The Introspective Peepshow: Consciousness and the 'Dreaded

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Introspective Peepshow: Consciousness and the 'Dreaded Bakker 1 The Introspective Peepshow: Consciousness and the ‘Dreaded Unknown Unknowns’ On February 12th, 2002, Secretary of Defence Donald Rumsfeld was famously asked in a DoD press conference about the American government’s failure to provide evidence regarding Iraq’s alleged provision of weapons of mass destruction to terrorist groups. His reply, which was lampooned in the media at the time, has since become something of a linguistic icon: [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that we know we don’t know. But there are also unknown unknowns; there are things we don’t know we don’t know.1 In 2003, this comment earned Rumsfeld the ‘Foot in Mouth Award’ from the British-based Plain English Campaign. Despite the scorn and hilarity it occasioned in mainstream culture at the time, the concept of unknown unknowns, or ‘unk-unk’ as it is sometimes called, has enjoyed long-standing currency in military and engineering circles. Only recently has it found its way to business and economics (in large part due to the work of Daniel Kahneman), where it is often referred to as the ‘dreaded unknown unknown.’ For enterprises involving risk, the reason for this dread is quite clear. Even in daily life, we speak of being ‘blind-sided,’ of things happening ‘out of the blue’ or coming ‘out of left field.’ Our institutions, like our brains, have evolved to manage and exploit environmental regularities. Since knowing everything is impossible, we have at our disposal any number of rehearsed responses, precooked ways to deal with ‘known unknowns,’ or irregularities that are regular enough to be anticipated. Unknown unknowns refer to those events that find us entirely unprepared–often with catastrophic consequences. Given that few human activities are quite so sedate or ‘risk free,’ unk-unk might seem out of place in the context of consciousness research and the philosophy of mind. But as I hope to show, such is not the case. The unknown unknown, I want to argue, has a profound role to play in developing our understanding of consciousness. Unfortunately, since the unknown unknown itself constitutes an unknown unknown within cognitive science, let alone consciousness research, the route required to make my case is necessarily circuitous. As John Dewey (1958) observed, “We cannot lay hold of the new, we cannot even keep it before our minds, much less understand it, save by the use of ideas and knowledge we already possess” (viii-ix). Blind-siding readers rarely pays. With this in mind, I begin with a critical consideration of Peter Carruthers (forthcoming, 2011, 2009a, 2009b, 2008) ‘innate self-transparency thesis,’ the account of introspection entailed by his more encompassing ‘mindreading first thesis’ (or as he calls it in The Opacity of the Mind (2011), Interpretative Sensory-Access Theory (ISA)). I hope to accomplish two things with this reading: 1) illustrate the way explanations in the cognitive sciences so often turn on issues of informatic tracking; and 2) elaborate an alternative to Carruthers’ innate self-transparency thesis that makes, in a preliminary fashion at least, the positive role played of the unknown unknown clear. Since what I propose subsequent to this first leg of the article can only sound preposterous short of this preliminary, I will commit the essayistic sin (and rhetorical virtue) of leaving my final conclusions unstated–as a known unknown, worth mere curiosity, perhaps, but certainly not dread. 1 Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/There_are_known_knowns Bakker 2 Follow the Information Explanations in cognitive science generally adhere to the explanatory paradigm found in the life sciences: various operations are ‘identified’ and a variety of mechanisms, understood as systems of components or ‘working parts,’ are posited to discharge them (Bechtel and Abrahamson 2005, Bechtel 2008). In cognitive science in particular, the operations tend to be various cognitive capacities or conscious phenomena, and the components tend to be representations embedded in computational procedures that produce more representations. Theorists continually tear down and rebuild what are in effect virtual ‘explanatory machines,’ using research drawn from as many related fields as possible to warrant their formulations. Whether the operational outputs are behavioural, epistemic, or phenomenal, these virtual machines inevitably involve asking what information is available for what component system or process. Let’s call this process of information tracking the ‘Follow the Information Game’ (FIG).2 In a superficial sense, playing FIG is not all that different from playing detective. In the case of criminal investigations, evidence is assembled and assessed, possible motives are considered, various parties to the crime are identified, and an overarching narrative account of who did what to whom is devised and, ideally, tested. In the case of cognitive investigations, evidence is likewise assembled and assessed, possible evolutionary ‘motives’ are considered, a number of contributing component mechanisms are posited, and an overarching mechanistic account what does what for what is devised for possible experimental testing. The ‘doing’ invariably involves discharging some computational function, processing and disseminating information for subsequent computation. The theorist quite literally ‘follows the information’ from mechanism to mechanism, using a complex stew of evolutionary rationales, experimental results, and neuropathological case studies to warrant the various specifics of the resulting theoretical account. We see this quite clearly in the mindreading versus metacognition debate, where the driving question is one of how we attribute propositional attitudes to ourselves as opposed to others. Do we have direct ‘metacognitive’ access to our beliefs and desires? Is mindreading a function of metacognition? Is metacognition a function of mindreading? Or are they simply different channels of a singular mechanism? Any answer to these questions requires mapping the flow of information, which is to say, playing FIG. This is why, for example, Peter Carruthers’ “How we know our own minds” and the following Open Peer Commentary read like transcripts of the diplomatic feuding behind the Treaty of Versailles. It’s an issue of mapping, but instead of arguing coal mines in Silesia and ports on the Baltic, the question is one of how the brain’s informatic spoils are divided. Carruthers holds forth a ‘mindreading first’ account, arguing that our self-attributions of PAs rely on the same interpretative mechanisms we use to ‘mind read’ the PAs of others: There is just a single metarepresentational faculty, which probably evolved in the first instance for purposes of mindreading... In order to do its work, it needs to have access to perceptions of the environment. For if it is to interpret the actions of others, it plainly requires access to perceptual representations of those actions. Indeed, I suggest that, like most other conceptual systems, the mindreading system can receive as input any sensory or quasi-sensory (eg., imagistic or somatosensory) state that gets “globally broadcast” to all judgment-forming, memory-forming, desire-forming, and decision-making systems. (2009b, 3-4) 2 ‘Information’ is here understood in the broadest, nonsemantic sense of ‘systematic differences making systematic differences.’ Bakker 3 In this article, he provides a preliminary draft of the informatic map he subsequently fleshes out in The Opacity of the Mind. He takes Baars (1988) Global Workspace Theory of Consciousness as a primary assumption, which requires him to distinguish between information that is and is not ‘globally broadcast.’ Consistent with the massive modularity endorsed in The Architecture of the Mind (2006), he posits a variety of informatically ‘encapsulated’ mechanisms operating ‘subpersonally’ or outside conscious access. The ‘mindreading system,’ not surprisingly, is accorded the most attention. Other mechanisms, when not directly recruited from preexisting cognitive scientific sources, are posited to explain various folk-psychological categories, such as belief.3 The tenability of these mechanisms turns on what might be called the ‘Accomplishment Assumption,’ the notion that all aspects of mental life that can be (or as in the case of folk psychology, already are) individuated are the accomplishments of various discrete neural mechanisms. Given these mechanisms, Carruthers makes a number of ‘access inferences,’ each turning on the kinds of information required for each mechanism to discharge its function. To interpret the actions of others, the mindreading system needs access to information regarding those actions, which means it needs access to those systems dedicated to gathering that information. Given the apparently radical difference between self and other interpretation, Carruthers needs to delineate the kind of access characteristic of each: Although the mindreading system has access to perceptual states, the proposal is that it lacks any access to the outputs of the belief-forming and decision-making mechanisms that feed off those states. Hence, self-attributions of propositional attitude events like judging and deciding are always the result of a swift (and unconscious) process of self- interpretation. However, it isn’t just the subject’s overt behavior and physical circumstances that provide the basis for the interpretation. Data about perceptions, visual
Recommended publications
  • Pet Shop Boys Introspective (Introspectivo) Mp3, Flac, Wma
    Pet Shop Boys Introspective (Introspectivo) mp3, flac, wma DOWNLOAD LINKS (Clickable) Genre: Electronic Album: Introspective (Introspectivo) Country: Ecuador Released: 1988 Style: Synth-pop MP3 version RAR size: 1773 mb FLAC version RAR size: 1773 mb WMA version RAR size: 1819 mb Rating: 4.9 Votes: 443 Other Formats: MP3 MMF ASF ADX AHX AC3 VQF Tracklist Hide Credits Hago Lo Que Se Me Antoja (Left To My Own Devices) A1 Producer – Stephen Lipson, Trevor HornVocals – Sally Bradshaw Quiero Un Perro (I Want A Dog) A2 Mixed By – Frankie Knuckles La Danza Del Dominó (Domino Dancing) A3 Mixed By – Lewis A. Martineé, Mike Couzzi, Rique AlonsoProducer – Lewis A. Martineé No Tengo Miedo (I'm Not Scared) B1 Producer – David Jacob (Siempre En Mi Mente / En Mi Casa) (Always On My Mind / In My House) B2 Producer – Julian MendelsohnWritten-By – Christopher*, James*, Thompson* Está Bien (It's Alright) B3 Producer – Stephen Lipson, Trevor HornWritten-By – Sterling Void Companies, etc. Manufactured By – Ifesa Distributed By – Fonorama Other versions Category Artist Title (Format) Label Category Country Year PCS 7325, 79 Pet Shop Introspective (LP, Parlophone, PCS 7325, 79 UK 1988 0868 1 Boys Album) Parlophone 0868 1 Pet Shop Introspectivo (Cass, 66312 EMI 66312 Argentina 1988 Boys Album, RE) Pet Shop Introspectivo (Cass, 20059 EMI 20059 Argentina 1988 Boys Album) 080 79 0868 Parlophone, 080 79 0868 Pet Shop Introspective (LP, 1, 080 7 EMI, 1, 080 7 Spain Unknown Boys Album) 90868 1 Parlophone, EMI 90868 1 Introspective (CD, Pet Shop Not On Label 13421 Album,
    [Show full text]
  • Flowers for Algernon.Pdf
    SHORT STORY FFlowerslowers fforor AAlgernonlgernon by Daniel Keyes When is knowledge power? When is ignorance bliss? QuickWrite Why might a person hesitate to tell a friend something upsetting? Write down your thoughts. 52 Unit 1 • Collection 1 SKILLS FOCUS Literary Skills Understand subplots and Reader/Writer parallel episodes. Reading Skills Track story events. Notebook Use your RWN to complete the activities for this selection. Vocabulary Subplots and Parallel Episodes A long short story, like the misled (mihs LEHD) v.: fooled; led to believe one that follows, sometimes has a complex plot, a plot that con- something wrong. Joe and Frank misled sists of intertwined stories. A complex plot may include Charlie into believing they were his friends. • subplots—less important plots that are part of the larger story regression (rih GREHSH uhn) n.: return to an earlier or less advanced condition. • parallel episodes—deliberately repeated plot events After its regression, the mouse could no As you read “Flowers for Algernon,” watch for new settings, charac- longer fi nd its way through a maze. ters, or confl icts that are introduced into the story. These may sig- obscure (uhb SKYOOR) v.: hide. He wanted nal that a subplot is beginning. To identify parallel episodes, take to obscure the fact that he was losing his note of similar situations or events that occur in the story. intelligence. Literary Perspectives Apply the literary perspective described deterioration (dih tihr ee uh RAY shuhn) on page 55 as you read this story. n. used as an adj: worsening; declining. Charlie could predict mental deterioration syndromes by using his formula.
    [Show full text]
  • A Meditation on Boredom
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by UEL Research Repository at University of East London Running head: A MEDITATION ON BOREDOM A meditation on boredom: Re-appraising its value through introspective phenomenology Dr. Tim Lomas, University of East London, School of Psychology, [email protected] Note: This article may not exactly replicate the final version published in Psychology, Public Policy, and Law. It is not the copy of record. 2 Running head: A MEDITATION ON BOREDOM Abstract Boredom is almost universally regarded as a dysphoric mental state, characterised by features such as disengagement and low arousal. However, in certain quarters (e.g., Zen Buddhism), boredom is seen as potentially having great value and even importance. The current study sought to explore boredom through a case study involving introspective phenomenology. The author created conditions in which he would experience boredom for an hour, and recorded his experience in real-time using a variant of the Experiencing Sampling Method. The data were analysed using an adaptation of Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis. The results indicated that the state of boredom contained three main sources of value: (a) altered perception of time; (b) awakened curiosity about the environment; and (c) exploration of self. Consequently, the paper offers a re-appraisal of boredom, suggesting that rather than necessarily being a negative state, if engaged with, boredom has the potential to be a positive and rewarding experience. Keywords: boredom; meditation; phenomenology; introspection; wellbeing. 3 Running head: A MEDITATION ON BOREDOM The problem of boredom Boredom is almost universally regarded as a negative mental state.
    [Show full text]
  • The Art of Thinking Clearly
    For Sabine The Art of Thinking Clearly Rolf Dobelli www.sceptrebooks.co.uk First published in Great Britain in 2013 by Sceptre An imprint of Hodder & Stoughton An Hachette UK company 1 Copyright © Rolf Dobelli 2013 The right of Rolf Dobelli to be identified as the Author of the Work has been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means without the prior written permission of the publisher, nor be otherwise circulated in any form of binding or cover other than that in which it is published and without a similar condition being imposed on the subsequent purchaser. A CIP catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library. eBook ISBN 978 1 444 75955 6 Hardback ISBN 978 1 444 75954 9 Hodder & Stoughton Ltd 338 Euston Road London NW1 3BH www.sceptrebooks.co.uk CONTENTS Introduction 1 WHY YOU SHOULD VISIT CEMETERIES: Survivorship Bias 2 DOES HARVARD MAKE YOU SMARTER?: Swimmer’s Body Illusion 3 WHY YOU SEE SHAPES IN THE CLOUDS: Clustering Illusion 4 IF 50 MILLION PEOPLE SAY SOMETHING FOOLISH, IT IS STILL FOOLISH: Social Proof 5 WHY YOU SHOULD FORGET THE PAST: Sunk Cost Fallacy 6 DON’T ACCEPT FREE DRINKS: Reciprocity 7 BEWARE THE ‘SPECIAL CASE’: Confirmation Bias (Part 1) 8 MURDER YOUR DARLINGS: Confirmation Bias (Part 2) 9 DON’T BOW TO AUTHORITY: Authority Bias 10 LEAVE YOUR SUPERMODEL FRIENDS AT HOME: Contrast Effect 11 WHY WE PREFER A WRONG MAP TO NO
    [Show full text]
  • Starr-Waterman American Popular Music Chapter 11: the 1970S: Rock Music, Disco, and the Popular Mainstream Key People Allman
    Starr-Waterman American Popular Music Chapter 11: The 1970s: Rock Music, Disco, and the Popular Mainstream Key People Allman Brothers Band: Most important southern rock band of the late 1960s and early 1970s who reconnected the generative power of the blues to the mainstream of rock music. Barry White (1944‒2004): Multitalented African American singer, songwriter, arranger, conductor, and producer who achieved success as an artist in the 1970s with his Love Unlimited Orchestra; perhaps best known for his full, deep voice. Carlos Santana (b. 1947): Mexican-born rock guitarist who combined rock, jazz, and Afro-Latin elements on influential albums like Abraxas. Carole King (b. 1942): Singer-songwriter who recorded influential songs in New York’s Brill Building and later recorded the influential album Tapestry in 1971. Charlie Rich (b. 1932): Country performer known as the “Silver Fox” who won the Country Music Association’s Entertainer of the Year award in 1974 for his song “The Most Beautiful Girl.” Chic: Disco group who recorded the hit “Good Times.” Chicago: Most long-lived and popular jazz rock band of the 1970s, known today for anthemic love songs such as “If You Leave Me Now” (1976), “Hard to Say I’m Sorry” (1982), and “Look Away” (1988). David Bowie (1947‒2016): Glam rock pioneer who recorded the influential album The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars in 1972. Dolly Parton (b. 1946): Country music star whose flexible soprano voice, songwriting ability, and carefully crafted image as a cheerful sex symbol combined to gain her a loyal following among country fans.
    [Show full text]
  • Valuing Thoughts, Ignoring Behavior: the Introspection Illusion As a Source of the Bias Blind Spot ଝ
    Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 43 (2007) 565–578 www.elsevier.com/locate/jesp Valuing thoughts, ignoring behavior: The introspection illusion as a source of the bias blind spot ଝ Emily Pronin ¤, Matthew B. Kugler Department of Psychology, Green Hall, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA Received 3 September 2005; revised 16 May 2006 Available online 20 July 2006 Communicated by Fiedler Abstract People see themselves as less susceptible to bias than others. We show that a source of this bias blind spot involves the value that people place, and believe they should place, on introspective information (relative to behavioral information) when assessing bias in themselves versus others. Participants considered introspective information more than behavioral information for assessing bias in themselves, but not others. This divergence did not arise simply from diVerences in introspective access. The blind spot persisted when observers had access to the introspections of the actor whose bias they judged. And, participants claimed that they, but not their peers, should rely on introspections when making self-assessments of bias. Only after being educated about the importance of nonconscious processes in guiding judgment and action—and thereby about the fallibility of introspection—did participants cease denying their relative susceptibility to bias. © 2006 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Keywords: Bias blind spot; Introspection illusion; Self—other; Nonconscious inXuences; Self-perception In a recent news story, a federal judge defended his ability The tendency to see bias in others, while being blind to it to be objective in handling a case involving a long-time friend. in ourselves, has been shown across a range of cognitive In another story, government scientists defended their impar- and motivational biases (for a review, see Pronin, Gilovich, tiality in evaluating drug companies from whom they received & Ross, 2004).
    [Show full text]
  • Clarifying Translanguaging and Deconstructing Named Languages: a Perspective from Linguistics
    Applied Linguistics Review 2015; 6(3): 281–307 Ricardo Otheguy*, Ofelia García and Wallis Reid Clarifying translanguaging and deconstructing named languages: A perspective from linguistics DOI 10.1515/applirev-2015-0014 Abstract: The concept of translanguaging is clarified, establishing it as a particular conception of the mental grammars and linguistic practices of bilinguals. Translanguaging is different from code switching. Under translanguaging, the mental grammars of bilinguals are structured but unitary collections of features, and the practices of bilinguals are acts of feature selection, not of grammar switch. A proper understanding of translanguaging requires a return to the well known but often forgotten idea that named languages are social, not linguistic, objects. Whereas the idiolect of a particular individual is a linguistic object defined in terms of lexical and structural features, the named language of a nation or social group is not; its boundaries and membership cannot be established on the basis of lexical and structural features. The two named languages of the bilingual exist only in the outsider’s view. From the insider’s perspective of the speaker, there is only his or her full idiolect or repertoire, which belongs only to the speaker, not to any named language. Translanguaging is the deployment of a speaker’sfull linguistic repertoire without regard for watchful adherence to the socially and politically defined boundaries of named (and usually national and state) languages. In schools, the translanguaging of bilinguals tends to be severely restricted. In addition, schools confuse the assessment of general linguistic proficiency, which is best manifested in bilinguals while translanguaging, with the testing of profi- ciency in a named language, which insists on inhibiting translanguaging.
    [Show full text]
  • Influencing Choice Without Awareness
    Consciousness and Cognition 37 (2015) 225–236 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Consciousness and Cognition journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/concog Influencing choice without awareness ⇑ Jay A. Olson a,c, , Alym A. Amlani b, Amir Raz a,c, Ronald A. Rensink d a Department of Psychiatry, 1033 Pine Avenue West, McGill University, Montreal, QC H3A 1A1, Canada b School of Business, Kwantlen Polytechnic University, Main Building, Room 206, 12666 72 Avenue, Surrey, BC V3W 2M8, Canada c The Lady Davis Institute at the SMDB Jewish General Hospital, Montreal, QC, Canada d Departments of Psychology and Computer Science, University of British Columbia, 2136 West Mall, Vancouver, BC V6T 1Z4, Canada article info abstract Article history: Forcing occurs when a magician influences the audience’s decisions without their aware- Received 18 July 2014 ness. To investigate the mechanisms behind this effect, we examined several stimulus Available online 7 February 2015 and personality predictors. In Study 1, a magician flipped through a deck of playing cards while participants were asked to choose one. Although the magician could influence the Keywords: choice almost every time (98%), relatively few (9%) noticed this influence. In Study 2, par- Forcing ticipants observed rapid series of cards on a computer, with one target card shown longer Magic than the rest. We expected people would tend to choose this card without noticing that it Volition was shown longest. Both stimulus and personality factors predicted the choice of card, Free will Decision making depending on whether the influence was noticed. These results show that combining Sense of agency real-world and laboratory research can be a powerful way to study magic and can provide Persuasion new methods to study the feeling of free will.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Indie', Or Alternative, Are Band
    Exemplar for internal assessment resource Music for Achievement Standard 91425 When did it become so popular and how? The first ‘Indie’ bands which defined the genre ‘Indie’, or Alternative, are bands such as REM, The Smiths, Husker Du and Sonic Youth, These bands were commonly played in the United Kingdom and the United States during the 1980’s on various college radio stations. College radio stations played a huge part in the ‘Indie’ music scene. It was one of the only ways one could hear previously unknown or experimental music as a lot of it was not played on mainstream radio. For example, to this day 95bFM are a successful college driven radio station which have been around since 1969. It started as a pirate college radio station which broadcast from a boat in Auckland’s Waitemata harbour. These college radio stations effectively started the ‘Indie’ movement and scene, which created a huge devoted following. The development of the ‘Indie’ scene is also likely due to the number of subgenres which fit under the Alternative or ‘Indie’ genre, for example Shoegaze (commonly based around guitar effects and their ‘droning riffs’ and given the name due to guitarists looking at their feet whilst playing; this is due to guitar effects pedals and their non-confronting and introspective nature), Garage Punk (characterised by a dirty overdriven choppy guitar sound; not as politically driven as most Punk bands) and Grunge (originated in Seattle; commonly called the Seattle sound, it’s a fusion of Punk, Heavy Metal and Alternative music). You can see from the top selling albums throughout the 80’s until today that the volume of ‘Indie’ bands increased dramatically.
    [Show full text]
  • Cage the Elephant's Social Cues Is out Today on Rca
    CAGE THE ELEPHANT’S SOCIAL CUES IS OUT TODAY ON RCA RECORDS WATCH THEIR PERFORMANCE ON LATE NIGHT WITH STEPHEN COLBERT HERE CAGE THE ELEPHANT AND BECK THE NIGHT RUNNING CO-HEADLINING TOUR BEGINS THIS JULY (New York —April 19, 2019) Today, Cage The Elephant has released their fifth studio album, Social Cues, out now on RCA Records. Fans can stream/purchase the album HERE. Social Cues was produced by John Hill (Santigold, Florence + The Machine, Portugal. The Man, tUnE- yArDs), recorded at Battle Tapes Recording, Blackbird Studio and Sound Emporium in Nashville and The Village Recording Studio in Los Angeles. It was mixed by Tom Elmhirst and mastered by Randy Merrill in New York City. To mark the album’s release, the band appeared on Late Night With Stephen Colbert last night, performing their single, “Ready To Let Go.” Watch their performance HERE. “Ready To Let Go,” remains #1 at Alternative Radio in both the US and Canada, marking the band’s 8th Alternative #1. Cage The Elephant has achieved more #1s at the format than any band this decade. Photo Credit: Neil Krug This summer, Cage The Elephant and Beck will head out on their co-headlining, The Night Running Tour in North America. Spoon will open all dates as a special guest with additional support from Starcrawler, Sunflower Bean and Wild Belle in select cities. The two artists collaborated on the single “Night Running,” that appears on Social Cues. Full dates below. Tickets are on sale now at LiveNation.com. Beck and Cage The Elephant have partnered up with PLUS1 and $1 from every ticket sold will be donated back into each city they are playing in, supporting local food security initiatives as they work towards ending hunger in their communities.
    [Show full text]
  • Alone in a Crowd of Sheep: Asymmetric Perceptions of Conformity and Their Roots in an Introspection Illusion
    University of Pennsylvania ScholarlyCommons Marketing Papers Wharton Faculty Research 4-2007 Alone in a Crowd of Sheep: Asymmetric Perceptions of Conformity and Their Roots in an Introspection Illusion Emily Pronin Jonah A. Berger University of Pennsylvania Sarah Molouki Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.upenn.edu/marketing_papers Part of the Cognition and Perception Commons, Cognitive Psychology Commons, Community Psychology Commons, Interpersonal and Small Group Communication Commons, Marketing Commons, Social Influence and oliticalP Communication Commons, and the Social Psychology Commons Recommended Citation Pronin, E., Berger, J. A., & Molouki, S. (2007). Alone in a Crowd of Sheep: Asymmetric Perceptions of Conformity and Their Roots in an Introspection Illusion. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 92 (4), 585-595. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.92.4.585 This paper is posted at ScholarlyCommons. https://repository.upenn.edu/marketing_papers/292 For more information, please contact [email protected]. Alone in a Crowd of Sheep: Asymmetric Perceptions of Conformity and Their Roots in an Introspection Illusion Abstract The results of 5 studies showed that people see others as more conforming than themselves. This asymmetry was found to occur in domains ranging from consumer purchases to political views. Participants claimed to be less susceptible than their average peers to broad descriptions of social influences, and they also claimed to be less susceptible than specific peers ot specific instances of conformity. These studies further demonstrated that this asymmetry is not simply the result of social desirability, but it is also rooted in people's attention to introspective versus behavioral information when making conformity assessments.
    [Show full text]
  • Omission Neglect and the Bias Blind Spot: Effects of the Self-Other Asymmetry in Susceptibility to Bias and Responsiveness to Debiasing
    Omission Neglect and the Bias Blind Spot: Effects of the Self-Other Asymmetry in Susceptibility to Bias and Responsiveness to Debiasing A dissertation submitted to the Division of Research and Advanced Studies of the University of Cincinnati In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY (PH.D.) IN THE DEPARTMENT OF MARKETING of the College of Business 2011 By Xiaoqi Han M.A., Marquette University Committee Chair: Frank R. Kardes, Ph.D. i ABSTRACT Omission Neglect and the Bias Blind Spot: Effects of the Self-Other Asymmetry in Susceptibility to Bias and Responsiveness to Debiasing By Xiaoqi Han Chair: Dr. Frank R. Kardes Research on the bias blind spot shows that people are less capable of identifying biases in their own judgment than in others. People generally believe that they are less susceptible to biases than their peers and average people. This dissertation investigates the self-other bias asymmetry with respect to omission neglect. Omission neglect refers to insensitivity to missing or unknown information. Results from bias blind spot research imply a potential relationship between the self-other asymmetry in bias belief and omission neglect. Research on bias correction suggests that people holding a higher degree of asymmetry in bias beliefs may be less likely to correct biases even when omissions are made noticeable. Ironically, consumers who believe that they are less vulnerable to omission neglect may be more susceptible to omission neglect. Consumers may be also less likely to correct their judgment even when omitted information is made noticeable. The goal of the dissertation is to develop debiasing techniques to debias omission neglect in order to improve consumer judgment and decision making.
    [Show full text]