203287 TP Final Vol 2.Ai
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
4.1 Overview4.1 4.1 Overview CHAPTER 4 WSIP Facility Projects – Setting and Impacts Chapter 4 Sections 4.1 Overview 4.11 Public Services and Utilities 4.2 Plans and Policies 4.12 Recreational Resources 4.3 Land Use and Visual Quality 4.13 Agricultural Resources 4.4 Geology, Soils, and Seismicity 4.14 Hazards 4.5 Hydrology and Water Quality 4.15 Energy Resources 4.6 Biological Resources 4.16 Collective Impacts Related to WSIP Facilities 4.7 Cultural Resources 4.17 Cumulative Effects 4.8 Traffic, Transportation, and Circulation (References included under each section) 4.9 Air Quality 4.10 Noise and Vibration 4.1 Overview This chapter addresses the Water System Improvement Program (WSIP) facility improvement projects described in Chapter 3, Section 3.9, and provides a program-level evaluation of the potential environmental impacts of constructing and operating each of the 22 regional WSIP facility projects. This overview section describes key aspects of the approach to analysis that applies to the program-level impact evaluation of WSIP facility projects. This chapter focuses only on the WSIP projects and does not address the effects of the proposed WSIP water supply and system operations through 2030, which are evaluated separately in Chapter 5. Chapter 5 addresses the effects of the proposed water supply and system operations on the Tuolumne River system, Alameda Creek system, Peninsula system, and Westside Basin Groundwater Resources. The Chapter 4 impact analysis is based on preliminary information about the individual projects that are proposed for implementation following approval of the WSIP. The project information presented is conceptual in nature, based on readily available information about the projects, types of facilities proposed, and their general site locations. This level of information is appropriate for this programmatic analysis of these projects. This chapter identifies the general types of impacts that could be expected to result from the individual projects, based on existing project SF Planning Department Case No. 2005.0159E 4.1-1 PEIR on SFPUC Water System Improvement Program / 203287 4. WSIP Facility Projects – Setting and Impacts Overview information. The information about the individual projects continues to evolve as data about the project sites, design, operation, and effects are refined. All projects will be examined in more detail at the project level. If the individual WSIP projects have additional significant impacts that were not addressed in this Program EIR, the San Francisco Planning Department will prepare EIRs or negative declarations to examine the site-specific and project-specific effects of the individual projects. More detailed information about the individual projects (i.e., construction plans as well as siting and operational details) will be considered in the project-level environmental documents. Sections 4.2 through 4.15 present program-level impacts associated with each WSIP facility project by environmental resource topic. Section 4.16 presents combined or collective impacts resulting from implementation of multiple WSIP facility projects, also organized by environmental resource topic. Section 4.17 presents cumulative impacts resulting from implementation of the WSIP as a whole in conjunction with other cumulative development. Scope of the WSIP Facility Impact Analysis This program-level impact analysis identifies the potential environmental effects of the individual WSIP projects based on general information about each project and project site(s). To date, many of the WSIP projects have been developed at the conceptual level only and only some projects have more detailed siting and design information. Accordingly, this program-level evaluation addresses all projects from a broad, overview perspective. It does not provide detailed, site- specific impact assessment of each project, but rather frames the nature and magnitude of the expected environmental impacts associated with the proposed WSIP projects. Based on these impacts, Chapter 6 identifies the appropriate program-level mitigation measures in general terms; these measures would be refined to specifically apply to each project as the projects are further developed. Since there are undetermined aspects of many of the WSIP projects at this stage of program planning, this Program Environmental Impact Report (PEIR) errs on the conservative side of impact significance determination and assumes that separate, project-level California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review would confirm the existing conditions and degree of impact. The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) is conducting detailed project development studies on many of the WSIP projects concurrent with preparation of the PEIR. For many of the WSIP projects, project-level CEQA review is being conducted or will be conducted as appropriate to provide additional information and analyses and further address the site-specific impacts outlined in this PEIR. The project-level analyses will consider whether additional project information changes the environmental impact determinations contained in the PEIR about the individual project, and whether the programmatic mitigation measures identified in this PEIR should be refined. Both project-level EIRs and negative declarations are being prepared or will be prepared for many of the WSIP projects. All projects will be assessed to determine whether additional environmental review is required. [Additional discussion on the appropriate level of detail for environmental analysis was prepared in response to comments on the Draft PEIR. Please refer to Section 14.4, Master Response on PEIR Appropriate Level of Analysis (Vol. 7, Chapter 14).] SF Planning Department Case No. 2005.0159E 4.1-2 PEIR on SFPUC Water System Improvement Program / 203287 4. WSIP Facility Projects – Setting and Impacts Overview Study Area for WSIP Regional Facility Projects The study area applicable to the WSIP facility projects discussed in this chapter extends from Oakdale Portal on the SFPUC regional water system, which is the easternmost location of any of the WSIP projects (i.e., the San Joaquin Pipeline System project, SJ-3), westward along the regional water system to San Francisco, which is the westernmost location of the WSIP projects. The study area for the WSIP facility projects includes the five regions described in Chapter 2, Section 2.2 and shown in Figure 2.1: the San Joaquin (SJ), Sunol Valley (SV), Bay Division (BD), Peninsula (PN), and San Francisco (SF) Regions (there are five regional WSIP projects located in both San Francisco and northern San Mateo County, overlapping with parts of the Peninsula Region). No WSIP facility projects are proposed east of Oakdale Portal in the Hetch Hetchy region of the regional system, so no discussion of this eastern region is provided in this chapter. The locations of the WSIP projects are shown in Figures 3.5a and 3.5b. In a few instances (i.e., Section 4.15, Energy Resources, and Section 4.16, Collective Impacts Related to WSIP Facilities), the impact analysis addresses impacts of the program area rather than the study area. The program area encompasses the entire area affected by the WSIP, from Hetch Hetchy Reservoir to San Francisco. WSIP Project Names Chapter 3, Table 3.10, describes each WSIP project and gives the complete project name and number. Throughout this chapter, the WSIP project names are abbreviated and the project number is also referenced. To aid the PEIR reader, a complete WSIP project list is presented as Figure 4.1-1. The list gives the full project names, abbreviated project names, and reference numbers and is organized by region. Proposed Project Sites The impact analysis in this PEIR is based on project description information provided by the SFPUC with respect to facility location and conceptual project construction and operation scenarios for each of the projects. This information is summarized in Chapter 3 and further detailed in Appendix C. In cases where the SFPUC has chosen a preferred site location for a particular project, each section in this chapter evaluates the impacts of the WSIP facility improvement projects at their preferred site locations (as listed in Table 3.12 in Chapter 3). Some WSIP projects have alternative locations (specified in Tables 3.10 and 3.11); impacts associated with potential project development at these alternative locations are not evaluated in this PEIR, although generic impacts for each type of facility that could apply to the alternative sites are described. Project location alternatives and alternative site design and layout would be evaluated as appropriate in the project-level CEQA evaluations for select WSIP projects. For some WSIP projects, specific project locations have not yet been developed. In these cases, the program-level analysis considers the range of alternatives presented and a reasonable worst-case scenario regarding the potential environmental impacts that could occur. SF Planning Department Case No. 2005.0159E 4.1-3 PEIR on SFPUC Water System Improvement Program / 203287 GUIDE TO NAMES AND NUMBERS OF WSIP FACILITY IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS SAN JOAQUIN REGION No. Project Title Abbreviated Project Title SJ-1 Advanced Disinfection Advanced Disinfection SJ-2 Lawrence Livermore Supply Improvements Lawrence Livermore SJ-3 San Joaquin Pipeline System SJPL System SJ-4 Rehabilitation of Existing San Joaquin Pipelines SJPL Rehabilitation SJ-5 Tesla Portal Disinfection Station Tesla Portal Disinfection SUNOL VALLEY REGION