56 Meeting of the GCZMA. 57 Meeting of the GCZMA 3. 58 Meeting of The

INDEX to the 56 to 58th Minutes of the Meetings of Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority (GCZMA)

Sr. No. Particulars Page Nos. 1. 56th Meeting of the GCZMA. 2-8

2. 57th Meeting of the GCZMA 9-25

3. 58th Meeting of the GCZMA 26

MINUTES FOR THE 56 TH GCZMA MEETING OF THE GOA COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY TO BE HELD ON 25 / 08 / 2010.

56.1

Item No. 1 (Construction / Reconstruction / Development in CRZ-II Area).

Case No. 1

Proposed construction of residential building in Chalta No. 7,8,23,24 & 4 of P.T. sheet No. 65 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Mario J. Alvares (GCZMA/S/10-11/ 18 ).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case No.2

Proposed repair and renovation and addition on ground and first floor to the existing house in Chalta No. 28, 29 & 30 of P.T. sheet No. 12 of Panaji city, Tiswadi Taluka, by Mr. Dharmanand Verekar (GCZMA/N/10-11/28).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/NGPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case No.3

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in Chalta No. 34, 37 of P.T. sheet No. 4 of Panaji city, Tiswadi Taluka, by Mrs. Filomena Costa (GCZMA/N/10-11/33).

Decision: Approved, subject to the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/NGPDA and local authority guidelines.

56.2

Item No. 2 (Repair & Renovation/Development in CRZ-III Area).

Case No. 1

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house (Collapsed) in Sy. No. 5/7 of Maxem- Loliem village, Canacona Taluka, by Mrs. Inacinha Fernandes (GCZMA/S/10-11/16).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same. This house was broken during the flash floods last year.

Case No. 2

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. No. 5/7 of Loliem village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Victor Dias (GCZMA/S/10-11/17).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.This house was broken during the flash floods last year.

Case No. 3

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing Bhatti (Distillery) in Sy. No. 130/13 of Agonda village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Heraldo Fernandes (GCZMA/S/10-11/23).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 4

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.No. 174/19 of Calangute Village, Bardez Taluka, by Mr. Joao F. Fernandes, Cruz Fernandes, Severina Fernandes( GCZMA/N/09-10/23).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 5

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.no. 207/4 of Calangute Village, Bardez Taluka, by Mr. Maria D.Gonsalves, Mr. Bruno A. Gonsalves( GCZMA/N/09- 10/35).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No.6

Proposed repairs of existing house in Sy. No. 132/9 of Nagorcem-Palolem Village, Canacona Taluka, by Smt. Laxmi Vishram Pagi ( GCZMA/S/10-11/26).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No.7

Proposed repairs of existing house in Sy. No. 132/21 of Nagorcem-Palolem Village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Molu R.N. Gaonkar ( GCZMA/S/10-11/27).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 8

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. no. 61/7 of Nagorcem-Palolem Village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Cruz Rodrigues( GCZMA/S/09-10/54).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No.9

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 261/8 of Calangute village Bardez taluka, Mrs. Natalina Fernandes & Mr. Velly Fernandes (GCZMA/N/10- 11/10)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 10

Proposed repair to the existing structure (G+1) in survey no. 318/2, 4 of Calangute village Bardez Taluka, M/s. Synapse Information Services Pvt. Ltd. (GCZMA/N/10-11/26)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 11

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 173/1-L of Poinguinim village of Canacona taluka, by Mr. Joaquim Dias (GCZMA/S/10-11/19)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 12

Proposed Re-construction/repair and renovation to the existing house in survey No. 35/0 of Siridao village Tiswadi taluka, Mr. Antonio Pires (GCZMA/N/10-11/ 25 )

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 13

Proposed repairs and renovation/alternation to the existing house in Survey No. 4/1 of Village Baiguinim, Tiswadi Taluka ,by Parneeta Muppana. (GCZMA/N/10-11/24) Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

. Case No. 14 Proposed Reconstruction/repairs and renovation to the existing house in Survey No. 207/5(Part) of Village Borim, Ponda Taluka, by Deepa J. Miringkar.(GCZMA/N/10-11/34) Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 15

Proposed repairs and renovation to the existing two structures in Survey No. 197/1-G of Village Reis-Magos, Bardez Taluka, by Mario Walter Fernandes (GCZMA/N/10-11/36) Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

56.3

Item No. 3 (Wire fencing/Bio fencing/compound wall)

Case No. 1

Proposed construction of compound wall in Chalta No. 41 of PTS. No. 86 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Our Lady of Desterro Church (GCZMA/S/-09-10/22)

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that any traditional access should not be blocked and also subject to the construction should be in accordance with the local building bye laws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case No. 2

Proposed construction of compound wall in Chalta No. 2 of PTS No. 175 of Vasco city, Mormugao taluka, by M/s. Mormugao Port Trust (GCZMA/S/10-11/21)

Case No.3

Proposed construction of compound wall/wire Mesh Fencing in survey No. 16/1(Part) and 14/3(Part) of Cortalim village of Mormugao taluka, by Mr. Dominic Rodrigues,(GCZMA/S/10-11/24)

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that any traditional access should not be blocked. Wire fencing/ Bio fencing is permitted within CRZ-III area.

Case No. 4

Reconstruction of existing gate at Raj Bhavan in chalta No. 1 of PTS. No. 168 of Panaji city Tiswadi taluka, by Chief Architect (PWD), Altinho, Panaji-Goa (GCZMA/N/10-11/30)

Decision: Approved on account of security reasons, subject to the condition that any traditional access should not be blocked

56.4

Item No. 4 (Other development / construction of jetty / Repair of barges / Dry-Docks / Regularisation etc.)

Case No. 1

Permission for berthing and operation of motor yatch/motor boats the property abutting Sy.No. 31/4 of Penha da Franca in Bardez taluka, by Mr. Agnelo J. Fernandes,(GCZMA/N/10-11/27)

Decision: The GCZMA members opined that there exists a bird sanctuary and thick mangroves within buffer area of the wildlife eco-sensitive area. The GCZMA members where not infavour of that the proposal and opined that prior approval from Forest Department should be obtained

Case No. 2

Permission for laying GAIL 24” dia Pipeline & OFC across Nala in South Goa District, by GAIL (India) Limited, (GCZMA/N/10-11/ 12).

Decision: After presentation done by the officials of GAIL (India), Ltd., it was decided to approve the proposal for laying GAIL 24” dia pipeline & OFC., subject to Compensatory Afforestation of the mangrove species be carried out in consultation with Forest Department, over thrice the area lost. Similarly a monitoring group should be set up to monitor the pipe laying process in such eco-sensitive and vulnerable areas.

Case No. 3

Permission for setting up of Reverse Osmosis Water Generation Plant at INS HANSA at Dabolim, by Commanding Officer, INS HANSA Dabolim(GCZMA/S/10-11/10)

Decision: Deferred, More details are required from the project proponent as regards to the development sought to be carried out in the matter. It is suggested that rain water harvesting should be undertaken

Case No. 4

Extension of Jetty 50 mts. towards Betim side for Fisheries Complex Malim and joining of space between the jetty and Auction shed by Fisheries Department (GCZMA/N/10-11/17)

Decision: The detail presentation was given by Directorate of Fisheries, where Dr. Sharmila Monteiro was present. GCZMA members raised a queries on impact of flow of water, congestion and constriction of the river, reclamation of the area, sea level rise impacts on account of the proposed extension of jetty. It was also decided that Fisheries Department should undertake a Rapid EIA study and place the matter to GCZMA.

Case No. 5

Proposed NOC for floating pontoon jetty and undertaking barge repairs along the riverside adjoining in Survey No. 41/2 of Village Vagurbem of Ponda Taluka, by M/s. Sudarshan Dry Docks (GCZMA/N/09-10/67)

Decision: Deferred, as there is a pending SCN for alleged violation of CRZ Notification, 1991in the same Sy Nos. The matter to be taken up after disposing the SCN

Case No. 6

Proposed regularization of barge loading jetty bearing Sy. No. 58/1 of Sirsaim Village, Bardez Taluka by M/s. Anant V. Sarmalkar (GCZMA/S/389).

Decision: Approved, from CRZ angle.

56.5

Item No. 5 (Cases of Roads / Public Access / Land Acquisition and Development by Government Departments)

Case No. 1

Improvement and black topping from Dhawalkhajan to Borim in V.P.Agonda in Canacona Taluka, (GCZMA/S/08-09/50).

Decision: Approved, in public interest.

56.6

Item No. 6 (Additional Item)

Case No. 1

Land Acquisition for widening of approach roads leading to various beaches in Mandrem Constituency in Pernem Taluka by Asst. Engineer (PWD) Siolim (GCZMA/N/09-10/38).

Decision: Approved, in public interest

Case No. 2

Regularization of the reconstructed structure in bearing survey No.25/6(Part) of Assagao village, Bardez taluka, by Mr. Audumbar Sirsaikar(GCZMA/N/08-09/74).

Decision: Deferred, Matter to be heard. Both complainant and project proponent should be present.

Case No. 3

Shack Policy 2010-11

Decision: Member Secretary briefed the GCZMA members about the proposal received from Tourism Department on shacks. Whereby they have proposed to maintain same number of shack like last year, due to the condition imposed by GCZMA last year to freeze number of shack. Director (Tourism) explained that there are few additional request for putting up shacks in other areas. MS, GCZMA explained the matter in Vikas Bhagat V/s. GCZMA in Hon’ble High Court, regarding shack on beaches at Palolem. It appears that during highest high tide in the month of December/January, water level goes beyond Tourism Department allotted shacks. Hence they fall between LTL and HTL. GCZMA Members where of the view that such a situation of shack, in LTL and HTL should not be allowed. As regard the other matter GCZMA decided to defer the issue to the next meeting.

*******************************

MINUTES FOR THE 57 TH GCZMA MEETING OF THE GOA COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY HELD ON 16 / 12 / 2010.

57.1

Item No. 1 (Construction/Reconstruction/Development in CRZ-II Area).

Case No. 1

Proposed construction of residential/commercial building in Chalta No. 24 of P.T. sheet No. 136 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Chandrakant S.N. Pednekar (GCZMA/S/10- 11/ 33).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case No.2

Proposed construction of first floor to the existing residential house in Chalta No. 7, 241, 242, 243 of P.T. sheet No. 172 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Mohammad B. Bepari (GCZMA/S/09-10/32 ).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case No.3

Proposed construction of residential building and in Chalta No. 261 of P.T. sheet No. 152 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Gustavo de Souza (GCZMA/S/10-11/ 31).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case No.4

Proposed construction of commercial centre in Chalta No. 83 of P.T. sheet No. 104 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by M/s. Pisces Exim India Pvt. Ltd. (GCZMA/S/10-11/35 ).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case No.5

Proposed re-construction/ renovation of existing Marina bar and restaurant in Chalta No. 34 of P.T. sheet No. 135 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mormugao Municipal Council (GCZMA/S/10-11/ 34).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case No.6

Proposed repair/ renovation of existing house and addition of first floor in Chalta No. 47of P.T. sheet No. 4 of Panaj city, Tiswadi Taluka, by by Omkar P. Herlekar(GCZMA/N/10- 11/42).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/NGPDA and local authority guidelines.

Case No.7

Proposed reconstruction of existing house in Chalta No. 9of P.T. sheet No. 3 of Panaj city, Tiswadi Taluka, by Smt. Maria Jonefina Piedade Fernandes & Others(GCZMA/N/10- 11/41).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/NGPDA and local authority guidelines.

57.2

Item No. 2 (Repair & Renovation/Development in CRZ-III Area).

Case No. 1

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. No. 27/0 of Sirideo village, Tiswadi Taluka, by Mr. John D’Souza (GCZMA/N/10-11/43).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 2

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house / structure in Sy. No. 58/1(Part) of Assagao village, Bardez Taluka, by Mr. Rajiv N. Rekhi C/o Brahmand Dabolkar (GCZMA/N/10-11/ 46).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 3

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. No. 25/1 of Assagao village, Bardez Taluka, by Mr. Prakash alias Chokha Chodankar (GCZMA/N/10-11/32).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 4 Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. No. 67/3 of Chicalim village, MormugaoTaluka, by Mr. Urbano Rodrigues(GCZMA/S/10-11/ 38).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same. Case No. 5 Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. No. 412/9 of Tivim village, Bardez Taluka, by Smt. Eve Vaz (GCZMA/N/10-11/31).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 6

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy.no. 49/3 of Velsao Village, Mormugao Taluka, by Mrs. Perpetua Anita Dourado Rodrigues( GCZMA/S/10-11/28).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 7

Proposed repairs and renovation to the existing house in Survey No. 112/7 of Village Candolim; Mr. Tahir Isani.(GCZMA/N/10-11/38) Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 8

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. No. 85/24 of Reis-Magos village, Bardez Taluka, by Mr. Govind R. Naik & Mrs. MadhuraV.Naik (GCZMA / N / 10-11 /53).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 9

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing structures in Sy. Nos. 340/1, 354/2,355,356/7,356/8 and 353/5 of Anjuna village, Bardez Taluka, by Mr. Kewal Singh Virk (GCZMA / N / 10-11 /51)

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 10

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 128/24 of Calangute village Bardez taluka, Mr. Suresh Savardekar (GCZMA/N/10-11/49)

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 11

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 125/2 of Candolim village Bardez Taluka, Mr. Malcolm D. Pedder (GCZMA/N/10-11/47)

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 12

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 156/1 of Calangute village Bardez Taluka, by Piedade Vital (GCZMA/N/10-11/48)

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 13

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey No. 248/9 of Calangute village Bardez Taluka, Mr. Tukaram S. korgaonkar (GCZMA/N/10-11/52)

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 14

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey No. 113/23 of Siolim village Bardez taluka, Mr. Vassudev P. Garudi (GCZMA/N/10-11/44)

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No.15

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing house in survey no. 117/4-B & 3 of Morjim village Pernem Taluka, by Mr. Damaciano F. D’Souza (GCZMA/N/10-11/ )

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 16

Proposed repair and renovation to the existing structure in survey No. 5/7 of Issorcim village of Mormugao taluka, by Mr. Lourenco Rodrigues (GCZMA/N/10-11/37)

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 17

Proposed repair of existing structure/house in Sy. No. 41/1 of Colva, Salcete Taluka by Mr. Thomas Rodrigues(GCZMA/S/10-11/39)

Decision: Approved for repairs of the existing structure/house, subject to the condition that same plinth size is maintained.

57.3

Item No. 3 (Wire fencing/Bio fencing/compound wall)

Case No. 1

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.no. 8/7-A of Pale village, Mormugao taluka, by Mrs. Naseem Sheikh (GCZMA/S/10-11/36)

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that any traditional access should not be blocked and also subject to the condition that construction should be in accordance with the local building bye laws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines.

57.4

Item No. 5 (Other development / construction of jetty / Repair of barges / Dry-Docks / Regularisation etc.)

Case No. 1

Clearance for strengthening of existing jetty of Village Sarmanas, Taluka Bicholim (GCZMA/N/10-11/ 54)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle for strengthening of existing jetty as per same size, height and design.

Case No. 2

Clearance for strengthening of existing jetty of village Surla, Taluka Bicholim (GCZMA/N/10-11/55)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle for strengthening of existing jetty and a conveyor belt system. Subject to the conditions of Compensatory afforestation of mangrove species to be carried out in consultation with Forest Department.

Case No. 3

Proposed NOC to install pumping system and to discharge cooling water after suitable treatment into River Mandovi at survey no. 33 of Amona village, Bicholim taluka. (GCZMA/N/10-11/57)

Decision: Deferred. This matter to be decided alongwith the personal hearing in the matter of Shri Khemlo Sawant v/s Sesa Goa Ltd.

Case No. 4

Proposed repair of existing jetty and setting up of mobile Conveyor belt and dredging in Sy. Nos. 141/0 145/0, 146/0, 147/0 of Navelim village, Bicholim Taluka by M/s. Muktar logistics (INDIA)Pvt. Ltd.(GCZMA/N/10-11/)

Decision: Deferred, it was decided to refer the proposal to the Village Panchayat for their views and put up in the next meeting.

Case No. 5

Clearance/Renewal for loading jetty in survey no. 48/0 of Curchorem village, Quepem Taluka by M/s. Agencia Commercial Maritima (GCZMA/S/08-09/25)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs of existing jetty and strengthening of retaining wall.

Case No. 6

Proposed reconstruction of commercial complex cum Office building in Sy. No. 31/4(Part) & 32(Part) of Village Casa-be-de-Sanquelim, Bicholim taluka by Sanquelim Municipal Council. (GCZMA/N/10-11/29).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle,

Case No. 7

Permission for berthing and operation of motor yatch/motor boats the property abutting Sy. No.31/4 of Penha da Franca in Bardez Taluka, by Mr. Agnelo J. Fernandes (GCZMA/N/10-11/ 27).

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, subject to the condition that the activity should not in any manner hamper the environment or violate the eco-sensitive area at site. Only temporary wooden structure are permitted to be erected.

Case No. 8

Proposed CRZ Clearance for Construction of Ice Plant in survey No. 76/P of Penha-da- Franca Village, Bardez Taluka, by M/s. Mandovi Fishermen, Co-op Marketing Society Malim, Fisheries Complex, Betim-Goa. (GCZMA/N/10-11/61).

Decision: The activity like Ice plant is permitted as per CRZ Notification for the existing fishing activity. The matter regarding regularizing the 03 structures erected should be decided separately by GCZMA sub-committee. On deciding the above matters, approval be conveyed.

Case No. 9

Proposed NOC for floating pontoon jetty and undertaking barge repairs along riverside adjoining Sy. No. 41/2 of village vaghurme, Ponda. by M/s. Sudarshan Dry Docks (GCZMA/N/09-10/67)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, to undertake the said activity only.

57.5

Item No. 6 (Cases of Roads / Public Access / Land Acquisition and Development by Government Departments)

Case No.1

NoC for Land Acquisition-Acquisition for implementation of the Sewerage scheme for Taleigao, Dona Paula and Caranzalem

Decision: Approved, in public interest.

57.6 Personal hearings: Case 1: in the matter of Chicalim Villagers Action Committee & Goa Foundation v/s State of Goa, GCZMA and others regarding permission granted to M/s. Pinky Shipyard at Chicalim.

Adv. E.O. Mendes present on behalf of M/s Pinky Shipyard. Dr. Borkar and Mr. Rui Araujo present on behalf of CVAC. CVAC sought time to respond and sought the NIO references / recommendations on the issue. Counsel for M/s Pinky Shipyard opposed the grant of additional time and sought for conclusion of the hearing. GCZMA members informed both the parties to place their arguments on the merits of the case and the Writ Petition which they have filed.

GCZMA decided that even though CVAC prayer for adjournment was devoid of substance, but in view of natural justice and directions of High Court; it opportunity of hearing, tentatively on 07/01/2011 (Friday) at 3.00 pm. Both the parties were also asked to file their written submissions along with copy of the Writ Petition. They were also asked to file advance copies of submission to other party before next date of hearing and also file counter reply if consider necessary.

Goa Foundation who has sought time through written application has been granted additional time.

Case 2: In the matter of the compliant filed by Shri. Khemlo Sawant, against illegal operation of jetties by M/s. Sesa Goa at Amona, Bicholim – Goa.

Mr/ Khemlo Sawant complainant in the matter present. Adv. Ramani and officers of M/s Sesa Goa present. Mr. Sawant explained, in brief, his grievances and detailed that the operations of loading / unloading of mineral ore on the two jetties at Amona is illegal as the jetties are itself illegal with the construction being carried out without any permissions from the authorities concerned. He claimed that all certificates given by M/s Sesa Goa have been fabricated and are bogus in nature.

Adv. Ramani stated that the matter or complaint is made is in respect of two jetties where mineral ore transportation takes place. He stated that jetties are permitted from 1969 by the Captain of Ports and that they have undertaken renovation of the jetties in 1987. As per the Captain of Ports rules they have paid dues for use of riverine land on 24/10/1996.

When GCZMA questioned the veracity of 1969, Captain of Ports letter and plans annexed to it, approved if any, it was informed that the plans have been misplaced in their Office and during transmission period since last 40 years and that they would provide the same after search.

Adv. Ramani denied the charges made by Shri Khemlo Sawant while the complainant further alleged that the Company is generating fraudulent documents. He pointed out to the plan for dredging in which police case is filed.

GCZMA directed M/s Sesa Goa, to provide relevant documents, approved plans of jetties for construction (1969) and repairs (1987) and other documents. Hearing adjourned to the next date.

57.7 Any other matters.

1. MS, GCZMA explained the functioning of GCZMA since the last meeting held on 29/08/2010 and the decisions taken during that time. Dr. A. G. Untawale, Member, GCZMA sought information on the complaints made regarding illegal felling of mangroves at entrance to Panaji,Merces and Ribander. Besides the illegal cutting of sand dune vegetation at Miramar. MS, informed that the Police complaint has been filed and Dy. Collector (Tiswadi) is currently inquiring in the matter.

2. Chairman (GCZMA) brought to the notice the matter regarding CRZ issues raised during security Co-Ordination Meeting on Coastal Security Chaired by Hon’ble Home Minister. It was explained the GCZMA has taken necessary steps in consultation with Director

(Panchayats). Various matters regarding illegal construction in Canacona beach belt have been stayed either by Appellate Authority or the Hon’ble High Court and they are currently sub- judice. In Canacona there are temporary wooden structures and tents / shacks put up by traditional inhabitants which are permissible activities and which the Police are seeking removal citing security concerns and law and order problems. Chairman (GCZMA) directed that appropriate reply be send to Home Department highlighting the facts in these cases.

3. MS, GCZMA sought the approval of GCZMA to constitute a teams of 03 members of GCZMA each to conduct spot inspections or violation and direct action immediately at site under the authority of GCZMA. All such decisions taken would be ratified in the ensuring meetings of GCZMA full body. This was approved. GCZMA decided to review the 05 member sub- committee to hear all cases pertaining to violations of CRZ with full authority of GCZMA on fortnightly basis. The decisions shall be ratified in the next ensuing GCZMA meeting and orders issued thereafter.

57.8 Additional Items

57.8.1

Item No. 1 (Construction/Reconstruction/Development in CRZ-II Area).

Case No. 1

Proposed re-construction of building in Chalta No. 31 of P.T. sheet No. 88 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Allan E. Dias (GCZMA/S/10-11/ 51).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines

Case No.2

Proposed construction of residential building in Chalta Nos. 227 & 228 of P.T. sheet No. 152 of Vasco city, Mormugao Taluka, by Mr. Sagar Gurudas Nayak (GCZMA/S/10-11/52).

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/MPDA and local authority guidelines

Case No. 3

Proposed construction of new office building for works division (Bldg.), PWD at Patto Panaji and in Chalta Nos. 35 & 36 of PTS No. 34 of Panaji city, Tiswadi Taluka.(GCZMA/N/10-11/64)

Decision: Approved, subject that the construction should be in accordance with the local building byelaws and in accordance with TCP/NGPDA and local authority guidelines

57.8.2

Item No. 2 (Repair & Renovation/Development in CRZ-III Area).

Case No. 1

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. No. 82/11 of Nagorcem-Palolem village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Ravi Y. Komarpant (GCZMA/S/10-11/40).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 2

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. No. 83/2 of Nagorcem-Palolem village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Mariano Fernandes (GCZMA/S/10-11/41).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 3

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. No. 5/9 of Loliem village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Gonzalo Vicente Pinto (GCZMA/S/10-11/43).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 4

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. No. 137/10 of Agonda village, Canacona Taluka, by Mrs. Fatima Fernandes (GCZMA/S/10-11/45).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 5

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. No. 124/15 of Nagorcem-Palolem village, Canacona Taluka, by Mr. Francisco Fernandes (GCZMA/S/10-11/30).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 6

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house in Sy. No. 19/3 of Pale village, Mormugao Taluka, by Smt. Antonetta Fernandes (GCZMA/S/10-11/ 47).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 7

Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house in Sy. No. 230/15 of Mandrem village, Pernem Taluka, by Mr. Naresh K. Raina C/o Mr. Albert D’Souza (GCZMA/N/10- 11/66).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 8 Proposed reconstruction/repairs and renovation of existing structure in Sy. No. 119/3 of Morjim village, Pernem Taluka, By Mr. Prabhakar S. Naik (GCZMA/N/09-10 /54) Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 9 Proposed reconstruction/repairs and renovation of existing structure in Sy. No. 230/15-A of Madrem village, Pernem Taluka, By Mrs. R.R. Borkar (GCZMA/N/08-09/76) Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 10 Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house bearing No. 353 in Sy. No. 119/10-13 of Agonda village, Canacona Taluka, by Mrs. Sarita Sanjay Bandekar (GCZMA/S/10- 11/42).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 11 Proposed repairs and renovation of the existing house bearing No. 170 in Sy. No. 36/5 & 6 of Nagorcem-Palolem in CanaconaTaluka, Mr. Anthony/Antonio Manuel Gracias (GCZMA/S/10-11/25) Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 12

Proposed repairs and renovation of existing house and wire fencing bearing no. 253 in Sy. No. 185/33 of Morjim village, Pernem Taluka, by Mr. Pradip M. Ambiye (GCZMA / N / 10-11 /56).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 13

Proposed repairs and re-construct of existing ruin house in Sy. No. 272/7 of Madrem village, Pernem Taluka, by Mrs. Piedade Fernandes (GCZMA / N / 10-11 /45).

Decision : Approved from CRZ angle, permission for repairs and renovations granted subject to the condition that the plinth and FAR remain the same.

Case No. 14

Proposed repair existing compound wall and strengthening of retaining wall of the creek in survey no. 138/1(Part) of Benaulim village Salcete taluka, NUSI/ITF (GCZMA/S/10-11/48)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle,

Case no. 15

Proposed repairs of bund wall/retaining wall in Sy. No. 96/14 of Arambol Village, Pernem Taluka, by Laximikant Y. Parsekar (GCZMA/N/10-11/67)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle,

57.8.3

Item No. 3 (Wire fencing/Bio fencing/compound wall)

Case No. 1

Proposed wire fencing in Sy.No. 31/1 of Nagorcem-Palolem village, Canacona taluka, by Mr. Vijay Pai khot (GCZMA/S/10-11/49)

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that any traditional access should not be blocked. Wire fencing/bio fencing is permitted within CRZ-III area.

57.8.4

Item No. 5 (Other development / construction of jetty / Repair of barges / Dry-Docks / Regularisation/Dredging etc.)

Case No. 1

Regularisation of existing old ship repair yard in Cortalim village, Mormugao Taluka, by Shaparia Dock and Steel Co. Pvt. Ltd. (GCZMA/S/10-11/12)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle,

Case No. 2

Proposed construction of barge repairs and construction of Marine Vessels in Sancoale village, Mormugao Taluka by Framen Shipping Pvt. Ltd. (GCZMA/S/10-11/11)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle, subject to the condition that no permanent construction /reclamation / land filling allowed in the river area.

Case No. 3

Proposed dredging of the river Mandovi near existing jetty in Survey No.17/4 of Kttombi village, Bicholim taluka, by M/s. Bandekar Brothers Pvt. Ltd.(GCZMA/N/09-10/06)

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that dredged material should not be dumped within No Development Zone area (NDZ) of the river Mandovi.

Case No. 4

Proposed dredging across the sand bar at the mouth of river Chapora, Captain of Ports

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that dredged material should not be dumped within No Development Zone area (NDZ) of the river Chapora.

Case No. 5

Proposed dredging in the vicinity of St. Pedro-Diwar ferry route in the Mandovi River.

Decision: Approved, subject to the condition that dredged material should not be dumped within No Development Zone area (NDZ) of the river Mandovi.

57.8.5

Item No. 6 (Cases of Roads / Public Access / Land Acquisition and Development by Government Departments)

Case No. 1

Land Acquisition for construction of road from Goval to Nuvem in V.P. Cola of Canacona Taluka.(GCZMA/S/10-11/53)

Decision: Approved, in public interest.

Case No. 2

Land Acquisition for widening of existing road from Co-cochin bar to taligao road junction via Karo sankiv bridge including construction of bridges (2nos) at Karo sankov in St. cruz Constituency by Asst. Engineer, PWD(GCZMA/N/10-11/65)

Decision: Approved, in public interest.

Case No. 3

Construction of anti sea erosion works at Arambol Beach V.P. Arambol, by Executive Engineer (WRD), Panaji (GCZMA/N/10-11/62)

Decision: Approved,

Case No. 4

Proposed Acquisition of land for construction of road to Dadeshwar Temple at Narva VP Sao Mathias, Tiswadi Taluka in property bearing survey nos. 3/1(P), 46/3(P), 5(P),7/1(P),2(P),3(P) & 4(P)

Decision: Approved from CRZ angle,

57.8.6 Other matters.

Case no. 1 : Matter of India Oil Corporation, construction of retail outlet / shopping unit at M/s Heera Petroleum pump, Panaji.

MS, GCZMA explained the matter pursuant to the LAQ in Assembly. From the records available in file and the reply filed by IOC and petrol pump owner is it seen that, approval has been obtained from all Authorities. The area is in CRZ-II of CCP. This construction is on landward side of existing structure. GCZMA decided to drop the show cause notice and permit occupancy of the structure constructed. No additional constructions are allowed and fencing is required to be erected on mangrove side to prevent any damage to mangroves. No land filling allowed.

Case no. 2 : Matter of construction of Residential Complex at Colva village in Sy. no. 58/1, 2, 3 and 5 of Shri Agnel Alcasoas.

MS, GCZMA explained that the construction at site was approved in 1994 and construction commend for the 1 st phase of the complex which got completed. When 2 nd phase was to be constructed, TCP informs that the project proponent that the area is just touching 500 mts. CRZ line. The site was inspected by Engineer Pascoal Noronha, Member (GCZMA) who has seeen that the construction part on the landward side of the 500 m line. Since it is an ongoing construction, GCZMA decided to permit the same subject to the approval conveyed by TCP, as during the relevant time of approval, project site was totally outside 500 mts. CRZ area.

Case no. 3 : Matter of delineation of the land mass in river Zuari of M/s Crystal Island at Quelossim, Cortalim.

CRZ line was demarcated for the said land mass (island like structure) at Quellosim of M/s Crystal Island Ltd. The site was inspected jointly by Dr. Simon de Souza and DSLR. The area is low lying paddy (not cultivated) and marshy. It is eco-sensitive zone with mangroves fringe. M/s Crystal Island have sought to correct the delineation as given earlier.

GCZMA discussed the request and have found no substantive grounds enough to change / alter the delineation. Request rejected.

Case no. 4 : Additional shacks as per request of Director (Tourism).

MS, GCZMA and Director (Tourism) explained the request made by Hon’ble MLA’s of Siolim ( for 2 shacks at Anjuna / Vagator) and Mandrem ( for shacks at Gaudewada, Morjim). They explained that space for shacks are available and that some more can be permitted. It was

24 seen that the matter of shacks is presently before the Hon’ble High Court and that the number of shacks have been frozen for 03 years.

It was decided that spot site inspection should be carried out GCZMA sub-committee and matter referred to Hon’ble High Court with site feasibility report.

Case no. 5 : In the matter of permission granted for dry dock for one Mr. Raymond D’Sa, D’Sa Engineering at Cortalim.

MS, GCZMA explained that approval was conveyed by GCZMA for construction of dry- dock to one M/s D’Sa Engineering. The adjacent dry dock owner, M/s Vipul Shipping complained that M/s D’Sa Engineering has encroached in his area and that the dry dock is being built in riverine area besides there is no access to the land. GCZMA office held the approval in abeyance. Replies have been received from D’Sa Engineering. It is seen that Captain of Ports has allowed use of riverine land.

It was decided that spot inspection should be conducted by GCZMA sub-committee and approval reconveyed after confirming factual details at site.

Case no. 6: In the matter of illegal construction of road in the property of M/s Suvarna Bandekar and M/s Heritage Builders at Sernabatim in Sy. no. 16/4 by Mr. Govec Cardozo

MS, GCZMA explained the matter of complaints made regarding illegal construction in aforesaid area by the said Cardozo. The Dy. Collector (Salcete) report also indicate fresh road being made without approvals. This is a serious NDZ violation.

GCZMA directed that spot inspection should be conducted by GCZMA sub-committee and road removed. Other inspection to be carried out and action taken.

*********

58 th Meeting is Personal Hearing