The Bulletin Thank Our Executive Director Mariana Whitmer for the Time and Energy She of the S OCIETY for a MERICAN M USIC Put In
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The launching of a new journal came about only through the hard work of many people in the Society. I especially want to thank Susan Key, who headed the Journals Concerns Committee and who has invested an extraordinary amount of work in this issue. I also want to The Bulletin thank our Executive Director Mariana Whitmer for the time and energy she put in. Many members of the Journals OF THE S OCIETY FOR A MERICAN M USIC Concerns Committee, Carol Oja, Judith FOUNDED IN HONOR OF O SCAR G . T. S ONNECK Tick, George Keck, and Michael Pisani, also deserve special thanks – Carol and Vol. XXXII, No. 3 Fall 2006 Judith, in particular, as they took the lead in assembling the massive docu- ment that went before the Cambridge FROM THE PRESIDENT: Press Syndicate. The current editor, Ellie NEW JOURNAL FOR SAM Hisama, and the previous editor, David Nicholls, also contributed considerably. Beginning in 2007 our official journal has never offered us any royalties or profit Ellie deserves special kudos, not only will be the Journal of the Society for sharing on institutional members, which for all of her input, which only someone American Music (JSAM). We are delight- is a significant sum. That, we discovered, in the editor’s position could supply, but ed to have Cambridge University Press is unique for society journals. When we because she has been right in the middle as a publishing partner, and to have the indicated we were not renewing the cur- of the transition and has handled that resources of one of the most prestigious rent contract Illinois chose not to continue with aplomb and cool diplomacy. Finally presses in academia fully supporting it. further discussion. Rather than litigate the I want to thank James Mercer, an attor- With Cambridge, we can expect a greater title American Music, whose ownership is ney who, at the invitation of Susan Key, international presence at a time when the ambiguous in the contract, we chose to offered his services to us pro bono. Jim entire world is becoming interested in start afresh with a new press and a new deserves a special award for all the work American music; use of advanced digi- title that announces to the world who we this entailed. tal technology in both distribution and are. Now that we have our new journal, support of the journal – something that Our society is grateful for the early its future depends very much on its con- promises to become even more signifi- support University of Illinois Press gave, tent. The scholarly world as well as many cant as the world moves further into the when Sonneck was a new, fledgling soci- libraries will be looking at it closely to digital age; and a financial arrangement ety and the journal was only a vision for see just how it measures up. I would like that will help put our society on even our members who believed that American to encourage the entire society to support better footing. JSAM has the potential to music needed a stronger voice in the it, not only through your membership but become one of the premier journals in the scholarly community. Much has changed especially through your scholarly contri- field of music. since then, not the least the exponential butions. I know that Ellie has many ideas We did not make this move lightly. growth of American music as an area of and plans, but the quality cannot be better Rumors are rampant and the record needs scholarly investigation. 24 years ago there than the content she receives. I especially to be set straight. For 24 years SAM has was only a handful of scholars interested want to encourage senior scholars, as well published American Music as its offi- in the field, papers at conferences such as younger scholars, to submit material. cial journal with University of Illinois as the national meeting of the American In many ways the future depends on that. Press. I appointed the Journals Concerns Musicological Society were few and far Please join me in making JSAM an Committee because we have had serious between, and in many institutions stu- outstanding voice of our society. editorial problems with UIP for at least dents were actively discouraged from – Michael Broyles the past ten years. In attempting to look pursuing dissertations in American music. into this the committee met with hostility Now the musical landscape is quite dif- FAQs on SAM’s New Journal and resistance, and in some cases requests ferent. The study of American music for information were ignored or rejected. thrives, and has a central place in many – Ellie Hisama In addition SAM has recently run a small curricula. Composers, performers, and Editor, Journal of the Society for operating deficit, mostly because of the scholars together have demonstrated the American Music cost of the journal. Our contract was due richness and diversity of American musi- for renewal and prudence dictated that we cal culture, the foundation upon which all What is your background in American do some comparison shopping. We dis- scholarly investigation is built. The field music studies? covered six other presses that were eager of musicology itself has engaged all types I hold a Ph.D. in music theory from the to offer us much better terms, both finan- of music with a vigor inconceivable 25 Graduate Center of the City University cially and editorially. For instance UIP years ago. continued on page 55 STANDPOINTS Imagining an Ideal Graduate Program in American Music – The SAM Student Forum Editor’s Note: “Standpoint” appears in every fall issue of the Bulletin. It is meant to provoke discussion, of jazz and other popular musics; and reflection, and even controversy. Please respond with a letter to the editor or short essay; all responses the increasing frequency of advertised will be printed in a “Counterpoint” section of the winter Bulletin. Deadline is 17 December (when most of us are finishing semesters), so please consider sending your response early! And if you are interested academic positions for specialists in in writing a future Standoint, or have an idea for a topic, please let me know. It is hoped that this series American music. Reflecting on the grow- will engender discussions that we can continue at annual meetings and among ourselves, and that it will ing presence of American music stud- broaden our understanding of what we do – collectively and individually. ies in the academy, Cockrell exclaims, – Sandra Graham, Bulletin Editor “American Music as a subject worthy of [email protected] interest, study, and career planning has arrived!” (p. 277). Introduction American music – programs that will pre- But, even with all of this growth, pare the next generation of Americanists This installment of “Standpoint” has been Cockrell proposes that the development to take the field beyond what we can envi- renamed “Standpoints,” in the plural, of American music studies as an academic sion today. since it is the result of an ongoing col- discipline cannot yet be declared a com- – Ryan Raul Bañagale laborative effort by members of the SAM plete success, noting that “the fact that the Harvard University Student Forum. It is not an end result, one last step toward traditional discipline- hood is as yet untaken – the development but rather a launching point to consider I. Background the topic at hand. The study of American of doctoral programs – is of a magnitude music stands at a crossroads in imagining The Summer 2004 issue of American of significance not to be underesti- new paradigms for graduate programs Music presented the proceedings of a mated… Without Ph.D. programs of that transcend conventional boundaries panel held at the 2002 conference of standing, fields of scholarly interest are and incorporate interdisciplinary work the International Association of Music subjects; with them, they are disciplines” both within and beyond the academy. Libraries, Archives, and Documentation (p. 277). Taking Cockrell’s observation as The issues are manifold and, as observed Centres (IAML) entitled “Disciplining its starting point, the Society’s Student during our standing-room-only session at American Music: Issues Affecting Forum organized a panel discussion for the Chicago conference in March, highly Scholars, Teachers.” As part of that panel, the 2006 SAM/CBMR conference in contentious. Clearly the subject merits Dale Cockrell presented a position paper Chicago entitled “Imagining an Ideal further discussion. entitled “Can American Music Develop a Graduate Program in American Music” Just as the SAM History Project Method?” in which he identifies “seven with the primary goal of continuing the seeks to understand better how the study gestational stages that lead from general- discussion initiated by Cockrell and the of American music became institutional- interest topic or subject to fully developed other scholars who participated in the ized and validated through the work of scholarly discipline” (p. 273). These are: 2002 IAML panel. Furthermore, this the Society’s founding members, our 1) subject definition, 2) methodology panel sought to integrate the next gen- panel and this essay strive to gauge the development and expression, 3) scholarly eration of American music scholars into progress of American music studies and society formation, 4) scholarly publica- a discussion already taking place among to explore possible routes for its contin- tions, 5) curriculum development, 6) spe- more established scholars. These young ued development. In order to contemplate cialist faculty, and 7) doctoral programs. scholars will inevitably shape the future the “ideal,” we must first establish what Cockrell explains that, by his estimation, development of American music studies we have in the present. Following a brief all but one of these gestational stages as a discipline.