Crown Policies and Purchases in Muriwhenua 1840-1850

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Crown Policies and Purchases in Muriwhenua 1840-1850 EMPIRE ON THE CHEAP: CROWN POLICIES AND PURCHASES IN MURIWHENUA 1840-1850 A Historical Report commissioned by the waitanqi Tribunal Barry Rigby 6 March 1992 / EMPIRE ON THE CHEAP: CROWN POLICIES AND PURCHASES IN MURIWHENUA 1840-1850 TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE I INTRODUCTION 4 (a) Purpose 4 (b) Thesis statement 5 (c) Outline 5 II ORIGINS OF THE TREATY 1837-1840 8 (a) Historiography 8 (b) Imperial Illusions 9 (c) Maori depopulation 16 (d) Vested interests 18 III HOBSON'S CHOICE 1840-1842 21 (a) strict economy 21 (b) Land in Treaty transactions 23 (c) Crown Mangonui Purchases 1840-1841 36 (d) Crown conceptions of Maori land rights 43 (e) The Crown/CMS Alliance 48 IV COLONIAL CRISIS 1842-1845 54 (a) Inadequate administration 54 (b) Land claims policy 57 (c) The Oruru conflict 62 (d) FitzRoy's choice 67 V COLONIAL AND IMPERIAL CONFLICT 1845-1847 71 (a) Disestablishment of the CMS 71 (b) Land and conflict 73 (c) Grey's Maori allies 76 (d) The Wasteland debate 78 (e) Grey, Panakareao and the CMS 80 VI CROWN CONTROL 1848-1850 85 (a) The Resident Magistrate system 85 (b) White and Maori 86 (c) The Mixed Economy 88 (d) Crown Autocracy 92 - 3 - PAGE VII CONCLUSION 95 (a) Issues arising from the evidence 95 (b) How cheap was justice? 96 VIII MAP 1840-1841 Crown Mangonui Purchases 41 - 4 - I INTRODUCTION (a) Purpose This report presents an overview of Crown policies and purchases in Muriwhenua during the 1840s. It treats this subject more exhaustively than the "Preliminary Report on the Historical Report" filed in December 1989, or the subsequent Mangonui, Muriwhenua North and Oruru reports. This report examines not only the Crown's actions in Muriwhenua, but the imperial and colonial policies governing those actions. Likewise, it examines not just the 1840 and 1841 Crown Mangonui purchases, but also the Crown's changing conception of Maori land rights both before and after the Treaty transactions at the beginning of the decade. The purpose of including imperial and colonial policies wi thin the investigation is to locate Muriwhenua history within a larger context than was possible in previous reports. without consideration of the larger imperial and colonial context, Crown actions in Muriwhenua cannot be fully understood. Since Margaret Mutu and Anne Salmond will examine the Maori context of those actions, this report deals largely with things Pakeha. Nonetheless, the history of the 1840s was one of dynamic interaction between Maori and Pakeha. Consequently, this report cannot ignore situations where Maor i clearly influenced, and were influenced by, Crown actions. Although I've also avoided detailed examination of the Crown Land Claims commissions, the subject of Richard Boast's and other claimant research reports, I've not been able to avoid them entirely. Since the Godfrey commission reveals a great deal about the Crown's conception of Maori land rights in Muriwhenua, as does the debate about missionary land claims, both receive proper attention. - 5 - (b) Thesis statement The central thesis of this report is that the Crown's policies and purchases in both Muriwhenua and New Zealand during the 1840s attempted to get "empire on the cheap". Though historians such as McLintock, Wards and Adams detected this theme in Crown policies towards New Zealand, they haven't 1 considered the consequences of this for Maori • In this report, I argue that to uphold Treaty obligations incurred in 1840, the Crown had to commit considerable resources. To protect Maori land rights effectively, it had to conduct a thorough investigation of Maori customs, for example. I argue that not only did the Crown fail to commit sufficient resources to uphold its Treaty obligations, its policies invariably sacrificed justice in the interests of strict economy. By seeking "empire on the cheap", the Crown tried to buy justice cheaply. In this process, I maintain, the Crown short-changed Maori. (c) Outline In developing this thesis, I've organised the report into five main chapters, in addition to the introduction and conclusion. In Chapter II, Imperial origins of the Treaty, I'll begin by reviewing how historians have explained annexation by Treaty. I then examine some imperial illusions, and Maori depopulation, which preceded the Treaty. This leads me to further identify the vested interests of the Pakeha architects of the Treaty. A H McLintock, Crown Colony Government in New Zealand (Wellington 1858); Ian Wards, The Shadow of the Land: A Study of British Policy and Racial Conflict in New Zealand 1832-1852 (Wellington 1968); Peter Adams, Fatal Necessity: British Intervention in New Zealand 1830-1847 (Auckland 1977). - 6 - Chapter III, entitled Hobson's Choice, points out how the Crown's first executive officer in New Zealand had very few options left open to him by his superiors in London and Sydney. Hobson's superiors insisted that he operate on a shoe-string budget, while upholding Treaty obligations. The key Treaty transactions in Northern New Zealand focused on Maori land rights. I examine those transaction in considerable detail. The Kaitaia transaction, in particular, prepared the way for the 1840-1841 Mangonui purchases. In each of these transactions, CMS missionaries played a crucial role. I therefore examine what I refer to as the Crown/CMS alliance. The strains of an under-resourced colonial administration plunged New Zealand into crisis between 1842 and 1845. This is the subject of Chapter III. The Crown Land Claims commissions, hampered by lack of funds and erratic policy shifts, reflected and contributed to a deepening of the crisis. In Muriwhenua the crisis contributed to the 1843 Oruru conflict. The crisis also produced a series of drastic measures by Governor FitzRoy which contributed to his recall during the Northern war of 1845. In Chapter V, Colonial and Imperial conflict, I argue that Grey's arrived to replace FitzRoy signalled a major shift in Crown policy. Grey dissolved the Crown's alliance with the CMS while recruiting Maori allies (including Panakareao) during the Northern War. Imperial authorities contributed an added dimension to the conflict with the "waste-land" doctrine enunciated in 1846. The colonial and imperial conflict came to Muriwhenua in late 1847 with Nugent and Symonds' visit to Mangonui, Oruru and Kaitaia. Although Grey refrained from implementing the imperial "waste­ land" doctrine, he established direct Crown control in predominantly Maori areas such as Muriwhenua through his Resident Magistrate system. I examine this system briefly in - 7 - Chapter VI, entitled Crown Control 1848-1850. Since Grey maintained that a thriving mixed economy underlay the extens ion of Crown control, I examine this phenomenon in Muriwhenua. Finally, I assess the impact on Maori rights of what Grey's biographer describes as Crown autocracy. In conclusion, I suggest issues arising from the evidence and interpretation presented in this report. I also conclude on what can be learned of the consequences of "empire on the cheap" . - 8 - II IMPERIAL ORIGINS OF THE TREATY (a) Historiography Historians explaining the origins of the Treaty of Waitangi normally fall into one of two schools. These may be described as the consensus school, and the conflict school. Consensus historians normally emphasis the humanitarian ideals embodied in the Treaty. The younger Sinclair wrote in 1959 that the Treaty inaugurated a "new and noble experiment" in colonial history. Recently, Orange has continued this theme. Despite her criticism of the Crown for failing to honour the Treaty, she generally sees it as originating in humanitarian idealism and bicultural consensus2 • Historians emphasising conflict between the humanitarian architects of the Treaty, and its detractors; and between Maori and Pakeha settler interests, include two former Official Historians, McLintock and Wards. In 1958 McLintock argued that misguided idealism embodied in the Treaty led the Crown to protect Maori interests at the expense of Pakeha interests3 • A decade later Wards argued that the Crown sought control over both Maori and Pakeha settler interests, and stumbled upon the Treaty as the most expedient way to achieve such control4. In assessing the imperial origins of the Treaty, Adams came to a similar conclusion in 1977. He argued that the "Treaty was intended to protect the Maoris only insofar as their rights were compatible with British dominance .•• " 5 • 2 Keith Sinclair, Historv of New Zealand (Harmondsworth 1959) p71; Claudia Orange, The Treaty of Waitangi (Auckland 1987) pp38, 59. 3 McLintock, Crown Colony Government, pp70-1 4 Wards, Shadow of the Land, ppix-x, 28 5 Adams, Fatal Necessity, pp14-15. I' - 9 - Neither consensus nor conflict historians have probed the imperial origins of the Treaty very deeply. In embracing a view of imperial idealism, consensus historians have failed to consider that this idealism may have been .. based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of Maori society during the 1830s. On the other hand, conflict historians oversimplify the divisions between Crown, humanitarian and vested interests. They also pay insufficient attention to how Maori actions could influence imperial and colonial outcomes. (b) Imperial Illusions During the late 1830s, Crown actions were influenced by four major illusions which historians usually ignore. Although the illusory nature of these assumptions may not be potently obvious, they were that: 1 Maori had alienated most of their land; 2 Land in Maori hands was virtually valueless; 3 Maori were almost all under missionary control; and; 4 Maori would meekly accept annexation to Britain. The first illusion, that during the 1830s Maori alienated most of their land, arose partly from Busby and missionary reports, and partly from testimony before the House of Lords Select Committee on New Zealand in 1838. In mid 1837, James Busby, the British Resident in the Bay of Islands informed London that Maori had alienated most of Northern New Zealand to British settlers.
Recommended publications
  • He Waiata, a Song for the Sacred Mountains and Tribes of Whangārei
    Members of the Hātea Kapa Haka group sing a waiata (song) during the unveiling of the Waka and Wave sculpture at the end of the Hīhīaua Peninsular. He waiata, a song for the sacred mountains and tribes of Whangārei Tēnei au ka piki ngā paringa pā tūwatawata, pā maioro o Maunga Parihaka, kia kite atu ngā hapū me ngā maunga tapu e Ka huri whakaterāwhiti ko taku aro ki te kapua hōkaia ki rūnga Maunga Rangitihi Tērā ko Ngāti Pūkenga me Te Tāwera e Ka rere atu au ki te kohu tatao ana i ngā kōhatu teitei o Maunga Manaia, ko Ngai Tāhūhū te iwi e Ka whakarērea te pou o te whare kia tau iho rā ki runga Maunga Rangiora Ko Takahiwai te papakāinga, ko Patuharakeke te hapū e Ka huri whakauta au kia rere atu ki runga Otaika ka tau ki Te Toetoe ko Pā-Te Aroha te marae e Ka hoki whakatehauāuru ki Maunga Tangihua, ki Maunga Whatitiri, ki aku huānga Te Uriroroi me Te Parawhau e Ka huri whakararo taku titiro ki a Ngāti Kahu, ngā uri a Torongare, ko Hurupaki, ko Ngārārātunua, ko Parikiore ngā maunga e Ka haere whakaterāwhiti ki Maunga Maruata me Maunga Pukepoto, kia tau iho ki roto o Ngāti Hau e Tēnei ka hoki ki Maunga Parihaka, kātahi au ka tau iho e Here I climb the embankments of the great fortress Mt. Parihaka that I may see my tribal kinfolk and their sacred mountains Eastward does my gaze turn to the clouds pierced by Mt. Rangitihi, there are Ngāti Pūkenga and Te Tāwera Now I fly onwards to the mists suspended above the lofty peaks of Mt.
    [Show full text]
  • The Native Land Court, Land Titles and Crown Land Purchasing in the Rohe Potae District, 1866 ‐ 1907
    Wai 898 #A79 The Native Land Court, land titles and Crown land purchasing in the Rohe Potae district, 1866 ‐ 1907 A report for the Te Rohe Potae district inquiry (Wai 898) Paul Husbands James Stuart Mitchell November 2011 ii Contents Introduction ........................................................................................................................................... 1 Report summary .................................................................................................................................. 1 The Statements of Claim ..................................................................................................................... 3 The report and the Te Rohe Potae district inquiry .............................................................................. 5 The research questions ........................................................................................................................ 6 Relationship to other reports in the casebook ..................................................................................... 8 The Native Land Court and previous Tribunal inquiries .................................................................. 10 Sources .............................................................................................................................................. 10 The report’s chapters ......................................................................................................................... 20 Terminology .....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • New Zealand Wars Sources at the Hocken Collections Part 2 – 1860S and 1870S
    Reference Guide New Zealand Wars Sources at the Hocken Collections Part 2 – 1860s and 1870s Henry Jame Warre. Camp at Poutoko (1863). Watercolour on paper: 254 x 353mm. Accession no.: 8,610. Hocken Collections/Te Uare Taoka o Hākena, University of Otago Library Nau Mai Haere Mai ki Te Uare Taoka o Hākena: Welcome to the Hocken Collections He mihi nui tēnei ki a koutou kā uri o kā hau e whā arā, kā mātāwaka o te motu, o te ao whānui hoki. Nau mai, haere mai ki te taumata. As you arrive We seek to preserve all the taoka we hold for future generations. So that all taoka are properly protected, we ask that you: place your bags (including computer bags and sleeves) in the lockers provided leave all food and drink including water bottles in the lockers (we have a researcher lounge off the foyer which everyone is welcome to use) bring any materials you need for research and some ID in with you sign the Readers’ Register each day enquire at the reference desk first if you wish to take digital photographs Beginning your research This guide gives examples of the types of material relating to the New Zealand Wars in the 1860s and 1870s held at the Hocken. All items must be used within the library. As the collection is large and constantly growing not every item is listed here, but you can search for other material on our Online Public Access Catalogues: for books, theses, journals, magazines, newspapers, maps, and audiovisual material, use Library Search|Ketu.
    [Show full text]
  • Proposed Dwelling & Onsite Wastewater Disposal 18 Deeming
    Brett Sheldon Proposed Dwelling & Onsite Wastewater Disposal 18 Deeming Road, Okiato Williams & King, Kerikeri1 2 July 2020 1 Williams & King - a Division of Survey & Planning Solutions (2010) Ltd Surveyors, Planners, Resource Managers - Kerikeri and Kaitaia PO Box 937 Kerikeri Phone (09) 407 6030 Email: [email protected] 1.0 Overview The Applicants, Brett Sheldon and Fleur Aspen, propose a new dwelling at 18 Deeming Road, Okiato, in the Coastal Residential Zone. The new dwelling will be located within twenty metres of a vegetated area on the downslope side of the subject site. Clearance of indigenous vegetation is required to prepare the building site. Wastewater will be treated and disposed on site, and the proposed system requires a discharge consent and land use consent due to the site constraints (size and position in relation to the coastal marine area). The application site is zoned Coastal Residential in the District Plan. This application has been assessed as being a discretionary activity overall. 2.0 Description of Proposal Proposed Dwelling A new single bedroom dwelling is proposed, with the majority of the indoor area comprising a single level, and an internal staircase accessing a lower deck area and stairs accessing a higher car port via a covered deck. The floor area of the dwelling comprising the stair well and level 2 building area amounts to 101.6m². Deck areas amount to 84.6m² (note that the lower level deck is situated below the level 2 building). The carport will be 22.4m² and is accessed by a new driveway beyond the vehicle access to the existing shed.
    [Show full text]
  • HORAHORA LOCAL STUDY 23 November 2016 RECEIVED
    Wai 1040, #A70 HORAHORA LOCAL STUDY 23 November 2016 Barry Rigby Waitangi Tribunal Unit, November 2016 A report commissioned by the Waitangi Tribunal for the local issues research programme for the Te Paparahi o Te Raki (Wai 1040) inquiry. Contents Preface ............................................................................................................................................................... vi CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION.................................................................................................................... 1 1. 1 The Research Commission ............................................................................................................ 1 1.2 Purpose .................................................................................................................................................. 1 1.3 Location ................................................................................................................................................. 2 1.4 Scope and Methodology .................................................................................................................. 2 1.5 The Claims ............................................................................................................................................ 9 1.6 Claimant Evidence ........................................................................................................................... 10 1.7 Organisation of the Report ..........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Directions to the Duke of Marlborough Hotel
    Directions to The Duke of Marlborough Hotel BY CAR Aprox 3.5 hours north of Auckland The Duke of Marlborough Hotel is a lovely drive through some of the most scenic parts of New Zealand. Take your time and discover some of the other things that Northland has to offer. If you have your own transport there are two main ways to get to Russell, depending on how much time you have and your sense of adventure. THE HIGHWAY The most direct route is to take State Highway 1 from Auckland to Cape Reinga. About 45 minutes north of Whangarei at Kawakawa take SH11 to Opua, Paihia and Russell (via vehicle ferry). Although the road is windy, it is fully sealed and well signposted. At the top of the hill leading to Opua, turn right and head down to the vehicle ferry which operates a continuous service during the day and a reduced service until 10:00pm. Bookings are not required and you pay on board. Car Ferry Facts First ferry Leaves Okiato 06:40am (mainland side), Leaves Opua 06:50am (Russell side) Last ferry leaves: Okiato 2200 (mainland side) , Leave Opua 2150 (Russell side) Travel time: 10mins Tickets: Purchased on board - cash and eftpos/visa available On the other side (called Okiato) keep following the main road for approximately 7km to Russell. You will find us right on the water front in Russell Village. You can enter our carpark from York Street or from The Strand. Feel free to park your car, come and check in and someone can come and help with your luggage.
    [Show full text]
  • Workingpaper
    working paper The Evolution of New Zealand as a Nation: Significant events and legislation 1770–2010 May 2010 Sustainable Future Institute Working Paper 2010/03 Authors Wendy McGuinness, Miriam White and Perrine Gilkison Working papers to Report 7: Exploring Shared M āori Goals: Working towards a National Sustainable Development Strategy and Report 8: Effective M āori Representation in Parliament: Working towards a National Sustainable Development Strategy Prepared by The Sustainable Future Institute, as part of Project 2058 Disclaimer The Sustainable Future Institute has used reasonable care in collecting and presenting the information provided in this publication. However, the Institute makes no representation or endorsement that this resource will be relevant or appropriate for its readers’ purposes and does not guarantee the accuracy of the information at any particular time for any particular purpose. The Institute is not liable for any adverse consequences, whether they be direct or indirect, arising from reliance on the content of this publication. Where this publication contains links to any website or other source, such links are provided solely for information purposes and the Institute is not liable for the content of such website or other source. Published Copyright © Sustainable Future Institute Limited, May 2010 ISBN 978-1-877473-55-5 (PDF) About the Authors Wendy McGuinness is the founder and chief executive of the Sustainable Future Institute. Originally from the King Country, Wendy completed her secondary schooling at Hamilton Girls’ High School and Edgewater College. She then went on to study at Manukau Technical Institute (gaining an NZCC), Auckland University (BCom) and Otago University (MBA), as well as completing additional environmental papers at Massey University.
    [Show full text]
  • Download All About Islands
    13 Motukokako Marsden Rangihoua Bird Rock ‘Hole in the rock’ Heritage Cross 12 DOC a 6 l u Park Cape Brett Hut s n Lighthouse i n R e a P n g a ih u o r ua e B T r ay e u P Deep Water P u Cove n Te Pahi a 11 I Islands n l e t Okahu Waewaetorea HMZS Canterbury 10 Wreck Dive k l a W 7 9 t t e 4 km r B Moturoa e Black Motukiekie p Urupukapuka a Rocks C y 8 Rawhiti a B e k O Moturua Otehei Bay a o r Motuarohia Brett Walk o 5 pe T Ca e T 4 / u r u m u o m rb angamu a Ha h m g W u u T n um ra a c h m Tapeka Point k a W ng ha Waitangi W Mountain Bike Park Long Beach Waitangi Treaty Grounds 14 Did you know? RUSSELL Project Island Song is a wildlife sanctuary. The Waitangi seven main islands in the eastern Bay of Islands 3 Pompallier have been pest mammal free since 2009, and the Mission Haruru natural eco-systems are being restored. Falls www.projectislandsong.co.nz 2 To Helena Bay / Whangarei PAIHIA 1 5 Point of interest Passenger ferry Scenic views Food NORTHLAND NZ To Kaikohe / Kerikeri / Kerikeri Kaikohe To Tohu Whenua Water taxi Iconic photo stop! Cafe Kaitaia Swimming Tour boat Local favourite Shop Okiato Whangarei Snorkeling Mountain biking Don’t miss Private boat Opua Forest et e Inl aikar Walking track Petrol station EV Charging Camping Opua Car Ferry W Find more at northlandjourneys.co.nz 2019 © Northland Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • I-SITE Visitor Information Centres
    www.isite.nz FIND YOUR NEW THING AT i-SITE Get help from i-SITE local experts. Live chat, free phone or in-person at over 60 locations. Redwoods Treewalk, Rotorua tairawhitigisborne.co.nz NORTHLAND THE COROMANDEL / LAKE TAUPŌ/ 42 Palmerston North i-SITE WEST COAST CENTRAL OTAGO/ BAY OF PLENTY RUAPEHU The Square, PALMERSTON NORTH SOUTHERN LAKES northlandnz.com (06) 350 1922 For the latest westcoastnz.com Cape Reinga/ information, including lakewanaka.co.nz thecoromandel.com lovetaupo.com Tararua i-SITE Te Rerenga Wairua Far North i-SITE (Kaitaia) 43 live chat visit 56 Westport i-SITE queenstownnz.co.nz 1 bayofplentynz.com visitruapehu.com 45 Vogel Street, WOODVILLE Te Ahu, Cnr Matthews Ave & Coal Town Museum, fiordland.org.nz rotoruanz.com (06) 376 0217 123 Palmerston Street South Street, KAITAIA isite.nz centralotagonz.com 31 Taupō i-SITE WESTPORT | (03) 789 6658 Maungataniwha (09) 408 9450 Whitianga i-SITE Foxton i-SITE Kaitaia Forest Bay of Islands 44 Herekino Omahuta 16 Raetea Forest Kerikeri or free phone 30 Tongariro Street, TAUPŌ Forest Forest Puketi Forest Opua Waikino 66 Albert Street, WHITIANGA Cnr Main & Wharf Streets, Forest Forest Warawara Poor Knights Islands (07) 376 0027 Forest Kaikohe Russell Hokianga i-SITE Forest Marine Reserve 0800 474 830 DOC Paparoa National 2 Kaiikanui Twin Coast FOXTON | (06) 366 0999 Forest (07) 866 5555 Cycle Trail Mataraua 57 Forest Waipoua Park Visitor Centre DOC Tititea/Mt Aspiring 29 State Highway 12, OPONONI, Forest Marlborough WHANGAREI 69 Taumarunui i-SITE Forest Pukenui Forest
    [Show full text]
  • Okiato the Site of New Zealand's First Capital
    Okiato The Site of New Zealand’s First Capital Historic Heritage Assessment Melina Goddard, DoC, Bay of Islands Area Office 2010 Okiato: The site of New Zealand’s first capital, Bay of Islands: Historic Heritage Assessment Melina Goddard, DOC, Bay of Islands Area Office 2010 Cover image: Felton Mathews plan of Russell. P.P 1842, 569, Correspondence Respecting the Colony of New Zealand Peer-reviewed by Andrew Blanshard, Katrina Upperton, Bay of Islands Publication information © Copyright New Zealand Department of Conservation (web pdf # needed) In the interest of forest conservation, DOC Science Publishing supports paperless electronic publishing. CONTENTS 1. Site overview 2 2. History description 3 3. Fabric description 4 4. Cultural connections 5 5. National context 5 6. Historic significance 6 7. Fabric significance 6 8. Cultural significance 7 9. Management recommendations 7 10. Management history 7 11. Management documentation 8 12. Sources 8 13. Endnotes 9 14. Location and site maps and pictures 10 Ceramic images from investigations of Okiato (Harris 2009). i FIGURES LIST Figure 1: Old land claim map 132 LINZ database Figure 2: Aerial of Okiato with DoC reserve area. QGIS Figure 3: James Reddy Clendon. Alexander Turnbull Library Figure 4: Government House, old Russell. 1840. Alexander Turnbull Library Figure 5: Captain William Hobson. Alexander Turnbull Library Figure 6: Location map of Okiato in the Bay of Islands from map toaster Figure 7: Okiato today facing south east (A. Blanshard) Figure 8: Okiato today location of the first government house and well (A Blanshard Figure 9: Traces of old Russell visible in 1943 as surveyed by Jack Lee Figure 10: Profile and contents of well (Robinson 1995) Figure 11: Plan of the investigations undertaken in 1992-1993.
    [Show full text]
  • Ecolenso Is the Free Email Publication of the Colenso Society, 32 Hawkestone St, Thorndon, Wellington 6011: Please Forward It to Interested Others
    eColenso eColenso is the free email publication of the Colenso Society, 32 Hawkestone St, Thorndon, Wellington 6011: please forward it to interested others. Contributions should be emailed to the editor, Ian St George, [email protected]. Volume 7 number 12 December 2016. ISSN 1179-8351 Past issues are at http://www.colensostudy.id.au/Newletter%20Masthead.htm “At ground level, all history is microhistory, accumulated and aggregated.” —Nile Green 1 Contents Colenso Conference 2 3 The mission schooner Columbine 4 The Columbine Sold to the missionaries Gilbert Mair and the Columbine Please The emancipation of the missionaries Sold again—and again—and again relax Colenso and the Columbine be safe What did she look like? Voyage to Castlepoint and have a L’Héroine 20 Happy Christmas eColenso contents in 2016 21 Waitangi Regional Park 22 2 Colenso Conference 2 THE WORKS In the end it was a very successful conference – enjoyable, stimulat- ing, refreshing, immersing us in that extraordinary world that was The complete writing of William Colenso, 19th century New Zealand and in the life and times of that extraordi- published papers, booklets, letters to nary nineteenth century polymath William Colenso, his work and editors, unpublished letters, journals, that of his contemporaries. diaries, all as Word files on one searchable “In the end” because the Director and staff of the Stout Research memory stick. Plus .pdfs of all copies of eColenso Centre at the Victoria University of Wellington (the conference or- to December 2016. Plus e-copies of Colenso’s ganiser) had to find a new venue after the earthquakes had closed Molesworth St and thus access to the National Library; because (for collections, Doctor Colenso I presume?, Bagnall the same reason) the ceremonial opening of William Colenso Square & Petersen’s William Colenso.
    [Show full text]
  • James Cowan and the Frontiers of New Zealand History
    James Cowan and the Frontiers of New Zealand History JAMES COWAN was perhaps the most ambiguous writer in what may be called the Frederick Maning tradition of 'representing' Maori to Pakeha. Like Maning and his epigones, Cowan made much of his privileged knowledge of Maori culture and history; unlike them, however, he combined this position with the devices of 'pioneer' literature. Cowan's combination of these and other tradi- tions problematized the writing of New Zealand history. His favoured subjects were the geographical and racial 'frontiers' of New Zealand in the nineteenth century; his use of various and not entirely compatible traditions of Pakeha writing placed him on a discursive 'frontier' as well. The histories Cowan wrote on this discursive frontier in the first four decades of this century are the subject of this article.1 My focus here is on the texts and the ways in which they were written, not on the persona of the writer. The self-fashioning aspects of Cowan's writings are fascinating, but I will not discuss them here. An inclination toward biographical interpretation predominates in New Zealand cultural history, and I want to suggest some of the possibilities of alternative approaches. I intend to look first at Cowan's methods as a historian, and the related matters of his style and his narrative structures. I then consider his general narrative of New Zealand history and race relations. I will then discuss the relations between Cowan's texts and their various contexts. Cowan's work was a syncretism of a wide range of contexts.
    [Show full text]