®
The Monthly Newspaper of the Philadelphia Bar Association Vol. 37, No. 7 July 2008
Women in the Profession Summit Volunteers Work to Fight Foreclosures ■ By Jeff Lyons
P’ to help low-income home- owners facing mortgage foreclosures has received national attention. “I was at a big seminar in Dallas about the subprime mortgage crisis and one of the panelists held up a copy s
n of !e Wall Street Journal o y L
f
f that had an article talking e J
y b
about our efforts here in o t
o Judge C. Darnell Jones II
h Philadelphia,” Philadelphia P U.S. District Court Judge Petrese B. Tucker (from left) discusses communication across the gender Court of Common Pleas gap as U.S. Court of Appeals Judge Dolores K. Sloviter and Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas Judge President Judge C. Darnell Jones II recalled. Frederica A. Massiah-Jackson look on at the First Women in the Profession Summit on June 18. The “/ey wanted me to talk about it. I told them the pro opening panel also included U.S. District Court Senior Judge Norma L. Shapiro, Judge Diane M. Welsh, bono community was the backbone in the effort. And Court of Common Pleas Judge Marlene F. Lachman and moderator Lynn A. Marks. The program includ- ed keynote remarks by Comcast’s Charisse Lillie. For more coverage, see Page 8. they were in awe. /ey couldn’t believe it would hap- continued on page 16 Get Practice Help With LPM Referral In This Issue 2 Chancellor’s Forum ■ By Jeff Lyons Size Firm Committee as well as Technol- to draft an agreement or where to go for ogy, Financial Management, Business a technology issue or any of those types 6 Image Conscious O Management and Marketing are all of things, you contact the Bar Associa- of Bar Association membership is the committees that fall under the umbrella tion and they will put you in touch with 9 Networking Advice Law Practice Management Division. of the Law Practice Management Divi- a consultant. You’ll be entitled to a free “Every member of the Bar is a mem- sion,” Siegel said. one-hour consultation with an indi- 11 Conference Preview ber of the Division automatically; it’s “/e Division offers you what is vidual who has expertise in that area. 17 Striking a Balance part of your benefits of being a member essentially the lawyer referral service If you choose to work with him or her, of the Association,” explained Division for law practice management,” Siegel you have that ability.” 20 More Than Golf Co-Chair Daniel J. Siegel. “/e Solo explained. “If you have an issue that Siegel said there is a wide range of and Small Firm Committee, the Mid- comes up and you need to find out how continued on page 17
Bridging The Gap “Know what you don’t know.”
(&)* $ $ '% ' .%' / $ To learn more, visit: www.ITAcceleration.com Technology Legal !) $ $/% ' $ '% (&)For*%ensic + "Computing , $ % + "■# " eRISK-$ '$* Pr*$otection ■ IT Infrastructure ■ Expert Services 995 Old Eagle School Road, Suite 307 ! Wayne, "P#A 19087 $ % & Phone 610-995-9160 CHANCELLOR’S FORUM Working Together to Improve Philadelphia
■ By Asima Panigrahi
P’ show “how important the city is to us and how important we are to the city,” Chancellor A. Michael Pratt told attend- ees of a June 10 Chancellor’s Forum. /e theme of the event was “work- ing together to improve our city.” /e forum’s panel consisted of Philadelphia City Councilman James Kenney; Eric
Mayberry, president and publisher of s n o y L
Metro Philadelphia; Ahmeenah Young, f f e J
executive vice president of the Pennsylva- y b
o t
nia Convention Center; and Paul Levy, o h president and CEO of the Center City P Moderator Carl E. Singley (from left) joins Paul Levy, Ahmeenah Young, Chancellor A. Michael Pratt, Eric Mayberry and District. /e panel was moderated by Councilman James Kenney before the June 10 Chancellor’s Forum. Carl E. Singley. Levy discussed the marked economic was “clinically depressed as a city” and working with numerous mayors over his initiatives that were not getting attention and political changes that have taken there were few efforts made towards 17 years as councilman and compared with the Street administration, CityStat place in Philadelphia from World War II “reinventing and realigning government.” and contrasted the various leadership and 311 – a non-emergency call system, to the present, including the development He then discussed the “climate of change” styles. He stated that the difference be- are now both well underway. He also of highways, the rail system, the tour- that came with the Nutter administration tween the Nutter and the Street adminis- discussed city council’s previous efforts ism industry and the growth of the city’s and noted that there currently is a “strong trations is that the current administration to remove the one-year residency rule for ethnic demography. He noted that during momentum for reform and change.” has “transparency, conversation and city employees. Council passed the initia- the Rendell administration, Philadelphia Councilman Kenney then discussed mutual respect.” He also noted that two continued on page 21
Certified Public Accountants CertifiedC Certified Public Public AccountantsA Accountantse c r t c i ountfi e d P a nt ubl s i c
“ serving Kevin J. Conner, MST, CPA “ serving“ serving KevinManaging J. Conner Dir, ectorMST, CPA · Litigation Consulting Services the needs KevinManaging J. Conner Dir,ector MST, CPA · Litigation Consulting Services the needs DianaManaging L. Sherman, Director CISA, CPA · Litigation Consulting Services the needs DianaDir ectorL. Sherman, of Audit Services CISA, CPA · Expert Witness Testimony of our clients DianaDir L.ector Sherman, of Audit Services CISA, CPA · Expert Witness Testimony of our clients Director of Audit Services · Expert Witness Testimony sinceof 1991 our” clients · Forensic Accounting since 1991” · Forensic Accounting since 1991” · Taxation,· Forensic Domestic Accounting & International · Taxation, Domestic & International 110 South State Street, Suite 200 110 South State Street, Suite 200 Registered Firm of the · Business· Taxation, Valuations Domestic & International Newtown, Pennsylvania 18940 PublicRegistered Company Firm Accounting of the · Business Valuations Newtown, Pennsylvania 18940 PublicOversight Company Board Accounting (PCAOB) 215/860-3322110 South • Fax: State 215/860-3653 Street, Suite 200 215/860-3322 • Fax: 215/860-3653 MemberOversightRegistered Firm Board of Firm CP (PCAOB)A of Connect the · SEC· Business Audits Valuations e-mail: [email protected], Pennsylvania 18940 PublicMember Company Firm of CP AccountingA Connect · SEC Audits e-mail: [email protected] Oversight Board (PCAOB) 215/860-3322 • Fax: 215/860-3653 Member Firm of CPA Connect · SEC Audits e-mail: [email protected]
2 Philadelphia Bar Reporter July 2008 philadelphiabar.org Frontline Bar’s Legislative Program Makes Editor-in-Chief Sunah Park Difference in Lives of Membership Editor Emeritus Bruce H. Bikin E our very serious con- By A. Michael Pratt they represent. Each af- Associate Editors championed to our elected representa- cerns with the proposed fected nonprofit would Heather J. Holloway tives is one of the central missions of the regulations. Beaser have needed to take Asima Panigrahi Philadelphia Bar Association. /rough appeared before the com- significant amounts of Brian K. Sims a comprehensive legislative program, we mittee at public meetings money away from its Kathryn C. Harr Ria C. Momblanco work on a variety of levels to make sure in Harrisburg on two mission in order to com- Regina Parker the Association’s positions are heard, additional occasions ply with the regulations. Raymond M. Williams while lobbying for effective change that and the Association’s Following the detailed benefits our members, our community task force submitted and compelling testimo- Contributing Editor and our profession. additional suggestions ny of Beaser, Crisci and Richard Max Bockol /ese efforts often may not make and comments to revised others, a draft proposal Advisory Editors front-page news. But a significant num- draft language from the was publicly circulated Molly Peckman ber of the positive changes we see that regulations committee. by the Pennsylvania Marc W. Reuben benefit our lawyers, our clients and our In our testimony and written com- Lobbyist Disclosure Regulations Com- Director of Communications community happen because the Phila- ments, we raised a number of important mittee changing the proposed regulations Mark A. Tarasiewicz delphia Bar Association had a seat at the substantive and technical concerns. For and indicating that monitoring legislation table. example, the proposed regulations would will no longer be considered lobbying. Senior Managing Editor Recently, we argued that Pennsylvania’s have expanded the definition of lobbying /e committee made other, significant Jeff Lyons proposed lobbying disclosure regula- to include merely monitoring legislative improvements in the proposed regula- Copy Editor tions went well beyond the words of action or administrative action, without tions in response to our suggestions, as Adrienne Cornwall the statute, would severely hamper the any requirement that there be some ef- well. practice of law and would impose unfair fort to influence that legislative action or After a very open and collaborative Executive Director Kenneth Shear and unnecessary compliance burdens on administrative action. process, the regulations committee has attorneys and their clients. /us, a banking lawyer who merely issued much improved revised draft The Philadelphia Bar Reporter (ISSN 1098-5352) is Past Association Chancellor Law- follows proposed changes in Banking regulations. /e current draft is being re- published monthly and available by subscription for $45 rence J. Beaser, chair of the Association’s Department regulations on behalf of a viewed by our task force and, if necessary, per year by the Philadelphia Bar Association, 1101 Mar- Task Force on Pennsylvania’s Lobbying client would have needed to register as a additional comments will be submitted to ket St., 11th !oor, Philadelphia, Pa. 19107-2911. Period- icals postage paid at Philadelphia, Pa. POSTMASTER: Disclosure Act and a partner at Blank lobbyist. In addition, the lawyer’s client the regulations committee and the Inde- Send address changes to Philadelphia Bar Reporter, Rome LLP, and Anthony J. Crisci, the would have been required to register as a pendent Regulatory Review Committee. c/o Philadelphia Bar Association, 1101 Market St., 11th Association’s lobbyist, testified on behalf ‘principal,’ and would have been required /e work of the Association’s lobbying !oor, Philadelphia, Pa. 19107-2955. Telephone: (215) 238-6300. Association Web site: philadelphiabar.org. of the Association before the Lobbyist to report amounts paid to the lawyer to act task force, led by Beaser and Crisci, is Newspaper e-mail address: [email protected]. Disclosure Regulations Committee at monitor the regulation changes. illustrative of the efforts the Bar Associa- The editorial and other views expressed in the Phila- public hearings in Harrisburg last year We also argued that the draft regula- tion consistently undertakes to protect its delphia Bar Reporter are not necessarily those of the Association, its of"cers or its members. Advertising and in March of this year. tions would have put a strain on public members from the overreach of govern- rates and information are available from Howard Hyatt /ey expressed orally at the hearing, interest groups and other nonprofits that ment. at MediaTwo, 1014 W. 36th St., Baltimore, MD, 21211. and in our 18 pages of written comments, monitor legislation to help the people continued on page 18 Telephone: (410) 902-5797. Page 1 skyline photo by Edward Savaria, Jr./PCVB Riders Sought for Bar Team in ACS Event
Tell Us T P B A- age of his cancer, he was able to be treated ing all firms to pass on to their entire staff What You Think! tion will saddle up again this year and and afforded an opportunity to have a information about the ride and encourag- take part in the 36th Annual American vibrant life. ing their support and participation. Last The Philadelphia Bar Reporter Cancer Society Bike-a-/on on Sunday, Two members of Meyer’s extended year, 125 riders from the Bar Association welcomes letters to the editors for publication. Letters should be typed. July 13. family have been recently diagnosed and participated and joined the more than There is no word limit, but editors /e ride brings awareness to the issues are now undergoing treatment. 4,600 cyclists,” Meyer said. reserve the right to condense for of cancer and how it affects friends, fami- By serving as co-chairs of Team /e ride concludes at the Buena Vista clarity, style and space considerations. lies, colleagues and community. Another Philadelphia Bar Association, Feinman Camping Ground. /ere, friends and Letters must be signed to verify purpose of the ride is seeking to raise and Meyer have the opportunity to give family members greet the cyclists for a authorship, but names will be withheld funds in support of cancer research. a little back to the community and aid picnic, a chance to relax and to observe upon request. Letters may be mailed, /e ride leaves Philadelphia and winds in the research process which has been so the survivor ceremony that honors all faxed or e-mailed to: Jeff Lyons, Senior 65 miles to Buena Vista, N.J. instrumental in diagnosis and treatment cancer survivors, regardless of whether Managing Editor, Philadelphia Bar Reporter, Philadelphia Bar Association, /is year’s Philadelphia Bar Associa- of all forms of cancer. “We’re encourag- they rode or are just present in the crowd. 1101 Market St., 11th !oor, Philadel- tion team is co-chaired by Mark Feinman phia, Pa. 19107-2955. Phone: (215) and Jim Meyer. Feinman has ridden in 238-6345. Fax: (215) 238-1159. E-mail: this event for the past dozen years and is a To register for the Association’s 2008 American Cancer Society Bike- reporter@ philabar.org. near 33-year cancer survivor. Being one of WebCheck a-Thon team, visit acsbike.org. the fortunate ones who learned at an early philadelphiabar.org July 2008 Philadelphia Bar Reporter 3 More than 150 Attend Federal Bench-Bar
U.S. District Court Judge Michael Baylson (from left) is joined by Felicia Sarner, U.S. Dis- Philadelphia City Solicitor Shelley R. Smith (left) is joined by trict Court Senior Judge Norma L. Shapiro, Robert A. Zauzmer and William A. DeStefano Board of Governors Chair Stephanie Resnick at the Federal on a panel about the impact of Booker on sentencing procedure and sentences in the Bench-Bar Conference. Smith was the keynote speaker. Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
U.S. Bankruptcy Court Chief Judge University of Pennsylvania Law M. Kelly Tillery, along with Chief Maureen Barden provided an update Stephen Raslavich offered state of School Professor Catherine T. Struve Judge Bartle and Craig D. Mills, on the federal prisoner re-entry the court remarks with U.S. District made a presentation on proposed were panelists for “Proving Willful- program. Court Chief Judge Harvey Bartle III revisions to the Federal Rules of ness in Trademark and Trade Secret and Clerk of Court Michael Kunz. Civil Procedure. Claims.” s n o y L
f f e J
y b
s o t o h P U.S. District Court Judges Thomas I. Vanaskie and Legrome U.S. District Court Chief Judge Harvey Bartle III (from left) meets with Federal Courts D. Davis presented “Juror Questions: Procedures, Pro!ts and Committee Chair Charles S. Marion and Vice Chair Craig D. Mills before the June 6 Federal Pitfalls.” Bench-Bar Conference at the Downtown Marriott. More than 150 people attended.
4 Philadelphia Bar Reporter July 2008 philadelphiabar.org STATE CIVIL LITIGATION SECTION Justice McCaffery Lauds Legal Staffs ■ By Jeff Lyons Podcast T Pennsylvania Supreme Court are the Spotlight lawyers employed on the justices’ staffs, Visit philadelphiabar.org to listen to Justice Seamus P. McCaffery told the podcast from this program. members of the State Civil Litigation Section at the Section’s June 11 Quarterly best not to get it wrong,” Justice McCaf- Meeting. fery said. “Each and every one of us has teams In addition to his involvement as the of attorneys who work for us that don’t mental health liaison, Justice McCaffery get there on political patronage. /ey get said he is looking into creating a statewide there on merit. /ey get there because veterans court, following the lead of the they are extremely talented people,” New York courts. “Post-traumatic stress Justice McCaffery said. “It’s important to disorder is a very, very important issue for surround yourself with the best and the a lot of veterans. We have young men brightest – first-round draft choices.” and woman coming back from Afghani- s
/e vast majority of the work product stan and Iraq and they are pretty stressed n o y L
f is a collaborative effort of the chambers out. A lot of them try to self medicate, f e J
y
themselves, the justice said. “I have a either through alcohol or through drugs, b
o t o minimum of five or six attorneys that and they find themselves locked up.” h P look at an opinion that I’m responsible Justice McCaffery said there’s a strong Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice Seamus P. McCaffery is the !rst retired for. My chief has 30 years as an appellate belief that about one-third of the people Philadelphia Police of!cer elected to the bench. lawyer. My deputy has close to 25 years incarcerated statewide are there because as an appellate lawyer. /ese are appellate of health issues. “I’m hell-bent on making st * professionals. /ey are the consummate sure we can create a first-rate program 1 DEPO = 1 MONTBLANC PEN legal public servants. Could they leave statewide that’s going to address mental and make a lot of money somewhere else? health issues and veterans issues. /ese You’re darn right they could. You can’t are things that I think that we as a society You Book believe the income a lot of these attorneys need. /ere’s an awful lot of people and give up to come and work with us. I like you can’t warehouse them. We need to to bring in the best and the brightest get them treated and get them back into The Depo, because it assures the legal community society. /e days of just throwing people that our work product is going to be the in jail are long gone,” he said. best,” he said. “I take great pride in being a public “We’re not an error-correcting court. servant and I take great pleasure in work- We’ll Bring /at’s the Superior Court’s role. Our role ing for the people because I’m elected is to look at the big picture and to ensure by the people. We on the court need to that the rule of law is followed. And the understand that we work for you and role of law, and how it’s applied across the with you. You don’t work for us. It’s real The Sword board. No justice and no justice’s staff is important that we understand your needs going to sit down and try to figure out so we can do everything and anything ...well, not exactly, but the pen is mightier than why to not do the right thing. We can’t we can to make your life a little easier,” the sword, especially when it comes to litigation! afford to get it wrong. And we try our Justice McCaffery said. Take your first deposition with Bell Reporting and Bar Night at the Phillies Aug. 5 we’ll hand deliver a Montblanc pen to your firm. (215) 236 - DEPO J B A- Seating (subject to availability) with tion Night at the Phillies on Tuesday, fellow Bar Association supporters will be Philadelphia, PA New York, NY Aug. 5 as the National League East located on the Field Level Baseline (Sec- champion Phils take on the Florida Mar- tions 108 & 109). Enter the promotion Baltimore, MD Washington, DC lins at Citizens Bank Park at 7:05 p.m. code BAR when ordering tickets online. www.BellReporting.com To purchase tickets for Bar Associa- We Never Take Your Business For Granted! *Deposition must be booked 7 business days in advance, at least 3 hours long, and booked before 12/31/08; attorney must be tion Night at the Phillies on Aug. 5, available to personally receive the pen on behalf of the firm; transcript charge must be paid in full. Limit one pen per client. This promotion is an ethical “giveaway” as Bell’s rates are “reasonable” and in fact are among the lowest in the Philadelphia area. We WebCheck visit phillies.com/philabar. simply choose to return profits back to our clients (see Rules 1.5 and 1.7 of Pennsylvania’s Rules of Professional Conduct). Instead of receiving the pen, Bell will gladly make a monetary donation to a cause of your choice in your firm's name.
philadelphiabar.org July 2008 Philadelphia Bar Reporter 5 Castille Honored Panelists: G. Craig Lord (from left) of Blank Rome Image Isn’t LLP joins Pennsylvania Supreme Court Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille, Nick DeBenedictis of Aqua America and Mark Everything, Schweiker of the Greater Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce at a June 5 luncheon honoring Justice Castille at the But it Helps Park Hyatt Philadelphia at the Bellevue. ■ By Brian K. Sims
T career in the legal community are as varied as the types of careers themselves. Generally, most attorneys agree that a commitment to fairness, a keen intel- JULY lect, and a strong work ethic are among the essentials. /en why the seemingly CLE COURSES endless focus on tailored suits, open-toed heels, and monogrammed cufflinks? Well, as famous Philadelphian Ben- jamin Franklin reminded us, “Eat to July 1 Thorny Issues in Modern Pennsylvania Landlord/Tenant Practice • The CLE The CLE please thyself, but dress to please others.” Conference Center Conference Center On June 3, the Young Lawyers Division July 8 Changing Law Firms-Ethical Guidance for Law Firms & Attorneys • The CLE Wanamaker Building looked to answer these questions with a Conference Center 10th Floor, Ste.1010 program “Crafting and Marketing Your July 9 21st Annual Civil Litigation Update • The CLE Conference Center Image: What Every Young Lawyer Needs to Know.” Basics of Special Education Law for Parents and New Attorneys • The CLE /e program, moderated by past YLD Conference Center Chair Natalie Klyashtorny, included July 10 A Lawyers’s Guide to Diagnostic Testing: Everything You Wanted to Know discussions with local marketing, human but Were Afraid to Ask • The CLE Conference Center resources and style gurus and offered July 14 PLI - 9th Annual Private Equity Forum 2008 - Simulcast • The CLE Conference guidance for taking control of your own Center public image and avoiding those faux pas and foibles guaranteed to make you the July 15 Fundamentals of Estate Planning - Simulcast • The CLE Conference Center topic of discussion at the water cooler, st Legal Writing for the 21 Century • The CLE Conference Center company picnic or even the judge’s PLI - 9th Annual Private Equity Forum 2008 - Simulcast • The CLE Conference chambers. Center Brian Lipstein, an image consultant July 16 Business Insurance • The CLE Conference Center with Henry A. Davidsen Master Tai- lors in Center City, said “how you put The Basics of Employment Law - Simulcast • The CLE Conference Center yourself together says a lot about how July 17 Open Source Software Licensing - Simulcast • The CLE Conference Center you’re going to care for your work. It adds credibility to who you are, to what you’re July 18 Special Interests and the Government Process - Simulcast • The CLE Conference Call PBI Center doing, to the job you’re trying to get or Customer Service at the client you’re trying to please.” Theater Skills in the Courtroom • The CLE Conference Center 800-247-4724 Gina Furia Rubel, president and CEO July 21 & 22 PLI - Basics of Accounting & Finance: What Every Practicing Lawyer Needs to of Furia Rubel Communications Inc., to register for a Know - Simulcast • The CLE Conference Center agrees. “As an employer, one of the first July 23 The Brave New World of Medical Malpractice Litigation • The CLE course or for more things I do is look to see how someone Conference Center information. presents themselves,” says the attorney- turned-communications expert. July 24 Reel Justice! Power, Passion & Persuasion in the Modern Courtroom Register online at The CLE Conference Center “In public relations, we like to use the www.pbi.org word ‘public’ as opposed to audiences Using the Internet for Legal Research • The CLE Conference Center and you’re always in front of a ‘public,’” July 25 Paternity Cases • The CLE Conference Center The Pennsylvania Bar according to Rubel. “If you’re at home July 30 Identity Theft - Simulcast • The CLE Conference Center Institute is an with your significant other, if you’re out accredited CLE at a young lawyers event, if you’re in your July 31 Negotiation & Conflict Resolution for Lawyers - Simulcast • The CLE continued on page 19 Conference Center provider. PLI - The Pocket MBA for Lawyers 2008: Everything You Need to Know About Finance - Simulcast • The CLE Conference Center Podcast Spotlight Visit philadelphiabar.org to listen to the podcast of this program.
6 Philadelphia Bar Reporter July 2008 philadelphiabar.org JPT Program Spring Receptions Changes Issued Chancellor A. Michael Pratt (from left) joins In-House Counsel Committee Co-Chairs A Marilyn He"ey and Douglas judges pro tempore in the Court of Common Pleas Com- Gaston and James McDonald merce Program has been issued with changes taking effect at the Committee’s May 20 on July 1, said Judge D. Webster Keogh, administrative reception at the Park Hyatt judge of the trial division. Philadelphia at the Bellevue. More than 50 people attended Judges pro tempore will now be required to have at least the reception, which was spon- 15 years of litigation experience. /ey also will be required to sored by Ballard Spahr Andrews take part in at least 10 hours of alternative dispute resolution & Ingersoll, LLP. training and have taken part in at least three ADR proceed- ings. JPTs currently involved in the program will have one year to update their credentials. Judge Keogh said the changes have been in the works for nearly a year. /e changes came as a result of conversations with current and former Commerce Program judges as well as the Philadelphia Bar Association’s Business Litigation r e f
Committee. f e a h
“We wanted to make the qualifications transparent,” c S
t t a l e o r
Judge Keogh said. “We’re putting the information out there i B V
l y e b
to show who is qualified and what individuals need to do to a o h t c o i h M P become qualified as JPTs. It also recognizes the complexities y b
o Business Litigation Committee Chair Marc that these Commerce Program cases are frought with.” t o h In May, the Board of Governors approved a resolution P Zucker (from left) is joined by Philadelphia Family Law Section Chair Patricia Dubin greets Court of Common Pleas Judge Albert W. in support of amending administrative procedures with the Court of Common Pleas Judge Daniel J. Anders Sheppard Jr., Darryl J. May and Judge Mark Commerce Program. Judges pro tem will be able to receive a at a reception for Family Court judges on June I. Bernstein at a reception following a train- fee of $300 per hour after three hours of pro bono work on a 10 at the Trump Tower showroom at One Lib- ing seminar for judges pro tempore at The CLE case, provided the litigants agree to pay the JPTs beyond the erty Place. Conference Center on June 17. three-hour period.
philadelphiabar.org July 2008 Philadelphia Bar Reporter 7 WOMEN IN THE PROFESSION COMMITTEE Lillie: Mentors Key to Retaining Women
■ By Kathryn C. Harr
“T - ship between a mentor and a new lawyer can make all the difference between retaining and losing” female attorneys, Charisse Lillie noted in her keynote ad- dress at the First Women in the Profes- sion Summit held on June 19. “In most of our organizations,” Lillie explained, “we have much less of an issue Committee Co-Chair Maria A. Feeley (from left) moderates a panel on best practices for with recruiting women lawyers than we the retention and promotion of women with J. Gordon Cooney Jr., Thomas A. Decker, do retaining women lawyers.” Lillie em- Charisse R. Lillie Patrick C. Dunican Jr., Amy B. Ginensky and John J. Soroko. phasized strong mentors as an invaluable resource in her professional development and urged firms to create mentorship relationships. “In a good mentoring relationship, the mentor is going to learn s
sometimes more than the mentee learns.” n o y L
f
Lillie is vice president, human resources, f e J
y
Comcast Corporation and senior vice b
s o t president, human resources, Comcast o Natalie Klyashtorny (from left), Danielle Banks, Kelly Dobbs h P Cable Corporation. Bunting, Nicole C. Whittington, Kimberly M. Ruch-Alegant, Kamil Ali-Jackson (from left), Wanda E. Flowers, Teresa Although describing her view of Chancellor-Elect Sayde J. Ladov and Nancy O’Mara Ezold Ciccotelli, Lorraine K. Koc and Roberta D. Liebenberg were women in the profession as “optimistic,” discussed hot topics for women. panelists for a discussion on corporate diversity efforts. Lillie cited sobering recent statistics. concentrate on diversity. When female of that diversity and inclusion,” Lillie model and mentor. White men comprised 86 percent of law employees or employees of color leave, noted, observing that diversity serves an “I don’t think that success in the game firm partnership positions and 96 percent Lillie advocated creating an assessment organization’s economic self-interest, too. of hiring and retaining women is rocket of all CEO positions; the American Bar tool to understand the barriers to reten- Lille recounted her childhood in at- science. A lot of the retention game is Association reported that 81 percent of tion of that talent. Ultimately, leadership tending a legally segregated elementary going to be fueled by good old-fashioned minority female associates have left their has to “walk the walk and talk the talk.” school in Houston and later as being part humanity in dealing with your women law firms within five years of being hired. Recognizing that efforts to retain of the first wave of African American lawyers,” Lillie noted. /e report spanned small and large firms, women lawyers benefit the retention of students to integrate the Catholic schools as well as governmental agencies. all lawyers, Lillie also observed the impact in Houston. Kathryn C. Harr, an associate with Trujillo “Retention of women, retention of of the entry of “Generation Y” into the “I’ve learned to be very grateful for Rodriguez & Richards, LLC, is an associate diverse employees is something that has workforce. /e generation’s demand for those scars, those little nicks of day-to-day editor of the Philadelphia Bar Reporter. to be ingrained in the organization,” Lillie demand for flexibility and collaboration life, because it’s through those lessons in said. Using her company, Comcast, as an “will have a positive impact on the efforts life that I’ve really developed a passion example, Lillie cited successful practices in to recruit and retain women including in for diversity and inclusion and the joy of Podcast encouraging the retention of women, in- the legal profession.” making a difference in the various orga- Spotlight cluding employing a director of diversity “When corporations and law firms are nizations in which I’ve been affiliated,” Visit philadelphiabar.org to listen to who focuses solely on diversity efforts and inclusive, there are intended business and Lillie said. She learned from her parents, the podcast from this program. a cross-functional team of leaders that economic successes that result as a result both teachers, the value of being a role Sandra Day O’Connor Award Nominees Sought
T W P C- To nominate someone for the Sandra Judge); U.S. District Court Judge Anita mittee is seeking nominations for the Day O’Connor Award, print a nonina- B. Brody; Leslie Anne Miller, first woman 2008 Sandra Day O’Connor Award. WebCheck tion form at philadelphiabar.org. president of the Pennsylvania Bar Associa- Deadline for nominations is /ursday, tion; Lila G. Roomberg of Ballard Spahr July 31. /e committee established the award /e award has since been presented to Andrews & Ingersoll, LLP; the late Judge /e award is conferred annually on a in 1993 to recognize the important the late Juanita Kidd Stout, former justice Judith J. Jamison; Ellen T. Greenlee, chief woman attorney who has demonstrated contributions that women attorneys of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court; defender of the Defender Association of superior legal talent, achieved significant in Philadelphia have made to the legal Deborah R. Willig, first woman Chancel- Philadelphia; former Chancellor Audrey legal accomplishments and has furthered profession. lor of the Philadelphia Bar Association; C. Talley; U.S. /ird Circuit Court of the advancement of women in both /at year, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Professor Marina Angel, of the Temple Appeals Judge Marjorie O. Rendell; the profession and the community. /e Sandra Day O’Connor presented the University Beasley School of Law faculty; Pennsylvania Superior Court Judge Phyl- award presentation will be made during first award to U.S. District Court Senior U.S. /ird Circuit Court of Appeals lis W. Beck; Roberta D. Pichini and Lynn the October Quarterly Meeting. Judge Norma L. Shapiro. Judge Dolores K. Sloviter (former Chief A. Marks.
8 Philadelphia Bar Reporter July 2008 philadelphiabar.org Network with a Purpose, Lawyers Advised
target audience will be in attendance. ■ By Raymond M. Williams Also, evaluate the potential for build- Neen James o!ered ing strategic alliances. Finally, consider P N J your “return on networking.” /ink of tips to make network- acknowledged that networking is key to the time you will spend at the event, ing proactive, produc- business development for solo and small preparation time prior to the event, and firm attorneys, but encouraged attorneys follow-up time subsequent to the event in tive and profitable. to engage in what she refers to as “pro- the context of your hourly rate (i.e., time networking.” spent not practicing law). Pro-networking is networking with t$IBOHFUIFGPDVTBOENFUIPET a purpose, James said at the May 28 of networking. Instead of approaching working should be a daily activity. After s n joint meeting of the Solo and Small networking with a “what’s in it for me” o attending a planned networking event, y L
f f
Firm Committee and the Marketing attitude, start thinking about what it is e devote at least 15 minutes a day to follow- J
y b Committee of the Law Practice Manage- you can do to help the person with whom up during the week after the event. At o t o h
ment Division. “It is proactive, produc- you are speaking. It is also important to P all times, have a list of five target people, tive and, most importantly, profitable.” “get beyond the nametag.” Help others Neen James encourages attorneys firms or companies. Most importantly, James pointed out that all too often, to get beyond your nametag by explain- to be proactive when it comes to leverage your current network. Cultivate networking. the focus of networking is on the event, ing to them what it is you actually do. the contacts you already have. conjuring images of endless handshaking Be more than just “an attorney at ABC importance and receive others’ cards in a and forced interaction with strangers, firm.” By the same token, don’t assume way that conveys their importance to you. Raymond M. Williams, a partner at DLA which leaves many attorneys with feelings that a person cannot help you simply be- t#SPBEFOZPVSWJFXPGXIBUOFUXPSL- Piper, is an associate editor of the Philadelphia of anxiety and negativity at the mention cause of the title on his or her nametag. If ing is. Networking is marketing. As such, Bar Reporter. of the word. For attorneys who wish to that person cannot give you business, he it need not always involve a group or cost successfully make the transition from “tra- or she may know someone who can. In money. Networking can be as simple as ditional” networking to pro-networking, addition, realize that other attorneys are a phone call, e-mail, sending someone a James provided the following tips: not necessarily your competition. Explore newspaper clipping or handwritten note, Podcast t#FTUSBUFHJDɨJOLTUSBUFHJDBMMZ opportunities for referrals and other stra- publishing an article, or serving on the Spotlight and do your research before accepting tegic alliances. Finally, your business card board of a professional or community Visit philadelphiabar.org to listen to an invitation to an event. Take time to is your shop front. Make sure it properly organization. the podcast from this meeting. determine whether members of your represents your business. Give it with t%FWPUFUJNFUPOFUXPSLJOH/FU-
The Lawyers’ Club of Philadelphia presents A SPECIAL AND UNIQUE CLE
Judge Gene D. Cohen (Ret.)3 Francis P. Devine III, Esq.2 Louis W. Fryman, Esq.2 Montgomery, McCracken, Pepper Hamilton, LLP Conrad O’Brien Gellman Walker & Rhoads, LLP and Rohn
COURSE PLANNER Harris T. Bock, Esq. The Dispute Resolution Institute
Judge Abraham J. Gafni, (Ret.) Donna Lee Jones, Esq.1 Judge D. Webster Keogh1 Philadelphia - The Union League Villanova Law School Saltz, Mongeluzzi, Administrative Judge Barrett & Bendesky Court of Common Pleas Wednesday, July 23, 2008 3 CREDITS Registration begins at 1:00 2 SUBSTANTIVE 1 ETHICS 2:00 – 5:15 P.M. Reception following program from 5:15 - 6:30
The Union League of Philadelphia, 140 South Broad Street
Judge Richard B. Klein Judge Frederica Judge Mary A. McLaughlin Judge Thomas N. O’Neill Jr. Lincoln Ballroom – Second Floor Superior Court of PA Massiah-Jackson US District Court US District Court Court of Common Pleas Register today - Space is limited! BY PHONE: 800-656-1237 ONLINE: www.DisputeRI.com AN EXCEPTIONAL VALUE! $60 FOR LAWYERS’ CLUB MEMBERS (includes CLE and Reception) $120 FOR NON-MEMBERS (includes CLE, Reception, Membership Judge Eduardo C. Robreno Andrew F. Susko, Esq. Joe H. Tucker, Jr. , Esq.1 Kathleen Wilkinson, Esq. US District Court White and Williams LLP Booth & Tucker, LLP Wilson, Elser, Moskowitz, in The Lawyers’ Club and two FREE receptions in fall 2008) Edelman & Dicker LLP $100 FOR NON-MEMBERS (CLE and Reception only) 1 Lawyers’ Club Board Member 2 Lawyers’ Club Past President 3 Lawyers’ Club Past Board Member
philadelphiabar.org July 2008 Philadelphia Bar Reporter 9 CITY POLICY COMMITTEE Smith: Law Department Work Unique, Fullfilling
■ By Jeff Lyons and city council. “Aside from the conflicts that are inherent in representing both T C S’ the executive branch and the legislative where you can do good legal work as a branch, we have, a lot of times, almost lawyer and really try to positively effect final authority to direct what’s going on change for issues and people that you re- with particular projects,” she said. ally care a lot about, the city’s top lawyer “It’s a unique opportunity to be very told members of the City Policy Com- involved both as lawyers and on the s mittee on June 19. policy side. You don’t have billable hours n o y L
f
Shelley R. Smith spent 13 years in the and some of the other things people find f e J
y
law department before moving to private frustrating with private practice,” Smith b
o t o practice. She was appointed by Mayor said. h P Nutter as city solicitor early this year. “/e other very valuable thing about City Solicitor Shelley R. Smith meets with the City Policy Committee, where she “It’s a unique place to work as a law- the experience of working in our office is talked about ways the city and the Bar Association can work together. yer,” Smith said. “As somebody said when that 99 times out of 100 you get to try to I first started in the law department, it’s do the right thing, to get the right result, lawyer in our department in all the time the one place where as a lawyer where you for the right reason. You get to factor in I’ve been connected with it who was not can simply practice law. And that’s abso- all the consequences of a particular deci- trying to figure out what the right solu- Podcast lutely true. It’s a place where lawyers have sion,” she said. tion was, factoring in all of the issues and Spotlight the opportunity to focus almost entirely “We represent city agencies and depart- considerations and really trying to try to Visit philadelphiabar.org to listen to on legal issues.” ments and legislators but ultimately, we come to the right conclusion that would the podcast of this meeting of the Smith said her office is responsible really represent the citizens of Philadel- best serve the citizens,” she said. City Policy Committee. for making all legal decisions for all city phia. We take that responsibility very Smith said people often ask how law- departments, and that includes the mayor seriously. I have not ever worked with a yers and the Bar Association can be help- ful. /e first way that members of the bar front-page news. Some of the hottest legal can do to be helpful is to recognize “for issues in the city are happening in our of- INCORPORATION us, it’s not just about law firms wanting fice. I recognize that. /ere are other ways to get business from the city. Nothing lawyers can be helpful to the city besides AND frustrates me more than lawyers reading soliciting us for business.” about a case, seeing we’ve had a negative “/ere are so many issues that impor- LIMITED LIABILITY result and, wanting to helpful, calling us tant to the future of the city, like labor up and saying ‘hey, we can do it better.’ ’’ negotiations and education issues. It’s COMPANY FORMATION Smith said she understands that law- important that the people involved in yers like to do business with the city. “/e CONVENIENT, COURTEOUS SAME DAY SERVICE cases are interesting and they’re often continued on page 17
PREPARATION AND FILING SERVICES IN ALL STATES ATTORNEY DISCIPLINARY / ETHICS MATTERS CORPORATION OUTFITS AND LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY OUTFITS
SAME DAY SHIPMENT OF YOUR ORDER
CORPORATE STATUS REPORTS UCC, LIEN AND JUDGMENT SEARCH SERVICES DOCUMENT RETRIEVAL SERVICES
0ENNSYLVANIA AND .EW *ERSEY MATTERS .O CHARGE FOR INITIAL CONSULTATION 2EPRESENTATION CONSULTATION AND EXPERT TESTIMONY IN MATTERS M. BURR KEIM COMPANY INVOLVING ETHICAL ISSUES AND THE 2ULES OF 0ROFESSIONAL #ONDUCT SERVING THE LEGAL PROFESSION SINCE 1931 James C. Schwartzman, Esq. &ORMER