Dance on Screen This page intentionally left blank on Screen Genres and Media from Hollywood to Experimental Art

Sherril Dodds Lecturer in Dance Studies Department of Dance Studies University of Surrey © Sherril Dodds 2001

All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted her right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2001 by PALGRAVE Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N. Y. 10010 Companies and representatives throughout the world PALGRAVE is the new global academic imprint of St. Martin’s Press LLC Scholarly and Reference Division and Palgrave Publishers Ltd (formerly Macmillan Press Ltd). ISBN 978-1-4039-4145-9 ISBN 978-0-230-50958-0 (eBook) DOI 10.1057/9780230509580 This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Dodds, Sherril, 1967– Dance on screen : genres and media from Hollywood to experimental art / Sherril Dodds. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index.

1. Dance in motion pictures, television, etc. I. Title. GV1779 .D63 2001 791.43’655—dc21 00–069217

10987654321 10 09 08 07 06 05 04 03 02 01 For Hazel and Dick Dodds This page intentionally left blank Contents

List of Plates ix

Preface xi

Acknowledgements xv

1 Dance on Screen: A Contextual Framework 1 Visual culture in the late twentieth century 1 Histories of dance on screen 4 Screen dance and critical perspectives 16 A focus on screen dance practitioners 22 The live body and the screen body: a technical comparison 29

2 Images of Dance in the Screen Media 36 Hollywood dance films: popular representations of dance 37 Television advertising and dancing bodies 44 Dance and pop music video: a musicology of the image 49 The translation of theatre dance to screen 56 Early dance for the camera 62

3 Video Dance: Televisualizing the Dancing Body 68 An introduction to video dance 68 Manipulating the dancing body on screen 71 Choreographic content in video dance 80 The dance of the camera and the cut 89

4 Strategies on Television 95 Dance, television and postmodernism 95 Breaking the realist code 98 Fragmented narratives and episodic structures 106 The performing body 113 Seizing the spectator’s eye 120

5 Hybrid Sites and Fluid Bodies 126 Video dance and hybridity 126 Video dance, television advertising and music video 127 The consumer body and the promotional network 135

vii viii Contents

Discourses of technology: the technophobic and the technophilic 146 The mechanical body 153 The digital body 159 The fluid body: transgression and disruption 169

Appendix: List of Works Discussed in Chapters 3 and 4 175

Notes 177

Bibliography 186

Index 194 List of Plates

1 Hands Choreographer: Jonathan Burrows, Director: Adam Roberts, 1996 © Arts Council of England and BBC Television 2 Alistair Fish Choreographer: Aletta Collins, Director: Tom Cairns, 1995 © Arts Council of England and BBC Television 3 Touched Choreographer: Wendy Houstoun, Director: David Hinton, 1995 © Arts Council of England and BBC Television 4 Drip Choreographer: Matthew Bourne, Director: Frances Dickenson, 1996 © Arts Council of England and BBC Television 5 Dwell Time Choreographer: Siobhan Davies, Director: David Buckland, 1996 © Arts Council of England and BBC Television 6 Storm Choreographer: Aletta Collins, Director: Tom Cairns, 1996 © Arts Council of England and BBC Television 7 Man Act Choreographers: Man Act, Director: Mike Stubbs, 1996 © Arts Council of England and BBC Television 8 boy Choreographer: Rosemary Lee, Director: Peter Anderson, 1996 © Photograph: Margaret Williams, MJW Productions 9 Spectre de la Rose Choreographer: , Director: Margaret Williams, 1994 © Photograph: Margaret Williams, MJW Productions

ix This page intentionally left blank Preface

In writing this book I hope to offer the reader an opportunity to delve into the wealth and breadth of dance practices on screen. The material for the book came out of my doctoral research (Dodds, 1997) but my interest in the screen media has a much longer history. As an under- graduate student I was introduced to the art films of Peter Greenaway, in particular Drowning by Numbers (1988). The film is less concerned with action-driven narrative than with an opulent visual play. Not only do a series of quirky games litter the plot, but Greenaway also inscribes the film with puns, jokes and witty references. The screen is like a canvas for pastoral images in which corpses, fireworks and num- bers are integrated into the landscape. What struck me was the pri- macy of formal structuring devices and compositional concerns. During my MA studies, video became an essential tool for studying dance irrespective of its ephemeral nature or geographical locality. The easy accessibility of video allowed me to see Swedish choreographer Mats Ek’s radical reworking of Swan Lake (1987) with its bald-headed, flat-footed swans. It was also during this period that I became aware of how the screen could take dance out of the theatre into alternative locations and new environments. Over and over again I watched the radical juxtaposition of people and settings in Pina Bausch’s The Lament of the Empress (1989): a man carrying a wardrobe across a field; a bunny girl stumbling over ploughed land; and a woman sitting smoking on an armchair in the middle of a busy highway. Similarly, Lea Anderson’s Perfect Moment (1992) introduced me to the versatility that the camera could bring to dance through constructing images that could only exist on screen. As a student I was intrigued by these multi- ple platforms for dance, especially with regard to how the screen opened up new choreographic possibilities. It is not just dance that fascinates me. I am an avid spectator of all forms of screen media: reruns of The Simpsons, the latest Woody Allen film or just browsing around the World Wrestling Federation web site. It is this vocabulary of popular and art media images that informs how I look at dance on screen. Unfortunately, at present there is a lack of scholarly writing on the subject. Although a clutch of referee journal articles and features in popular magazines are in print, there is a dearth of reference texts that deal with the area of screen dance. The most

xi xii Preface recent is Parallel Lines: Media Representations of Dance (Jordan and Allen, 1993). This anthology provides a valuable collection of articles on a diverse range of subjects; however, since its publication there has been a proliferation of dance works made specifically for the screen, an area which is only touched upon in Parallel Lines. I sense this situation might change, however. As a field of academic study, dance on screen is rapidly evolving. I am increasingly coming into contact with other scholars interested in this area and there are numerous students keen either to write dissertations on the subject or else to create their own dance films. Promising developments are taking place in higher educa- tion. A number of departments now run modules or courses in ‘dance in the media’ or ‘’ and this type of institutional recog- nition firmly places screen dance within a scholarly framework. This comment is not intended to undermine or disregard the artistic context out of which screen dance emerges; rather it is a call for a critical dia- logue that can allow practitioners, students and scholars to analyse, interpret and evaluate this rich field of dance practice. It therefore appears to be a prime time for a text devoted to the sub- ject of dance on screen. This book sets out to provide a comprehensive introduction to the diversity of screen dance forms through cultural, economic, critical, artistic, historical, technical and theoretical perspec- tives. Although the book primarily addresses images of dance on film and television, in acknowledgement of the related and rapidly expand- ing area of digital screen dance, developments in this field form a small part of the discussion. Chapter 1 commences with an overview of the cultural context in which contemporary screen dance is situated, and considers some of the different rationales and approaches to putting dance on screen. It traces the historical developments of the field, from the early flickering dance films at the beginning of the century, through the advent of television, to the recent experimentation between dance and digital media. This lineage is followed by an exam- ination of the current artistic context in which screen dance is located, contrasting the writings of dance critics with the views of screen dance practitioners. To bring this chapter to a close, a technical examination of the ‘screen’ is undertaken to provide the groundwork for the case studies that follow. Chapter 2 offers some rich examples of the field in practice in order to address the diverse ways in which the screen media have dealt with the dancing body. The chapter begins at the commer- cial end of screen dance by looking at 1980s Hollywood dance films, television advertising and music video. From this consumerist imagery the remainder of the chapter turns to art dance on television. It deals Preface xiii both with television adaptations of stage dance and early examples of dance made for the camera. Whereas the first two chapters provide a general introduction to dance on screen, the remaining chapters focus specifically on dance that is conceived and choreographed for television. Chapter 3 presents the concept of ‘video dance’, an experimental area of work that explores the creative interface between dance and television. It is sug- gested that video dance, as a relatively new genre of dance on screen, can be characterized by cutting-edge imagery and innovative filming techniques. Drawing on examples from the BBC’s Dance for the Camera series and Channel 4’s Tights Camera Action!, Chapters 3 and 4 investi- gate the distinctive character of video dance. Chapter 3 is concerned with how the televisual apparatus acts on the dancing body and the implications of this for choreographic practice, the performing body, positions of spectatorship and critical readings. Chapter 4 then addresses the impact of dance practice on television. In this chapter it is argued that the choreographers of video dance are rooted in a post- modern stage dance tradition. Drawing on literature from the disci- plines of dance studies and film/television studies, Chapter 4 examines how video dance employs postmodern stage dance strategies that chal- lenge notions of realism, linear narrative and psychologically moti- vated characters, and call into question the way in which the television screen is perceived. Drawing on the contextual and analytic work of Chapters 1 and 2 and the discursive findings of Chapters 3 and 4, Chapter 5 sets out to construct a theoretical paradigm with which to conceptualize video dance based on the notions of ‘hybridity’ and ‘fluidity’. In addition to dance and television, it is argued, the body intersects with other aes- thetic practices and intellectual frameworks. First, Chapter 5 addresses the notion of a ‘consumer body’. It considers the similarities between video dance and the imagery of television advertisements and music videos and the extent that video dance merges and overlaps with these promotional texts. Second, Chapter 5 examines the ‘technological body’. Drawing on Benjamin’s (1973) thesis of ‘mechanical reproduc- tion’ and more recent writings on ‘new digital technologies’, it investi- gates the technological implications of video dance in terms of how the body is conceived. Chapter 5 concludes with a discussion of how video dance disrupts existing boundaries of dance and television to become a medium of artistic challenge and creative vitality. I hope that this book appeals not only to the dance community but also to any scholars, students and practitioners with an interest in xiv Preface media studies, visual culture, film and television, digital technologies, the performing arts and the body as a locus of social meaning. Finally I would like to thank Palgrave for continuing to support the field of dance scholarship.

SD Acknowledgements

I would like to thank my colleagues at the Department of Dance Studies, University of Surrey for their continual support and encour- agement, and Chris Jones from the National Resource Centre for Dance for her precious advice on the initial book proposal and helpful hints en route. Thanks are also due to the professionals from the field of screen dance who have contributed in multiple ways to the writing of this book: Bob Lockyer from the BBC; Rodney Wilson from the Arts Council of England; Anne Beresford from MJW Productions; Katrina McPherson who was meticulous in her explanations of technical termi- nology; and the practitioners, Tom Cairns, Anna Pons Carrera, Emma Gladstone, David Hinton, Wendy Houstoun, Alison Murray and Margaret Williams, who kindly gave up time from their hectic sched- ules to be interviewed. I also thank the Arts Council of England and BBC Television, and Margaret Williams for allowing the use of their photographs in this book. I would also like to thank my parents Hazel and Dick Dodds, and my partner James Powell who never failed to be a cheery companion as I agonized over different stages of the writing process. Finally, my sincerest thanks go to Dr Theresa Buckland for having faith in this particular project and for being such a generous mentor and friend.

xv