Stalinist Terror and Democracy: the 1937 Union Campaign
Stalinist Terror and Democracy: The 1937 Union Campaign WENDY GOLDMAN IN A PRISON CAMP IN THE 1930S, a young Soviet woman posed an anguished question in a poem about Stalinist terror: We must give an answer: Who needed The monstrous destruction of the generation That the country, severe and tender. Raised for twenty years in work and battle?^ Historians, united only by a commitment to do this question justice, differ sharply about almost every aspect of "the Great Terror":^ the intent of the state, the targets of repression, the role of external and internal pressures, the degree of centralized control, the number of victims, and the reaction of Soviet citizens. One long- prevailing view holds that the Soviet regime was from its inception a "terror" state. Its authorities, intent solely on maintaining power, sent a steady stream of people to their deaths in camps and prisons. The stream may have widened or narrowed over time, but it never stopped flowing. The Bolsheviks, committed to an antidemocratic ideology and thus predisposed to "terror," crushed civil society in order to wield unlimited power. Terror victimized all strata of a prostrate population.^ 1 would like to thank the American Council of Learned Societies for its support, and William Chase, Anton D'Auria, Donald Filtzer, J. Arch Getty, Lawrence Goldman, Jonathan Harris, Donna Harsch, Aleksei Kilichenkov, Marcus Rediker. Carmine Storella, and the members of the Working Class History Seminar in Pittsburgh for their comments and suggestions. ' Yelena Vladimirova, a Leningrad communist who was sent to the camps in the late 1930s, wrote the poem.
[Show full text]