Indicator Project South Africa Indicator Donor Members
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
m INDICATOR PROJECT SOUTH AFRICA INDICATOR DONOR MEMBERS MAJOR DONORS First National Bank of Southern Africa Ltd South African Breweries Ltd Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd Anglogold Ltd AECI Ltd Barlow Limited Chamber of Mines South Africa Colgate-Palmolive (Pty) Ltd ESKOM Johnson & Johnson Liberty Life Pick 'n Pay Corporate Services Pretoria Portland Cement Co Rand Merchant Bank Richards Bay Minerals South African Sugar Association Southern Life Foundation University of South Africa (UNISA) Woolworths (Pty) Ltd LIBRARY 3-NOV 1998 institute of •< < - rnent studies INDICATOSOUTH AFRICRA EDITORIAL BOARD SIMON BEKKER Department of Sociology, University of Stellenbosh RICHARD HUMPHRIES Centre for Policy Studies, Johannesburg ALEXANDER JOHNSTON Department of Politics, University of Natal, Durban MESHACK KH0SA Centre for African Research and Transformation, Durban ANTOINETTE LOUW Institute for Security Studies, Johannesburg JULIAN MAY Centre for Social and Development Studies, University of Natal, Durban VALERIE M0LLER Institute for Social and Economic Research, Rhodes University VISHNU PADAYACHEE Centre for Social and Development Studies, University of Natal, Durban WILLIAM SAUNDERSON-MEYER Division of Communication and Publicity, University of Natal, Durban LAWRENCE SCHLEMMER South African Institute of Race Relations, Johannesburg INDICATOR PROJECT SOUTH AFRICA CENTRE FOR SOCIAL AND DEVELOPMENT STUDIES, UNIVERSITY OF NATAL , DURBAN 4041 EDITOR: Ted Leggett ADMINISTRATION AND MARKETING: Jenny Pillay PUBLISHER: William Saunderson-Meyer PRODUCTION: Q ARTWORKS Publishing & Communications ASSOCIATE PUBLISHER: Fran Fearnley PRINTING: Natal Witness Subscription information: Telephone: (031) 260 2525 Fax: (031) 260 2813 e-mail: [email protected] Editorial information: Telephone: (031) 260 1375 Fax: (031) 260 2359 e-mail: [email protected] Web site:http://www.und.ac.za/indicator IDS r 088607 POLITICAL A PAPER TIGER? THE DECLINE OF THE SACP M 0 N 1 T " 0 R PATRICK LAURENCE BETWEEN UNILATERALISM AND THE DESPITE IMPRESSIVE MEMBERSHIP ROLLS, THE CULTURE OF SOLIDARITY: SACP IS PROVING TO BE A PAPER TIGER. THE SACP THE NON-ALIGNED MOVEMENT AFTER WILL BE OUTFLANKED ON THE LEFT BY A POPULIST DURBAN PARTY IF IT DOES NOT RAISE ITS VOICE IN DEFENCE OF THE POOR. ALEXANDER JOHNSTON THE TASK OF THE NON-ALIGNED MOVEMENT ECONOMIC REMAINS THE SAME IN THE POST-COLD WAR MONITOR WORLD: TO FIND A WAY IN WHICH DEVELOPING COUNTRIES CAN HAVE A VOICE IN INTERNATIONAL GLOBAL FINANCIAL CRISIS: WHY WE POLITICS AND ECONOMICS. SHOULD CARE, WHAT WE SHOULD DO PATRICK BOND POLITICAL INTOLERANCE AND ETHNICITY: INVESTIGATING SOCIAL IDENTITY THE RECENT INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL CRISIS GIVES LEADERS IN SOUTH AFRICA A RARE OPPORTU- JAMES L GIBSON NITY TO CHALLENGE THE WASHINGTON CONSENSUS. AMANDA GOUWS The TIME HAS COME TO DEMAND A NEW SYSTEM THAT SERVES HUMAN NEEDS, NOT FINANCIAL PROFIT. STUDIES OF ETHNIC TOLERANCE HAVE SHOWN SOUTH AFRICANS TO HAVE VERY LITTLE CONCERN FOR THE RIGHTS OF OTHER GROUPS. GREATER LESS IDEOLOGY, MORE COMMONSENSE: GROUP ATTACHMENT IS ASSOCIATED WITH GREATER FINANCIAL GLOBALISATION AND THE POLITICAL INTOLERANCE. CURRENCY CRISIS VISHNU PADAYACHEE A VOLKSTAAT FOR AFRIKANERS ALTHOUGH SOUTH AFRICA STOOD OUT FAIRLY WELL CHRIS JOOSTE AGAINST THE FIRST WAVE OF THE EMERGING MAR- LESS THAN ONE THIRD OF THE AFRIKANERS IN KETS CRISIS, UNCERTAINTIES ABOUT BOTH GLOBAL SOUTH AFRICA WOULD BE INTERESTED IN A VOLK- AND LOCAL CONDITIONS MADE IT RIPE FOR SPECU- STAAT. HOWEVER, DIFFERENCES OF OPINON LATION. AMONG AFRIKANERS SHOULD NOT BE USED TO JUSTIFY INACTION on THE PART OF THE GOVERN- MENT. DEVELOPMENT M 0 0 R DRAWING THE LINE: AIDS AND DEVELOPMENT: NO EASY BORDER DISPUTES AND ELECTORAL ANSWERS POLITICS ALAN WHITESIDE KAREN MICHAEL KUSENIDLAMINI ASSESSING THE PRESENT IMPACT OF AIDS STRIC- THREE SETS OF POLITICALLY-CHARGED DISPUTES TLY IN TERMS OF ECONOMICS CAN BE MISLEADING. HAVE EMERGED OVER THE PROVINCIAL BORDERS, SOME INDICATORS MAY IMPROVE, SOME DROP DIS- WHICH WERE ESTABLISHED IN A RUSHED AND PRORTIONATELY, AND DEVELOPMENT EFFORTS MAY UNREPRESENTATIVE PROCESS. ACTUALLY SPEED THE SPREAD OF THE DISEASE. INDICATOR SA • Vol 15 No 3 CONTENTS VIRGIN TESTING: LEGAL ONE ANSWER TO THE AIDS EPIDEMIC? MONITOR GEORGINA HAMILTON THOUSANDS OF YOUNG WOMEN AND GIRLS ARE EMPLOYMENT EQUITY: BEING ATTRACTED TO A REVAMPED ZULU RITUAL - LEADERSHIP CHALLENGE OR NECESSARY THEY ARE HAVING THEIR VIRGINITY PUBLICLY EVIL? "TESTED". OPPONENTS TO THE PRACTICE POINT OUT THAT IT IS UNRELIABLE AND THAT IT STIGMA-' ADELE THOMAS TISES VICTIMS OF SEXUAL ABUSE. As THE EMPLOYMENT EQUITY ACT BECOMES LAW, IT IS ESSENTIAL THAT EMPLOYERS EMBRACE THIS CHANGE AND MAKE USE OF DIVERSITY. THIS MUST CHALLENGE TO TRADITION: BE INITIATED FROM THE TOP DOWN, AND ENTAILS MEDICAL COMPLICATIONS OF TRADITIONAL ARTICULATING "SOUND BUSINESS REASONS" LINK- XHOSA CIRCUMCISION ING DIVERSITY TO OTHER BUSINESS GOALS. GRAEME MEINTJES THE MODERN MANIFESTATION OF THIS ANCIENT RITUAL HAS BEEN LINKED TO DEATHS, INJURIES AND PENILE MUTILATIONS. THE MODERN CEREMO- NY HAS TAKEN ON OVERTONES OF MACHISMO AND INDICATOR PROJECT SOUTH AFRICA produces ETHNIC NATIONALISM. Indicator South Africa and Crime & Conflict. II is based at the Centre for Social and Development Studies at (lie University of Natal. Opinions PARTICIPATIVE DEMOCRACY AND RURAL expressed are not necessarily those of the Editorial Committee and should not be taken to represent the LOCAL GOVERNMENT IN KWAZULU-NATAL policies of companies or organisations which are donor members of Indicator Project South Africa. MARK BUTLER RURAL PEOPLE SUPPORT HAVING TRADITIONAL Copyright for all materials herein is held by AUTHORITIES IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT, BUT THEY INDICATOR PROJECT SOUTH AFRICA. Permission to publish or reproduce any part of this publication DO NOT THINK THE SHOULD PARTICIPATE IN VOT- must be obtained from the publisher. ING, POLITICAL DEBATES, AND FINANCIAL DECI- SIONS. THEY ALSO FEEL THAT REPRESENTATIVES SHOULD BE ELECTED AT A LOCAL LEVEL FROM CAN- DIDATES WHO ARE KNOWN FOR THEIR COMMITMENT TO THE COMMUNITY. COMPARATIVE M N I T 0 R NIGERIA'S CONTESTED DEMOCRATISATION: ADJUSTMENT, AUTHORITARIANISM, AND "CIVIL SOCIETY" FRANCO BARCHIESI NIGERIA'S STRUGGLE CALLS INTO QUESTION THE LINK BETWEEN DEMOCRATISATION AND THE GROWTH OF CIVIL SOCIETY. THE CRISIS OF CIVIL SOCIETY AND THE CRISIS OF STATE INSTITUTIONS ARE, UNDER NEOLIBERALISM AND STRUCTURAL ADJUSTMENT POLICIES, ULTIMATELY COMPLEMEN- COVER ILLUSTRATION BY TARY PROCESSES. MICHELLE MERRIFIELD INDICATOR SA • Vol 15 No 3 ww.N SOUTH AFRICA'S ULICMFDH THINK TANK FOUR TIMES A YEAR, INDICATOR PROJECT SOUTH AFRICA IS FIRST WITH THE BEST. INDICATOR SOUTH AFRICA - the quarterly brainstorming session with the best minds in the country - covers key issues in the political, economic, industrial, social, legal and development fields. Indicator cov- ers the latest research findings, observations from the field and the per- spectives of decision makers in the public and private sectors. CRIME & CONFLICT is a unique L. Safely and Security quarterly journal that specialises in is Bodily Harm? analysing and reporting on a wide range THE BAROMETER OF SOCIAL TRENDS of issues - from political violence to Ll white-collar crime. It goes beyond the sensationalism which characterises media reporting on these issues, to probe causes and consider solutions. O • "Indicator SA has achieved an enviable reputation for skilled, in-depth research... its impartiality and accuracy are acknowledged. Indicator occupies a tddm unique position in the information supply in our rapidly changing country." The Mercury Us I® "... a prestigious research publication." Sunday Timas "Indicator SA, is an informative, non-propagandistic and jargon-free quarterly M • monitor of South African trends. A good source for up-to-date statistics and pithy analysis." Heribeit Adam ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTION RATES CORPORATE INSTITUTIONAL • Indicator and Crime & Conflict R275 • Indicator and Crime & Conflict R200 • Indicator R225 • Indicator R150 • Crime & Conflict R70 • Crime & Conflict R60 INDIVIDUAL OVERSEAS • Indicator and Crime & Conflict R120 • Indicator and Crime & Conflict $95 • Indicator R100 • Indicator $85 • Crime & Conflict R40 • Crime Conflict $30 BOTH JOURNALS ARE PUBLISHED FOUR TIMES A YEAR. PRICES INCLUDE VAT AND POSTAGE. Name: Address: Return to: Indicator Project SA University of Natal Durban 4041 ggESrJ'SS Or fax to: (031) 260 2813 OARTWORKS/1JN0898/3 EDITORIAL ace has become a distasteful subject for eager to down even before the last hangover has most sensible South Africans. To recol- faded. lect that so much pain was caused over In South Africa, ethnic identity has trans- R formed itself into an odd bundle of entitlements. so many years by something so utterly arbitrary and trivial is a profoundly nauseating experi- The claim of black South Africans to a better ence. But apartheid seems to have ensured that way of life is not premised solely on human cleaning up after the race error will be an inte- rights or civil delict or an ancestral claim to the gral part of South African life for the foreseeable land and its fruits, but on a curious and ill- future. defined amalgam of all of these. The continued Though largely discredited as a scientific call for a volkstaat is likewise tied to the pecu- concept, the sociological reality of ethnic iden- liar idea that property rights can arise out eth- tity is not similarly susceptible to rational dis- nicity. All this seems rather backward in a proof. If indeed it is possible at all, uprooting world where