Report to the HEA on Gender Equality Aspects of the Provost Appointment Process
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Report for the HEA on Gender Equality Aspects in the 2021 Provost/President Appointment Process Trinity College Dublin, The University of Dublin 1 Appointment Professor Linda Doyle was appointed as the next Provost at the Board meeting of the 21 April 2021. She will take over as Provost of Trinity on the 1 August 2021. She is the first woman to be appointed to the post in the Trinity’s 429-year history. Professor Doyle has held the role of Dean of Research at Trinity and was the founder Director of CONNECT, the Science Foundation Ireland national research centre for Future Networks and Communications. Her expertise is in the fields of wireless communications, cognitive radio, reconfigurable networks, spectrum management and creative arts practices. Professor Doyle has been Chair of the Douglas Hyde Gallery and is Chair of the Ofcom Spectrum Advisory Board in the UK. Originally from Cork, Professor Doyle initially studied electrical engineering at UCC, before completing a Masters and Ph.D. in Trinity. 1.2. Media Coverage As detailed below the election of Professor Doyle generated a considerable amount of very favourable media coverage. Trinity College Dublin names Prof Linda Doyle as first female Provost RTÉ.ie - April 10, 2021 The election of Linda Doyle received widespread and positive coverage across the media including The Irish Times, Irish Independent, Sunday Independent, Irish Examiner, the Business Post, Evening Echo, Irish Examiner, Silicon Republic, RTE and Newstalk. The RTE package can be found here: https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2021/0410/1209012-trinity-college-provost/ while an interview on Newstalk can be found here: https://www.newstalk.com/podcasts/newstalk-breakfast-with-susan- keogh/prof-linda-doyle-first-female-provost-of-trinity-college-dublin The Business Post article is here: https://www.businesspost.ie/education/linda-doyle-elected-first-ever-female-provost-of-tcd-34758f4c Silicon Republic: https://www.siliconrepublic.com/innovation/linda-doyle-provost-trinity-college-dublin The Irish Times: https://www.irishtimes.com/news/education/trinity-college-dublin-names-linda-doyle- as-first-woman-provost-in-429-years-1.4534221 Echo Live: https://www.echolive.ie/corknews/arid- 40262933.html 2 Process Overview The process which Trinity uses is set down in the Statutes1. It involves an advertisement phase, followed by an interview to determine which candidates are invited to proceed to a 1 See 6.2 for the text of the relevant statute. 1 nomination and election phase. Following the election, the choice of the electorate is forwarded to Board which duly appoints the chosen person to be the next Provost. The electorate are primarily full-time members of academic staff but also includes student representatives sitting on the College Board and University Council and the members of Board who are external to TCD. 2.1 Committee Structure A number of committees as specified in the Statutes, and populated mainly by members of Board2, were set-up. The membership is shown in Table 1, Table 2, Table 3 and Table 4. Steering Committee Gender Registrar Brendan Tangney (STEM) M Secretary to the College John Coman M Board Fellow Louis Brennan (AHSS) M Board Academic Staff Non-Fellow Kathleen McTiernan (AHSS) F Staff Non Academic Kevin Byrne M Table 1 :Membership of the Steering Committee Recommendation Committee3 Gender Chair of Fellows Cliona O' Farrelly (HS) F Board Fellow Diarmuid Rossa Phelan (AHSS) M Board Non-Fellow David Grouse M Table 2 : Membership of the Recommendation Committee Interview Committee Gender Board Fellow Chair Rose Anne Kenny (HS) F Board Fellow 2 Khurshid Ahmad (STEM) M Board Fellow 3 Caitriona Leahy (AHSS) F Board Non Fellow Eoin Hand (SU) M Board Non-Employee/Student Andrea Nolan F Table 3 : Membership of the Interview Committee Appeals Committee Gender Board Fellow (chair) Ross McManus (HS) M Board Academic Non-Fellow Aidan Seery (AHSS) M Board Staff Non Academic Rachel Mathews-McKay F Board Fellow (alternate) Fintan Sheerin M Table 4 : Membership of the Appeals Committee 2 See 6.1 for members of Board by constituency and gender 3 Advises on the composition of the Interview Committee 2 Faculties Arts Humanities and Social Sciences AHSS Science Technology Engineering and Maths STEM Health Sciences HS Table 5 : Key to faculties in TCD 2.2 Timeline The timeline for the process is shown in Table. Table 5: Timeline for the appointment process 3 3 Advertisement and Search The post was advertised on the College’s website, on social media and in a number of leading media outlets as follows: 1. Trinity CORE portal (digital) 2. Public jobs.ie (digital) 3. jobs.ac.uk (digital) 4. universityvacancies.com (digital) 5. Irish Examiner (newspaper, print) 6. Times Higher UK (digital) 7. Irish Times (print) 8. Sunday Times (print) 9. Chronicle of Higher Education (US) 10. Unijobs.com.au (Australia and New Zealand) 11. Academicjobseu.com (EU) The advertisement for the position stated that candidates must possess the following. “It is a requirement of the Trinity College Dublin Statutes that candidates for the Provostship shall possess: 1. significant academic standing; 2. evidence of capacity for management and administration such as is required in an educational or equivalent institution; 3. evidence of leadership skills and the ability to represent the College externally. The Provost will take the lead role in implementing the University’s Strategic Plan, fundraising for the University and advancing gender equality.” A website was created which was published all information about the process. https://www.tcd.ie/provost-appointment/ A recruitment company (Perrett Laver) was hired to assist in the process. They contacted 104 individuals (31% female; 69% male) throughout the course of the search, including both potential candidates as well as sources of recommendations. Although a small number of individuals considered the position, no individual approached decided to put forward an application. Applicants who submitted valid applications on time and containing all the required documentation were forwarded to the Interview Committee. 16 applications were received. Table 6 below shows details of applicants by gender and country. Some applications were incomplete or late and so 6 were forwarded to the Interview Committee. 4 Trinity Staff Gender Country Member 1 Male Vietnam N Riyadh, Saudi 2 Male Arabia N Bangladesh, 3 Male South Asia N 4 Male Columbia N 5 Male India N 6 Male Canada N 7 Male India N 8 Male Pakistan N 9 Male India N 10 Female Ireland Y 11 Female Ireland Y 12 Female Ireland N 13 Female Ireland Y 14 Female Ireland Y 15 Female England N 16 Male Canada N Table 6: Applications by gender and country 4 Interview Stage The role of the Interview Committee was to determine if the applicants met the criteria for being invited to seek (12) nominations from the electorate to enable their name to appear on the ballot. Three applicants, all female, met the necessary criteria and went forward for election. Gender Successful (Y/N) # 1 Female N 2 Female Y 3 Male N 4 Female Y 5 Female N 6 Female Y Table 7: Interviewees by gender 5 5 The Election A formal election campaign ran from the 5 February to the 7 April 2021. The schedule and recordings of the main events were published on the Provost Appointment Website4. Voting took place on Saturday 10 April 2021. Because of the Pandemic voting took place electronically and was observed by the electorate through a Zoom webinar. There were 867 people in the electorate of which 43% were female. This is reflective of 45% female in the full-time academic staff. ---------------------------------------------- 4 Videos of events are currently restricted to those with a TCD username and password but public links can be provided. 6 6 Appendices 7 Appendix 6.1 Trinity Board Membership 2020/21 Name School/Area Gender Ex Officio Prof Patrick Prendergast Engineering M Prof Jürgen Barkhoff Languages, Literatures and Cultural Studies (German) M Prof Kevin Mitchell Genetics and Microbiology (Genetics) M Prof Brendan Tangney Computer Science & Statistics M Prof Veronica Campbell Medicine (Physiology) F Elected Prof Khurshid Ahmad Computer Science & Statistics / TCIN M Prof Louis Brennan Business M Prof Andrew Burke Business M Mr Kevin Byrne Estates & Facilities M Prof Daniel Faas Sociology M Mr David Grouse Physics M Mr Eoin Hand SU President M Prof Rose Anne Kenny Medicine (Medical Gerontology) F Ms Leah Keogh SU Welfare Officer F Prof Caitriona Leahy Languages, Literatures and Cultural Studies (German) F (temporary substitute for Prof Sarah Alyn Stacey) Ms Rachel Mathews-McKay Library F Prof Ross McManus Medicine (Clinical Medicine) M Prof Kathleen McTiernan Linguistic, Speech and Communication Sciences F Ms Megan O’Connor SU Education Officer F Prof Lorna Roe Medicine (Public Health & Primary Care) / TCIN F Prof Diarmuid Rossa Phelan Law M Ms Gisèle Scanlon GSU President F Prof Aidan Seery Education M Prof Fintan Sheerin Nursing and Midwifery (Intellectual Disability Nursing) M Prof John Walsh Education M Appointed Ms Jill Donoghue External Member F Prof Andrea Nolan External Member F In attendance – Ex Officio Mr John Coman Secretary’s Office M Mr Peter Reynolds FSD M In attendance Prof Juliette Hussey Global Relations F Mr Patrick Magee Acting COO M Ms Victoria Butler Secretary’s Office F Ms Aoife Crawford Secretary’s Office F Provost Establishment 1. (1) Pursuant to the Principal Enactments, the Provost is Head of the College and a member of the Body Corporate of the College. Functions