The Influence of Anthropomorphic Spokescharacters on Consumers’ Recycling Intentions
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE INFLUENCE OF ANTHROPOMORPHIC SPOKESCHARACTERS ON CONSUMERS’ RECYCLING INTENTIONS Ritesh Jain MBA (Marketing), BTech (Civil Engineering) Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Philosophy School of Advertising, Marketing, and PR QUT Business School Queensland University of Technology 2021 Keywords Anthropomorphism, Anthropomorphic spokescharacters, Anthropomorphic spokescharacter appeal, Branding, Brand mascots, Brand spokescharacters, Celebrity endorsement, Confirmatory Factor Analysis, Cuteness, Cute appeals, Elaboration Likelihood Model, Endorsement effectiveness, Environmental communication, Environmental marketing, Experiments, Exploratory Factor Analysis, Human celebrities, Human endorsers, Humour, Humorous appeals, MANCOVA, Matchup hypothesis, MTurk study, Nostalgia, Nostalgic appeals, Online study, Past recycling behaviour, Perceived behavioural control, Product involvement, Recycling, Recycling attitude, Recycling intentions, Recycling involvement, Social marketing, Source liking, Source attractiveness, Source expertise, Source relevancy, Source Trustworthiness, Subjective norms, Structural Equation Modelling, Theory of Planned Behaviour. The Influence of anthropomorphic spokescharacters on Consumers’ Recycling Intentions i Abstract Brand spokescharacters are fictional, animated characters, created by marketers as brand symbols at the end of nineteenth century for the promotion of brands. Subsequently they were considered distinct from brand symbols or logos. Originally addressed as trade characters, they appeared on product packaging and were used to give a sort of personality to manufacturers of the brands. Over the years they have acquired a prominent position as a branding element, have been found quite effective in commercial marketing and remain popular among consumers, across age and gender. Given their endorsement effectiveness in commercial marketing and the popularity of using human celebrities in social and environmental marketing, it is startling that these anthropomorphized characters (such as M&M characters, Tony the Tiger and others) have not being used in a social marketing context, especially in environmental communications as endorsers to influence environmental attitudes and behaviours of consumers. Given the risks associated with using human celebrities’ endorsers, environmental marketers should explore using these fictitious characters in their marketing communications. Therefore, the first objective of this study was to explore whether these anthropomorphized brand spokescharacters can be effective endorsers for environmental causes like recycling. Further, past studies have attempted to define human celebrity appeal as well as appeal of animal species used in fundraising campaigns by environmental marketers. However, no study till date has attempted to unpack the anthropomorphized brand spokescharacter appeal, which is surprising since for the last thirty years researchers have addressed and considered these spokescharacters as appealing. Hence, the second objective of this study was to explore the constituents and structure of anthropomorphized spokescharacter appeal. Since these brand spokescharacters have been addressed as likable, cute, humorous, and objects of nostalgia by consumers in different studies, this study proposed these dimensions as constituents of spokescharacter appeal. To achieve both the objectives of this study, a conceptual model along with associated hypotheses were developed by reviewing relevant literature. ii The Influence of anthropomorphic spokescharacters on Consumers’ Recycling Intentions To test the effectiveness of anthropomorphized spokescharacters in environmental communication, an experimental research method was deployed, and data collected online from U.S participants recruited from Amazon’s MTurk was analysed using a two-step procedure. First, MANCOVA was performed to find significant differences in recycling attitudes and intentions across different treatment groups. One-way independent samples MANCOVA with type of condition as factor revealed that as compared to control group, cognitive attitude towards recycling in all seven treatment conditions increased significantly. For affective attitude towards recycling and recycling intentions, differences were not significant between groups. For two-way ANOVA with gender and type of condition as independent factors, interaction effects were observed for cognitive attitude towards recycling, marginal effect for recycling intention and insignificant differences for affective attitude towards recycling. Gender main effect was reported for affective attitude towards recycling. Post that, merged data was analysed through a Structural Equation Modelling technique using SPSS AMOS v26. Results showed that spokescharacter appeal and expertise positively influence affective attitude towards recycling and recycling intentions, mediated through its relevancy and trustworthiness dimensions. Attractiveness was found to be reducing endorsement effectiveness, confirming matchup hypothesis predictions in an environmental marketing context. The model fitted the data well with 50% of the variance in recycling intentions explained. Also, the model better explained the variance in recycling intentions of participants who were less involved with recycling (as against highly involved ones), confirming the predictions of Elaboration Likelihood Model in environmental marketing context using anthropomorphized spokescharacters. Even though not the objective of this study, some empirical evidence was found to suggest that anthropomorphized spokescharacters can be better endorsers than human ones in environmental communication. This study offered seven theoretical contributions to the literature and seven practical implications for environmental marketers. As using anthropomorphized spokescharacters in environmental communication is an emerging area, this study has offered a number of future research directions for social and environmental marketing researchers. The Influence of anthropomorphic spokescharacters on Consumers’ Recycling Intentions iii Table of Contents Keywords..............................................................................................................................i Abstract ...............................................................................................................................ii Table of Contents ................................................................................................................ iv List of Figures ..................................................................................................................... vi List of Tables ..................................................................................................................... vii Statement of Original Authorship ........................................................................................ ix Acknowledgements .............................................................................................................. x Chapter 1: Introduction .................................................................................... 1 1.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................... 1 1.2 Background to the research ........................................................................................ 1 1.3 Justification for the research ....................................................................................... 2 1.4 Research Questions .................................................................................................... 4 1.5 Research Methodology ............................................................................................... 5 1.6 Contribution to the theory and practice ....................................................................... 6 1.7 Organization of the thesis ........................................................................................... 6 Chapter 2: Literature Review......................................................................... 11 2.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................. 11 2.2 Anthropomorphic brand spokescharacters................................................................. 12 2.3 Source appeal of anthropomorphized brand spokescharacters ................................... 28 2.4 Source effectiveness dimensions............................................................................... 47 2.5 Influence of spokescharacter’s appeal on consumer perceptions and recycling intentions ........................................................................................................................... 53 2.6 Mediating Effects of Source Relevancy .................................................................... 55 2.7 2.7 Recycling Attitude and Intentions ....................................................................... 59 2.8 Research Framework and Summary of Hypotheses ................................................... 65 Chapter 3: Research Design ........................................................................... 69 3.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................. 69 3.2 Research Paradigm ................................................................................................... 69