Volume 5: the Fight for the Continuity of the Fourth International
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TROTSKYISM VERSUS REVISIONISM A DOCUMENTARY HISTORY VOLUME FIVE The fight for the continuity of the Fourth International $5 .95 TROTSKYISM VERSUS REVISIONISM TROTSKYISM VERSUS REVISIONISM A DOCUMENTARY HISTORY edited by C. Slaughter VOLUME FIVE The fight for the continuity of the Fourth International NEW PARK PUBLICATIONS Published by New Park Publications Ltd., 186a Oapham High Street, London SW4 7UG 1975 Set up, Printed and Bound by Trade Union Labour Distributed in the United States by: Labor Publications Inc., 135 West 14 Street, New York, New York 10011 ISBN 0 902030 72 8 Printed in Great Britain by Plough Press Ltd.(TU) r/o 180 Oapham High Street, London SW4 7UG Contents FOREWORD CHAPTER ONE: THE FOURTH INTERNATIONAL LIVES Document 1 Resolution of the seventh annual conference of the Sociaist Labour League, June 7,1965 Document 2 Preiminary record of the Third World Conference of the International Committee, April 4-8,1966 5 Document 3 Resolution of the Third World Conference, April 8,1966 8 CHAPTER TWO: THE THIRD CONFERENCE OF THE IC IN STRUGGLE AGAINST REVISIONISM Document 4 Report of the commission on rebuilding the Fourth International and the tasks of the IC, April 8,1966 30 Document 5 Resolution of the American Commission, April 8,1966 34 Document 6 Statement of the IC on he Robertson group (USA), April 9, 1966 36 Document 7 Manifesto of the International Committee, April 1966 40 Document 8 Submissions to the Third Conference from Voix Ouvrhra, March 8 and 22,1966 64 Document 9 Declaration of the Union Communiste InternatJonalste to an OCI meeting, March 20,1966 75 CHAPTER THREE: THE LIQUIDATIONS THEORIES OF THE OCI Document 10 Record of work of the IC since the Third Conference, May 1967 80 Document 11 Statement by the OCI, May 1967 84 Document 12 Reply to the OCI by the Central Committee of the SLL, June 19,1967 107 CHAPTER FOUR: THE STRUGGLE IN THE INTERNATIONAL COMMITTEE Document 13 Notes by Cliff Slaughter of the IC meeting of June 17-18,1967 134 Document 14 Notes for proposed speech by Dany Sylveire to Revokes National Youth Assembly, June 24, 1967 140 Document 15 Letter from the SLL to the OCI, June 27,1967 142 Document 16 The OCI announces more differences with the SLL, August 1967 144 Document 17 Minutes of the International Committee meeting, September 30-October 1,1967 152 Document 18a SLL statement in defence of the OCI, June 22, 1968 155 18b Declaration by the International Committee, June 25,1968 157 18c Statement on the OCI by the Newsletter Editorial Board, June 25,1968 160 CHAPTER FIVE: THE OCI BLOCS WITH THE CENTRISTS Document 19 The Rebutting of the Fourth International In Latin America is underway, by Marc-EtJenne Laurent, May 1971 166 Document 20 Resolution before the Essen Youth Rally, July 1971 184 Document 21 Young Sociaists amendment to the Essen Resolution, July 1971 194 Document 22 Letter from the Essen Liaison Committee to the Young Sociaists National Committee, November 1971 195 Document 23 Extracts from the discussion of the Essen Liaison Committee, November 5-6,1971 198 GLOSSARY OF NAMES AND ORGANIZATIONS 201 INDEX 204 Note on sources The documents published in these volumes have been collected from the journals, internal bulletins and correspondence of the Trotskyist movement over the period since 1951. The series is designed to provide the basic documentation of the fight within the Fourth Inter national during that time. Editing of the text has been kept to a minimum: footnotes and bracketed explanatory notes have been added only for essential reference. In all other respects the documents have been reproduced as they appear in the sources indicated below. Each volume has a foreword introducing the reader to the main developments covered in it, with a glossary of names and an index provided as additional guides to the documents. The sources for the documents used in this volume are as follows: 1. Original document before the 7th Annual Conference of the Socialist Labour League 2. Official Record of the Third World Conference of the Interna tional Committee 3. 4, 5, 6, 7. Fourth International, Vol.3, No. 3, August 1966 8. Translated from Voix Ouvriere, March 8 and 22, 1966 9. Translated from a verbatim account taken at the OCI meeting of March 20, 1966 10. Original document before the 9th Annual Conference of the Socialist Labour League 11,12. Pre-Conference discussion Bulletins for the 9th Annual Con ference of the Socialist Labour League 13, 14, IS. Internal Bulletin of the Socialist Labour League 16. Translated iromStudies and Documents, Vol. 2, No. 8(b), August 1967 17. Minutes of the International Committee 18a. The Newsletter, June 22, 1968 18b. The Newsletter, June 25, 1968 18c. The Newsletter, June 25, 1968 19. Translated for this volume from La Correspondance Internationale ('Bulletin du Comite International pour la reconstruction de la IV Internationale'), No. 1 20. Translated from the original draft of the Resolution before the Essen Rally 21. As quoted in the statement of the International Committee, October 24, 1971 22,23. Translated for this volume from correspondence received by the Young Socialists, November 1971 Foreword After 18 years membership of the International Committee of the Fourth International, the French Organization Communiste Inter- nationaliste (OCI) in 1971 split with the majority of this Committee. At that time, the OCI leaders claimed to be the true representatives of the continuity of the struggle against revisionism and the building of the Fourth International carried forward since 1953 by the Interna tional Committee (see the companion volumes I-IV of this series). By 1974, however, the OCI was publicly on record as having commenced formal discussions at the level of leadership, with the so-called 'United Secretariat', i.e. the revisionist political organiza tion carried on by Pablo after the split of 1953. Present at the negotia tions were Pierre Frank and Livio Maitan, among the most prominent and right-wing liquidationist leaders of the Pabloite revisionists ever since 1953. The talks were arranged and attended, by leaders of the Socialist Workers' Party of the United States, who had been working with the OCI to this end for over a year. (Jntercontinental Press, January 1975: see appendix to Volume VI of this series). At first sight, these events represent a remarkable about-face from the position of the OCI in the 1950s and 1960s. When it suited them, the OCI leaders would draw attention to the fact that they were the first to clash, politically and organizationally, with Pablo, Frank and Mandel (Germain). When the SWP, founder-member of the IC, participated at the Pabloite 'reunification' of 1963 (See Volume IV), die OCI supported (though making little or not independent con tribution to the struggle) every step in the struggle against liquidationism. Indeed, the CXI affected a very intransigent stance. For example when the SLL (predecessor of the Workers Revolutio nary Party) proposed a 'parity committee' to engage the SWP and the XI XII THE FIGHT FOR CONTINUITY OF THE FI Pabloites in open political discussion, they first opposed this and then accepted it very reluctantly. Yet now it is the same leadership of the OCI who appears in talks with the Pabloite revisionists, and who are commended by the latter for their 'sincerity' and 'seriousness'. For its part, the IC majority was in no doubt that the questions on which the OCI split from the IC in 1971 were just as fundamental as those which had been at the centre of the struggle in 1953 and 1963. There could be no compromise once the OCI had persisted in a basic revision of Marxism (the rejection of dialectical materialism as the theory of knowledge of Marxism) to the point of publicly voting with enemies of Trotskyism against the IC, at the Essen Youth Rally of July 1971. (See Chapter Five below, and statement of the IC of the FI (Majority) October 24, 1971). The act of splitting in 1971, and the political basis on which it was carried out, were in all essentials a capitulation to the same Pabloite revisionism to which the OCI for mally returned in 1974. It is now time to make available in one place not only all the already public documents of the 1971 split and the work of the IC in the years leading up to it, but also certain internal reports and communications which make absolutely clear the principled struggle of the IC to answer and clarify the growing revisionist tendencies in the OCI between 1967 and 1971. Whilst the IC took up in detail the distortions of the OCI leadership and the questions of Bolshevik leadership and internationalism and then, in 1970, more and more openly on the basic philosophical issues, it also fought in complete solidarity with the OCI when De Gaulle's government declared it illegal following the May-June General Strike in 1968. The Socialist Labour League, for example, led a broad public campaign in the British labour movement against the repression, and considerable funds were raised to help the OCI (See Document 18 below). When the SWP took the road back to Pabloism in 1957-63, they attempted to justify this capitulation on the grounds that the Pabloites were returning to the principled positions on the main political questions. This manoeuvre failed when it was attempted on the basis of the Pabloites' reaction to the Hungarian Revolution of 1956, was eventually carried through on the bandwagon of the Cuban Revolution and the supposedly new, independent, and 'naturally Marxist' leadership of Castro and Castroism. On this entirely spurious basis, the 'reunification' was carried through with an agreement not ot discuss at all the fundamental issues which had necessitated the split of 1953.