The Importance of Mutation, Then and Now: Studies with Yeast Cytochrome C
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
2 F. Sherman / Mutation Research 589 (2005) 1–16 Mutation Research 589 (2005) 1–16 Contents 1. My first encounter with yeast research . .................................................. 2 The importance of mutation, then and now: 2. Identification of CYC1 ............................................................... 3 Mutation Research 589 (2005) 1–16 ☆ 3. Importance of cytochrome c ........................................................... 4 studies with yeast cytochrome c www.elsevier.com/locate/reviewsmr Community address: www.elsevier.com/locate/mutres Fred Sherman * Reflections in Mutation Research 4. CYC1 encodes iso-1-cytochrome c ....................................................... 4 5. Isolation and characterization of cyc1 mutants. .............................................. 5 Department ofThe Biochemistry importance and Biophysics, of University mutation, of Rochester then Medical andSchool, now:Box 712, Rochester, studies NY 14642, USA Accepted 26 July 2004 with yeast cytochrome c$ 6. Generating altered genes and proteins, then and now .......................................... 6 Available online 23 September 2004 7. Deducing DNA sequences from protein sequences. .......................................... 8 Fred Sherman* 8. ‘‘Site-directed’’ mutagenesis in early times . .............................................. 10 Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics, University of Rochester Medical School, Box 712, Rochester, NY 14642, USA 9. Cloning CYC1 and transcriptional regulation. .............................................. 10 Accepted 26 July 2004 Available online 23 September 2004 10. Subsequent and current studies . ...................................................... 11 11. A final reflection ................................................................... 14 Abstract Acknowledgements . ................................................................... 14 The development of a genetic system based on the CYC1 gene was initiated over 40 years ago, primarily because of the anticipated ease of sequencing of the corresponding encoded protein, iso-1-cytochrome c from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The References ........................................................................... 14 success of the iso-cytochrome c system was dependent on the early development of methods for detecting and selecting cyc1 defective mutants and CYC1 functional revertants, and of methods for fine-structure genetic mapping using deletions and single- site mutations. The nonsense codons TAA and TAG, and the initiation codon ATG, were determined from the amino acid 1. My first encounter with yeast research emphasized to me that the existence of bacteriophages alterations of iso-1-cytochromes c from intragenic revertants; this represented the first assignments of such codons in a eukaryotic organism. The types of desired sequences were expanded by selecting recombinants from cyc1 cyc1 nonfunctional was one of the major advantages for using E. coli, and mutants or CYC1 CYC1 functional mutants, permitting the early determination of the rules of translation,� which differed from I began using yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, as it was suggested that I find phages acting similarly on � those of prokaryotes by use of the most 50 AUG codon for initiation of translation. The sequence of 44 base pairs of CYC1 was an experimental organism 50 years ago, when I first yeast. My immediate response was ‘‘where do I find determined with altered iso-1-cytochromes c from revertants of frameshift and initiation mutants, allowing the early cloning of the joined the biophysics graduate program at Berkeley in them?’’ It was explained to me that the natural habitat gene. A method was developed for transforming yeast directly with synthetic oligonucleotides, resulting in the convenient 1954. Soon after my arrival, the director of the program of yeast was on the surface of fruits and that tropical production of CYC1 mutants with defined sequences. At this point in time, Sherman and colleagues have published approximately discussed a possible research project involving yeast. birds eat fruit. Therefore, a likely source of yeast 240 papers on or using the iso-cytochrome c system, dealing with such diverse topics as translation, informational suppressors, In this regard, one of the main interests of biophysicists phages was tropical bird feces. At that moment a transcription and transcription termination, recombination, ectopic recombination, mutagen specificity, regulation by Ty1 at that time was target theory and the effects of ionizing thought flashed through my mind, ‘‘I am going to be elements, evolution of duplicated chromosomal segments, structure–function relationships of cytochrome c, protein stability radiation. This was a time when physicists overly sent to the jungles of the Amazon or the Congo and degradation, biosynthesis and mitochondrial import of cytochrome c, mitochondrial proteases, co- and post-translational interpreted survival curves and before DNA repair was to collect tropical bird feces.’’ ‘‘Where do I go to modifications, and mRNA degradation. Current work on degradation of proteins in mitochondria, on degradation of mRNA in the considered. Carl C. Lindegren had already described collect tropical bird feces?’’ I asked. The answer was nucleus, and on N-terminal acetylation stems from properties of CYC1 mutants isolated in early screens more than a decade ago. the heterothallic life cycle, and Robert K. Mortimer logical but disappointing, ‘‘The local San Francisco # 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. was busy making a polyploid series of yeast, haploid Fleishhacker Zoo across the Bay Bridge.’’ My next Keywords: Cytochrome c; Nonsense codons; Inititation codon; Protein stability and degradation; N-terminal acetylation; mRNA degradation through hexaploid, a series which appeared to be useful question was ‘‘how do I get inside the cages?’’ I was for exploring target theory [1]. I was informed that reminded that I am now a graduate student and have to any new fundamental information on yeast would be be resourceful and independent. of considerable importance, since it was the up-and- I called the Zoo and asked to speak to the Director, $ This article is part of the Reflection in Mutation Research series. To suggest topics and authors for Reflection, readers should contact the series editors G.R. Hoffmann ([email protected]) or D.G. MacPhee ([email protected]). coming microorganism of the future. a Ph.D. in zoology. I explained to the Director that I * Tel.: +1 585 275 6647; fax: +1 585 275 6007. This was the time when Escherichia coli was was a graduate student at the University of Calfornia, E-mail address: [email protected]. clearly the model system for molecular biology. It was and that I would like to collect fresh tropical bird 1383-5742/$ – see front matter # 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.mrrev.2004.07.001 200 ELSEVIER REFLECTIONS IN MUTATION RESEARCH: 1999 – 2019 201 F. Sherman / Mutation Research 589 (2005) 1–16 3 4 F. Sherman / Mutation Research 589 (2005) 1–16 feces. There was pause, then a hesitant response, ‘‘Oh, chronize cells by heat shock. I attempted to deduce the the RAD7 and OSM1 loci as well as the CYC1 locus encompassing the heme group was already sequenced you mean bird shit—yeah, that’s OK.’’ number of genetic determinants in a cell by [5–7]. Some 5 years later, a second deletion, cyc1-237, [13], and entire cytochromes c from various species The next day I arrived at the Zoo fully equipped mathematically modeling the kinetics of rÀ induction with the same seemingly pleiotropic set of phenotypes were being sequenced in several laboratories. Thus, with vials, spatulas, a notebook and my roommate, a after growth at elevated temperatures. After receiving was unexpectedly uncovered among meiotic segre- investigating cytochrome c appeared to be an ideal pre-law student who was responsible for recording the my degree, I investigated recombination in yeast as a gants. The origin of this type of deletion was not project, especially because yeast had the advantage of species of the birds and the time of collection of the Post-doctoral Fellow at Seattle with the late Herschell understood until Liebman et al. [8] noted that certain being a eukaryotic microorganism with a well-defined specimens. We were both adorned with official- Roman. Subsequently, I entered a second post- laboratory strains spontaneously gave rise to high genetic system. The advantages of using yeast looking white lab coats. After entering an aviary, a doctoral position in the laboratory of the late Boris frequencies of deletions encompassing the CYC1, cytochrome c became even more evident a few years crowd gathered in front of the cage and it soon became Ephrussi at Gif-sur-Yvette, France, where I initiated a OSM1 and RAD7 genes and that the deletions were later when Narita et al. [14] announced the complete clear to them what our purpose was. Apparently, we research program in 1960 that led to the discovery of flanked by Ty1 elements [6,9]. Thus, cyc1-1, the first amino acid sequence of iso-1-cytochrome c. were more interesting than the animals. As soon as a the CYC1 gene. cytochrome c deficient mutant, was uncovered because bird defecated, several members of the crowd pointed of the rare occurrence of a spontaneous deletion in a and shouted ‘‘There’s one, there’s one.’’ strain containing an unrelated pet mutation. 4. CYC1 encodes iso-1-cytochrome c After returning to the University and refrigerating 2.