DOCSLIB.ORG

Sedilia in Medieval England

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Sedilia in Medieval England SEDILIA IN MEDIEVAL ENGLAND Cherry Hinton (Cambridgeshire), parish church, sedilia in chancel, 1220s or 30s James Alexander Cameron Submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the History of Art The Courtauld Institute of Art University of London January 2015 ABSTRACT This thesis forms the first monograph on sedilia, the seats for the clergy officiating at the high altar. The focus is on the medieval kingdom of England, as there are an unparalleled number of stone sets built into the walls of its parish churches, often featuring the most impressive sculpture in the building. After a survey of the liturgical and documentary evidence for ecclesiastical seating in Chapter One, Chapter Two gives an overview of the corpus of sedilia in English medieval churches, and establishes a standard ‘classic’ type of three niches, set into the thickness of the south wall by the altar, divided by shafts and surmounted by arches. The origins of this type are then investigated in Chapter Three and attributed to English architectural style and a preference for dado arcading. In Chapter Four, the continuing spread of this type is shown to be dependent on local building practice, and the occasional development into a site of conspicuous display as diagnostic of its recognition as an important fitting by high-ranking patrons. Chapter Five departs from the narrative approach for a close assessment of the more impressive sets, and uses these to investigate the mechanisms of patronage behind sedilia, the significance of their imagery, and signs of their extra-liturgical use in lay confession. Chapter Six examines the decline of sedilia in England in the fifteenth century within the Perpendicular Style, and also attitudes to them just before the Gothic Revival in the nineteenth century. Chapter Seven provides an investigation into parish church staff and whether sedilia can be considered as proof that a high mass with priest, deacon and subdeacon was taking place in the rural parish churches where they often appear, and how the material object relates to historical documentation. TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................... 1 List of Illustrations ....................................................................................................... 3 List of Maps and Charts ............................................................................................. 20 Introduction .............................................................................................................. 21 Chapter One: Liturgical and Documentary Evidence .......................................... 28 Liturgical references............................................................................................... 28 The liturgical significance of the south side of the altar .................................... 33 The modern origin of the term ‘sedilia’ ................................................................. 36 Medieval documentary evidence............................................................................ 39 Cathedrae ministrorum altaris: Documented wooden alternatives to sedilia ... 42 Conclusion to Chapter One .................................................................................... 46 Chapter Two: Introduction to the Corpus of Sedilia in England and Wales ..... 47 Amassing the corpus: the sedilia survey of England and Wales ............................ 47 Assessment of the corpus: the types of sedilia classified ....................................... 49 ‘Classic’ sedilia .................................................................................................. 49 ‘Stepping’ of sedilia seats and the order of seated clergy .............................. 52 The sedile ........................................................................................................... 57 ‘Single-niche’ sedilia ......................................................................................... 60 ‘Drop-sill’ sedilia ............................................................................................... 62 Stone armchairs .................................................................................................. 66 Dating the corpus: Stylistic assessment of ‘C13’, ‘Dec’ and ‘Perp’ ...................... 70 Mapping the corpus: Geographical distribution ..................................................... 74 Location in the church ............................................................................................ 78 Number of seats...................................................................................................... 80 Fittings, polychromy and questions of original appearance................................... 81 Conclusion to Chapter Two ................................................................................... 83 Chapter Three: The Origins of Sedilia................................................................... 84 The apsed east end and synthrona of the first millennium..................................... 84 The square-ended chancel and the first sedilia ...................................................... 89 Early extant examples of sedilia on the south side of English chancels ............ 90 The earliest ‘classic’ sedilia ............................................................................... 95 Conclusion on the functional development .......................................................... 100 The ‘Englishness of English sedilia’: The formal development .......................... 101 Decorative arcading ......................................................................................... 102 The rejection of the apsidal east end ................................................................ 106 Conclusion on the formal development ............................................................... 109 Chapter Four: The Spread and Development of Sedilia .................................... 110 Sedilia in the early thirteenth century: The consolidation of an idea ................... 110 Case studies of parish church regional style ........................................................ 115 South East: Kent and Sussex / Canterbury and Chichester dioceses ............... 116 North East: Northumberland and County Durham / Diocese of Durham ........ 119 South West: Diocese of Salisbury / Wiltshire .................................................. 122 Conclusion on the importance of regional style ............................................... 124 Development of sedilia as a site of display in the second half of the thirteenth century .................................................................................................................. 125 Episcopal patronage of canopied sedilia, and the pointed-trefoil gable........... 132 Conclusion on the late-thirteenth-century development .................................. 135 The sedilia in the Gothic great church ................................................................. 135 Wooden sedilia in aisled choirs........................................................................ 142 Stone sedilia in aisled choirs ............................................................................ 145 Mural sedilia at unaisled high altars in great churches .................................... 151 Conclusion on great-church sedilia .................................................................. 153 Sedilia design in the fourteenth century ............................................................... 153 Chapter Five: The Imagery of Fourteenth-Century Sedilia .............................. 161 The sedilia of Heckington and Hawton ................................................................ 161 Mechanisms of patronage .................................................................................... 164 Association of sitters with imagery: The iconography of hierarchy .................... 170 The Exeter sedilia and statues above seats ....................................................... 173 The Westminster sedilia and figures behind seats ........................................... 176 Stained glass and sedilia................................................................................... 183 Conclusion on the iconography of hierarchy on sedilia ................................... 185 The possible use of sedilia as a site of confession ............................................... 187 The sedilia at Croft-on-Tees and the narrative of absolution ........................... 193 The Dorchester Abbey sedilia and imagery of sin ........................................... 195 The Ripon Minster sedilia and the monstrous gaze ......................................... 200 Conclusion to Chapter Five .................................................................................. 203 Chapter Six: The Decline of Sedilia ...................................................................... 204 Before the decline: the transition from the Decorated to Perpendicular in the second half of the fourteenth century ................................................................... 204 Perpendicular sedilia ............................................................................................ 208 Grand sedilia of the fifteenth century and the relationship to woodwork ............ 210 ‘Classic’ sedilia as an archaism in the fifteenth century ...................................... 217 After the Reformation
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Church Building Terms What Do Narthex and Nave Mean? Our Church Building Terms Explained a Virtual Class Prepared by Charles E.DICKSON,Ph.D
    Welcome to OUR 4th VIRTUAL GSP class. Church Building Terms What Do Narthex and Nave Mean? Our Church Building Terms Explained A Virtual Class Prepared by Charles E.DICKSON,Ph.D. Lord Jesus Christ, may our church be a temple of your presence and a house of prayer. Be always near us when we seek you in this place. Draw us to you, when we come alone and when we come with others, to find comfort and wisdom, to be supported and strengthened, to rejoice and give thanks. May it be here, Lord Christ, that we are made one with you and with one another, so that our lives are sustained and sanctified for your service. Amen. HISTORY OF CHURCH BUILDINGS The Bible's authors never thought of the church as a building. To early Christians the word “church” referred to the act of assembling together rather than to the building itself. As long as the Roman government did not did not recognize and protect Christian places of worship, Christians of the first centuries met in Jewish places of worship, in privately owned houses, at grave sites of saints and loved ones, and even outdoors. In Rome, there are indications that early Christians met in other public spaces such as warehouses or apartment buildings. The domus ecclesiae or house church was a large private house--not just the home of an extended family, its slaves, and employees--but also the household’s place of business. Such a house could accommodate congregations of about 100-150 people. 3rd-century house church in Dura-Europos, in what is now Syria CHURCH BUILDINGS In the second half of the 3rd century, Christians began to construct their first halls for worship (aula ecclesiae).
    [Show full text]
  • The Restoration of Medieval Stained Glass*
    The Restoration of Medieval Stained Glass* Gottfried Frenzel The victim ofits own composition and ofmodem air tiny particles. The particles fall out of each panel: thus pollution, Europe's most radiant art is now threat- the window disintegrates. ln England stained-glass windows are exposed to ened ~'ith destruction. The efforts at preservation heavy smog. Canterbury Cathedral displays the re- depend on knowledge of the glass. sults. The cathedral includes the Trinity chapel and its Light bas long served religion as a :symbol. It has ambulatory , or processional aisle, which incorporates signified creation (" Let there be lighlt" was the first the chapel called the Corona, constructed between 1174 and 1220. ln both chapels some of the stained command of the Creator) as weIl as salvation (John glasshas been attacked. Pits have formed, which have the Evangelist saw the Heavenly Jerusalem illumi- nated as if made " of jasper" and its walls " like clear now perforated the panels, leaving them quite porous, so that acid raiD cao reach the ioDer surface of the glass") The earthly reflections of such visions, glass and eat into the paintwork there. achieved throughout the Middle Ages by means of France is the classic repository of stained glass. A light, were the period' s most brilliant works of art: the single cathedral, the one in Chartres, is decorated with stained glass windows of Romanesque and Gothic more than 2,000 square meters of stained glass from chapels, churches, minsters and cathedrals. For al- the 12th and 13th centuries, the period when the art most a millennium, in the caseof the earliest stained- reachedits peak in France.
    [Show full text]
  • Gothic Beyond Architecture: Manchester’S Collegiate Church
    Gothic beyond Architecture: Manchester’s Collegiate Church My previous posts for Visit Manchester have concentrated exclusively upon buildings. In the medieval period—the time when the Gothic style developed in buildings such as the basilica of Saint-Denis on the outskirts of Paris, Île-de-France (Figs 1–2), under the direction of Abbot Suger (1081–1151)—the style was known as either simply ‘new’, or opus francigenum (literally translates as ‘French work’). The style became known as Gothic in the sixteenth century because certain high-profile figures in the Italian Renaissance railed against the architecture and connected what they perceived to be its crude forms with the Goths that sacked Rome and ‘destroyed’ Classical architecture. During the nineteenth century, critics applied Gothic to more than architecture; they located all types of art under the Gothic label. This broad application of the term wasn’t especially helpful and it is no-longer used. Gothic design, nevertheless, was applied to more than architecture in the medieval period. Applied arts, such as furniture and metalwork, were influenced by, and followed and incorporated the decorative and ornament aspects of Gothic architecture. This post assesses the range of influences that Gothic had upon furniture, in particular by exploring Manchester Cathedral’s woodwork, some of which are the most important examples of surviving medieval woodwork in the North of England. Manchester Cathedral, formerly the Collegiate Church of the City (Fig.3), see here, was ascribed Cathedral status in 1847, and it is grade I listed (Historic England listing number 1218041, see here). It is medieval in foundation, with parts dating to between c.1422 and 1520, however it was restored and rebuilt numerous times in the nineteenth century, and it was notably hit by a shell during WWII; the shell failed to explode.
    [Show full text]
  • A Community of Monks Or Nuns, Ruled by an Abbot Or Abbess. Usually Founded by a Monastic Order
    Abbey - a community of monks or nuns, ruled by an abbot or abbess. Usually founded by a monastic order. Abbeys oftne owe some form of feudal obligation to a lord or higher organization. They are normally self-contained. Abjuration - renunciation, under oath, of heresy to the Christian faith, made by a Christian wishing to be reconciled with the Church. Accidie - term used in ascetical literature for spiritual sloth, boredom, and discouragement. Acolyte - a clerk in minor orders whose particular duty was the service of the altar. Advocate - lay protector and legal representative of a monastery. Advowson - the right of nominating or presenting a clergyman to a vacant living. Agistment - a Church rate, or tithe, charged on pasture land. Aisle - lateral division of the nave or chancel of a church. Alb - a full-length white linen garment, with sleeves and girdle, worn by the celebrant at mass under a chasuble. Almoner - officer of a monastery entrusted with dispensing alms to the poor and sick. Almonry - place from which alms were dispensed to the poor. Almuce - large cape, often with attached hood, of cloth turned down over the shoulders and lined with fur. Doctors of Divinity and canons wore it lined with gray fur. Cape was edged with little Ambulatory - aisle leading round an apse, usually encircling the choir of a church. Amice - a square of white linen, folded diagonally, worn by the celebrant priest, on the head or about the neck and shoulders. Anathema - condemnation of heretics, similar to major excommunication. It inflicts the penalty of complete exclusion from Christian society.
    [Show full text]
  • Aspects of the Architectural History of Kirkwall Cathedral Malcolm Thurlby*
    Proc Antiqc So Scot, (1997)7 12 , 855-8 Aspects of the architectural history of Kirkwall Cathedral Malcolm Thurlby* ABSTRACT This paper considers intendedthe Romanesque formthe of Kirkwallof eastend Cathedraland presents further evidence failurethe Romanesque for ofthe crossing, investigates exactthe natureof its rebuilding and that of select areas of the adjacent transepts, nave and choir. The extension of the eastern arm is examined with particular attention to the lavish main arcades and the form of the great east window. Their place medievalin architecture Britainin exploredis progressiveand and conservative elements building ofthe evaluatedare context building. the ofthe in use ofthe INTRODUCTION sequence Th f constructioeo t Magnus'S f o n s Cathedra t Kirkwalla l , Orkney comples i , d xan unusual. The basic chronology was established by MacGibbon & Ross (1896, 259-92) and the accoune Orkneth n i ty Inventory e Royath f o l Commissio e Ancienth d Historican o an nt l Monuments of Scotland (RCAHMS 1946,113-25)(illus 1 & 2). The Romanesque cathedral was begun by Earl Rognvald in 1137. Construction moved slowly westwards into the nave before the crossing was rebuilt in the Transitional style and at the same time modifications were made to the transepts includin erectioe gpresene th th f no t square eastern chapels. Shortly after thi sstara t wa sextensioe madth eastere n eo th befor f m no n ar e returnin nave e worgo t th t thi n .A k o s stage no reason was given for the remodelling of the crossing and transepts in the late 12th century.
    [Show full text]
  • North Norfolk District Council (Alby
    DEFINITIVE STATEMENT OF PUBLIC RIGHTS OF WAY NORTH NORFOLK DISTRICT VOLUME I PARISH OF ALBY WITH THWAITE Footpath No. 1 (Middle Hill to Aldborough Mill). Starts from Middle Hill and runs north westwards to Aldborough Hill at parish boundary where it joins Footpath No. 12 of Aldborough. Footpath No. 2 (Alby Hill to All Saints' Church). Starts from Alby Hill and runs southwards to enter road opposite All Saints' Church. Footpath No. 3 (Dovehouse Lane to Footpath 13). Starts from Alby Hill and runs northwards, then turning eastwards, crosses Footpath No. 5 then again northwards, and continuing north-eastwards to field gate. Path continues from field gate in a south- easterly direction crossing the end Footpath No. 4 and U14440 continuing until it meets Footpath No.13 at TG 20567/34065. Footpath No. 4 (Park Farm to Sunday School). Starts from Park Farm and runs south westwards to Footpath No. 3 and U14440. Footpath No. 5 (Pack Lane). Starts from the C288 at TG 20237/33581 going in a northerly direction parallel and to the eastern boundary of the cemetery for a distance of approximately 11 metres to TG 20236/33589. Continuing in a westerly direction following the existing path for approximately 34 metres to TG 20201/33589 at the western boundary of the cemetery. Continuing in a generally northerly direction parallel to the western boundary of the cemetery for approximately 23 metres to the field boundary at TG 20206/33611. Continuing in a westerly direction parallel to and to the northern side of the field boundary for a distance of approximately 153 metres to exit onto the U440 road at TG 20054/33633.
    [Show full text]
  • Draft Site Allocations & Development Management Plan
    Braintree District Council Draft Site Allocations and Development Management Policies Plan Sustainability Appraisal and Strategic Environmental Assessment Environmental Report – Non Technical Summary January 2013 Environmental Report Non-Technical Summary January 2013 Place Services at Essex County Council Environmental Report Non-Technical Summary January 2013 Contents 1 Introduction and Methodology ........................................................................................... 1 1.1 Background ......................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 The Draft Site Allocations and Development Management Plan ........................................ 1 1.3 Sustainability Appraisal and Strategic Environmental Assessment .................................... 1 1.4 Progress to Date ................................................................................................................. 2 1.5 Methodology........................................................................................................................ 3 1.6 The Aim and Structure of this Report .................................................................................. 3 2 Sustainability Context, Baseline and Objectives.............................................................. 4 2.1 Introduction.......................................................................................................................... 4 2.2 Plans & Programmes .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Gothic Revival Character of Ecclesiastical Stained Glass in Britain
    Folia Historiae Artium Seria Nowa, t. 17: 2019 / PL ISSN 0071-6723 MARTIN CRAMPIN University of Wales THE GOTHIC REVIVAL CHARACTER OF ECCLESIASTICAL STAINED GLASS IN BRITAIN At the outset of the nineteenth century, commissions for (1637), which has caused some confusion over the subject new pictorial windows for cathedrals, churches and sec- of the window [Fig. 1].3 ular settings in Britain were few and were usually char- The scene at Shrewsbury is painted on rectangular acterised by the practice of painting on glass in enamels. sheets of glass, although the large window is arched and Skilful use of the technique made it possible to achieve an its framework is subdivided into lancets. The shape of the effect that was similar to oil painting, and had dispensed window demonstrates the influence of the Gothic Revival with the need for leading coloured glass together in the for the design of the new Church of St Alkmund, which medieval manner. In the eighteenth century, exponents was a Georgian building of 1793–1795 built to replace the of the technique included William Price, William Peckitt, medieval church that had been pulled down. The Gothic Thomas Jervais and Francis Eginton, and although the ex- Revival was well underway in Britain by the second half quisite painterly qualities of the best of their windows are of the eighteenth century, particularly among aristocratic sometimes exceptional, their reputation was tarnished for patrons who built and re-fashioned their country homes many years following the rejection of the style in Britain with Gothic features, complete with furniture and stained during the mid-nineteenth century.1 glass inspired by the Middle Ages.
    [Show full text]
  • St. Paul's Church, Scotforth
    St. Paul’s Church, Scotforth Contents Summary 2 Our Vision 3 Who Is God Calling? 3 The Parish and Wider Community 4 Church Organization 7 The Church Community 8 Together we are stronger 10 Our Buildings 11 The Church 12 The Hala Centre 13 The Parish Hall 14 The Vicarage 15 The Church Finances 16 Our Schools 17 Our Links into the Wider Community 20 1 Summary St Paul’s Church Scotforth is a vibrant and accepting community in Lancaster. The church building is a landmark on the A6 south of the city centre, and the vicarage is adjacent in its own private grounds. Living here has many attractive features. We have our own outstanding C of E primary school nearby with which we have strong links. And very close to the parish we also find outstanding secondary schools, Ripley C of E academy and two top-rated grammar schools. In addition Lancaster’s two universities bring lively people and facilities to the area. Traveling to and from Scotforth has many possibilities. We rapidly connect to the M6 and to the west coast main train line. Our proximity to beautiful countryside keeps many residents happy to remain. We are close to the Lake District, the Yorkshire Dales, Bowland forest, Morecambe Bay, to mention just a few such attractions. Our Church is a welcoming and friendly place. Our central churchmanship is consistent with the lack of a central aisle in our unusual “pot” church building! Our regular services (BCP or traditional, in church or in the Hala Centre) use the Bible lectionary to encourage understanding and action, but we also are keen to develop innovative forms of worship.
    [Show full text]
  • The Great Houses & Estates of Brecknockshire
    BRECKNOCK HISTORY FESTIVAL SEPTEMBER & OCTOBER 2017 The Great Houses & Estates of Brecknockshire A range of events across the historic county of Breconshire organised by members of the Brecknock History Forum. Events are being held at the following locations: Brecon Hay on Wye Llandew Llangynidr Llanhamlach Penpont Treholford Brecknock History Forum An informal gathering of groups interested in local and family history across Breconshire. For more information please contact Elaine Starling (01874 711484 or [email protected] Some events are part of OPEN DOORS which celebrates the architecture and heritage of Wales. For a full list of the events being organised for OPEN DOORS across the whole of Wales in September please see the Cadw website. Cover Illustration: Robert Johnson, Survey of the manors of Crickhowell and Tretower, 1587 (National Library of Wales, Badminton Estate Maps, Volume 3, f. 68v) This brochure is kindly sponsored by the Usk Valley Trust ‘JUSTICE AND JOY’ BRECONSHIRE ESTATES FROM THE PERSPECTIVES OF LANDLORD AND TENANT Saturday, 9 September 2017 9.30 am - 4.00 pm The Stables Conference Centre, Penpont, Brecon, LD3 8EU Cost: £10 (£8 Brecknock Society Members) The title of the conference comes from the statement by a 19th Century tenant that paying the rent was an act of justice but securing the freehold was an act of joy. No doubt landlords also have their experiences of justice and joy! Refreshments are not included but tea and coffee can be purchased and a light lunch (cost around £8) will also be available. Please let us know when registering (or by 4 September) if you require lunch.
    [Show full text]
  • BELCHAMP ST PAUL and BELCHAMP OTTEN PARISH COUNCIL Minutes of the Meeting Held on Tuesday 20 October 2020 at 7.30Pm Using the Zoom Online Platform
    BELCHAMP ST PAUL AND BELCHAMP OTTEN PARISH COUNCIL Minutes of the meeting held on Tuesday 20 October 2020 at 7.30pm using the Zoom online platform Present: Councillors David McKee (Chairman), Harvey Bamford, Robin Lock, Sarah Mardon, Tony Money, Stephen Nice, Jill West and Dave Winslow plus District Councillor Iona Parker (joined for Item 2357) and County Councillor David Finch (left after Item 2351.1). In attendance: Diane Smith (Clerk). 2347. Apologies for Absence and Declarations of Interest Apologies had been received from Councillors Scott Bridge, Norman East and David Middleditch. There were no Declarations of Interest. 2348. Public Forum - No members of the public were present 2349. Confirmation of the Minutes of the meeting on 1 September 2020 The Minutes were approved and would be signed by the Chairman at the next meeting held in person. 2350. Matters arising from the September PC meeting 1. Belchamp Otten Community Woodland project (Item 2332.1) – Former Councillor Mark Skellett had confirmed that all three landowners approached at Belchamp Otten had declined to take part in this project. The PC were not in a position to purchase land for the project, because of their limited resources and they also noted potential problems with public liability if residents used equipment to prepare and maintain such a site. Although supportive of the idea, the Council therefore concluded that this project could not be taken forward at this time. They wished to record their thanks to Mark Skellett for his work on this project. 2. ECC Salt Bag Partnership for 2020 (Item 2334.3) – Members wished to thank John Clarke for agreeing to store the salt bags at his property.
    [Show full text]
  • New Season of Bradford Cathedral Coffee Concerts Begins with Baritone Singer James Gaughan
    Date: Thursday 9th January 2020 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE PRESS RELEASE New season of Bradford Cathedral Coffee Concerts begins with baritone singer James Gaughan The monthly Coffee Concerts held at Bradford Cathedral return on Tuesday 14th January when baritone singer James Gaughan performs a programme of music at 11am. Entry is free and refreshments are available from 10:30am. James Gaughan is an experienced soloist specialising in the song and concert repertoire. Based in York, he studies at the De Costa Academy of Singing with Michael De Costa. James gives lunchtime recitals throughout the year. Past performances include at Southwell Minster; Derby, Lincoln, 1 HOSPITALITY. FAITHFULNESS. WHOLENESS. [email protected] Bradford Cathedral, Stott Hill, Bradford, BD1 4EH www.bradfordcathedral.org T: 01274 777720 Sheffield and Wakefield Cathedrals; Emanuel United Reformed Church, Cambridge; Christ Church Harrogate; Hexham Abbey; Great Malvern Priory and others. He also performs regularly as a soloist with choirs and choral societies. Past performances include of Elijah (Mendelssohn); Stabat Mater (Astorga); Cantata 140 (Bach); Ein Deutsches Requiem (Brahms); Requiem (Fauré); Israel in Egypt (Handel); Paukenmesse (Haydn) and Messiah (Handel). James Gaughan: “The programme I’ve prepared is based around the poets, rather than around the composers. I think it’s become quite normal these days to have the historical concerts, where you go from composer to composer and knit them closely together. “What I’ve tried to do with this set-up is to place little sets from different periods of poetry, which means I can have quite a varied set of three songs which could theoretically be from three different centuries which gives a lot of variety for the audience, but still have some coherent link to it.” The monthly Coffee Concert programme continue with saxophonist Rob Burton in February, pianist Jill Crossland in March and Violin and Piano duo James and Alex Woodrow in April.
    [Show full text]