Research Article U-Pb and Hf Analyses of Detrital Zircons from Paleozoic and Cretaceous Strata on Vancouver Island, British Colu
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
GeoScienceWorld Lithosphere Volume 2021, Article ID 7866944, 20 pages https://doi.org/10.2113/2021/7866944 Research Article U-Pb and Hf Analyses of Detrital Zircons from Paleozoic and Cretaceous Strata on Vancouver Island, British Columbia: Constraints on the Paleozoic Tectonic Evolution of Southern Wrangellia Daniel Alberts ,1 George E. Gehrels ,1 and Joanne Nelson 2 1Department of Geosciences, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA 2British Columbia Geological Survey, Victoria, British Columbia V8W 9N3, Canada Correspondence should be addressed to Daniel Alberts; [email protected] Received 23 February 2020; Accepted 25 January 2021; Published 26 February 2021 Academic Editor: Sarah Roeske Copyright © 2021 Daniel Alberts et al. Exclusive Licensee GeoScienceWorld. Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0). Wrangellia is a late Paleozoic arc terrane that occupies two distinct coastal regions of western Canada and Alaska. The Skolai arc of northern Wrangellia in south-central Alaska and Yukon has been linked to the older, adjacent Alexander terrane by shared Late Devonian rift-related gabbros and also by Late Pennsylvanian postcollisional plutons. Late Devonian to Early Permian Sicker arc rocks of southern Wrangellia are exposed in uplifts on Vancouver Island, southwestern British Columbia, surrounded by younger strata and lacking physical connections to other terranes. Utilizing the detrital zircon record of Paleozoic and Cretaceous sedimentary rocks, we provide insight into the magmatic and depositional evolution of southern Wrangellia and its relationships to both northern Wrangellia and the Alexander terrane. 1422 U-Pb LA-ICPMS analyses from the Fourth Lake Formation (Mississippian–Permian) reveal syndepositional Carboniferous age peaks (344, 339, 336, 331, and 317 Ma), sourced from the Sicker arc of southern Wrangellia. These populations overlap in part known ages of volcanism, but the Middle Mississippian cumulative peak (337 Ma) documents a previously unrecognized magmatic episode. Paleozoic detrital zircons exhibit intermediate to juvenile ƐHf ðtÞ values between +15 and +5, indicating that southern Wrangellia was not strictly built on primitive oceanic crust, but instead on transitional crust with a small evolved component. The Fourth Lake samples yielded 49 grains (3.4% of the total grains analyzed) with ages between 2802 Ma and 442 Ma, and with corresponding ƐHf ðtÞ values ranging from +13 to -20. In age—ƐHf ðtÞ space, these grains fall within the Alexander terrane array. They were probably derived from sedimentary rocks in the basement of the Sicker arc. By analogy with northern Wrangellia, this basement incorporated rifted fragments of the Alexander terrane margin as the combined Sicker-Skolai arc system advanced ocean-ward due to slab rollback in Late Devonian to Early Mississippian time. Ultimately, data from detrital zircons preserved in the Fourth Lake Formation provides significant information allowing for an updated tectonic model of Paleozoic Wrangellia. 1. Introduction Wrangellia and Karmutsen Formation of southern Wrangel- lia, that overlie Paleozoic arc-related sequences [1, 2]. Paleo- Wrangellia is one of the most outboard of the major northern zoic sequences of southern Wrangellia comprise the Upper Cordilleran terranes. It occupies two separate regions: south- Devonian to Lower Permian Sicker and Buttle Lake Groups central Alaska and southwestern Yukon (northern Wrangel- [3–7]. Those in northern Wrangellia comprise the Carbonif- lia) and Haida Gwaii and Vancouver Island (southern erous to Lower Permian Skolai Group, including the Station Wrangellia) (Figure 1 inset). It was originally defined as a Creek and Hasen Creek formations [8–13]. coherent terrane based on characteristic thick piles of Until recently, the records of Paleozoic arc activity in Triassic flood basalts, the Nikolai Greenstone of northern southern versus northern Wrangellia were considered to be Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/lithosphere/article-pdf/doi/10.2113/2021/7866944/5292498/7866944.pdf by guest on 23 September 2021 2 Lithosphere Knight inlet Bute inlet 129°W, 50°N Coast Plutonic Complex Tertiary Rocks Nanaimo Eocene Crescent terrane Dragon Property = Eocene Pacifc Rim terrane Bedingfeld Uplif = Buttle Lake Uplif = Cretaceous Nanaimo Group Cowichan Uplif = Wrangellia Terrane Comox Samples Tis Study Jurassic Island Intrusions/ Fourth Lake Samples West Coast Crystalline Complex North Samples Saltspring Jurassic Bonanza Group Island South Samples Ruks, 2015 Triassic Karmutsen Formation Detrital Samples Victoria Devonian Sicker/ Samples CO1 and CO2 Matthews et al., [2017] Trust Fault Carboniferous Buttle Lake Groups 100 km 125°W, 48°N Figure 1: Generalized geologic map of Vancouver Island (modified from Massey et al. [82, 83]). Inset map indicates relevant terranes of the northern Cordillera, location of study area, and general locations for three subdivisions of the Alexander terrane: SEM: Saint Elias Mountain region [17, 18]; SE: Alaska [65, 66, 71]; and BIM: Banks Island assemblage [65]. Abbreviations for displayed tectonic components on inset map: YA: Yakutat; CH: Chugach; CPC: Coast Plutonic Complex; PE: Peninsular; WR: Wrangellia; sWR: southern Wrangellia; nWR: northern Wrangellia; AX: Alexander. Sample locations for this study are denoted with squares. Colored circles are used to represent samples from Ruks [14]. Yellow hexagon represents sample location for samples from Matthews et al. [42]. Dashed ellipses mark the area of uplifts. divergent, with Sicker volcanism confined to the Late Devo- to E-MORB basalts [7]. As such, the Sicker arc has been nian [7] and Station Creek volcanism poorly constrained as modeled as developing in an intraoceanic setting as a possible Carboniferous [11], with Pennsylvanian plutonism [12]. An extension of the Skolai arc, but with no direct connection to Early Mississippian U-Pb age from the base of the Station older terranes [15]. Creek Formation [13] and an extensive database of Devonian This study presents U-Pb ages and Hf isotope composi- to Permian U-Pb and microfossil ages from the Sicker Group tions of detrital zircons from upper Paleozoic strata of south- [14] now support consideration of the Sicker and Station ern Vancouver Island. These data are then used to refine Creek as parts of a single, evolving arc system, such as pro- interpretations on the tectonic evolution of southern Wran- posed by Beranek et al. [15], mainly based on data from gellia. First, the main grain populations will provide addi- northern Wrangellia. tional information on the nature and duration of Paleozoic The tectonic settings of northern and southern Wrangel- arc-related igneous activity. Second, minor grain populations lia are also distinct. Northern Wrangellia lies adjacent to the can be used to test for the possible presence of pre-Late Devo- older Alexander terrane and has been linked to it by Late nian basement to this part of Wrangellia. We analyzed nine Devonian gabbro complexes [13] and Pennsylvanian plu- samples from southern Vancouver Island, including five tonic suites that crosscut the terrane boundary [12, 15]. samples from the Fourth Lake Formation of the Buttle Lake Southern Wrangellia is isolated from other terranes by faults, Group and four samples from the Comox Formation at the by the Late Jurassic Coast Plutonic Complex, and by seaways, base of the Upper Cretaceous Nanaimo Group where it which render its Paleozoic tectonic context highly enigmatic. directly overlies Paleozoic strata (Figure 1). Nanaimo Group Moreover, the Sicker Group of Vancouver Island has been samples were analyzed primarily to gather additional infor- modeled as a Late Devonian nascent arc succession that mation about the Paleozoic history of Vancouver Island via developed on oceanic crust [4–7]. The lowest exposed rock primary and second-cycle zircons potentially preserved in unit, the lower Duck Lake Formation, is a pile of N-MORB these rocks. Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/lithosphere/article-pdf/doi/10.2113/2021/7866944/5292498/7866944.pdf by guest on 23 September 2021 Lithosphere 3 2. Geological Background Near the Duke River fault, the Station Creek Formation is absent, and the Hasen Creek nonconformably overlies the 2.1. Alexander Terrane. The late Paleozoic arc complex at the Late Devonian Steele Creek gabbro complex [13]. The Hasen base of northern Wrangellia has been linked to the adjacent Creek Formation represents postsubduction clastic sedimen- Alexander terrane in terms of probable basement and tec- tation following the Alexander-Wrangellia collision. tonic coevolution [13, 15]. This section begins with a descrip- tion of that older crustal fragment. The Alexander terrane 2.3. Paleozoic Stratigraphy and History of Southern extends over thousand kilometers from the St. Elias Moun- Wrangellia. The oldest rocks on Vancouver Island record tains on the Yukon-Alaska border, through southeast Alaska the early evolution of the southern Wrangellia arc. Included and along the north and central coast of British Columbia are Late Devonian–Carboniferous rocks of the Sicker Group ff (Figure 1 inset). It is a composite of two terranes with di er- and Mississippian–Permian strata of the Buttle Lake Group ent pre-Permian histories, the main Craig subterrane and the (Figures 1 and 3), which are exposed in the Buttle Lake and much smaller Admiralty subterrane of Admiralty Island, Cowichan uplifts of central and southern Vancouver Island southeast Alaska