Warfare by Another Name: Russian Computer Hacking Against the United States and the West Jumada I, 1438 - February 2017

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Warfare by Another Name: Russian Computer Hacking Against the United States and the West Jumada I, 1438 - February 2017 20 Dirasat Warfare by Another Name: Russian Computer Hacking against the United States and the West Jumada I, 1438 - February 2017 Jack Caravelli & Sebastian Maier Warfare by Another Name: Russian Computer Hacking against the United States and the West Jack Caravelli & Sebastian Maier 4 Dirasat No. 20 Jumada I, 1438 - February 2017 © King Faisal Center for research and Islamic Studies, 2017 King Fahd National Library Cataloging-In-Publication Data Caravelli, Jack Warfare by Another Name: Russian Computer Hacking against the United States and the West, / Jack Caravelli ; Sebastian Maier, - Riyadh, 2007 34 p ; 16.5 x 23 cm ISBN: 978-603-8206-23-2 1 - Russia - Foreign relations - United States I - Sebastian Maier (co. author) II - Title 327.73047 dc 1438/6686 L.D. no. 1438/6686 ISBN: 978-603-8206-23-2 Table of Content Abstract 7 Introduction 8 “Nonlinear War” or Making Sense of the Gerasimov Doctrine 12 The Importance of Resilience in the Cyber Domain 14 The Aftermath of the Edward Snowden Leaks 15 Disruption and Hacking Surrounding the 2016 US Presidential Election 18 Beyond the Political: Industrial Espionage and Cyber Fraud against the US 25 Manipulation Attempts in the Run-Up to the Elections in France and Germany in 2017 28 Conclusion 29 5 Abstract Russia has developed one of the world’s most extensive cyber warfare capabilities and views those capabilities as a means to advance its strategic objectives in both war and peacetime. This paper examines Russia’s approach to the use of its cyber capabilities and how they are integrated into Russia’s broader objectives for dealing with its adversaries. Particular focus is placed on Russia’s unprecedented use of cyber to influence political elections in the West, including in the United States, France and Germany. To further its objectives, Russia also has used relations with outsiders such as at WikiLeaks to disseminate information considered damaging to Russian foes such as the US political campaign of Hillary Clinton. The paper concludes that there are very limited means to either deter or hold accountable Russian uses of cyber, implying Russian cyber attacks will continue and could easily expand to Middle East nations. 7 8 Dirasat No. 20 Jumada I, 1438 - February 2017 Introduction The development of the Internet and the computers that access it are among mankind’s greatest scientific achievements. Together, they form cyberspace, “the realm of computer networks (and the users behind them) in which information is stored, shared and communicated online.”1 Behind this definition there occurs an almost endless series of global cyber activities daily. They can encompass everything from sending a simple birthday greeting to a friend across the globe to corporations or medical institutions exchanging data with their counterparts and dialogue occurring within or between governments. The people who developed the Internet intended that it would be free and accessible to all. By harnessing the use of information, they wished to make science serve the greater human good. That idealistic and even noble view has been achieved in numerous ways, including through the examples mentioned here. By any standard, the Internet is a wondrous development that advances global prosperity. But that is only part of the story, however. At the same time, the promise of the Internet also has given way to a darker reality. Today, cyber criminals carry out numerous cyber attacks that provide enormous financial gain through such activities as stealing proprietary data. Moreover, terrorist organizations such as Daesh use the Internet as a means to propagate their violent visions, encourage their followers, and recruit new adherents. Another growing threat is the use of the Internet by various nations wishing to advance their political goals. China, North Korea, and Iran all have mastered the Internet in ways designed to further their policy ends of disrupting their enemies and undermining opposing governments. China, for example, robbed the U.S. Office of Personnel Management of the personnel files of 22 million Americans who had served their government in various capacities. (1) P. W. Singer and Allan Friedman, Cybersecurity and Cyber Warfare: What Everyone Needs to Know (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014), 13. Perhaps above all, no nation has used the Internet in more creative and politically motivated ways than the Russian government and those who work on its behalf. Russian cyber attacks against the West, which are often, though not always, launched against the United States, are persistent, effective, and growing in scope and nature. Moreover, cyber attacks can be as devastating as kinetic attacks, albeit in different ways. Through much of the twentieth century, and certainly since the end of World War II, the Soviet Union, and then Russia, have sought to use propaganda and related techniques to influence or gain advantage over other nations. Of course, Russia’s use of the Internet to carry out cyber attacks is more recent, but it still spans several decades. The 1991 collapse of the Soviet Union resulted in the steep decline of what would become the Russian military. In ensuing years, the Soviet political collapse also became a financial collapse, and for a long time the military would be starved for financial support. Senior military commanders saw that the relatively low costs of conducting information warfare and cyber operations were a way to compensate for some of the growing shortcomings in other areas of combat capabilities. At the same time, Russian military strategists, who were always keenly aware of what their adversaries were doing, also studied the importance of U.S. electronic warfare operations in the 1991 U.S.-led war to oust Saddam Hussein’s Iraqi military forces from Kuwait. As a result, the combination of need and the recognition of U.S. advances in cyber warfare led Russia to fully embrace the need for a robust set of cyber-warfare capabilities. Revealing Attributions: Operation “Moonlight Maze” and “Grizzly Steppe” Improvements did not happen overnight, but they did slowly emerge. In 1998, the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) carried out an investigation it called Operation Moonlight Maze in response to a series of attempts to 9 10 Dirasat No. 20 Jumada I, 1438 - February 2017 break into computers where information regarding sensitive U.S. Air Force technologies was stored. In particular, the information was held at Wright Paterson Air Force Base in Akron, Ohio, one of the air force’s top research and development centers. There also were attacks against computer networks at two of America’s most important nuclear weapons facilities, Sandia National Laboratory and Los Alamos National Laboratory, both in New Mexico. The investigation resulted in the FBI’s conclusion that thousands of pages of documents had been stolen and the hacking operation had been extended to other nations, including Germany, the United Kingdom, Canada, and Brazil. This was not the first time Germany had been victimized by a hacker. In the 1980s it had been targeted by a German citizen, Markus Hess, who sold German secrets to Russia. That episode underscored the importance of identifying insider threats. The FBI found that four Internet addresses listed in Russia were involved in the late 1990s attacks, although the Russians never acknowledged any role in them. In 2007, Russia began carrying out government-sponsored attacks against selected Western nations, including Estonia, Lithuania, Poland, and Georgia. For example, in April and May 2007, Russian hackers launched cyber attacks against the Estonian government and financial institutions in retaliation for Estonia’s decision to remove a Russian World War II memorial. A year later—in June 2008—in retaliation for similar “crimes,” the Lithuanian government’s webpage was defaced and the Russian symbols of the hammer and sickle were inserted on its webpage as punishment for similar perceived crimes. None of this came as a surprise to astute observers such as Michael McFaul, a former U.S. ambassador to Russia. Speaking several years ago, McFaul said that “for years now the Kremlin has looked for ways to disrupt democracies, to help the people that they like to come to power and to undermine the credibility of the democratic process.”2 (2) See “The Key to Putin’s Cyber Power,” The Atlantic, December 30, 2016; interview with Uri Friedman. There is little doubt that those attacks and subsequent Russian cyber attacks against even more formidable targets, such as the United States and Germany, can be traced to official actions. The GRU, the Russian military intelligence organization, and the FSB, the successor to the notorious KGB, maintain a dedicated cadre of cyber experts.3 Moreover, and equally important, the foreign intelligence service, known as the SVR, closely monitors the Western media and bloggers for insights and information that can be used or distorted to serve Russian political goals. In late 2016, a joint U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) report titled, “Grizzly Steppe: Russian Malware Cyber Activity,” singled out those Russian government organizations that had been directly implicated in cyber attacks against critical infrastructure in the United States. U.S. companies were advised to notify government officials of any suspicion of cyber attacks on their computers. Other vulnerable institutions identified in the report included universities, think tanks, areas of critical infrastructure, and political organizations. Predictably, the Russian government denied all the charges, using such descriptions as “hysteria” and “groundless” to describe the reporting.4 That report, while useful in identifying much of Russia’s cyber activity, failed to address a major threat to U.S. national security overseas, that of information warfare. In Afghanistan, the United States has been fighting a resilient foe, the Taliban, since 2001. This protracted war has cost the United States thousands of lives and well over a trillion dollars.
Recommended publications
  • ACTUALIZADA 140121) (Pdf
    LISTA DISCOS 33’ORDEN ALFABETICO A ABBA – Super Truper (RCA/México/1980) - $40 ABBA – Voulez Vous (RCA/México/1979) - $30 ACDC – Back in black (Atlantic/México/1980) - $1000 (AGOTADO) ACDC – Highway to hell (Atlantic/México/1979) - $499 (AGOTADO) ACDC – Power rage (Gamma/México/1980) - $700 (AGOTADO) Agustín Lara – Álbum del recuerdo (Peerles/México)- $60 Agustín Lara – Música Española (Musart/México) - $70 Agustín Lara – Un poco de lo mío (RCA Víctor/México) - $70 Air Supply – Air Supply (Arista/México/1985) - $5550 Al Hudson – One way Featuring (MCA Records/México/1980) - $100 Alice Cooper – El show de Alice cooper (Warner Bros/México/1982) - $300 Alice Cooper – Va al infierno (Warner Bros/México/1976) - $400 Ana Gabriel – Hice Bien Quererte (Lambada) (CBS/México/1989) - $120 Ana Gabriel – Quien como tú (CBS/México/1989) - $380 Andy Williams – Maria (CBS/Mexico/1962) - $200 B Barry Manilow – Tryin´ To Get The Feeling (Arista/México/1975) - $110 Barry White – The man (20th century/México/1978) - $130 Banda Taurina – American Military Marches (AF/México/1957) - $135 Bee Gees – 16 Greatest Hits (Polydor/México/1986) - $100 Beethoven, Oleg Kagaan, Sviatoslav Richter – Violin Sonatas 'Spring' & No. 4 In A Minor (EMI/UK/1976) - $70 The Beatles - 1962 – 1966 (Apple Records/México/1979) - $200 (AGOTADO) The Beatles – Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (Country Flag Series) (Apple Records/Japan/1976) – $2000 The Beatles – White Album (Apple records/México/1968) - $399(AGOTADO) Beethoven – Concerto for Violin, Op. 61 (Vox/USA) - $30 Beethoven
    [Show full text]
  • Consuls of the Dardanelles and Gallipoli
    1 COLLABORATIVE ONLINE RESEARCH PROJECT Consuls of “THE DARDANELLES” and “GALLIPOLI” (Updated Version no: 4 – February 2013) Welcome to a resource being compiled about the consuls and consulates of “The Dardanelles” and “Gallipoli”. This is an ongoing project. In this fourth update, many new details have been added, especially from genealogical sources, and some questions clarified. The information shown here is not complete and may contain errors. For this reason, it may appear rather haphazard in some places. In time, a more coherent narrative will emerge. The project aims to take advantage of the Internet as a source of information and as a means of communication. There is now a vast and increasing amount of information online which allows us access to sources located in various countries. Many sources are quoted verbatim until the content can be confirmed in comparision with other sources. If you are a researcher, family member, or simply interested in some aspect of this topic, you may be able to help by providing additions, corrections, etc., however short. This will help to fill in gaps and present a fuller picture for the benefit of everybody researching these families or this locality. Comments and contributions should be sent to the following e-mail address: (contact[at]levantineheritagefoundation.org) The information here will be amended in the light of contributions. All contributions will be acknowledged unless you prefer your name not to be mentioned. Many different languages are involved but English is being used as the “lingua franca” in order to reach as many people as possible. Notes in other languages have been and will be included.
    [Show full text]
  • Emotion, Action and the Journey of Feelings in the Actor's Mournful
    The Lamenting Brain: Emotion, Action and the Journey of Feelings in the Actor’s Mournful Art Panagiotis Papageorgopoulos Department of Drama and Theatre Royal Holloway College University of London Submission for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy 2009 Page | 1 I hereby declare that this submission is my own work and that, to the best of my knowledge and belief, it contains no material previously published or written by another person nor material which to a substantial extent has been accepted for the qualification of any other degree or diploma of a University or other institution of higher learning, except where due acknowledgment has been made in the text. 1/12/2009 Panagiotis Papageorgopoulos Page | 2 ABSTRACT This thesis is motivated by the question of how and why actors perform and experience emotion, especially in cases when the emotional demands are as extreme and urgent as in Greek tragedy. In order to answer this question the thesis embarks on two main tasks: (a) to reappraise the position, function and technique of emotion in the work of four key practitioners of twentieth century Western acting (Stanislavski, Meyerhold, Brecht and Grotowski) from the point of view of contemporary neuroscience, and (b) to trace their original paradigm in the professional mourners’ psychotechnique of emotion, as found in ancient and modern Greek ritual lamentation for the dead. The first part of the thesis attempts to reread and reframe twentieth century western acting’s technique of emotion by adopting the radically new neuroscientific paradigm of emotion, which reappraises emotion as a catalytic faculty in the formation of motivation, decision-making, reasoning, action and social interaction.
    [Show full text]
  • Deal Signed by Jagger& Richard •••Mathews Runs Date* CBS France Records Go Behind Iron Curtain
    Senator Dirksen: Artist With A Bullet • • • Wolpin Exits Famous Jan. 1 • • Bell To Handle New Greene- Stone Labels* $1 Mil Writer Deal Signed By Jagger& Richard •••Mathews Runs Date* CBS France Records Go Behind Iron Curtain Int'l Section FRONT COVER: AND ALONG CAME THE ASSOCIATION Begins Pg. 55 p All the dimensions of a#l smash! *smm 1 4-439071 P&ul Revere am The THE single of '66 B THE SPIRIT OP *67 from this brand PAUL REVERE tiIe RAIDERS INCLUDING: HUNGRY THE GREAT AIRPLANE new album— STRIKE GOOD THING LOUISE 1001 ARABIAN NIGHTS CL2595/CS9395 (Stereo) Where the good things are. On COLUMBIA RECORDS ® "COLUMBIA ^MAPCAS REG PRINTED IN U SA GashBim Cash Bock Vol. XXVIII—Number 22 December 17, 1966 (Publication Office) 1780 Broadway New York, N. Y. 10019 (Phone: JUdson 6-2640) CABLE ADDRESS: CASHBOX, N. Y. JOE ORLECK Chairman of the Board GEORGE ALBERT President and Publisher NORMAN ORLECK Executive Vice President MARTY OSTROW Vice President LEON SCHUSTER Disk Industry—1966 Treasurer IRV LICHTMAN Editor in Chief EDITORIAL TOM McENTEE Associate Editor RICK BOLSOM ALLAN DALE EDITORIAL ASSISTANTS MIKE MARTUCCI JERRY ORLECK BERNIE BLAKE The past few issues of Cash Box Speaking of deals, 1966 was marked Director Advertising of have told the major story of 1966. by a continuing merger of various in- ^CCOUNT EXECUTIVES While there were other developments dustry factors, not merely on a hori- STAN SO I PER BILL STUPER of considerable importance when the zontal level (label purchases of labels), Hollywood HARVEY GELLER, long-range view is taken into account, but vertical as well (ABC's purchase of ED ADLUM the record business is still a business a wholesaler, New Deal).
    [Show full text]
  • Lp Stock Database
    Excluding Children, Classical/Ballet/ Opera, Religious Vinyl 4U Main Database (see other databases for these) 1 LP (x1) 2 Contact: Judy Vos [email protected] LP's (x2) # of LPs in Artist/s or Group Composer Album Name Album 101 Strings After a hard day x1 101 Strings Lerner&Loewe Camelot x1 101 Strings Exodus and other great movie themes x1 101 Strings Webb/BacharachMillion Seller Hits x1 10CC Bloody Tourists x1 ABBA Arrival x1 ABBA Gracias por la Musica x1 ABBA Gracias por la musica (in Spanish) x1 ABBA Greatest Hits x1 ABBA Greatest Hits x1 ABBA Greatest Hits x1 ABBA Greatest Hits x1 ABBA Greatest Hits x1 ABBA Super Trouper x1 ABBA Super Trouper x1 ABBA Super Trouper x1 ABBA Super Trouper x1 ABBA The Album x1 ABBA The Album x1 Abba The Album x1 ABBA The Singles - The 1st 10 years x2 ABBA The Visitors x1 ABBA The Visitors x1 ABBA The Visitors x1 ABBA The Visitors x1 ABBA The Visitors x1 ABBA Voulez Vouz x1 ABBA Voulez-Vous x1 ABBA Voulez-Vous x1 ABBA Voulez-Vous x1 ABC Beauty Stab x1 Acker Bilk Stranger on the shore x1 Acker Bilk & Bent Fabric Cocktails for Two x1 Acker Bilk & others Clarinet Jamboree x1 Acker Bilk & Stan Tracey Blue Acker x1 Acker Bilk Esquire A Taste of honey x1 Acker Bilk with Leon Young Stranger on the Shore x1 Adam and the Ants Kings of the Wild Frontier x1 Adam and The Beasts Alasdair Clayre x1 Adamo A L'Olympia x1 Adamo Adamo x1 Adamo The Hits of Adamo x1 Adrian Brett Echoes of Gold x1 Adrian Gurvitz Classic x1 Agnetha Faltskog Eyes of a woman x1 Agnetha Faltskog Wrap your arms around me x1 A-Ha Stay on these
    [Show full text]
  • Congressional Record—House H1233
    February 11, 2009 CONGRESSIONAL RECORD — HOUSE H1233 he wanted the Freedom of Choice Act sure every woman has the right to evening. Two important issues. I thank to be the first piece of legislation that know what options are available to Mr. Speaker for his indulgence. he would sign as President. So impor- her, to know what is an abortion, what Let’s be thinking, men and women, tant to this pro-abortion President is does it mean. For women who have the and ask God for the wisdom of Socrates the issue of the Freedom of Choice Act, opportunity to see their unborn child as we debate and make decisions on he wanted to make that the signature on an ultrasound machine, it’s an these terribly important issues facing item of his Presidency. earthshaking experience to see your our Nation and our people. It’s a cruel statement to make to the baby, your flesh and blood, moving on With that, I yield back my time. children of this country because there’s an ultrasound machine. a lie that’s been perpetrated over the It takes a woman, it takes the father f years since the 1960s. Planned Parent- of that baby to think of what this hood has said ‘‘every child, a wanted means. This is human life, and it SPECIAL ORDERS GRANTED child;’’ which, by implication, means causes them to want to choose life and By unanimous consent, permission to that if a mother does not want the give life to that unborn child. address the House, following the legis- Reasonable restrictions have been child, it’s better to kill the child than lative program and any special orders passed all across this country in many to allow that child to receive life.
    [Show full text]
  • ANDRESSA CARAVELLI Anticorpo Recombinante Anti-Intimina: Uma
    ANDRESSA CARAVELLI Anticorpo recombinante anti-intimina: uma ferramenta para o diagnóstico rápido de Escherichia coli enteropatogênica e de Escherichia coli enterohemorrágica Dissertação apresentada ao Programa de Pós-Graduação Interunidades em Biotecnologia USP/Instituto Butantan/IPT, para obtenção do Título de Mestre em Biotecnologia. São Paulo 2013 ANDRESSA CARAVELLI Anticorpo recombinante anti-intimina: uma ferramenta para o diagnóstico rápido de Escherichia coli enteropatogênica e de Escherichia coli enterohemorrágica Dissertação apresentada ao Programa de Pós-Graduação Interunidades em Biotecnologia USP/Instituto Butantan/IPT, para obtenção do Título de Mestre em Biotecnologia. Área de concentração: Biotecnologia Orientador: Prof. Dra. Roxane Maria Fontes Piazza Versão original São Paulo 2013 DADOS DE CATALOGAÇÃO NA PUBLICAÇÃO (CIP) Serviço de Biblioteca e Informação Biomédica do Instituto de Ciências Biomédicas da Universidade de São Paulo reprodução não autorizada pelo autor Caravelli, Andressa. Anticorpo recombinante anti-intimina: uma ferramenta para o diagnóstico rápido de Escherichia coli enteropatogênica e de Escherichia coli enterohemorrágica / Andressa Caravelli. -- São Paulo, 2013. Orientador: Profa. Dra. Roxane Maria Fontes Piazza. Dissertação (Mestrado) – Universidade de São Paulo. Instituto de Ciências Biomédicas. Programa de Pós-Graduação Interunidades em Biotecnologia USP/IPT/Instituto Butantan. Área de concentração: Biotecnologia. Linha de pesquisa: Diagnóstico de Escherichia coli diarreiogênicas. Versão do título
    [Show full text]
  • Entire Issue
    E PL UR UM IB N U U S Congressional Record United States th of America PROCEEDINGS AND DEBATES OF THE 110 CONGRESS, FIRST SESSION Vol. 153 WASHINGTON, MONDAY, MAY 21, 2007 No. 83 House of Representatives The House met at 10:30 a.m. and was report being physically or sexually protects the bottom line of business, called to order by the Speaker pro tem- abused by a husband or boyfriend at and it improves the quality of life of pore (Mr. SALAZAR of Colorado). some point in their lives. our American society. The physical and psychological con- f Mr. Speaker, I thank the many advo- sequences of domestic violence are ex- cacy groups for their support of the DESIGNATION OF SPEAKER PRO acerbated by the less obvious economic SAFE Act and for the work they do TEMPORE consequences. For example, one of the every day to end domestic and sexual The SPEAKER pro tempore laid be- key reasons survivors stay in or return violence in our country. fore the House the following commu- to an abusive environment is because And I sincerely thank Representative nication from the Speaker: they are financially dependent upon POE for his cosponsorship, and I look their abuser to provide for them and WASHINGTON, DC, forward to working with him and my May 21, 2007. their children. As a result of the abuse, colleagues in Congress to pass the I hereby appoint the Honorable JOHN T. employed women often lose their jobs SAFE Act and empower women against SALAZAR to act as Speaker pro tempore on due to frequent tardiness or absentee- the violence in their life.
    [Show full text]
  • Music 96676 Songs, 259:07:12:12 Total Time, 549.09 GB
    Music 96676 songs, 259:07:12:12 total time, 549.09 GB Artist Album # Items Total Time A.R. Rahman slumdog millionaire 13 51:30 ABBA the best of ABBA 11 43:42 ABBA Gold 9 36:57 Abbey Lincoln, Stan Getz you gotta pay the band 10 58:27 Abd al Malik Gibraltar 15 54:19 Dante 13 50:54 Abecedarians Smiling Monarchs 2 11:59 Eureka 6 35:21 Resin 8 38:26 Abel Ferreira Conjunto Chorando Baixinho 12 31:00 Ace of Base The Sign 12 45:49 Achim Reichel Volxlieder 15 47:57 Acid House Kings Sing Along With 12 35:40 The Acorn glory hope mountain 12 48:22 Acoustic Alchemy Early Alchemy 14 45:42 arcanum 12 54:00 the very best of (Acoustic Alchemy) 16 1:16:10 Active Force active force 9 42:17 Ad Vielle Que Pourra Ad Vielle Que Pourra 13 52:14 Adam Clayton Mission Impossible 1 3:27 Adam Green Gemstones 15 31:46 Adele 19 12 43:40 Adele Sebastan Desert Fairy Princess 6 38:19 Adem Homesongs 10 44:54 Adult. Entertainment 4 18:32 the Adventures Theodore And Friends 16 1:09:12 The Sea Of Love 9 41:14 trading secrets with the moon 11 48:40 Lions And Tigers And Bears 13 55:45 Aerosmith Aerosmith's Greatest Hits 10 37:30 The African Brothers Band Me Poma 5 37:32 Afro Celt Sound System Sound Magic 3 13:00 Release 8 45:52 Further In Time 12 1:10:44 Afro Celt Sound System, Sinéad O'Connor Stigmata 1 4:14 After Life 'Cauchemar' 11 45:41 Afterglow Afterglow 11 25:58 Agincourt Fly Away 13 40:17 The Agnostic Mountain Gospel Choir Saint Hubert 11 38:26 Ahmad El-Sherif Ben Ennas 9 37:02 Ahmed Abdul-Malik East Meets West 8 34:06 Aim Cold Water Music 12 50:03 Aimee Mann The Forgotten Arm 12 47:11 Air Moon Safari 10 43:47 Premiers Symptomes 7 33:51 Talkie Walkie 10 43:41 Air Bureau Fool My Heart 6 33:57 Air Supply Greatest Hits (Air Supply) 9 38:10 Airto Moreira Fingers 7 35:28 Airto Moreira, Flora Purim, Joe Farrell Three-Way Mirror 8 52:52 Akira Ifukube Godzilla 26 45:33 Akosh S.
    [Show full text]
  • Congressional Record United States Th of America PROCEEDINGS and DEBATES of the 106 CONGRESS, SECOND SESSION
    E PL UR UM IB N U U S Congressional Record United States th of America PROCEEDINGS AND DEBATES OF THE 106 CONGRESS, SECOND SESSION Vol. 146 WASHINGTON, THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 14, 2000 No. 108 House of Representatives The House met at 9 a.m. The point of no quorum is considered WELCOME TO PRIEST VENKATACH- Priest Venkatachalapathi Samul- withdrawn. ALAPATHI SAMULDRALA drala, Shiva Hindu Temple, Parma, f (Mr. BROWN of Ohio asked and was Ohio, offered the following prayer: given permission to address the House O God, You are Omnipresent, PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE for 1 minute and to revise and extend Omnipotent, and Omniscient. You are The SPEAKER. Will the gentleman his remarks.) in everything and nothing is beyond from Ohio (Mr. BROWN) come forward Mr. BROWN of Ohio. Mr. Speaker, You. You are our Mother and Father and lead the House in the Pledge of Al- today is a great day for Indian-Amer- and we are all Your children. Whatever legiance. ican relations. For the first time, a You do is for our good. You are the Mr. BROWN of Ohio led the Pledge of Hindu priest has given the opening ocean of mercy and You forgive our er- Allegiance as follows: prayer at a session of Congress, and the rors. You are our teacher and You I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the Prime Minister of India later this guide us into righteousness. United States of America, and to the Repub- Today, in this great Hall, are assem- lic for which it stands, one nation under God, morning will address a joint session of bled the elected Representatives of the indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Full Issue
    Contents March 2012 , volume 6, issue 1 4 Editor’s PoliCy AnAlysis A BluePrint for eu energy seCurity by Mitchell A. Belfer 23 The PolitiCAl eConomy of energy seCurity And nuCleAr energy in JordAn by Imad El-Anis 46 MoldovA’s PolitiCAl self And the energy Conundrum in the Context of the euroPeAn neighBourhood PoliCy by Cătălin Gomboş and Dragoş C. Mateescu 75 Worth the energy? the geoPolitiCs of ArCtiC oil And gAs by Peter Hough 91 The impacts of internAtionAl Aid on the energy seCurity of smAll islAnd develoPing stAtes (sids): A CAse study of tuvAlu by Sarah Hemstock and Roy Smith 113 NAto, disCourse, Community And energy seCurity by Giovanni Ercolani 141 UnCovering north KoreA’s energy seCurity dilemmA: PAst PoliCies, Present ChoiCes, future oPPortunities by Virginie Grzelczyk 164 Controversies of Putin’s energy PoliCy: the ProBlem of foreign investment And long-term develoPment of the russiAn energy seCtor by Olga Khrushcheva 189 PolAnd’s Quiet revolution: shAle gAs exPlorAtion And its disContents in PomerAniA by Edyta Materka 221 BooK revieWs Investing in the United States: Is the US Ready for FDI from China EU Counterterrorism Policy: A Paper Tiger Spying 101: The RCMP’s Secret Activities at Canadian Universities, 1917-1997 Writing on War Security in a Changing Global Environment: Challenging the Human Security Approach Always more at cejiss.org Frequently updated articles and comments reflecting changes in interna- tional relations between our hard copy publications. editor’s PoliCy AnAlysis A BluePrint for eu energy seCurity Introduction In the spirit of this special issue of CEJISS – which addresses a variety of issues and geopolitical questions – on energy security, the following analysis intends to provide insight into the EU’s energy vulnerabilities and then suggest some policy options for the EU to consider.
    [Show full text]
  • Pimentel Thesis
    THE MAKING OF A FEMALE REVOLUTIONARY DURING THE NEAPOLITAN REPUBLIC OF 1799: THE LIFE AND WORK OF ELEONORA DE FONSECA PIMENTEL A Thesis Presented to the faculty of the Department of History California State University, Sacramento Submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS in History by Francesca Maria Golia SPRING 2016 © 2016 Francesca Maria Golia ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ii THE MAKING OF A FEMALE REVOLUTIONARY DURING THE NEAPOLITAN REPUBLIC OF 1799: THE LIFE AND WORK OF ELEONORA DE FONSECA PIMENTEL A Thesis by Francesca Maria Golia Approved by: __________________________________, Committee Chair Dr. Mona Siegel __________________________________, Second Reader Dr. Jeffrey Wilson ____________________________ Date iii Student: Francesca Maria Golia I certify that this student has met the requirements for format contained in the University format manual, and that this thesis is suitable for shelving in the Library and credit is to be awarded for the thesis. __________________________, Department Chair ___________________ Dr. Aaron Cohen Date Department of History iv Abstract of THE MAKING OF A FEMALE REVOLUTIONARY DURING THE NEAPOLITAN REPUBLIC OF 1799: THE LIFE AND WORK OF ELEONORA DE FONSECA PIMENTEL by Francesca Maria Golia Eleonora de Fonseca Pimentel was no ordinary woman. Eighteenth-century Neapolitan intellectuals recognized her passion for learning and her poetic talent and welcomed her into their salons and academies at a very early age. Even the Bourbon monarchs of the Kingdom of Naples were impressed by her skill and appointed her as court librarian. Pimentel was able to infiltrate the masculine world of learning due the unique circumstances of the Italian Enlightenment, which was more open to permitting exceptional women an advanced education, and it allowed them to pursue their studies further than any other women of the eighteenth century outside of the Italian peninsula.
    [Show full text]