1St CAC Meeting Minutes of 2021-22 Booklet No 1
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MAHARASHTRA POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD Minutes of 1st Consent Appraisal Committee Meeting of 2021-2022 held on 12.04.2021 & 15.04.2021 at 03:00 p.m. conducted through Video Conferencing (Microsoft Teams). Following members of the Consent Appraisal Committee were present: 1. Shri Sudhir Shrivastava, Chairman Chairman, M.P.C. Board, Mumbai. 2. Shri Ashok Shingare, Member Member Secretary, M.P.C. Board. 3. Shri P.P. Nandusekar, Member Technical Advisor, MIDC. 4. Shri Tuhin Banerjee, Member Sr. Scientist, NEERI. 5. Shri P.K. Mirashe, Member Convener Assistant Secretary (Technical), M.P.C. Board, Mumbai. Additional Chief Secretary, Home (Transport) Dept., Mumbai on leave of absence was granted to them. Following Officer of MPCB were present for the meeting: 1. Shri V.M. Motghare Invitee Member Joint Director (APC), M.P.C. Board, Mumbai. 2. Shri Y.B. Sontakke, Invitee Member Joint Director (WPC), M.P.C. Board, Mumbai. 3. Dr. A.S. Supate, Invitee Member Principal Scientific Office, M.P.C. Board, Mumbai. 4. Shri N.N. Gurav, Invitee Member Regional Officer (HQ), M.P.C. Board, Mumbai. Chairman of the committee welcomed the members of the committee and allowed proceeding of the meeting to start. st 1 Meeting of 2021-22 (Booklet No. 1) dtd. 12.04.2021 & 15.04.2021 of Consent to Establish/ Operate/Renewal) Page 1 of 70 The meeting thereafter deliberated on the fresh agenda items [Booklet No. 1 of Consent to Establish/ Operate/Renewal cases] placed before the committee and following decision were taken: Sr. Application Industry name Decision on Consent granted Remarks / Discussion No. Unique and Address grant of Upto Number consent Booklet No. 1 1 MPCB- RR Mega City APPROVED 30.04.2022 Committee noted that, the case was discussed in Consent CONSENT- Builders Ltd., 1st Consent to Appraisal Committee meeting held on 07/08/2020 and noted 0000091132 S.No.221/2,222/1,2 Operate that, PP has applied for grant of 1st Consent to Operate (Phase- 22/4,222/5/1(P),222 (Phase-II) II) for residential Construction project having Total Plot Area of /5/2(P),223/1,223/2, 2 2 223/3,2 1,20,596 M and Built-up Area of 57,650.01 M out of Total 2 23/4,223/5,224/1 & Construction BUA of 1,92,390.25 M . others Hinjewadi village Mulshi Committee also noted that, PP has obtained EC and Consent to Operate (Part), but copies are not submitted along with the application, not submitted detailed water budget, treatment provided and its disposal path, not submitted details of Solid waste management and Architect certificate. Committee further noted the SRO-Pune-II remark about non submission of desired information and required documents. Therefore, it was decided to issue Show Cause Notice for refusal of Consent to Operate due to lack of clarity as mentioned. Also was decided to call SRO’s verification report about status of completion of the project. Accordingly, SCN for refusal of 1st Consent to Operate (Phase- II) was issued vide letter dtd. 19/08/2020. Committee further noted that, PP has submitted reply and required documents. SRO-Pune-II has submitted visit report st 1 Meeting of 2021-22 (Booklet No. 1) dtd. 12.04.2021 & 15.04.2021 of Consent to Establish/ Operate/Renewal) Page 2 of 70 through mail on 18/12/2020 stating that, Construction of Phase-II has completed, presently finishing work was undergoing. Provided OWC & STP of 885 CMD capacity MBBR based technology STP including recirculation tank for the storage of treated effluent which will be reuse for flushing purpose. Also reported that during visit no occupancy was found in any of the building. In view of above, it was decided to grant 1st Consent to Operate (Phase-II) for Residential Construction project having Total Plot Area of 1,20,596 M2 and Built-up Area of 57,650.01 M2 out of Total Construction BUA of 1,92,390.25 M2 by imposing following conditions. 1. PP shall Operate & Maintain STP properly to achieve treated sewage standard for the parameter BOD-10 mg/lit. 2. The treated effluent shall be 60% recycled for secondary purposes such as toilet flushing, air-conditioning, cooling tower make up, firefighting etc. and remaining shall be utilized on land for gardening and/ or connected to local body sewer line with water metering system. 3. PP shall operate organic waste digester along with composting facility/bio-digester (biogas) for the treatment of wet garbage. 4. PP shall make provision of charging ports for electric vehicles at least 10% of total available parking slots. 5. PP shall extend existing BG of Rs. 25 Lakh towards O & M of Pollution Control System and compliance of Consent conditions. st 1 Meeting of 2021-22 (Booklet No. 1) dtd. 12.04.2021 & 15.04.2021 of Consent to Establish/ Operate/Renewal) Page 3 of 70 2 MPCB- Sandvik Mining and APPROVED 31.03.2024 Committee noted that, PP has applied for demerger of consent. CONSENT- Rock Technology Consent to industry has divided main unit into 3 parts, namely M/s Sandvik 0000094831 India Pvt. Ltd, CTS operate with Asia Pvt Ltd, M/s Sandvik Materials Technology India Pvt. Ltd NO. 2223, 2223/1, demerger of and M/S Sandvik Mining and Rock Technology India Pvt. Ltd, Dapodi, Tal. Haveli, unit Dist. Pune. through NCLT and has submitted Court Order for Demerger. Committee also noted that, M/s. Sandvik Mining and Rock Technology India Pvt. Ltd has proposed to carry out the activities viz Mining & Construction Tools, Rock Drilling Tools- 452000 Nos/Y, Mining & Construction Equipment's (Rock Crushing products such as Crushers, Screens, Feeders, Mobile Plants, Drills and other miscellaneous equipment's and their spares etc)- 1068 Nos/Y. The tread and domestic effluent generated proposed to send at M/s. Sandvik Asia Pvt Ltd. for the treatment. Agreement copy regarding the same is uploaded. The unit has total 17 nos of stacks and provided filters and water scrubber as APC to paint booth, and dust collectors, fume extractions to various stacks. Committee also noted that the said application was discussed in earlier CAC meeting and was decided to defer and call the PP for presentation. Accordingly, PP has made presentation and presented their demerger proposal in detail also submitted that, they are in the process of providing ZLD system which will be completed up to December 2021. Also the existing land is in the name of Sandvik Asia Pvt Ltd and Sandvik Mining & Rock Technology India Pvt. Ltd., and applied to add the name of SMRTIPL in the property card also the Sandvik Material Technology India Pvt. Ltd is having lease with SAPL st 1 Meeting of 2021-22 (Booklet No. 1) dtd. 12.04.2021 & 15.04.2021 of Consent to Establish/ Operate/Renewal) Page 4 of 70 In view of above we may consider the application for grant of demerger of the consent by imposing following conditions; In view of above we may consider the application for grant of demerger of the consent by imposing following conditions; 1. PP shall submit an undertaking towards jointly and several responsibility of all the three unit towards the consent conditions and environmental compliance. 2. PP shall provide separate treatment for sewage. 3. PP shall provide ZLD system for trade effluent up to December 2021. Consent shall be issued after obtaining additional consent fees, if any.. 3 MPCB- Sandvik Asia Pvt APPROVED 31.03.2024 Committee noted that, PP has applied for demerger of consent. CONSENT- Ltd., CTS NO. Consent to industry has divided main unit into 3 parts, namely M/s Sandvik 0000094676 2223, 2223/1 operate with Asia Pvt Ltd, M/s Sandvik Materials Technology India Pvt. Ltd Mumbai-Pune demerger of and M/S Sandvik Mining and Rock Technology India Pvt. Ltd, Road, Dapodi, Tal. unit through NCLT and has attached Court Order for Demerger. Haveli, Dist. Pune. Committee also noted that, M/s. Sandvik Asia Pvt Ltd, PP has provided ETP for the treatment of Industrial effluent and treated effluent is connected to STP for further treatment. Treated effluent is reuse in process & Toilet flushing and remaining disposed on land for gardening purpose on 4.7 acres of Land. JVS results are found within the limit. Committee further noted that, PP has DG sets equipped with acoustic enclosures and Dust collectors, scrubbers and small ESPs to the various stacks and vents. Committee further noted that the said application was discussed in earlier CAC meeting and was decided to defer the case and call the PP for presentation. Accordingly, PP has made presentation and presented their demerger proposal in st 1 Meeting of 2021-22 (Booklet No. 1) dtd. 12.04.2021 & 15.04.2021 of Consent to Establish/ Operate/Renewal) Page 5 of 70 detail also they have submitted that, they are in the process of providing ZLD system which will be completed up to December 2021. Also the existing land is in the name of Sandvik Asia Pvt Ltd and Sandvik Mining & Rock Technology India Pvt. Ltd., and applied to add the name of SMRTIPL in the property card also the Sandvik Material Technology India Pvt. Ltd is having lease with SAPL In view of above we may consider the application for grant of demerger of the consent by imposing following conditions; In view of above we may consider the application for grant of demerger of the consent by imposing following conditions; 1. PP shall submit an undertaking towards jointly and several responsibilities of all the three unit towards the consent conditions and environmental compliance.