Wai 1040, #A48

Wai 1040

Validation review of the Crown’s tabulated data on land titling and alienation for the Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry region: Old land claims, surplus land and scrip

Dr Barry Rigby 1 October 2014

Commissioned by the Waitangi Tribunal

Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

Contents Abbreviations ...... iii Glossary ...... iv Introduction ...... 1 Background ...... 1 Approach and methodology ...... 1 Consultation with the parties ...... 1 Scope ...... 2 Outline of the report ...... 2 Aggregation...... 2 Scrip-surplus land distinction ...... 3 Crown grant information ...... 4 Sources in the comments column ...... 5 Answers to questions on the draft report ...... 5 How to use the spreadsheet ...... 7 Guide to spreadsheet columns ...... 8 OLC no. (columns B-C) ...... 8 Survey plan no. (column D) ...... 8 Block name (columns E-F) ...... 8 Name of settler claimant (column G) ...... 9 Original transaction (column H) ...... 9 Crown grant (column I) ...... 9 Surplus land (columns J-K) ...... 9 Scrip land (columns L-M) ...... 9 Comments (column N) ...... 10 Conclusion ...... 10 Appendix A: Old Land Claims data table Appendix B: Commission direction

ii Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

Abbreviations ANZ Archives New Zealand, Wellington AJHR Appendices to the Journals of the House of Representatives Bold row Old Land Claims missing from the Crown spreadsheet Bold type Information at variance with Crown information (in the same column) BSP Berghan supporting papers (vol & page numbers) CP Crown purchase Insignificant Grants less than 5 acres, often in Kororāreka Lapsed Commissioner Heaphy’s effective dismissal of OLCs in 1881 No grant 1840s Commissioners’ recommendation interpreted by Bell as disallowance R fol Crown grant Register and folio (numbers) RWOLC Rangahaua Whanui Old Land Claims report 1997 SLC Surplus Land (Myers) Commission 1946-1948 schedules (as follows) Series 1: Grants in full Series 2: Grants and surplus Series 3: Grants and compensation Series 4: Scrip in full Series 5: Disallowed – Reverted to Crown Series 6: Disallowed or Withdrawn – Reverted to Maoris Series 7: Scrip paid – Reverted to Maoris Series 8: Not investigated – Reverted to Crown or Maoris Series 9: Grant recommended or annulled – Reverted to Crown or Maoris Series 10: Disputed Claims – Purchased by Government Series 11: Claims acquired by Government without payment

iii Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

Glossary The four key terms used in any discussion of old land claims are:  Crown grant: the legal instrument by which the Crown attempted to guarantee secure title to a defined area. Written boundary descriptions within the grant document defined 1840s grants. Only during the 1850s did the Crown require surveyed grant boundaries to be included in the document. The Crown grant is the precursor to the modern Torrens system introduced after 1870.  Native reserve: area that commissioners or the Crown set aside for Maori within a larger area claimed to have been alienated prior to 30 January 1840. In some cases, for example, at Waitangi, the Crown failed to implement commissioners' reserve recommendations which accompanied their grant recommendations.  Surplus land: the difference between the area commissioners determined to have been alienated prior to 30 January 1840, and that included in the Crown grant and/or reserved area. After 1856, Commissioner Bell required most claimants to survey both areas at the same time, thereby defining the extent of surplus. The Crown claimed title to surplus land where commissioners determined that Maori consented to the original transaction.  Scrip land: claimed areas which Pakeha claimants vacated after accepting a Crown offer of equivalent value in the form of either a promissory note (scrip) or cash. Claimants normally exchanged their scrip for land in the vicinity of Auckland after it became the colonial seat of government in 1841. The Crown could then claim title to the supposedly vacant scrip land.

iv Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

Validation review of the Crown’s tabulated data on land titling and alienation for the Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry region:

Old land claims, surplus land and scrip

Dr Barry Rigby

Introduction

Background In his 25 October 2013 Local Issues Research Review, Richard Moorsom (the Tribunal’s Chief Historian) recommended a validation review of OLC, scrip and surplus land data (#6.2.13, table 1, 1.2(a)). He based his recommendation on Crown counsel Andrew Irwin’s acknowledgement of the incompleteness of the Crown’s OLC spreadsheets filed in July 2012. He also stated that Crown counsel, in his 20 September 2013 memo (Wai 1040, #3.2.242) , concurred with claimant counsel Moana Tuwhare’s 5 July 2013 request that the Tribunal commission such a review to provide parties with more accurate OLC information (Wai 1040, #3.2.171). The Chief Historian recommended that ‘a validation review of the Crown’s tabulated data on OLCs [be] commissioned to address any inaccuracies and fill any gaps found, to the extent practicable and in consultation with the parties’.

Following consultation with parties at the judicial conference of 25 November 2013, the recommended OLC validation review project was approved by Presiding Officer Judge Coxhead in his memorandum-directions of 24 December 2013 (#2.6.51, appendix A, table 1, 1.2(a)). Judge Coxhead formally commissioned this project on 31 July 2014 (Wai 1040, #2.3.11 – see appended).

Approach and methodology

Consultation with the parties The subject of appropriate consultation between parties and Tribunal staff arose in discussion between Ms Tuwhare and Mr Irwin over the focus of my OLC evidence. Initially, I proposed dealing with the limitations of the OLC spreadsheets in my evidence, later presented at the September 2013 hearing. Rachel Hogg then replaced Mr Irwin in continuing discussions with Ms Tuwhare and me in November and December 2013. I shared an abbreviated version of the draft report and the draft spreadsheet with Ms Hogg and Ms Tuwhare on 14 April 2014.

1 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

Scope In the accompanying spreadsheet I have presented the original Crown figures alongside the result of the validation appraisal. I have found approximately 132 instances of unvalidated figures for surplus and scrip land. I have inserted approximately 23 claims missing from the Crown’s data. I have also extracted approximately 30 ‘half caste’ and additional claims from the Crown’s Pre-emption Waiver claims sheet (in which they do not belong). I did not consider pre-emption waiver claims (1050 to 1299). The pre-emption waiver claims are to be the subject of a separate exercise that will include consideration of pre-1865 Crown purchases.

Outline of the report This report addresses four questions I have attempted to answer in constructing my spreadsheet. They are: a) Would a sensible aggregation of claims (usually by claimant in a specific location) assist the reader? b) Did the Crown conflate scrip and surplus acreage in its 2012 spreadsheet? c) What additional Crown grant information would assist the validation of the 2012 spreadsheet? d) What missing source and explanatory information is required for the validation of the 2012 spreadsheet?

Following this I respond to questions submitted by Crown counsel regarding the aggregation of OLC data for the region as a whole. I then set out ways in which parties could use the spreadsheet data before explaining each of the 13 columns. Finally, I make some guarded concluding remarks.

The abbreviations employed in my 13-column, 559-row draft OLC spreadsheet are listed in the front pages, together with a glossary of the four key terms employed in analysing OLCs.

Aggregation In the edited OLC spreadsheet I have aggregated claims, where appropriate, in the comments column. Initially I intended to reduce multiple claims for a single claimant to a single row. For example, Busby’s eight Waitangi claims (OLC 14-22) resulted in a single survey, a single

2 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

Crown grant, and a single surplus land figure. Rendering this information in a single row would have precluded my questioning the Crown’s surplus land figure for OLC 20. Consequently, for Busby’s claims, I have retained the Crown’s eight original rows, but I have aggregated OLC 14-22 data in an additional final row to make it clear that this applies to all eight Busby Waitangi claims. The grant, surplus and scrip columns of the aggregated rows are shaded in grey.

I have aggregated the multiple claims of CMS families in the same way. For instance, James Shepherd’s seven Whangaroa-Kerikeri claims (OLC 802-808) involved eight different surveys. Thus, they could not be reduced to a single row. Nor was it possible to aggregate surplus land acreage, since it was recorded in different surveys. Instead I have aggregated total Shepherd Crown grant acreage in an additional final row immediately below the OLC 808 row. This aggregate figure is significant. It shows that the Crown granted Shepherd more than any other CMS missionary.

Generally, my rule of thumb in aggregating claims data is to make concrete outcomes (such as Shepherd’s total grant acreage) more intelligible. Aggregated data can be easily located by searching for italicised and hyphenated OLC numbers in column C, and in the comments column. Aggregated data is also shaded grey.

Scrip‐surplus land distinction The Crown appeared to conflate scrip and surplus land in its data. When it recorded a scrip payment, it often entered the same figure as surplus land acreage. This follows an official practice begun as early as 1878. When Lands Department officials first listed OLC survey plans they recorded scrip and surplus land in a single column entitled surplus (see ‘List of Plans . . .’ OLC 5/12/38). The Crown’s rendering of scrip payments, as opposed to scrip land, also creates difficulties since payments and land quantities varied. Consequently, I have replaced monetary values with acreage. I have normally relied on the so-called ‘scrip surveys’ for establishing reliable acreage figures.

In calculating surplus land acreage, I have also relied upon the original OLC plans, which normally identify grant and surplus boundaries. In some cases, I have checked plan-based surplus acreage with that calculated by the Lands and Survey staff assisting the 1946-1948 surplus lands, or Myers, commission (abbreviated as SLC). For example, SLC staff reduced

3 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

the Busby Waitangi surplus land figure of 1046 acres recorded on the survey plan SO 930A to 1010 acres. SLC staff apparently revised the original figure to account for overlap between surplus arising from Busby’s Waitangi claims and that arising from the adjoining Hingston Onewhero claim (OLC 227). I have referenced this information to SLC 3:1 (the Lands and Survey record of this calculation at MA 91/5/10, series 3, p 1).

In one or two cases I question the SLC calculation. SLC staff declared that 2448 acres of surplus land arose from the Kemp Waipapa (OLC 595) in the Kerikeri area. Yet the balance between the surveyed and grant acreage (the normal way of calculating surplus) was 11,819 acres. I believe that the wide difference between these two figures arose from the fact that the Crown in 1869 granted to two Maori individuals 7184 acres at Pungaere, and in 1920 the Crown returned to Maori 2196 acres at Puketotara in a claims settlement. SLC staff treated both these areas as Maori land in spite of the Crown’s earlier claim to both as surplus land within Kemp’s Waipapa claim area. Hence, although I have recorded the SLC figure in the comments column, I have also recorded that it does not include either Pungaere or Puketotara West in its calculation. I have entered in the surplus column the balance between surplus and grant acreage, that is 11,819 acres.

Crown grant information Crown grants provide base-line information upon which other calculations depend. Just as deducting grant acreage from surveyed acreage is the normal way of calculating surplus acreage, the totalling of multiple grants by claim and claimant yields one of the most tangible outcomes of the entire OLC process. The Crown’s original data focussed instead on four separate sets of commissioners’ recommendations. While these recommendations led, in most cases, to Crown grants they did not constitute a tangible outcome.

I have therefore compiled a detailed record of properly referenced Crown grant information. I have recorded, wherever possible, grantee, date and Register references in the comments column. In some complex cases, I have summarised the grantee information. McDonnell’s five Te Horeke-Motukaraka claims (OLC 1032-1038), for example, produced at least 12 different Crown grants to at least ten different grantees, mostly in the Whangarei area, far from the location of the Hokianga claim area. At rows for OLC 1037 and 1038 I have recorded the Hokianga and Whangarei grant acreages as the most tangible outcomes of this complex process, but I have not recorded the names of each of the ten grantees.

4 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

In the course of compiling this detailed Crown grant information I have discovered that while Commissioner Bell rewrote the grants record book after 1856, he did not override approximately 15 of the original 1844-1845 FitzRoy grants within the Te Raki area. These grants were apparently accompanied by surveys, even though many of the plans are missing from the grant Registers. All the valid 1844-1845 Crown grants are referenced to the five original Register 5 volumes. The approximately 200 post-1856 Crown grants are contained within the larger two Register 15 volumes (R15 and R15a).

Sources in the comments column I have recorded written source information in the comments column. This includes information from Bell’s 1863 Appendix (AJHR 1863 D-14), and from the 1878 and 1881 official ‘settlement’ schedules (AJHR 1878 H-26; AJHR 1881 C-1). It also includes references to the SLC schedules listed below under abbreviations. Crucial visual source information, in addition to the written sources, appears in the survey plan column (D).

I should emphasise that I have employed appropriate caution in using Bell’s 1863 Appendix, and in using the 1946-1948 SLC schedules. Bell’s failure to include surplus or scrip land acreage in his appendix suggests that he fell far short of full disclosure. Likewise, the SLC’s failure to publish the supporting data in its final report (AJHR 1948 G-8) denied the public the opportunity to examine the sources of its complex calculations.

My edited version of the Crown’s OLC spreadsheet is an attempt to disclose the most essential information on the tangible outcomes of the entire process. I have omitted what I regard as inessential data in the full awareness that parties may not agree with my selection choices.

Answers to questions on the draft report In my draft report I stated that I had not attempted to add up any of the acreage columns at the end of the sheet. I consciously avoided this because I had so many questions about the reliability of those acreage figures. I added that after considering comments on the draft version of what follows, it might be possible to add up the grant, surplus and scrip columns. I have now received questions from the Crown, dated 3 September 2014, that have prompted me to add up the grant, surplus and scrip columns. In calculating totals for the grant, surplus

5 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014 and scrip columns, I eliminated the 132 unvalidated surplus and scrip figures identified in my draft report, but these figures still appear on the spreadsheet with question marks beside them. My answers to the Crown comments and questions appear below in italics.

1. Question: Are you able to draw any conclusions about the total extent of lands that were, through the Old Land Claims process in the Te Paparahi o te Raki/Northland inquiry district: I must preface my answers by stating that, as indicated at p 6 of my 1 August draft report, my figures did not include the results of 1844-1845 pre-emption waiver claims. These claims are to be the subject of a separate exercise that will include consideration of pre-1865 Crown purchases. 1.1 granted to settlers? 134,671.58 acres 1.2 retained by the Crown as surplus land? 54,414.99 acres 1.3 retained by the Crown as “scrip” lands? 5,657.75 acres

2. Question: Is the reference to “nearly 300,000 acres” accurate in paragraph 166 of the Crown’s statement of position and concessions,1 where the Crown states that it calculates that: Te Paparahi o Te Raki Maori lost nearly 300,000 acres of land as a net result of the Crown’s investigation in the 1840s and 1850s of hundreds of land claims based on land transactions that Northland Maori and Europeans entered into before the Treaty was signed […] and between 1843 and 1844 […]. My total of Crown grants, surplus and scrip land of 194,744.32 acres applies only to claims based on pre-Treaty transactions. It is therefore difficult to compare with the Crown’s overall figure, which includes pre-emption waiver claims.

3. Question: Do you agree with the following estimations at paragraph 167 of the Crown’s statement of position and concessions2: 3.1 105,088 acres were lost to Northland Maori through Crown grants to Europeans;

1 #1.3.2 at page 53. 2 #1.3.2 at page 53.

6 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

My figure of 134,671.58 acres is higher than the Crown’s. Since my figure is based directly on Crown grant acreage, I believe it is reliable. 3.2 125,675 acres were lost to Northland Maori through the Crown’s retention of surplus lands; 3.3 60,910 acres were lost to Northland Maori through the Crown’s retention of scrip lands3; and My lower figures for both surplus (54,414.99 acres) and scrip (5,657.75) acreage are based largely on survey information. I believe that the surveys show what the Crown brought into the public domain. I attribute my lower figures for both surplus and scrip land to the fact that almost all of the 132 unvalidated Crown figures come from these columns. 3.4 between 160,000-190,000 acres in total were retained by the Crown as surplus lands in the North Island. I did not assess anything outside the Te Raki inquiry area, so I cannot estimate North Island surplus land acreage. 4. Question: Would you alter any of the figures in the table located on page 54 of the Crown’s statement of position and concessions, which is entitled “Land loss from pre- Treaty and pre-emption waiver land transactions”? I will be able to answer this question only if and when Tribunal staff complete a quantification of the results of pre-emption waiver claims.

How to use the spreadsheet The best way to use the spreadsheet for most users will be either by claim number, or by block name and location. I have adopted Bell’s single sequence numbering (from one to 1375). I have added locations to many block names to assist users. Many users will want to see the original survey plans. Fortunately, most of the OLC and ML (Maori Land) plans referred to in column B are available in the CFRT Northland Map Set (or Arcflax 1.0, Northland, 2D & 3D Geographic Information System Viewer, including Crown Purchases, Old Land Claims, Native Land Court Blocks, and other historical map image DVDs), which

3 Where a settler would have been granted land in the Te Paparahi o Te Raki/Northland inquiry district, but instead exchanged that land for land elsewhere (eg Auckland) and where the Crown retained the land originally claimed by the settler in the Te Paparahi o Te Raki/Northland inquiry district.

7 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

is on the Wai 1040 record of inquiry as A45. Most OLC plans are on disk 4 of that set, and most ML plans are on disk 5.

In the spreadsheet I have identified the approximately 132 instances of unvalidated figures for surplus and scrip land by placing a question mark to the right of these figures in a ‘validated’ column. For the approximately 23 claims missing from the Crown’s data that I have added to the spreadsheet, I have rendered the entire new row in bold type. I have added the approximately 30 ‘half caste’ and additional claims extracted from the Crown’s Pre- emption Waiver claims sheet at rows 522-559.

Guide to spreadsheet columns The following is a column by column guide to the spreadsheet.

OLC no. (columns B‐C)

The validated column (C) to the right of the Crown’s original OLC numbers column (B) differs from it only very slightly. Aggregated OLC numbers (eg Busby’s Waitangi claims shown as OLC 0014-22) appear in the validated column. In cases where commissioners considered different claims together (eg OLC 0040 and 519), I have added the additional claim number in bold in the validated column. As indicated above, I have identified claims missing from the Crown’s data with an entire row in bold type.

Survey plan no. (column D)

For the sake of simplicity I have a single survey plan column. I have entered new information in bold alongside the original Crown information. Please note that none of the OLC survey plan numbers correspond to claim numbers.

Block name (columns E‐F)

In my validated block name column (F) I have added locality information in bold to assist the reader. In a few places I have corrected misspelt names; for example, with OLC 0122 at row 74 I have corrected ‘Raurau’ to ‘Rahurahu’. In that case I have also given Mangamuka as the locality.

8 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

Name of settler claimant (column G)

In almost all cases, except where the Crown omitted claims, I have validated the name of the original settler claimant. Neither the Crown nor I have attempted to identify derivative claimants who may have purchased claims, or land, from the original claimant. When the Crown granted land to someone who was not the original claimant, however, readers can assume that this person was a derivative claimant.

Original transaction (column H)

The Crown’s transaction acreage figures are based on the original statements of claim filed by settler claimants. In most cases these figures greatly exceeded what the Crown was prepared to grant such claimants. Only when such claims were measured by survey do the claimed acreage figures reach anything approaching reality.

Crown grant (column I)

I have attempted to validate significant Crown grant acreage by referring (in the comments column) to the original grants Register reference at Archives New Zealand. Please note that my grants information is not exhaustive. I have not included grants of less than five acres (mainly in the Kororareka/Russell township area). I refer to these as ‘insignificant grants’ in the comments column.

Surplus land (columns J‐K)

I have relied largely upon original OLC survey plans to establish surplus land acreage. As previously discussed with regard to the scrip-surplus land distinction, these plans normally identify both grant and surplus acreage. In some cases Maori attempted to claim surplus land subsequently in the Native Land Court. This occurred in Powditch’s Waitapu and Okura claims (OLC 384-385) at Whangaroa. On the recommendation of the Crown’s district officer, Judge Monro in 1876 dismissed Maori claims to over 2,000 acres of surplus land there, shown on the survey plans as ‘Govt. Land’ (see ML 3181 and 3182).

Scrip land (columns L‐M)

Scrip land is, as Mr Irwin described it his 3 September questions to me: Where a settler would have been granted land in the Te Paparahi o te Raki/Northland inquiry district, but instead exchanged that land for land elsewhere (eg Auckland) and where the Crown retained the land originally claimed by the settler in the Te Paparahi o te Raki/Northland inquiry district.

9 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040): Dr Barry Rigby, ‘Old land claims validation report’ 1 Oct 2014

In order to retain scrip land, however, the Crown had to identify it by survey. To my knowledge, only at Hokianga did the Crown survey scrip land in any systematic way. This surveyed acreage forms the basis of the relatively limited scrip land acreage figure that I give in answer to Mr Irwin’s question about scrip land.

Comments (column N)

I have used the far right hand comments column to record either source information or information that assists understanding of the concrete outcomes of the over 500 settler claims based on pre-Treaty transactions. I normally omit comment on claims that did not result in concrete outcomes. Some of my comments are quite compressed. For example, with Potter’s Parehau claim (OLC 0380 at row 168) I comment: ‘“No proof of alienation” (RA Fitzgerald) BSP 7:3935. Yet “land reverted to Crown . . .” SLC 11:1’. This suggests an anomaly. Commissioner Fitzgerald found the claim to be without merit, yet Myers Commission staff during the 1940s evidently believed that the Crown treated it as land alienated from Maori. In fact the commission staff named their series 11 as ‘Claims acquired by Government without payment’.

Conclusion

In conclusion, I hasten to add that I have been unable to uncover much information on a number of claims. For several of the so-called ‘half-caste claims’, file information no longer exists at Archives New Zealand.

I must therefore add a cautionary note similar to the Crown’s disclaimer issued on 6 July 2012, and again on 20 September 2013. In those memoranda Mr Irwin stressed the provisional and incomplete nature of the Crown’s spreadsheet data (Wai 1040, #3.1.783; #3.2.242). At the same time, I believe that I have attempted to present Old Land Claims data that is both more usable and more complete than that which the Crown produced during 2012.

10 Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0012 OLC 0012 OLC 270 Pakunui Pakunui Pakanae Henry Richard Oakes 300 0 300 ? 300 69.3.0 Hokianga Scrip Claim OLC 0013 OLC 0013 DP12400 LT Opunga Opunga John Israel Montefiore 343 47 171 ? 218 ? Montefiore Opunga grant, 22 Oct 1844, R5b fol 21 12400 OLC 0014 OLC 0014 (Waitangi) (Waitangi) James Busby 270 - -- OLC 0015 OLC 0015 (Waitangi) (Waitangi) James Busby 25 - -- OLC 0016 OLC 0016 (Waitangi) (Waitangi) James Busby 500 - -- OLC 0017 OLC 0017 (Waitangi) (Waitangi) James Busby 2000 - -- OLC 0018 OLC 0018 (Waitangi) (Waitangi) James Busby 100 - -- OLC 0019 OLC 0019 (Waitangi) (Waitangi) James Busby 60 - -- OLC 0020 OLC 0020 Te Puke Te Puke Waitangi James Busby 1500 632 ? --No separate surplus OLC 0021 OLC 0021 (Waitangi) (Waitangi) James Busby 5000 - -- OLC 0022 OLC 0022 SO 930A (Waitangi) (Waitangi) James Busby 150 - -- OLC 0014-22 9374 1010 Combined OLC 14-22 . Busby grant 7 Sep 1872, R86a, fol 206. SLC 3:1 OLC 0023 OLC 0023 OLC 282 Bream Bay? Bream Bay? Waipu James Busby 25000 ?- ? - - Plan missing OLC 0026 OLC 0026 Kirikopuni Wairoa R William Christmas 250 W Bray grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 276 OLC 0024 OLC 0024 OLC 282 Waipu Waipu James Busby 15000 ?- ? - - Plan missing OLC 0027 OLC 0027 (Hokianga) (Hokianga) Motukaraka William Salmon Deloitte & 2000 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 2. 'Reverted to Maoris'. SLC 9:1 William Stewart OLC 0036 OLC 0036 OLC 401 (Great Barrier Island) (Great Barrier Island) William Abercrombie, J. 20000 0 - - - - Plan missing. Overlap with Crown purchases Nagle & William Webster OLC 0040 OLC 0040 & 519 OLC 254 Warewarekauri Warewarekauri John Anderson 1000 ? 1000 ? 1000 3871 Hokianga Scrip Claims. Possible grants not traced. Native reserve 219 acres

OLC 0041 OLC 0041 Wau or Apara Wau or Apara Whirinaki Robert Angus 1000 0 158 ? 50 ? No grant. BSP 1:367 OLC 0042 OLC 0042 Winii Island Winii Island Thomas Applebee & George ? 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 1:369 Clapham OLC 0047 OLC 0047 ML 11791 (Paroa Bay) (Paroa Bay) Francis Atherton 320 0 - - - - 'Reverted to Maoris' partly as Otamarua ML. SLC 9:1 OLC 0048- OLC 0048-0050 (Hokianga) (Hokianga) Rawene James Baker 3200 253? 3200 ? 722 944 Plan missing. Combined with OLC 89, 90, 811 & 814. SLC 4:2 0050 OLC 0051 OLC 0051 OLC 44 (Paroa Bay) (Paroa Bay) John Barber 100 - --- OLC 0052 OLC 0052 OLC 175 Opoiti Opoiti Paroa Bay John Barber 100 - --- OLC 0053 OLC 0053 OLC 275 Toutaranui Toutaranui John Barber 30 - --- OLC 0054 OLC 0054 Potarah Potarah John Barber 100 - --- OLC 0055 OLC 0055 ML 3233, 3401 (Tepuna) (Tepuna) John Barber 40 - - - -

OLC 0051-55 211 OLC 51-55. Hill -Barber grants 6 Aug 1860, 10 Feb 1862. R15 fol 171, R15a fols 233-234 OLC 0056 OLC 0056 OLC 33 Otehi Otehi Paroa Penin Thomas Bateman (later 22 28.3.20 - - - - Clendon grant 24Jun 1861 , R15, fol 196 Clendon) OLC 0057 OLC 0057 (Waikare) (Waikare) Thomas Bateman ? 0 - - - - Withdrawn AJHR 1863 D-14 p 5 OLC 0058 OLC 0058 OLC 353 Motukakia Motukakia Motukiekie Thomas Bateman 100 67 - - - - Bateman grant, 14 Jul 1866. R15a fol 341 OLC 0059 OLC 0059 OLC 16 (located between the Akeake Kerikeri Thomas Bateman (later 1500 1157 542 128 948.1 ? WS Grahame grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 285. Included in the 1860 'Tareah and Kidi Kidi' William Smellie Grahame) Hikuwai CP. SLC 2:11 rivers) OLC 0062 OLC 0062 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Thomas Bateman 0.5 0 - - - - Withdrawn AJHR 1863 D-14 p 5 OLC 0063 OLC 0063 Kororareka Richard Holton & Benjamin E. ? 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 2:608 Turner OLC 0065 OLC 0065 OLC 158&42 Waimate John Bedggood 250 185.2.0 - - - - Bedggood-Pugh grants, 27 Oct 1859, R15 fols 128, 130 OLC 0067 OLC 0067 OLC 53 Puketona Puketona Waitangi Thomas Black & William 300 310 - - - - Green and Black grant, 17 Mar 1856. R5e fol 17 Green OLC 0075 OLC 0075 Kororareka William Brown ?0----No grant. BSP 2:710 OLC 0081 OLC 0081 OLC 106 (Paroa Bay) (Paroa Bay) John Byron 90 53.3.17 - - - - Byron grant, 11 Jul 1861. R15 fol 200 OLC 0082 OLC 0082 Mangataipa or Warou Mangataipa or Warou Thomas Cassidy 1500 0 1053 ? 1053 ? No plan to confirm surplus or scrip OLC 0083 and OLC 0083 and 0036 OLC 271 Te Rurunga Te Rurunga Waima Thomas Cassidy 1000 63 150 ? 1000 380 Hokianga Scrip Claims. Cassidy family grant (OLC 369) 12 Jun 1873, AJHR 0036 1878 H-26 p 5 OLC 0087 OLC 0087& 208 OLC 255 Rangiwhakataka Rangiwhakataka Motukiore William Nicholas & Thomas 700 0 467 ? 467 393 Hokianga Scrip Claim. Two Native reserves 32 acres Chadwick OLC 0088 OLC 0088 Kororareka William Chalk 0.25 0 - --- No grant. BSP 2:831 OLC 0089 OLC 0089 OLC 436 Kothugatoa or Paramu Kothugatoa or Paramu Rawene Charles Henry Chambers 300 259 ? -- OLC 0090 OLC 0090 OLC 436 (Omanai River) (Omanaia River) Rawene Charles Henry Chambers 1000 - --- OLC 0089-90 416 OLC 89-90. Montefiore grant, 25 Nov 1859, R15, fol 140 OLC 0093 OLC 0093 Whangaroa Charles Henry Chambers 600 0 - --- No grant. BSP 2:922 OLC 0094 OLC 0094 OLC 276 Tei Tei Mangamuka Alexander Chapman 300 0 54 ? 54 340 Hokianga Scrip Claim. Native reserve 27 acres

Page 1 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0095 OLC 0095 & 447 OLC 258 Papawhakahota Papawhakahota Omanaia Alexander Chapman 900 0 136.5 ? 136.1 178.2.0 Hokianga Scrip Claim. Surveyed with OLC 447 OLC 0096 OLC 0096 Mangapouri Mangapouri Matapouri William Harvie Christie and J. 15000 0 1427.5 ? 2000 ? Mostly wiithin the 4707 acre 1864 Matapouri CP. SLC 7:1 Duffies OLC 0097 OLC 0097 (Kawakawa River) (Kawakawa River) John & Mary Church 147 foot frontage - - - -

OLC 0098 OLC 0098 (Kawakawa River) (Kawakawa River) John & Mary Church 100 - --- OLC 0097-98 - OLC 97-98. Lapsed, AJHR 1881 C-1 p2. Within 1859 Kawakawa CP. SLC 9:6 OLC 0100 OLC 0100 Kororareka George Thomas Clayton ?0-3.1.16 - - SLC 2:2 OLC 0101 OLC 0101 Huaahine Huaahine George Thomas Clayton 2.5 0 - - - - OLC 101, 103, 111, 113 lapsed, AJHR 1881 C-1 p 2 OLC 0102 OLC 0102 Kororareka George Thomas Clayton 10---- OLC 0103 OLC 0103 Oneroa Oneroa George Thomas Clayton 3 0 - - - - OLC 101, 103, 111, 113 lapsed, AJHR 1881 C-1 p 2 OLC 0108 OLC 0108 Kororareka George Thomas Clayton 20---- OLC 0109 OLC 0109 Kororareka George Thomas Clayton 9 0 - - - - 5 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:3 OLC 0110 OLC 0110 Kororareka George Thomas Clayton <1 0 - --- OLC 0111 OLC 0111 Kororareka George Thomas Clayton 8 0 - - - - 8 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:4 OLC 0112 OLC 0112 Kororareka George Thomas Clayton 5 0 - - - - None of the Clayton Kororareka claims produced significant grants. See R5a fols 46, 49-50; R5c fol 85 OLC 0113 OLC 0113 (Pomare's Pa) (Pomare's Pa) George Thomas Clayton 202? - - OLC 101, 103, 111, 113 lapsed, AJHR 1881 C-1 p 2 OLC 0114 OLC 0114 OLC 132 (Okiato?) (Okiato) James Reddy Clendon 220 0 220 ? - 229 See plan. Site of first colonial capital at 'Russel OLC 0115 OLC 0115 OLC 133 Kaikatearoa Kaikatearoa James Reddy Clendon 80 0 80 ? - 280 Adjacent to Okiato/Russel OLC 0116 OLC 0116 OLC 12 &13 (Manawaora?) (Manawaora?) James Reddy Clendon 3000 1613 657 657 - - JR Clendon grants, 5 & 24 June 1861. R 15 fols 193, 195. 'Affected by the [1938] Manawaora Petition'.SLC 2:20 OLC 0117 OLC 0117 OLC 140 Kakekiroa Kakekiroa Matauwhi James Reddy Clendon 10 23.1.0 - - - - JR Clendon grant , 19 Jan 1864 , R15a fol 299 OLC 0118 OLC 0118 OLC 139 Kaierara Kaierara Kororareka James Reddy Clendon (& 4 8.1.0 - - - - Gould grant, 9 Sep 1859. R15 fol 147 Frank Gould) OLC 0119 OLC 0119 (Tamariri and (Tamariri and "Uditanana") James Reddy Clendon (& 25 - - - - Included in Clarke's Waimate OLC 633 grant. BSP 3:1403 "Uditanana") Waimate George Clarke) OLC 0120 OLC 0120 OLC 131 (Manawara) (Manawara) Waikare James Reddy Clendon (& 60 1323 - - - - WB White grant, 5 Dec 1862. R15a fol 267 George Clarke) OLC 0121 OLC 0121 SO 949D Orongo Orongo James Reddy Clendon (& 400 273 544 ? 544 ? J Johnson grant 24 Jul 1854, R1E fol 5 George Clarke) OLC 0122 OLC 0122 OLC 142 Raurau Rahurahu Mangamuka Denis Browne Cochrane 1000 200 800 ? 800 ? Hokianga Scrip Claim. Jane Clendon grant, 19 Jan 1864, R15a fol 298. SLC 3:3 OLC 0123 OLC 0123 & 346 OLC 274 Pukahau Pukahau Denis Browne Cochrane 500 0 500 ? 500 ? Included in Poynton's OLC 346. BSP 3:1498 OLC 0124 OLC 0124 & 966 OLC 260 ML Koroau Horohoro Denis Browne Cochrane 500 0 328 ? 328 278 Hokianga Scrip Claim. Appears to be within Te Karae ML. SLC 7:1 11647 OLC 0126 OLC 0126 OLC 136 Horari Orare Waikare N William Cooke & Robert Day 40 - - - -

OLC 0127 OLC 0127 Pahiko Pahiko Waikare S William Cooke & Robert Day 200 - - - -

OLC 0126-27 226.2.35 OLC 126-127. Cook grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 292 OLC 0135- OLC 0135-0139 Kororareka Dan Cooper, J. Holt & W.B ? 0.0.19 - - - - Cooper, Holt, Rhodes grant, 26 Jun 1868. AJHR 1878 H-26 p 3 0139 Rhodes OLC 0140 OLC 0140 ML 4408 Pakanae, Hokianga George Cooper 1000 0 603 301.1 ? Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 2. 'Reverted to Maoris' as Whakatahataha ML. SLC 9:1 OLC 0161 OLC 0161 & 773 OLC 4 &152 Putakotare Putakotare Waimate James Davis 15 - - - - See OLC 773 for grant and surplus details OLC 0162 OLC 0162 OLC 156 Waipuna Waipuna Waitaruke Patrick Donovan 20 8.2.0 - - - - Brighton grant, 27 Oct 1859. R15 fol 129 OLC 0165- OLC 0165-0167 (Kororareka Beach) (Kororareka Beach) William Drake ? 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 3:1654 0167 OLC 0172 OLC 0172 OLC 423, 211- Kerikeri-Lake Omapere John Edmonds 2112? 621.0.17 ? 1160 1022 Edmonds Kerikeri grant, 20 May 1872. AJHR 1878 H-26 p 3 ; Edmonds 213 family Omapere grants, 17 Apr 1874, R15a fols 378-388 OLC 0173 OLC 0173 George Hemmings & Robert 10 - --- Edney OLC 0174 OLC 0174 OLC 183 Okura Kerikeri George Hemmings & Robert 40 ? ? 20 20 Edney OLC 0173-74 4.3.0 OLC 173-174. J Johnson grant 19 Sep 1861. R15a fol 223 OLC 0176 OLC 0176 Warau Warau Hokianga Samuel Egert 350 0 214.5 ? 214.5 ? No plan to confirm surplus or scrip OLC 0177 OLC 0177 Orira Samuel Egert 600 0 - -- - No plan OLC 0178- OLC 0178-0180 OLC 191 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) John Evans less than 1 0 - - - - 0180

Page 2 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0181- OLC 0181-0183 OLC 192 Waikari and Tokakapura Waikari and Tokakapura John Evans 30 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 2. 20 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:1 0183 OLC 0190 OLC 0190 Mata Karaka Mata Karaka Waima Edward Fishwick 1200 0 1200 ? 1200 ? No plan OLC 0191 OLC 0191 Te Raro Te Raro Waima Edward Fishwick 80 0 80 ? 80 ? No plan OLC 0192 OLC 0192 & 968 ML 4409 Kote Kototai Kote Kototai Waima Edward Fishwick 0.5 - - - - 16 acres 'Reverted to Crown' after dismissal at NLC. SLC 9:1 OLC 0193 OLC 0193 Kototai Kototai Waima Edward Fishwick 0.5 - --- OLC 0192-93 0 OLC 192-193. Insignificant grants. See R5a fols 8-9 OLC 0194 OLC 0194 Edward Fishwick 600 0 600 ? --No grant. AJHR 1863 D-14 p 14 OLC 0199 OLC 0199 Awaroa, Whangarei Peter Greenhill 2500 0 1053 ? 2500 2500 Surveyed & resumed by Govt' (Bell nd) . BSP 4:2330 OLC 0200 OLC 0200 OLC 172 (Waikare River) (Waikare River) Otuihu E George Greenway 100 89.2.2 - - - - Greenway Otuihu E grant, 16 May 1844. R5 fol 55 OLC 0201 OLC 0201 Waikare Pa Waikare Pa George Greenway 50 0 - --- OLC 0202 OLC 0202 OLC 72 Otho Otho Waikare South George Greenway 200 117.1.5 - - - - Waetford grant, 19 Sep 1861. R15a fol 220 OLC 0203 OLC 0203 Moutukoura Moutukoura George Greenway 3 0 - - - - See OLC 767 OLC 0208 OLC 0208 OLC 255 Kohi Kohi Motukiore William Richardson Gundry 500 0 500 ? 463 463 Hokianga Scrip Claim. NRs 32 acres shown on plan OLC 0209 OLC 0209 & 1370 OLC 310 Otarihau Otarihau Motukaraka William Richardson Gundry 500 0 500 ? 500 500 See OLC 1370 Gundry grant OLC 0212 OLC 0212 James Hamilton 11 0 - --- No grant. BSP 5:2445 OLC 0223 OLC 0223 OLC 225 (Waitemata Harbour) (Waitemata Harbour) Thomas Hellyer 320 377 - - - - Stratford grant, 8Aug 1860. R15 fol170 OLC 0224 OLC 0224 (Pomare's Pa) (Pomare's Pa) Otuihu George Hemmings 0.25 0 0.25 ? --See OLC 173 Johnson grant OLC 0225 OLC 0225 Henry Henderson ?0----No grant. BSP 5:2463 OLC 0227 OLC 0227 OLC 27 Onewhero Waitangi N William George Cornelius 1600 1276 - 319 - - Hingston grant, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fol 240 Hingston OLC 0228 OLC 0228 OLC 22 SO Wharau Kerikeri Inlet William George Cornelius 500 214.2.0 500 ? - - Hingston grant, 21 Apr 1881. AJHR 1881 C-1 p2 2434 Hingston OLC 0229 OLC 0229 Moutopapa Motupapa Kerikeri Inlet William George Cornelius 4 4 - - - - Hingston grant, 19 Jul 1844. R5a fol 18 Hingston OLC 0230 OLC 0230 OLC 211 "Othahowey" "Othahowey"Kerikeri William George Cornelius 560 58 300 ? - - Hingston grant, 21 Apr 1881. AJHR 1881 C-1 p2 Hingston OLC 0231 OLC 0231 ML 7260 "Worikitti" "Worikitti" Waikare Thomas Hopkins & William 300-400 0 350 350 - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 2 'Reverted to Maoris' within Waikare ML. SLC Tully Pearse 9:1 OLC 0233 OLC 0233 (Whangaruru) (Whangaruru) H.C. Holman ? 0 - - - - Missing from Berghan. Reverted to Maori. SLC 8:2 OLC 0242 OLC 0242 OLC 267 (Mangamuka River) (Mangamuka River) Robert Hunt 3000 0 2560 ? 2560 533 Hokianga Scrip Claim OLC 0243 OLC 0243 (Mangamuka) (Mangamuka) Robert Hunt ?0----No grant. BSP 5:2844 OLC 0247 OLC 0247 OLC 96 Te Take Te Take Rangiahua Henry Jellicoe 1500 50 ? -- OLC 0248 OLC 0248 Te Ngaio Te Ngaio Rangiahua Henry Jellicoe 100 50 49 -- OLC 0247-48 837 OLC 247-248. Webster-Campbell grant, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fol 227; SLC 2:2 OLC 0249 OLC 0249 OLC 286 (Paroa Bay) (Paroa Bay) James Johnson 100 0 100 ? -- OLC 0250 OLC 0250 SO 6006 & (Paroa Bay) (Paroa Bay) James Johnson 10 0 - - - - OLC 249-250. 60 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:1 6308 OLC 0270 OLC 0270 OLC 5 Mokau North Whangaroa Thomas Joyce 3000 508 992 992 - - Hopkins grant, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fol 225;SLC 2:2 OLC 0271 OLC 0271 (near Waimate) (near Waimate) Thomas Joyce 4 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 3 OLC 0272 OLC 0272 OLC 273 & 266 Pakaihekatoa Pakaihekatoa Waima James Kelly, James Philip 2000 ? ? 1958 Hokianga Scrip Claim. Included in OLC 0468. Lloyd, John Baker & Thomas Hollingsworth OLC 0274 OLC 0274 John Baptis LaCourt & James ? 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 5:3042. Became Motuti ML. SLC 6:4 Honorius LaCourt OLC 0275 OLC 0275 OLC 259 Kohukohu Kohukohu John Baptis LaCourt & James 5000 0 - -- 37? No grant. BSP 5:3036. 37 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 5:1 Honorius LaCourt OLC 0277 OLC 0277 OLC 186 Kohukohu Kohukohu Whirinaki John Leef 200 58.2.0 - - - - Leef grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 289 OLC 0278 OLC 0278 OLC 30 Purerua James Leitch 550 151.2.7 - - - - Lamont grant, 19 Sep 1863. R15a fol 268 OLC 0284 OLC 0284 SO 1653a Okeo Wairoa R Edward Lord 340 340 McGregor grant, 3 Sep 1856. R21 fol 135. ANZ file missing OLC 0283 OLC 0283 OLC 187 Rueto Rueto Whangaroa William Lillico 35 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 3. 25 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:5 OLC 0285 OLC 0285 Kororareka Edward Lucett ?0----No grant. BSP 5:3160 OLC 0302- OLC 0302-0304 Whangaroa Hugh McLiver 3600 0 785 ? 785 ? No grant. BSP 6:3173-74 0304 OLC 0305 OLC 0305 Kororareka Hugh McLiver 102 by 67 feet 0- -- - OLC 0306 OLC 0306 Te Wahapu Te Wahapu Gilbert Mair 350 394.3.0 - - - - Mair Te Wahapu grant, 4 Oct 1844. R5a fol 64 OLC 0307 OLC 0307 Whangarei Gilbert Mair 5000 1798 - - - - Mair Whangarei grant, 10 Jun 1853. AJHR 1863 D-14 p 23 OLC 308 & OLC 308 & 646-7 OLC 100 Titoki-Whatitiri Makepeace & Powell 0 765 'Reverted to Maoris' as Tokirikiri-Mangakahia ML. SLC 7:2 646-7 ML267, ML 9071 OLC 0311 OLC 0311 OLC 122 Ohoke Onoke Hokianga S Frederick Edward Maning 200 99.3.0 - - - - Maning grant, 11 Jul 1861. R15a fol 202

Page 3 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0312 OLC 0312 John Marmon 200 108 ? 200 ? OLC 0313 OLC 0313 John Marmon 200 108 ? 200 ? OLC 0314 OLC 0314 John Marmon 250 ? ? - - Incl. in Wairere ML. SLC 6:4. See also OLC 1364 OLC 0315 OLC 0315 John Marmon 250 ? ? 250 ? OLC 0316 OLC 0316 John Marmon 300 - --- OLC 0317 OLC 0317 OLC 123 Rawhia, Hokianga John Marmon 300 - --- OLC 0312-17 523 OLC 312-317. Marmon Rawhia grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 297. Incl. in Waihou ML. SLC 6:4 OLC 0318 OLC 0318 OLC 269 Upper Waihou Richard Mariner & Francis 1500 0 108 108 1500 324 Hokianga Scrip Claim Bowyer OLC 0319 OLC 0319 ML 6581 Paroa Bay, Bay of Islands Alexander Marshall 300 0 ? ? ? ? 93 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Paroa ML. SLC 9:5 OLC 0326 OLC 0326 OLC 127 "Amaupurrie" "Amaupurrie" Omapere John Martin 45 10.1.0 - - - - Martin Omapere grant, 1 Jul 1861. R15 fol 201 (Hokianga) OLC 0327 OLC 0327 "Arai Touru" "Arai Touru" Hokianga South John Martin 50 53 50 ? - - Martin South Head grant, 22 Oct 1844. R5b fol 27. 29 acres 'Reverted to Hd Crown' as Pilot Station 1870. SLC 9:5 OLC 0332 OLC 0332 & 1265 (Motutapu Island) (Motutapu Island) Thomas Maxwell 2560 3648 - 80 - - R Graham grant 20 Nov 1857, R 15, fol 14; Maxwell family grant, 24 Aug 1870, R15a fol 368; SLC 2:3 OLC 0334 OLC 0334 Waiuku Waiuku Waimate John Marquarie Palmer 20 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 3. Approx 20 acres apparently 'Reverted to Maoris'. SLC 9:7 OLC 0337 OLC 0337 (Matakana) (Matakana) Thomas James Millon & John 5000 2560 - - - - Millon-Skelton grants, 22 Oct 1844, 15 Feb 1845. R5b fol 33; R5c fol 58 Skelton OLC 0339 OLC 0339 OLC 350 Mata Mata Hokianga N Peter Monro 600 95.3.7 - - - - Hopkins grant, 4 Aug 1870. R15a fol 340. 'Natives permitted survey of only 95 acres . . .' AJHR 1878 H-26 p 5 OLC 0341 OLC 0341 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) William Benjamin Moores 0.25 0 - - - - Insignificant grant OLC 0346 OLC 0346 OLC 274 Whangarei Robert Mulholland 500 0 - - - - Reverted to Maori. SLC 8:2 OLC 0348- OLC 0348-0349 ML 11647 Totara Totara, Te Karae Hokianga John Murray 1500 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 3 . Approx 1500 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Te 0349 Karae ML. SLC 9:6 OLC 0352 OLC 0352 OLC 262 & 312 Moutu Kauri Moutu Kauri Hokianga George Nimmo 200 0 200 ? 200 181 Hokianga Scrip Claim

OLC 0353 OLC 0353 OLC 18,not 312 Otuwere Otuwhere, Waitangi Benjamin Nesbit 500 230 - 125 - Scott-Hart grants, 6 Jul 1859. R15 fols 71-73; SLC 2:3

OLC 0354 OLC 0354 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Joseph Norman & Charles 47 x 95 feet 0 - - - - Insignificant grant John Cook OLC 0356 OLC 0356 Pipiro Pipiro James Scott Odeland 300 0 ? ? -- OLC 0357 OLC 0357 Te Kauri Te Kauri, Hokianga James Scott Odeland 300 0 - --- OLC 0358 OLC 0358 ML 93 Makananui and Pateko Makananui and Pateko James Scott Odeland 500 0 - - - - OLC 356-358. Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 3. Approx 900 acres 'reverted to Maoris' as Ahutoatoa. SLC 5:1 OLC 0363 OLC 0363 ML 6809 (Wangaruru Bay) (Wangaruru Bay) Whangaruru John Marquarie Palmer 250 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 3. Approx 250 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Whangaruru-Whakaturia ML. SLC 9:6 OLC 0369 OLC 0369 & 83 OLC 271 Tuki Tuki Tuki Tuki, Waima James Pearson 1000 63 158.5 ? - 317 Hokianga Scrip Claim. NLC Cassidy family grant, 12 Jun 1873. AJHR 1878 H-26 p 5 OLC 0377 OLC 0377 SO 939 Waihoatou Waihoatou, Omanaia Thomas Honan 30 0 30 ? - 30 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 3. Included in the Papakawau Scrip Survey. 'Reverted to Crown' SLC 9:6 OLC 0378 OLC 0378 OLC 264 Tukatahoa Tukatahoa, Mangamuka Henry Pearson 80 0 0 80 10.3.20 Hokianga Scrip Claim. 'Reverted to Maoris'as Pukahu ML. SLC 7:2 OLC 0379 OLC 0379 OLC 256 Tonappu and Tonappu and Tarouakukupa Henry Pearson 2000 0 77 ? 1594 77.1.0 Hokianga Scrip Claim Tarouakukupa OLC 0380 OLC 0380 OLC 243 Parehau Parehau, Purerua Thomas Potter 80 0 - - - - 'No proof of alienation' (RA Fitzgerald) BSP 7:3935. Yet 'land reverted to Crown . . .' SLC 11:1 OLC 0381 OLC 0381 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) William Potter 0.5 0 - --- No grant. BSP 7:3941 OLC 0383 OLC 0383 OLC 240 Kaimanga Kaimanga, Onewhero William Powditch 140 - -- OLC 0384 OLC 0384 OLC 134 (Waitapu) (Waitapu), Whangaroa William Powditch 400 - - - ML3181 OLC 0383-84 165 783 OLC 383-384. Snowden grant, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fol 226; SLC 2:3. Shown as 'Govt land' on ML 3181 OLC 0385 OLC 0385 ML 3182 Okura Okura, Whangaroa William Powditch 3000 0 1500 1470 1500 ? Shown as 'Govt. Land' on ML 3182 OLC 0386 OLC 0386 OLC 274 Pukanou Pukanou, Magamuka Thomas Poynton 100 0 100 ? 427 427 OLC 0387 OLC 0387 Papakawau Papakawau, Omanaia Thomas Poynton 200 0 200 ? 427 427 OLC 0388 OLC 0388 Omanaia Thomas Poynton 150 0 150 ? 427 427 OLC 0389 OLC 0389 Takaroa Takaroa, Omanaia Thomas Poynton 200 0 200 ? 427 427 OLC 0390 OLC 0390 Pongue Pongue, Omanaia Thomas Poynton 2000 0 465 ? 427 427 OLC 0391 OLC 0391 Mangamuka Thomas Poynton 800 0 800 ? 427 427 OLC 386-391. Hokianga Scrip Claims

Page 4 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0393 OLC 0393 OLC 218 SO Tippa Tippa Tipatipa, Waikare Frederick Reid 500 106 114 ? - - H Johnson grant, 31 May 1881. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 3. 110 acres 'Reverted to 2050 Crown'. SLC 9:3 OLC 0394 OLC 0394 ML 322 Owara Owara Whara, Te Puna John Reid 30 0 30 ? - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 3. 6 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Whara ML. SLC 9:3 OLC 0395 OLC 0395 ML 293 Te Karaka John Reid 0 122 acre Crown grant to Maori, 30 Mar 1867. R39a fol 139. Te Karaka ML 293. SLC 6:4 OLC 0396 OLC 0396 Mangonui Te Tii Francis Richards 0 '. . . Presumably reverted to Maoris'. SLC 9:14 OLC 0397 OLC 0397 Haurakina Isd GF Robinson 360 Reader Wood grant, 25 Jun 1862. R15a fol 259 OLC 0399 OLC 0399 OLC 65 Hui Tohia Hui Tohia Kohukohu George Frederick Russell 400 - --- OLC 0400 OLC 0400 OLC 66 Huitohia Huitohia Upper Waihou George Frederick Russell 300 - --- OLC 0401 OLC 0401 Kohu Kohu Kohu Kohu George Frederick Russell 50 - --- OLC 0399-0401 170 OLC 399-401. Webster-Campbell grants 10 Feb 1862. R15a fols 228, 236 OLC 0402 OLC 0402 OLC 277 Take Tai Taketahi, Motukiore George Frederick Russell 400 0 310 ? 251 335 Hokianga Scrip Claim OLC 0408 OLC 0408 OLC 26 Wananaki Whananaki David Salmon 7000 0 - - - - 103 acres surveyed at Kerikeri (in exchange? OLC 0409 OLC 0409 (Island of Moturoa) (Island of Moturoa) David Salmon 600 363.0.37 - - - - J Salmon grant, 13 Oct 1843. R5 fols 10-12 OLC 0416 OLC 0416 (near Waikare & Kerikeri Thomas Stewart Scott 145 feet frontage 0 - - - - No grant. AJHR 1863 F-14 p 32 Kawakawa Rivers) OLC 0422 OLC 0422 (Kerikeri River) (Kerikeri River) William Johnson Smal 3000 0 - --- No grant. BSP 8:4666. Approx 3000 acres 'Reverted to Maoris'. SLC 9:14 OLC 0423-424 OLC 0423-424 (Takapuna and Weiti) (Takapuna and Weiti) Alexander Brodie Sparke 62500 - - - - See Campbell grants, OLC 453-454 OLC 0429 OLC 0429 OLC 344 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Thomas Spicer 56 x 56 feet 0- -- - OLC 0430 OLC 0430 (Paramatta) (Paramatta) Thomas Spicer 80---- OLC 0431 OLC 0431 OLC 198 Uruti Uruti Kororareka S Thomas Spicer 100 0 100 ? 87.5 ? OLC 0432 OLC 0432 Waiparoa Waiparoa Thomas Spicer 120 x 120 feet 0- -- - OLC 0433 OLC 0433 (Waiparoa) (Waiparoa) Thomas Spicer 0.25 0 - --- OLC 0434 OLC 0434 (Waipara) (Waipara) Thomas Spicer 0.5 0 - --- OLC 0435 OLC 0435 OLC 194 Pomare Bay Thomas Spicer 400 0 372 ? 372 ? OLC 0436 OLC 0436 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Thomas Spicer 4 0 - - - - OLC 436 & 438. Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p3 OLC 0437 OLC 0437 Thomas Spice 150 0 75 ? 87.5 ? OLC 0438 OLC 0438 Tepuna Tepuna Thomas Spicer 0.5 0 - - - - OLC 436 & 438. Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p3 OLC 0440 OLC 0440 (Waikare River) (Waikare River) Thomas Spicer 500 0 - --- OLC 0441 OLC 0441 ("Hill called Mike") Maiki Thomas Spicer 1.5 24 - - - - R Graham grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 275 OLC 0442 OLC 0442 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Thomas Spicer <1 0 ---- OLC 0444 OLC 0444 Rahuwai Samuel Stephenson 15 - --- OLC 0445 OLC 0445 OLC 229 Tapeka Tapeka Samuel Stephenson 15 - --- OLC 0444-45 25.3.0 OLC 444-445. Stephenson grant 16 May 1844. R5 fol 56 OLC 0446 OLC 0446 Pakona Pakona, Whangaroa Edward Stillard 60 0 60 ? 60 ? Reverted to Maoris'. SLC 7:2 OLC 0447 OLC 0447 OLC 258 "Bukohoe or Kowekatahi" Omanaia Henry Ashford Strout & 600 0 87 ? 340 178.2.0 Hokianga Scrip Claim Henry Harrison OLC 0448 OLC 0448 ML 849 (Waikau) (Waikau) WaikareN James Stuart ? 0 - - - - 115 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Ikaroa ML. SLC 9:4 OLC 0449 OLC 0449 OLC 250 Pataua North James Stuart 5000 1560 - - - - Thorne grant 29 Jun 1864. R15a fol 320 OLC 0450 OLC 0450 Okoka Okoka, Kawakawa James Stuart 10 344 - - - - OLC 448 & 550. Thorne grant (elsewhere) 20 Aug 1868. R15a fol 360 OLC 0451 OLC 0451 OLC 231 (Paroa Bay) (Paroa Bay) William Sturley 100 100 - - - - Sturley Paroa Bay grant, 22 Oct 1844. R5c fol 11. Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4. 44 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:8 OLC 0452 OLC 0452 (Waikare River) (Waikare River) Henry Swain 300 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4. 100 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:8 OLC 0453 OLC 0453 OLC 138 Weiti Weiti Henry Tayler & Alexander 20000 2235 - - - - OLC 453-454. Campbell grants, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fols 283-284 Brodie Sparke OLC 0454 OLC 0454 Takapuna Takapuna Henry Tayler 1000 0 500 ? 500 ? Within 1841 Mahurangi CP OLC 0457 OLC 0457 Motuihe H Tayler 430 Tayler grant, 8 Sep 1843. R5 fols 6-8 OLC 0461 OLC 0461 Puparahaka Puparahaka, Hokianga Alexander Thompson 1800 0 693 ? 1825 ? Unsurveyed land north of Rawhia. BSP 9:5381 OLC 0464 OLC 0464 OLC 254 Upper Waihou Stephen MacDonald & ? 0 693 ? - 50 Included in Orira Scrip Survey. Approx 50 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC William Thurlow 11:1 OLC 0467 OLC 0467 Te Kotoro Te Kotoro, Waima William Trusted 500 0 385 ? 67.13 ? Unsurveyed. BSP 9:5463 OLC 0468 OLC 0468 & 272 OLC 273 Pakaikatoa Pakaikatoa, Waima Pierre Piene Tuite 500 0 96 ? 174 475 Hokianga Scrip Claim. Includes OLC 272 (Kelly). BSP 9:5471 OLC 0469 OLC 0469 OLC 236 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Benjamin Evans Turner 20---- OLC 0470 OLC 0470 Kohokae Kohokae Benjamin Evans Turner 80 - --- OLC 0471 OLC 0471 (Uruti) (Uruti) Benjamin Evans Turner 25 - --- OLC 0472 OLC 0472 (Uruti) (Uruti) Benjamin Evans Turner 30 - --- OLC 0470-72 89.2.38 OLC 470-472, Turner Uruti grant, 16 May 1844. R5 fol 57 OLC 0473 OLC 0473 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Benjamin Evans Turner 7 0 - - - - OLC 469-473. Kororareka grants all less than 5 acres OLC 0479 OLC 0479 Hokianga Patrick Walsh 350 0 277 ? 280 ? No plan to verify surplus or scrip OLC 0496 OLC 0496 Whangarei George Weller ?0?? - - Missing from Berghan. Reverted to Maori. SLC 8:2 OLC 0512 OLC 0512 OLC 87 Motiti [Island] Motiti Isd Hokianga William White 1 8.3.0 8 ? - - F White grant, 10 Jun 1862. R15a fol 258

Page 5 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0513 OLC 0513 OLC 64 Mata Te Mata, Hokianga S William White 150 ? ? --See OLC 516 OLC 0514 OLC 0514 OLC 265 Ruapapaka Ruapapaka, Horeke William White 2 0 87 ? - - 'Govt Land . . . Reverted to Natives' as ML 1471. SLC 6:6. See also OLC 265 OLC 0515 OLC 0515 OLC 272 Rotoponga Rotoponga, Wairere William White 1000 0 271 ? 1000 ? No grant information OLC 0516 OLC 0516 OLC 85 & 64 Te Mata, Hokianga William White 500 - - - - OLC 0513/16 462 OLC 513 & 516. W Russell Te Mata grant, 10 Jun 1862. R15a fol 255 OLC 0517 OLC 0517 William White & George 250 0 66 ? 250 ? See OLC 513-518 Burdekin grant Frederick Russell OLC 0518 OLC 0518 OLC 254 Umawera William White & George 470 1280 - - - - OLC 513 -518. Burdekin Umawera grant, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fol 247 Frederick Russell OLC 0519 OLC 0519 OLC 254 Orira William White & George 10000 0 693 ? 6099 2372? SLC 3:2, 4:1. Combined with OLC 40, 315 and 416 in Orira scrip survey. Frederick Russell Difficult to determine acreage OLC 0520 OLC 0520 Kapowai Matthew Whytlaw 3000 0 2560 ? 2560 800.2.0 Native Land Claims Commission 1920 settled scrip land dispute. 1162 acres returned to Te Kapotai. SLC 4:7 OLC 0521 OLC 0521 OLC 54, 58 Titirangi, Ahikakariki and Titirangi, Ahikakariki and KaipaiaHenry Williams 1000 - --- &45 Kaipaia OLC 0522 OLC 0522 OLC 54 Powerua Pouerua Henry Williams 3000 - --- OLC 0523 OLC 0523 OLC 54 Hihi Hihi Henry Williams 500 - --- OLC 0524 OLC 0524 OLC 245 Pukeaira Pukeawa Henry Williams 2000 2000 - 1043 --H Williams Pukeawa grant, 15 Jun 1852. R5c fol 20; SLC 2:7 OLC 0525 OLC 0525 OLC 54 Pakapu Pakapu Henry Williams 500 - --- OLC 0526 OLC 0526 OLC 43 &47 Puketona Puketona Henry Williams 2000 7203 - - - - OLC 521-523, 525-526. Multiple grants. 24 Aug 1857, 2 May 1858, 24 Jun 1861, R15, fols 1-9, 21, , 197-198 OLC 0521-23, 0525 7203 OLC 521-523, 525. Multiple grants. 24 Aug 1857, 2 May 1858, 24 Jun 1861, R15, fols 1-9, 21, , 197-198 OLC 0527 OLC 0527 Mangakahia Mangakahia John Williams ?0----No grant. BSP 10:6052 OLC 0529 OLC 0529 Umukahu Umukahu William Williams 300 - --- OLC 0530 OLC 0530 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) William Williams 400 - --- OLC 0531 OLC 0531 Taiamai Taiamai William Williams 20 - --- OLC 0532 OLC 0532 Taupotaka Taupotaka William Williams 20 - --- OLC 0533 OLC 0533 Uropi, Koao and Kioneone Uropi, Koao and Kioneone William Williams 100 - - - -

OLC 0534 OLC 0534 OLC 43 & 47 ("Maungaturoto") ("Maungaturoto") William Williams 100 - --- OLC 0529-34 1488 OLC 529-534. H Williams Jr grant. 2 Mar 1858, R15, fol 22. NR 3.2.0 OLC 0535 OLC 0535 Kauwau Kauwau, Oneroa Thomas Wing 120 0 ? ? - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4. Approx 120 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:8 OLC 0536 OLC 0536 ML 1169 Kohe Kohe Kohe Kohe, Kapowai Samuel Allen Wood 100 0 ? ? - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4. 18 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Kohekohe ML. SLC 9:8 OLC 0537 OLC 0537 OLC 73 Orongo Kororareka S John Wright 600 262.2.3 - - - - Wright grant, 4 Oct 1849. R5a fol 66 OLC 0539 OLC 0539 OLC 312 Koutu Mungerou or One Koutu Mungerou or One Tree William Young 640 227.3.29 - -- Nimmo grant, 10 Aug 1866. R15a fol 345 (2.1.4) ; W Young grant, 14 Feb Tree Hill Hill 1881, AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4 (225.2.25) OLC 0540 OLC 0540 Te Raueana Te Raueana, Upper Waihou William Young 640 0 271 ? 640 ? No plan to verify surplus or scrip OLC 0541 OLC 0541 OLC 67 Opanone Opononi William Young 100 41 - - - - Webster grant, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fol 235 OLC 0542 OLC 0542 ML 8099 Wau Nui Wau Nui, Hokianga North Hd William Young 100 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4. Apprx 100 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Kahakaharoa ML. SLC 9:8 OLC 0543 OLC 0543 (Tutukaka) (Tutukaka) Francis Atherton, James Kelly 6000 0 1005 ? 1005 ? 'Reverted to Maoris' as Rehuotane, Whakahewa & Te Maika ML SLC 7:2 and Frederick Whitaker OLC 0544 OLC 0544 OLC 238 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Francis Atherton, James Kelly 2 0 - - - - No grant information and Frederick Whitaker OLC 0545 OLC 0545 OLC 135 "Kohi" (Waikare) "Kohi" (Waikare) Charles Baker 1212 1260 - - - - C Baker grant, 2 Mar 1858. R15 fol 16 OLC 0546 OLC 0546 OLC 109 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Charles Baker 30 8.0.4 - - - - C Baker grant, 2 Mar 1858. R15 fol 15 OLC 0547 OLC 0547 Mangakahia Mangakahia Charles Baker 5000 0 1920 ? 1920 ? 'Baker unable to obtain possession'. AJHR 1878 H-26 p5. Within 1876 Oue & 1896 Tarakiekie CPs. SLC 10:1 OLC 0548 OLC 0548 (Kororareka Beach) (Kororareka Beach) William Baker 0.25 0 - --- No grant information OLC 0549 OLC 0549 OLC 35 SO 795 Totara North William Baker 10000 1259 2889 2889 - - H Snowden grant, 1 Dec 1860. R15 fol 185; SLC 2:12

OLC 0550 OLC 0550 OLC 428 Mutataunga Motuhanga, Waitaruke William Baker 15 15 - - - - W Baker Jr grant 8 Aug 1879. AJHR 1881 C-1, p 4 OLC 0551 OLC 0551 Whangaroa W Baker 15 0 - - - - Withdrawn 1843. BSP 11:6877 OLC 0554 OLC 0554 OLC 128 Oneroa-Matauwhi William Derby Brind 440 396.2.17 - 50 - - McMillan grant, 19 Sep 1861. R15a fol 212; SLC 2:3 OLC 0555 OLC 0555 Urupukapuka Urupukapuka William Derby Brind 150 0 - - - - Reverted to Maori as ML 7113. SLC 6:6 OLC 0556 OLC 0556 OLC 91 Tapeka Tapeka Kororareka N William Derby Brind 30 12.1.10 - - - - Brind Tapeka grant, 16 May 1844. R5 fol 58 OLC 0557 OLC 0557 Kororareka William Derby Brind ? 0 - - - - Withdrawn. BSP 12:6993 OLC 0567 OLC 0567 Kororareka Walter Brodie 0.75 0.1.10 - - - - Brodie grants, 30 Jun 1849. AJHR 1863 D-14 p 44

Page 6 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0568 OLC 0568 Otawake Otawake, Okahu Isd Walter Brodie 120 0 - --- No grant. BSP 12:7100 OLC 0569 OLC 0569 ML 6800 "Ocoddehee" Okorihi, MatauriOcoddehee" Walter Brodie 380 0 - - - - 380 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Matauri ML. SLC 9:8 OLC 0571 OLC 0571 "Tetaddy", Howe and Matauri"Tetaddy", Howe and Walter Brodie 3000 0 - - - - Reverted to Maori as part Matauri. SLC 6:6 others others OLC 0573 OLC 0573 ML 2576 Toa Toa Toa toa, Te Puna Manheim Brown 10 0 - - - - Reverted to Maori as part Toatoa. SLC 6:6 OLC 0574 OLC 0574 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Manheim Brown 60 x 70 feet 0? ? -- OLC 0575 OLC 0575 Paroa Bay Manheim Brown 7 0 - - - - Approx 8 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Paroa ML. SLC 9:7 OLC 0576 OLC 0576 (Paroa Bay) (Paroa Bay) Manheim Brown 80---- OLC 0577- OLC 0577-0578 Wytata Wytata Kororareka Manheim Brown 30 0 - - - - Approx 30 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:7 0578 OLC 0579 OLC 0579 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Manheim Brown 4 0 - - - - OLC 573-579. Grants recommended, but none resulted. AJHR 1863 D-14 p 45 OLC 0580 OLC 0580 Te Puna Patrick Byrne & George Beers ? 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 12:72223

OLC 0586 OLC 0586 Kororareka-Oneroa John Eales ?0?? --No grant. BSP 12:72228 OLC 0589 OLC 0589 Paengaroa, Kerkeri William Thomas Fairburn 400 0 ? ? --No grant. BSP 12:72243. See also OLC 32. SLC 6:6 OLC 0594 OLC 0594 OLC 52 Tihari Te Hare, Waimate James Kemp 50 356? ? ? - - Grant acreage on plan unverified OLC 0595 OLC 0595 OLC 60 Mangaparirua Waipapa-Puketotara- James Kemp 5000 6598 ? 11,819 - - Kemp Waipapa grants,16 Jul, 1859 , R15 fols 58-66; SLC 2:4 deducted Pungaere, Kerikeri Pungaere (7184a) & Puketotara W (2196a) OLC 0596 OLC 0596 Kiareroa Kiareroa, Kerkeri James Kemp 150 ? ? -- OLC 0597 OLC 0597 OLC 34 Kororipo Kororipo, Kerikeri James Kemp 6 ? ? -- OLC 0598 OLC 0598 OLC 24 Puawa Puaua, Kerikeri James Kemp 70 ? 67.2.30 -- OLC 0596-98 26.0.13 OLC 596-598. Kemp family grants, 27 Oct 1859, R15 fol 126, 19 Jan 1864, R15a fol 270 OLC 0599- OLC 0599-0602 OLC 38 Kaeo, Mangaiti, Paetu and Kaeo-Mangaiti, Whangaroa James Kemp 4000 2722 1742 1742 - - OLC 599-602, Kemp Whangaroa grants, 19 Sep 1861. R15a fols 211; SLC 0602 Pitakatahi 2:4 OLC 0603 OLC 0603 OLC 21 Te Puna-Hohi John King 3000 710 2090.75 - - OLC 0604 OLC 0604 OLC 19 Otaha-Waiaua John King 1500 11770 2090.75 8746 -- OLC 0605 OLC 0605 Tapuati Tapuati John King 500 0 2090.75 -- OLC 0606 OLC 0606 John King 150 0 2090.75 - - OLC 603-606. King family Otaha-Te Puna grants, 16 Jul 1859. R15 fols 50- 57 OLC 0607 OLC 0607 Philip H. King 1---- OLC 0608 OLC 0608 Philip H. King 3---- OLC 0609 OLC 0609 Philip H. King 1---- OLC 0607-09 6.1.26 OLC 607-609. PH King Te Puna grant, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fol 239 OLC 0610 OLC 0610 OLC 126 (Waiaua) Te Puna (Waiaua) Philip H. King 1500 - --- OLC 0611 OLC 0611 OLC 228 (Waiaua) Otaha(Waiaua) Philip H. King 800 - --- OLC 0610-11 3276 OLC 610-611. E Stephenson grant, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fol 245 OLC 0614 OLC 0614 Paroa Bay Henry Rich 150 0 - - - - Incl. in Otamarua ML. SLC 6:6 OLC 0615 OLC 0615 Wahihi Wahihi -Maiki John Roberton 20 0 - - - - See OLC 954 Pompallier grant OLC 0616 OLC 0616 DP 8078 "Island of Moturohe in "Island of Moturohe in Paroa John Roberton 400 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4. Greenway awarded CT in 1912 'by adverse Paroa Bay" Bay"Motuarohia occupation'. SLC 9:8 OLC 0624 OLC 0624 OLC 278 (Mangamuka River) (Mangamuka River) Joseph William Wright 1000 0 389 ? 1500 389 Hokianga Scrip Claim OLC 0625 OLC 0625 OLC 263 "The Pukaou" "The Pukaou"Mangamuka Joseph William Wright 100 0 18 ? 100 18 Hokianga Scrip Claim OLC 0633 OLC 0633 OLC 55 (Waimate) (Waimate) George Clarke 1500 1426 1498 ? - - Clarke Waimate grants, 16 Jul 1859. R15 fols 67-69 OLC 0634 OLC 0634 OLC 1 (Waimate) Whakanekeneke George Clarke 4000 6531 ? 1914 - Clarke-Hopkins grants, 16 Jul 1859, 10 Feb 1862, R15 fol 70, R15a fol 229; SLC 2:5 OLC 0637 OLC 0637 OLC 209 Orongo-Te Wahapu Joel Samuel Polack 100 43 - - - - Polack Orongo grant, 25 Jan 1860. R15 fol 178 OLC 0638 OLC 0638 & 642 Kororareka Joel Samuel Polack 9.5 0 - 4.2.3 0 SLC 2:5 OLC 0639-640 OLC 0639-640 Haruru Waitangi Joel Samuel Polack 152 15.2.0 - - - - John Busby grant, 14 Apr 1876. R15a fol 396 OLC 0641 OLC 0641 Waitangi R Isd Joel Samuel Polack 30 0 300 ? 300 ? Non-existent island! OLC 0642 OLC 0642 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Joel Samuel Polack 1 - - - - Apparently joined to OLC 638 OLC 0643 OLC 0643 (Paramatta) (Paramatta) Kororareka John Scott 1 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4 OLC 0644 OLC 0644 ML 427 Wairoa Wairoa Te Puna James Jones 22 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4. Approx 22 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Wharengaere ML. SLC 9:10 OLC 0645 OLC 0645 OLC 117 Waikare N Edmund Powell & John 400 0 ? ? - - Reported as OLC 815. Reverted to Maori. SLC 8:4. See also OLC 815 McLeod OLC 0648 OLC 0648 Otuihu Otuihu John Falconer 0.5 0 - --- No grant. BSP 14:8412 OLC 0649 OLC 0649 (Paroa Bay) (Paroa Bay) Robert Field 250 0 - --- No grant. BSP 14:8416. 'Covered by later claims . . .' SLC 6:7 OLC 0650- OLC 0650-0652 OLC 41 Kerikeri South Hd Henry Day 2000 71 - - - - Day grant, 4 Oct 1859. R15 fol 123. Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4. 275 acres 0652 'reverted to Crown. SLC 5:1

Page 7 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0653- OLC 0653-0655 Kerikeri-Whangaroa George Clapham 7 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 14:8471a 0655 OLC 0656 OLC 0656 Waohuriapuna Waohuriapuna Te Puna? James Stiles ?0----No grant. BSP 14:8473 OLC 0657 OLC 0657 (Kawakawa) (Kawakawa) Henry Johnson 200 0 - --- No grant. BSP 14:8481 OLC 0658- OLC 0658-0659 OLC 57 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) & Te Puna CMS (Henry Williams) 4.5 0 - - - - See OLC 699. No evidence of a grant. 0659 OLC 0660 OLC 0660 OLC 251 Motuorangi Motuorangi Paihia CMS (Henry Williams) 0.5 ? ? -- OLC 0661 OLC 0661 (Paihia) (Paihia) CMS (Henry Williams) 3?? -- OLC 0662 OLC 0662 (Paihia) (Paihia) CMS (Henry Williams) 9?? -- OLC 0663 OLC 0663 (Paihia) (Paihia) CMS (Henry Williams) 5?? -- OLC 0664 OLC 0664 Horotutu Horotutu CMS (Henry Williams) 50 ? ? -- OLC 0665 OLC 0665 Motu Maire Motu Maire CMS (Henry Williams) 10 ? ? -- OLC 0666 OLC 0666 Waitara Waitara WaitangiTe Tii CMS (Henry Williams) 700 ? ? -- OLC 0667 OLC 0667 (Paihia) (Paihia)Te Haumi-Opua CMS (Henry Williams) 800 ? ? -- OLC 0668 OLC 0668 Kotikotinga Kotikotinga CMS (Henry Williams) 100 ? ? -- OLC 0669 OLC 0669 Te Karaka Te Karaka Opua CMS (Henry Williams) 100 ? ? -- OLC 0660-69 773 1038 OLC 660-669. Paihia grant, 23 Dec 1851. R5e fol 5. 'Affected by the [1925] Opua Petition . . .' SLC 2:23 OLC 0670 OLC 0670 Otuihu CMS (Henry Williams) 0.75 0 - --- OLC 0672- OLC 0672-0673 OLC 39 (Kerikeri River) (Kerikeri River) CMS (Samuel Marsden, 640 345 - - - - Kerikeri mission grant, 1 Nov 1859. R15 fol 133 0673 Bulter and Kemp) OLC 0676 OLC 0676 OLC 48 (Waimate) (Waimate) CMS (Richard Davis) 735 37 - - - - Waimate mission grant, 1 Nov 1859. R15 fol 136 OLC 0677 OLC 0677 Warengarahu or Waimate Warengarahu or CMS (Richard Davis) 50 0 - --- Tapapanui Tapapanui OLC 0678 OLC 0678 OLC 48 Waikuku & Hawera Waimate Waikuku & Hawera CMS (William Williams) 100 1229.3.0 - - - - OLC 677-678. Waimate mission grants, 6 Dec 1850. R5e fols 1-3 OLC 0679 OLC 0679 Waitohi Waitohi CMS (William Williams) 60 0 - --- OLC 0697 OLC 0697 OLC 56 Hohi Hohi CMS (Samuel Marsden) 80 - --- OLC 0698 OLC 0698 OLC 57 (Te Puna) (Te Puna) CMS (John King) 12 - --- OLC 0699 OLC 0699 OLC 40 (Te Puna) (Te Puna) Waikapu CMS (John King) 150 - --- OLC 0697-99 219.2.38 OLC 697-699. CMS Te Puna-Hohi grants, 1 Nov 1859. R15 fols 134-135 OLC 0700 OLC 0700 OLC 125 Kaikatoa Kahikatoa Waikare Samuel Hayward Ford 200 - --- OLC 0701 OLC 0701 Kerepaka Kerepaka Samuel Hayward Ford 100 - --- OLC 0702 OLC 0702 Samuel Hayward Ford ?---- OLC 0703 OLC 0703 Samuel Hayward Ford 50 - --- OLC 0700-03 461 OLC 700-703. Bleazard grant, 19 Sep 1861. R15a fol 213 OLC 0706 OLC 0706 OLC 257 "Whanganamnui" "Whanganamnui" Hokianga S James Honey & Edward 200 0 200 ? 200 24.3.0 Hokianga Scrip Claim Parker OLC 0711 OLC 0711 OLC 74 Ngunguru N Robert Thwaites 8 291 - - - - Thwaites grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 293. See also OLC 1242-1243 OLC 0713 OLC 0713 Whangaroa Thomas Cooper 40 0 - --- No grant. BSP 16:9406 OLC 0719 OLC 0719 OLC 401 (Great Barrier Island) (Great Barrier Island) William Webster 20000 0 - - - - Missing from Berghan. Plan also missing from LINZ OLC 0722 OLC 0722 OLC 154 & Whangateau W Webster & Dacre 0 1844 grant cancelled; the 'Natives having encroached . . .' AJHR 1878 H- 154a 26 p6. ANZ file missing OLC 0728 OLC 0728 (Hatea River) (Hatea River) Whangarei Robert & William Carruth 1500 938 - - - - Corrected R & W Carruth grant, 29 Sep 1851. R5 fol 80 OLC 0729 OLC 0729 (Waimate) (Waimate) Benjamin Ashwell 20 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 4. 7 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:10 OLC 0732 OLC 0732 Whangaroa Peter Moody ?00 -- OLC 0733 OLC 0733 Mangakahia Peter Moody ? 0 - - - - OLC 732-733. No grants. BSP 16:9480,9499-500 OLC 0734- OLC 0734-0735 OLC 3 (Kerikeri) (Kerikeri) CMS Families (James Kemp) 3100 5997 333 333 - - CMS Families Kerikeri grants, 16 Jul 1859. R15 fols 75-81, 83-91; SLC 2:6 0735 OLC 0736 OLC 0736 (Waimate) (Waimate) CMS Families (James Kemp) 500 166 1050 1050 - - CMS Families Waimate grants, 16 Jul 1859. R15 fols 82; SLC 2:6 OLC 0737 OLC 0737 Haruru James Busby 100 - - - - Granted under OLC 639 (Polack) OLC 0738 OLC 0738 (Kaeo River) (Kaeo River) Thomas Florance 2560 0 2560? ? 2560 ? Unsurveyed scrip land OLC 0739- OLC 0739-0743 OLC 300 Kororareka Thomas May Battersby & 79 x 140 feet 0 - - - - Town plan (OLC 300) missing from LINZ 0743 William Moores OLC 0745 OLC 0745 Kotopauri Kotopauri Kawakawa William Foreman 40 0 - - - - Withdrawn. BSP 17:9837 OLC 0746 OLC 0746 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Pierre Bonnefin 5.5 0 - --- No grant. BSP 17:9851 OLC 0748 OLC 0748 Hokianga Jacque Bernard ?0----No grant. BSP 17:9853 OLC 0749 OLC 0749-759 Kororareka Jacque Bernard ?0----No grant. BSP 17:9857, 9872-74, 9888-89 OLC 0761 OLC 0761 & 27 Hokianga William Stewart ? - - - - Reported as OLC 27. BSP 17: 9892 OLC 0764 OLC 0764 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Alexander Gray & George 1.25 0 - - - - Insignificant grants to Gray daughters. BSP: 17:9945 Cooper OLC 0765 OLC 0765 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Ambroise Bagile Victoun De 60---- Sentis

Page 8 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0766 OLC 0766 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Ambroise Bagile Victoun De 10 0 - --- Sentis OLC 0767 OLC 0767 Ambroise Bagile Victoun De 60---- Sentis OLC 0768 OLC 0768 Waikare Waikare Ambroise Bagile Victoun De 70 0 - - - - OLC 765-768 & 771. No grants. BSP 17:9947. Approx 500 acres Sentis 'presumably reverted to Maoris'. SLC 9:14 OLC 0769 OLC 0769 OLC 151 SO (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Ambroise Bagile Victoun De 18 11 30 5.1.8 30 ? F White grant, 10 Jun 1862. R15a fol 257; SLC 2:5 12268 Sentis OLC 0771 OLC 0771 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Ambroise Bagile Victoun De 0.5 - --- Sentis OLC 0772 OLC 0772 OLC 377 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Ambroise Bagile Victoun De 20---- Sentis OLC 0773 OLC 0773 & 161 OLC 4 &152 (Waimate) (Waimate) Richard Davis 3000 4308 367 362 - - Davis family grants, 15 Feb 1859, R15 fol 29-35; SLC 2:6 OLC 0777 OLC 0777 Pukenui Pukenui Waimate Peleg Wood ?0----No grant. BSP 17:10142 OLC 0778 OLC 0778 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Jules Augusten Duvauchelle 20---- OLC 0779 OLC 0779 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Jules Augusten Duvauchelle 4000 0 - --- OLC 0780 OLC 0780 Kororareka Jules Augusten Duvauchelle 0.25 0 - --- OLC 0782 OLC 0782 (Wahihi) (Wahihi) Jules Augusten Duvauchelle ?0---- OLC 0783 OLC 0783 Jules Augusten Duvauchelle ?0---- OLC 0784 OLC 0784 Jules Augusten Duvauchelle ?0---- OLC 0785 OLC 0785 "Toremaron" "Toremaron" Jules Augusten Duvauchelle 15 0 - - - - OLC 778-780, 782-785. No grants. BSP 17:10189, 10183-84 OLC 0786- OLC 0786-0787 ? ? Charles Blanchard ? 0 - - - - Missing from Berghan. No grants. AJHR 1863 D-14 p60 0787 OLC 0788 OLC 0788 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Didier Huma Joubert 54 square feet 0- -- - OLC 0789 OLC 0789 OLC 358 Taokeranui Taokeranui Waikare North Didier Huma Joubert 114 114 - - - - Joubert grant, 9 Sep 1859. R15 fol 104 OLC 0791 OLC 0791 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Edward Eugene Caflers ?0---- OLC 0792 OLC 0792 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Edward Eugene Caflers 24p. 0 - --- OLC 0793 OLC 0793 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Edward Eugene Caflers 7p. 0 - --- OLC 0794 OLC 0794 ML3668 "Tooheranui" "Tooheranui" Waikare Edward Eugene Caflers 490 0 490 ? 490 ? Waikaipapoa ML 98 acres OLC 0795 OLC 0795 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Edward Eugene Caflers ?0---- OLC 0796 OLC 0796 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Edward Eugene Caflers ? 0 - - - - OLC 791-796. Insignificant grants, AJHR 1863 D-14 p 60 OLC 0798 OLC 0798 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Francis Hodgkinson 2r. 33p. 0 - --- OLC 0799 OLC 0799 OLC 109 ? (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Francis Hodgkinson 60 feet by 90 feet - - - - Grant in OLC 546 (C Baker). AJHR 1863 D-14 p 60

OLC 0800 OLC 0800 "Waikareki and NgunguruWaikareki and Francis Hodgkinson 400 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 17:10361 Towkookoopa" Towkookoopa" OLC 0802 OLC 0802 OLC 14, 227 Tauranga, Whangaroa James Shepherd 2000 1697 1697 - - SLC 2:8 OLC 0803 OLC 0803 OLC 25, 28 Upokorau, Whangaroa James Shepherd 6000 4440 4163 - - SLC 2:8 OLC 0804 OLC 0804 Parengiora Parengiora Parangiora James Shepherd ?---- OLC 0805 OLC 0805 OLC 17 Waitete Kerikeri N James Shepherd 400 573 378 - - SLC 2:8 OLC 0806 OLC 0806 OLC 226 Okura Kerikeri S James Shepherd 400 1685 1439 - - SLC 2:8 OLC 0807 OLC 0807 OLC 50 Touwai Whangaroa James Shepherd 30 - --- OLC 0808 OLC 0808 OLC 51 Whangaroa town James Shepherd 130 - --- OLC 0802-08 10427.5 OLC 802-808. Shepherd grants, 19 Sep 1861, 15 Dec 1864, 28 Jun 1875. R15a fols 214-221, 330, 393 OLC 0809 OLC 0809 OLC 15 Puketi John Muggridge Orsmond 3000 5014 6727 4926 - - Orsmond -Shepherd Puketi grants, 19 Jan , 24 Oct 1864. 20 Feb 1866. R15a fols 269, 301-307, 312, 337; SLC 2:13 OLC 0810 OLC 0810 Mimiwhangata Robert Anwyl 1000 0 ? ? - - No grant. BSP 18:10745. Reverted to Maori. SLC 8:4 OLC 0811 OLC 0811 Makutu Makutu, Rawene Robert Anwyl 1500 0 140 ? - - Included in missing Herd's Point Scrip Survey together with OLC 50, 89. & 90. BSP18:10780. Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 5 OLC 0812 OLC 0812 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) John Neilson ?0?? - - No grant. BSP 18:10781 OLC 0814 OLC 0814 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) John McLeod 1839 0 - -- - No grant. AJHR 1863 D-14 p 62 OLC 0815- OLC 0815-0816 OLC 117 "Apukupuku and Apukupuku and Tongurie John McLeod 300 216.3.0 - - - - McLeod grant, 10 Jun 1862. R15a fol 248. See also OLC 645, apparently 0816 Tongurie" Waikare N Reverted to Maori. SLC 8:4 OLC 0817 OLC 0817 OLC 184 Tamakurinui Tamakurinui Milford Isd, Willam Jones 40 45.0.18 - - - - Jones grant, 16 Jul 1859. R15 fol 76 Whangaroa OLC 0818 OLC 0818 OLC 194 (Waikare River) (Waikare River) North Samuel Harvey 400 390.2.0 - - - - Harvey grant, 19 Jul 1866, R15a fol 343 OLC 0819 OLC 0819 ML 3153 (Waikare River) (Waikare River) North Kororareka Land Company 160 0 - - - - Approx 160 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Waikohu ML. SLC 9:12 (Thomas Spicer) OLC 0820 OLC 0820 Tuhanaia Tuhanaia Kororareka Land Company 180 0 - --- (Thomas Spicer)

Page 9 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0821 OLC 0821 "Mount Mike" "Mount Mike" Kororareka Land Company 20---- (Thomas Spicer) OLC 0822 OLC 0822 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Kororareka Land Company 20---- (Thomas Spicer) OLC 0823 OLC 0823 (Oueroa Beach) (Oueroa Beach) Kororareka Land Company 20 0 - --- (Thomas Spicer) OLC 0824 OLC 0824 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Kororareka Land Company 3r. 1p. 0 - --- (Thomas Spicer) OLC 0825 OLC 0825 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Kororareka Land Company 1 1 - - - - Amy Baker grant, 21 Apr 1881. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 5 (Thomas Spicer) OLC 0826 OLC 0826 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Kororareka Land Company 20---- (Thomas Spicer) OLC 0827 OLC 0827 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Kororareka Land Company 16p. 0 - --- (Thomas Spicer) OLC 0828 OLC 0828 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Kororareka Land Company 2a. 1r. 0 - - - - OLC 819- 824, 826-828. Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 5. Approx 100 acres (Coruthwaite Hector) 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:11 OLC 0829- OLC 0829-0830 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Thomas Grenier 3r. 14p. 0 - - - - Insignificant Turner grant. R15 fol 92 0830 OLC 0836 OLC 0836 OLC 437 Otonago (later Otarahiko) Mangamuka Otonago (later Joseph William Wright 25 10.1.0 10 ? - - Montefiore Mangamuka grant, 25 Nov 1859. R15 fol 141 Otarahiko) OLC 0842 OLC 0842 OLC 180 Parua Bay-Whangarei Hds Thomas Scott, Flower Russell 3000 636 - - - - Scott, Ross, Hay grants, 20 Jun 1862, R15a fols 260-261, 263. Lapsed. & James Anderson AJHR 1881 C-1 p 5! OLC 0844 OLC 0844 OLC 184 Milford Isd, Whangaroa William Jones ? - - - - Granted under OLC 817 (Jones) OLC 0845 OLC 0845 OLC 51 Otakia Otakia, Whangaroa Robert Lawson 100 - - - - Granted to Shepherd at Whangaroa town.(OLC 808) OLC 0846 OLC 0846 Whangaroa Robert Lawson 100 0 - --- No grant. BSP 19:11255 OLC 0857 OLC 0857 Okura Okura, Kerikeri Joseph Aberline 200 0 200 ? 250 ? Derived ftrom OLC 655 (Clapham). Included in Te Papa CP. RWOLC p 314

OLC 0858 OLC 0858 Uriti Creek Uriti Creek, Uruti Joseph Aberline 108 0 - --- No grant. BSP 19:11301-02 OLC 0861 OLC 0861 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Charles Robertson ?0----No grant. BSP 19:11304 OLC 0862 OLC 0862 OLC 20 Purerua S Edward Bolger 150 157 - - - - Bolger grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 287 OLC 0863 OLC 0863 OLC 29 Purerua S Edward Bolger 300 437 - 76 - C & H Davis grant, 19 Jan 1864, R15a fol 286; SLC 2:7 OLC 0867- OLC 0867-0869 OLC 381 Kororareka John Johnson 80 x 160 feet - - - - 0869 OLC 0870 OLC 0870 OLC 381 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) John Johnson 3a. 3r. 0 - - - - OLC 867-870. Insignificant Johnson grants, AJHR 1863 D-14 p 65 OLC 0871 OLC 0871 OLC 71 Wangamamu Whangamumu John Johnson & Harry 1000 640 - - - - Johnson grant, 1 Nov 1859. R15 fol 132 Henderson OLC 0872 OLC 0872 Puketi Charles Berry Waitford 600 0 244.5 ? 244.1 ? Probably within Orsmond-Shepherd Puketi OLC 809 grant OLC 0873- OLC 0873-0874 (Pa Bay & the Kawakawa Kawakawa Philo B. Perry 1 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 19:11472 0874 River) OLC 0878- OLC 0878-0880 OLC 69 (Kaeo River) (Kaeo River) William Spickman 2000 1896 - - - - Grants Kaeo-Totara N, 27 Oct 1859, 25 Jan 1860. R15 fols 127, 182 0880 OLC 0881 OLC 0881 OLC 181 Waikoura Whangaroa John Hayes 1000 534 - - - - Hayes grants, 28 Sep 1860, 24 Jun 1864. R15 fol 176, R15a fol 319 OLC 0882- OLC 0882-0883 OLC 241 Kahoe Whangaroa Edward Boyce 120 308 92? 92 - - T Flavell grant, 9 May 1864. R15a fol 316; SLC 2:9 0883 OLC 0884- OLC 0884-0886 Dominick Ferrari 17 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 19:11557 0886 OLC 0896 OLC 0896 (Mangonui River) (Mangonui River) Thomas Shearing 60 0 - - - - Missing from Berghan. No grant. AJHR 1863 D-14 p67 OLC 0897- OLC 0897-0898 OLC 52 (Waimate) (Waimate) James Hamlin 87 - - - - Included in Kemp OLC 594 grant. BSP 19:11561 0898 OLC 0912 OLC 0912 Mangonui Te Tii William Butler 60 0 - --- No grant. BSP 20:11615 OLC 0916 OLC 0916 Purerua Henry Tod Appleton 100 0 - --- No grant. BSP 20:11616 OLC 0917 OLC 0917 Purerua Frances Russell Manning 200 0 - --- No grant. BSP 20:11620 OLC 0918 OLC 0918 Whakaihunia Wairoa R Alexander Ross 198 J Wilson grant, 9 May 1864. R15a fol 317 OLC 0921 OLC 0921 (Tutukaka) (Tutukaka) Thomas Black 1500 0 1500 ? 390.75 ? OLC 0922 OLC 0922 (Waikare River) (Waikare River) Thomas Black 10 0 10 ? 390.75 ? OLC 0923 OLC 0923 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Thomas Black 1500 0 1500 ? 390.75 ? OLC 0925 OLC 0925 ML 3795, 3808 Ngunguru Thomas Black & William 3000 0 3000 ? 390.75 ? OLC 921-925. 'Reverted to Maoris' as Horohoro & Waiparera ML. SLC 7:3 Green OLC 0926 OLC 0926 (Kawakawa River) (Kawakawa River) Robert Milne 5000 0 - - - - Withdrawn. BSP 20:11748 OLC 0930 OLC 0930 Mangawhai William Mayhew 20000 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 5. Within the 1854 Mangawhai CP. SLC 9:12 OLC 0932 OLC 0932 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) L. Poncet 60 x 90 feet 0- -- -No grant. BSP 20:11792 OLC 0933 OLC 0933 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) John Lette 0.25 0 - - - - Insignificant grant. AJHR 1878 H-26 p 6

Page 10 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 0934 OLC 0934 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Edmund Roff ?0----No grant. BSP 20:11873 OLC 0935- OLC 0935-0936 Otarawa-Ureroa Wairoa R Edmund Roff 160 Roff grants, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fols 241-242 0936 OLC 0938 OLC 0938 OLC 81 Wesleydale Kaeo Wesleyan Missionary Society 53 103 103 ? 133 ? WMS grants, 10 Jun 1862, R15a fol 250 OLC 0939 OLC 0939 Tarawana Tarawana, Upper Waihou Wesleyan Missionary Society 50 76.3.25 - - - - WMS grants, 10 Jun 1862, R15a fol 250 OLC 0940 OLC 0940 OLC 78 Mangungu Mangungu Wesleyan Missionary Society 1000 483 - - - - WMS grants, 10 Jun 1862, R15a fol 250 OLC 0941 OLC 0941 OLC 77 Pakanae Wesleyan Missionary Society 200 124.1.6 - - - - WMS grants, 10 Jun 1862, R15a fol 250 OLC 0942 OLC 0942 OLC 79 Tangiteroria Wesleyan Missionary 133.3.8 H Atkins grant, 5 Jan 1864. R15a fol 281 Society OLC 0943 OLC 0943 Te Maire Te Maire, Wairere Wesleyan Missionary Society 500 0 - - - - OLC plan 79 is Tangiteroria, not Wairere OLC 0944 OLC 0944 OLC 80 Te Poinga Te Poinga, Waima Wesleyan Missionary Society 100 36.2.0 - - - - WMS grants, 10 Jun 1862, R15a fol 250 OLC 0951 OLC 0951 OLC 197 Purakau Purakau Hokianga N Roman Catholic Mission 150 104.2.0 - - - - Pompallier grant, 10 Feb 1862. R15a fol 232 (Father Anderson Baty) OLC 0952- OLC 0952-0953 (Korarareka) (Korarareka) Roman Catholic Mission 70 feet of 0 - - - - Insignificant grant. BSP 21:12030 0953 (Father Anderson Baty) frontage OLC 0954 OLC 0954 & 615 Waihihi-Maiki Roman Catholic Mission ? 85 - - - - Pompallier grant, 10 Sep 1861. R15 fol 209 (Father Anderson Baty) OLC 0960 OLC 0960 Taumatakai Taumatakai, Waikare John Walmsley and others 800 0 - --- No grant. BSP 21:12159 OLC 0965 OLC 0965 Hokianga William Stewart ? - - - - Settled in OLC 27 (Deloitte & Stewart). AJHR 1863 D-14 p 71 OLC 0966 OLC 0966 OLC 260 Horohoro Horohoro, Mangamuka Thomas Mitchell 1500 0 271 ? - 271 Hokianga Scrip Claim. 271 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 9:10 OLC 0967 OLC 0967 OLC 174 Okopa Hokianga N Robert Hardiman 50 37 - - - - Hardiman grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 277 OLC 0968 OLC 0968 Hokianga Hannah Farden 300 0 - - - - Reported as OLC 194 (Fishwick). 16 acres 'Reverted to Crown' after dismissal at NLC. SLC 9:1 OLC 0969 OLC 0969 OLC 130 Motu Kiore Motu Kiore Thomas Birch 300 74.2.0 - - - - Birch grant 19 Jan 1864, R15a fol 290 OLC 0970 OLC 0970 OLC 261 Punehu, Hokianga Robert Campbell 12 0 12 ? - - No grant. BSP 21:12240. See also Half-Caste claim OLC 1361 (Wumhall & Smith). 29 acres 'Reverted to Crown'. SLC 11:1 OLC 0971 OLC 0971 OLC 65 Te Kohukohu Te Kohukohu Matthew Mariner 1000 0 ? ? 950 ? SO 3976 refers to a Russell grant in Kohukohu township OLC 0972 OLC 0972 Orira-Rawhia John Grant 600 0 - - - - Unsurveyed scrip land. BSP 21:12342. 102 acres 'Reverted to Crown'; 27 acre 'to Maoris'. SLC 9:13 OLC 0973 OLC 0973 ML 6199 Tarawawa Tarawawa, Upper Waihou John Grant 50 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 5. 37 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Pukoro No 2. SLC 9:14 OLC 0973A OLC 0973A Hokianga John Grant 200 0 - --- No grant. BSP 21:12362 OLC 0974- OLC 0974-0975 (Kaeo) (Kaeo) John Lander 162 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 21:12379 0975 OLC 0978 OLC 0978 Mahurangi Gordon D. Browne 5000 0 - --- No grant. BSP 21:12381b. SLC 6:15 OLC 0991 OLC 0991 Kororareka George Russell ? 0 - - - - Reported with OLC 638 & 642 (Polack). BSP 21: 12386 OLC 0992- OLC 0992-0994 Kororareka George Russell ? 0 - - - - Withdrawn. BSP 21:12390 0994 OLC 0995 OLC 0995 Kororareka George Russell ? 0 - - - - Withdrawn. BSP 21:12396 OLC 0997 OLC 0997 Kororareka Matthew Smith Finlay 0.125 0 - --- No grant. BSP 21:12397 OLC 0998 OLC 0998 Whangaruru Joseph Riley 0 No grant. AJHR 1863 D-14 p 73. ANZ file missing OLC 0999 OLC 0999 Kororareka William Dodds ?0----No grant. BSP 21:12400 OLC 1000 OLC 1000 James Watson & James 30 0 - - - - No grant. BSP 21:12405 Anderson OLC 1001 OLC 1001 E. Prevost 10 0 - --- No grant. BSP 21:12406 OLC 1002 OLC 1002 (Cavelles Island) (Cavelles Island) Cornthwaite Hector 300 0 - --- No grant. BSP 21:12409 OLC 1003 OLC 1003 ML 272 (Mongonui River) (Mongonui River) Te Puna S Donald McKay 40 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 5. 37 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Waitaraiti ML

OLC 1004 OLC 1004 (Kororareka) (Kororareka) Donald McKay 120 sq ft 0 - - - - Insignificant grant. BSP 21:12415 OLC 1005 OLC 1005 OLC 182 (Kororareka) Purerua Thomas Hansen ?0--00No grant. BSP 22:12449. See OLC 1309 grant OLC 1006 OLC 1006 Kawakawa William Foreman - - - - - Reported as OLC 745 (Foreman) OLC 1015 OLC 1015 Te Whaiti Te Whaiti, Hokianga Fanny Wing 200 0 - - - - Became ML. J White, 17 Sep 1860. BSP 22:12475 OLC 1016 OLC 1016 Motukaraka Christopher Harris 5000 0 - --- No grant. BSP 22:12477 OLC 1020 OLC 1020 Taheke William Cozens 500 0 - --- No grant. BSP 22:12498 OLC 1024 OLC 1024 Kororareka Donald McKay - - - - - Reported with OLC 1004 (McKay) OLC 1027 OLC 1027 Kawau Isd H Tayler & JF Beattie 4630 Grant of entire island referred to AJHR 1863 D-14 p 75.ANZ file missing OLC 1029 OLC 1029 OLC 177 Morekaraka Morekaraka, Waimate John Edward Hargreaves 1.5 0 - - - - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 5 OLC 1030 OLC 1030 OLC 176 (Waimate) (Waimate) John Edward Hargreaves 12 11 - - - - Hargreaves grant, 25 Nov 1859. R15 fol 148 OLC 1031 OLC 1031 Kohukohu Kohukohu Eleanor Baker 60 0 60 ? --No grant. BSP 22:12544 OLC 1032 OLC 1032 OLC 89 & 102 Te Horeke Te Horeke Thomas McDonnell 12800 - - - Approx 5500 acres 'Reverted to Maoris' as Utakura ML. SLC 9:14 OLC 1033 OLC 1033 OLC 90 Mataka Motukaraka Isd Thomas McDonnell 5500 - --

Page 11 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Wai 1040 OLC data Old Land Claims‐Rigby Dr Barry Rigby ‐ 1 Oct 2014 Appendix A

Original Crown Survey plan transaction grant OLC no. no. Block Name Name of settler claimant (acres) (acres)Surplus land (acres) Scrip land (acres) Comments

Crown Validated Validated Crown Validated Validated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated Crown Valid-ated OLC 1034 OLC 1034 OLC 268 Motukaraka Motukaraka Point Thomas McDonnell 50000 - - 2735? Affected by the [1938] Motukaraka Petition'. Disputed scrip land 'reverted to Crown'. SLC 4:21 OLC 1035 OLC 1035 (Waima & Omanui (Waima & Omanui Rivers) Thomas McDonnell ? - -- Rivers) OLC 1032-35 339.2.2 616.1.9 OLC 1032-1038. McDonnell Horeke-Motukaraka grants, 4 Dec 1860, R15 fols 149-151; SLC 2:6 (Horeke) OLC 1038 OLC 1038 Thomas McDonnell ? 2749 - - - - OLC 1032-1038. McDonnell grants (elsewhere) 15 Feb 1859, 4 Oct 1859, 25 Jan 1861, 19 Jan 1864. R15 fols 36-39, 118-119, 188, 288, R15a fols 309- 311 OLC 1043 OLC 1043 OLC 275 Upper Waihou Baron de Thierry 1500 0 1500 ? 1500 814 Hokianga Scrip Claim OLC 1044 OLC 1044 Waima Baron de Thierry 110 0 110 ? 110 ? Perhaps confused with OLC 1045 OLC 1045 OLC 1045 OLC 150 (Waima River) (Waima River) Baron de Thierry 3000 109 - - - - De Thierry grant, 3 May 1860. R15 fol 161 OLC 1047 OLC 1047 OLC 369 & 108 Tuari Kura Tuari Kura Whangarei Hds Gilbert Mair ? 2585 - 3890 - - JL Campbell grants, 23 Au 1861, R15a fols 207-208; SLC 2:6

OLC 3A OLC 3A Whangaroa Mahinepua Whangaroa Charles Cook - 0 Late notice, no jurisdiction. BSP 26:15351 OLC 13A OLC 13A Bay of Islands Otuihu William Cains - 0 No grant information verified OLC 23A OLC 23A Bay of Islands Waimate Kent children 50 51 Clarke Crown grant as trustee, 22 Aug 1865. R15a fol 331 OLC 25A OLC 25A ML 2287 Bay of Islands Toukauri Waimate Mrs Stockman - 20 NLC grant. Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6 OLC 26A OLC 26A Bay of Islands Bay of Isds George Cook -0 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6 OLC 27A OLC 27A Bay of Islands Bay of Isds Matilda Cook -0 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6 OLC 28A OLC 28A Bay of Islands Bay of Isds William Cook 20 0 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6 OLC 36A OLC 36A-37A Bay of Islands Bay of Isds R Annoyl -0 Lapsed 5 Nov 1872. BSP 226:15466 OLC 47A OLC 47A Bay of Islands Bay of Isds Mary Anne Davis -0 No grant. BSP 26:15479-81 OLC 48A OLC 48A-49A Bay of Islands Bay of Isds J Baker's children -0 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6 OLC 1302- OLC 1302-1303 Bay of Islands Bay of Isds WB Moores & H Coolahan ?0 No grant information verified 1303 OLC 1304 OLC 1304 OLC 431 Bay of Islands Onewhero Waitangi N John Irving 586 596 Irving grant, 4 Oct 1859. R15 fol 121 OLC 1306 OLC 1306 OLC 231 Waikare North Henry Sturley 83 Sturley grant, 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 295. ANZ file missing OLC 1307 OLC 1307 Bay of Islands Bay of Isds Waihihi William Butler 49 49 W Butler grant, 20 Jun 1862. R15a fol 262 OLC 1309 OLC 1309 Mahurangi Purerua Thomas Hansen ? 24 Hansen grant 19 Jan 1864. R15a fol 279 OLC 1312 OLC 1312 Matauri Thomas Flavell 0 No grant information verified. ANZ file missing OLC 1313 OLC 1313 Mangonui Te Tii Sullivan 0 No grant information verified. ANZ file missing OLC 1324 OLC 1324 OLC 280 & Whangarei Ngunguru James Busby & E Levington 40000 0 Overlapping CPs & ML. SLC 3:1. ANZ file missing 280A OLC 1327 OLC 1327 OLC 63 & SO Hokianga Hokianga, Rawene Francis White ? 588 F White grant, 11 Jul 1861. R15 fol 199 898 OLC 1328 OLC 1328 OLC 86 & 438 Hokianga Hokianga, Wharerimu, Waima Francis White ? 55 W White Jr grant, 10 Jun 1862. R15a fol 256 OLC 1334 OLC 1334 Bay of Islands Bay of Isds Kororareka Charles Trenor ? 0 No grant information verified OLC 1336 OLC 1336 Otoua, Hokianga JN Inches 0 No grant information verified OLC 1339 OLC 1339 Taiamai Samuel May 0 No grant information verified OLC 1340 OLC 1340 Bay of Islands Bay of Isds & Hokianga J Lake ? 0 No grant information verified OLC 1342 OLC 1342 Hokianga Hokianga Alfred Dudley 500 0 No grant information verified OLC 1344 OLC 1344 Hokianga Hokianga Orira Samuel Makin 14 0 No grant information verified OLC 1345 OLC 1345 Hokianga Hokianga Mangamuka William Bellingham - 0 No grant information verified OLC 1357 OLC 1357 OLC 233 Te Totara Omapere Lake Snowden children 77 Wi Hongi NLC grant, 25 Apr 1871. R80a fol 94. ANZ file missing OLC 1358 OLC 1358 Mahurangi Mahurangi J Sullivan - Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6 OLC 1359 OLC 1359 OLC 143 Bay of Islands Bay of Isds, Omapere Lake Henry Cook - 42 NLC Anna Cook grant , 1 Jan 1870. AJHR 1878 H-26 p 8 OLC 1360 OLC 1360 OLC 144 & 145 Bay of Islands Bay of Isds, Kororareka George Cook -0 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6

OLC 1361 OLC 1361 OLC 261 Hokianga Hokianga Punehu H Munhall & W Smith -0 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6. See OLC 970 (Campbell) OLC 1364 OLC 1364 Hokianga Hokianga J Marmon child -0 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6. Incl. in Wairere ML. SLC 6:4. See also OLC 314 OLC 1365 OLC 1365 OLC 420 Bay of Islands Hokianga Waimate Geo Clarke child Ann - 0 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6. Reverted to Maori as Patito-Tapapanui ML Coldicutt 245. SLC 8: 6 OLC 1366 OLC 1366 Hokianga Kohokohu David Clarke son BSP 26:15316 OLC 1367 OLC 1367 OLC 279 ML Hokianga Hokianga Waima Bryers children 323 316 NLC Chas Bryers grant, 23 Nov 1871. AJHR 1878 H-26 p 8 2028 OLC 1368 OLC 1368 OLC 311 ML Hokianga Hokianga Wairere Annabella Webster 67 63 NLC Annabella Webster grant, 28 Jun 1870. AJHR 1878 H-26 p 8 1470 OLC 1370 OLC 1370 OLC 315 ML Hokianga Motukaraka Gundry children 0 Lapsed. AJHR 1881 C-1 p 6. See OLC 209 (Gundry) 4684

Page 12 of 12 Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Appendix B Wai 1040, #2.3.11

Wai 1040

WAITANGI TRIBUNAL

CONCERNING the Treaty of Waitangi Act 1975

AND the Te Paparahi o Te Raki regional inquiry

DIRECTION COMMISSIONING RESEARCH

1. Pursuant to clause 5A of the second schedule to the Treaty of Waitangi Act 1975, the Tribunal commissions Dr Barry Rigby, a member of the Tribunal’s staff, to prepare a validation review report on the Crown’s tabulated old land claims, surplus land and scrip data for the Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry.

2. The purpose of the review is to test the reliability of the Crown’s old land claim (OLC) data filed in July 2012 (#1.3.2(a)) and to address any inaccuracies and gaps found. The report is to produce data which:

a) Aggregates claim information;

b) Distinguishes between scrip and surplus land data;

c) Completes essential Crown grant information; and

d) Identifies and comments on the sources of information, where appropriate.

3. The data should be provided in table format together with a brief analytical report. Where information from primary sources not on the record of inquiry has been consulted, the source material should be filed as supporting documents wherever possible.

4. As previously directed (Wai 1040, #2.6.51 Appendix A item 1.2), in carrying out the review the commissionee will consult with the parties. Specifically, the commissionee will consult with Crown and coordinating claimant counsel. The consultation will focus in particular on accessing technical data utilised for the Crown’s tables and on the methodology to be employed in the review.

5. The commission commenced on 6 January 2014. A complete draft of the report and data will be circulated in electronic file format to the claimants and the Crown for feedback, including on the accuracy of the data.

6. The commission ends on 1 October 2014, at which time the report and data must be submitted for filing in unbound form, together with indexed copies of any supporting documents. An electronic copy of the report and supporting documents should also be provided in PDF file format. The data should be provided in both Excel spreadsheet and PDF formats. The report, the accompanying data and any subsequent evidential material based on it must be filed through the Registrar.

7. The report may be received as evidence and the author may be cross-examined on it.

8. The Registrar is to send copies of this direction to:

Dr Barry Rigby Claimant counsel and unrepresented claimants in the Te Paparahi o Te Raki inquiry (Wai 1040) Chief Historian, Waitangi Tribunal Unit Principal Research Analyst, Waitangi Tribunal Unit Manager – Research and Inquiry Facilitation Services, Waitangi Tribunal Unit Inquiry Supervisor, Waitangi Tribunal Unit Local Issues Research Programme Supervisor, Waitangi Tribunal Unit Inquiry Facilitator(s), Waitangi Tribunal Unit Solicitor-General, Crown Law Office Director, Office of Treaty Settlements Chief Executive, Crown Forestry Rental Trust Chief Executive, Te Puni Kōkiri

DATED at Wellington this 31st day of July 2014

Judge C T Coxhead Presiding Officer WAITANGI TRIBUNAL

2