the strategic issues of Afghanistan in regional and international levels. Afghanistan Institute for Strategic Studies strives to help the society in improvement and development of democracy, security, peace, good governance and other matters through conducting independent researches, translating and publishing books and scientific papers, convention of national and international gatherings and conferences. Disclaimer The analysis provided in this study are solely those of the author and do not reflect viewpoint of AISS. A Constitutional Reckoning with The Taliban’s Brand of Islamist Politics The Hard Path Ahead Author: Haroun Rahimi Publishing No: AISS-P-038-2021 Circulation: 500 Copies Address: Qala-e-9 Borja, Kart-e-Parwan, Kabul, Afghanistan Contact Number: (+93) 202232806 CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGMENT ......................................................................... II EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..................................................................... 1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................. 6 WHAT FRAMEWORKS WOULD THE TALIBAN USE TO ARTICULATE THEIR VIEWS ON THE RELATION BETWEEN THE STATE LAW
    [Show full text]
  • Women and Conflict in Afghanistan
    Women and Conflict in Afghanistan Asia Report N°252 | 14 October 2013 International Crisis Group Headquarters Avenue Louise 149 1050 Brussels, Belgium Tel: +32 2 502 90 38 Fax: +32 2 502 50 38 [email protected] Table of Contents Executive Summary ................................................................................................................... i Recommendations..................................................................................................................... iii I. Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 1 II. Decades of Civil War ........................................................................................................ 2 A. The Anti-Soviet Jihad ................................................................................................ 2 B. The Taliban’s Gender Apartheid ................................................................................ 4 III. Post-2001 Gains ............................................................................................................... 7 A. Constitutional Guarantees and Electoral Rights ....................................................... 7 B. Institutional Equality, Protection and Development ................................................ 9 IV. Two Steps Forward, One Step Back ................................................................................. 13 A. Political Empowerment and Electoral Gains............................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Agreement on Provisional Arrangements in Afghanistan Pending the Re-Establishment of Permanent Government Institutions
    AGREEMENT ON PROVISIONAL ARRANGEMENTS IN AFGHANISTAN PENDING THE RE-ESTABLISHMENT OF PERMANENT GOVERNMENT INSTITUTIONS The participants in the UN Talks on Afghanistan, In the presence of the Special Representative of the Secretary-General for Afghanistan, Determined to end the tragic conflict in Afghanistan and promote national reconciliation, lasting peace, stability and respect for human rights in the country, Reaffirming the independence, national sovereignty and territorial integrity of Afghanistan, Acknowledging the right of the people of Afghanistan to freely determine their own political future in accordance with the principles of Islam, democracy, pluralism and social justice, Expressing their appreciation to the Afghan mujahidin who, over the years, have defended the independence, territorial integrity and national unity of the country and have played a major role in the struggle against terrorism and oppression, and whose sacrifice has now made them both heroes of jihad and champions of peace, stability and reconstruction of their beloved homeland, Afghanistan, Aware that the unstable situation in Afghanistan requires the implementation of emergency interim arrangements and expressing their deep appreciation to His Excellency Professor Burhanuddin Rabbani for his readiness to transfer power to an interim authority which is to be established pursuant to this agreement, Recognizing the need to ensure broad representation in these interim arrangements of all segments of the Afghan population, including groups that have not been
    [Show full text]
  • Women Redefining Democracy for Peace, Justice and Equality Antigua, Guatemala: May !" # !$, $""%
    WOMEN REDEFINING DEMOCRACY FOR PEACE, JUSTICE AND EQUALITY ANTIGUA, GUATEMALA: MAY !" # !$, $""% 1 WOMEN REDEFINING DEMOCRACY FOR PEACE, JUSTICE AND EQUALITY ANTIGUA, GUATEMALA: MAY !" # !$, $""% 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS 4 Bringing Down the Walls - Making Democracy Matter - by Mia MacDonald 38 DAY THREE 8 INTRODUCTION 39 Reflecting Back, Looking Forward - Transitioning from Day Two to Day Three 8 The Context and Moment 39 Panel #4 – Media and Communications as Democratizing Tools for Women 8 The Nobel Women’s Initiative 41 Small Group Discussion – Women Redefining Democratic Participation 9 Conference Aims 43 Panel #5 – New Perspectives and Strategies for the Future: Making Democracy Meaningful to Women, Peace and Justice 10 Agenda 45 Women in Iran - The One Million Signatures Campaign 46 Concluding Panel - Redefining Democracy 47 A New Definition of Democracy 11 DAY ONE 12 Conference Opening and Welcome 14 Imprisoned Laureate: Aung San Suu Kyi and Burma’s Struggle for Democracy 48 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 16 Panel #1: Women and Democracy – The Promises and the Realities 17 Defining Democracy 50 CONFERENCE MEDIA 18 Small Group Discussion 50 Nobel Women’s Initiative Media - Press Release 20 Panel#2 – Women’s Struggles for Democracy from Outside the Institutions of Governance and Power 52 Nobel Women’s Initiative Media - A Sample of Conference ‘Tweets’ 21 Israel and Palestine 53 Participant Reflections - A Collection of Conference Blogs 22 Closing of Day One 53 Defining Democracy from the Bottom Up by Anisha Desai 54 It’s So Hard to Find Obedient Girls These
    [Show full text]
  • Humanitarian and Reconstruction Assistance to Afghanistan, 2001
    A Joint Evaluation Evaluation A Joint A Joint Evaluation Afghanistan was a troubled country in 2001. Not only is Afghanistan one of the poorest HUMANITARIAN 2001-05 AFGHANISTAN, ANDTO RECONSTRUCTION ASSISTANCE countries in the world, but protracted armed confl ict since 1978 had forced 6 million HUMANITARIAN AND out of a population of some 25 million people to fl ee to neighbouring countries, caused massive destruction of infrastructure and paved the way for warlords to rule over large RECONSTRUCTION ASSISTANCE parts of the country. The 2001 11 September attack by Al Qaeda placed Afghanistan at the centre of international politics and provoked the US-led ‘Coalition of the Willing’s attack on 7 October on Al Qaeda bases in Afghanistan in collaboration with a loose alliance of TO AFGHANISTAN, 2001-05 Northern Afghan groups and the subsequent overthrow of the Taliban regime. After the international military operation and up to mid-2004 Afghanistan received close FROM DENMARK, IRELAND, THE NETHERLANDS, SWEDEN to Euro 3.2 billion in total of humanitarian and development aid to rebuild the country. Of this, 25 % - Euro 791 billion came from fi ve bilateral donors: the United Kingdom, AND THE UNITED KINGDOM the Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark and Ireland. In 2004 the fi ve donors decided to commission a joint evaluation of their aid programmes 2001-2005. The evaluation was carried out by a consortium led by Chr. Michelsen Institute, Bergen, Norway, contracted by Danida’s Evaluation Department on behalf of the fi ve donors. The donors’ support to Afghanistan was not just another humanitarian operation. It was a multi-dimensional intervention combining the objectives of development co-operation with broad foreign and domestic policy objectives, where the donors – of whom some had taken an active part in ousting the old regime – also aimed at supporting Afghanistan’s new start through putting into place a new and democratically elected government and market economy.
    [Show full text]
  • International Women of Courage Award Ceremony Recipients
    INTERNAT I ONAL WOMEN ’S DAY International Women of Courage Award Ceremony MARCH 10, 2008 International Women of Courage Award Ceremony HOSTE D BY Under Secretary for Democracy and Global Affairs Paula J. Dobriansky FEATUR I NG The Honorable Condoleezza Rice Secretary of State MON D AY , MARC H 10, 2008 AN IN I T I AT I VE O F T H E Offi CE O F T H E SEN I OR COOR di NATOR F OR INTERNAT I ONAL WOMEN ’S ISSUES INTERNAT I ONAL WOMEN O F COURAGE In celebration of International Women’s Day, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice will present the second annual Award for International Women of Courage to eight women from around the world. This award pays tribute to emerging women leaders and recognizes the courage and leadership shown by each as they struggle for social justice and women’s rights. This is the only award within the Department of State that pays tribute to emerging women leaders worldwide. Today, the Secretary of State will pay tribute to this year’s honorees from Somalia, Paraguay, Pakistan, Kosovo, Fiji, Iraq, Afghanistan, and the Palestinian Authority. They are among over 95 exceptional women nominated by U.S. Embassies worldwide for their extraordinary work in advancing women’s rights. 1 Suraya Pakzad Afghanistan Suraya Pakzad is the founder of Voice of Women, one of a minority of organizations dedicated to helping women in Afghanistan. Voice of Women is based in Herat but has offices in three provinces across the region. Founded in 1998, her organization continued to operate during the Taliban rule, mainly in Kabul, and continues to face tremendous challenges even today.
    [Show full text]
  • The World's 500 Most Influential Muslims, 2021
    PERSONS • OF THE YEAR • The Muslim500 THE WORLD’S 500 MOST INFLUENTIAL MUSLIMS • 2021 • B The Muslim500 THE WORLD’S 500 MOST INFLUENTIAL MUSLIMS • 2021 • i The Muslim 500: The World’s 500 Most Influential Chief Editor: Prof S Abdallah Schleifer Muslims, 2021 Editor: Dr Tarek Elgawhary ISBN: print: 978-9957-635-57-2 Managing Editor: Mr Aftab Ahmed e-book: 978-9957-635-56-5 Editorial Board: Dr Minwer Al-Meheid, Mr Moustafa Jordan National Library Elqabbany, and Ms Zeinab Asfour Deposit No: 2020/10/4503 Researchers: Lamya Al-Khraisha, Moustafa Elqabbany, © 2020 The Royal Islamic Strategic Studies Centre Zeinab Asfour, Noora Chahine, and M AbdulJaleal Nasreddin 20 Sa’ed Bino Road, Dabuq PO BOX 950361 Typeset by: Haji M AbdulJaleal Nasreddin Amman 11195, JORDAN www.rissc.jo All rights reserved. No part of this book may be repro- duced or utilised in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanic, including photocopying or recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without the prior written permission of the publisher. Views expressed in The Muslim 500 do not necessarily reflect those of RISSC or its advisory board. Set in Garamond Premiere Pro Printed in The Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan Calligraphy used throughout the book provided courte- sy of www.FreeIslamicCalligraphy.com Title page Bismilla by Mothana Al-Obaydi MABDA • Contents • INTRODUCTION 1 Persons of the Year - 2021 5 A Selected Surveyof the Muslim World 7 COVID-19 Special Report: Covid-19 Comparing International Policy Effectiveness 25 THE HOUSE OF ISLAM 49 THE
    [Show full text]