DOCSLIB.ORG

ABSTRACT HUNTER, FRANCES STALLINGS. a Synthesis of Three

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
ABSTRACT HUNTER, FRANCES STALLINGS. a Synthesis of Three ABSTRACT HUNTER, FRANCES STALLINGS. A Synthesis of Three Surface Surveys in Central Jordan and an Interpretation of Increased Settlement and Land Use in the Late Byzantine Era. (Under the direction of committee chair Dr. S. Thomas Parker.) The Middle East in the Byzantine period is one of the least analyzed historic periods. Scholars assumed that this was a time of turmoil and unrest when people moved away from the frontiers Rome had previously controlled. New archaeological work is forming contrasting ideas. Evidence from three surface surveys by Burton MacDonald conducted in central and western Jordan, question former ideas of abatement. This thesis will begin with a historical narrative of the ancient Middle East form the Bronze through the Byzantine periods before discussing the surveys. Surface surveys, by nature, are less intensive than excavations because they only analyze surface evidence. These surveys, the Wadi el Hasā Survey, the Southern Ghors and Northeast Άrabah Survey and the Tafila-Busayra Survey produced the first occupational evidence for the contiguous 2, 000 square kilometer area south of Wadi el Hasā. The geology, topography and climate of this area were important factors in land use, so each of these will be discussed relative to ancient land use. Primary sources provide information about this area, its inhabitants, settlement and land use of the region. Diodorus and Strabo are particularly informative. Secondary sources include ancient Middle East scholars Devin Butcher, G. W. Bowersock, Jodi Magness and S Thomas Parker. Methodology will lead discussions of data for each survey. Dates of ceramic artifacts from these surveys establish patterns and shifts in settlement. Parallels for pottery by A.D. Tushingham’s work in Dibon and J.W.Hayes’s Late Roman Pottery provide dating information for these ceramics. Stores of papyri found both in Nessana and Petra will be discussed in conjunction with archaeological evidence. Excavation work in surrounding areas aid in reconstructing Byzantine sedentarization, as central and western Jordan was interconnected with these areas in ancient times. Archaeological excavations by Colt and Urman in the Negev, S. Thomas Parker’s work at Lejjūn and Aila and several excavations in and around Petra will be used to compare settlement and land use in these related areas. Using the three surveys, excavation evidence from the Negev, Petra and nearby areas and support from ancient papyri, this thesis will argue for increased settlement and agricultural land use in this area of Jordan during the Byzantine Era. As a postscript, this thesis will offer thoughts about the implication of the surveys on future archaeological work in central Jordan. A Synthesis of Three Surface Surveys in Jordan and an Interpretation of Increased Settlement and Land Use in the Late Byzantine Era by Frances Stallings Hunter A thesis submitted to the Graduate Faculty of North Carolina State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts History Raleigh, North Carolina August 2010 APPROVED BY: _______________________________ ______________________________ Dr. S. Thomas Parker Dr. Ronald H. Sack Committee Chair ________________________________ Dr. Craig T. Friend DEDICATION For my mother The first historian I ever knew Ann Ware Stallings (1936-1996) ii BIOGRAPHY Frances Stallings Hunter attended Converse College and Auburn University, re- ceiving a Bachelors degree from Auburn in 1982 in Fine Arts. After many years as a stay at home mother, preschool teacher and substitute teacher in the Wake County Pub- lic Schools, she enrolled in the graduate program at North Carolina State University in 2005. While in graduate school, Fran has served as the History Graduate Student Asso- ciation Treasurer for three years. She was inducted into Phi Alpha Theta History Honor Society in 2008 and the National Honors Scholars Society in 2009. She also received the Outstanding Graduate Student in Greek award in 2007. She worked as a teacher assistant to Dr. Mark Sosower teaching Greek and to Dr. S. Thomas Parker, working in the ceramics lab and teaching. Fran is currently a museum educator at Mordecai Histor- ic Park in Raleigh, North Carolina. iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to express my appreciation to my children and husband for patience and understanding these last five years. And especially my husband for his genius with a computer! My professors have been invaluable throughout this process. Dr. Tom Parker for guidance and assistance with all things Roman, Dr. Craig Friend for pushing me to be a better writer, and Dr. Ronald Sack for being the first to encourage me and believe in my ability to succeed in graduate school. The History Department at N C State has been open and helpful in every way and has guided me through the past five years, especially Norene Miller who made sure I got everything done. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES ....................................................................................................... vii LIST OF FIGURES ...................................................................................................... viii LIST OF PHOTOGRAPHS ......................................................................................... xi CHAPTER 1 ................................................................................................................. 1 A. Introduction ................................................................................................ 1 B. History – Intensification and Abatement .................................................... 5 C. Overview of Surveys and Methods ............................................................ 18 I. History of Exploration .................................................................... 18 II. Wadi el Hasā Survey ...................................................................... 22 III. Southern Ghors and Northeast Άrabah Survey .............................. 25 IV. Tafile-Busayra Survey .................................................................... 27 D. Topography, Geography and Climate ........................................................ 33 E. Primary Sources .......................................................................................... 40 F. Secondary Sources ...................................................................................... 44 CHAPTER 2 ................................................................................................................. 47 A. Wadi el Hasā ............................................................................................... 47 I. Methods .......................................................................................... 47 II. Evidence ......................................................................................... 53 a. WHS Central and Eastern Universes .................................. 59 b. WHS Western Universe ..................................................... 62 B. Southern Ghors and Northeast Άrabah ....................................................... 65 I. Methods .......................................................................................... 65 II. Evidence ......................................................................................... 68 C. Tafila-Busayra ............................................................................................ 77 I Methods .......................................................................................... 77 II. Evidence ......................................................................................... 84 v CHAPTER 3 ................................................................................................................. 96 A. Further Research ......................................................................................... 97 I. Pottery ............................................................................................. 97 II. Watermills and Grinding Stones in WHS ...................................... 110 III. Mills and Grinding Stones .............................................................. 116 a. SGNAS ............................................................................... 116 b. TBAS .................................................................................. 118 B. Further Evidence ........................................................................................ 121 I. Negev .............................................................................................. 122 a. Nessana Papyri ................................................................... 122 b. Excavations in the Negev ................................................... 126 II. Petra ................................................................................................ 130 a. Petra Papyri ........................................................................ 130 b. Petra Archaeology .............................................................. 132 III. Limes Arabicus Project .................................................................. 134 IV. Aila ................................................................................................. 135 V. Archaeological Work in the Region after MacDonald ................... 136 C. Synthesis and Conclusion ........................................................................... 138 I. Synthesis of Information ................................................................ 138 II. Future
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Asor Academic Program
    ASOR ACADEMIC PROGRAM **Please note that dates and times are subject to change. Wednesday, November 16 7:00-8:15pm A1 Andrew G. Vaughn (ASOR) Welcome to the 2011 Annual Meeting (5 min.) Timothy P. Harrison (University of Toronto and ASOR President) Introductions (10 min.) Plenary Address Gil J. Stein (The Oriental Institute, University of Chicago), (60 min.) Thursday, November 17 8:20-10:25am A2 Ancient Inscriptions I Theme: The Broad Tableau: Inscriptions of the Pharaonic, Persian, Hellenistic, and Roman Periods Christopher Rollston (Emmanuel School of Religion), Presiding 8:20 Nathanael Andrade (West Virginia University), “Caravans, Euergetism, and Inscriptions: Palmyra’s Engagement with Hellenism” (20 min.) 8:45 Nikolaos Lazaridis (California State University), “Crossing the Egyptian Desert: Epigraphic Work At Kharga Oasis” (20 min.) 9:10 Stephen Pfann (University of the Holy Land), “The Mount Zion Inscribed Stone Cup and Its Context” (20 min.) 9:35 Matthieu Richelle (Vaux-sur-Seine), “New Readings in Tell el-Mazar Ostracon No3” (20 min.) 10:00 David Vanderhooft (Boston College) and Oded Lipschits (Tel Aviv University), “The Yehud Jar Stamp Impressions in the Changing Administration of Persian Period Judah” (20 min.) A3 Archaeology of Cyprus I Theme: This session focuses on current archaeological research in Cyprus from prehistory to the modern period. Erin Walcek Averett (Creighton University), Presiding 8:20 Introduction (5 min.) 8:25 Alan Simmons (University of Nevada), “When Did Cyprus Become a Crossroads: The Evidence for Early Seafaring in the Mediterranean?” (15 min.) 8:45 Vasiliki Koutrafouri (Society of Antiquaries of Scotland and University of Edinburgh), “Narrowing the Gap? The Aceramic and Ceramic Neolithic of Prastio-Mesorotsos, Cyprus” (15 min.) 9:05 Sam Crooks (The University of Melbourne), “What Are These Queer Stones? Baetyls: Aniconism and Ambiguity in Prehistoric Cypriot Cult” (15 min.) 9:25 A.
    [Show full text]
  • ASOR's Committee on Archaeological Policy Tour
    Summer 2005 Volume 55, no. 2 ASOR’s Committee on Archaeological Policy Tour – 2005 one, incorporating a review of previous seasons’ work, pres- Burton MacDonald, CAP Chair ent objectives, and plans for future in-fi eld seasons. During the tour, we were joined by Michèle Daviau, Wilfrid Laurier he 2005 ASOR/CAP tour included visits to Jordan, Israel, University, along with several members of her team, who and Cyprus June 13–26. Participants included Lawrence were preparing for their upcoming season. This provided us TT. Geraty, ASOR President, Douglas R. Clark, ASOR’s with the opportunity not only to meet with Younker, his staff, Executive Director, and the writer and, because virtually all and volunteers, but to chat also with members of the Kh. Al- international travel was covered by projects or individuals, the Mudayna/Wadi ath-Thamad expedition about their upcom- expense to ASOR was minmal. The directors of the Albright ing season. Institute, the American Center of Oriental Research, and the The Tall Jalul team onsite (with Kh. al-Mudayna/Wadi ath-Thamad staff Cyprus American Archaeological Research Institute, namely visitors), hearing the pitch to join ASOR. Photo courtesy of John McVay. Sy Gitin, Pierre Bikai, and Tom Davis, respectively, joined us Other photos courtesy of Douglas Clark, unless indicated otherwise. for segments of the tour. Moreover, Larry G. Herr, Canadian University Col- lege, who was in Jordan as a team member of the “Ayl to Ras an-Naqb Archaeo- logical Survey Project,” participated on the tour’s Jordan segment. Nabil Khairy, Profes- sor in the Department of Archaeology, University of Jordan, Amman, graciously provided tour members use of his Mercedes-Benz for the Jordanian portion of the tour.
    [Show full text]
  • Volume 55, Number 1, Spring
    Spring 2005 Volume 55, no. 1 Global Moments in the Levant our ASOR archaeologists, Bert deVries (Calvin Col- the rise of monotheism during the Late Bronze and Iron Age; lege), Øystein S. LaBianca (Andrews University), the global moments that led to the rise of the Greco-Roman-, FThomas Levy (UCSD) and Bethany Walker (Grand Val- Byzantine-, Islamic- and Modern Capitalist ‘great traditions,’ ley State University) will be joining an international team of and various political developments, for instance the fact that, anthropologists, archaeologists, geographers, historians and from the earliest empire states in Egypt and Mesopotamia, sociologists in a study of “Global Moments in the Levant.” the Levant has been of strategic importance to a long succes- The team of 16 researchers will be headed by Leif Manger, sion of superpowers, starting with the ancient Egyptians and Professor of Anthropology, University of Bergen, Norway, ending with the United States. to study “breakthrough events that change people’s lives A major objective of the collaboration is to advance un- and their futures.” The team was informed in February 2005 derstanding of how global moments alter the lives of local by the Norwegian Research Council that their application groups and communities. This is especially where the con- “Global Moments in the Levant: Towards an Understanding tribution of archaeology will be important, for it provides of a Contact Zone between Peoples, Cultures and States” had the best window on how the daily lives of ordinary men and been approved for funding over the next four years in the women have changed in response to successive global mo- amount of 16 million Norwegian Kroner or ca.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Meeting PROGRAM and Abstract Book
    2 0 0 9 November 18-21, Astor Crowne Plaza Hotel, New Orleans, Louisiana Orleans, New Hotel, Plaza Crowne Astor 18-21, November Annual Meeting Program and Abstract Book Abstract and Program Meeting Annual ASOR AnnuAl meeting new ORleAnS, lOuiSiAnA • nOvembeR 18-21, 2009 ©2009, Rose /AtlantaPhotos.com Please Visit Please details for www.asor.org/am/index.html call 1.404.659.6500 call $159 Single/double and $179 triple/quad $179 and Single/double $159 165 Courtland Street NE, Atlanta GA 30303 30303 GA Atlanta NE, Street Courtland 165 2010 Annual Meeting Annual 2010 Hotel Atlanta Sheraton November 17-20, 2010, 2010, 17-20, November Save the Date! the Save The room block is open—make your reservation now! reservation your open—make is block room The Ask for the “ASOR Annual Meeting” Annual “ASOR the for Ask BECOME AN AMERICAN SCHOOLS OF ORIENTAL RESEARCH CONTRIBUTING MEMBER Founded in 1900, ASOR is the premier learned society that supports and fosters historical and archaeological research in the eastern Mediterranean. Together with its affiliated research centers in Amman, Jerusalem, and Nicosia, ASOR supports more archaeological excavations in the eastern Mediterranean than any other American society. Like most educational, religious, artistic, and cultural institutions, ASOR relies on financial support from lay colleagues and interested professionals to continue its work. Please consider a Contributing Membership—the $125 fee allows you to support the work of ASOR with a tax-deductible gift of $100 and receive a discounted subscription
    [Show full text]
  • Nea, Once and Again
    Fall 2000 Volume 50, Number 3 NEA, ONCE AND AGAIN t seems to be ASOR’s particular cient Near East.” He went on to pledge to understanding of, the peoples and cultures cross to bear to suffer on a periodic continue the tradition of “readability and re- of the Near East from the earliest times … basis a “stock taking” of Near East- liability” established by Wright. by offering educational opportunities in ern Archaeology (formerly Biblical NEA/BA has benefited in the years before Near Eastern history and archaeology to Archaeologist), its goals and its fo- and since from a series of remarkable edi- undergraduates and graduates in North Icus. Founded in 1938 by G. Ernest Wright tors. (My four years working in collabora- American colleges and universities, and for the purpose of providing a reliable ac- tion with David Hopkins [Editor, 1993–1998] through outreach activities to the general count of biblical archaeology to the educated were among the most rewarding of my pro- public” relies largely on NEA. But NEA re- lay public, BA gradually became too special- fessional career.) lies primarily on academics, and academics ized for the audience for which it was in- But twenty-five years after BA’s redesign, (let’s face it) are often ill-equipped to address tended. it is indeed time to take stock. a general audience. Fears of its becoming another BASOR In that time, profound changes have taken So, the question we have to ask ourselves (“Minutes of the Annual Meeting of the Cor- place in the educational curriculum in is whether we are meeting the needs of our poration,” BASOR 209 [1973] 3) led to a re- American schools at all levels.
    [Show full text]
  • Committee on Archaeological Policy 2006 Tour
    Spring/Summer 2006 Volume 56, nos. 1–2 Committee on Archaeological Policy 2006 Tour Burton MacDonald, CAP Chair he American Center of Oriental Research reception on June 6 in honor of Pierre and Patricia Bikai on their Tretirement from the directorship of ACOR and the intro- duction of Barbara Porter and Christopher Tuttle as the new ACOR director and assistant director, respectively, provided me with the opportunity to meet with many of the directors of archaeological projects that are ASOR/CAP affi liated. The reception took place while I was in Jordan carrying out the sec- ond season of “The Ayl to Ras an-Naqb Archaeological Survey, Southern Jordan.” During the reception and the following day I was able to meet with a number of dig directors who were either in the fi eld or working on some aspect of their research while in Jordan. Tom Parker, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, was delighted to show me his just published, two-volume work The Late Bronze Age palace at Khirbat al-Mudayna on the Wadi ath- on “The Limes Arabicus Project,” which involved work at the Thamad. Roman period sites of al-Lajjun, Qasr Bshir, and Da`janiya between 1980 and 1989. He now turns his attention to the them in the fi eld, I was able to see them on June 6 and chat publication of his completed “The Roman `Aqaba Project,” with them about their project. which involved the excavation of the Roman site of Ayla at Martha Joukowsky, Brown University, Providence, RI,was al-`Aqaba in southern Jordan.
    [Show full text]
  • “East of the Jordan” : Territories and Sites of the Hebrew Scriptures / by Burton Macdonald
    “EAST OF THE JORDAN” Territories and Sites of the Hebrew Scriptures ASOR Books Volume 6 Victor Matthews, editor Billie Jean Collins ASOR Director of Publications “EAST OF THE JORDAN” TERRITORIES AND SITES OF THE HEBREW SCRIPTURES by Burton MacDonald American Schools of Oriental Research • Boston, MA “EAST OF THE JORDAN” Territories and Sites of the Hebrew Scriptures Copyright © 2000 The American Schools of Oriental Research Cover illustration: Aerial photograph of Tell Hisban, courtesy of Richard Cleave. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data MacDonald, Burton, 1939- “East of the Jordan” : territories and sites of the Hebrew scriptures / by Burton MacDonald. p. cm. — (ASOR books : v. 6) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-89757-031-6 (alk. paper) 1. Jordan—Antiquities. 2. Excavations (Archaeology)—Jordan. 3. Bible. O.T.—Antiquities. I. Title. II. Series. DS153.3 .M32 2000 933—dc21 00-008888 Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper. Contents List of Figures vi List of Tables vi Abbreviations vii Acknowledgments viii 1 Introduction 1 2Biblical Site Identification: History and Methodology 9 3Natural Environment 21 4 Sodom, Gomorrah, Admah, Zeboiim, Bela (=Zoar)— the “Cities of the Plain”—and Lasha 45 5 Exodus Itineraries: Routes and Related Sites East of the ªArabah, the Dead Sea, and the Jordan 63 6 Settlement of the Israelite Tribes East of the Jordan 101 7 Ammonite Territory and Sites 157 8Moabite Territory and Sites 171 9 Edomite Territory and Sites 185 10 Gilead Territory and Sites 195 Appendix: List of Biblical Site Identifications for Jordan 209 References 213 Indexes 275 v List of Figures Fig.
    [Show full text]